Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
What Might Have Been

What Might Have Been

One choice splits Lucy's future between a coastal photographer and the ex who broke her heart.
by Holly Miller 2022 320 pages
3.78
4k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

The Smugglers Collision

A broken promise puts two old futures in view

After nine years at Figaro, Lucy Lambert quits when her boss, Georgia, gives a promised copywriting job to an outsider. At The Smugglers, waiting for a bus and nursing a nonalcoholic drink, Lucy checks her horoscope and meets Caleb, a warm photographer who shares her affection for the town. Their easy conversation barely begins before she spots Max Gardner, her university boyfriend, outside.

Lucy abandons Caleb and hurries into the street. Max has come to Shoreley for work and admits he wondered whether to contact her. He is leaving for a diving trip, but they exchange numbers and promise to catch up. Lucy has not seen him in nearly ten years, yet the old conviction that he was the one returns at once.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening gives chance a double entrance: Lucy meets a genuinely new possibility just before the sight of Max revives an unfinished emotional story. Her sudden departure from Caleb shows how nostalgia can command attention before a person has time to question it. The job rupture matters equally. Lucy is not simply choosing between two men; she has reached a point where remaining in a life built around deferred promises no longer feels safe.

Stay Or Go

A spare room competes with a long-delayed novel

Lucy’s friend Jools offers her a room in London and encourages her to apply for a copywriting job at the prestigious Supernova Agency. At home, Lucy’s sister Tash proposes another route: stay in Shoreley, take a part-time job at Pebbles & Paper, and finally write the novel she abandoned after leaving university.

Lucy has spent years telling herself that a stable salary and Georgia’s promises can wait; writing has always been the ambition she postponed. Her old notebook recalls the travels she cut short in Australia, though she has never explained why. The book now branches around Lucy’s decision. In one life she stays, choosing the coast and Caleb. In the other she goes to London, where Max and a demanding new career await.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The fork is not a simple contrast between safety and ambition. Both choices offer Lucy a form of self-respect: London asks her to claim professional recognition, while Shoreley asks her to trust an uncertain creative desire. Her reliance on signs and timing helps her act, but also lets her avoid asking what she wants without a guarantee. The novel’s split structure makes that avoidance visible by letting each decision become a whole life.

Stay: The Beer Mat

Lucy calls the photographer she left waiting

Lucy accepts weekday shifts at Pebbles & Paper, where owner Ivan trains her to run the till and assumes she is already a novelist. At home, she finds the beer mat Caleb slipped into her coat and calls him to apologize for disappearing after Max appeared. Caleb is delighted she got in touch.

At his studio, Lucy tells him she wants to write a love story inspired by her parents; he encourages the ambition and admits his marriage to Helen has ended. Their first proper date takes them to Shoreley’s seafront for fish and chips. Caleb explains that he and Helen wanted different lives, and the two kiss beside the water. At his rented cottage, they linger over coffee and Lucy’s half-written book, then kiss again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Caleb’s appeal emerges through attention rather than grand display. He remembers Lucy’s favorite pub snack, listens to her uncertain plans, and does not treat her dream as a joke. That steadiness gives her a different kind of romantic evidence from the dramatic recognition she associates with Max. Her decision to call him is also a small act of repair: she acknowledges that her earlier choice affected another person instead of treating the encounter as disposable.

Go: Soho and Max

Lucy lands her dream writing job and rekindles first love

Lucy moves into Jools’s London house-share and survives Supernova’s eccentric interview, earning a junior copywriter position despite having little professional writing experience. She messages Max after his trip; his reply makes clear that their chance meeting stayed with him too.

At their reunion dinner, Lucy tells him about the job, while Max apologizes for ending their university relationship without giving her an explanation. Their conversation rekindles the ease and attraction they once shared, and Lucy goes back to his flat.

