Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
What It Should Be

What It Should Be

A hockey star falls for his sister's married nanny, whose dangerous husband threatens their future.
by Grayce Rian 2024 345 pages
3.93
467 ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

Carson Wilder, a newly drafted hockey star, meets Dakota Meyer when his twin sister, McKenna, interviews her to care for her toddler, Cadence. He is instantly captivated by Dakota’s warmth, wit, and love of classic books.

Her quick teasing makes his attraction feel mutual, but after Dakota accepts the job, McKenna warns him that she is married. Carson reins himself in and settles for hoping they can become friends, unaware that Dakota’s marriage is already a place she is trying to escape.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The first meeting establishes the romance’s central imbalance: Carson can name his desire, while Dakota must conceal both her attraction and her plans for freedom. His instinct is to turn affection into play, using nicknames and teasing to make closeness feel safe. Her marriage makes that safety conditional from the beginning. The nanny job is more than a meet-cute convenience. It gives Dakota a foothold in a new life, while bringing her into the orbit of a family whose ease and affection contrast with the control she experiences at home.

A Secret Exit Plan

Dakota saves nanny wages while hiding Aaron’s control

By September, Dakota is quietly building a way out of her marriage to Aaron Ackerman, a lawyer who controls her clothes, reading, schedule, and access to her location. She has opened a separate bank account for her nanny wages and secretly obtained an IUD, while telling Aaron she is only helping a friend with a baby.

Carson’s attention makes the job unexpectedly comforting, but she does not mistake his kindness for a reason to stay. At his early hockey game, Aaron’s repeated calls and messages pull her out of the crowd before she can meet her visiting brother, Brody. She apologizes to McKenna and hurries home, where Aaron turns her absence into another occasion to monitor and reprimand her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Dakota’s escape plan depends on practical secrecy because emotional clarity alone cannot make her safe or financially independent. The separate account, concealed contraception, and cover story are not signs of indecision; they are adaptations to a partner who treats ordinary autonomy as disobedience. Carson’s presence offers a contrast, but the narrative keeps Dakota’s choices grounded in her own survival rather than in rescue by romance. Aaron’s location tracking also plants a consequential danger: surveillance that once polices Dakota’s movements can later be used to threaten the people she loves.

A Daughter Discovered

Griffin learns Cadence is his after two years apart

At Carson’s NHL debut, Colorado opponent Griffin Turner sees toddler Cadence and recognizes his own eyes in hers. McKenna confirms that Griffin is her father, then recounts telling him about the pregnancy in Boston, when he was using drugs and rejected her.

Carson remembers the same night and initially believes Griffin knowingly abandoned them. Griffin says he has no memory of the exchange: after the binge, he entered therapy, surrendered his old phone, and later changed teams without receiving McKenna’s messages.

Her call from the hospital on Cadence’s birth night went unanswered. The explanation does not erase the harm, but it changes Carson’s certainty about Griffin’s motives. Griffin asks to meet his daughter, and McKenna must decide whether to let him try.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelation turns an apparent moral certainty into a painful dispute over memory, addiction, and accountability. Griffin’s lack of recollection cannot undo McKenna’s experience of being rejected, but his account complicates Carson’s assumption that the abandonment was deliberate. This is not an instant absolution: McKenna remains entitled to distrust him, and Griffin must demonstrate that recovery can become responsible action. Carson’s role shifts too. His protective loyalty helped McKenna survive, yet it may also have prevented Griffin from being given another chance to answer for what he did.

Bruises Beneath Harley Quinn

Carson spots marks Dakota cannot safely explain

On Halloween, Carson dresses the family as Batman characters and gives Dakota a Harley Quinn costume. While helping her with its accessories, he notices dark bruises on her wrist. Dakota claims they came from consensual intimacy with Aaron, but Carson recognizes that she is avoiding the question and grows alarmed.

She withdraws before he can press her, unwilling to expose a truth she is still trying to manage alone. During trick-or-treating, Carson declines photographs so Cadence can enjoy family time without public attention, then tells Dakota that he hopes Griffin will become part of their family again.

