Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
We All Want Impossible Things

We All Want Impossible Things

As her best friend enters hospice, a restless mother confronts what love can and cannot mend.
by Catherine Newman 2022 224 pages
3.94
66k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

At the cancer hospital in New York, Edi’s infusions have stopped, though no one has plainly prepared her family for what that means. Her husband, Jude, and her best friend, Ash, learn that hospice care must begin elsewhere and face a painful choice: bringing Edi to Ash’s home in Massachusetts would separate her from Jude and their seven-year-old son, Dash.

Edi refuses at first, unable to bear leaving her child. After Dash visits, she agrees to travel north. The decision offers her a place to be cared for, but asks her to surrender the home and daily motherhood she most wants to keep.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening frames hospice not as a simple change of medical setting but as a rupture in family life. Edi’s central loss begins before her death: she must leave Dash while still alive, and the adults around her must decide what care can mean when cure is no longer possible. Ash’s uncertainty is essential. She cannot make the choice painless, so she tries to make it bearable through companionship and practical action. The prologue establishes the novel’s governing tension between love’s impulse to protect and the helplessness of loving someone whose choices and body cannot be controlled.

Three Weeks at Shapely

Ash turns bedside visits into a second household

At Graceful Shepherd Hospice, which Edi jokingly renames Shapely, Ash settles into the strange rhythm of visits, meals, medicines, and songs. Edi’s advanced illness makes ordinary pleasures newly important: she requests French toast, listens to hospice musician Cedar, and jokes with Ash about the dogs and other residents.

Ash learns the staff’s routines and cares for Edi in intimate, practical ways, while her own home continues around her. Teenager Belle cooks and skips school; older daughter Jules studies at MIT; Honey, Ash’s estranged husband, still visits and helps. Edi’s brother Jonah comes from New York. Their presence keeps Edi connected to her family, but medication sometimes blurs who has visited and what she remembers.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hospice routines resist the idea that dying is one continuous, elevated moment. Edi’s days contain appetites, grooming, pets, music, and confused recollections, so Ash’s care is measured in small acts rather than grand declarations. Shapely becomes a second household because its kitchen and ordinary chores coexist with medical equipment and loss. Ash’s divided attention also matters: she is a mother and separated wife at home, but at the hospice she is Edi’s most constant witness. The novel treats caregiving as a form of presence that is repetitive, bodily, and emotionally uneven.

The Night Sky Break

Edi leaves her room to see the stars

Edi tells Ash that she fears she should never have left Brooklyn. She is grieving the small acts of motherhood she can no longer perform for Dash, including comforting him when he has a cold. Ash reminds her that years of feeding and caring for him have shaped his body and memory, though neither reassurance can erase Edi’s longing.

Later, Edi asks to go outside despite the winter cold. With Belle helping push the wheelchair and hospice staff managing the tubes, the three women reach the courtyard. Edi looks up at the open sky and asks to stay out longer, then asks Ash to take her home. She quickly softens the request, but the outing gives her a brief sense of freedom beyond the room’s ceiling.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Edi’s grief is not abstract fear of death. It is the anticipated absence from Dash’s ordinary future, especially the repetitive care that makes a parent feel necessary. Ash answers with a material account of inheritance: a child carries care in habits and in the body, even when the caregiver cannot remain. The courtyard scene briefly changes the scale of Edi’s world. Her body remains tethered to equipment, but the stars restore a view that is not organized by hospital walls. The moment offers relief without pretending that relief can undo separation.

A Cake Without a Recipe

Edi asks Ash to recover one vanished taste

When Edi rejects the hospice grilled cheese, she asks Ash to find a lemon polenta cake she tasted decades earlier and has never been able to locate again. The request becomes part of a cookbook Ash is assembling for Dash, filled with the foods Edi has made for him. Edi also asks Ash to prepare her funeral eulogy without turning it into a tribute to their friendship alone; she wants her documentary career and her own character remembered.

