Key Takeaways
Make your private fear the destination, not another excuse to avoid it.
The list keeps changing. Matthew Polly arrives at Princeton determined to repair what he sees as wrong with himself. He conquers intellectual insecurity through study, but his fear of physical confrontation remains. As a child, he was bullied and rarely fought back. At twenty-one, convinced that Shaolin kungfu might make him brave and spiritually settled, he leaves college for China. His plan is more than martial arts training: he wants to test whether he can become someone different by choosing the place that most frightens him.
A quest meets reality. Polly has romantic ideas about Shaolin, drawn from kungfu films and Buddhist texts. He knows little about the country, cannot reliably find the temple, and arrives with uncertain Chinese. The gap between the fantasy and the journey becomes part of the test: wanting transformation is easy; living through confusion, pain, and loneliness is harder.
What's striking is how self-improvement can disguise a demand for proof of worth. Polly treats courage as a missing credential, much as he once treated intellectual achievement as a cure for insecurity. That framing makes the journey vivid, but it also risks turning every hardship into a test he must pass. In behavioral terms, approaching a feared situation can create new learning, but only when the challenge is survivable and chosen. The useful lesson is not to seek maximum pain. It is to identify the fear that achievement has been helping someone avoid.
Meet the real institution, not the legend you packed in your suitcase.
A monastery becomes a destination. Polly expects an isolated home of warrior monks. Instead, he finds a tourist village crowded with private kungfu schools, souvenir stalls, and attractions that turn Shaolin into a rough-edged theme park. The monks he hoped to meet are difficult to find, and the temple itself is partly a reconstruction. The place is not a timeless fantasy. It is a working institution trying to survive a turbulent present.
Tradition has been rebuilt. The book traces Shaolin's changing fortunes: its reputation as a center of martial and Buddhist practice, its suppression under Mao, the destruction and persecution of the twentieth century, and its revival after the 1981 film Shaolin Temple, starring Jet Li. Tourism and tuition help rebuild the community, but they also reshape what visitors see. The monks perform for audiences as well as train.
The memoir usefully complicates the search for authenticity. Institutions are not museum pieces: they adapt to political pressure, economic need, and public appetite. Shaolin's commercial performances can look like a betrayal of tradition, yet tourism helps sustain the people and practices that make the site meaningful. This tension appears in heritage preservation worldwide, where the revenue that protects a landmark can also alter it. The outsider's romantic gaze is part of the story too. It wants an untouched past, while actual residents need work, food, and room to make choices.
Repeat fundamentals until your body can answer before panic takes over.
Training is mostly repetition. Polly discovers that Shaolin practice is less cinematic than its legends: warm-ups, calisthenics, stretching, basic movements, and repeated forms, day after day. He struggles to raise his legs, and the second day leaves him so sore he can barely walk. His teacher explains that resting until the pain disappears will not necessarily make the next session easier. The work is to return, carefully, and let the body adapt.
The right practice depends on the goal. Traditional forms preserve elaborate sequences, but Polly worries they will not help him face a real fight. After watching bar brawls from the sidelines, he shifts to sanda, Chinese kickboxing, where a small set of punches, kicks, and throws are drilled against resisting partners. He learns that a technique that looks beautiful is not automatically useful under pressure. Practice must match the task it is meant to prepare someone for.
This account captures an important distinction in skill learning: rehearsing movements and performing under pressure are related, but not identical. Repetition can make a response more available when attention narrows, while sparring reveals whether that response survives resistance. That does not make forms worthless. They can build coordination, balance, and memory, even when they are not direct combat rehearsal. The more precise question is what each drill trains and how that learning transfers. Polly's shift from forms to sanda is a practical adjustment, not a verdict on every traditional practice.
Keep fighting when victory is gone, if courage is the real prize.
Defeat becomes the lesson. Polly's first sanda coach, the former national champion Coach Cheng, makes him spar with stronger fighters until losing feels familiar. The purpose is not to pretend pain is pleasant. It is to keep fear from deciding every move. Months later, Polly enters a tournament against the reigning Chinese champion in his weight class. The opponent throws him, kicks him, and sends him off the raised platform in the opening round.
