Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Community Building on the Web

Community Building on the Web

Secret Strategies for Successful Online Communities
Turn a small online gathering into a trusted community that members help shape and sustain.
by Amy Jo Kim 1999 380 pages
3.68
101 ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Key Takeaways

Build social scaffolding around needs members and owners both value

Start with a real need. A community is more than an audience gathered around content. It is a group with something meaningful in common, whose members can get to know one another over time. Kim calls the design that supports these relationships “Social Scaffolding”: the purposes, places, identities, roles, rules, events, rituals, and groups that help a community take shape.

Make the exchange clear. Members need a reason to return, while owners need a worthwhile return on their investment, whether that investment is money, time, or goodwill. GeoCities grew by helping inexperienced Internet users build home pages, meeting a practical need in a supportive setting. A planning exercise can reveal where member needs and owner goals overlap, and where they conflict.

Analysis

What's striking is the insistence that community value must be mutual, not merely measured by traffic or revenue. This resembles stakeholder design: the service lasts when its benefits are legible to participants as well as sponsors. The tension is real, though. A business goal such as maximizing page views can pull against members' desire for a small, trusting space. Naming that conflict early does not solve it, but it gives a team a basis for making deliberate tradeoffs instead of quietly redefining success around whichever metric is easiest to count.

Let a small community grow through feedback instead of grand launches

Begin with a nucleus. Kim’s approach favors a focused start over a fully built digital town. The WELL began with ten public discussion areas; GeoCities launched with six neighborhoods and a basic home-page tool. Both could expand as members revealed what they actually needed. This keeps empty spaces from making a young community feel abandoned and limits the cost of committing to features no one uses.

Keep the loop open. Growth should respond to changing needs. Gather conversational feedback through email, interviews, surveys, and discussions, then compare it with behavioral evidence such as attendance, posting, and time spent in different areas. Make changes visible to members, and gradually give them more influence over the community’s culture and operations.

Analysis

This is a practical form of iterative design, with an important social twist: feedback is not only a way to improve the product, it is a way to share ownership. The distinction between what people say and what they do is useful, but behavioral data can mislead. A crowded chat room may signal curiosity, not belonging; a quiet support group may still be valuable to its participants. Strong decisions combine counts with context, especially when the people most affected are not the loudest or most active users.

Give people places to talk, then organize them around how members think

Conversation makes community. A gathering place can be a mailing list, message board, chat room, game, or virtual world. The tool should fit the activity: email suits groups that already use it and conversations that unfold over time; message boards preserve context and archives; chat creates immediacy and works well for scheduled meetings. A steady stream of content alone does not let an audience form relationships.

Make the map intuitive. Organize those places using categories, geography, or familiar media structures, and choose a system members can navigate and extend. eBay’s product categories help buyers browse and sellers list items. AncientSites used historically named cities to help history enthusiasts find a place that matched their interests. A site map and search function become increasingly important as the community grows.

Analysis

The useful design question is not simply which tool has the most features, but which one makes the desired social behavior easy. This echoes the idea of affordances: a tool invites certain actions while making others awkward. A chat room encourages quick exchange but is a poor archive; a forum can preserve knowledge but feel slow during a live event. The book’s advice to choose structure from the member’s point of view remains sound, though a metaphor that feels welcoming to one audience can confuse another. Test the map with actual newcomers.

Make identity persistent enough for trust, but transparent enough to protect privacy

Give identity context. A profile records information about a member and their participation. Kim distinguishes the System Profile, the information the service tracks; the Personal Profile, what the member can see about themself; and the Public Profile, what other members can see. A persistent member name lets people recognize one another across visits and helps connect activity across message boards, chat, and other tools.

Earn the right to know. Profiles can include interests, contributions, group affiliations, and reputation. On eBay, members’ feedback about completed transactions helped buyers judge whom to trust. But registration should not demand unnecessary personal details, and members should know what is collected, what is public, and how information will be used. Trust depends on keeping privacy promises, not merely posting them.

Analysis

The profile is both a social tool and a concentration of power: it can help members assess one another, while enabling the platform to observe and classify them. That dual role makes consent and control essential, not decorative. Reputation scores can reduce uncertainty in transactions, but they compress complicated experiences into simple judgments and can be unfair when context is lost. The most defensible systems make identity useful without pretending it is complete, and let members understand and correct the information that shapes how others see them.