Ash agrees, aware that Edi has spent her life listening closely to other people’s stories. Their old jokes and shared memories continue, but Edi’s questions make the future unmistakable. Ash starts searching for the baker, trying to fulfill a wish that has no reliable recipe or timetable.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The cake and the eulogy are paired acts of preservation. Edi wants a lost taste restored and her life accurately represented, but both requests expose the limits of memory: Ash cannot be certain what the cake contained, and love may tempt her to make the eulogy about herself. Edi’s insistence on being remembered as a filmmaker and listener protects her individuality from being reduced to illness or best friend. The cookbook for Dash converts maternal care into something portable. These projects give Ash tasks, but they cannot turn remembrance into a substitute for Edi’s presence.

Ash’s Unquiet Bed

Sex offers relief, then troubles her daughters

Ash seeks the sensation of being wanted while Edi is dying, and she has sex with Dr. Soprano, Edi’s hospice physician. The encounter follows a family dinner with Honey and Belle, where Ash’s attachment to her still-familiar husband remains visible beneath their separation.

A walk in the woods with Belle exposes more: years earlier, Ash slept once with Luca, her first love, and later told Honey, who accepted the fact but could not give her the intensity she craved. Belle has seen an explicit message from Dr. Soprano and worries that her mother’s partners, and the parents’ separation, are hurting her. Ash apologizes rather than defending herself. Edi separately asks that her future eulogy be about Edi, not Ash’s devotion.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Ash’s sexual choices are attempts to interrupt grief and loneliness, not evidence that she has escaped either. She wants desire to make her feel vividly chosen, while her attraction to the stable, familiar Honey remains unresolved. Belle’s intervention reveals the cost of Ash’s private coping strategy: the daughter is not simply judging sex, but trying to understand why her family has changed. Edi’s request for an independent eulogy makes a related demand. Ash must distinguish love from possession, whether she is speaking about her friend or seeking validation from a lover.

A Temporary Rally

Edi asks what death will leave behind

Edi’s electrolytes become dangerous, her feeding tube site looks infected, and Dr. Soprano warns Ash that her condition may be changing. Then Edi has a better evening after a nurse helps relieve her constipation, and she asks Ash what she thinks happens after death. Ash offers no certainty, only the hope that people persist in memory and in the lives they have touched.

Meanwhile, Honey tracks down Daisy Goldstar, the baker behind Edi’s long-missing cake. Daisy confirms the cake existed and promises a surprise rather than the recipe. Edi’s energy briefly returns, but she also urges Ash to write her own book instead of ghostwriting wealthy clients’ memoirs. The reprieve gives them room to talk, not evidence that Edi is recovering.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The rally complicates the family’s desire for a clean downward line. A good evening does not cancel the medical warning, and the uncertainty makes Ash hungry for explanations she cannot supply. Her answer about an afterlife is improvised, but its emotional truth lies in the relationships Edi has already shaped. The cake search functions similarly: a real response from Daisy gives the friends something concrete to anticipate, without promising that Edi will live to enjoy it. Edi’s challenge to Ash’s writing also turns care outward, asking her friend to treat her own experience as worthy of sustained attention.

Honey’s Closed Door

Edi challenges Ash to stop discarding their marriage

A snowy night brings Ash, Honey, Belle, and Belle’s partner Scriv together for sledding, supper, and a film, briefly restoring the old family ease. But Edi confronts Ash about sleeping with Dr. Soprano and reminds her that Honey is loving, loyal, and still devoted to her. Ash goes home and asks Honey to come to bed with her.

He refuses, unwilling to restart their marriage on impulse. Soon Belle reveals that Honey is dating Gemma, a former catering client, and tells Ash to stop expecting him to wait forever. The news sharpens Ash’s regret, but does not resolve what went wrong between them. Edi’s frankness has made Ash face the difference between missing a marriage and knowing how to repair it.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Edi’s rebuke is not a simple instruction to reunite. She names the value Ash has difficulty recognizing because steadiness can feel less vivid than pursuit. The snow-day gathering shows that the family’s affection survives their separation, while Honey’s refusal establishes that affection alone does not restore trust or shared life. Belle’s account of Gemma forces Ash to acknowledge Honey’s independence. The scene thus shifts the question from whether Ash is loved to whether she can choose and sustain the kind of love she says she wants. Her regret is real, but it is not yet a decision.