Watching McKenna cautiously allow Griffin closer to Cadence, Dakota sees Carson’s tenderness toward the people he loves, even as she keeps her own danger hidden.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The costume briefly gives Dakota a playful public identity, but the uncovered bruises expose how little control she has over what others can see. Her lie is a protective reflex, not evidence that she doubts the injury matters. Carson’s concern is emotionally perceptive, though he cannot yet distinguish what Dakota is ready to disclose from what he wants to know. The scene also links privacy to care: he shields Cadence from cameras, while Dakota remains unable to shield herself from Aaron. Their intimacy deepens through observation, but trust still requires a disclosure she cannot safely make.

Christmas, Carefully Rebuilt

Brody notices Dakota’s fear as Griffin returns

At Christmas in Texas, Brody sees that Dakota is skittish and unhappy, and urges her not to let Aaron diminish her. She still cannot tell her family about the abuse, afraid Brody will confront him and damage his own life. Carson’s Christmas messages offer a gentler connection, while Dakota shares her wish to write and her fondness for Little Women.

Back in Minnesota, Griffin makes breakfast for McKenna and Cadence, apologizes to Carson for how his grief and addiction hurt them, and accepts Carson’s apology for punching him. McKenna gives Griffin a week with her and Cadence in Denver; Griffin responds with concert tickets for the family, including one in memory of his sister, Katie. His return begins to turn remorse into shared plans.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This holiday section places two forms of silence side by side. Dakota’s family recognizes distress but cannot help with a truth she is not yet able to reveal; Carson’s messages offer closeness without demanding disclosure. Meanwhile, Griffin’s reconciliation with Carson is made credible through specific acts of repair, including cooking for the daughter he missed and accepting responsibility for his past. McKenna’s visit to Denver is not a sudden restoration of trust, but a measured experiment in co-parenting. The family’s rituals hold grief and hope together rather than pretending one cancels the other.

The Emerald Dress

Aaron humiliates Dakota before Carson asks the truth

At the law firm’s New Year’s Eve gala, Dakota discovers that Carson’s father, Theodore Wilder, is one of the firm’s founding partners and that Aaron works there. Before they leave, Aaron insults her emerald gown and calls her appearance shameful, then takes her to the event as if his earlier cruelty were ordinary.

Carson meets the couple and understands from Dakota’s strained composure that she needs him to play along. Later, he asks whether she is happy with Aaron.

Rather than admit the truth, Dakota tells Carson that his privilege makes it easy for him to imagine freedom. The words hurt him, but she leaves the ballroom before she can explain. The encounter ends with Carson knowing her marriage is wrong, but not knowing how dangerous it has become.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The gala makes class and power concrete rather than abstract: Carson’s family owns the institutional setting in which Aaron’s career depends, while Dakota is trapped beside the man who controls her. Aaron’s criticism is not a single outburst but part of a pattern that has trained her to anticipate humiliation. Carson’s question offers a possible opening, yet his social privilege makes the answer feel dangerously simplistic to Dakota. Her sharp rebuke protects her from exposing more than she can manage, while also wounding the person she increasingly trusts.

The Doorstep After Midnight

Carson takes Dakota to hospital and calls his father

Hours after the gala, Dakota reaches Carson’s house battered and barely able to stand. He calls his teammate Bennett to drive them to hospital because Carson has been drinking, then stays beside her as doctors identify a collapsed lung, broken ribs, a bruised kidney, and cuts requiring stitches. Dakota tells the doctor that Aaron assaulted her and admits she does not feel safe at home.

When Carson explains that his father can help, she fears Aaron will retaliate if he loses his job. Theodore arrives, offers legal representation, and begins the protection order and divorce filings. The firm fires Aaron. Dakota agrees to leave their house for good, and Carson asks her to stay with him rather than face recovery alone.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The doorstep is the moment Dakota’s hidden reality becomes a public fact, first to Carson and then to medical and legal authorities. Her injuries give her testimony physical urgency, but the crucial change is that she names Aaron as the person who harmed her. Carson’s insistence on a sober driver shows care expressed through restraint, while Theodore’s legal intervention converts family support into concrete protection. Dakota’s fear about Aaron’s career reveals how thoroughly his ambitions have been made part of her burden. Accepting shelter is not a romantic surrender; it is an immediate act of safety.