They spend the weekend together and agree to see whether their old relationship can begin again. Tash warns her that the reunion may be nostalgia rather than destiny, but Lucy is exhilarated by the possibility that the life she imagined with Max has returned.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

London gives Lucy immediate external proof of competence: Supernova hires her to do the work Figaro kept withholding. At the same time, Max offers emotional familiarity, making the new city feel less like a risk. The danger is that their physical and conversational ease can conceal the unanswered question at the center of their history. Lucy’s hope is understandable, but it is not yet the same thing as trust.

Stay: A Novel By Sea

Caleb’s belief helps Lucy risk sharing her pages

Caleb courts Lucy with an outdoor performance of Romeo and Juliet, meals at his cottage, and walks along the shore. Lucy begins drafting a 1920s romance based loosely on her parents, but she hesitates to show anyone her pages.

Tash and Simon offer cautious praise; Caleb gives specific encouragement, and his confidence helps Lucy attend novelist Ryan Carwell’s writing group. Fellow member Emma defends Lucy’s work when another writer dismisses romance, and the group’s criticism becomes useful rather than humiliating.

Lucy and Caleb grow intimate, and he becomes part of Tash’s family life, winning over young Dylan. Then Caleb tells Lucy that he and Helen went through six unsuccessful rounds of IVF before their marriage ended. Lucy likes him deeply, but now wonders whether she is entering a future he has already grieved.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Writing and romance develop through the same exposure problem: Lucy wants recognition but fears that sharing her work, or her feelings, will invite rejection. Caleb’s useful praise is not merely flattering; it gives her permission to keep working without promising success. His IVF disclosure complicates the comfort of their new relationship. Lucy learns that intimacy includes another person’s unfinished history, not just the version of the past that makes a new romance feel uncomplicated.

Go: Tash’s Buried Secret

An accidental message explains Max’s unexplained departure

In the London path, Lucy’s reunion with Max quickly becomes serious enough for her to ask why he ended their university relationship. He cannot give her a full answer, and his distress unsettles her.

Later, Lucy sees a message Tash mistakenly sends to her instead of Max, urging him to end things before Lucy learns the truth. Max’s silence confirms that the secret concerns them both. When he comes to Lucy’s house, she presses him until he admits that Tash drove to Norwich after Lucy canceled her visit during a fight with Max.

Tash and Max drank together, then slept together. Max ended his relationship with Lucy soon afterward, while Tash concealed what had happened for nearly a decade as Lucy blamed herself and struggled after university. Lucy cuts them both off.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelation changes the meaning of an old heartbreak: Lucy’s belief that she was abandoned for an unknowable reason had become part of the story she told about herself. The betrayal is doubled because Tash’s silence let Lucy carry the blame alone. The scene also exposes how a single concealed act can shape years of decisions without the injured person’s knowledge. Lucy’s anger is not only about sex; it is about having been denied the truth needed to understand her own life.

Stay: A Birthday Confession

Caleb admits he loves Lucy after overhearing her doubts

During a London visit with Caleb, Lucy considers Max’s unexpected message and worries aloud to Jools about Caleb’s marriage and his past with Helen. Caleb overhears enough to feel that Lucy may still prefer her ex.

At Dylan’s birthday party, he keeps his distance until Lucy finds him and they speak privately in the garden. Caleb admits he has fallen in love with her; Lucy tells him she feels the same and wants him, not Max. Their reunion brings the relationship into the open.

At the same party, Lucy overhears Tash and Simon arguing about Andrea, the colleague with whom Simon once had a one-night stand. Tash later explains that they went to therapy and chose to rebuild their marriage, showing Lucy that love can survive a serious breach without making the hurt disappear.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Caleb’s withdrawal turns Lucy’s private uncertainty into a consequence the relationship can no longer avoid. Their reconciliation requires each to state a choice rather than rely on chemistry to do the work. Tash and Simon’s history gives the scene a difficult parallel: forgiveness is possible, but it is neither automatic nor proof that betrayal was harmless. The story places Lucy’s romantic idealism beside a more effortful model of commitment.

