Key Takeaways
Judge public policy like an investor: count long-term returns, not just upfront costs.
Start with first principles. Joel Greenblatt applies an investor’s habit of testing assumptions and tracking incentives to public policy. Inspired by Thomas Paine’s challenge to inherited authority, he asks readers to examine institutions that persist through custom, even when their results disappoint. The book’s central question is how government and business can work together to widen opportunity while growing the economy.
Look beyond this year’s ledger. Greenblatt argues that policies should be assessed not only by their immediate price, but also by their effects on employment, poverty, education, and future public spending. He contrasts this perspective with accounting that records current outlays more readily than uncertain future benefits. His proposals are deliberately practical: change incentives, test alternatives, and focus on who gains or bears the risk.
The investor’s lens is useful because public decisions often distribute costs now and benefits later, while budgets make the costs easier to see. It also directs attention to incentives, not merely stated intentions. Yet social investments differ from securities: their returns are difficult to measure, unevenly distributed, and sometimes valuable even when they do not produce fiscal savings. A policy can improve dignity or fairness without paying for itself. Greenblatt’s framing is strongest as a prompt to examine tradeoffs, rather than as a claim that every public good must clear a financial return threshold.
Stop treating a child’s ZIP code as an educational destiny.
Opportunity begins at school. In most communities, a child’s address determines the public school available, while families with money can pay for private school or move to a better district. Greenblatt argues this makes unequal access structural, not simply the result of individual choices. He cites a stark urban outcome: only about one in eleven poor or minority students entering high school is likely to graduate college.
More spending has not guaranteed progress. Over fifty years, inflation-adjusted spending per pupil roughly doubled while national reading and math scores did not improve. A federal program that spent $7 billion trying to improve low-performing schools found no significant effect on measured student outcomes. These figures do not prove that every school reform fails, but they challenge the assumption that adding money or reorganizing schools automatically gives children a better education.
The ZIP-code argument highlights how public services can reproduce private advantage: housing markets bundle school access with wealth, making a nominally universal system unequal in practice. The spending figures are a valuable warning against treating inputs as outcomes. Still, broad test-score averages can conceal gains for particular students or skills, and a failed program does not show that all school investment is ineffective. A sound response needs both accountability for results and careful measurement of what schools can reasonably influence amid poverty, health, and family pressures.
Give families real choices, then scale schools that prove they teach.
Results can travel beyond affluent districts. Greenblatt helped launch Success Academy, a New York City charter network that accepted students through an open lottery. In 2019, more than 90 percent of its students passed state math and English tests, compared with fewer than 40 percent of similar students in district schools. The network served 18,000 students across 45 schools, most from disadvantaged backgrounds. Another example is P.S. 172, a low-income Brooklyn district school whose students with disabilities and English learners achieved unusually high test results under a long-serving principal.
Choice meets political resistance. Greenblatt argues that charter growth gives families an alternative when assigned schools fail, but that funding, control, and union rules create opposition. He favors supporting effective schools rather than rejecting them by category. His examples show promise, not a universal formula: good charter schools and exceptional district schools both matter.
The strongest point is that school quality should be judged by what students learn, not by whether a school fits a preferred institutional label. Lottery-based comparisons and the examples of students arriving from other schools make the results harder to dismiss as simple selection. However, exceptional schools may depend on leadership, staffing, or extra instructional time that cannot be reproduced everywhere. Choice also requires enough genuinely good seats and transparent admissions. The useful policy question is therefore not charter versus district, but how to identify, reproduce, and make accountable the practices that help students learn.
Let employers recognize demonstrated skill, not just a four-year pedigree.
Build another route to work. Greenblatt proposes alternative certification: tests, courses, or other credentials that let candidates demonstrate job-relevant knowledge and ability without relying solely on a traditional degree. Employers would publish which credentials they consider for particular jobs, while third parties provide preparation and assessment. The proposed system is meant to open a route for people whose schooling or finances made college difficult to complete.
