Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Chances Are...

Chances Are...

Three old friends reunite on Martha’s Vineyard, where a long-vanished woman still haunts them.
by Richard Russo 2017 320 pages
3.77
22k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

In 2015, Lincoln Moser, Teddy Novak, and Mickey Girardi return to Martha’s Vineyard as sixty-six-year-old friends who first met at Minerva College. Their bond was tested in 1969, when a draft lottery gave Mickey a dangerously low number, Lincoln a safer one, and Teddy a number that seemed to spare him.

Outside the sorority house, their friend Jacy comforted Mickey, though she was engaged to another man. The moment captured the friendships’ central contradiction: each man loved Jacy, and each believed their shared loyalty could contain that love.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening puts youthful intimacy beside the lottery’s blunt arithmetic. Before the friends can imagine themselves as a lasting unit, the state assigns them separate risks and futures. Jacy’s comfort of Mickey makes that division personal: Lincoln and Teddy witness the same embrace, yet experience it as envy. Their shared history begins not with perfect unity but with competing private desires. By bringing the men back to the island decades later, the prologue turns a youthful moment of luck into the unfinished question that will shape their reunion.

The House Calls Them Back

A recession makes three old friends face one decision

In 2015, Lincoln, a Las Vegas commercial real-estate broker, travels to Martha’s Vineyard to assess the small Chilmark house his mother left him. The recession has damaged his business, and he and his wife, Anita, have also helped their adult children recover financially. Selling the property could protect the family, though Lincoln has avoided telling his old friends how close he came to losing everything.

Teddy arrives from Syracuse, and Mickey comes from nearby Cape Cod. Their gathering is meant to be practical and brief. But the house belonged to Lincoln’s mother, who loved the island, and the neighbor pressing to buy it, Mason Troyer, already makes the decision feel less like a routine sale.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The inherited house is both an asset and an emotional obligation. Lincoln’s financial reasoning is real, but the decision to sell threatens the last physical link to a mother whose life he only partly understood. His silence about his near-financial ruin also echoes the family habit of managing appearances rather than exposing need. The friends arrive to help assess property, yet the reunion immediately places them inside a different kind of reckoning: what they owe the dead, what they conceal from one another, and whether affection can survive the truths that age has kept buried.

A Mother’s Hidden Shore

Lincoln discovers the money behind his childhood comfort

Before Lincoln leaves Arizona for Minerva, his mother Trudy finally challenges her husband, Wolfgang Amadeus Moser, over their son’s college choice. She tells Lincoln that the family’s comfortable life has depended on her money, not solely on his father’s mine. Her parents’ estate left a small house in Chilmark protected in a trust, and rental income from it paid for luxuries the Mosers could not otherwise afford.

Trudy refuses to sell the property and arranges for Lincoln to inherit it, asking him to keep it unless necessity forces him to let it go. Her revelation sends him east, but also unsettles his faith in the obedient mother and authoritative father he thought he knew.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Trudy’s disclosure does more than finance Lincoln’s education. It breaks the story his father has told about who provides, who decides, and whose past deserves to survive. The Chilmark house becomes a quiet form of resistance: Trudy cannot remake her marriage, but she can preserve a place untouched by her husband’s control. Lincoln inherits both the property and the burden of interpreting it. His later uncertainty about selling is therefore not sentimentality alone; it is a struggle over whether he has inherited his mother’s independence or merely another obligation he does not know how to carry.

Three Hashers, One Star

Jacy unsettles their loyalties before graduation

At Minerva, scholarship students Lincoln, Teddy, and Mickey become friends while working at a sorority house. Lincoln serves meals, Teddy works in the kitchen, and Mickey chooses the pots and pans, where music matters more than flirting with the wealthy students out front.

Jacy, lively and restless, becomes their closest female friend and the object of all three men’s affection, though she is engaged to Vance, a polished law student from her social world.