Go: Choosing the Second Chance

Tash’s confession helps Lucy reconsider Max

After weeks apart from Tash, Lucy finally hears her sister’s explanation. Tash admits the affair with Max was brief and drunken, but does not pretend that duration makes it harmless. She also tells Lucy that Simon once cheated on her and that they chose therapy and repair.

Lucy decides she may be able to make a conscious choice about Max without pretending the past did not happen. She visits him, and they agree to move slowly while rebuilding trust. Later, at a karaoke club, Lucy sees a man who resembles Nate, the stranger she met in Australia, and flees in panic.

She tells Max how Nate drugged and robbed her, leaving her with missing memories and a lasting fear of losing control. Max urges her to seek professional help, and their renewed relationship begins to make room for the truth she has hidden.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Tash’s account does not erase her betrayal; it gives Lucy a more complicated framework for judging people who have caused harm. Lucy chooses to try again with Max, but the choice is morally fraught because desire and forgiveness arrive before trust is fully rebuilt. Revealing the Australian trauma is a distinct act of intimacy: Lucy allows Max to see why uncertainty and blackouts frighten her, rather than letting him mistake her caution for indifference.

Stay: Helen Returns

Caleb refuses his ex-wife and asks Lucy to face fear

Caleb’s estranged wife, Helen, unexpectedly appears outside his studio and asks him to meet. Lucy worries that their shared history, especially the failed IVF, may draw him back. Caleb later explains that Helen wants him to return to London, but he has told her he loves Lucy and wants a divorce.

He asks Lucy to consider traveling with him for six months. She quickly refuses, then finally explains what happened in Australia: Nate drugged her, took her money and belongings, and left her unable to know what else occurred.

Caleb recognizes that fear has narrowed her life, but does not demand that she travel. Instead, he asks her to consider whether refusing every journey lets Nate keep taking experiences from her. Lucy is not ready to board a plane, but she begins to question the limit she set.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Helen’s return makes Lucy confront the difference between a former marriage and a present commitment. Caleb’s response matters because he neither hides the past nor asks Lucy to compete with it. His challenge about travel also reframes recovery: safety cannot be measured only by avoiding reminders. Lucy retains control over what she can attempt, while beginning to see that her fear, though protective, has also become a boundary imposed by someone who is no longer present.

Stay: Smoke and Departure

A house fire changes two families’ plans

Caleb’s divorce is finalized, and he finds an opening to photograph cultural heritage sites in Southeast Asia. Lucy encourages him to apply, even though the six-month separation frightens her.

Before he leaves, an electrical fire breaks out while they are house-sitting at her parents’ cottage; Lucy and Caleb escape, and firefighters contain the damage. The crisis brings the family together, but Lucy’s parents, Ruby and Gus, reveal that they have decided to divorce after thirty-five years.

Their marriage, once the unquestioned proof of Lucy’s belief in soulmates, has reached its end. Caleb leaves for his assignment, and Lucy remains in Shoreley. She must now manage the distance from the man she loves while watching the romantic certainty that shaped her childhood fall away.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The fire turns a familiar home into a literal reminder that security can be interrupted without warning. The parents’ decision deepens that rupture: Lucy’s model of lifelong, destined love proves human rather than invulnerable. Caleb’s departure offers a different test of commitment. Unlike a breakup forced by secrecy, this separation is chosen openly for work and growth, asking Lucy to distinguish loving someone from keeping them physically close.

Stay: The Bali Proposal

Lucy crosses an ocean to meet Caleb again

While Caleb is abroad, Lucy finishes the first draft of her novel, though a literary competition rejects her work. Georgia, now retraining as a teacher, reconnects with Lucy and offers to send the manuscript to agent Naomi Banks. Lucy begins revisions with Naomi’s guidance.

After five months apart, she accepts Jools’s suggestion to surprise Caleb in Bali. The journey is frightening, but Lucy reaches his hotel and reunites with him; together they spend ten days exploring the island between his assignments.