A degree also signals persistence. The book discusses research suggesting that employers value credentials partly because finishing school signals conscientiousness and follow-through. A broad series of assessments could test skills more directly, but a single exam risks repeating the limits of the GED, which has not produced outcomes equivalent to a high school diploma. Greenblatt’s model therefore treats testing as one part of hiring, not a complete substitute for judgment.
This proposal addresses a real mismatch: employers use degrees as efficient screening devices, even when the degree’s subject matter is not central to the work. Skills-based hiring can widen access while making criteria more explicit. But a new credential system can become another gatekeeping market, especially if preparation is costly or tests reward familiarity with the format. Tests also capture only a slice of work: collaboration, reliability, and learning on the job are harder to measure. The design challenge is to validate credentials against actual performance and ensure candidates can prepare without substantial private resources.
Support low-paid work directly instead of pricing weaker skills out.
Raise take-home pay through work. The earned income tax credit, or EITC, supplements earnings for eligible workers, particularly those with children. Greenblatt argues for expanding it to support workers whose current productivity may not justify a higher employer-paid wage. In his example, the existing federal EITC cost $68 billion in 2018 and helped lift nearly six million children above the poverty line. He also notes that eligible workers can fail to claim the benefit and that complex rules create errors.
Make support simpler and more immediate. Greenblatt proposes paying an expanded credit through regular payroll rather than waiting until tax filing. His larger proposal would guarantee a minimum effective hourly income; his more targeted version would triple the existing program to about $200 billion. He estimates the latter’s net public cost below $50 billion after added tax revenue and reduced benefit spending, while acknowledging that long-term savings depend on estimates and outcomes.
A wage subsidy can support household income while preserving employers’ incentive to hire workers whose current skills command low wages. Payroll delivery also addresses a practical weakness of tax credits: a benefit received months later may not help with this week’s rent or childcare. The central complication is incidence. If subsidies become predictable, employers may capture some of their value through lower wages, and eligibility rules can create sharp phaseouts that affect additional work. Greenblatt’s cost estimates depend on behavioral and social savings that are uncertain, so the policy merits transparent evaluation as well as a clear income guarantee.
Treat skilled immigration as productive capacity, not a fixed job queue.
Talent can create more work. Greenblatt argues that skilled immigrants often complement domestic workers rather than simply displace them. He cites an estimate that every 100 skilled foreign-born workers are associated with 183 additional jobs for U.S.-born workers, and a National Academies estimate valuing the net fiscal contribution of a highly educated immigrant at about $1 million. Immigrants have also founded many major companies and startups.
Make entry responsive to employers. The book proposes retaining employer sponsorship while removing numerical caps for qualifying skilled workers. Under its example, an employer would pay a salary of at least $60,000 plus a 20 percent tax, and a worker employed for five years within six would qualify for permanent residency. The tax could support education and training for current residents. Greenblatt treats refugee and lower-skilled immigration as separate policy questions, not reasons to forgo skilled workers.
The complementary-worker argument is important: a growing firm can need specialized hires and additional local staff at the same time. Immigration policy can therefore affect the size of the economic pie, not only the division of existing jobs. But estimates of jobs created or lifetime fiscal contribution are averages, not guarantees for every region or occupation. The proposed employer tax may help fund adjustment, yet its level could also deter hiring or encourage firms to shift work elsewhere. Clear wage protections and monitoring matter if the aim is to attract talent without weakening standards for workers already in the country.
Make bank shareholders absorb more losses before taxpayers do.
Give banks a thicker cushion. Banks borrow heavily, so even modest losses can threaten their ability to meet obligations. Greenblatt notes that JPMorgan’s tangible common equity was about 7 percent of total assets at the end of 2018. Regulators had added capital rules, risk assessments, and bail-inable debt, which can be converted into equity during a failure. Yet critics argued that authorities might hesitate to impose losses on large-bank creditors during a crisis.