Their intimacy grows through parties, music, and a late-night trip to a dog track, where Jacy’s boldness draws them into trouble with her sorority house president. She kisses each man afterward, leaving the three friends to wonder whether their loyalty can survive a choice none of them dares to demand.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The trio’s friendship offers refuge from class differences, but Jacy makes that refuge unstable. The men imagine themselves bound by an equal fellowship, while each privately hopes to be chosen. Jacy’s engagement appears to settle the matter, yet her public affection disrupts the safe explanation that their love is merely harmless. Mickey’s preference for the kitchen also establishes his practical independence from Minerva’s status games. The college years are not simply a prelude to adulthood. They are a rehearsal in wanting incompatible things while pretending that a shared code can keep desire from becoming competition.

The Cold Water Choice

A swim makes Jacy question her engagement

During the friends’ final Memorial Day visit to Chilmark, Troyer corners Jacy in the kitchen and gropes her. Mickey pulls him away and knocks him down, while Lincoln and Teddy remain outside, unaware until they hear the crash. The next day Jacy asks Teddy to take her to Gay Head. They walk beyond the clothed families, strip, and enter the freezing water together.

The swim becomes a private crossing: Jacy kisses Teddy and admits that she may not marry Vance. For Teddy, the moment is joyful and frightening, because he knows his friends love her too. He returns to the house with her, but neither tells Lincoln or Mickey what happened between them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Protection and desire converge in this section, but they do not produce a simple romantic victory. Mickey’s punch answers Troyer’s entitlement with immediate force; Teddy’s encounter with Jacy is chosen, intimate, and therefore ethically more complicated. He knows the other men’s feelings but accepts her attention without seeking their consent or clarifying what it means. Jacy’s declaration is tentative, not a settled decision, and Teddy’s happiness outruns his understanding. The cold water strips away the social roles surrounding them, yet it cannot erase the engagement, the friendship, or the consequences waiting on shore.

A Note Before Dawn

The friends wake to an empty room and no answers

On their last night together, the four friends grill dinner, drink, and sing around the Chilmark house as if their fellowship can outlast the changes ahead. Jacy never tells Lincoln and Mickey that she is reconsidering her wedding, and Teddy does not explain their afternoon together. At dawn, Teddy sees her leave with a backpack.

She leaves a brief note saying she cannot bear a goodbye, and the men let her go without following. Later, her fiancé receives a postcard from the Vineyard ending their engagement. Her parents report her missing, but police find little: no clear proof of where she went, only an uncertain sighting on a ferry and the friends’ account that she left alone.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The departure is both an act of agency and a failure of friendship. Jacy escapes a future she no longer wants, but the men’s silence leaves her alone at the moment when they could have asked what she needed. Teddy interprets her leaving as a verdict on himself; Lincoln remembers feeling relief. Their different responses expose the private bargains beneath their shared language of loyalty. The inconclusive police inquiry then gives the silence a long afterlife. Because none of the friends knows where Jacy went, each can preserve a different version of the last morning, and none can fully trust it.

Old Friends, New Fault Lines

Their lives have diverged, but Jacy remains present

On the island, the three men fall back into familiar teasing, though age has left visible marks: Lincoln’s back is stiff, Teddy is wary of the mental episodes he calls spells, and Mickey bears a scar from a motorcycle accident. Their working lives have diverged as sharply as their temperaments. Lincoln has built a career and a large family with Anita.

Teddy edits books and runs a small religious press, but doubts whether it has a future. Mickey still plays music, though he has learned to hide financial trouble and physical vulnerability behind jokes. When Teddy mistakes a young woman at the ferry for Jacy, the sight unsettles him. The island has revived a memory he has spent decades trying to contain.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The reunion does not restore youth; it shows the labor each man has done to make a life around its losses. Lincoln equates security with responsibility, Teddy manages himself by limiting emotional risk, and Mickey protects his independence with humor. Their old nicknames briefly make continuity feel effortless, but the bodies and careers reveal otherwise. Teddy’s mistaken recognition of Jacy signals that the island is intensifying more than nostalgia. It is exposing the distance between remembered intimacy and actual knowledge. Each friend returns believing he knows the others, yet their present selves are already full of private information the group has never shared.

The File Marked Missing

A retired officer turns reunion into an interrogation

Lincoln visits the Vineyard Gazette to search its old editions and finds the report about Jacy’s disappearance. The article gives her formal name, Justine, and confirms that her family and fiancé never heard from her again. A newspaper employee, Beverly, directs him to Joe Coffin, a retired island police officer who kept case files.

