Plot Summary
The Broken Nazar
Dina Whitlock runs Serendipity Café, a London refuge where her enchanted pastries lend customers comfort and courage. She keeps her witchcraft secret, pours her feelings into food, and avoids romance because intimacy has hurt her before. Then Scott Mason, a broad-shouldered British Museum curator fascinated by protective charms, enters and accidentally knocks a nazar amulet from the wall.
Their conversation sparks an attraction Dina does not trust. The coffee machine breaks, a customer spills drinks, and further ill omens accumulate. That night, Dina reads her tea leaves: romance is approaching, and disaster will follow. She recognizes the warning as the return of a hex she has spent years trying to outrun.
Dina’s café makes care tangible: she converts remembered comfort into food that helps others find their own steadiness. The broken amulet unsettles that carefully managed world, but the omen is also an invitation to interpret coincidence as fate. Her first response is not curiosity but containment. The trouble is that the protective habits that keep her safe from another heartbreak also prevent her from testing whether this new connection is actually dangerous.
A Spell That Stayed
At thirteen, Dina tried to cast a fate spell to bind herself to a school crush, then abandoned it when the crush faded. Years later, she used the same spell to keep her first love, Rory, from ending their relationship. Rory drove toward Dina, crashed on an icy motorway, and woke in hospital furious that magic had overridden her choice.
In anger, Rory seemed to curse Dina, promising that people who loved her would be hurt. Dina believed her. Later partners suffered accidents just as affection deepened, including a chef burned by an oven glove and a woman injured on a hike. Dina stopped dating seriously and never told her parents the full story, fearing both the hex and their response to her sexuality.
The remembered curse gives Dina a clear explanation for painful events, but that clarity comes at a cost: it turns uncertainty into a life sentence. Her original mistake was using magic to control another person’s choice; her lasting response is to deny herself choice in return. The belief that love inevitably harms others becomes both a supernatural threat and a psychological defense, protecting Dina from rejection while making closeness seem morally reckless.
Three Meetings, One Escape
On the train to Little Hathering for Eric and Immy’s wedding, Dina’s familiar, Heebie, escapes her carrier and settles contentedly into Scott’s arms.
The two share hot chocolate and talk about Dina’s café and Scott’s plan for a traveling exhibition of protective objects, including artifacts the British Museum should return to their countries of origin. Dina enjoys his attention, but remembers her tea leaves and refuses to give him her number when his mother calls him from the platform.
Later, after wine and a fall on the pavement leave Dina dazed, Scott finds her while walking his corgi, Juniper, and carries her to her parents’ house. They discover he is Eric’s best man and Dina is Immy’s maid of honor, so the weekend will keep them together.
The repeated encounters give Dina a chance to call attraction coincidence, then fate, without having to act on it. Scott’s practical kindness complicates that escape: he helps her when she is vulnerable without demanding anything in return. His museum work also establishes a parallel between their values. Dina restores emotional balance through care; Scott wants historical objects returned to the communities whose histories they carry.
The Cottage for Two
At Honeywell House, the wedding venue, Dina arrives with her parents and reconnects with Immy and Rosemary, her closest friends. Immy has assigned Dina and Scott the same secluded hunting lodge, hoping they will enjoy a fling.
The cottage sits beside ancient woods that stir Dina’s magic, while Scott chops wood outside and admits he is uneasy in enclosed spaces. Left alone, they set ground rules for sharing the rooms and struggle to concentrate on anything but each other.
Dina’s family home has already shown how magic can make a place feel protective and alive; the lodge carries a different, older presence. When Scott helps Dina light the fire by guiding her hands over flint, their careful politeness turns charged, and Dina retreats to the shower to regain control.
The cottage compresses the distance Dina usually maintains between desire and consequence. Immy’s matchmaking is playful, but it also deprives Dina of the easy option of leaving the room whenever attraction becomes frightening. The fire-lighting scene matters because Scott teaches rather than takes over, offering closeness without coercion. Dina’s retreat shows how quickly care can feel dangerous to someone who has learned to associate intimacy with harm.
