Key Takeaways
1. Philosophy as Life's Guide: Sageliness Within, Kingliness Without
In China, philosophy has been every educated person’s concern.
Philosophy's central role. Unlike other civilizations where religion often dominated, philosophy in China served as the primary guide for educated individuals. From childhood, Chinese students were immersed in philosophical texts like the Four Books, which shaped their understanding of life, the universe, and knowledge itself. This deep integration meant that Chinese people were philosophical rather than religious, finding their craving for higher values satisfied through reflective thought.
Beyond mere knowledge. Chinese philosophy's function extends beyond accumulating factual information; it aims at the elevation of the mind. It seeks to transcend the mundane and access super-moral values, offering a direct path to spiritual fulfillment without the need for religious dogma or rituals. This pursuit of higher understanding is not just an intellectual exercise but a way of life, demanding continuous self-schooling to overcome selfishness and achieve unity with the universe.
The ideal sage. The ultimate goal of Chinese philosophy is to cultivate a sage, characterized by "sageliness within and kingliness without." This ideal individual achieves spiritual cultivation internally while actively functioning in society, embodying both this-worldly and other-worldly virtues. The sage's engagement with social affairs is not a sacrifice but an essential part of personal development, making philosophy inseparable from political thought and practical living.
2. Confucius: Rectifying Names for Moral Order
Let the ruler be ruler, the minister minister, the father father, and the son son.
Order through names. Confucius believed that a well-ordered society hinges on the "rectification of names," meaning that actual roles and behaviors must align with their ideal implications. Each social name—ruler, minister, father, son—carries inherent responsibilities and duties. When individuals fulfill these, there is harmony between name and actuality, leading to societal stability.
Human-heartedness and righteousness. At the core of individual virtue, Confucius emphasized jen (human-heartedness) and yi (righteousness). Yi signifies the moral "oughtness" of actions, performed for their intrinsic rightness, not for personal gain. Jen, meaning "loving others," provides the concrete essence for these duties, extending from family affection to broader societal care through the principle of chung (conscientiousness) and shu (altruism).
Knowing Ming and inner peace. Confucius taught that one should strive to do what is right, leaving the outcome to Ming (Heaven's Decree or fate). This "knowing Ming" means accepting the inevitability of external conditions beyond one's control, thereby freeing oneself from anxiety over success or failure. This detachment from external results allows for inner happiness and freedom from fear, marking a crucial step in spiritual development.
3. Mo Tzu: Universal Love and Utilitarian Governance
The task of the human-hearted man is to procure benefits for the world and to eliminate its calamities.
Critic of Confucianism. Mo Tzu, a contemporary of Confucius, challenged traditional institutions and Confucian ideals from a utilitarian perspective. He criticized Confucian emphasis on elaborate rituals, music, and belief in fate, arguing they wasted resources and fostered idleness. Mo Tzu's philosophy stemmed from the hsieh (knights-errant) class, emphasizing discipline and practical utility over aristocratic refinement.
All-embracing love. Mo Tzu's central doctrine was chien ai (all-embracing love), advocating that everyone should love others equally and without discrimination, extending care for friends as one's own family. He justified this through a "tests of judgment" based on "being beneficial to the country and the people," arguing that mutual love eliminates calamities like warfare and oppression, leading to universal benefit.
Divine and political sanctions. To ensure the practice of all-embracing love, Mo Tzu introduced religious and political sanctions. He asserted the existence of God and spirits who reward good and punish evil, and proposed a totalitarian state where the ruler, chosen by the people and sanctioned by Heaven, unifies standards of right and wrong. This absolute authority was necessary to prevent societal chaos, reflecting the troubled times and the hsieh's emphasis on group obedience.
4. Taoism's Path: Naturalness, Reversal, and Transcendence
Reversal is the movement of the Tao.
