Key Takeaways
Treat gender inequality as a system, not a collection of private misfortunes
A pattern hiding in plain sight. Carter begins with a childhood memory of growing up among Black neighbors in segregated Georgia. Rachel Clark, a Black farmworker and his childhood heroine, taught him about nature, faith, and dignity. Yet the society around them used selected Bible verses to defend racial hierarchy. Carter sees a parallel in the global subordination of women: religious claims about female inferiority combine with economic advantage and accepted violence to make unequal treatment seem normal.
The harm spreads outward. In Carter’s account, this system reaches from rape, trafficking, and forced marriage to unequal pay, political exclusion, and poor health care. These are not isolated injuries to individual women. They deprive families and societies of half their potential contributors, while weakening the human rights commitments meant to protect everyone.
What's striking is the book's insistence that private suffering has public architecture. That perspective aligns with structural explanations of inequality: rules, incentives, and everyday expectations can reinforce one another even without a single mastermind. The comparison with racial segregation gives Carter a vivid moral lens, though gender and race are not interchangeable histories. The useful question is not whether every instance has the same cause, but which institutions make the harm predictable, excusable, and difficult to challenge.
Read sacred texts by their moral center, not by power's convenient fragments
Interpretation has consequences. Carter argues that religious texts can be used to defend either equality or male authority. He points to Jesus speaking with women whom society shunned, rejecting the unequal punishment of adultery, and accepting women as followers and messengers. He also notes that Paul’s letters name women as leaders and coworkers, even though other passages have been used to bar women from teaching or leadership.
Reform can grow from faith. Carter left the Southern Baptist Convention after it adopted restrictions on women’s roles, but remained active in a local congregation with women pastors and deacons. Muslim advocates in Sisters in Islam similarly make arguments for women’s rights through their own study of the Koran. His point is not that every passage is simple, but that religious authority should not be monopolized by those who benefit from one interpretation.
This section treats interpretation as a contest over institutional authority, not merely a puzzle about ancient wording. That is a useful corrective to the claim that discrimination is simply dictated by religion: believers actively select, interpret, and institutionalize texts. At the same time, textual reinterpretation alone cannot undo unequal control of pulpits, schools, or law. The strongest reform efforts pair scholarship with women’s participation in the institutions that decide which interpretations carry practical force.
Make violence the exception in law and foreign policy, not its model
Public violence teaches a lesson. Carter connects the acceptance of violence in war and criminal justice to the broader tolerance of abuse. His criticism of the 2003 Iraq invasion rests on just-war principles: force should be a last resort, discriminate between combatants and civilians, and be proportionate to the threat. He argues that bombardment and drone strikes can cause civilian suffering while damaging the credibility of human rights claims.
Punishment can become its own industry. Carter describes a shift toward incarceration instead of rehabilitation. He reports that the U.S. prison population had grown to more than five times its level when he was president, while the number of incarcerated Black women had risen by 800 percent. He also cites costly capital cases and wrongful convictions, arguing that state killing does not reliably deter violence and can signal that lethal retaliation is acceptable.
The central insight is about legitimacy: institutions do more than punish behavior, they communicate which forms of harm are acceptable. This connects to criminology’s concern with the example set by the state and to peacebuilding’s emphasis on civilian trust. The argument is strongest when it distinguishes security from revenge and asks whether force achieves its stated purpose. It needs care, however, not to imply that every public use of force has the same effects or that nonviolence alone resolves immediate threats.
Protect survivors who report assault, or institutional silence protects perpetrators
Silence is often produced. Carter recounts how a college student who had been raped while he was governor faced officials reluctant to prosecute. They expected the accused student to claim consent and feared that the survivor would endure public scrutiny without a likely conviction. He later argues that campuses need clear reporting procedures, trained advocates, confidential support, and consequences for proven offenses.
Low reporting can hide repeat offenders. A study he cites found that more than 95 percent of assaulted students stayed silent. In a separate sample of 1,882 students, researchers identified 120 rapists, 76 of them serial offenders who had each, on average, seriously harmed fourteen victims. Carter also describes military cases in which commanders controlled prosecution decisions, creating conflicts of interest. He supports stronger Title IX enforcement and more independent legal review.
