Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Who to Believe

Who to Believe

A Maine therapist's clients circle a murder case as another body appears; whose secrets matter?
by Edwin Hill 2024 314 pages
3.90
1k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Laurel's Unquiet Death

A therapist hears fear beneath the town's rumors

A news report announces that Laurel Thibodeau, co-owner of Monreith's Firefly Bistro, was found suffocated in her home. A week later, Dr. Farley Drake's client Alice Stone comes to therapy on her fortieth birthday and admits she knew Laurel. Simon Thibodeau, Laurel's husband, looks guilty to the town: he lied about a catering job, gambled away twenty thousand dollars, and carried a large life insurance policy on Laurel.

Yet Laurel had also been stealing from church members to help cover the couple's debts. Farley pieces together his clients' gossip, watches them outside his office, and wonders whether the killer might be among them. Alice leaves him with the question the police have not answered: if Simon did not kill Laurel, who did?

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening makes communal knowledge feel both useful and dangerous. Farley treats therapy as a privileged vantage point from which to assemble a case, but his habit of observing clients outside the office already blurs the boundary between care and surveillance. Alice's careful disclosure invites him to investigate while withholding the fact that would matter most. Meanwhile, Simon's public guilt is assembled from real flaws, not proof. The novel begins by showing how a small town can mistake a convincing story for an established truth, and how a therapist's confidence in reading people may be another form of misjudgment.

The Shrink's Entanglements

Farley's private life makes every boundary negotiable

Farley is not merely Alice's therapist. He has become her friend, though he knows the relationship should have ended when he began dating Richard Macomber, Alice's friend and the estranged husband of Reverend Georgia Fitzhugh.

Farley also once treated Georgia, whose sessions exposed her conflict between a vulnerable private self and the polished minister the town expects. At Georgia's church, Farley meets state detective Brock London and sees former clients, including Everett Irving, moving through the same network of secrets.

He then collects Georgia's suspended daughter, Chloe, after she punches Taylor Lawson, and takes her for ice cream despite her grounding. Chloe needles him about the adults' affairs, while Chief Max Barbosa warns that he does not trust Farley around her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Farley's relationships collapse professional, romantic, and social roles into one another. His belief that he can manage these overlaps through observation and charm disguises the fact that he has made himself indispensable in other people's private lives. Georgia's split between public authority and private need mirrors Farley's own division between clinician and lover, though he sees her conflict more clearly than his own. Chloe, who notices the adults' hidden attachments, punctures their self-protective performances. Her presence makes the town's blurred boundaries more than an ethical problem: they shape the emotional world a child is trying to navigate.

The Crime Board

Damian's murder theory points back toward Farley

At Alice's birthday gathering, filmmaker Damian Stone presses Max about the Thibodeau investigation and argues that the murder may connect to other suspicious deaths. Farley later slips into Damian's office and finds photographs of Steve Alabiso and Jeanine Geller beside Laurel's.

He recognizes the first two victims because he killed them himself, staging their deaths to resemble suicide and leave suspicion on their spouses. Damian has begun linking the cases through the victims' affairs and their spouses' alibis.

Alice finds Farley studying the board and asks what he would do if a patient confessed to murder. Her warning unsettles him, especially because she knows Damian's search for truth can expose what lies close to home. Farley leaves the party planning to silence Alice before she can reveal more.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The board turns Damian's storytelling into a threat because it organizes separate private tragedies into a pattern. Farley recognizes himself in the pattern, yet his narration tries to preserve control by presenting his killings as calculated and deserved. The contrast is important: he can explain how he staged each death, but explanation is not moral insight. Alice's question about confidentiality quietly tests whether he can separate professional duty from self-preservation. His decision to target her shows that his clinical language has become a tool for managing danger, not understanding another person.

Alice's Hidden Ledger

Her marriage contains an affair and older secrets

Alice's perspective reveals that she met Damian as an undergraduate while he was her professor, and that their affair cost him his teaching job and his first marriage. She became the family's main earner while accepting Damian's recurring affairs as part of the marriage she chose.

In Monreith, his latest affair is with Laurel. Alice also has her own history: as a young teenager in Germany, she killed an older teacher who exploited her, and in Maine she killed Father Jean-Marc after learning he abused children.