Early Taoist individualism. Taoism originated from recluses who sought personal purity by escaping the chaotic world, later developing a philosophical justification for their withdrawal. Yang Chu, an early exponent, emphasized "each one for himself" and "despising things and valuing life," advocating for self-preservation and avoiding external entanglements, even if it meant not benefiting the world.
Lao Tzu's cosmic laws. The Lao-tzu introduced the concept of the Tao as the unnamable, eternal "Non-being" from which all "Being" arises. It posited "reversal is the movement of the Tao" as an invariable law of nature, where extremes inevitably revert to their opposites. This understanding guides human conduct towards meekness, humility, and contentment, advocating wu-wei (non-action) – not doing nothing, but acting without artificiality, arbitrariness, or over-doing.
Chuang Tzu's absolute happiness. Chuang Tzu further developed Taoism by emphasizing the relativity of all things and the identification of the self with the universe. He distinguished between relative happiness (achieved by freely exercising one's natural ability) and absolute happiness (achieved by transcending finite distinctions, including life and death). Through "sitting in forgetfulness" and dispersing emotion with reason, the sage becomes one with the infinite, achieving a state of "no self, no achievement, no name," and finding "usefulness in the useless."
5. The School of Names: Logic, Relativity, and Universals
A white horse is not a horse.
Analysis of names and actualities. The School of Names, or Ming chia, focused on the relationship between ming (names/concepts) and shih (actualities/concrete things). Its members, often called "debaters" or "sophists," engaged in paradoxical arguments to highlight the complexities of language and perception, challenging common sense and legal interpretations.
Hui Shih's relativity. Hui Shih emphasized the relativity and changeability of actual things. His "ten points" illustrated that concepts like "greatest" and "smallest," "high" and "low," "today" and "yesterday," are relative. He argued that all things are both similar and different, leading to the conclusion that "love all things equally; Heaven and Earth are one body," by transcending superficial distinctions.
Kung-sun Lung's universals. In contrast, Kung-sun Lung focused on the absolute and permanent nature of names or universals. His famous proposition, "a white horse is not a horse," distinguished between the universal "horseness" (shape) and "whiteness" (color), arguing that the specific combination "white horse" is distinct from the general concept "horse." This exploration of abstract universals, or chih (pointers), revealed a world "beyond shapes and features," akin to Plato's realm of Ideas.
6. Legalism: Law, Statecraft, and Historical Pragmatism
Affairs go according to their time, and preparations are made in accordance with affairs.
Response to feudal decline. Legalism emerged during the chaotic Warring States period as a pragmatic response to the disintegration of feudal society. Rejecting the traditional li (rituals) for aristocrats and xing (punishments) for commoners, Legalists advocated for universal, fixed laws (fa) and centralized authority to govern large, complex states. They believed in realistic methods over idealistic moral programs.
Han Fei Tzu's synthesis. Han Fei Tzu, the school's greatest theorist, synthesized the Legalist principles of fa (law), shu (statecraft), and shih (power/authority). He argued that an intelligent ruler, regardless of personal virtue, could govern effectively by strictly enforcing laws, using rewards and punishments as "two handles." This system aimed to make people incapable of wrongdoing rather than relying on their inherent goodness.
Rejection of historical regression. Unlike other schools that idealized the past, Legalists held a progressive view of history, asserting that new times demand new measures. Han Fei Tzu famously illustrated this with the "man who waited by the tree" for another hare, ridiculing those who cling to outdated methods. Legalism thus provided the theoretical justification for the Ch'in dynasty's unification of China, emphasizing efficiency and control over traditional morality.
7. Yin-Yang and Five Elements: Cosmic and Social Harmony
The Yin is the correlate of the Yang, the wife of the husband, the subject of the sovereign.
Occult origins, scientific spirit. The Yin-Yang school originated from fang shih (occult practitioners) who sought to interpret nature positively, laying groundwork for scientific inquiry. They developed theories of the Five Elements (Wood, Fire, Soil, Metal, Water) and the Yin and Yang principles to explain the universe's structure and origin, correlating natural phenomena with human conduct.