The Cake Arrives

A fall turns Edi’s decline unmistakable

During the night, Ash wakes to find Edi on the floor after a fall; Edi’s PICC line has come out, and blood appears in her stomach drainage bag. Dr. Soprano explains that the bleeding is part of the illness and that the hospice can offer comfort, not a correction. Ash contacts Edi’s family and friends, urging anyone who wants to visit to come soon.

Edi wakes long enough to ask for a particular ice cream bar. Then a package arrives from Daisy Goldstar: the fabled lemon polenta cake. Ash cuts a slice while Jude watches by video call. Edi tastes it, but finds it less perfect than memory promised. The cake fulfills the search and exposes how little even a long-awaited pleasure can repair.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The fall makes the body’s decline impossible to treat as a distant possibility. Ash wants to separate the accident from the disease, as if a preventable event might still be reversed, but the physician refuses that distinction. His answer is painful because it strips away the hope that better vigilance could have saved Edi. The cake arrives at exactly the wrong and right time: it is a success in practical terms, yet its taste cannot recover the past or alter the prognosis. Edi’s disappointment is not ingratitude. It is a lucid reminder that memory can preserve a pleasure more perfectly than reality can reproduce it.

A Family Comes Running

Belle’s crash gathers everyone at Shapely

The next day, Ash receives a frightening call from the hospital, then learns Belle and Scriv have survived a minor car crash. Belle has a small head injury, and Ash brings her home before taking her to Edi. Jules, Honey, Jude, Jonah, and Edi’s friend Alice gather at Shapely, where they share food, champagne, stories, and music around Edi’s bed.

Edi cannot manage a toast, but listens as each person recalls a different part of her life. Ash sees the people Edi brought together and recognizes that they are living fully in the same room where they are losing her. Elsewhere in the hospice, Junior dies and Ruth worsens, making the gathering feel less like an exception than a whole community facing mortality.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Belle’s accident briefly shifts Ash’s attention from Edi’s decline to the possibility of losing her own child. The relief of finding Belle safe makes the family’s reunion at Shapely more charged, not less. Their party does not deny what is happening; eating and telling stories become ways to stay present beside Edi when conversation is difficult. The hospice’s other losses prevent the gathering from becoming a sentimental bubble. Edi’s bed sits within a place where many families are doing the same work, and that shared reality enlarges Ash’s grief while making the group’s companionship more consequential.

The Pringle Mistake

A snack sends Edi into a dangerous cough

After a night at Ash’s house, the visitors return with supplies and Jude reports that Edi has needed more and more to drink. Ash offers her Pringles, hoping to bring back an ordinary pleasure. Edi reaches into the can, eats a stack, then chokes; nurse Olga clears the blockage and warns them to stick to soft food. The family is shaken by how easily a familiar snack has become dangerous.

A hospice chaplain leads Ash, Jude, and Alice through a meditation, but Ash cannot quiet her thoughts or find a meaning for Edi’s death. She asks whether they should help Edi find closure. The chaplain tells them they cannot do that work for her. Back at the bedside, Edi briefly becomes clear enough to tell Ash she has been a good friend.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The Pringles incident turns affection into a practical risk. Ash offers food because feeding is one of the family’s oldest forms of care, but Edi’s body no longer accepts the gestures that once expressed love. The chaplain’s guidance challenges Ash’s urge to manage the emotional meaning of Edi’s death as though it were another caregiving task. Closure cannot be delivered on behalf of the dying. Edi’s brief lucidity matters precisely because it is not a grand resolution: she recognizes Ash and names their friendship, then returns to confusion. The scene gives Ash a gift without pretending it settles grief.

Goodbye Before Dawn

Her family leaves while Edi still breathes

Edi grows unresponsive, and her breathing becomes rattly. After visiting her, Jules and Belle kiss her and say goodbye; Ash and the others begin to feel that the end is near. Ash steps outside with Jude, who reveals that he knows about Ash and Jonah’s long-standing intimacy and does not think Edi needs an explanation now.