When she finds a cracked burner phone hidden beneath Noah's mattress, she suspects it may connect Damian to Laurel, but cannot yet face what the police might uncover. She keeps it from Max and prepares for her birthday party with suspicion tightening around her husband.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Alice distinguishes agency from innocence. She insists that her adult choices were her own, yet her past includes violence she has justified as protection from men who harmed the vulnerable. Her marriage to Damian is similarly organized around control: she provides financial security and accepts infidelity rather than surrendering her independence. The burner phone threatens that arrangement because it could convert private knowledge into public evidence. Alice's restraint is not simply denial; it is a strategy learned through years of moving between households and keeping parts of herself concealed. That strategy has protected her, but it also leaves others exposed.

A Body on the Marsh

Max finds Farley beneath the farm's bluff

After the birthday party, Max Barbosa hears a scream and runs through the storm to Moulton Farm. He finds Alice soaked and bloodied beside a body near the boat launch. At first, he assumes she has killed Damian, but the dead man is Farley. Alice says she found him while searching for Harper, her dog, and Max calls in the scene before the rising tide can erase it.

Damian emerges from the house alive and admits he had been sleeping with Laurel, though he says she was alive when he left her home the night she died. Brock arrives, takes control, and warns Max that his personal connection to Alice and his unsanctioned response make him a witness, not the investigator. Max also admits Alice kissed him at the party.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The body's discovery converts Max's private longing into a conflict of duty. He wants to protect Alice, but the scene requires him to treat her as a potential suspect and himself as compromised. His first assumption, that Damian is dead, reflects how quickly the affair has become the lens through which he interprets events. The tide gives the investigation physical urgency: evidence is not merely hidden by lies, but literally at risk of being washed away. Brock's arrival restores procedure, while also exposing how easily Max's desire to rescue Alice could contaminate the truth.

The Missing Mallet

Evidence makes the dead therapist a suspect

Brock interviews Damian and discovers the whiteboard connecting Laurel to Steve and Jeanine. Damian also shows him anonymous texts from someone claiming the deaths are linked, including a message about therapy sessions being confidential.

The case turns when investigators confirm that Farley's DNA was at Laurel's crime scene, and Brock notes that Farley wore dark clothing, a balaclava, and carried a hunting knife when he died. One of the six croquet mallets used at the party is missing, and the wound on Farley's head could fit such a weapon.

The clues complicate Damian's theory: Farley may have been the killer he was tracking, even as someone at the party killed him. Max recuses himself, but Brock keeps him close for his knowledge of the town.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The evidence reverses the moral direction of the investigation. The therapist who appeared to be an observer of other people's secrets may have been the most dangerous person in the room. Yet the clues do not simply solve the case: the missing mallet implicates the party's guests, while the knife and disguise suggest Farley arrived with violent intent. The anonymous texts further complicate authorship, since their accuracy does not establish who sent them or why. Brock's disciplined uncertainty contrasts with the town's appetite for a single culprit and insists that suspicion must remain provisional.

Richard's Midnight Text

A message turns the boyfriend into a suspect

Richard Macomber, who has recently left Georgia for a life with Farley, carries secrets of his own: an offshore account, cash from questionable car deals, and a deed to half of Farley's house. On the night Farley disappears, Richard sees him leave during the storm but does not follow. In the morning, detectives learn that a text from Richard's number asked Damian to meet at the dock, close to where Farley's body was found.

Richard does not remember sending it, and the burner phone that received it is now in Damian's possession. After a tense ride with Damian, Richard takes the phone to the station, but Max arrests him when the recovered message appears to link him to the murder. The town's attention turns toward the grieving boyfriend.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Richard's apparent simplicity has always been a social mask. His hidden money and carefully controlled account reveal a capacity for practical self-protection, while his new relationship with Farley exposes how long he has allowed others to define him. The suspicious text exploits both vulnerabilities: it makes a private message look like a deliberate invitation to the crime scene. Richard's arrest demonstrates how evidence can be technically real yet misleading when its context is withheld. He becomes a plausible suspect not because the investigation has proved his guilt, but because his secrets make the false story easier to believe.