Change the financing, not only the rulebook. Greenblatt proposes raising bank equity to 20 to 30 percent of assets, partly through preferred stock. He would make bank preferred dividends tax-deductible for the bank and tax-free to investors, lowering the cost of raising this loss-absorbing capital. His aim is to reduce bailout risk and preserve lending. The proposal is a subsidy to bank investors, which he presents as a trade for lower taxpayer exposure and less need for restrictive regulation.
More equity reduces the leverage that turns ordinary loan losses into systemic danger. It also changes incentives: investors who stand to lose more have reason to scrutinize risk before a crisis, rather than relying on regulators to catch every bad decision. The counterpoint is that equity is not free, and a tax preference shifts costs elsewhere while potentially favoring financial institutions. Higher capital requirements can also affect lending prices and availability. The policy case depends on whether the proposed cushion reduces public risk enough to justify its fiscal cost and whether banks pass any financing benefits to borrowers.
Start retirement saving early, but automate choices people routinely mishandle.
Time magnifies small contributions. Greenblatt compares two investors earning 10 percent annually. One invests $2,000 each year from age 19 through 25, then stops; the other contributes the same amount each year from age 26 through 65. At 65, the early starter has about $930,641, compared with about $893,704 for the later investor. The point is not that these returns are guaranteed, but that early compounding gives savings more time to grow.
Make saving the default, not a test of discipline. Australia’s superannuation system requires employer contributions to employee retirement accounts. Greenblatt favors a U.S. supplement to Social Security, with automatic contributions, limited diversified investment choices, and support for lower earners. He warns against simply privatizing Social Security: in his account, self-managed investors underperformed automatically managed ones, even when following the same basic strategy.
Automatic enrollment responds to a well-established behavioral pattern: people often delay complex decisions, even when they intend to save. Defaults can turn a future intention into a present contribution, while diversified funds reduce the burden of individual stock picking. Yet the illustration’s 10 percent return is an assumption, not a promise, and private accounts expose workers to market volatility. A robust design must also protect people with low or interrupted earnings and preserve adequate support for current retirees. The central insight is not that markets solve retirement, but that institutions can make long-term saving easier to begin and harder to abandon.
Analysis
Common Sense is a policy argument built around one recurring question: what happens when incentives reward the wrong behavior? Greenblatt’s investor background gives the book a distinctive through-line. In schools, he asks whether funding and authority follow student outcomes. In hiring, he questions why a degree stands in for skills and persistence. In labor policy, he favors supplementing low wages over setting a wage floor that some workers may not yet earn. In immigration, he treats talent as a potential source of growth. In banking, he wants private investors to bear more of the downside. In retirement, he emphasizes early saving and systems that limit predictable mistakes.
The book’s strength is its insistence on testing institutional habits against real outcomes. It also makes proposals concrete enough to debate, including salary thresholds, contribution rates, and capital targets. Its investor analogy encourages attention to delayed effects that annual budgets can obscure.
The analogy has limits. Schools, safety nets, immigration, and retirement generate benefits that resist clean financial valuation, and estimates of future savings can be sensitive to assumptions. Evidence from successful schools or past programs does not automatically establish that a policy will scale nationally. Several proposals also rely on employers or investors responding as intended, although their incentives may differ from the public interest. The book is most persuasive when it identifies a failure, specifies a mechanism, and invites a test. It is less conclusive when modeled long-term benefits are treated as nearly certain. Its lasting contribution is a practical standard for reform: preserve what works, measure what happens, and do not confuse the familiar with the fair or effective.
Review Summary
Readers found Common Sense to be an engaging book, though not primarily about investing as some expected. It discusses social issues like education, immigration, and banking regulation, offering pragmatic solutions. Many appreciated Greenblatt's logical approach and data-driven ideas, particularly regarding charter schools and alternative certification. Some critics found it too US-centric or lacking depth. Overall, reviewers valued the thought-provoking content and Greenblatt's ability to explain complex concepts, despite disagreements with some proposals.