Five Elements and dynastic cycles. The Five Elements were seen as dynamic forces, each producing and overcoming the next in a fixed sequence, governing seasons and directions. Tsou Yen extended this to a philosophy of history, where dynastic changes corresponded to the ascendancy of a particular Element, dictating governmental style and even symbolic colors. This theory provided a mechanistic explanation for historical cycles and the rise and fall of empires.
Yin and Yang as cosmic principles. The Yin (feminine, passive, dark) and Yang (masculine, active, light) were fundamental cosmic principles whose interaction produced all phenomena. The Book of Changes used trigrams and hexagrams to symbolize these interactions, explaining the production of things and the natural order. Tung Chung-shu later integrated these principles to justify social hierarchies, seeing the sovereign as Yang and the subject as Yin, thus linking cosmic order to human relationships.
8. Human Nature: Mencius's Goodness vs. Hsün Tzu's Evil
The nature of man is evil; his goodness is acquired training.
Mencius: Innate goodness. Mencius championed the theory that human nature is inherently good, endowed with "four beginnings" of virtue: commiseration (human-heartedness), shame and dislike (righteousness), modesty and yielding (propriety), and a sense of right and wrong (wisdom). These beginnings, if nurtured, naturally develop into full virtues, distinguishing humans from beasts. He believed that morality is an internal, spontaneous development.
Hsün Tzu: Acquired goodness. Hsün Tzu directly countered Mencius, asserting that human nature is inherently evil, driven by desires for profit and sensual pleasure. He argued that any goodness in man is "acquired training" through culture and education. Despite this, he maintained that all men possess intelligence, making it possible for them to learn and become good, thus emphasizing the transformative power of human effort and social institutions.
The role of culture and li. For Hsün Tzu, society and its li (rites, rules of conduct) are essential to curb man's innate evil and enable collective living. Li provides the necessary regulations to limit desires and prevent strife, thereby creating morality. He also saw li as refining human emotions and distinguishing man from animals, making culture not just a necessity but a defining characteristic of humanity.
9. Neo-Taoism: Nothingness, Self-Transformation, and Feng Liu
The Tao is everywhere, but everywhere it is nothing.
"Dark Learning" and the void. Neo-Taoism, or hsiian hsiieh, reinterpreted classical Taoism, particularly Lao Tzu and Chuang Tzu, by emphasizing wu (nothingness) as the ultimate reality. Hsiang Hsiu and Kuo Hsiang, key figures, asserted that the Tao is literally nothing, and that things are not created by a divine entity but arise spontaneously through "self-transformation" (tu hua), a continuous flux of existence.
Interdependence and naturalness. Despite the absence of a Creator, Neo-Taoists recognized the necessary interrelationship of all things, where each exists for its own sake yet contributes to the whole. They advocated living according to tzu-jan (naturalness/spontaneity) rather than ming-chiao (institutions/morals), believing that new institutions and morals should arise naturally with changing circumstances, making wu-wei (non-action) a dynamic adaptation to the times.
The spirit of feng liu. This philosophy fostered the feng liu (wind and stream) spirit, characterized by elegance, freedom, and a subtle sensitivity to life and the universe. Feng liu individuals lived according to pure impulse, transcending conventional distinctions and societal norms. They sought pleasure not merely sensuously, but aesthetically, appreciating beauty and expressing emotions without attachment, embodying a romantic and artistic approach to existence.
10. Chinese Buddhism: Ch'anism's Silence and Sudden Enlightenment
Since originally there was nothing, Whereon can the dust fall?
Buddhism's Chinese transformation. Introduced in the 1st century A.D., Buddhism initially mingled with Taoist occultism and philosophy, leading to "interpretation by analogy" (ko yi). Over centuries, it evolved into "Chinese Buddhism," notably the Ch'an (Zen) school, which synthesized Indian Mahayana concepts with Taoist ideas, becoming deeply ingrained in Chinese thought, art, and literature.