Chloe Finds the Phone

A stolen device connects the adults' secrets

Chloe's account fills in the days before the murder. Angry at Georgia's refusal to give her a phone, she breaks into the church and steals a cracked device from the Lost and Found. Noah helps her try passcodes, but Alice eventually takes the phone after finding the teenagers with it. Chloe also punches Taylor after Taylor insults Richard for being gay, earning a suspension and a month of grounding.

On the stormy night of Farley's death, Chloe sneaks out to retrieve the phone from the farmhouse and sees Georgia near the property. Later, she recognizes that the phone's code, 0531, points to her mother's past. Chloe carries what she has learned to Max, but fear for her father makes her hesitate before telling the whole truth.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Chloe's actions begin as ordinary adolescent defiance: she wants privacy, access to peers, and a way to move through town without adult supervision. But the stolen phone places her inside a chain of adult secrecy that she cannot safely interpret. Her punch is also a response to a direct attack on her father's identity, not simply a burst of teenage aggression. The book lets Chloe's moral growth emerge through selective disclosure. She has learned to keep secrets from the adults who monitor her, yet she must decide which secret will protect her family and which will perpetuate harm.

Georgia Builds a Pattern

Two betrayed spouses lead her toward Farley

Georgia's earlier memories reveal how the anonymous texts began. After hearing that Everett Irving's wife had been involved with Steve Alabiso, and later learning from a colleague that Jeanine Geller had also been having an affair, Georgia connects both dead lovers to Farley, who had treated the betrayed spouses.

She buys a burner phone and sends Damian clues, hoping to unsettle Farley and provoke an explanation, not believing the therapist is truly a killer. The texts give Damian the beginnings of his murder theory.

Georgia's motives are tangled with resentment over Farley sleeping with Richard while treating her, and with her need to keep her own public reputation intact. What starts as petty revenge becomes a trail she can no longer control.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Georgia's investigative impulse grows from professional observation, but its engine is personal injury. She sees a pattern because her role requires her to notice what a community conceals, then uses that insight not to seek justice but to punish Farley indirectly. The burner phone becomes an instrument of controlled exposure: she can provoke discovery while remaining outside its consequences. Her error is not simply underestimating Farley. It is assuming that she can manage the truth as she manages her public persona, releasing only enough to regain power without becoming answerable for what follows.

Laurel Names the Threat

A theft confession becomes a deadly confrontation

Georgia discovers that Laurel has been selling jewelry stolen from elderly church members, and confronts her with proof from an online listing. Laurel explains that Simon's gambling debts have brought threats from a creditor, but she also reveals she knows about Georgia's relationship with Max and her own affair with Damian.

More dangerously, Laurel has seen Damian's anonymous messages and recognizes that they could point toward someone close to Farley. Georgia leaves without resolving the encounter, then watches Damian visit Laurel the following night and promise to tell Alice about their affair.

Afraid Laurel will expose the burner campaign and her betrayal of Farley, Georgia enters the house after Damian leaves and suffocates Laurel with a plastic bag, then leaves Farley's hair to implicate him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Laurel's death grows from intersecting acts of concealment rather than one isolated motive. Her theft is a desperate response to Simon's debts, but the threat she poses to Georgia is the possibility that private betrayals will become public facts. Georgia's ministerial identity makes her skilled at hearing confession, yet she cannot tolerate being treated as a person who must confess. By planting Farley's hair, she attempts to redirect accountability toward someone she already distrusts. The act exposes the danger of moral bookkeeping: Georgia casts herself as correcting one betrayal while committing a more final one.

The Dockside Frame

Georgia borrows Richard's phone and a mallet

At Alice's party, Georgia notices that the burner phone has resurfaced and moved from Alice to Damian. She fears he will trace its messages back to her. After the guests leave, she takes Richard's phone and sends the burner a message asking Damian to meet at the dock, hoping the text will make Richard look responsible.

She also takes a croquet mallet and hides beneath the gangway, intending to kill Damian before he can expose her. Chloe arrives unexpectedly in the storm.

Georgia sees her daughter, abandons the mallet, and follows her instead of continuing toward Damian. Farley, meanwhile, has gone to the farm on his own mission. The storm leaves both women with knowledge of one another's presence, but neither yet understands the full danger.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The dock concentrates the novel's competing forms of concealment. Georgia uses Richard's phone to manufacture an incriminating trace, while the mallet makes her plan materially real. Chloe's sudden appearance interrupts the action not through force but through attachment: Georgia's role as a mother briefly overrides her role as a self-protective killer. That interruption does not undo what she has done to Laurel or prevent the next crime. The storm's obscured sightlines mirror the characters' limited knowledge, but the scene also demonstrates that intimate relationships can disrupt a planned narrative in ways evidence cannot.