A House Made Safer

Therapy helps Dakota rebuild while Carson stays close

After leaving the hospital, Dakota moves into Carson’s home and begins therapy with Tasha while the divorce and protection order proceed. Recovery is uneven: a flashback to Aaron’s assault wakes her in terror, and Carson comforts her without treating her fear as an inconvenience.

He uses humor and their shared television habit to help her return to the present. Dakota, in turn, sees Carson’s anxiety growing after the car accident that nearly killed McKenna and Katie, though he is reluctant to seek help.

Their routines become intimate without either demanding a relationship: books by the fire, shared meals, and Carson checking that she has what she needs. The home offers shelter, but healing also requires Dakota to regain confidence in her own choices.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Safety here is built through repeated, ordinary actions rather than a single declaration. Carson offers presence without making Dakota’s trauma a debt she must repay, while her therapy gives her tools that do not depend on his availability. Their care begins to move in both directions as Dakota recognizes that Carson’s cheerfulness conceals anxiety. The domestic routines are especially significant because Aaron had controlled the details of Dakota’s daily life; now she can choose a book, a seat, or a quiet evening without punishment. The house becomes a setting where autonomy can be practiced again.

The Crash Reopens Fear

A photographer hits Carson’s truck with Cadence inside

During a rainy funcle outing, Carson takes Cadence to an indoor playground and then a diner. A photographer follows them, questions Carson about the child, and later rear-ends his truck at an intersection before fleeing without license plates.

A second vehicle strikes the front of the truck. Carson finds Cadence unharmed, but the crash triggers the fear he has carried since McKenna’s accident and Katie’s death. Doctors diagnose Carson with a concussion, and his family insists he be examined rather than dismissing his injury.

In the weeks that follow, Dakota helps him through a panic attack and encourages him to see a therapist. Carson begins treatment under a pseudonym to protect his privacy, making the choice he once feared would look weak.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The collision turns Carson’s protective instinct into a source of vulnerability: his attempt to give Cadence a happy outing becomes the very situation he fears most, even though she is physically safe. The photographer’s pursuit also violates the boundary Carson tries to maintain between public fame and family life. Dakota’s response is a reversal of their earlier dynamic, when he protected her during crisis. She offers grounding without pretending to cure him, and his decision to seek therapy marks a change from managing appearances to acknowledging need. The incident makes care reciprocal and exposes the cost of treating anxiety as a private failing.

The Cabin and the Confession

Dakota grounds Carson as Griffin proposes to McKenna

At the family cabin, Carson has a panic attack before the drive to collect Cadence. Dakota steadies his breathing and guides him through affirmations, then drives his truck herself.

Griffin proposes to McKenna that day, and their engagement leaves Carson grieving the prospect of his twin sister and niece moving into Griffin’s home. Dakota stays close; the two play Scrabble, talk about fear and loneliness, and acknowledge how important their friendship has become.

Carson admits he will not take advantage of her feelings or her dependence on his hospitality. He then contacts Dakota’s therapist to arrange his own appointment. His care for Dakota is no longer the only reason he is changing; with her help, he begins to accept support for himself.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Carson’s panic attack interrupts the image of the effortless athlete and makes his vulnerability visible to Dakota, who responds with the same practical attention he once gave her. Her affirmations model a form of care that does not shame or infantilize him. Griffin’s engagement, meanwhile, brings happiness and loss at once: Carson supports the couple but fears the household that made him feel needed will disappear. His promise not to exploit Dakota’s dependence is ethically important because their friendship exists within a housing imbalance. Seeking therapy makes his growth an act of self-responsibility, not merely a bid to keep her close.

A Book of Her Own

Dakota claims writing as Carson invites her abroad

At Griffin and McKenna’s bachelor party, Carson sings a Taylor Swift song directly to Dakota, and their flirtation becomes harder to dismiss. During the wedding, his best-man speech honors the childhood bond shared by Carson, McKenna, Griffin, and Katie, turning a family celebration into a remembrance of the friend they lost.