Guide members from curious visitor to contributor, leader, and culture keeper

Expect different needs. The Membership Life Cycle is Kim’s model for how participation changes as people become more involved. A visitor needs orientation; a novice needs instruction; a regular needs reasons to stay engaged; a leader needs authority and support; an elder can share knowledge and community history. These are roles people may move through, not fixed personality types.

Build the transitions. A visible welcome area can answer basic questions, show a site map, and explain how to participate. A welcome message, a newcomer discussion, or a practice space can help a novice learn without being embarrassed. The community should also offer experienced members meaningful ways to contribute. The goal is not to convert every visitor into a leader, but to make each level of participation understandable and worthwhile.

Analysis

This model is useful because it treats onboarding and retention as different design problems. A newcomer who cannot find the door needs something different from a veteran who feels there is nothing left to do. It also directs attention to knowledge transfer: experienced members can make tacit norms visible to newcomers. The sequence should not be mistaken for a universal ladder, however. Some people prefer to participate quietly, move between roles, or leave after finding what they need. A healthy community makes deeper involvement possible without treating it as the only successful outcome.

Give community leaders training, visible authority, and a clear chain of support

Treat leadership as a program. Leaders may greet newcomers, host discussions, answer questions, teach, coordinate events, or enforce standards. The Leadership Pyramid describes a range from enthusiastic regulars through volunteers and paid roles to full-time staff. The Leadership Ritual is the process of selecting, training, and welcoming official leaders. Leaders need clear duties, useful tools, a private place to consult one another, and a manager who can resolve problems beyond their authority.

Power needs preparation. When Ultima Online introduced volunteer Counselors with limited training, some used their new powers unfairly, damaging members’ trust. By contrast, Slashdot distributed temporary moderation duties to qualified members, allowing the site to spread editorial work as posting grew. Both examples point to the same requirement: screen carefully, explain expectations, and monitor how authority is used.

Analysis

The leadership design here anticipates a classic organizational problem: authority delegated without accountability becomes arbitrary, while responsibility without authority becomes frustrating. A clear escalation path helps leaders act consistently and know when to seek help. Member-led moderation can also increase legitimacy because decisions are not made solely by distant staff. Yet volunteer labor is not cost-free. It requires recognition, boundaries, and careful attention to whether unpaid roles are replacing work that ought to be paid. A stable program supports leaders as people, not merely as a cheap operating system.

Write rules for your culture, enforce them fairly, and revise them with member input

Make expectations explicit. The Etiquette Cycle is the ongoing process of creating community standards, enforcing them, and revising them as the community changes. Useful documents include a member agreement, behavioral guidelines, and a privacy policy. They should explain matters such as identity, acceptable conduct, content ownership, and how complaints are handled. A support group or youth area may need additional local rules.

Pair rules with tools. Ignore lists and private spaces can help members manage ordinary friction, but they cannot replace fair enforcement. CNN’s discussion standards emphasized focused, on-topic conversation; the WELL took a more permissive approach to debate. In either culture, members need to know what the rules mean in practice. Feedback from members and leaders can reveal unclear or outdated policies, while explanations of decisions help preserve trust.

Analysis

Rules do more than prevent disruption. They communicate what kind of disagreement a group can tolerate and whose safety matters. This connects to procedural fairness: people are more likely to accept an unpleasant decision when the process is clear and applied consistently. Member participation can improve rules, but consultation is not the same as a promise of majority rule. Owners and managers still carry responsibility for decisions. The important safeguard is honesty about who decides, what evidence matters, and how members can challenge mistakes.

Use recurring events to create habits, and rituals to give the group a memory

Schedule reasons to return. Events bring members together at a particular time and place. Kim groups them as meetings, such as support chats; performances, such as interviews or classes; and competitions, such as contests or tournaments. Planning, facilitation, and follow-up all matter: publish the schedule, assign trained hosts, prepare for disruption, and share transcripts or results afterward. Regular gatherings help members build relationships through repeated contact.