On their last evening, Caleb proposes with a blue sapphire ring Lucy had admired in a shop. Lucy accepts. Her trip does not erase what happened in Australia, but it proves she can travel toward something she wants rather than letting fear make every decision for her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The journey is both romantic reunion and a practical act of reclaiming agency. Lucy does not overcome trauma through a sudden cure; she takes a specific risk for a specific reason and discovers she can endure the journey. Her writing follows a similar pattern. Rejection does not settle whether she is a writer, and Georgia’s offer creates another opening. Neither love nor art arrives as fate’s reward; both require continued participation.

Go: The London Life

Lucy and Max rebuild while old fears remain

In the London path, Lucy and Max resume their relationship after speaking honestly about their past. Lucy earns recognition at Supernova for a climate-change campaign, and she accepts psychological help through Max’s work insurance after disclosing the trauma in Australia.

When the fire damages her parents’ home, they decide not to divorce; instead, they use the insurance money and Gus’s voluntary redundancy to pursue an old dream of sailing around the world. Max later asks Lucy to move into his flat, and after months of hesitation she agrees.

Their life together is loving and successful, though the old betrayal has not vanished from the family’s memory. At a Surrey conference, Lucy prioritizes an important presentation and tells Max not to drive out to see her that night.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This branch offers Lucy the success and partnership she once imagined, but it does not make life frictionless. Therapy addresses a wound she could not resolve by willpower, while the family’s response to the fire contrasts with the other path: the same shock leads her parents toward renewed adventure. Lucy’s refusal of Max’s visit is reasonable in the moment, yet the narrative will make its consequence impossible to separate from chance.

Go: The Ring in the Drawer

A police call turns an ordinary refusal irreversible

In the early hours, Surrey Police call Lucy and ask whether she is Max’s partner. She learns that Max turned his car around after she declined his visit and died when a lorry struck his vehicle on the M25. Lucy is consumed by the thought that accepting his offer might have changed the night, though no choice could have guaranteed safety.

After his funeral, she finds a small ring box hidden among his shirts. Dean, Max’s closest friend, explains that Max bought the engagement ring the week before the crash and had been planning to propose. Lucy must grieve both the man she lost and the future she did not know he was preparing to offer. The ring gives her a final, painful confirmation of how completely Max had chosen her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The catastrophe makes counterfactual thinking feel almost irresistible: Lucy can identify one small decision and imagine it as the hinge on which Max’s survival turned. Yet the story does not establish that she caused the crash; it shows grief searching for a controllable explanation. The hidden ring intensifies the loss by revealing a future that was real to Max but never reached Lucy. Love becomes legible after the fact, when it can no longer be answered.

Go: Hope After Loss

Lucy finds a future in the child Max left behind

Still grieving, Lucy discovers she is pregnant with Max’s child. Their daughter, Hope, becomes a source of joy as well as a daily reminder of the father she will never meet. Lucy returns to work and continues therapy, accepting support from Tash, Jools, and her family. A year later, she sits with Hope at a pond and receives an old photograph from Caleb, who had captured Lucy and Max outside The Smugglers on the night they met again.

The image comforts her, but she no longer treats it as proof that fate had arranged their lives. She understands that she and Max chose one another, and that every path carried consequences neither could foresee. She would choose him again, while building the life she has with Hope.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Hope does not function as a replacement for Max or a cure for grief. She makes the future concrete, while the photograph restores a moment Lucy once feared she had lost. Caleb’s image is important because it records their mutual wonder without claiming to explain what followed. Lucy’s final shift is from needing destiny to certify her love toward accepting that a chosen life can matter even when it ends in loss.

Epilogue

In the Stay path, Lucy is newly married to Caleb when she visits the hospital with Jools, who is giving birth. She unexpectedly meets Max, now married and waiting for his own daughter to arrive. Lucy feels curiosity rather than longing; they exchange congratulations and part with kindness.