Dakota tells Carson that watching him pursue hockey helped her recognize her own ambition: she wants to write a romance novel. Carson listens as she describes its football player hero and forbidden connection, then invites her to join the group’s trip to Italy, where the setting could inform her book.

Dakota initially refuses, wary of imposing on Griffin and McKenna’s honeymoon, but Carson makes clear that he wants her there for herself, not just as a nanny or research partner.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Dakota’s writing ambition is a second form of escape, but unlike her secret plan to leave Aaron, it is a future she chooses for pleasure and creation. Carson’s support matters because he does not treat the dream as impractical or subordinate it to his own career. His wedding speech also shows how the group’s shared past can be honored without freezing everyone inside grief. The Italy invitation brings emotional risk into the open: Dakota is being asked to travel as a person Carson wants beside him, not as an employee. Her hesitation reflects care for others as much as fear of intimacy.

Milan’s First Kiss

Dakota chooses Carson after the Eras concert

In Milan, Carson finally explains the private joke behind calling Dakota Austen: he noticed her Pride and Prejudice sweatshirt at their first meeting. He gives her a bracelet linking that name to the dream girl he has always seen in her.

Before Taylor Swift’s concert, he tells her his feelings were never merely friendly and promises to accept whatever place she can offer him. Dakota gives him a matching bracelet and says she is ready to risk more than friendship.

McKenna interrupts before they can kiss, but later Carson takes Dakota to a lit fountain, where they share their first kiss. In Venice, their first proper date and growing physical intimacy help Dakota experience pleasure without fear, giving her evidence that Aaron’s abuse has not taken away her capacity to feel safe.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The bracelet turns a year of teasing into an honest account of how Carson has seen Dakota, while her matching gift makes that recognition mutual. Crucially, she chooses the timing of their first kiss; Carson’s patience allows desire to become consent rather than pressure. Their intimacy also carries a psychological consequence beyond romance. Dakota’s pleasure is not presented as a cure for trauma, but as a reclaimed experience in which her body responds to her own desire. The trip gives them room to become a couple away from their roles as employer’s brother and nanny, without erasing the history that shaped those roles.

Italy Becomes Home

Their journey joins love, writing, and future plans

Across Venice, Florence, Rome, and the Amalfi Coast, Carson and Dakota build a relationship through shared discoveries and deliberate care. He arranges time and places that help her write, while she supports his therapy and listens as he imagines creating a youth sports camp near his family’s lake cabin.

In Amalfi, Dakota tells him she loves him, and Carson answers that he has wanted to say the same but waited until she was ready. After the trip, he surprises her with a library built into his house, furnished for her books and writing, and asks her to make the home theirs. Dakota hesitates under the weight of her past, then agrees. The room makes his belief in her work tangible, but their new security is about to be tested.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Italy functions as more than a romantic backdrop because each character uses the time away to imagine a life not organized solely around survival or professional performance. Carson’s youth-camp idea expands his identity beyond hockey, while Dakota turns travel into material for a novel. Their declarations of love arrive after a sustained practice of listening, restraint, and shared decision-making. The library is a particularly concrete promise: Carson does not merely praise Dakota’s talent, he changes the space they inhabit to support it. Her hesitation matters because choosing a home again requires trust after a home once became dangerous.

Blackmail Breaks the Home

Aaron threatens to publish private recordings

After Dakota returns to Minnesota wearing Carson’s jersey, Aaron sends her private photos and videos taken without her consent. He demands that she leave Carson within two days or he will release the material and ruin Carson’s public reputation.

He reveals that he hired the photographer who caused the crash with Carson and Cadence, making the earlier collision part of a deliberate campaign. Fearing that the threat will damage Carson and his family, Dakota packs without telling him the truth and says she is returning to Texas because their relationship moved too fast.