Coffin remembers interviewing Troyer after Mickey broke his jaw, and he presses Lincoln on the friends’ motives and opportunity. He offers dark scenarios in which the three men harmed Jacy and covered it up, while admitting that the evidence cannot settle whether she died or simply vanished. Lincoln leaves shaken, newly suspicious of Troyer and, for the first time, of Mickey.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Coffin’s interrogation converts absence into accusation. His procedural skepticism is not baseless: the three friends were among the last people to see Jacy, and their attachment gives them both motive and reason to conceal. Yet his vivid reconstructions blur the line between inference and evidence. Lincoln is vulnerable because he wants certainty, not merely information; a plausible story can therefore feel more trustworthy than the people he loves. The scene’s psychological pressure comes from a familiar inversion: loyalty begins to look like blindness, while suspicion poses as courage. Lincoln must decide whether doubt is responsible inquiry or a new form of self-deception.

Troyer Names Mickey

An angry neighbor denies knowing what happened

Troyer confronts Teddy at the Chilmark house after Coffin questions him. He resents Lincoln’s inquiries and insists he had nothing to do with Jacy’s disappearance. Rather than reassure Teddy, he directs suspicion toward Mickey, citing the old assault and claiming the man should be questioned. Teddy rejects the accusation, but Troyer’s insistence gives Lincoln’s doubts a new target.

Meanwhile, Lincoln learns from realtor Martin that Troyer’s property has no recorded easement across the Moser land, despite the dirt road being his only route to the main road. The access problem explains Troyer’s persistent interest in buying the house, but his sudden hostility suggests the dispute is no longer just about land.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Troyer is dangerous partly because he combines genuine self-interest with a theatrical capacity to make others look guilty. His denial does not establish innocence, and his accusation against Mickey does not establish anything either. The missing easement gives his offers a concrete motive, which complicates the men’s moral reading of him: he may be an opportunist without being a murderer. Lincoln’s investigation now has two tracks, one legal and one emotional. The danger is that he will let the second determine the first, treating a neighbor’s repellent character as proof of a crime he cannot verify.

A Voice From 1971

A singer’s familiar sound sends Teddy crashing

Mickey brings Lincoln and Teddy to a crowded Oak Bluffs club to hear his band. During the performance, a purple-haired singer joins him and delivers a song associated with Jacy’s old appearances at Minerva. Teddy recognizes the voice and collapses, striking a wineglass and badly cutting his face.

While Teddy is taken for treatment, Lincoln hears from Coffin that Mickey once beat a man into a coma, an assault recorded in Connecticut. The victim was Donald Calloway, the man Jacy had presented as her father. The singer, Delia, is not simply an echo of the past, and Mickey’s hidden history is now too substantial for Lincoln to dismiss as an old friend’s private business.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The performance makes memory physical. Teddy’s collapse is not proof of the supernatural, but it shows how a voice can overwhelm the defenses he has built around loss. The song also draws the men toward a past they had kept separate from their adult lives. At the same moment, Coffin supplies a fact that changes the moral balance: Mickey has used serious violence before, and the victim was connected to Jacy. The juxtaposition is deliberately destabilizing. The friends must now hold tenderness and threat together, resisting both sentimental absolution and the easy certainty that one violent act explains an entire person.

The Father Behind the Frame

A photograph exposes the lie inside Jacy’s family

Jacy’s history begins to surface through the story she once told Mickey. As a teenager, she learns that the handsome bartender in an old club photograph, Andres Demopoulos, may be her biological father, not Donald Calloway. Her mother Vivian confirms that she and Andres had loved each other, but she chose the wealth and safety offered by Donald.

Andres later develops a degenerative illness that makes him appear drunk and unsteady. Jacy discovers that he has died shortly before her college graduation, and the news deepens her despair. After rejecting a suicide attempt, she takes cash from Donald’s safe. Teddy’s invitation to the island gives her an opening to flee Greenwich, her engagement, and the family story built around her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Jacy’s family history repeats the novel’s central problem of inheritance, but here the inheritance is not property. It is a story imposed on a child to protect adult choices. Vivian’s concealment may have begun as protection, yet it leaves Jacy unable to distinguish care from control. Learning the truth does not automatically liberate her; it first makes her feel trapped by the people who constructed her identity. The money she takes is practical escape, not a symbolic cure. Her choice to leave is an attempt to reclaim authorship, though she cannot know what illness, love, and exile will demand next.

