Key Takeaways
More than half of Americans remix religion instead of simply abandoning it
The census misses belief. The book estimates that more than half of Americans are religiously “Remixed,” drawing on three overlapping groups: people who are spiritual but not religious, unaffiliated people who still believe in something spiritual, and people who combine an established religion with practices from elsewhere. The estimate is not a precise headcount, since the groups are difficult to measure and may overlap. But the central point is clear: a religious label tells little about what someone believes or does. A 2018 Pew study cited in the book found that 72 percent of religiously unaffiliated Americans believed in God or a higher power. Only about 7 percent identified outright as atheist or agnostic.
A changed kind of faith. These Americans are not necessarily leaving spirituality behind. Many are moving its authority from churches and formal creeds toward personal experience, selected practices, and chosen communities.
The distinction between affiliation and belief is useful because a survey checkbox can make religious change look more complete than it is. People may leave institutions while keeping prayer, ritual, or spiritual explanations of experience. The reverse also happens: a person may retain a religious label as family inheritance without practicing its doctrine. The book's estimate is best read as a cultural argument, not a clean demographic statistic. Its strength lies in showing that secularization can mean institutional exit without the disappearance of spiritual needs.
Define religion by the work it does, not only the god it names
Four human needs. The book uses a functional lens: religion can be understood by how it supplies meaning, purpose, community, and ritual, whether or not it makes claims about a deity. Meaning explains how the world works and where suffering comes from. Purpose gives people a role within that account. Community connects them to others, and ritual turns shared commitments into repeated action.
A theater can become sacred. The opening example is Sleep No More, an immersive production in Manhattan where masked visitors explore a theatrical world, hunt for hidden connections, and sometimes meet actors privately. Repeat visitors built friendships and rituals around returning. The author sees the same pattern in workouts, fandom, and political activity: ordinary actions take on religious force when they organize a shared story and identity.
This framework helps explain why a fitness class or fan community can feel more consequential than its official purpose suggests. Ritual and belonging are not exclusive to churches, and collective emotion can make a group feel larger than its individual members. The lens also needs boundaries. If every activity that offers identity or shared excitement counts as religion, the category risks becoming too broad to distinguish a church from a hobby. The four functions clarify what to look for, while leaving room to ask how deeply and durably each group meets those needs.
Today's DIY spirituality is an old American pendulum sped up by technology
A recurring American tension. Burton traces the pull between institutional religion and personal, emotionally driven spirituality back through American history. Revivalists in the Great Awakenings emphasized inward conversion. Nineteenth-century Transcendentalists and New Thought teachers stressed personal intuition and self-reliance. After a mid-century high point for mainline Protestant institutions, the social upheavals of the 1960s helped renew spiritual seeking outside them.
What is different now. The current wave inherits that history, but the Internet makes spiritual materials and communities easier to find, while consumer capitalism packages practices as products. The result is a faster, more customized marketplace. People can borrow rituals from several traditions, discover others who share their interests, and build a spiritual identity without joining a single institution.
The historical comparison counters the idea that spiritual experimentation began with social media. The more precise claim is that digital tools and consumer choice change the scale and speed of an older American pattern. That distinction matters: continuity explains why these movements feel familiar, while technology helps explain why they spread differently. The pendulum metaphor is vivid, though history rarely swings neatly between two poles. Established churches also adapt, and personal spirituality can exist inside institutions rather than simply replacing them.
Online fandom taught audiences to create meaning, not just consume stories
Fans became makers. Internet communities let people interpret fictional worlds together, write new stories, and form friendships with others who shared their interests. The book describes “Snapewives,” a small group of Harry Potter fans who treated Severus Snape as a real spiritual presence and built rituals and relationships around him. Their beliefs were extreme, but they show how fiction can become material for private meaning and group identity.
Stories shape public life. Harry Potter fandom also gave people shared symbols for interpreting real events. At the March for Our Lives rally, protesters used references to the series to frame their campaign as a struggle between good and evil. Fan-created stories and symbols now circulate alongside official works, giving audiences a role in deciding what a story means.