Carson asks her to explain, but she insists he must let her go. Believing she is protecting him, she leaves the home and the library they had just made together, while Carson is left devastated and without the reason.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Aaron weaponizes intimacy by turning private images into instruments of public control, extending the surveillance that began with tracking Dakota’s location. His threat exploits her most reliable vulnerability: she has learned to protect others by absorbing harm herself. The lie she tells Carson is therefore both an act of love and a return to the isolation that once kept her trapped. Carson’s request for honesty cannot overcome the danger she believes she is managing. The departure also reveals a limit in their communication: mutual devotion has grown, but Dakota still assumes she must decide alone what risks Carson is allowed to face.

Aaron Enters the House

Carson’s security footage catches the stalker breaking in

On Halloween, Carson’s upgraded security system alerts him to a man breaking into his house. He and his father arrive before police and find Aaron searching the bedroom. Aaron claims Dakota was supposed to leave Carson and reveals that he came to make sure neither of them could keep her.

When Carson challenges him, Aaron attacks with a knife. Theodore restrains him, but not before the blade cuts Carson’s side and he collapses. Police take Aaron into custody for breaking in, stalking, threatening to distribute intimate material, and assault with a weapon.

The break-in confirms that Dakota’s fear was not an imagined obstacle, but Carson’s wound makes the danger personal. With Aaron arrested, Carson goes to Texas to tell Dakota what happened and ask her to come home.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The security system converts Carson’s earlier unease into evidence, while Aaron’s presence in the bedroom makes the threat impossible to dismiss as a private conflict between former spouses. His explanation exposes the bargain he imposed on Dakota: her separation from Carson was supposed to be the price of keeping the images secret. Carson’s injury demonstrates the physical reach of that coercion, but Theodore’s intervention and the police response prevent the confrontation from becoming a private revenge fantasy. The episode shifts the burden away from Dakota alone. Aaron’s actions are now visible to family and law enforcement, and the danger can be answered collectively.

Home, Then a Promise

Dakota returns and Carson proposes on the ice

In Texas, Carson finds Dakota at her family’s ranch and tells her Aaron is in custody. She learns Carson was cut while stopping the break-in, and recognizes that leaving him did not keep him untouched by the danger. She agrees to return with him. Before the family’s Thanksgiving skate, Dakota finally tells Brody what Aaron did; Brody is hurt that she hid it but supports her and sees how much happier she is with Carson.

On the ice, Carson proposes, promising a love that will not depend on her silence or compliance. Dakota accepts, and their families gather around them. The engagement completes the emotional repair begun when she first chose to trust Carson, while her disclosure to Brody ends the secrecy that protected Aaron.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion is not secured by Carson’s grand gesture alone. Dakota returns after learning the truth about his injury and choosing the relationship with fuller knowledge of its risks. Her conversation with Brody repairs a second bond: accepting help means allowing loved ones to know what happened, even when disclosure brings hurt and regret. The proposal’s setting on the ice joins Carson’s lifelong vocation to the shared future he now wants. More importantly, his promise distinguishes love from the coercive bargain Aaron imposed. Dakota’s yes is meaningful because it follows both safety and an honest account of the past.

Epilogue

On their wedding day in Texas, Dakota learns that her football romance series has secured a publishing deal. She tells Carson, then reveals that she is pregnant. Carson takes in the news as the two of them prepare to become husband and wife and parents.

They record a message for their future child, welcoming the new life they will build together. Dakota’s writing dream and the family she once feared she might never have now meet in the same morning, and Carson answers both with the steady devotion that has defined their relationship.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending joins two forms of creation that Dakota once kept at a distance: writing a story of her own and building a family chosen through trust. The publishing news validates her ambition without making her success a condition of being loved. Pregnancy, in turn, is framed against the coercion she once feared in marriage: this future is discussed and welcomed with Carson, rather than imposed by Aaron. Their message to the child makes the future feel already relational, addressed to someone they hope to meet. The romance resolves not by erasing Dakota’s history, but by giving her room to author what comes next.

Analysis

The romance is built around a distinction between protection and control. Aaron calls surveillance concern, dictates Dakota’s choices, and turns private images into threats; Carson’s care, at its best, creates room for her to decide. That contrast is more than a villain-versus-hero shorthand because Carson also has to confront his own controlling impulse to manage every danger and carry every burden. His anxiety becomes part of the story rather than a flaw the romance magically cures. He seeks therapy, accepts help, and learns to support Dakota without treating her as someone he can save by force of devotion.