Canada Was No Cure

Music and illness reshape Mickey’s life with Jacy

After leaving the Vineyard, Jacy meets Mickey in Woods Hole and persuades him to cross into Canada with her. He hides in the car trunk to avoid the border officials, abandoning the promise he made his father to report for military service. They build a life around music, and Jacy becomes the band’s magnetic lead singer.

Their daughter is placed for adoption, with Mickey named as the father. Jacy’s inherited cerebellar ataxia advances; a fall from a stage damages her body and ends her performing life. She disappears from Mickey for a year, then returns after the draft amnesty, only to die after falling down the stairs. During this period Mickey also finds Donald Calloway and beats him into a coma.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Canada offers escape from the draft and from Greenwich, but it cannot free Jacy from her body or Mickey from the promise he has broken. Their music gives her a public self larger than the illness, until a fall takes that stage away. Mickey’s concealment of the daughter and the assault on Donald arise from the same mixture of love, shame, and control: he acts decisively, then hides what his actions mean. His story refuses a neat moral verdict. He is capable of tenderness and violence, but neither cancels the other, and both shape the silence that survives Jacy.

The Daughter Returns

Mickey’s confession gives Delia a place in the family

With Teddy recovering and Lincoln pressing for answers, Mickey finally tells the full story of his life with Jacy. Delia is their daughter, now a singer struggling with opioid addiction who found Mickey through the band’s online presence. Mickey had kept her existence secret because he promised Jacy, but also because he did not want to share the woman he had loved with his friends.

Lincoln’s suspicion turns to shame; Teddy recognizes how the revelation transforms the voice that brought him down. Rather than recoil from Delia’s anger or guardedness, Teddy embraces her and offers her work repairing the Chilmark house. Delia does not promise recovery, but she gives Teddy her number and considers his offer.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The confession replaces the old mystery with a difficult kinship. Delia is not a recovered version of Jacy, and neither Mickey nor the two friends can make her into one. Her presence instead tests whether they can care without demanding that she heal their grief. Mickey’s admission that he withheld her partly from possessiveness makes his secrecy morally legible without excusing it. Lincoln’s shame matters because he had nearly allowed suspicion to erase a lifetime of friendship. Teddy’s offer of work is modest and practical, a form of care that does not pretend to cure addiction or repair the past.

An Easement, Not a Sale

Lincoln chooses friendship and a future for the house

After learning what happened, Lincoln tells Coffin that Jacy died and that the men were not responsible for her disappearance. He urges the retired officer to accept the operation Beverly wants him to have, and Coffin finally yields. Lincoln also tells Troyer he will keep the Chilmark house rather than sell it, but grants him a legal easement for a dollar.

Teddy plans to stay in the house, handle repairs, and begin a new life beyond his failing press; he also intends to remain in Delia’s orbit without treating her as a project. Mickey takes responsibility for helping his daughter return to treatment. Lincoln leaves for home with a fuller understanding of his friends and a reason to return to the island.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending resolves the book’s practical conflicts through limited acts of repair, not grand absolution. Lincoln cannot recover Jacy or reclaim the years of silence, but he can stop converting suspicion into punishment. The easement turns a hostile property dispute into a deliberate neighborly concession, while Teddy’s stay gives the inherited house a future that is neither sale nor shrine. Coffin’s choice to accept care also revises his own fatalism. The friends remain flawed and separate, yet they choose continued responsibility for one another. Their chances are not guaranteed; they are made meaningful by what they do next.

Analysis

Chances Are... is built around a deceptively simple question: what happened to Jacy after she left Martha’s Vineyard? The mystery matters less as a puzzle to solve than as a pressure test for three men who have mistaken shared memories for shared knowledge. Their friendship is real, but it has never made them transparent to one another. Each carries private shame, and each has shaped the past into a story that lets him continue living.