People Also Read
Glossary
roundabout
Alternative route to opportunityA strategy for pursuing a goal through a different path when the direct route is blocked or dominated by powerful competitors. Greenblatt borrows the term from an account of conifers thriving in less favorable terrain. In education, it means helping people reach good jobs through alternatives to the conventional school-to-college pathway.
alternative certification
Nondegree proof of abilityGreenblatt’s proposed system for recognizing job candidates through relevant tests, courses, programs, or other evidence of accomplishment, rather than relying only on a traditional diploma. Employers would identify which credentials they would consider for particular roles, while independent providers could develop instruction and assessments. The proposal treats credentials as one input to hiring, not as a complete measure of a person.
earned income tax credit
Tax credit for workersA U.S. tax credit that supplements earnings for qualifying workers, with benefits shaped by income and family circumstances. Greenblatt presents it as a way to increase the take-home pay of lower-paid workers while preserving the incentive to work. His proposal expands the credit and delivers support through payroll, rather than relying only on a payment after annual tax filing.
bail-inable debt
Debt convertible into equityCertain bank debt that regulators can convert into equity if a bank approaches failure. The conversion is intended to absorb losses and recapitalize the institution without relying immediately on public funds. Greenblatt notes that its effectiveness depends partly on whether authorities would actually impose creditor losses during a financial crisis, when doing so might intensify instability.
Total Loss Absorbing Capacity
Capital available for lossesA measure of a major bank’s capacity to absorb losses, drawing on equity and certain liabilities that can be converted or written down. Greenblatt uses the concept to compare a bank’s apparent equity cushion with a broader pool of resources available in distress. The measure matters because a bank’s reported equity alone may understate the capital regulators can use before taxpayers are exposed.
superannuation
Australia’s employer-funded retirement savingAustralia’s system of retirement accounts funded in large part by mandatory employer contributions. Employees can choose among professionally managed funds, and the accumulated savings can be invested in assets such as stocks, bonds, real estate, and infrastructure. Greenblatt presents superannuation as a model for getting workers to save early, while noting that Australia also provides a public Age Pension.
FAQ
What's "Common Sense: The Investor's Guide to Equality, Opportunity, and Growth" about?
- Author's Perspective: Joel Greenblatt, a professional investment manager, offers his insights on policies that could foster equality, opportunity, and growth in the U.S.
- Main Themes: The book discusses education reform, immigration, financial regulation, and retirement savings, proposing practical solutions to systemic issues.
- Unique Approach: Unlike typical policy books written by politicians or economists, Greenblatt provides a business and investment-oriented perspective.
- Goal: The book aims to address societal challenges by leveraging the strengths of government and the private sector to create a more equitable society.
Why should I read "Common Sense: The Investor's Guide to Equality, Opportunity, and Growth"?
- Practical Solutions: The book offers actionable ideas for improving education, immigration, and financial systems.
- Diverse Perspectives: Greenblatt's investment background provides a unique angle on public policy issues.
- Engaging Style: The author uses humor and relatable anecdotes to make complex topics accessible.
- Broader Understanding: Readers gain insights into how economic policies can impact equality and growth.
What are the key takeaways of "Common Sense: The Investor's Guide to Equality, Opportunity, and Growth"?
- Education Reform: Greenblatt emphasizes the need for school choice and charter schools to improve educational outcomes for low-income students.
- Immigration Benefits: The book highlights the economic advantages of skilled immigration and suggests reforms to attract talent.
- Financial Regulation: Greenblatt advocates for restructuring bank incentives to prevent future financial crises.
- Retirement Savings: The author proposes a system similar to Australia's superannuation to ensure better retirement outcomes for Americans.
How does Joel Greenblatt propose to reform education in the U.S.?
- School Choice: Greenblatt supports breaking the link between zip codes and school quality, advocating for vouchers and charter schools.
- Charter Schools: He highlights the success of charter networks like Success Academy in providing quality education to disadvantaged students.
- Systemic Challenges: The book discusses the difficulties in reforming public schools and the need for innovative solutions.
- High Expectations: Greenblatt stresses the importance of maintaining high expectations for all students, regardless of background.
What are Joel Greenblatt's views on immigration in "Common Sense"?