Dakota’s arc is not simply from an abusive marriage into a healthier romance. She has to rebuild trust in her perceptions, disclose what she has been taught to hide, and imagine a future that includes work she chooses for herself. The nanny job first gives her money and a reason to move through the world beyond Aaron’s supervision. Her writing then expands that freedom into authorship: she can invent a future rather than only flee the present. Carson’s library matters because it turns encouragement into material support, while the publishing deal confirms that Dakota’s creative life has value independent of the relationship.

The supporting romances and family bonds sharpen this central movement. Griffin’s missed fatherhood shows how grief and addiction can obscure responsibility without erasing its consequences; his repair with McKenna depends on action, not a single explanation. Carson’s loyalty to his twin is generous but also bound up with fear of being left behind. As these families change, the story asks whether love can survive the loss of its familiar arrangement. Its answer is not that devotion prevents pain, but that secure love allows people to speak, seek help, and choose one another without surrendering their separate futures.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Hockey star Carson Wilder falls for Dakota Meyer, the nanny caring for his twin sister's toddler, but Dakota is married to controlling lawyer Aaron and secretly saving money to escape. Carson discovers her injuries after Aaron seriously assaults her, and helps her find medical, legal, and therapeutic support. As Dakota recovers in Carson's home, their friendship deepens, while Carson confronts anxiety tied to a past car crash that killed his sister Katie. Dakota pursues her dream of writing romance, and she and Carson begin a relationship during a family trip to Italy. Aaron threatens to release intimate recordings and sends a photographer to cause a crash involving Carson and the child. Dakota leaves to protect Carson, but Aaron breaks into the house and wounds him with a knife. After Aaron is arrested, Carson brings Dakota home. She tells her brother about the abuse, accepts Carson's proposal, and later marries him. On their wedding day, she learns her books will be published and that she is pregnant.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.93 out of 5
Average of 467 ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

What It Should Be is a highly rated contemporary romance novel featuring Carson and Dakota's slow-burn love story. Readers praise the emotional depth, character development, and swoon-worthy moments. The book explores themes of healing, trust, and unconditional love. Many reviewers appreciate the reverse age gap, vacation romance, and mental health representation. The chemistry between the main characters is described as captivating, with a perfect balance of sweetness and spice. Fans of the series enjoy seeing familiar characters and are excited for future installments.

Your rating:
4.53
113 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Dakota Meyer

The guarded dreamer

Dakota is a Texas-raised English graduate, Brody’s younger sister, and McKenna’s nanny. Her love of books and quiet ambition to write coexist with a learned habit of minimizing her own needs. She is observant, witty, and capable of warmth, but years of controlling treatment have made ordinary choices feel risky. Dakota’s careful planning shows resourcefulness rather than passivity: she creates financial independence and seeks a way out before anyone knows she needs help. Her relationships with Carson, McKenna, and her family offer different kinds of belonging, yet she must learn to accept support without surrendering agency. Writing becomes a language through which she can imagine a future that belongs to her.

Carson Wilder

The devoted hockey rookie

Carson is McKenna’s twin brother, Cadence’s adoring uncle, and a newly drafted NHL player for the Minnesota Wolverines. Outgoing and flirtatious, he uses nicknames, jokes, and small acts of service to make people feel welcome. Beneath that ease, he carries anxiety about losing the people he loves, sharpened by the accident that took Katie’s life and nearly took McKenna’s. Carson is intensely protective, sometimes to the point of making himself responsible for everyone else’s safety. His relationship with Dakota asks him to balance care with patience, and his decision to seek therapy shows him learning that vulnerability can coexist with strength. Hockey matters deeply to him, but he wants a life that reaches beyond the rink.

McKenna Wilder

Carson’s fiercely loyal twin

McKenna, usually called Mack, is Carson’s twin, a college volleyball player, and Cadence’s mother. She has survived grief, a serious car accident, and the strain of raising a child while studying and competing. Her protectiveness comes from hard experience, but she remains capable of humor and deep tenderness. Mack does not rush trust; she watches what people do, especially when Cadence is involved. Her friendship with Dakota grows through shared care and a mutual love of books, while her complicated history with Griffin requires her to weigh old hurt against new accountability. She is a central source of family cohesion, though her independence means she does not simply accept help without considering what it costs others.