Georgia's Last Cover

Damian confronts her, then dies on Drift Road

The morning after Farley's death, Damian visits Georgia at the church and recognizes that she sent the burner messages. He attacks her, demanding the phone and an explanation. Georgia escapes, gets into her car, and later finds Damian cycling along Drift Road.

She deliberately drives into him, leaving him unconscious beside the guardrail, then searches his clothes and the roadside for the missing burner. She returns to the church, where Chloe tells her Max has arrested Richard and that the phone is in police hands.

With the clues converging, Georgia tells Chloe they must stand together, but Chloe has already given Max the information that links her mother to the farm. Georgia's attempt to protect herself has now produced two deaths and exposed her to investigation.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Georgia's second killing is different from Laurel's: it follows a direct confrontation, but it is still a choice to eliminate the person who can reveal her. The violence punctures the minister's practiced distinction between public service and private weakness. Her search for the burner after the crash shows that she remains focused on controlling the account of events even as her actions become harder to conceal. Chloe's cooperation with Max marks the decisive break. The daughter Georgia tried to shield and manage becomes the person who refuses to accept a family bond as a reason for silence.

Harper Remembers Farley

The dog reveals who swung the final mallet

The dog's later memories disclose what happened in the storm before Max found Farley's body. Farley returned to the marsh wearing a disguise and carrying a knife because he intended to kill Alice after recognizing her past violence.

Alice admits she killed Father Jean-Marc and the abusive teacher from her youth, and Farley confirms that he killed Steve, Jeanine, and others. When he reaches for Alice, she strikes him repeatedly with a croquet mallet, killing him in self-defense.

She throws the weapon into the bay, then tells Max she found Farley's body after searching for Harper. Georgia did not kill Farley, despite her own plan to use a mallet that night. The dog remembers the two women's actions, while the humans construct competing accounts.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Harper's point of view changes the meaning of the investigation without making the killing morally simple. Alice's violence is defensive in the immediate confrontation, but her earlier murders complicate any clean claim of innocence. Farley, who had narrated his killings as justified, becomes a direct threat to the person he meant to silence. The dog's memory is valuable precisely because Harper does not interpret events through reputation, professional duty, or guilt. She records scent, movement, and fear. The novel uses that limited perspective to expose how human testimony can be both truthful and strategically incomplete.

Epilogue

Three months later, Harper lives between Alice's farm and Max's cottage, where the two adults share a bed while pretending their relationship is still casual. Georgia is in jail after confessing to Laurel's and Damian's murders. The prosecutor does not charge Richard, and investigators link Farley to killings in several states, leaving his death case open but low priority.

Chloe misses her mother and worries about her father, yet she has begun to make peace with Taylor and is forming a life beyond the adults' secrets. Max stays in Monreith rather than taking the Springfield job. In the marsh, Harper finds a discarded croquet mallet and recognizes it from the night Farley died.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending offers partial justice rather than emotional repair. Georgia's confession accounts for two deaths, while Farley's broader crimes explain why authorities are reluctant to spend resources on the murder that remains unresolved in court. Alice and Max build a life together, but their intimacy rests beside an unspoken act that Harper alone has witnessed. Chloe's future is not defined by a tidy reconciliation: she is still grieving, still wary, and increasingly able to set limits with Max. The recovered mallet makes the landscape a quiet archive. The community may move on, but the evidence of its violence has not disappeared.

Analysis

Who to Believe builds its mystery around the difference between knowing someone's secrets and understanding what those secrets mean. Farley treats his patients' disclosures as material for insight, then extends that habit into surveillance and murder. His confidence in interpretation is a form of control: he believes he can identify another person's hidden self while keeping his own beyond scrutiny. The rotating narrators steadily dismantle that confidence. Alice, Max, Richard, Chloe, and Georgia each offer credible accounts shaped by loyalties and fears, not simply deliberate lies. Readers must distinguish factual accuracy from emotional investment.