The novel repeatedly sets personal choice against forces that cannot be chosen: the draft lottery, class, inherited illness, family history, and the accidents of bodies. Yet it does not argue that people are powerless. Mickey chooses to flee the draft; Jacy chooses escape; Lincoln chooses whether to preserve the house; Teddy chooses whether to risk intimacy and meaningful work. These choices do not guarantee good outcomes, but they create responsibility where certainty is impossible.

The family stories sharpen that distinction. Trudy’s property preserves a part of herself outside her husband’s control. Vivian’s concealment, meant to protect her daughter and preserve a respectable life, instead leaves Jacy to make decisions without the truth. Mickey’s silence about Delia similarly grows from love and possessiveness at once. The novel treats secrecy not as a single moral category but as a habit that can begin in fear, become self-protection, and finally damage the people it was meant to spare.

By the end, no revelation restores the friends’ lost youth or makes their histories clean. Lincoln’s easement, Teddy’s decision to stay, and Mickey’s effort to help Delia are smaller than redemption and more credible for it. The men cannot repair what happened to Jacy, but they can stop using uncertainty as permission to abandon one another. Their future remains open because it depends on what they do, not on what they wish had happened.

Summary in 60 Seconds
In 2015, Lincoln, Teddy, and Mickey reunite at Lincoln’s inherited Martha’s Vineyard house, where a neighbor wants to buy the property. Their memories return to 1969, when all three loved Jacy, a college friend who vanished after leaving the island. A retired officer’s questions revive suspicions, while the neighbor points them toward Mickey and a singer’s familiar voice sends Teddy into a panic. The men uncover Jacy’s painful family history, including the truth about her biological father and her degenerative illness. Mickey reveals that he fled to Canada with Jacy, played music with her, and had a daughter with her, Delia. Jacy later died after a fall; Mickey had also attacked the man she believed was her father. Delia, now struggling with opioid addiction, reconnects with Mickey. Lincoln keeps the house and grants the neighbor access, Teddy stays to repair it, and Mickey tries to support Delia’s recovery.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.77 out of 5
Average of 22k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.
Your rating:
4.73
18 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Lincoln Moser

The dutiful inheritor

A Las Vegas commercial real-estate broker, Lincoln is the son of Wolfgang Amadeus and Trudy Moser, the husband of Anita, and one of Mickey and Teddy’s oldest friends. He values order, work, and responsibility, but his confidence in those virtues is complicated by the domineering father whose habits he fears he has inherited. Lincoln’s instinct is to solve problems through practical decisions, even when the true problem is grief or guilt. The Chilmark house forces him to reconsider what he owes his mother and what he has mistaken for certainty. His affection for his friends is deep, though he can be slow to recognize how little he actually knows about their private lives.

Teddy Novak

The wary book fixer

Teddy is a small-press publisher, editor, and former college friend of Lincoln and Mickey. Raised by two distracted high-school teachers, he became observant, intellectually curious, and wary of asking others for care. He has long managed recurring mental episodes by keeping his life predictable, and his work suits his talent for repairing other people’s writing rather than exposing his own. His first love left him with a private wound he has never fully examined. Teddy’s sharp judgments can protect him from disappointment, but they also distance him from people who might offer real intimacy. Beneath his restraint is a persistent wish to be useful and to belong.

Mickey Girardi

The working musician

Mickey is a Cape Cod musician and sound engineer, the youngest child in a large working-class Irish and Italian family. His father’s blunt loyalty and his own early love of guitar shaped a man who trusts concrete acts more than explanations. At Minerva he chose the sorority kitchen over the socially desirable dining room, preferring the honest rhythm of work and music to status. Mickey’s humor makes him the group’s counterweight to Lincoln’s worry and Teddy’s introspection, though his easygoing surface conceals shame and a fierce capacity for violence. He is loyal, stubborn, and suspicious of people who mistake compromise for weakness.

Jacy

The restless fourth friend

Jacy, born Justine Calloway, is a Minerva student whose energy draws Lincoln, Teddy, and Mickey into an intimate friendship. She is engaged to Vance, yet the life expected of her by her wealthy Greenwich family does not seem to satisfy her. Jacy is curious about other people’s worlds and impatient with the rules that confine her own. Her wit and boldness coexist with private uncertainty, making her difficult for the men to understand even as all three fall in love with her. She values freedom, but freedom is not simple for her: each attempt to choose for herself carries consequences she cannot foresee.