Fandom shows how interpretation can become a form of social infrastructure: a shared story gives strangers a vocabulary for talking about values and belonging. That can encourage creativity and mutual support, especially for people who feel out of place in their local surroundings. The same participatory power can produce entitlement when fans expect creators to follow their preferred version of a story. Co-creation expands who gets to speak, but it does not remove conflict over who owns a narrative.
Wellness turns self-improvement into worship, then makes failure feel personal
The self as a sacred project. SoulCycle illustrates the book's account of wellness culture: a paid exercise class becomes a ritual of group energy, motivational teaching, and self-transformation. The class described costs $34 before extras, while the wider wellness industry was estimated at $4.2 trillion. Wellness products promise more than health. They can promise purification, purpose, and a better self.
An old idea in new packaging. Burton connects this culture to New Thought, a nineteenth-century American movement that taught that belief and mental attitude could influence health and success. Modern wellness often replaces a clear doctrine with loose talk of energy, toxins, and intuition. That can make self-care feel empowering, but it can also imply that illness or hardship reflects a failure to think positively, optimize the body, or choose the right products.
Wellness can provide structure, motivation, and a sense of agency, especially when ordinary routines feel empty. Its risk appears when a useful practice becomes a moral test: health is treated as proof of virtue, and suffering as evidence of personal failure. This is a familiar problem in self-help systems that promise control over outcomes shaped by many factors. The book's critique is strongest when aimed at unsupported claims and blame, rather than at exercise or care for oneself, which can be valuable without becoming a total explanation of life.
Witchcraft turns personal spirituality into political resistance, but can become a brand
Ritual as protest. At a Brooklyn shop called Catland, organizers held a ritual directed at Brett Kavanaugh after his Supreme Court confirmation. More than 10,000 people registered interest, though the shop's back room held about 60. Participants meditated, read a psalm, and shared experiences of abuse. The organizer described the event as both magical practice and a way to process trauma. The ritual offered a community and a political act, whether or not participants believed the spell had supernatural effects.
Resistance for sale. Contemporary witchcraft often presents itself as feminist, queer-friendly, and opposed to hierarchy. Yet as it attracts consumers, it can be repackaged as an aesthetic. Sephora withdrew a proposed witch starter kit after criticism, including objections to its use of white sage, a plant with significance in Native American ceremonies.
The example shows that ritual can do social work even when participants disagree about its supernatural force. A shared ceremony can make private grief visible and give protest a memorable form. The commercial tension is not unique to witchcraft: movements gain reach through symbols, then face pressure to simplify those symbols into purchasable goods. That pressure also raises questions of cultural ownership. A practice's popularity does not by itself make its use respectful, informed, or detached from the communities that sustained it.
Polyamory turns chosen relationship rules into a challenge to marriage's authority
A long history of sexual idealism. In 1848, preacher John Humphrey Noyes founded the Oneida community in New York. Its members shared property and practiced what Noyes called free love, believing that human beings could overcome jealousy and conventional sexual rules. The book connects this nineteenth-century experiment to today's sexual utopians: people who treat consensual nonmonogamy or kink as more than private preferences, using them to question inherited models of intimacy and family.
Agreements replace scripts. Modern polyamorous and BDSM communities often negotiate relationship boundaries directly, rather than assuming that one social template fits everyone. The book estimates that about 5 percent of Americans identify as polyamorous, while around 20 percent have tried ethical nonmonogamy. These models can create chosen communities, but they require communication, trust, and ongoing consent.
Negotiating expectations openly can expose assumptions that conventional couples may never discuss, and it can give people with different needs more room to build workable relationships. Still, customization is not a guarantee of fairness. Unequal power, insecurity, and changing desires do not disappear because partners write rules together. The most useful lesson is not that one relationship structure is more evolved than another. It is that agreements should be explicit, revisable, and attentive to the people affected by them.