Later, she returns to Caleb and admits she is ready for them to try for a child. Their wedding, held in the garden where they once watched a play, joins the people who helped Lucy build a life beyond the past. The two endings stand beside each other: one gives her a future with Caleb, the other a daughter who carries Max’s memory.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue refuses to turn either branch into a simple correction of the other. In the Stay ending, Lucy can meet Max without being pulled back into the belief that their past was a promise. In the Go ending, she carries Max forward through Hope while continuing to live beyond him. The hospital setting places birth, memory, and closure in the same corridor, but offers no universal verdict on which life is better. The book’s final emphasis is on the lives people make from choices, including choices whose costs only become visible later.

Analysis

What Might Have Been treats a life choice not as a fork with one correct road, but as the beginning of a whole sequence of relationships, losses, and opportunities. Lucy’s two routes make that proposition concrete. Staying in Shoreley gives her space to write and love Caleb, whose steadiness supports her gradual return to travel. Going to London gives her the career she wanted and a second chance with Max, but it also returns her to the consequences of his old betrayal. Neither branch is insulated from pain. In the Go life, an ordinary refusal to accept Max’s late visit becomes entangled with the fatal crash that follows, making Lucy’s regret painfully understandable without making her responsible for what she could not know. In the Stay life, love does not mean that Lucy and Caleb avoid uncertainty; they face his unfinished marriage, her trauma, and months apart. The novel’s repeated language of soulmates and signs tests the comfort of believing that love is guaranteed by destiny. Lucy’s parents, whose romance once seemed to prove that belief, change their marriage plans, while Tash and Simon show that repair can be chosen after injury. Across both outcomes, the deeper question is not whether the right person exists, but what a person does with love once it is real. The novel makes room for fate as a feeling, but gives responsibility to choices: leaving, returning, speaking honestly, seeking help, and continuing after loss. Its two endings refuse to cancel each other. One life contains a marriage to Caleb; the other contains Max’s daughter and Lucy’s grief. Both are meaningful because Lucy lived them, not because one can be declared the only life she was meant to have.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After quitting her unfulfilling job, Lucy must choose between staying in her coastal hometown to write or moving to London for a copywriting career. In the Shoreley branch, she falls for photographer Caleb, faces her trauma from a drugging and robbery in Australia, and travels to Bali to reunite with him. She completes a novel, accepts Caleb's proposal, and later encounters Max with affection rather than longing. In the London branch, Lucy rekindles her relationship with Max, despite discovering he once slept with her sister Tash and ended their university romance without telling her why. They rebuild trust, but Max dies in a car crash after Lucy declines his late-night visit. She discovers he planned to propose and learns she is pregnant. Their daughter Hope helps Lucy move forward as she grieves and continues therapy.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.78 out of 5
Average of 4k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

What Might Have Been is a sliding doors-style contemporary romance following Lucy, who must choose between staying in her hometown to write a novel and pursue a relationship with photographer Caleb, or moving to London to rekindle her romance with ex-boyfriend Max. Reviews are largely positive, praising the emotional depth, clever dual timelines, and thought-provoking themes around fate and choice. Some readers found the pacing slow and Lucy's character difficult to connect with, while others were moved to tears by the ending.

Your rating:
4.67
17 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Lucy Lambert

The divided-hearted writer

Lucy is the novel’s observant, self-questioning center, a former advertising planner who has long wanted to write fiction. She is drawn to signs and romantic certainty, partly because they make risk feel guided rather than chosen. A traumatic experience in Australia has made her wary of travel, alcohol, and situations where she cannot stay in control. Lucy’s humor and attentiveness often conceal how intensely she compares herself with her polished sister and more accomplished colleagues. Her two possible lives test different versions of courage: claiming professional ambition in London, or building a creative life and relationship in Shoreley. In both, she must learn that longing can reveal what matters without dictating what she should do.