The institutional focus is valuable because it shifts attention from survivor behavior to the conditions governing disclosure, investigation, and safety. Reporting systems are credible only when they offer both support and procedural fairness. Clear rules, independent investigators, protection against retaliation, and timely communication can reduce the burden on survivors without presuming guilt. The challenge is to design processes that are neither a private cover-up nor a substitute for evidence, but a reliable route to accountability.
Give women resources and authority, then let local knowledge lead
Women were not just beneficiaries. Carter’s work on Guinea worm disease showed that women often understood water use and household health better than outside officials. In South Sudan, trained women volunteers helped identify cases and protect villages from reinfection. The disease spread through contaminated water, so prevention depended on local behavior as well as medicine. Women also created songs, plays, and illustrated cloths to explain how filters could prevent infection.
Health work can shift power. In Ethiopia, women health workers helped expand treatment for trachoma, a disease that can cause blindness. A simple sanitation effort led to 86,500 household latrines in its first year and 2.9 million by 2012. Carter’s broader lesson is practical: programs succeed when women who know the community help shape and deliver them, rather than being treated as passive recipients of outside aid.
These examples make a strong case for participation as an effectiveness strategy, not just a matter of representation. Local knowledge helps identify barriers that distant planners may miss, while responsibility and visible success can build confidence and agency. This resembles community-based public health, where trust often determines whether people adopt an intervention. Yet participation should not become a way to shift unpaid labor onto women. Authority, training, materials, and compensation matter as much as a place in the program.
Make education and public information usable, not merely available
A right needs a route. Carter tells the story of a girl in Vikhroli, India, whom his mother taught to read and write while serving there as a nurse. Decades later, the girl had become president of a local university. The story captures what education can unlock, but Carter also stresses practical access to information about land, schooling, public services, jobs, and legal rights.
Exclusion can be administrative. In Liberia, the Carter Center helped establish community justice advisors who brought legal information and mediation into rural communities. In Guatemala, 75 percent of people interviewed in one study said women received less public information than men. Women reported barriers including fear, limited mobility, and not knowing what information was available. Without knowledge of rights and procedures, people cannot readily claim them, and officials can deny services with little scrutiny.
The distinction between formal access and usable access is essential. A policy may promise equal rights while distance, literacy, cost, language, or intimidation makes those rights unreachable in practice. This connects to the capability approach, which asks whether people can actually convert resources into choices and action. Information programs are not automatically empowering, however. They work best when institutions also respond to claims, protect people from retaliation, and make procedures understandable.
Treat girls as full family assets, not burdens to discard or sell
Preference can become lethal. Carter describes sex-selective abortion, neglect, and infanticide as forms of female gendercide. Citing an estimate from 2012, he reports at least 160 million missing females worldwide. The imbalance is not merely a statistic: a shortage of girls can fuel trafficking and the sale of women into marriage or sexual exploitation.
Poverty compounds the bargain. An estimated 14 million girls were being married before age eighteen each year, with poorer girls at greater risk. Child brides often leave school and face greater risks to their health and safety. Carter also cites an estimate of nearly 30 million people living in modern slavery, including people in forced labor, coerced marriages, and involuntary prostitution. Laws matter, but he argues that lasting change also requires families and communities to see daughters as educated, capable contributors rather than costs to be transferred elsewhere.
The book links practices often discussed separately through a shared economic logic: girls’ lives and labor are treated as resources controlled by others. That framing helps expose how poverty and gender norms reinforce one another. It also cautions against assuming that criminal bans alone can reverse family decisions made under scarcity or social pressure. Education, livelihoods, safety, and legal rights can alter the perceived costs and benefits, but those gains must not be made conditional on girls proving their economic usefulness.
Track power in wages, public office, and maternal survival
Equality needs a scorecard. Carter uses measures of pay, political representation, and health to show that formal rights do not guarantee equal outcomes. In the United States, women’s full-time annual earnings were reported at 76.5 percent of men’s in 2012, and women held only 18 percent of seats in Congress. Across the world, women occupied about 21 percent of parliamentary seats in the figures he cites.
