Key Takeaways
Treat abolition as building safety, not simply removing police and prisons
Abolition builds as well as dismantles. Kaba defines prison-industrial complex abolition as a political vision, an analysis of oppression, and an organizing strategy. Its aim is not to leave people without help, but to build conditions that support safety: housing, food, education, health care, meaningful work, and ways to address harm without cages or policing. The starting question shifts from how to improve existing institutions to what communities need in order to thrive.
Safety is more than enforcement. Kaba distinguishes safety from the feeling of security produced by armed authorities. Police may be called to handle mental-health crises, school discipline, or other social needs, but those tasks can often intensify harm. Abolition asks why these needs have so few well-resourced responses, then invites people to develop alternatives together. It is a direction for practical work, not a claim that a world without harm is possible.
What's powerful here is the move from institutional critique to a positive account of what safety requires. It echoes public-health approaches that reduce risk by improving housing, education, and access to care, rather than relying only on emergency response. That shift also changes the test for policy: does it increase people's capacity to live safely, or merely increase the state's capacity to control them? The challenge is that social provision does not prevent every act of violence. A serious abolitionist vision must address immediate danger as well as its structural causes, while refusing to mistake imperfect alternatives for proof that punishment works.
Stop calling the system broken when its harms follow its design
History changes the diagnosis. Kaba argues that policing and incarceration are not neutral tools that occasionally malfunction. In the South, policing grew from slave patrols; in the North, early police forces helped suppress labor unrest and protect property. After emancipation, Black Codes and convict leasing helped reassert control over Black people and their labor. The system's history makes its unequal treatment harder to dismiss as a recent mistake.
Routine contact matters too. Kaba describes Chicago police stopping more than 250,000 people in a summer, with Black residents making up 32 percent of the city's population but 72 percent of those stopped. She also recalls thirteen-year-old Beverly Lee, shot by a Detroit officer in 1947 and soon classified as a justifiable killing. The everyday harassment and the headline-making death belong to the same history of criminalization.
The historical argument is strongest when it links present-day practices to institutional origins, rather than treating the past as background decoration. That approach resembles path-dependence analysis: institutions inherit rules, incentives, and assumptions that shape what they do now. Still, history alone cannot prove that every institution or intervention is identical across time. The useful question is how specific practices distribute power and harm today. Kaba's examples press readers to examine routine stops, budgets, and incentives, not just dramatic incidents or the character of individual officers.
Center survivors without demanding they perform perfect innocence
Victimhood is not a purity test. Kaba examines how Black women and girls can be treated as aggressors even when they defend themselves against abuse. Marissa Alexander fired a warning shot to protect herself from her abusive husband and received a twenty-year sentence under Florida's mandatory minimum law. Cyntoia Brown, who was sixteen and involved in survival sex work when she killed an adult client, was sentenced to life and would have had to serve at least fifty-one years before parole eligibility.
Agency and vulnerability coexist. Kaba challenges portrayals that reduce survivors to helpless figures or demand that they fit a narrow image of innocence. Multiple studies cited in the book found that 71 to 95 percent of incarcerated women had experienced physical violence from an intimate partner. The abuse-to-prison pipeline describes how survivors can be criminalized for defending themselves, escaping abuse, or securing the resources they need to survive.
This insistence on complexity is a form of epistemic justice: people who are usually spoken about get to retain agency over how their own experiences are described. It also exposes how racial and gender stereotypes shape who receives credibility and protection. A caution follows, though. Rejecting the perfect-victim test should not become a reason to flatten differences among survivors or presume that every person wants the same response. The stronger principle is to let affected people define their needs, while recognizing how law, media, and public sympathy can constrain which stories are heard.
Replace cages with accountable, community-led responses to harm
Accountability is not revenge. Transformative justice is a community-based approach to addressing harm that supports the person harmed, asks what conditions made the harm possible, and works to change those conditions so harm is less likely to recur. It is not a softer name for a court sentence or a single meeting. People responsible for harm must choose to engage; a process cannot force genuine accountability.
Repair takes sustained work. Kaba contrasts this approach with Larry Nassar's sentencing, which gave survivors a public voice but relied on an extreme prison term and a judge's punitive rhetoric. Transformative justice would also examine the institutions that ignored disclosures and enabled abuse. A process may involve boundaries, restitution, behavioral change, and community support. It may be painful and is not automatically a healing experience; its goals should be clear, and facilitators should know their limits.
The distinction between accountability and punishment is analytically useful because it separates consequences from deliberately inflicting suffering. It also broadens responsibility beyond the individual who caused harm to organizations that concealed or enabled it. But community processes are not inherently safe simply because they are outside the state. They require time, skill, clear boundaries, and real support for survivors, and participation cannot be treated as a substitute for their consent. Kaba's framework is most compelling when understood as disciplined practice, not a ready-made procedure that communities can apply identically to every case.
Judge reforms by whether they shrink carceral power
Follow the money and authority. Kaba urges readers to oppose reforms that add police funding, expand surveillance, or make policing more entrenched through technology and training. Body cameras and community dialogues may change appearances without changing the institution's power. The key question is whether a proposal reduces contact with police and prisons or strengthens their reach.