The inexpressible First Principle. Ch'anism, particularly the Southern school of Hui-neng, emphasized wu (non-being) and the inexpressibility of the "First Principle." Masters often used paradoxical statements, silence, or even physical actions ("stick or yell") to shock students into realizing that ultimate truth cannot be conveyed through words or conventional knowledge. This approach aimed to bypass intellectualization and foster direct experience.
Cultivation through non-cultivation. Ch'an advocated wu-hsin (no-mind) and wu-wei (non-action) as the path to Buddhahood, meaning acting without deliberate effort or attachment. This "cultivation through non-cultivation" involves performing ordinary daily tasks—eating, wearing clothes, carrying water—with a completely non-purposeful mind. The goal is not to achieve something new, but to realize one's inherent Buddha-nature through "Sudden Enlightenment," a complete, instantaneous understanding that transcends all distinctions.
11. Neo-Confucianism: Li (Principle) vs. Hsin (Mind)
The Supreme Ultimate is simply what is highest of all, beyond which nothing can be.
Revival and synthesis. Emerging after the Tang dynasty, Neo-Confucianism, spearheaded by figures like Han Yü and Li Ao, sought to revitalize Confucianism by reinterpreting classics like the Great Learning and Doctrine of the Mean. It integrated elements from Buddhism (Ch'anism) and Taoist cosmology, creating a comprehensive system that addressed metaphysical and super-moral concerns, aiming to achieve Confucian Sagehood within society.
Ch'eng-Chu School: Li (Principle). Ch'eng Yi and Chu Hsi developed the Li hsiieh (School of Li), positing Li (Principle/Law) as eternal, abstract, and antecedent to all concrete things. Every existing thing embodies a specific Li, and the Tai Chi (Supreme Ultimate) is the summation of all Li. The physical world arises from the Ch'i (matter/ether) condensing according to these Li. Spiritual cultivation involves "investigation of things" (ko wu) to understand Li and "attentiveness" (ching) to purify the mind.
Lu-Wang School: Hsin (Mind). Ch'eng Hao, Lu Chiu-yüan, and Wang Shou-jen founded the Hsin hsiieh (School of Mind), asserting that "the mind is Li." For them, the universe is a spiritual whole, and the mind is the legislator of all principles. Wang Shou-jen's "intuitive knowledge" (liang chih) is the mind's inherent, unclouded moral awareness, which, when extended through "rectification of affairs" (ko wu), leads to self-cultivation and unity with the universe.
12. Modern Chinese Philosophy: Synthesis and Elevated Living
Philosophy, especially metaphysics, is that branch of knowledge which, in its development, will ultimately become “the knowledge that is not knowledge."
Reaction and Western influence. The Ch'ing dynasty saw a reaction against Neo-Confucianism, with scholars advocating a "back-to-the-Han" movement, emphasizing textual scholarship over philosophical interpretation. The late 19th and early 20th centuries brought Western culture, science, and philosophy, challenging traditional Chinese thought. Figures like Yen Fu introduced Western ideas, while Wang Kuo-wei grappled with the tension between believable (positivistic) and lovable (metaphysical) philosophies.
Analytic and negative methods. The introduction of Western philosophy, particularly logic, offered China a new "analytic method" – a positive approach to making distinctions and defining objects. This complemented the traditional Chinese "negative method," prominent in Taoism and Ch'anism, which seeks to transcend distinctions and reveal what an object is not. The ideal future philosophy, it is suggested, will combine both methods, starting with positive analysis and culminating in negative, mystical understanding.
The four spheres of living. Philosophy's function is to elevate the mind, guiding individuals through four spheres of living: the innocent, the utilitarian, the moral, and the transcendent. The moral and transcendent spheres, products of spiritual creation, require philosophical understanding. The sage, living in the transcendent sphere, performs ordinary actions with profound understanding, embodying a life that is both of this world and the other, offering a path for future global philosophy.
Last updated:
Similar Books
