Key Takeaways
Power attracts some of the people least fit to wield it
The wrong people volunteer. On the Batavia shipwreck’s island, officer Jeronimus Cornelisz used his rank to organize killings. On ‘Ata, six stranded Tongan teenagers shared work and survived without appointing a leader. The contrast raises a question deeper than whether power changes people: who is drawn to positions of control in the first place?
Selection changes the story. In a 1971 prison experiment, some student guards abused their peers, a result often taken as proof that authority turns ordinary people cruel. A later study found that responding to an advertisement mentioning prison was associated with higher scores for aggression, dominance, and narcissism. The experiment may have selected unusually authoritarian participants rather than revealing what any ordinary person would do.
What's striking is how a recruitment funnel can quietly determine who gets studied, hired, or promoted before formal authority enters the picture. This resembles selection effects in labor markets: the people who choose a role are not a neutral sample of everyone capable of doing it. That does not prove that power is harmless, or that every candidate who seeks it is dangerous. It does mean institutions should ask what their opportunities attract, not only how officeholders behave once installed.
Keep hierarchy, but build in ways to stop anyone becoming untouchable
Equality required enforcement. For much of human history, small hunter-gatherer groups kept formal authority limited. Among the !Kung, people mocked successful hunters and rotated ownership of arrowheads, spreading credit for a kill so no hunter could easily turn achievement into rank. These practices helped restrain would-be dominators, though they did not eliminate conflict or violence.
Scale changed the bargain. Farming, population growth, and warfare helped create larger, more organized societies. Ranged weapons also made it easier for a group to challenge a physically dominant individual. As societies expanded, however, armies and large-scale cooperation favored formal leaders. Modern states can be highly hierarchical and comparatively safe. Hierarchy is therefore neither inherently just nor inherently cruel. It coordinates people at scale, but needs limits that prevent coordination from becoming domination.
The historical account usefully resists the fantasy that a flat society can simply be enlarged without cost. Large institutions need coordination, and coordination creates authority. The important distinction is between authority that helps people act together and authority that escapes challenge. The evidence about prehistoric egalitarianism is incomplete, and equality within a band did not necessarily mean equality for everyone. The practical question is not how to abolish hierarchy, but how to make power answerable to those who bear its consequences.
Choose leaders by evidence, not the face your instincts trust
Appearance masquerades as ability. In a Swiss experiment, children chose between faces of candidates who had competed in French elections. They picked the actual winner about 71 percent of the time, despite knowing nothing about the candidates. Other research discussed in the book finds that height, masculine appearance, and familiarity can make people seem more leader-like, even when those traits do not establish competence.
Bias shapes the field. In the book's snapshot of Fortune 500 companies, white men made up about 30 percent of the US population but 86 percent of the CEOs. A study of faculty hiring found that identical applications received better evaluations and higher proposed salaries when assigned male names. These patterns reflect barriers and learned prejudice as well as quick judgments about faces. They can also discourage capable people from applying.
Fast social judgments are useful when people must make decisions with little information, but leadership selection is exactly where those shortcuts can become costly. A face-based guess may predict whom a group already tends to favor, not who will make a sound decision. The distinction matters: predictive accuracy can reproduce an existing bias without validating it. Structured evaluation, anonymous review where practical, and diverse selection panels can shift attention from resemblance and confidence toward demonstrated judgment.
Change the rules around power, not just the people holding it
Context changes conduct. In a study of United Nations diplomats' parking, representatives from countries with very different corruption records behaved differently when enforcement was weak. After New York began taking diplomatic plates from repeat offenders, unpaid tickets by diplomats from high-violation countries fell sharply. The same people, in a changed system, behaved differently.
One ruler, two outcomes. Belgium's King Leopold II supported public reforms at home, yet oversaw murderous exploitation in the Congo, where he faced far less accountability. The contrast suggests that institutions can restrain or unleash the same person's worst impulses. Culture matters, too: research comparing Italian bank employees found that some workers' conduct shifted when they moved between regions with different workplace norms. Neither character nor context alone explains every abuse.
The systems argument moves attention from moral diagnosis to institutional design. Rules alter both incentives and expectations: people may follow a norm because they value it, because others do, or because consequences are credible. Those mechanisms can reinforce each other. But context is not an excuse that dissolves responsibility. The strongest account treats people and systems as interacting causes, then asks which lever can be changed before harm becomes routine.
Don't confuse power's effects with the misconduct power exposes
Four distortions complicate judgment. People in office may face morally impossible choices, as Thai prime minister Abhisit Vejjajiva did when deadly protests threatened to escalate. They may also become more effective at wrongdoing through practice, gain more opportunities to harm others, or attract more scrutiny than ordinary people. Each can make power appear more corrupting than it is, or conceal how bad conduct developed.
The distinction matters. Eric Allison, a career thief, said his intent did not change as he became more successful; he learned to steal more effectively. Conversely, officials with authority can cause greater harm simply because more people depend on their decisions. These explanations do not excuse abuse. They warn against treating visible misconduct as a simple measure of character or assuming that every worsening outcome began when someone gained power.