The novel also examines how institutions that promise care can conceal power. Therapy protects confidences, the church offers counsel, and policing claims impartiality, yet Farley, Georgia, and Max each carry personal desires into those roles. Their failures are not interchangeable. Farley weaponizes his clinical access; Georgia uses her pastoral authority to manage reputation; Max tries to balance public duty with attraction. The community's smallness intensifies each conflict because social knowledge circulates faster than verified evidence.

Chloe provides a crucial counterweight. Her phone dispute looks like ordinary adolescent rebellion, but her hunger for privacy and fairness exposes the adults' hypocrisy. She watches them control information, then must decide whether loyalty means protecting a parent or telling the truth. Harper's final narration completes the argument by offering an account unburdened by human reputation. The dog's sensory memory clarifies who killed Farley, but it cannot settle the larger moral questions: Alice has been both victim and killer, and Farley was both therapist and predator.

The ending resists a clean restoration of order. Georgia confesses to two murders, Richard avoids charges, Farley's other crimes come to light, and Alice and Max begin a life together. Still, Farley's death remains officially unresolved. The book's title is therefore less a puzzle about selecting the most trustworthy narrator than a warning that trust is never a substitute for evidence, and evidence itself can be arranged to tell a lie.

Summary in 60 Seconds
When Laurel Thibodeau is found suffocated, therapist Farley Drake hears suspicions about her husband, Simon, and learns that filmmaker Damian is investigating similar deaths. Farley secretly killed two earlier victims, but Alice Stone, one of his clients, knows more than she admits: she has killed men who abused children, and her husband Damian was having an affair with Laurel. After Farley is found dead near Alice's farm, evidence points toward Richard, Farley's boyfriend, while Georgia, a pastor and former client, is hiding her own role. Georgia killed Laurel to protect her reputation, then deliberately struck Damian with her car when he confronted her. Alice had killed Farley in self-defense after he came to murder her, and Georgia had planted clues to frame Richard. Chloe helps expose her mother's lies. Georgia confesses to Laurel's and Damian's murders, Richard is cleared, and Farley's other killings are uncovered, though his death remains officially unresolved. Alice and Max begin a relationship.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.90 out of 5
Average of 1k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Who to Believe receives mostly positive reviews, averaging 3.90/5. Readers praise its unique multi-POV structure, where the same events unfold through seven distinct narrators, including a dog. Many appreciate the clever mystery, well-developed characters, and surprising twists. Common criticisms include repetitiveness as the same events are retold from multiple perspectives, and some readers struggled to connect with characters. The audiobook's full cast of narrators is frequently highlighted as enhancing the experience. Overall, most readers found it an entertaining, suspenseful page-turner despite its structural quirks.

Your rating:
4.68
15 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Farley Drake

The charming therapist

A psychiatrist who recently settled in Monreith, Farley is handsome, affluent, observant, and accustomed to getting what he wants. He sees himself as a skilled reader of people and often watches clients outside the office, believing that such scrutiny gives him insight. His attraction to rescue roles shapes both his therapy and his relationships, especially with Alice and Richard. Farley is drawn to secrets partly because they let him feel in control of a room. His confidence, however, makes him careless about professional boundaries and other people's capacity to read him in return.

Alice Stone

The guarded financial planner

A successful financial planner, Alice is married to documentary filmmaker Damian and mother to Noah. A childhood spent moving between countries taught her to adapt quickly, identify allies, and keep parts of herself private. She likes control and financial independence, but she is not emotionally detached: she wants to be understood without surrendering the choices that have made her life hers. Her therapy with Farley is as much a weekly human connection as a search for change. Alice's fierce protectiveness toward her family coexists with a sharp ability to assess danger.

Max Barbosa

The watchful police chief

Monreith's chief of police, Max grew up on Mooney Point and carries a strong sense of responsibility for its residents, especially Chloe. His loyalty to the town is bound up with family history and the loss of the old property that Farley replaced with a new house. Max is disciplined at work but less certain in his private attachments, where old feelings and present attraction pull him in different directions. His instinct is to protect, sometimes before he has established what protection requires. That tension makes his personal loyalties a challenge to his professional judgment.