A Palm Reading Interrupted
At the rehearsal dinner, Dina’s parents tell Scott how they met and built a lasting marriage. Their story makes her feel the distance between the love she wants and the danger she believes she carries. Later, in a quiet parlor, Dina reads Scott’s palm and sees signs of a long life and enduring love. Scott draws close, but the house steward interrupts just before they kiss.
Dina leaves for the woods instead of returning to Scott, while her mother reminds her that magic is part of who they are and should not drive away people who can accept it. Dina still cannot bring herself to explain the hex. She returns to the cottage determined to keep Scott at a safe distance, though the palm reading has made that resolve harder.
Dina can read Scott’s palm but cannot imagine herself as the person who might share the future it suggests. The divination becomes less a prediction than a mirror for her self-exclusion. Her parents’ affection offers a model of love that survives time, yet it intensifies her fear because she believes she is uniquely barred from that kind of safety. Her mother’s reassurance is meaningful, but cannot substitute for the truth Dina withholds.
The Lovers’ Nook
During Immy and Eric’s scavenger hunt, Dina and Scott search Honeywell House for a hidden copy of Sense and Sensibility. Pulling the book triggers a concealed doorway, and they follow the passage to a tiny room built for private lovers. Scott’s claustrophobia surfaces, but he stays close to Dina. She asks what he would do if they were more than friends; he kisses her neck and then her mouth.
They stop when other guests approach, laughing at how nearly they were discovered. Dina makes clear she does not want a relationship, only the weekend. Scott accepts the boundary and agrees to keep their kiss secret. Their arrangement gives Dina a way to approach desire without admitting how much she already wants.
The hidden room externalizes the emotional conditions Dina has set: intimacy is allowed only if it stays concealed, temporary, and carefully defined. Scott respects her stated limit, which distinguishes his desire from the coercive magic that once shaped Dina’s first relationship. Yet secrecy does not make the connection smaller. It simply lets Dina postpone deciding whether she can trust what is happening.
Lost in the Maze
Immy’s hedge-maze contest exposes Scott’s claustrophobia when he loses his team and panics among the tall walls. Dina leaves the others, crushes chamomile to strengthen a locating spell, and follows her amethyst pendant to find him. She covers his eyes and leads him out by the hand, using the pendant again to trace the exit.
Along the way, Scott talks about rowing on the Thames and offers to show Dina the quieter stretch beyond the city. Once outside, he holds her close in relief, and she realizes she would have gone after him even if no romance were involved. The group sees their tenderness, ending any hope that their weekend arrangement can remain entirely secret.
The maze reverses the usual rescue pattern. Scott has carried Dina after her fall; now Dina uses her skill to guide him through a panic he cannot simply reason away. Her magic serves connection rather than control, and Scott lets himself be vulnerable without disguising fear as bravado. Their mutual care becomes evidence that the relationship is already more than a convenient physical escape.
Moonlight in a Teacup
Before the wedding, Dina shows Scott her magic in the woods, gathering moonlight into a teacup and scattering it across the trees. He watches in astonishment but does not recoil.
Later, Dina joins her mother, Immy, and Rosemary for their Samhain ritual, where special candles let them briefly feel the presence of dead loved ones. Dina remembers her aunt, Immy grieves her grandmother, and Rosemary reaches toward her mother. The ritual gives the women a shared moment of mourning and joy.
Afterward, Dina returns to the woods naked and finds Scott awake and waiting. They begin a passionate night together, though they stop short of intercourse. Dina has shown him a guarded part of herself, and his acceptance makes her wish the weekend could continue.
Magic here is not spectacle for its own sake. Dina’s moonlight spell is an act of trust, while the candles let grief become communal rather than private. The ritual links desire with remembrance: the women can welcome new attachment without pretending loss has vanished. Scott’s acceptance matters because Dina has learned to expect that revealing her full self will provoke fear or resentment.