Health gaps reveal unequal priority. Maternal mortality also varied sharply by income and country. Carter reports a global average of 210 maternal deaths per 100,000 births, compared with fewer than 10 in Scandinavian countries and Western Europe, and about 500 in Sub-Saharan Africa. He argues that tracking such differences makes it harder for governments to claim progress based on legal promises alone.
Measurement makes hidden inequality legible and lets citizens compare promises with outcomes. Pay, representation, and maternal health also reveal different mechanisms, from workplace rules to political access and health infrastructure. A single index can still conceal important variation within countries and among women facing multiple forms of exclusion. Metrics are most useful when paired with transparent methods, local data, and decision-makers who are accountable for changing the conditions behind the numbers.
Recruit community leaders to make reform socially enforceable
Norms change in public. Carter argues that outside organizations cannot end practices such as child marriage or genital cutting without community participation. In Senegal, Tostan helped local women discuss health, rights, and religious arguments against genital cutting. More than 6,400 villages across several countries had publicly decided to abandon cutting and forced child marriage by 2013, according to Carter.
Influential men can change the cost of silence. Carter describes a Congolese chief who helped secure the arrest of a soldier who raped a fourteen-year-old girl and protected her from community blame. In Malawi, a chief required care during childbirth; his district reported no maternal deaths for three years after forty deaths in 2007. Such examples show how leaders can make new expectations visible and defend people who challenge old ones.
Reform becomes durable when people see respected members of their own community endorse it, a principle familiar from social-norm research. These stories also show that leadership is not only ceremonial: a chief can enforce protection, while religious figures can challenge claims that harmful customs are sacred. The approach requires safeguards. Local authority can protect vulnerable people, but it can also reproduce the hierarchy being challenged, so women’s voices and independent legal protections must remain central.
Make equality enforceable through law, budgets, and public accountability
Promises need institutions. Carter points to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, or CEDAW, as commitments governments should implement. He urges the United States to ratify CEDAW and adopt the International Violence Against Women Act, which he presents as a way to make ending gender violence a foreign policy priority.
Enforcement shapes daily life. He highlights Title IX protections for students, laws against trafficking and forced marriage, and UN resolutions on women’s participation in peace and security. Morocco’s family law reforms offered another example: they raised the marriage age, expanded women’s rights in marriage and divorce, and restricted polygamy. Carter’s conclusion is that progress requires more than public sympathy. It requires rules, funding, monitoring, and consequences when officials fail to protect equal rights.
This closing argument translates moral concern into institutional design. Rights become more than aspirations when they specify duties, assign responsibility, and give affected people a way to seek remedy. The examples also show why international standards and local law must work together: global commitments can set a benchmark, while national institutions determine what happens in homes, schools, and courts. Legislation is not self-executing, so public reporting, adequate budgets, and independent enforcement are indispensable.
Analysis
The book’s central argument is that women’s subordination is sustained by mutually reinforcing systems: religious authority that legitimizes hierarchy, social norms that normalize control, and political or legal institutions that fail to protect those harmed. Carter’s distinctive contribution is to connect these systems to violence beyond the household. War, capital punishment, mass incarceration, and institutional indifference are not treated as separate policy debates; they help create a public climate in which coercion seems ordinary. His autobiographical perspective gives the argument moral credibility. The boy who accepted segregated customs becomes a leader who recognizes how inherited beliefs can disguise self-interest. The book is also strongest when it moves from diagnosis to mechanisms. Women’s leadership improves disease prevention, education, and local justice because they possess knowledge and relationships that formal programs often lack. The examples of community health workers, Tostan, and Liberia’s justice advisors show that equality is not an abstract reward to be granted after development. Participation itself can improve practical outcomes. Carter’s insistence on locally led change also guards against a familiar weakness in international advocacy: treating communities as passive targets of rescue.