Some changes can reduce harm now. Kaba supports efforts such as redirecting police and prison budgets toward social needs, ending cash bail, disarming police, increasing transparency, offering reparations, and creating independent civilian bodies with meaningful authority. She calls reforms that move toward dismantling oppressive institutions non-reformist reforms. They can provide immediate relief while shifting resources and power, rather than making the existing system more efficient or legitimate.
This provides a practical test for policy proposals, a welcome alternative to judging reforms by their reassuring language. Budget analysis is especially valuable because resources reveal institutional priorities more reliably than mission statements do. The framework also recognizes that people living with immediate harm cannot wait for a distant structural transformation. A useful extension is to track where diverted resources go and whether new services reproduce surveillance or coercion under another name. Reducing police power matters, but so does building accessible, accountable public capacity to meet the needs that policing currently claims to address.
Use defense campaigns to free people now and expose the system
Individual cases can teach structural lessons. Participatory defense campaigns are grassroots efforts to support people facing criminalization through actions such as raising funds, meeting practical needs, attending court, and building public pressure. Kaba argues that helping one person is not a distraction from abolition. It can make incarceration's harms visible and create support for people who are otherwise treated as disposable. The campaign should connect an individual case to the wider conditions that criminalize many others.
Chicago offers a concrete example. After decades of organizing for survivors of police commander Jon Burge's torture, the city passed a reparations package that included a formal apology, counseling, education, a public memorial, and a $5.5 million fund. Campaigns for Rekia Boyd and against the proposed No Cop Academy also built relationships, public understanding, and organizer skills, even when a campaign did not win its immediate demand.
Defense campaigns combine material assistance with political education, a pairing familiar from social-movement research on how shared action can turn isolated grievances into collective claims. They also challenge a common trap: treating a person as worthy of freedom only if the public accepts a story of innocence. Yet a campaign's visibility or internal solidarity should not automatically be counted as success. Organizers also need to ask whether the person received meaningful support, whether policies or resources changed, and whether the work strengthened the affected community's ability to shape future decisions.
Make hope a daily organizing practice, not a prediction
Hope does not require cheerfulness. Kaba describes hope as a practice of acting on the possibility of change while allowing room for sadness, anger, and fear. It is not a guarantee that a campaign will win quickly. An organizer's time horizon is smaller than the history of a movement, but work that helps even a few people can still matter.
Care can be collective. Rather than treating self-care as a private project, Kaba asks how communities can share the work of caring: bringing food when someone is sick, helping with children, and showing up in practical ways. This kind of mutual support can make organizing more sustainable. It also connects hope to action: people build confidence not only by imagining a better future, but by experiencing that others will help them work toward it.
This account joins emotional endurance to collective efficacy, the shared belief that people can coordinate and influence conditions around them. It avoids the shallow demand to stay positive, which can silence grief and exhaustion. Collective care also makes a political point: burnout is not always an individual's failure to manage stress; it can be a sign that labor and resources are distributed unfairly. Mutual aid, however, cannot replace public services or become an excuse to rely indefinitely on unpaid labor. Care needs structures, resources, and boundaries to remain sustaining.
Organize in accountable groups, because solo activism cannot build durable power
Organizing requires relationships. Kaba distinguishes activism, which can mean taking action on an issue, from organizing, which involves working with others toward a shared goal. Organizers need people who can challenge their decisions, those most affected by the issue must help shape the work, and a campaign needs a strategy for building power. Without accountability, individual action can become disconnected from the needs of the people it claims to serve.
The work is made through practice. Kaba's political outlook was shaped by her father's organizing and her mother's mutual aid. Her father taught that worthwhile work depends on other people. In practice, that means joining existing groups, learning from mistakes, and testing many locally grounded approaches rather than waiting for a perfect blueprint. Community relationships are not an optional supplement to abolition; they are part of how people create safety and make new responses possible.
The distinction between activism and organizing clarifies why intensity alone does not produce durable power. Accountability supplies a feedback loop: affected people can correct a strategy before it hardens into an outside intervention. This resonates with participatory design, where users help define the problem as well as evaluate proposed solutions. Collective work is not automatically democratic, however. Groups can reproduce hierarchy, exclude less powerful members, or mistake consensus for consent. Transparent decision-making, clear responsibilities, and room for dissent help make collectivity a practice rather than a slogan.
Analysis
This collection is less a policy blueprint than a record of abolitionist reasoning in motion. Essays, interviews, campaign histories, and a short speculative story circle the same question: how can people respond to harm without reproducing the violence of institutions built around surveillance, punishment, and confinement? The structure matters. Historical analysis exposes how criminalization became normal; accounts of survivors test who is granted protection; organizing stories show how alternatives are assembled in specific places.