Let events fit the community. iVillage’s Community Challenge combined weekly meetings, expert guidance, and a longer shared project around a practical life change. It shows how formats can be mixed when that serves members’ needs. Events should not be added simply because the platform makes them easy. Watch attendance and listen to participants; a well-run gathering that members do not need is still wasted effort.

Analysis

Regular events create what behavioral researchers call temporal structure: people know when to show up and what kind of interaction to expect. Repetition lowers the social cost of returning, while a shared activity gives conversation a natural focus. The iVillage example is especially effective because participants work toward something together rather than merely consuming a guest appearance. Still, attendance alone is a weak measure of value. Sensitive groups may be small by design, and an event can matter deeply to those present without producing impressive numbers.

Mark personal milestones and shared holidays so online members feel recognized and connected

Recognition makes belonging visible. Rituals are repeated, meaningful actions that help members navigate transitions and remember what a community values. A welcome greeting, a birthday acknowledgment, a seasonal celebration, or a rite of passage can turn an ordinary interaction into a shared experience. Communities can also mark their own founding dates and invite members to contribute stories, traditions, or event ideas.

Make room for grief, too. When an Ultima Online player known as Sir Death died in a motorcycle accident, fellow players asked the game staff for a memorial. Staff created a grave marker and a dolphin named in his honor; players visited and left offerings. Such gestures showed that relationships formed in the game mattered. Personalization should still be tactful: unexpected use of private information can feel intrusive, so participation in some rituals should be optional.

Analysis

Rituals help groups carry memory across time, especially when members do not share a physical setting. A memorial or annual celebration gives people a common way to acknowledge loss, continuity, and change. The Sir Death story makes clear that a digital environment can hold emotionally serious relationships, not just casual interaction. But ritual has a boundary: recognition can become surveillance when the platform uses personal data without permission. The most respectful design offers a meaningful invitation, not an obligation, and lets members decide which parts of their lives belong in public.

Give member-run groups room to flourish without surrendering the community’s wider purpose

Subgroups restore intimacy. As a community grows, members with a shared interest may form clubs, committees, guilds, or support groups. These subgroups give people a smaller setting in which to build closer relationships, and can help the larger community adapt to interests its founders did not anticipate. Provide suitable gathering places, group profiles, communication tools, and support for leaders.

Choose the right amount of structure. Yahoo Clubs made group creation easy, producing many groups, including inactive or overlapping ones. AncientSites required at least five people to apply and reviewed proposed groups for fit and quality. The first approach encouraged rapid experimentation; the second favored focus and oversight. Whatever the policy, make expectations clear, recognize useful groups, and plan for dormant spaces. Groups can strengthen loyalty, but members may become more attached to a group than to the larger site.

Analysis

Subgroups solve a genuine scaling problem: people can retain the intimacy of a small circle inside a large network. They also function as experiments, revealing interests that a central team may not have predicted. The tradeoff is governance. Too much approval can suppress useful initiatives, while unrestricted creation can leave a directory crowded with empty rooms. The appropriate balance depends on the community’s purpose and capacity to moderate. Most importantly, group leaders need both autonomy and a route to raise problems, so local identity can grow without severing accountability to the broader community.

Analysis

Kim’s central contribution is to treat online community as a designed social environment rather than a software feature set. The book’s nine strategies connect individual experience to organizational structure: a stated purpose guides the choice of gathering places; profiles create context; roles and leadership distribute work; rules establish boundaries; and recurring events, rituals, and subgroups give members reasons to return. The design is strongest when these parts reinforce one another. A profile that records useful contributions, for instance, supports recognition; a recognition practice can encourage participation; participation can produce leaders who help newcomers.

The framework also contains an important theory of scale. Growth is not simply adding more users or content. It changes the social system: newcomers can overwhelm regulars, informal norms become harder to transmit, and member-created groups can compete with the central organization for loyalty. Kim’s answer is adaptive structure: begin narrowly, listen continuously, and transfer more responsibility to members as the community matures. That is a persuasive alternative to assuming that centralized management can plan every social outcome in advance.

The book is rooted in the Web of its era, so many named platforms and technical choices are historical rather than current recommendations. Its durable value lies elsewhere: identity, trust, moderation, participation, and social memory remain design problems even when the interface changes. Some claims also need a modern qualification. More persistent identity can support accountability, but anonymity may be crucial for vulnerable users. More activity does not necessarily mean stronger relationships, and increased member participation can become unpaid labor if organizations benefit without sharing power or resources.