Some claims are more persuasive as moral arguments than as settled causal findings. The book draws a broad line between state violence and violence against women, but the relationship is complex and cannot be inferred from parallel examples alone. Many of its statistics are snapshots from the period of publication, and personal stories, however vivid, cannot establish prevalence by themselves. Religious traditions are also internally diverse, a fact Carter acknowledges but sometimes compresses into a struggle between empowering and restrictive readings.
The most useful synthesis is therefore institutional and relational. Interpretation matters, but so do who controls institutions, whether women can access information, whether survivors can report safely, and whether laws are enforced. Moral appeals can open a door; budgets, representation, accountability, and community participation determine whether anyone can walk through it. The book’s call to action is not simply to condemn abuse, but to redesign the conditions that make it possible and profitable.
Review Summary
A Call to Action offers a powerful examination of global challenges facing women, drawing on Carter's experiences and the work of the Carter Center. While some reviewers found it disorganized or self-promotional, many praised its accessibility and importance in highlighting issues like violence, discrimination, and religious misinterpretation. Carter's religious background and humanitarian efforts lend credibility to his arguments. The book covers a wide range of topics, including human trafficking, genital mutilation, and political representation. Reviewers appreciated Carter's candid approach and call for action, though some wished for more depth on certain subjects.
People Also Read
Glossary
CEDAW
women's equality treatyThe Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women is a United Nations treaty requiring governments that ratify it to work against discrimination in political, economic, social, cultural, and civil life. Carter calls it a foundational international commitment and urges the United States to ratify it.
IVAWA
international violence prevention proposalThe International Violence Against Women Act is a proposed United States law described by Carter as making the prevention of violence against women and girls a foreign policy priority. It would support health programs, survivor services, legal protections, education, and economic opportunities, while strengthening action against gender-based violence internationally.
SAFE
four-part trachoma controlSAFE is the World Health Organization's approach to controlling trachoma, the infectious eye disease that can lead to blindness. Its letters refer to surgery for advanced cases, antibiotics, face washing, and environmental improvements that reduce transmission. Carter describes work on all four elements, including community latrines and antibiotic distribution.
Tostan
community-led empowerment programTostan is a Senegal-founded organization and community education approach that helps people discuss human rights, health, and local practices. Carter highlights its emphasis on local decision-making rather than outside commands. In participating communities, women and men used new information and discussion to decide to abandon female genital cutting and forced child marriage.
brutalization effect
violence encouraging further violenceThe brutalization effect is the claim, discussed by Carter through research testimony on capital punishment, that executions may increase rather than deter homicide. The proposed mechanisms are public desensitization to killing, state endorsement of vengeance, and imitation of government violence. Carter uses this concept to question whether executions reduce crime.
Community Justice Advisors
local legal guidance and mediationCommunity Justice Advisors were local representatives established in parts of Liberia with Carter Center support. They helped people understand formal law, resolve disputes, and connect legal principles with community practices. Carter reports that they handled cases involving domestic disputes, property and financial claims, and crimes, bringing legal assistance closer to rural residents.
Global Gender Gap Report
country gender equality indexThe World Economic Forum's Global Gender Gap Report compares how countries distribute opportunities and resources between women and men. Carter describes four areas it measures: economic participation, education, political empowerment, and health and survival. Its scores assess relative gender gaps, not a country's overall wealth or the absolute well-being of every woman.
FAQ
What's A Call to Action: Women, Religion, Violence, and Power about?
- Focus on Women's Rights: The book addresses global issues of gender inequality, emphasizing how discrimination, violence, and religious interpretations contribute to the oppression of women and girls.
- Carter's Personal Experiences: Jimmy Carter shares his journey from his childhood in the South to his work with The Carter Center, highlighting the pervasive nature of gender-based violence.
- Call for Change: It serves as a call to action for individuals and religious leaders to advocate for gender equality and challenge cultural and religious norms that perpetuate discrimination.
Why should I read A Call to Action?
- Insightful Perspective: Gain insights from a former U.S. president dedicated to humanitarian efforts, particularly in advancing women's rights.