Caleb

The grounded photographer

Caleb is a Shoreley-born photographer with an easy warmth and a preference for honest, unposed work. He is attentive without being showy, often expressing care through remembered details, practical gestures, and genuine interest in other people. His marriage to Helen and their struggle to have a child have left him with complicated feelings about family and the life he wants. He values freedom and travel, but is not careless about commitment. Caleb’s steadiness gives Lucy room to speak about her ambitions and fears without demanding that she resolve them on his timetable. His confidence in her writing is rooted in the pages themselves, not simply in his attraction to her.

Max Gardner

Lucy’s first great love

Max is a successful property litigator whose charm and composure make him easy to trust. At university he and Lucy shared an intense first love and imagined a future together. His professional discipline grew partly from a childhood shaped by an unreliable mother and financial instability. Max is caring and thoughtful, but his instinct to manage painful situations privately can leave people he loves without the truth they need. His return to Lucy reopens a relationship that still holds tenderness, attraction, and unanswered questions. He represents not just the person she once loved, but the powerful pull of a future she has spent years imagining.

Tash

Lucy’s protective older sister

Tash is Lucy’s older sister, a polished and capable businesswoman who shares a close household with her husband, Simon, and their son, Dylan. Her confidence can make Lucy feel comparatively unfinished, but Tash is also a practical source of support and a fierce advocate for her sister. She tends to protect people by steering them toward safer choices, sometimes before asking what they want. Her own marriage and family life complicate her advice about love, forgiveness, and risk.

Jools

Lucy’s steadfast confidante

Jools has been Lucy’s closest friend since childhood and offers the kind of loyalty that survives distance, awkward decisions, and family crises. A nurse with a chaotic family background, she has built an orderly adult life while retaining a belief in romance and possibility. Jools encourages Lucy to take chances but does not confuse encouragement with control. Her practical kindness, frank humor, and readiness to provide a room, a listening ear, or moral support make her a stabilizing presence in both paths.

Simon

Tash’s devoted husband

Simon is Tash’s husband and Dylan’s father, a mild, handsome mortgage broker who values family and routine. His outward steadiness can make him seem less emotionally complicated than he is. He and Tash face strains that reveal the difference between a marriage that appears secure and one that must be actively maintained. Simon’s family role also gives Lucy a close view of the responsibilities and compromises that accompany long-term love.

Helen

Caleb’s estranged wife

Helen is a high-powered magazine editor whose ambitions and preferences have increasingly diverged from Caleb’s. Their marriage included years of shared plans and a difficult attempt to start a family. She is not merely a rival in Lucy’s imagination; she represents a substantial life Caleb built before meeting Lucy. Her presence forces Lucy to confront the fact that a new relationship does not erase the emotional weight of an old one.

Nate

The charming stranger abroad

Nate is the handsome Australian stranger Lucy meets during her travels. His polished manner and apparent interest in her offer a sharp contrast to the unease she feels in unfamiliar surroundings. His encounter with Lucy becomes part of the private history she struggles to explain, shaping her relationship to travel, alcohol, and trust.

Ryan Carwell

The demanding writing mentor

Ryan is a published novelist who leads Shoreley’s low-cost writing group. Animated and sometimes theatrical about craft, he takes Lucy’s writing seriously and presses her to share it beyond the safety of her own pages. His own stalled career gives his encouragement a personal edge: he knows that talent and recognition do not always arrive together.

Emma

Lucy’s outspoken writing peer

Emma is a fellow member of Ryan’s writing group, working on a novel about a woman who leaves her former life. Quick to challenge dismissive criticism, she becomes one of the first people outside Lucy’s family to defend her work. Her directness helps turn the group into a place where Lucy can risk being read rather than merely praised.

Georgia

The former boss who apologizes

Georgia founded Figaro and employed Lucy as a planner, relying on her to help the growing agency run smoothly. She repeatedly postponed Lucy’s move into writing, damaging both their professional relationship and their friendship. Later, Georgia reassesses her own life and approaches Lucy with a sincere apology. Her story shows how a rupture can prompt change for both the person who leaves and the person left behind.