Georgia Fitzhugh

The public-facing minister

Georgia is a Unitarian minister, Chloe's mother, and Richard's estranged wife. In public she is composed, welcoming, and skilled at helping parishioners through crisis; in private she resents the expectation that she must never falter. She chose a marriage that supported her public role, while a long friendship with Max represents the life she did not choose. Georgia's instinct to manage appearances can be compassionate, but it can also keep her from naming her own needs. Her ministry gives her unusual access to the town's confidences and makes her attentive to how reputations are built.

Richard Macomber

The underestimated mechanic

Richard, whom longtime friends still call Ritchie, is a mechanic and classic-car broker, Georgia's estranged husband, and Farley's new partner. For much of his life he has hidden behind the roles of dependable friend and easygoing husband. He is learning to express his queerness openly and to claim a style and identity that feel like his own. His affection for Chloe is deep, though work and avoidance sometimes keep him from responding when she needs him. Richard is more calculating than people assume, particularly about money and the risks of depending on others.

Chloe Macomber

The sharp-eyed daughter

Thirteen-year-old Chloe is Georgia and Richard's daughter. She is angry about her parents' separation, frustrated by her mother's rules, and determined not to be treated as a child who understands nothing. Pink hair, a secret taste for forbidden snacks, and a talent for noticing adult attractions help her assert a self that does not fit Georgia's expectations. Chloe can be funny and defiant, but she is also sensitive to rejection and to the ways adults hide information from her. Her loyalty to both parents makes her careful about what she reveals and to whom.

Damian Stone

The restless filmmaker

Damian is Alice's husband, Noah's father, and a documentary filmmaker whose projects often turn on discovering hidden stories. He is charismatic, fit, and quick to perform confidence, though his career has been less secure than his public manner suggests. He relies on Alice's financial success while chafing at that dependence. Damian is drawn to difficult subjects and has a gift for turning fragments into a compelling narrative, but that gift can become obsession. His marriage is built on shared history and mobility, as well as a recurring tolerance for choices that injure trust.

Brock London

The state-case detective

A state detective brought in to investigate Laurel's murder, Brock is methodical, direct, and alert to the ways local loyalties can distort a case. He asks for the detail people hope to omit and distinguishes what is known from what merely seems likely. His professionalism is tempered by personal experience as a husband and stepparent, which helps him read family tensions without excusing them. Brock's partnership with Max depends on useful local knowledge, but he is quick to insist that Max step aside when personal involvement compromises the investigation.

Harper

The loyal pit bull

Harper is Alice's rescued pit bull mix, found neglected near the marsh and taken in after Max warned that few people would want her. She follows Alice closely and trusts the household more readily than Alice trusts most people. Thunder frightens her, and her fear repeatedly draws the adults toward the places they would rather avoid. Harper's needs are simple and bodily: safety, food, company, and the chance to run. Her presence makes her a source of comfort, but also an attentive witness to behavior the people around her misread.

Noah Stone

Chloe's thoughtful friend

Noah is Alice and Damian's thirteen-year-old son and Chloe's close friend. Having moved between communities with his parents, he is accustomed to making new friends and then leaving them behind. He is gentle, technically curious, and less troubled than Chloe by being socially different. Noah sometimes experiments with adult behavior, including his father's hidden marijuana, while still retaining a child's instinct to seek closeness with his mother. His friendship with Chloe gives her a rare peer relationship in which she can be both mischievous and understood.

Laurel Thibodeau

The beloved restaurant owner

Laurel co-owns Firefly Bistro with her husband, Simon, and volunteers with Georgia's church, often helping older parishioners with errands. She is remembered as warm, efficient, and generous with regular customers. That public reputation sits beside the financial strain of her marriage and the private decisions she makes to meet it. Laurel is not merely a symbol of community virtue or victimhood: she has her own motives and makes choices that complicate the town's easy judgments.

Simon Thibodeau

The grieving restaurateur

Simon is Laurel's husband and the chef behind Firefly's food. Gambling debts, financial pressure, and his wife's death make him an immediate target of town suspicion. He can be proud and difficult, but grief leaves him isolated in a home that has become the center of public scrutiny. His connection to the church and to Alice's birthday catering shows how closely his life is woven into Monreith's social fabric. Simon's story demonstrates how a real weakness can make a person look guilty even when the evidence has not established guilt.