The book's strongest conceptual move is to refuse the false choice between punishment and doing nothing. It separates accountability from vengeance, and security from safety, then asks what material conditions and relationships could make harm less likely and repair more possible. Its attention to Black women and girls also corrects a recurring blind spot in public debates that treat police violence mainly through the experiences of men. Cases such as Marissa Alexander and Cyntoia Brown show how state power can punish survival while claiming to protect victims. The unresolved challenge is implementation. Kaba insists that there is no universal replacement for police or prisons, because needs differ across communities and situations. That openness is intellectually honest, but it places substantial demands on communities already short of time, funding, and safety. The book acknowledges volunteer exhaustion and limited capacity, yet does not offer a comprehensive model for distributing expertise or ensuring consistent safeguards. This is not a simple defect: a standardized substitute could recreate the same rigid, centralized logic being criticized. Still, experimentation requires investment, evaluation, and accountability, not just imagination.
A useful way to read the book is as both a moral argument and a method. It asks readers to question what they call justice, follow resources and power, learn from people directly affected, and join collective experiments before certainty arrives. Abolition appears not as a promise of instant consensus, but as a long political practice whose credibility depends on whether it reduces harm in the present while changing the conditions that produce it.
Review Summary
We Do This 'til We Free Us receives largely positive reviews for its accessible introduction to prison abolition and transformative justice. Readers appreciate Kaba's clear writing, thought-provoking ideas, and emphasis on collective action. Many find the book inspiring and eye-opening, praising its practical examples and nuanced discussions. Some criticize the repetitive nature of the collected essays and interviews, while others note the lack of citations. Overall, reviewers recommend it as an important resource for those interested in abolition, though some desire more concrete steps and in-depth analysis.
People Also Read
Glossary
Prison-industrial complex
Punishment and control systemsA term for the interlocking institutions and practices involved in policing, imprisonment, surveillance, and criminalization. The book uses it to describe more than prisons alone: the system is connected to social arrangements that control marginalized people and restrict access to safety and resources. Its reach includes institutions that may not look like prisons but can reproduce carceral forms of monitoring and punishment.
PIC abolition
Dismantling and building alternativesShort for prison-industrial complex abolition. It is a political vision, a structural analysis of oppression, and a practical organizing strategy. It seeks to dismantle policing, imprisonment, and surveillance while creating social conditions and community practices that support safety and address harm without relying on those systems. It is both a long-term horizon and work undertaken in the present.
Transformative justice
Community change after harmA framework for responding to interpersonal harm by supporting the person harmed, encouraging accountability from the person who caused harm, examining the conditions that enabled it, and changing those conditions to reduce future harm. It does not rely on punishment as its foundation. It is not a fixed procedure or a simple substitute for a criminal sentence, and its goals and methods depend on the situation.
Restorative justice
Repairing relationships and obligationsA framework that focuses on relationships damaged by violations and asks how the needs and obligations created by harm can be addressed. It gives communities an active role in repair and emphasizes accountability and right relationship. Kaba distinguishes it from using a single technique, such as a circle, as though that alone constitutes a complete restorative practice.
Non-reformist reforms
Changes that weaken carceral powerReforms that can reduce harm in the present while making it easier to dismantle, rather than strengthen, policing and imprisonment. Examples discussed include reducing and redirecting police budgets, ending cash bail, disarming police, increasing transparency, and providing reparations. The test is whether a reform shifts resources and power away from carceral institutions or expands their reach and legitimacy.
Participatory defense campaigns
Collective support for criminalized peopleGrassroots campaigns that support people facing criminalization through practical help, fundraising, public education, and pressure on authorities. Kaba treats them as an abolitionist strategy when they connect an individual's case to the wider conditions that lead to incarceration, rather than implying that only one supposedly exceptional person deserves freedom.
Abuse-to-prison pipeline
Survivors criminalized for survivalA pattern in which people who experience abuse, especially women and gender-nonconforming people, are criminalized for actions connected to surviving or escaping violence. Examples include defending themselves, trying to protect children, leaving an abusive home, or obtaining necessities under coercive conditions. The term highlights how systems that claim to protect people can instead intensify their exposure to punishment.
Abolitionist care
Care that challenges carceral harmA practice of supporting people facing criminalization through concrete, collective acts such as letter writing, financial assistance, visits, and defense campaigns. In Kaba's account, this care meets immediate needs while helping people understand how incarceration harms individuals and communities. It also expresses the principle that liberation is interconnected, rather than a benefit reserved for those judged especially deserving.
Reparations framework
Repair and prevent repeated harmA model for addressing state violence through repair, restoration, acknowledgment, cessation, and nonrepetition. In the discussion of Breonna Taylor, this means supporting affected families, recognizing the harm, ending practices that caused it, and changing the conditions that could produce similar harm again. It offers a wider conception of justice than prosecution of an individual officer alone.
Hope is a discipline
Practiced belief in changeA view of hope as a repeated choice to act on the possibility of transformation, rather than as optimism or a feeling of constant confidence. It allows grief and anger while sustaining long-term work. Kaba connects it to understanding oneself as one participant in a movement whose timeline extends beyond any single organizer's lifetime.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.