The strongest practical reading is therefore not a universal blueprint, but a diagnostic method. Ask what need a community serves, what kinds of interaction that need requires, who performs the work, how members can influence decisions, and what happens when the group changes. The answers should shape the tools, policies, and rituals. The test of good community design is not whether every feature exists, but whether the social structure helps people find one another, participate safely, and recognize that their presence matters.

Summary in 30 Seconds
Strong online communities meet a real need shared by members and owners. Start small, then use member feedback and observed behavior to decide what to build next. Persistent identity supports trust, while clear privacy choices protect members. Newcomers need guidance, and leaders need training, authority, and support. Fair rules, recurring events, and member-run groups help relationships deepen as the community grows.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.68 out of 5
Average of 101 ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Community Building on the Web receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.67/5. Readers appreciate the book's principles and strategies for building online communities, finding them still relevant. However, many note that the examples and technologies discussed are outdated, limiting the book's current applicability. Some reviewers suggest that an updated version would be valuable. Despite its age, the book is still considered helpful for understanding the fundamentals of online community building, with its nine design strategies praised for their timeless nature.

Your rating:
4.21
193 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Glossary

Social Scaffolding

Structures supporting community life

Kim’s name for an architectural approach to community design. It brings together purpose, gathering places, member identity, roles, leadership, etiquette, events, rituals, and subgroups. These elements support relationships and can be adapted as a community grows, rather than treating community as a collection of independent technical features.

Membership Life Cycle

Stages of member involvement

A model describing changing levels of participation in a community. It follows people from visitors and new members through regular participation and leadership, while recognizing long-time members who preserve and share community knowledge. The model helps designers anticipate different needs, such as orientation for newcomers and meaningful responsibility for experienced members.

Leadership Pyramid

Levels of community leadership

A framework for thinking about the range of people who help operate a community, from enthusiastic participants to volunteers, contractors, and full-time staff. The roles differ in compensation, authority, and responsibility. The framework encourages community builders to plan how leadership work is staffed and supported as the organization expands.

Leadership Ritual

Process for preparing leaders

The sequence through which a community selects, trains, and welcomes official leaders. It can include screening applicants, teaching policies and skills, assigning a mentor, and publicly recognizing successful recruits. The process helps new leaders understand their responsibilities and makes their change in status visible to the wider community.

Etiquette Cycle

Create, enforce, revise rules

Kim’s model for maintaining community standards through three continuing activities: creating rules, enforcing them, and revising them as needs change. It treats policy as an ongoing part of community management. Written agreements and guidelines establish expectations, while member feedback and consistent enforcement help keep those expectations relevant and credible.

System Profile

Information tracked by the service

The full collection of information a community stores about a member. It may include account details, stated interests, preferences, activities, and participation history. The System Profile supports functions such as personalization and record keeping, but it also raises privacy questions about what is collected, who can see it, and how it is used.

Personal Profile

Member’s private account view

The view of profile information available to the member themself. It can include account details, preferences, personal data, and settings, some of which may also be visible to other people. It gives members a way to inspect or update their information and helps distinguish private records from information shared publicly.

Public Profile

Information visible to members

The information other people in the community can see about a member. Depending on the site, it may include interests, affiliations, contributions, awards, or reputation. Public profiles help members find one another and interpret participation, but should reveal only information the community has clearly explained and the member has agreed to share.

Great Good Place

Informal public gathering place

A term Kim draws from Ray Oldenburg for a welcoming, neutral place outside home and work where people can gather, relax, and talk. In an online community, a chat room, message board, or other public space can serve this function when members can find it easily and understand what happens there.

FAQ

What's Community Building on the Web about?

  • Focus on Online Communities: The book delves into the dynamics of creating successful online communities, emphasizing social interactions and shared purposes.
  • Timeless Social Dynamics: It highlights that both physical and virtual communities share similar social dynamics, crucial for fostering member relationships.
  • Practical Strategies: Amy Jo Kim provides practical strategies and design guidelines for building engaging and sustainable online environments.

Why should I read Community Building on the Web?