Dylan

Lucy’s beloved young nephew

Dylan is Tash and Simon’s young son, an energetic child who loves toys, videos, and magic. His affection for Lucy gives her a strong bond with her sister’s household and makes family conflict impossible to treat as purely adult business. His straightforward observations often cut through the evasions of the people around him.

Ruby and Gus Lambert

Lucy’s romantic parents

Ruby and Gus are Lucy and Tash’s parents, whose holiday meeting in Menorca became the family’s cherished origin story. Their affectionate partnership shaped Lucy’s belief in soulmates and inspired her first novel. They are loving parents, but not symbols of perfect romance: work, age, and changing desires affect them too. Their choices force their daughters to reconsider what a lasting love story can look like.

Dean Farraday

Max’s loyal closest friend

Dean is a criminal barrister and Max’s longtime friend from university. Confident, sociable, and blunt, he knows Max across both his student years and adult life. He becomes an important link between Max’s private intentions and Lucy’s understanding of him, particularly when Max cannot speak for himself.

Nigel

Jools’s careful housemate

Nigel first appears as the courteous prospective housemate who brings muffins to view a room. He works in financial auditing after arthritis interrupted his hopes of becoming a professional pianist. His meticulousness and quiet good humor suit Jools’s preference for a dependable partner, while his music reveals a less conventional ambition beneath his sensible manner.

Plot Devices

The Stay Or Go Split

Two lives from one choice

The narrative divides after Lucy considers moving to London or remaining in Shoreley. The Stay route follows her life with Caleb and her return to writing; the Go route follows her move to Supernova and renewed relationship with Max. The parallel structure does not present one path as a simple mistake and the other as a reward. Instead, it lets readers see how separate choices create distinct forms of love, work, family, and loss.

Horoscopes and Signs

A tempting guide to chance

Lucy notices horoscopes, lucky coincidences, and family sayings about what is meant to happen. These signs help her take action when she is uncertain, including when she meets Max and when she considers changing careers. Their meaning remains unstable: a coincidence can feel like destiny, but it cannot tell Lucy what a relationship will require or protect her from its consequences. The motif gradually shifts from prophecy toward personal choice.

Lucy’s Unfinished Novel

Creativity as self-recovery

Lucy’s long-abandoned idea for a romantic novel connects her university ambitions, her parents’ love story, and the years when she could not bear to write. In the Stay path, the writing group, Caleb’s response, and Georgia’s introduction to an agent help her move from private daydream to sustained work. The manuscript is not simply a career prize. Writing gives Lucy a way to examine emotion, make meaning from memory, and claim an identity she had repeatedly postponed.

The Beach Hut

A sheltered place for risk

Caleb’s borrowed beach hut becomes a private setting where Lucy can write, swim, and grow close to him. It is both a shelter and a threshold: its warmth makes the cold sea bearable, while the shoreline beyond it invites Lucy to encounter uncertainty. The hut’s practical comforts suit Caleb’s style of care, and its changing view gives Lucy a place to work without leaving the town she has chosen.

Caleb’s Photograph

A memory returned with context

Caleb takes a candid image of Lucy and Max outside The Smugglers on the night they meet again. He first considers using it to contact Lucy, then deletes it because keeping it feels intrusive. Years later, he sends it to Lucy after Max’s death. The photograph preserves the happiness of their reunion without proving that they were destined to remain together. Its force comes from what it lets Lucy remember, and from the meaning she chooses to give that memory.

About the Author

Holly Miller grew up in Bedfordshire, UK, developing a lifelong love of reading and writing from an early age. After studying creative writing at art school, she built a career as a magazine editor, marketer, and creative copywriter. Her debut love story, The Sight Of You, was published in the UK and 23 other territories in 2020 and has been optioned for film by a Hollywood studio. Holly now lives in the Norfolk countryside with her husband and their rescue border collie, and has been actively working on additional novels beyond her successful debut.

Download PDF

To save this What Might Have Been summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.36 MB     Pages: 24

Download EPUB

To read this What Might Have Been summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.42 MB     Pages: 29
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...