The daughters return home to care for the cats, while Cedar plays for Edi and the remaining visitors sit beside her. No one can tell whether she hears them. Ash senses a change but cannot know what it means, and Edi continues breathing after the farewells. The family has to leave the question open, carrying their goodbye back into the night rather than receiving a clear sign that it was final.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This near-farewell exposes the limits of ritual. The family performs the acts that seem appropriate, but Edi’s continuing breath refuses the certainty they want. Jude’s disclosure about Ash and Jonah also removes one possible burden: Edi knew, and Jude believes that the knowledge does not require a final confession. Ash cannot control the timing of death or determine which words will matter most. Her daughters’ departure is practical, not a withdrawal of love. The scene makes uncertainty itself part of the labor of caregiving, as everyone must act without knowing whether they are present for the last moment.

The Room Goes Quiet

Edi’s final word points back to Dash

Edi does not recover. She dies at the hospice with her family and friends gathered around her, holding hands, tending her lips, and singing songs she loved as her breathing stops. Jude remembers that her last clear word had been Dash. Afterward, he tells them that Dash had texted in the night and described his mother waking him, kissing him, and then disappearing again.

The family takes the account as a final visit, though none can prove what happened. They stay awake together, eating French toast while dawn spreads over the meadow. Ash understands that Edi’s dying and the grief after her death are separate ordeals. The immediate work is over, but the absence she leaves has only begun.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The death scene does not offer a polished passage from suffering to peace. The friends sing, touch, and care for Edi’s body, while the body’s stillness makes their own continued heartbeat suddenly strange. Dash’s reported encounter gives the family an image of maternal love reaching beyond physical presence, but the book does not require certainty about the supernatural. It matters that Jude and Ash can hold the story as comfort. The French toast afterward is not a cure or a celebration of death. It is a return to the acts of living that grief interrupts but cannot permanently abolish.

Love After Edi

Ash turns hospice grief toward a new life

At Edi’s funeral, Ash speaks about Edi’s work and devotion to Dash, describing how she once spent whole weekends cutting fruit into tiny safe pieces for him. She tells him that his mother’s care is part of what he is made of. During shiva, Ash comforts Edi’s father, Myron, and reveals that she has been accepted to nursing school after telling Shapely’s director she hopes to return as a caregiver.

Honey, now separated from Gemma, asks Ash to be with him, and they begin again. Back home, Ash keeps Edi’s clothes and the shopping lists that record her final appetites. Belle cooks, Honey returns, and Ash accepts that grief will remain alongside ordinary meals, family life, and the work of caring for others.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Ash’s movement toward nursing is not presented as a cure for bereavement or a claim that suffering has made her wiser. She has seen care at its most competent and its most helpless, and chooses to enter that work knowing it cannot prevent every loss. Her eulogy translates Edi’s maternal devotion into something Dash can carry without reducing his mother to a memory. Reuniting with Honey likewise does not erase their separation; it begins from a clearer recognition of what they mean to one another. The ending’s domestic details make grief livable without making it small.

Analysis

The novel treats caregiving as a form of attention rather than a cure. Ash cannot stop Edi’s cancer, but she can learn the preferences that illness has not erased: which drink she wants, which shirt to wear, what music she recognizes, and when she needs someone to stop offering consolation. That distinction gives the book its ethical force. Love is not shown as power over another person’s fate; it is the work of meeting a person where they are, including when the meeting is messy, repetitive, or frustrating.

Food is the book’s most concrete language of attachment. Edi feeds Dash, Honey feeds Ash’s family, and Ash carries food and drinks to the hospice. These acts are intimate because they respond to particular bodies and appetites. Yet food cannot defeat the body’s decline. The failed taste of the long-awaited cake and the danger of the Pringles make clear that care can succeed as care while failing to change the outcome. The novel refuses to confuse devotion with control.