Griffin Turner

A father rebuilding trust

Griffin is Carson’s childhood best friend, McKenna’s former boyfriend, and a professional hockey player. After the loss of his sister Katie, he coped destructively with grief and addiction, damaging relationships he once valued. His temperament is usually loyal and affectionate, but grief can make him withdraw from the people who might help him. Griffin’s bond with McKenna is rooted in years of shared history, while his relationship with Cadence forces him to face the consequences of his absence. He is not defined only by his mistakes: therapy, recovery, and practical efforts to reconnect show a man trying to become accountable. His return to Carson’s life also tests whether friendship can survive pain without pretending the pain did not happen.

Aaron Ackerman

The controlling husband

Aaron is Dakota’s older husband and a lawyer at the firm founded by Carson’s father. He presents control as concern, monitoring Dakota’s location and dictating her appearance, reading, work, and schedule. His early decisiveness once seemed reassuring to Dakota, which helps explain how coercion became normalized in their marriage. Aaron’s fixation on reputation and professional advancement makes him especially dangerous when Dakota begins to leave. He is not simply jealous; he treats Dakota’s independence as a threat to his ownership of her life. His presence gives the story’s romance a sharp ethical contrast, showing how care respects a person’s choices while control tries to replace them.

Cadence Wilder

The family’s bright center

Cadence is McKenna and Griffin’s young daughter and Carson’s beloved niece. Her affection, laughter, and need for steady care draw the adults into one another’s lives. She is too young to understand the history around her, but her presence makes those histories consequential: McKenna must protect her privacy, Griffin must earn a place in her life, and Carson’s devotion to her intensifies his fear after the car crash. Cadence is not a plot token; she is a child whose safety and routines shape the adults’ choices.

Brody Meyer

Dakota’s protective brother

Brody is Dakota’s older brother and a celebrated professional football quarterback. After their father’s death, he took on a protector’s role and remains alert to shifts in Dakota’s behavior. His bluntness can feel overwhelming, but it comes from genuine concern rather than a wish to control her. Brody’s support is complicated by Dakota’s fear that he will react impulsively if he learns what Aaron has done. Their closeness is built on love and family history, but it requires her to trust him with painful truths and him to respect her choices.

Theodore Wilder

A father with legal reach

Theodore, Carson and McKenna’s father, is a senior lawyer and one of the founders of the firm where Aaron works. He is warm with his family and decisive when someone is in danger. His professional authority lets him offer Dakota concrete legal help, but he does not treat her as a case to manage without consent. Theodore’s support joins practical action with paternal steadiness, and his willingness to intervene makes clear that family loyalty can include confronting misconduct rather than protecting a powerful institution.

Elizabeth Wilder

The family’s steady mother

Elizabeth is Carson and McKenna’s mother, an affectionate grandmother to Cadence, and a reliable presence during family celebrations and crises. She helps create the welcoming atmosphere that draws people together, while her support for McKenna and Dakota is practical as well as tender. Elizabeth values closeness, but she does not need to dominate the family to hold it together. Her care offers a contrast to Aaron’s control: she makes room for others rather than demanding that they conform.

Katie Turner

The absent childhood friend

Katie was Griffin’s younger sister and McKenna’s childhood best friend, close to Carson and woven into the families’ shared history. Her quick wit and spirited loyalty remain present in the stories the others tell and the traditions they preserve. Katie’s absence shapes how Carson, McKenna, and Griffin understand grief, responsibility, and the possibility of moving forward. She is remembered as a distinct person, not merely as a symbol of loss.

Bennett Wilson

The disciplined team captain

Bennett is a demanding hockey captain and one of Carson’s teammates. He values preparation and accountability, often appearing reserved beside more playful players. Beneath his controlled manner is a dependable friend: he drives Carson and Dakota to the hospital when Carson cannot safely drive. His steadiness gives the team a counterweight to Carson’s spontaneous warmth and Jackson’s showmanship.