The second round matters more. Exhausted and convinced he cannot win, Polly nearly refuses to return. His coach and friend pull him back onto the platform. He attacks, gets thrown out again, and loses the match. Yet he has stayed in a contest he once would have fled. The medal is silver, but the personal victory is that he no longer needs a likely win in order to keep standing.
The tournament separates outcome from learning. A loss can change a person's expectations if it shows that fear, pain, and embarrassment are survivable. In exposure-based approaches to anxiety, the aim is not to erase fear on command, but to experience a feared situation without the expected catastrophe controlling behavior. Still, the story should not be mistaken for a rule that everyone must endure any challenge. Good exposure is chosen, proportionate, and bounded. Here, coaching, preparation, and a formal sporting environment make the risk different from reckless violence.
Learn local rules before mistaking difference for virtue or insult.
Politeness has its own grammar. In China, Polly learns that refusing a cigarette can reject a social gesture, that praise is often answered with practiced modesty, and that face, a person's public standing, shapes disagreements. He initially judges monks for seeking money, then learns that some are trying to support families or find a way out of constrained circumstances. He also recognizes his own romantic projection: he wants Chinese people to embody spiritual depth, even while many want the opportunities and comforts he represents.
Negotiation is contextual. Polly is charged far more than a German student for training. He challenges the fee and holds out until the school accepts a lower monthly payment. His tactics include reading status, patience, and a face-saving explanation. The episode is funny, but it reveals that his survival depends on learning how local relationships work, not simply assuming that American expectations about fixed prices and verbal agreements apply.
The most valuable cultural insight here is self-implication. Polly does not merely collect amusing customs; he notices the assumptions he brings and the ways his presence changes an interaction. That resembles reflexive anthropology, where an observer treats their own position as part of the evidence. Yet a memoir's sharp comic portraits can make a diverse society seem more uniform than it is. The strongest reading treats the scenes as encounters with particular people and institutions, not a complete guide to Chinese behavior. Cultural fluency begins with curiosity, but it also requires resisting easy generalizations.
Respect what survival costs before judging how people choose money or escape.
Poverty changes the choices. Deqing, one of Polly's closest friends and a gifted martial artist, tells him that his father was imprisoned after a fatal traffic accident. His mother could no longer support both sons, so she left Deqing at Shaolin as a child. He trained without tuition and sometimes scavenged strangers' leftovers for food. That history helps explain his hunger to perform, earn money, and spread Shaolin beyond China. Polly's earlier criticism of his commercial ambitions suddenly looks shallow.
Leaving is not simple. Some monks dream of emigrating after two colleagues defect during a tour of the United States. The leaders respond by limiting access to passports and discouraging contact with foreigners. A monk's decision to pursue money, a film role, a relationship, or a way out is shaped by poverty and institutional control, not just personal virtue. The book's friendships grow when Polly listens to these constraints rather than forcing his own expectations onto them.
Deqing's story makes agency visible without pretending that hardship leaves people untouched. A person's choices can be understandable and still carry costs, especially when economic need, family obligation, and state control overlap. This is a useful corrective to moral judgments made from a position of security. It also complicates the familiar idea that leaving is automatically freedom: migration can open possibilities while creating new dependence and loss. The memoir offers one person's account, not a representative portrait of every monk. Its force comes from showing how a friend's history changes the meaning of behavior that once seemed merely selfish.
Do not demand enlightenment on your schedule; let practice change its meaning.
The expected spirituality is missing. Polly arrives hoping to become an enlightened martial artist, but Buddhist practice is not the center of everyday life for the young performance monks. Their days are dominated by training, teaching, and performing. He tries meditation, but his mind wanders. Then, during a familiar spinning movement in practice, he experiences a brief and powerful sense of peace. It feels spiritually decisive, yet it fades as quickly as it arrived.
Practice changes direction. Polly comes to see kungfu itself as a form of moving meditation for the young monks: a physical discipline that can train attention and self-command. In his account, the relationship between martial and Buddhist practice varies with age, energy, and circumstance. The experience does not settle his theology or make him permanently calm. It does make his choice to come to Shaolin feel meaningful, even as his longing for a clear, lasting revelation remains unresolved.