Ash’s marriage and sexual choices mirror this problem. She wants intensity to prove she is wanted, but her affair and hospice liaisons do not resolve her loneliness. Honey’s steadiness can feel emotionally insufficient to her, even as his actions repeatedly show love. Edi’s blunt judgment forces Ash to consider whether she is rejecting a flawed relationship because she wants something better or because she cannot tolerate the ordinary limits of being loved by a real person. Their renewed relationship is therefore a choice made after grief has clarified what matters, not a reward for suffering.

The ending does not claim that loss becomes meaningful simply because people gather around it. Ash’s turn toward nursing grows from witnessing both the dignity and helplessness of hospice care. She can offer attention to others without imagining that attention will save them. Edi remains present through memory, family, and the habits she built in those she loved, but the novel allows that presence to coexist with absence. Its final comfort is not that grief ends. It is that life continues to make room for care, food, laughter, and love beside it.

Summary in 60 Seconds
When Edi’s cancer can no longer be treated, she leaves Brooklyn for hospice in Massachusetts, where her best friend Ash can care for her, though the move separates Edi from her husband Jude and their young son, Dash. Ash builds a bedside routine while facing her own estranged marriage to Honey, and Edi asks her to find a long-lost cake and write an honest eulogy. Ash’s affair with Edi’s doctor and her history with Edi’s brother Jonah complicate her feelings for Honey, who begins dating someone else. As Edi declines, a fall and a choking scare bring family and friends to her bedside. They gather, share memories, and say goodbye before Edi dies. Ash delivers the eulogy, enters nursing school, and reunites with Honey. She carries Edi’s memory into a life shaped by grief, family, and care.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.94 out of 5
Average of 66k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

We All Want Impossible Things receives mixed reviews. Many praise its raw, honest portrayal of friendship, grief, and end-of-life care, finding it both heartbreaking and humorous. Readers appreciate the authentic characters and emotional depth. However, some criticize the main character Ash as self-absorbed and dislike the scattered narrative style. The book's handling of difficult topics like cancer and hospice care resonates with many, while others find it uncomfortable. Overall, it's a polarizing read that evokes strong reactions, both positive and negative.

Your rating:
4.64
7 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Ash

Grief’s restless narrator

Ash is a food writer, mother, and lifelong best friend to Edi. She narrates through quick humor and self-mockery, often using jokes to keep fear from settling too heavily. Her care is practical: she brings drinks, tends Edi’s tubes and flowers, remembers what food she likes, and tries to preserve the stories that illness is eroding. At home, Ash is still attached to Honey even though they have separated, and she struggles to distinguish a desire for intensity from a desire for intimacy. Her love is generous but not selfless; she wants to be needed and sometimes turns other people into shelter from her own pain. The novel follows her learning to make that love useful without claiming it can control loss.

Edi

A vivid, exacting friend

Edi is Ash’s closest friend since childhood, a documentary filmmaker, wife to Jude, mother to Dash, and sister to Jonah. She has a gift for listening that draws people into telling the truth, paired with a sharp sense of humor and strong opinions about food, music, and how others remember her. Her illness does not erase her impatience, vanity, wit, or appetite. Edi wants to protect Dash from fear, but she also wants to remain part of his ordinary life. She expects honesty from Ash and is unwilling to let friendship become an excuse for Ash to dominate the story. Her insistence on being treated as a particular person, not merely a dying patient, shapes the care her friends try to give.

Honey

Ash’s devoted former husband

Honey is Ash’s estranged husband and the father of Jules and Belle. A former chef and caterer, he shows affection through food, patient help, and an unshowy willingness to be present. His even temperament comforts Ash and frustrates her; she sometimes reads his steadiness as a lack of desire, although his loyalty is evident to their daughters and friends. He remains involved in the family after moving out, cooking, helping with practical problems, and visiting Edi. Honey is not a flawless partner, nor is he simply the safe alternative to Ash’s more volatile attachments. His difficulty expressing anger and his continued affection make their separation emotionally complicated.