Jackson Wilson

The irreverent teammate

Jackson, often called Jax, is Bennett’s younger brother and Carson’s friend and teammate. Relaxed, mischievous, and socially confident, he uses humor to defuse tension and brings energy to the group. His teasing can be intrusive, but it also makes him a catalyst for the friends’ conversations about love and vulnerability. Jackson’s loyalty to Carson and the team sits beneath his playful public persona.

Tasha

Dakota’s therapist

Tasha is Dakota’s therapist, who teaches her grounding strategies and daily affirmations. Her practical tools help Dakota manage flashbacks and later give her a way to support Carson without pretending that affection alone can replace professional care.

Jolene Meyer

Dakota’s watchful mother

Jolene is Dakota and Brody’s mother, whose Texas home remains a source of family comfort. Her concern for Dakota is steady, even when Dakota cannot yet tell her the full truth, and she offers a place to return to when Dakota needs distance.

Dr. Frederick

The hospital physician

Dr. Frederick treats Dakota after the assault, explains her serious injuries, and asks whether she feels safe. Her calm, direct questions give Dakota space to disclose what happened and begin the formal process of seeking protection.

Plot Devices

Dakota’s hidden exit plan

A private route to freedom

Dakota’s separate bank account, concealed nanny job, and secret IUD make escape possible without alerting Aaron too early. Each detail reveals how thoroughly she has had to adapt to his control: wages must be hidden, work needs a cover story, and even decisions about her own body must remain private. The plan is not a simple countdown to leaving, because her limited money and fear of retaliation keep her exposed. Its practical logic helps explain why she does not immediately tell Brody or Carson what is happening. It also establishes that Dakota has been acting to save herself before Carson becomes part of her safety plan.

Three gentle squeezes

A wordless promise of care

Carson often squeezes Dakota’s hand three times, a gesture he uses to reassure her when words are difficult. At first it is a small, affectionate habit. As their trust grows, the gesture becomes a shared language for safety, support, and attachment. It works because it does not demand an immediate explanation or confession from Dakota, whose life has taught her to monitor what she says. The motif also travels in both directions: Dakota eventually returns the squeeze, showing that she is not only receiving care but choosing to offer it. Its meaning remains intimate rather than performative.

Therapy and affirmations

Tools for reclaiming agency

Dakota’s therapy gives her grounding techniques for flashbacks and panic, including naming what she can see, hear, and touch. She shares affirmations with Carson when his own anxiety overwhelms him, and her encouragement helps him seek therapy rather than hide from the stigma he fears as a professional athlete. These practices do not erase either character’s history. Instead, they offer concrete actions when old fear takes over, allowing both to regain enough composure to make choices. Therapy also keeps the romance from becoming a substitute for care: Carson can support Dakota, and Dakota can support Carson, while each still develops tools beyond the relationship.

The stolen images

Aaron’s weapon of exposure

Aaron secretly records intimate moments and later threatens to publish the material unless Dakota leaves Carson. The images convert private intimacy into leverage, exploiting Dakota’s fear that public scandal could damage Carson’s hockey career and family. His threat also reveals that the photographer who caused the crash with Carson and Cadence was part of his campaign. The device joins digital surveillance to physical danger: Aaron watches, gathers material, and uses the possibility of exposure to dictate Dakota’s movements. It becomes the direct cause of her sudden departure and prompts the security measures that later help expose his break-in.

About the Author

Grayce Rian is a contemporary romance author from the Midwest known for crafting stories that blend spice, angst, and sweetness. Her writing style has quickly gained a dedicated following, with readers praising her ability to create emotionally resonant characters and captivating relationships. Rian's personal life influences her work, as she draws inspiration from her own experiences as a high school sweetheart and mother of three. When not writing, she enjoys reading and spending time with her family. Rian's commitment to exploring complex themes while delivering satisfying romantic storylines has established her as a rising star in the genre.

Download PDF

To save this What It Should Be summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.36 MB     Pages: 26

Download EPUB

To read this What It Should Be summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.41 MB     Pages: 35
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...