Anita

Lincoln’s clear-eyed partner

Lincoln’s wife and a lawyer, Anita is perceptive, practical, and unafraid to challenge her husband’s habits. She understands his loyalty to his mother and sees how easily his father’s certainty can reappear in him. Anita has built a life with Lincoln and their children without surrendering her own judgment. Her absence from the island does not make her peripheral: her advice helps Lincoln measure the difference between family duty and self-deception.

Wolfgang Amadeus Moser

The commanding father

Lincoln’s father, known in the family by a teasing pronunciation of his initials, is a small, domineering Arizona mine owner and committed religious man. He speaks with absolute confidence and expects his household to accept his judgments as law. His force of personality shapes Lincoln’s instincts long after Lincoln leaves home. He is neither a simple villain nor an easy source of wisdom; his capacity for attachment exists beside a need for control that makes those closest to him work around his moods.

Trudy Moser

The quiet resister

Lincoln’s mother grew up in Massachusetts and carries a strong attachment to the family house on Martha’s Vineyard. In her marriage to Wolfgang Amadeus, she has learned to survive by yielding, but she is not without resolve. Her decision to preserve the Chilmark property and support Lincoln’s education reveals a private strength that her son has not understood. She wants him to inherit a life beyond his father’s narrow expectations, even if she cannot openly build that life for herself.

Delia

The guarded new singer

Delia is a singer with a rough-edged confidence and a life complicated by opioid addiction. She is wary of easy promises and quick to defend herself with sarcasm, habits shaped by instability rather than simple defiance. Music offers her both a skill and a way to make contact with others, though it does not erase her need for treatment or support. In meeting Teddy and Lincoln, she encounters men who knew her mother long before she did, and their memories become another part of the complicated story she must decide whether to trust.

Vivian Calloway

The keeper of appearances

Vivian is Jacy’s mother, a woman raised among wealth and social expectations. She makes a consequential choice to marry Donald rather than build a life with Andres, then spends years managing the truths her daughter is allowed to know. Vivian’s restraint is not mere coldness; it is also an attempt to control damage in a world where money and reputation seem to determine who is safe. Her choices nevertheless leave Jacy with a fractured understanding of family, love, and freedom.

Donald Calloway

The polished patriarch

Donald is Jacy’s socially recognized father, a wealthy Greenwich businessman whose authority depends on keeping his family’s public image intact. He is accustomed to having his wishes treated as common sense and views social standing as a form of security. His relationship with Vivian and Jacy is shaped by possession as much as affection. Donald represents the world Jacy is expected to inherit, one in which comfort can conceal the cost paid by people outside the family’s official story.

Andres Demopoulos

The vanished first love

Andres is a Greek-born food-service worker whose connection to Vivian belongs to the hidden history of the Calloway family. Handsome and warm in an old photograph, he stands apart from the polished world Vivian later chooses. His circumstances expose how little power charm or love can provide when class, immigration status, and illness shape a person’s options.

Mason Troyer

The pushy neighbor

Troyer is the owner of the large property below Lincoln’s Chilmark house. He is aggressive, socially abrasive, and accustomed to testing how far he can push other people. His history with the three friends includes an ugly encounter at the house, and in the present he wants to acquire Lincoln’s land. Troyer’s hostility makes him an obvious suspect, but his motives are also material and specific, a distinction the men must struggle to keep in view.

Joe Coffin

The haunted ex-cop

Coffin is a retired island police officer who still thinks like an investigator and carries the failures of his career into private life. He distrusts easy accounts of male innocence, particularly when women have been harmed. His probing questions unsettle Lincoln because they turn friendship into evidence and belief into a potential excuse. Coffin is perceptive, but his experience can harden into fatalism, and his own painful family history has made him unusually alert to the damage people do while insisting they mean well.

Beverly

The newspaper guide

Beverly works at the Vineyard Gazette and is Coffin’s daughter-in-law. She helps Lincoln find the old missing-person report and connects him with Coffin. Her kindness is practical rather than sentimental: she sees that the past still troubles people and offers them a way to investigate it. Beverly’s relationship with Coffin also reveals the private obligations that keep him connected to life beyond his police files.