A Wedding, A Storm
On the wedding day, Dina helps Immy feel like herself again after rejecting the heavy makeup chosen for her. She walks Immy down the aisle, performs a handfasting that binds the couple’s vows with ribbons for passion, joy, and loyalty, and sees Scott watching her. After the ceremony, they slip into a closet and Dina’s orgasm releases small golden lights around them.
That night, after Scott’s best-man duties and a possessive dance together, they return to the cottage and finally sleep together. Their lovemaking is tender as well as intense; when they climax together, the lights fail and a storm breaks outside. Dina wakes feeling closer to Scott than she intended, while he has begun to imagine a life beyond the weekend.
The wedding places Dina’s private fear beside a public celebration of chosen commitment. Her handfasting magic strengthens a bond the couple has already made; it does not manufacture affection. The lights and storm that follow her intimacy with Scott make her power visible in a new way, but the deeper change is relational: she lets herself be cared for and desired without treating pleasure as a debt.
Charms Against Bad Luck
After the wedding, Dina and Scott agree they are a couple, and she gives him her protective nazar necklace because she fears the old hex may target him. Scott introduces Dina to the protective-charms exhibition he has built at the British Museum.
He explains the histories of objects such as a dog statue rubbed for luck and a Zuni bear intended to return to its rightful museum. Dina senses the bear’s power and praises Scott’s effort to circulate artifacts back to their communities.
He offers to help trace Dina’s Amazigh heritage through an old map. Their happiness deepens, but danger keeps intruding: Scott narrowly avoids a falling exhibition poster, and a cyclist later knocks him down. Dina treats these accidents as signs that her charms may not be enough.
Scott’s exhibition and Dina’s protective practices both ask what care looks like across time. He wants museums to repair the imbalance created by taking cultural objects; she wants to protect a person she loves from a harm she cannot explain. The necklace is a loving gesture, but it also lets Dina manage the threat privately instead of sharing its history with Scott.
The Ladder Gives Way
Dina arrives at Scott’s flat after a cyclist has knocked him down, then later makes him a tea blend meant to steady his mind during work. At the museum, Scott climbs a library ladder to retrieve a book about Moroccan folklore and the ladder breaks beneath him. He is taken to hospital unconscious, then wakes with stitches and no internal bleeding.
Dina believes the accident proves the hex is intensifying. She tells Scott that a curse makes people who love her get hurt, admits her protective measures have failed, and ends their relationship to keep him safe. Scott refuses to accept that she must decide for him, but Dina leaves. Grieving and disoriented, he walks for hours through falling snow beside the Thames.
The accident transforms Dina’s private theory into an immediate crisis. Her confession is an act of honesty, but the breakup repeats the same pattern the hex has imposed: Dina tries to protect others by denying them agency. Scott’s refusal exposes the ethical contradiction in her sacrifice. She is choosing his risk for him, just as she once used magic to choose Rory’s future.
The Curse Was Hers
Heartbroken, Dina tells Immy and Rosemary what happened, and they urge her to seek her mother’s help. At home, Nour is shaken that Dina hid the curse and the story of her first love. Together they find a spellbook that explains Dina’s fate spell: it ended when Rory fell unconscious during its first month, and Rory was not a strong-bloodline witch able to redirect it.
The supposed curse Rory placed on Dina could not have come from that spell. Nour performs a reading to identify the hex’s source. Smoke spells Dina’s own name. The revelation recasts every later accident and Dina’s years of isolation: the threat was not Rory’s revenge, but a curse Dina had placed on herself.
The discovery does not erase the accidents or Dina’s suffering; it changes who has power to interpret them. Blaming Rory had allowed Dina to imagine the danger as an external sentence, while the spellbook reveals a pattern rooted in Dina’s own fear and shame. This is not a simple claim that distress is self-inflicted. It is a recognition that her protective belief has become an active barrier, sustained by the story she tells about what she deserves.
The Wall Comes Down
Nour explains that Dina’s self-hex has been reinforced by the belief that anyone who loves her will be hurt. As her mother applies henna in a pattern with an open eye, Dina tells her she is bisexual and that Rory was a woman. Nour apologizes for making Dina fear rejection and embraces her without reservation. In the mirror, Dina recognizes herself as someone worthy of love, not a danger others must escape.