Social justice offers a moral story, a community, and rituals of belonging
A political account of meaning. The book describes social justice culture as a civil religion: it explains social harm through unjust structures, gives participants a purpose in challenging them, and builds community through activism. Movements such as Black Lives Matter and #MeToo used social media to turn individual accounts into collective campaigns. The More in Common study cited in the book estimates that progressive activists make up about 8 percent of the US population.
Ritual has two sides. Protests and public campaigns can turn shared conviction into action. Online call-outs can also function as group rituals, allowing members to reaffirm moral commitments by condemning a perceived offense. That can make wrongdoing visible, but it can also turn punishment into a shortcut to solidarity, especially when public shaming substitutes for patient repair or institutional change.
The religious comparison is most persuasive when it identifies the movement's shared story, moral commitments, and repeated practices, rather than using religion as a put-down. Movements can provide solidarity and press institutions to respond to harms they have ignored. Their moral certainty also deserves scrutiny. A community that treats criticism as disloyalty can mistake consensus for justice, while public accountability can become spectacle. The key question is whether the ritual leads to durable changes in conditions, or mainly offers participants a temporary sense of moral unity.
Silicon Valley makes optimization a secular salvation project
Upgrade the human. Techno-utopian movements such as Rationalism and Transhumanism treat human limitations as problems to solve through improved reasoning, technology, or biology. Rationalists train themselves to notice errors in thought. Transhumanists imagine using technology to extend human abilities and lifespan. The book connects both to the Californian Ideology, a blend of countercultural individualism and faith in technological innovation and free markets.
Optimization becomes ordinary. The promise is not only that a few founders will build transformative technologies. Apps for meditation, fitness, sleep, and health invite ordinary users to monitor and improve themselves. The person becomes a project whose data can be tracked and whose habits can be tuned. This vision offers hope of greater control, but it can also turn efficiency into the measure of a worthwhile life.
Technological self-improvement can produce concrete benefits, and treating old systems as changeable can open useful possibilities. The danger is that technical language can make value judgments look like engineering problems with neutral answers. Deciding what counts as improvement, who bears its costs, and who controls the tools requires political judgment, not only better data. The book's comparison to religion usefully reveals the promised destination: not simply convenience, but a transformed human condition.
Online reactionaries turn alienation into brotherhood, then make nihilism dangerous
A myth of lost order. The book calls a strand of the online right atavistic because it longs for an imagined past of firm biological and social hierarchies. Jordan Peterson gives some followers a story of order and chaos, paired with practical discipline. More extreme communities in the manosphere frame men as victims of feminism and imagine violence as revenge. The black pill is the fatalistic belief that systemic problems have no personal solution.
Jokes can recruit. The online cult of Kek began partly as trolling and meme play, but its followers used its symbols to celebrate chaos and Trump’s rise. The book traces how ironic performance can overlap with sincere political identity and, in some cases, radicalization. These groups are not all alike, but they can give isolated people a powerful sense of brotherhood while directing their anger toward women, minorities, or democratic institutions.
The account helps explain why mocking a subculture as unserious can miss its appeal: members may find recognition and belonging before they adopt a coherent ideology. Humor and irony can lower the social cost of testing extreme ideas, while a group supplies explanations for personal frustration. Yet the category spans everything from self-help audiences to violent extremists. Keeping those differences visible avoids treating every critic of progressive politics as a terrorist, while still taking seriously the pathways by which online belonging can intensify grievance.
Analysis
The book's central achievement is to shift the question from whether Americans believe in God to where they now seek authority, belonging, and meaning. Its opening scene at the McKittrick makes that argument tangible: a commercial performance space becomes home, ritual, and community for people who would not describe themselves as churchgoers. From there, the narrative widens through American religious history, online fandom, wellness, witchcraft, sexuality, and competing political worldviews. This structure gives an abstract sociological claim human texture.
The four functions of religion, meaning, purpose, community, and ritual, are a strong interpretive tool. They show why the loss of institutional affiliation need not mean the loss of spiritual life. They also illuminate how consumer brands and online groups can borrow forms once associated with religious institutions. The danger is conceptual inflation. A sports crowd, an activist network, a meditation app, and a church may share some functions while differing radically in authority, duration, obligations, and beliefs. The framework identifies resemblance, not equivalence.