Theresa Whittier

Teddy’s perceptive patron

Theresa is the president of St. Joseph’s College and the person who gives Teddy’s small publishing venture institutional support. Intelligent and socially confident, she recognizes his talent while noticing the emotional distance he disguises as privacy. She and Teddy share companionship and mutual attraction, but he struggles to risk the honesty that a deeper relationship would require. Theresa’s willingness to name that failure makes her one of the few people who sees past his careful neutrality.

Vance

Jacy’s proper fiancé

Vance is Jacy’s wealthy, conventional fiancé, a law student who expects marriage to follow the path laid out by their families. His confidence in that future contrasts with Jacy’s growing restlessness. He is less a romantic rival than the embodiment of the respectable life she is expected to accept.

Tom Ford

The searching professor

Ford is a Minerva humanities professor who encourages Teddy to think beyond easy answers. His classes ask students to connect history with their own time, and his advice about writing becomes a lasting measure for Teddy. Ford’s influence helps shape the friends’ habit of asking what lies beneath the nearest explanation.

Delia’s mother

The unspoken absence

Delia’s mother is the parent who raises her before she seeks out Mickey. Her absence from the island reunion leaves Delia to decide how much of her history she wants from the father she has only recently found.

Plot Devices

The draft lottery

Luck made personal

The 1969 lottery assigns each young man a number that seems to determine his exposure to the Vietnam War. Mickey draws a number near the beginning of the sequence, while Lincoln and Teddy receive safer numbers. The event turns political history into a private test of loyalty, fear, and choice. It also gives the friends a shared memory that later acquires different meanings: what once felt like chance becomes a reference point for the decisions they made, the people they lost, and the lives they believe they might have lived.

The Chilmark house

Inheritance as obligation

The house Trudy preserves for Lincoln links his present to her childhood on Martha’s Vineyard and to the life she refused to surrender completely to her husband. Its rental income once supported the family, and its eventual ownership gives Lincoln a practical choice during financial uncertainty. As he returns to decide whether to sell, the property becomes the setting where old friends confront a disappearance and where Lincoln must distinguish care for his mother’s memory from obedience to inherited expectations.

Jacy’s disappearance

A mystery fed by silence

Jacy leaves the island before her friends wake, and the police investigation produces no confirmed account of where she went. The absence becomes an organizing mystery because each man remembers the last weekend differently and none knows the whole story. Decades later, Lincoln’s search through the newspaper archive and Coffin’s old case file turns uncertainty into suspicion. The mystery tests whether memory can be trusted when it is entangled with shame, loyalty, and desire, and it gives the friends a reason to return to the choices they left unexplained.

The inherited illness

The body resists escape

Cerebellar ataxia links generations through a degenerative condition that affects balance, speech, and movement. Its presence changes how Jacy understands her biological family and complicates the freedom she seeks in Canada. The illness is not a moral punishment or a metaphor that explains every choice; it is a material constraint that the characters cannot reason away. Its progression makes the story’s questions about chance and agency intimate, because the future can be shaped by decisions but not wholly controlled by them.

Music and memory

The past finds a voice

Music binds the friends’ college years to Mickey’s adult life, while songs Jacy once performed preserve a sensory trace of her presence. When Delia sings with Mickey’s band, Teddy recognizes the sound as a bridge to the girl he loved, and the performance precipitates his collapse. Music therefore acts as more than nostalgia: it creates a meeting point between generations and lets an inherited resemblance become emotionally undeniable before the characters understand its cause.

About the Author

Richard Russo is an acclaimed American author known for his richly drawn characters and stories rooted in small-town life. He has written seven novels, two short story collections, and a memoir titled Elsewhere. Russo received the prestigious Pulitzer Prize in 2002 for his novel Empire Falls, which was later adapted into a celebrated HBO miniseries. His beloved novel Nobody's Fool was also brought to the screen as a successful film adaptation. Russo's work is celebrated for its wit, warmth, and deep empathy for working-class communities, cementing his place as one of America's most respected literary voices.

Download PDF

To save this Chances Are... summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.37 MB     Pages: 24

Download EPUB

To read this Chances Are... summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.42 MB     Pages: 32
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
600,000+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...