- Comprehensive Analysis: Offers a thorough analysis of the intersection between religion, violence, and gender inequality, relevant for those interested in social justice.
- Inspiration for Activism: Encourages readers to become advocates for change, offering hope and practical steps to address global women's issues.
What are the key takeaways of A Call to Action?
- Global Gender Inequality: Emphasizes that gender discrimination is a global issue affecting women in all societies.
- Religious Misinterpretation: Discusses how distorted interpretations of religious texts justify violence and discrimination against women.
- Empowerment through Education: Highlights education and awareness as crucial tools for empowering women and changing societal norms.
What are the best quotes from A Call to Action and what do they mean?
- "No matter what our faith may be, it is impossible to imagine a God who is unjust.": Challenges the notion that any faith can justify discrimination, promoting justice and equality.
- "If women are equal in the eyes of God, why are we not equal in the eyes of men?": Highlights the hypocrisy in religious teachings that claim gender equality while perpetuating male dominance.
- "Women hold up half the sky.": Emphasizes the essential role women play in society and the need for their rights to be recognized.
How does A Call to Action address violence against women?
- Linking Violence and Gender: Connects societal acceptance of violence with systemic abuse of women, arguing that norms often condone such behavior.
- Examples of Abuse: Provides harrowing examples of violence against women, illustrating the widespread nature of these issues.
- Call for Accountability: Advocates for accountability from individuals and institutions, urging a cultural shift that condemns violence and supports victims.
What role does religion play in A Call to Action?
- Religious Justifications for Discrimination: Discusses how certain religious leaders misinterpret texts to justify the subordination of women.
- Potential for Positive Change: Argues that religion can be a force for good, encouraging believers to reinterpret faith in ways that promote equality and justice.
- Interfaith Dialogue: Emphasizes the importance of dialogue among different faiths to address gender discrimination and work towards shared solutions.
What specific methods does Jimmy Carter suggest for promoting women's rights?
- Education and Awareness: Stresses the importance of educating both men and women about gender equality and women's rights.
- Community Engagement: Advocates for grassroots movements that empower women and involve men as allies in the fight for equality.
- Policy Advocacy: Encourages support for policies and legislation that protect women's rights and promote gender equality at all levels.
How does A Call to Action relate to current global issues?
- Relevance to Modern Movements: Resonates with contemporary movements for gender equality, such as #MeToo and campaigns against gender-based violence.
- Intersectionality: Includes the intersection of gender with race, class, and religion, reflecting the complexities of social justice issues today.
- Global Perspective: Provides a global perspective on women's rights, relevant for readers interested in international human rights issues.
What personal experiences does Jimmy Carter share in A Call to Action?
- Childhood Reflections: Reflects on his upbringing in the segregated South, drawing parallels between racial and gender discrimination.
- Global Travels: Shares insights from his travels with The Carter Center, witnessing firsthand the struggles of women in various cultures.
- Family Influence: Discusses the impact of his wife, Rosalynn, and their shared commitment to advocating for women's rights.
How does A Call to Action propose to combat gender-based violence?
- Cultural Change: Emphasizes the need for a cultural shift that rejects violence as conflict resolution and promotes peaceful alternatives.
- Support Systems for Victims: Advocates for establishing support systems for victims, including legal assistance and counseling services.
- Engagement of Men: Calls for active involvement of men in addressing gender-based violence, recognizing their crucial role in changing societal attitudes.
What role do men play in A Call to Action?
- Advocates for Change: Emphasizes that men must be active participants in the fight for women's rights, challenging patriarchal norms.
- Addressing Male Violence: Discusses the importance of addressing male violence against women and the need for men to take responsibility.
- Partnership with Women: Stresses the importance of collaboration between men and women in promoting gender equality.
What are the challenges to implementing the changes proposed in A Call to Action?
- Resistance from Traditional Structures: Identifies resistance from established cultural and religious institutions as a significant barrier.
- Lack of Political Will: Discusses the need for political leaders to prioritize women's rights and gender equality.
- Societal Attitudes: Emphasizes the importance of grassroots movements in shifting perceptions and fostering a culture of equality.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.