The book is also strongest when it holds two truths together: remixing can give marginalized people access to practices and communities that traditional institutions denied them, and the same flexibility can be absorbed into markets that sell self-improvement as salvation. Its treatment of witchcraft and sexual communities makes this tension visible without reducing their participants to consumers. The account of reactionary online movements adds a darker warning: people seeking order and connection can find both in communities organized around grievance and destruction.
A further question follows from the book's argument. If customized spirituality reflects the Internet's promise of choice, then the issue is not simply whether individuals should choose their beliefs. It is whether shared institutions can earn trust without demanding uniformity, and whether chosen communities can sustain responsibility beyond personal fulfillment. The book maps the new religious marketplace with insight. Its lasting challenge is to readers and institutions alike: meaning can be remade, but durable common life requires more than a personally satisfying story.
Review Summary
Strange Rites explores the rise of "remixed" religiosity in America, challenging the notion that society is becoming less religious. Burton examines various modern spiritual movements, from wellness culture to fandom, as new forms of religion. Reviewers appreciate the book's insights into contemporary spirituality but some find the definition of religion overly broad. The writing style receives mixed reactions, with some praising Burton's analysis while others find it repetitive. Overall, readers find the book thought-provoking, offering a unique perspective on how people seek meaning, purpose, and community in a changing religious landscape.
People Also Read
Glossary
The Remixed
People with blended spiritual livesBurton's umbrella term for Americans whose sources of belief, practice, identity, and community combine elements of traditional religion with personal spirituality. It includes spiritual but not religious people, unaffiliated people who retain spiritual beliefs, and people who identify with a religion while also borrowing practices or beliefs from other traditions.
intuitional religions
Faith centered on personal experienceBurton's term for contemporary religious forms that locate spiritual authority in personal feeling and lived experience rather than chiefly in institutional hierarchy or formal creed. They commonly emphasize authenticity, self-direction, and suspicion of social rules, while providing some combination of meaning, purpose, community, and ritual.
faithful Nones
Unaffiliated people with spiritual beliefBurton's label for people who identify with no organized religion but retain spiritual beliefs or practices. Many believe in God, a higher power, or forms of spiritual energy. Unlike some spiritual but not religious people, they do not claim a religious identity or rely on a religious institution for community.
religious hybrids
Affiliated people who mix traditionsPeople who identify with an established religion and believe or practice part of it, while also adopting spiritual beliefs, rituals, or sources of meaning from elsewhere. A Christian who retains Christian identity but believes in reincarnation or uses practices from other traditions is one example discussed in the book.
collective effervescence
Shared energy that bonds a groupA concept from sociologist Émile Durkheim describing the heightened shared feeling people experience during collective, symbolically meaningful action. The experience reinforces a group's sense of identity and belonging. Burton uses it to explain why concerts, immersive theater, political gatherings, and other shared rituals can feel religiously significant.
New Thought
Mind cure through beliefA nineteenth-century American spiritual movement that taught that thought, belief, and inner attitude could affect health, success, and connection with the divine. Its emphasis on personal responsibility and positive thinking influenced later self-help, wellness culture, and prosperity-gospel teachings.
unbundling
Separating religion into chosen partsA term Burton attributes to scholars Casper ter Kuile and Angie Thurston. It describes the tendency to obtain religious functions from different sources rather than receiving them together from one institution. Someone might find community in fandom, ritual in yoga, and a sense of purpose in political activism.
participatory culture
Audiences create and share mediaMedia scholar Henry Jenkins's term for a culture in which people can create and circulate their own work, receive informal guidance from more experienced participants, and feel that their contributions matter. Burton uses it to describe how Internet fandom moved audiences beyond consuming stories into interpreting and rewriting them.
black pill
Fatalism about social changeA term used in incel and other online reactionary communities for the belief that social problems have no personal solution and that meaningful improvement is impossible. In the book, it marks a deeply pessimistic turn from self-improvement toward resignation, destructive fantasy, or nihilism.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.