The hex dissolves. Nour also encourages her to seek help beyond magic, because self-acceptance will require ongoing work. The house packs Dina’s bags and arranges a train ticket, sending her toward Scott and the exhibition opening. This time she travels to tell him the truth, not to protect him through silence.
The henna is an embodied counterspell: Dina does not merely learn a new fact about the curse, she sees herself through the loving gaze she had feared losing. Coming out and breaking the hex are distinct but connected acts. Her mother’s acceptance repairs a relationship Dina had kept at a distance, while Nour’s suggestion of counseling prevents magical resolution from being mistaken for effortless psychological recovery.
The Exhibition Reopens
At the opening of Scott’s Symbols of Protection exhibition, he learns it will travel to the Musée d’Orsay in Paris. Dina arrives without an invitation, using a spell to pass security, and finds him beneath a statue of Hathor. She apologizes for leaving and explains that she has broken the self-imposed hex. Scott tells her he still loves her and takes her back into his arms.
They return together to the exhibition, where Scott’s colleagues congratulate him and the opening succeeds. Dina later chooses her own flat as their destination, and Scott says home is wherever she and Heebie are. Their reunion resolves the danger that began with the broken amulet, while leaving Dina’s continued work on self-worth part of their shared future.
The museum opening brings the book’s two central forms of restoration together. Scott’s work asks institutions to return objects to their sources; Dina’s return asks her to repair a relationship by restoring truth and choice. The reunion is not a cure-all: Dina’s mother has already named the ongoing work ahead. Its promise lies in a different arrangement of responsibility, where love is neither forced nor refused in the name of protection.
Epilogue
A year later, Dina joins Scott, Eric, and Immy for Little Hathering’s Christmas lights. Immy is expecting twins, and Rosemary plans to return to England for the filming of her novel. Scott has a ring set with Dina’s mother’s sapphire, but he gives Dina the choice of whether to receive his surprise in public or later.
She chooses later, then kisses him beneath the newly lit tree. The moment points toward a proposal without showing its answer; what the scene makes certain is that Dina can now welcome a future without mistaking love for a threat.
The epilogue offers continuity rather than a final cure. Dina and Scott remain connected to friends, family, work, and ordinary public celebrations; their happiness is woven into a community rather than sealed off from risk. Scott’s careful handling of the ring respects Dina’s dislike of being ambushed, a quiet contrast with the coercive spell that began her history of romantic fear. By leaving the proposal unanswered, the ending grants Dina agency over the next step instead of treating marriage as proof that every wound has disappeared.
Analysis
Best Hex Ever turns a supernatural curse into an unusually precise study of how fear can become a governing story. Dina believes that love makes her dangerous, so she converts that belief into rules: do not date seriously, do not disclose the whole past, and leave before someone can be hurt. These choices appear protective, but they reproduce the isolation the curse seems to demand. Her central mistake is not simply believing in magic. It is treating a frightening interpretation as more authoritative than the people around her.
The novel makes consent the ethical boundary between helpful magic and coercion. Dina’s food spells encourage feelings already within people; her teenage fate spell overrides Rory’s choice and helps cause real harm. The distinction gives the romance a moral foundation. Scott’s respect for Dina’s magic matters because he does not require her to hide it, and his refusal to let her decide his risk for him challenges her self-sacrificial logic. Their intimacy is meaningful not because it proves destiny, but because both are choosing it.
The revelation that Dina has hexed herself does not reduce her suffering to a failure of self-esteem. The accidents and grief have been real, and the curse has shaped her life for years. Instead, the discovery identifies how shame and secrecy have become part of the mechanism that keeps her trapped. Her mother’s acceptance of her bisexuality repairs a specific fracture that Dina has carried since her first love. The henna spell makes that recognition visible, but Nour’s advice to seek support beyond magic acknowledges that insight is a beginning, not a permanent cure.