The scene is powerful because it preserves the difference between an experience and an explanation of that experience. A sudden sense of unity or peace can be psychologically real and personally important without proving a particular religious doctrine. That distinction allows spiritual language and critical thought to coexist. The memoir also suggests that attention can be cultivated through embodied repetition, a connection shared by contemplative practice, skilled performance, and some forms of movement training. But the briefness matters: a profound moment is not the same as permanent transformation, and readers need not reproduce it to find value in practice.
Power needs a moral boundary, especially when hurting someone feels good.
A win can expose a worse self. Polly defeats a visiting Taguo coach with repeated kicks, then tries to comfort him after the fight. When the defeated man praises him as America's greatest fighter, Polly answers with a cutting reminder that many Americans are better. The opponent's pride visibly collapses. Polly realizes he did not approach him out of compassion. He wanted to deliver one final blow to the man's dignity.
The ring does not contain every consequence. In competition, force is governed by rules, referees, and a defined space. Outside it, the same ability can become intimidation or humiliation. Polly is unsettled by how pleasurable the knockout felt and by how difficult it is to separate the fighter who wants to hurt an opponent from the person who wants to behave decently. Physical skill has made him more capable, but it has not automatically made him wiser.
This is the memoir's sharpest ethical complication: competence can increase both self-protection and the capacity to dominate. The ring gives aggression a rule-bound outlet, but those rules do not erase the emotional rewards of power. Research across moral psychology distinguishes inhibition from character: knowing how to stop an action is not the same as wanting to stop it. Polly's remorse matters because it names the harm without pretending that good intentions undo it. The practical question is not whether force can ever be justified, but what standards govern its use when winning and humiliation become tempting.
Measure a practice by the decades it survives, not the applause it wins.
The reunion changes the measure. Ten years after leaving Shaolin, Polly returns to find the village transformed. Abbot Yongxin has removed much of the tourist clutter, and many of Polly's friends have dispersed: some teach abroad, some open schools, and others pursue film work or family life. The old training hall remains, but the people who gave it meaning are mostly gone.
One form outlasts its audience. At a competition in nearby Deng Feng, Polly watches a farmer in his seventies perform with a heavy, practical weapon. His movements are not polished enough to win. Yet the man has kept practicing through war, political campaigns, bans, and economic upheaval. Polly is moved less by technical brilliance than by the long devotion the performance reveals. The ending shifts the question from how good he became to whether he can love a discipline with that kind of persistence.
The elderly farmer offers a counterweight to the memoir's early fixation on exceptional skill. Competitive excellence is visible and rankable; durable devotion is quieter, often carried through ordinary work and historical disruption. That contrast helps explain why a practice can matter even when it produces no fame or measurable victory. Still, endurance should not be romanticized as proof that every tradition is worth preserving unchanged. The more useful question is what a practice gives its practitioners, and what they choose to carry forward. The book closes not with mastery achieved, but with a more mature standard for valuing a life.
Analysis
American Shaolin works as memoir, travel narrative, and informal cultural history, but its deepest structure is a test of self-invention. Polly leaves Princeton with an almost adolescent bargain: if he can master kungfu, he can eliminate cowardice, become a man, and resolve spiritual uncertainty. The story's comedy repeatedly punctures that bargain. He arrives unable to navigate the language, misunderstands local customs, gets sick, loses fights, and discovers that Shaolin is neither a sealed monastery nor a timeless martial utopia. Yet these humiliations do not make the project meaningless. They make it more precise.
The book's most convincing transformation is not from weak fighter to champion. Polly never becomes the best, and his tournament defeat is central rather than incidental. He becomes more able to remain present when shame, pain, and fear urge him to flee. This is a modest but credible account of courage because it is demonstrated in behavior, not claimed as a permanent personality trait. At the same time, the memoir refuses a simple triumph story. New physical confidence brings pleasure in violence, and one victory leaves him ashamed of how he used his advantage. Skill solves one problem while creating another ethical demand.