- Skilled Immigration: Greenblatt argues for policies that attract skilled immigrants, who contribute significantly to the economy.
- Economic Impact: He cites studies showing that skilled immigrants create jobs and drive innovation.
- Policy Recommendations: The book suggests simplifying the visa process and removing caps on skilled worker visas.
- Balancing Act: Greenblatt acknowledges the need to address unskilled immigration and refugee issues but emphasizes the immediate benefits of skilled immigration.
How does "Common Sense" address financial regulation and banking?
- Incentive Structures: Greenblatt proposes aligning bank incentives with long-term stability by increasing equity capital requirements.
- Preferred Stock Solution: He suggests using tax-advantaged preferred stock to strengthen banks' financial positions.
- Regulatory Balance: The book critiques excessive regulation and advocates for smarter, incentive-based approaches.
- Systemic Risk: Greenblatt emphasizes the importance of preventing "too big to fail" scenarios through better capital structures.
What retirement savings solutions does Joel Greenblatt offer in "Common Sense"?
- Superannuation Model: Greenblatt recommends adopting a system similar to Australia's, where employers contribute to individual retirement accounts.
- Social Security Supplement: He suggests supplementing Social Security with private savings plans to ensure adequate retirement income.
- Investment Choices: The book advocates for limited, diversified investment options to protect individuals from poor investment decisions.
- Early Savings: Emphasizing the power of compounding, Greenblatt encourages starting retirement savings early in one's career.
What are the best quotes from "Common Sense" and what do they mean?
- "A long habit of not thinking a thing wrong, gives it a superficial appearance of being right." This quote underscores the need to question entrenched systems and seek innovative solutions.
- "Doing the right thing." Greenblatt uses this phrase to describe expanding the earned income tax credit, highlighting its benefits for low-income workers.
- "Where did this King guy come from anyway?" This rhetorical question challenges the status quo and encourages rethinking outdated systems.
- "Investing is hard." The author acknowledges the challenges of investing, advocating for structured, disciplined approaches to retirement savings.
How does Joel Greenblatt suggest improving the earned income tax credit (EITC)?
- Expansion Proposal: Greenblatt proposes expanding the EITC to ensure all workers earn at least $15 an hour.
- Cost Efficiency: He argues that the long-term benefits of reducing poverty and increasing workforce participation outweigh the costs.
- Implementation Changes: The book suggests paying EITC benefits as part of regular payroll to improve accessibility and reduce fraud.
- Economic Impact: Greenblatt highlights the EITC's role in encouraging work and supporting low-income families.
What is Joel Greenblatt's stance on charter schools in "Common Sense"?
- Support for Charters: Greenblatt is a strong advocate for charter schools, citing their success in improving educational outcomes.
- Opposition Challenges: He addresses the political and union opposition to charters, arguing for their expansion based on performance.
- Replication and Sharing: The book emphasizes the importance of replicating successful charter models and sharing best practices with public schools.
- Parental Choice: Greenblatt believes that charters provide essential choices for parents in low-income areas, offering a path to better education.
How does "Common Sense" propose to address the challenges of globalization and technology?
- Education and Training: Greenblatt emphasizes the need for education and retraining to help workers adapt to technological changes.
- EITC Expansion: He suggests using the EITC to support workers displaced by globalization and automation.
- Long-Term Perspective: The book advocates for thinking like long-term investors, focusing on sustainable growth and workforce adaptation.
- Policy Balance: Greenblatt calls for policies that balance technological advancement with social responsibility and economic equity.
What unique perspectives does Joel Greenblatt bring to public policy in "Common Sense"?
- Investment Lens: Greenblatt applies investment principles to public policy, focusing on long-term returns and systemic efficiency.
- Business Experience: His background as an investment manager provides a practical, results-oriented approach to policy challenges.
- Innovative Solutions: The book offers creative, market-based solutions to complex societal issues, such as education and immigration.
- Common Sense Approach: Greenblatt emphasizes straightforward, logical solutions that prioritize equality, opportunity, and growth.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.