Jude

Edi’s steadfast husband

Jude is Edi’s husband, Dash’s father, and a documentary filmmaker who shares Ash and Edi’s long history. He is exhausted by years of Edi’s illness but remains attentive to her needs and protective of their son. Jude must balance staying beside Edi with keeping Dash’s daily life intact, a conflict that makes every decision about visits and goodbyes painful. His dry humor allows him to stay in difficult rooms without pretending they are easy. He trusts Ash with Edi’s care and can speak plainly to her when she is overwhelmed. Jude’s loyalty is expressed less through grand gestures than through the long, ordinary labor of being there.

Jonah

Ash’s old, close friend

Jonah is Edi’s older brother and one of Ash’s oldest friends. He shares a childhood history with both women and returns from New York to visit Edi, bringing food, family memories, and an ease with Ash that rests on decades of trust. His successful finance career and wealth contrast with Ash’s less secure working life, but money is not his main contribution to the family. He offers humor, company, and a familiar refuge during Edi’s illness. Jonah’s closeness to Ash carries more emotional complexity than either of them openly discusses, while his loyalty to Edi remains central.

Belle

Ash’s sharp-eyed daughter

Belle is Ash and Honey’s seventeen-year-old daughter, an observant teenager with a quick tongue, a strong sense of fairness, and a gift for making food. She jokes with her mother but also notices when Ash’s choices affect the family. Belle is especially protective of Honey and struggles with the consequences of her parents’ separation, even as she insists that her own school problems are ordinary teenage behavior. Her bluntness can sound like mockery, but it often conceals tenderness. She can comfort Ash in the same language Ash has used to comfort her, and she treats Edi as a beloved aunt rather than a distant patient.

Jules

Ash’s thoughtful older daughter

Jules is Ash and Honey’s older daughter, a capable engineering student at MIT. Her intelligence and steadiness make her seem less complicated than Belle, but she is deeply attached to her family and to Edi. Jules comes home when the family needs her, offers calm support to Ash, and carries her own memories of Edi’s care. She is entering adulthood without losing the tenderness of childhood, which is visible in the way she still seeks closeness with her mother and sister.

Dash

Edi and Jude’s young son

Dash is seven and has spent several years living with his mother’s illness. He remains in Brooklyn with Jude while Edi receives hospice care in Massachusetts, a separation that weighs heavily on both parents. Ash and Edi’s family try to protect him without pretending he does not understand that something serious is happening. His childhood foods, lost teeth, school experiences, and small messages keep his ordinary life present in the hospice. Dash is the person Edi most wants to keep mothering, and his future is a central concern for the adults around him.

Alice

Edi’s glamorous old friend

Alice is Edi’s close friend from earlier years, admired by Ash and loved by Edi. Confident, stylish, funny, and generous, she represents a part of Edi’s life that Ash cannot claim as her own. When she comes to the hospice, she joins the family’s practical care and shared remembering without competing for attention. Ash’s old jealousy of Alice reveals how long she has measured her own closeness to Edi against other friendships.

Cedar

The hospice music guide

Cedar is a young hospice music therapist who brings his guitar to Edi’s room and learns songs she requests, sometimes searching for the music as he goes. He treats the work as meaningful rather than as a temporary stepping stone, and his earnestness makes Ash revise her assumptions about him. His performances give Edi a way to remain connected to music when speech and memory become difficult. Cedar’s presence also offers the family a quiet form of companionship that does not require conversation.

Dr. Soprano

The blunt hospice physician

Dr. Soprano is Edi’s hospice physician, a large, warm, direct man who explains medical changes without disguising their seriousness. His manner combines professional calm with real affection for his patients and their families. He can be reassuring without promising recovery, and he helps Ash understand what hospice can and cannot do. His relationship with Ash becomes intimate, complicating her efforts to use sex as a refuge from grief and drawing Edi’s disapproval.

Olga

The practical hospice nurse

Olga is a Ukrainian nurse at Shapely, loved by Edi and trusted by Ash. She is direct, capable, and attentive to the physical details that keep Edi comfortable. Her care can be brisk without being cold, as when she handles an urgent moment and returns to the work at hand. Olga helps make the hospice feel like a place staffed by people with distinct personalities, not merely a medical institution.