Its cultural insights are strongest when Polly admits his own projections. He arrives wanting Chinese people to embody a spiritual ideal, then learns that his friends have family histories, ambitions, and economic needs that do not exist to validate his fantasy. The book also situates Shaolin inside China's political and commercial changes, showing how a tradition survives partly by adapting to the systems that once threatened it. This is a valuable narrative, though not a substitute for a comprehensive history of China or Shaolin. Its evidence is personal encounter, memory, and the author's own later research, which he acknowledges may reorganize events. The final image of an elderly farmer practicing for decades gives the memoir its clearest answer: a life is not redeemed by becoming invulnerable, but by finding something worth returning to.
Review Summary
American Shaolin received mixed reviews, with many praising its humor, cultural insights, and engaging storytelling. Readers enjoyed Polly's self-deprecating style and his journey of self-discovery. The book offered a unique perspective on Chinese culture and Shaolin kung fu training. Some critics found it culturally insensitive or disliked Polly's portrayal of women. Overall, it was considered an entertaining and often funny account of a foreigner's experience in China, though opinions varied on its depth and cultural sensitivity.
People Also Read
Glossary
Eating Bitter
Enduring hardship through trainingA Chinese expression for accepting difficulty, discomfort, or suffering as part of work toward a goal. At Shaolin, it describes the physical pain of demanding practice as well as the patience required to live in a difficult environment. Polly initially treats it as a test of toughness, then learns that hardship can also reveal the circumstances and sacrifices behind another person's choices.
guanxi
Networks of personal relationshipsA Chinese term for relationships and connections that shape trust, obligation, access, and exchange. In Polly's account, personal ties affect prices, favors, institutional decisions, and the ability to solve problems. Guanxi is not simply friendship or bribery; it includes social obligations and status, and its value depends on the people and situation involved.
sanda
Chinese kickboxingA modern Chinese combat sport combining punches, kicks, and throws under rules designed to keep bouts focused on standing exchanges. Polly turns to sanda after questioning whether traditional forms prepare him for an actual fight. Its limited set of techniques gives him a practical training ground for timing, defense, and managing fear against resisting opponents.
qie cuo
A martial challenge matchA Chinese expression used for a challenge match between martial artists. In the book, a challenge is treated as a serious test of skill and the reputation of a school, not merely as casual sparring. The match that opens the memoir places Polly, a beginner and foreign disciple, against a Chinese martial arts master.
Iron kungfu
Conditioning the body to withstand blowsA family of practices in which repeated conditioning and focused breathing are used to make parts of the body more resistant to impact. Shaolin demonstrations include feats involving the head, stomach, limbs, and groin. Polly learns iron forearm training, which combines repetitive striking with medicinal treatments. The book presents these feats as physical conditioning, not invulnerability.
FAQ
What's American Shaolin about?
- Personal Journey: American Shaolin by Matthew Polly details his journey to China to study kungfu at the Shaolin Temple, focusing on his transformation and exploration of martial arts and Zen Buddhism.
- Cultural Exploration: The book highlights the cultural clash between Eastern and Western philosophies, as Polly navigates life as a foreigner in a traditional Chinese setting.
- Humor and Insight: Polly infuses humor into his narrative, sharing anecdotes about his training and interactions with monks, providing a unique perspective on martial arts and Chinese society.
Why should I read American Shaolin?
- Engaging Storytelling: Matthew Polly's writing is both entertaining and insightful, making it a compelling read for those interested in martial arts or travel narratives.
- Cultural Understanding: The book offers a deep dive into Chinese culture, particularly the traditions surrounding kungfu and the philosophy of the Shaolin monks.
- Personal Growth: Polly's journey of self-discovery and personal growth is relatable to anyone seeking to overcome challenges and find their place in the world.
What are the key takeaways of American Shaolin?
- Discipline and Hard Work: The book emphasizes the importance of discipline in achieving mastery, as seen in Polly's rigorous training regimen at the Shaolin Temple.
- Cultural Exchange: Polly highlights the value of cultural exchange and understanding, showcasing the richness that comes from engaging with different cultures.