Maggie

The church's sharp observer

Maggie is Georgia's church secretary, a longtime Monreith resident, and a mother and grandmother. She spends quiet hours on solitaire and a romance manuscript, and she often sees more than the people who treat her as background. Her warmth toward Chloe gives the girl a rare adult ally who does not demand a confession before offering sympathy. Maggie knows the town's routines and remembers its people, but she does not confuse familiarity with authority.

Taylor Lawson

Chloe's volatile classmate

Taylor is a classmate and former elementary-school friend of Chloe's. She uses gossip and social access to position herself among her peers, and her behavior helps make Chloe feel excluded. Taylor's home life is troubled, although Chloe initially sees mostly the cruelty directed at her. Her changing relationship with Chloe illustrates how school hierarchies can shift when the adults around a child also change.

Iris Parke

The investigating detective

Iris is a state detective working alongside Brock. Young, observant, and brisk in interviews, she notices the inconsistencies in Richard's account and pushes him to clarify relationships that the town treats as obvious. She represents the outside investigative team as it enters a community where nearly every witness knows another suspect.

Everett Irving

The church treasurer

Everett is the church treasurer and a former client of Farley's. He brings private marital distress into Georgia's orbit and helps expose how affairs and suspicions connect people across Monreith and nearby towns. His precise, reserved manner makes his disclosures feel especially weighty.

Plot Devices

Rotating narrators

Reframes the same evidence

The novel shifts among Farley, Alice, Max, Richard, Chloe, Georgia, and finally Harper. Each perspective reveals facts the prior narrator concealed or misunderstood, so the murder mystery advances through contradiction as much as through new evidence. The changing voices also alter the reader's sense of guilt: a character who appears protective in one account may be self-serving in another. The structure asks readers to revise judgments rather than settle on the first persuasive explanation.

The burner phone

Turns secrecy into evidence

A cracked prepaid phone carries anonymous messages linking deaths, a photo of Laurel's murder, and a message designed to implicate Richard. Its passcode and custody change the meaning of the same device as it moves among Chloe, Alice, Damian, and the police. The phone is not a neutral record: someone created it to direct suspicion, while its contents preserve clues that the sender could not fully control. It connects the past crimes to the present investigation and makes the question of who possesses evidence as important as what the evidence says.

Therapy confidentiality

Shelters and threatens secrets

Farley's clinical duty to protect patient disclosures becomes a moral and procedural pressure point. Alice tests the limits of confidentiality by asking what happens when a patient admits to murder, while Georgia's earlier sessions establish the therapist's access to the private lives of people connected to the case. The rule can protect someone seeking help, but it can also conceal information from investigators. The novel turns a professional boundary into a source of suspense, asking whether confidentiality remains care when the therapist has become personally entangled.

The croquet mallet

A party object becomes a weapon

The guests use a set of six mallets during Alice's birthday game. After Farley's death, only five remain, making an ordinary party object a central piece of forensic evidence and a possible weapon for several suspects. The mallet's meaning changes as the investigation unfolds: it supports suspicion of the guests, becomes part of a planned attack, and is later remembered by Harper as the instrument used in Farley's death. Its everyday familiarity helps conceal violence in plain sight.

Harper's memory

Reveals what people omit

The final perspective belongs to Harper, whose attention follows scents, sounds, and physical movement rather than the social explanations offered by the human characters. Her recollection restores the missing events on the marsh and distinguishes Georgia's abandoned plan from Alice's actual confrontation with Farley. The dog does not provide a legal account or moral verdict, but her sensory memory supplies the decisive narrative fact. This shift makes the ending both clarifying and unsettling: the clearest witness is one the investigators cannot question.

About the Author

Edwin Hill is an Edgar and Agatha Award–nominated author of standalone thrillers and mystery series. His works include What Happened Next, Who to Believe, The Secrets We Share, and the Hester Thursby series featuring Little Comfort, The Missing Ones, and Watch Her. He has earned starred reviews from Publishers Weekly, Kirkus Reviews, Booklist, and Library Journal, and was named one of Six Crime Writers to Watch by Mystery Scene magazine. He has also been featured in Us Weekly. Edwin lives in Roslindale, Massachusetts, with his partner Michael and their book-eating Labrador, Edith Ann.

Download PDF

To save this Who to Believe summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.36 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this Who to Believe summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.40 MB     Pages: 32
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...