Violet

A steady hospice nurse

Violet is one of Edi’s nurses at Shapely. She supports Ash as well as Edi, offering practical help and a compassionate presence when the family is frightened. Her attentiveness helps Ash understand the rhythms and limits of hospice care.

Jen Norman

A volunteer with history

Jen Norman volunteers at Shapely and has a past connection to Belle’s school. She and Ash also become sexually involved. Her brief appearances bring Ash’s private coping into the family’s everyday space.

Myron

Edi’s grieving father

Myron is Edi and Jonah’s father, an older man who struggles to show vulnerability and whose parenting style differs sharply from Ash’s warmer family life. His reserve can make him seem distant, but he is devoted to his children and grandson. When grief overwhelms him, Ash recognizes the pain beneath his usual manner.

Ruth

The hospice’s old resident

Ruth is a long-term hospice resident who watches Fiddler on the Roof, offers Ash lemon drops, and welcomes company. Her presence reminds Ash that people at Shapely continue to have preferences, rituals, and humor even as their lives near an end.

Junior

The birthday celebrant

Junior is another long-term hospice resident, known to Ash through small acts of companionship. On his hundredth birthday, Ash gives him a careful haircut, and his cheerful confusion makes the moment both funny and tender.

Scriv

Belle’s close companion

Scriv is Belle’s theyfriend and a young person who is often welcomed into Ash’s home. They share jokes and domestic comforts with Belle, and their presence helps make the family’s changing household feel lived in rather than defined only by its crises.

Plot Devices

Graceful Shepherd Hospice

A second family home

Shapely is both a hospice and a functioning household, with shared food, laundry, pets, music, and staff routines surrounding medical equipment and patient care. Its domestic atmosphere lets the characters carry on ordinary acts while confronting death. The hospice also brings Ash into contact with other residents and grieving families, widening her understanding beyond Edi’s room. Its practical limits matter: staff can manage pain and support comfort, but cannot reverse Edi’s illness or promise when the end will come.

The Missing Lemon Cake

A wish made tangible

Edi’s remembered lemon polenta cake gives Ash a specific task when so much about Edi’s illness is beyond her control. Ash recruits Honey to trace the baker, Daisy Goldstar, who confirms the cake existed and sends one to the hospice. The search connects Edi’s present appetite to her shared past with Ash, while the cookbook for Dash turns food into a record of maternal care. The delivered cake is a real fulfillment, but it cannot match memory or change Edi’s condition.

Food and caregiving

Love in edible form

Meals and snacks recur as ways the characters express love, attention, and habit. Ash brings Edi drinks and tries to satisfy her cravings; Honey cooks for the family; Edi’s cookbook preserves the foods she made for Dash. Food also insists on the body’s limits. A favorite snack can become dangerous when Edi can no longer swallow safely, and the dream cake disappoints when its taste cannot reproduce the past. The repeated acts of feeding show care as concrete labor, not merely sentiment.

Songs and shared memories

A language for staying

Songs, old jokes, photographs, and remembered stories let the characters recognize one another when illness disrupts conversation. Cedar plays music Edi requests, and the family later sings together at her bedside. Their memories also reveal relationships in motion: Ash recalls her marriage and childhood with Edi, while others bring stories that Ash does not own. These devices do not restore the past or guarantee a peaceful ending. They provide familiar patterns through which the characters can remain close when direct speech becomes difficult.

About the Author

Catherine Newman is an accomplished writer known for her candid and humorous approach to parenting and life. She has authored several books, including parenting memoirs and children's literature. Newman contributes regularly to various publications and websites, covering topics like family, relationships, and cooking. Her writing style is characterized by its honesty, wit, and relatability. Newman draws from personal experiences, including the loss of a close friend, which inspired "We All Want Impossible Things." Her work often explores the complexities of human relationships and the everyday challenges of family life, resonating with readers for its authenticity and humor.

Other books by Catherine Newman

Download PDF

To save this We All Want Impossible Things summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.28 MB     Pages: 24

Download EPUB

To read this We All Want Impossible Things summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.27 MB     Pages: 29
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...