Scott’s exhibition supplies a parallel account of repair. He wants protective objects returned to the communities from which museums took them; Dina needs to reclaim the truth of her own history. Both storylines reject the idea that care means possession. Objects, memories, and people cannot be protected by denying their origins or agency. The ending’s happiness is therefore not the abolition of risk. It is Dina and Scott choosing an honest relationship in which neither has to disappear to keep the other safe.
Review Summary
Best Hex Ever receives polarized reviews with an overall 3.46/5 rating. Many praise the cozy, witchy atmosphere, magical baking, and swoon-worthy romance between Dina and Scott, calling it perfect autumn reading with satisfying spice. However, critics cite excessive "insta-love," repetitive writing, overdone sex scenes that overshadow plot, and shallow character development. Some found the magic system poorly integrated and the dialogue cringey. Cultural representation of Moroccan heritage received mixed reactions. The book's heavy sexual content surprised readers expecting lighter fare based on the cover.
People Also Read
Characters
Dina Whitlock
The café’s kitchen witchDina owns Serendipity Café, where her kitchen magic turns remembered feelings into pastries and teas that help customers find comfort. Warm, funny, and observant, she is also a capable business owner who has built a life around caring for other people. Her bisexuality and witchcraft are important parts of her identity, though she has learned to conceal parts of herself when she fears judgment. Dina’s strongest conflict is between her appetite for closeness and her conviction that intimacy makes her dangerous. Her friendships with Immy and Rosemary, her bond with her parents, and her relationship with Scott reveal how much she values being known, even when being known feels riskier than being alone.
Scott Mason
The curator of charmsScott is a British Museum curator whose fascination with protective objects began in childhood, when charms offered hope during an unsettled early life. Adopted by Helene and Alex, he values family but has sometimes responded to emotional pain by leaving, including a long period abroad after a painful breakup. He is physically imposing, gently attentive, and more emotionally candid than he first appears. His work on a traveling exhibition reflects his belief that history should be shared with the communities that shaped it. Scott’s curiosity about magic and respect for Dina’s independence allow him to meet her hidden world without treating it as a problem to solve.
Immy
Dina’s horror-writing best friendImmy is a horror and science-fiction author, Dina’s closest friend, and Eric’s fiancée. She is exuberant, stubborn, and unembarrassed by her unusual tastes, from a gothic wedding venue to an unconventional dress. Her confidence can shade into meddling, especially when she decides Dina and Scott should be together, but her matchmaking comes from genuine concern for a friend who has retreated from romance. She trusts Dina with her private fears and shares a close friendship with Rosemary.
Nour Whitlock
Dina’s divining motherNour is a Moroccan-born divination witch with a theatrical manner, a sharp eye for other people’s feelings, and a deep bond with her daughter. She reads tea leaves, dreams, and auras, but her most powerful magic is often expressed through ordinary rituals shared with Dina. Nour’s warmth coexists with old-fashioned assumptions that make Dina cautious about discussing her romantic life. Her affection is fierce, and she believes magic is inseparable from the family’s history and identity.
Eric
Scott’s loyal rowing friendEric is Scott’s longtime best friend and Immy’s devoted partner. Their friendship began while traveling and is sustained by rowing, teasing, and the ease of people who know each other’s histories. Eric welcomes Scott back to London after a period of distance and wants him to build a settled life. His humor keeps wedding preparations light, while his loyalty gives Scott a reliable connection to home.
Rosemary
The ghost-seeing novelistRosemary is a gothic horror novelist and one of Dina’s oldest friends. She can see ghosts, a gift she treats with practical curiosity rather than fear. She is candid, fiercely loyal, and comfortable letting Dina keep a confidence until Dina is ready to share it. Her own writing career and complicated relationship with grief give her a life beyond the role of supportive friend.
Robert Whitlock
Dina’s steady fatherRobert is Dina’s Welsh father, an accountant and a steady presence in a family full of magic. He learned Darija for the people he loves and addresses Dina with an affectionate name meaning his life. Robert is less inclined to pry than Nour, but his quiet support makes the family home feel safe. His marriage to Nour gives Dina a lived example of lasting affection.