- Resilience in Adversity: Polly's experiences illustrate the need for resilience and adaptability when faced with challenges, both in martial arts and life.
What are the best quotes from American Shaolin and what do they mean?
- “To suffer and learn a lesson...”: This quote reflects the idea that true learning often comes through hardship and struggle, a central theme in Polly's training.
- “I do not fear the 10,000 kicks...”: Emphasizes the importance of mastery through repetition, a principle that underpins martial arts training.
- “You must not fear to eat bitter.”: Encapsulates the philosophy of enduring hardship for growth, encouraging embracing challenges as part of the journey toward mastery.
What challenges does Matthew Polly face in American Shaolin?
- Cultural Barriers: Polly struggles with language barriers and cultural misunderstandings as he tries to integrate into the Shaolin community.
- Physical Demands: The intense physical training takes a toll on his body, leading to injuries and moments of self-doubt about his abilities.
- Isolation: As the only foreigner in the village, Polly experiences loneliness and homesickness, which he must overcome to fully engage in his training.
How does American Shaolin depict the training at the Shaolin Temple?
- Rigorous Regimen: Training is depicted as grueling and demanding, with monks practicing for hours each day, focusing on both physical and mental discipline.
- Camaraderie and Competition: The book illustrates the bond between the monks, as well as the competitive spirit that drives them to improve their skills.
- Cultural Rituals: Polly describes various rituals and practices within the temple, showcasing the blend of martial arts and spirituality that defines Shaolin training.
How does humor play a role in American Shaolin?
- Lightens the Narrative: Polly uses humor to balance the serious themes of struggle and discipline, making the book more relatable and enjoyable.
- Coping Mechanism: Humor serves as a coping mechanism for Polly as he navigates the challenges of training and cultural differences.
- Cultural Commentary: Through humor, Polly offers insightful commentary on cultural differences and the quirks of life in China.
How does Matthew Polly's perspective change throughout American Shaolin?
- Initial Naivety: At the beginning, Polly approaches his journey with a romanticized view of martial arts and Eastern philosophy.
- Growth Through Experience: As he trains and faces challenges, he gains a deeper understanding of the complexities of kungfu and the realities of life in China.
- Cultural Appreciation: By the end of the book, Polly develops a greater appreciation for the culture and the people he trains with, recognizing the value of their traditions.
What is the significance of the title American Shaolin?
- Cultural Identity: The title reflects Polly's identity as an American navigating the rich traditions of Shaolin, symbolizing the blending of cultures.
- Martial Arts Journey: It signifies his journey to learn kungfu and the personal transformation he undergoes while immersed in the Shaolin way of life.
- Contrast and Conflict: The title encapsulates the contrasts between American individualism and the communal, disciplined nature of Shaolin culture.
How does American Shaolin address the theme of masculinity?
- Physicality and Strength: The book explores traditional notions of masculinity through the lens of martial arts, emphasizing physical strength and resilience.
- Emotional Vulnerability: Polly's experiences reveal the emotional struggles of men in a competitive environment, challenging stereotypes of stoicism and invulnerability.
- Brotherhood and Support: The relationships formed among the monks highlight the importance of camaraderie and support in navigating the challenges of masculinity.
How did Polly's perspective on martial arts change throughout American Shaolin?
- From Novice to Competitor: Initially, Polly approached martial arts with curiosity and admiration, but as he trained, he developed a competitive spirit.
- Understanding Mastery: Polly learned that mastery in martial arts is not just about physical prowess but also about mental discipline and emotional resilience.
- Cultural Appreciation: Through his training, Polly gained a deeper appreciation for the cultural significance of martial arts in China.
What impact did Polly's time at the Shaolin Temple have on his life?
- Life Lessons: Polly's experiences at the Shaolin Temple taught him valuable life lessons about discipline, resilience, and the importance of community.
- Cultural Appreciation: His time in China deepened his appreciation for Chinese culture and philosophy, particularly the teachings of kungfu and Buddhism.
- Personal Growth: The journey of self-discovery and transformation he underwent at the Shaolin Temple laid the foundation for his future pursuits.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.