  • Expert Insights: Amy Jo Kim, with over a decade of experience, offers valuable insights for anyone interested in online community building.
  • Comprehensive Framework: The book provides a framework for understanding community dynamics, helping to avoid common pitfalls.
  • Real-World Examples: It includes case studies from successful online communities, illustrating practical applications of the concepts discussed.

What are the key takeaways of Community Building on the Web?

  • Nine Design Strategies: The book outlines strategies like defining purpose, creating member profiles, and promoting events.
  • Membership Life Cycle: It details the roles members play from visitors to elders and how to support their transitions.
  • Social Scaffolding: Emphasizes structures and support systems that help communities grow and thrive.

What is the Membership Life Cycle in Community Building on the Web?

  • Five Stages: The cycle includes Visitors, Novices, Regulars, Leaders, and Elders, each with distinct roles.
  • Role Evolution: Members transition through these stages, gaining responsibility and influence as they engage more.
  • Supportive Environment: Community builders should create environments that support these transitions, ensuring newcomers feel welcomed.

How does Community Building on the Web define a successful community?

  • Clear Purpose: A successful community serves a clear purpose that aligns with member needs and owner goals.
  • Engagement and Interaction: It fosters meaningful interactions, allowing members to build relationships and a sense of belonging.
  • Adaptability: Successful communities evolve to meet changing member needs and environmental shifts.

What are the nine design strategies outlined in Community Building on the Web?

  • Define Purpose: Clearly articulate the community's purpose to guide development and attract the right members.
  • Create Gathering Places: Build spaces where members can interact and engage with one another.
  • Develop Member Profiles: Encourage evolving profiles to build trust and facilitate connections.

What role do profiles play in Community Building on the Web?

  • Identity and Context: Profiles provide context about members, helping others understand their contributions.
  • Trust and Accountability: They foster trust by showing participation history, aiding in decision-making.
  • Dynamic Interaction: Profiles evolve over time, reflecting activities and achievements, enhancing engagement.

How can I welcome newcomers according to Community Building on the Web?

  • Membership Ritual: Implement rituals like welcome emails, gifts, and event invitations.
  • Guided Tours: Offer tours or special topics to help newcomers learn and feel comfortable.
  • Supportive Environment: Create an atmosphere where newcomers can ask questions and receive help.

What are the leadership roles discussed in Community Building on the Web?

  • Support Providers: Leaders who answer questions and solve problems for members.
  • Hosts and Greeters: Facilitate activities and welcome newcomers, aiding integration.
  • Event Coordinators: Plan and manage events to keep the community engaged.

How does Community Building on the Web suggest managing leaders?

  • Selection and Training: Establish processes for selecting and training leaders to understand their roles.
  • Visibility and Accessibility: Make leaders visible and accessible, reinforcing their roles as guides.
  • Feedback and Support: Maintain communication with leaders, providing support for their responsibilities.

What are the best quotes from Community Building on the Web and what do they mean?

  • "You can't actually create close-knit groups...": Emphasizes creating environments for natural relationships to develop.
  • "Tools, not rules.": Highlights providing tools for interaction management over strict rules.
  • "Every meaningful transition has the potential to be ritualized.": Suggests celebrating significant events to reinforce bonds.

How can community builders ensure their communities evolve effectively?

  • Feedback Mechanisms: Implement feedback loops to understand member needs and adapt strategies.
  • Monitoring Engagement: Track engagement to identify trends and areas for improvement.
  • Flexibility in Policies: Be open to changing guidelines based on feedback to maintain relevance.

About the Author

Amy Jo Kim is a respected author and expert in the field of online community building. Her book, "Community Building on the Web," published over 20 years ago, has become a seminal work in the industry. Kim's approach focuses on nine design strategies for creating successful and sustainable online communities. These strategies emphasize the importance of clear purpose, flexible gathering spaces, meaningful member profiles, and strong leadership. Kim's insights have influenced the development of many online platforms and social media communities. While some of her examples may be outdated, her core principles continue to be relevant in the ever-evolving digital landscape. Kim's work has helped shape the way businesses and organizations approach community building in the online space.

Download PDF

To save this Community Building on the Web summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.43 MB     Pages: 21

Download EPUB

To read this Community Building on the Web summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.47 MB     Pages: 25
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...