Helene
Scott’s affectionate adoptive mumHelene is one of Scott’s adoptive mothers, a retired mortician with a sunny manner and a gift for filling silence with cheerful stories. She is perceptive about Scott’s emotional habits and worries that heartbreak may send him running again. Her warmth helps make the family home a place he wants to return to.
Alex
Scott’s other adoptive mumAlex is Scott’s other adoptive mother, a retired mortician who offers affection without demanding explanations. She recognizes when he is emotionally invested and encourages him to remain connected to home even when love makes him vulnerable. Her bond with Helene gives Scott a model of enduring partnership.
Rory
Dina’s first great loveRory met Dina at bakery school and became the first person outside Dina’s closest circle to learn about her magic. A talented, ambitious pastry student with dreams of Paris, Rory is central to Dina’s early understanding of desire, trust, and the risks of revealing a hidden self.
Heebie
Dina’s demanding familiarHeebie is Dina’s round, mostly black cat and magical familiar. Grumpy in appearance and affectionate on her own terms, she is a vivid part of Dina’s private home life. Her unexpected warmth toward Scott helps bring the two people together, while her stubborn routines keep Dina grounded.
Robin
The café’s trusted baristaRobin works at Serendipity Café and helps Dina manage its busy shifts. A spin instructor with a green mohawk and confident style, Robin is dependable, observant, and comfortable teasing Dina without undermining her authority.
Dr. MacDougall
Scott’s museum championDr. MacDougall is the British Museum’s head curator and the senior figure who hired Scott. She supports his unconventional exhibition plans and recognizes the value of making museum collections accessible while addressing their colonial history.
Alice
Scott’s guarded pastAlice is Scott’s former partner. Their relationship left him wary of repeating familiar dating rituals and contributed to his decision to leave London for work abroad. She remains part of the emotional history he must understand as he tries to build a home again.
Plot Devices
Dina’s self-hex
Fear made supernaturalThe apparent curse is presented as a force that harms people who fall in love with Dina. Believing Rory created it, Dina treats each later accident as evidence that love itself is unsafe. This belief drives her to conceal her past, reject Scott, and attempt to protect him without his knowledge. An old spellbook and Nour’s divination eventually identify Dina herself as the source. The device links magical causality to psychological self-protection without making the resulting danger feel imaginary.
Kitchen magic
Feeling baked into foodDina’s strongest magic works through baking and brewing. She uses memories and emotions as ingredients, giving customers a temporary push toward calm, confidence, or comfort rather than manufacturing feelings for them. The practice establishes her nurturing nature and the limits of her power: magic can support a choice but cannot create genuine love. Her spells make the café both a business and a place where care takes a physical, shareable form.
Protective charms
Objects that carry hopeNazar amulets, talismans, and lucky objects connect Dina’s family magic to Scott’s museum work. Dina uses a protective necklace in an attempt to keep Scott safe, while Scott studies how people have relied on charms across cultures. The objects can offer comfort and sometimes hold accumulated power, but they cannot replace trust or honest communication. Their presence also gives Scott a way to approach Dina’s heritage with respect and curiosity.
Tea-leaf divination
A forecast mistaken for fateDina reads tea leaves to interpret possible futures, including the warning that romance is approaching with danger attached. Her mother’s divination and prophetic dreams also influence family decisions. These readings are meaningful but not simple instructions; Dina’s fear causes her to treat them as fixed verdicts. The device creates suspense while exposing the difference between receiving a warning and surrendering the ability to choose.
Samhain candles
Grief made briefly visibleAt midnight on Samhain, Babylon candles let the women briefly feel the presence of departed loved ones. The ritual gives Dina, Immy, Rosemary, and Nour a shared way to remember family members and express grief that remains difficult in ordinary life. Its temporary nature matters: the candles do not undo loss, but they allow the living to experience connection without confusing remembrance with permanence.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.