This is a valuable correction to the habit of inferring character directly from outcomes. A leader's record is shaped by opportunity, visibility, constraints, and learning, not just virtue. The same caution applies in reverse: difficult circumstances can explain a decision without making it defensible. Separating explanation from exoneration helps accountability become more precise. It also encourages comparison with relevant alternatives, rather than judging an officeholder against an imaginary world in which every choice is clean.
Limit unchecked authority before it shrinks empathy and inflates risk
Power can change behavior. In a dictator-game experiment, participants given greater control over others were more likely to keep money for themselves. The chance of choosing the selfish option rose from 39 percent in the low-power condition to 78 percent in the high-power condition. Other research links power with greater risk-taking, less attention to others' distress, and a sense that ordinary rules apply less strongly.
Control also affects health. The Whitehall II study followed British civil servants and found that lower rank was associated with higher mortality. Researcher Michael Marmot argued that high demands are especially damaging when people have little control over their work. Studies of baboons and corporate executives suggest that the highest position can also bring stress, particularly when power is insecure. Authority can benefit its holder, but it is not a reliable shield against strain.
The behavioral findings offer a plausible mechanism: authority reduces dependence on other people's reactions, while increasing the ability to act without immediate consequences. That combination can weaken feedback, not just empathy. Still, laboratory power games are not equivalent to governing a country, and much psychology research relies on narrow participant samples. The useful conclusion is not that every powerful person becomes selfish, but that concentrated authority needs safeguards against predictable shifts in attention and risk tolerance.
Recruit beyond the ambitious, then screen for how candidates treat others
A narrow pool invites bad hires. In Stebbins, Alaska, a remote village struggled to recruit police officers and hired people with serious criminal records. One applicant with multiple convictions reportedly became an officer within hours. When few qualified people apply, formal standards can be waived and the least suitable candidates can inherit authority by default.
Change who sees themselves applying. New Zealand's police recruitment campaign showed officers helping people and responding to community needs, rather than presenting the job as combat. Applications rose 24 percent, with increases among women and Maori applicants. The book recommends broadening and deepening the applicant pool, actively approaching candidates who may not seek power, and screening for conduct and motives. Recruitment language, job design, and field assessments all influence who enters the process.
Recruitment is a form of institutional self-selection: a job's public image tells potential applicants what kind of person is welcome. A force that advertises aggression may repel precisely the candidates it needs, while a service-oriented message can widen the pool. Representation alone does not guarantee ethical conduct, and a polished campaign cannot replace careful vetting. The stronger approach combines an inviting role definition with evidence about how applicants actually behave under pressure.
Use random oversight and rotation to break closed circles of abuse
Randomness can dilute capture. Ancient Athenians used a device called a kleroterion to select citizens for public duties by lot. A modern version could place randomly selected citizens on advisory assemblies or organizational shadow boards. Such groups would not replace elected leaders or specialists, but could make their decisions answerable to people who are not competing for the same office.
Rotation disrupts collusion. Police official Helen King found that a tightly connected drug team was stealing seized drugs and selling them back. Moving staff between roles makes long-running schemes harder to conceal. In experiments, bribery fell when participants were paired with changing partners rather than repeatedly working with the same person: from 32 to 13 percent in Germany, and from 41 to 19 percent in China.
Random selection and rotation address different weaknesses. Sortition reduces the advantage of people who aggressively pursue oversight roles; rotation interrupts trust networks that can enable collusion. Neither should displace expertise or continuity where these are essential. Randomly selected reviewers need access to evidence, time to deliberate, and a route for their findings to matter. Otherwise randomness becomes ceremony, and the powerful retain control over the information that would challenge them.
Make decision-makers encounter the people their choices affect
Distance makes harm easier. Social psychologist Yaacov Trope's framework describes psychological distance through social, temporal, spatial, and experiential separation. Harm can feel abstract when victims are unfamiliar, far away, affected much later, or known only through reports. That distance can make decisions easier to execute while blunting concern about their human cost.
Bring consequences into view. Lawyer Ken Feinberg met personally with hundreds of families seeking compensation after the September 11 attacks. Listening to individual stories made the people affected by his calculations concrete. By contrast, legal adviser John Yoo described torture policy in detached terms and said the decisions had not kept him awake. The book argues for reminders of responsibility and direct contact with affected people, while recognizing that emotion can also distort judgment.
Personal encounters can interrupt the abstraction that turns people into costs, cases, or distant populations. This connects to a broader principle of moral psychology: vivid individuals often command attention that statistics do not. That is both a strength and a risk. Leaders may overreact to a compelling story while overlooking less visible victims. Human contact works best when paired with consistent rules, so empathy informs judgment without making outcomes depend on who tells the most affecting story.
Watch the powerful more than the people they control
Oversight should follow the capacity for harm. Offices often monitor ordinary workers closely while executives and boards remain comparatively opaque. Yet the book estimates that white-collar crime causes far greater financial damage than street property crime, and that corporate harms contribute to many preventable deaths. Monitoring should focus on decision-makers whose choices affect large numbers of people, rather than subjecting everyone to constant surveillance.
Make scrutiny unpredictable. New York police used integrity tests that gave officers opportunities to steal planted cash or misuse drugs. Random tests made officers believe they might be watched during ordinary duties, while avoiding permanent surveillance of the whole force. Journalism can play a similar role. Reporting on stolen school funds in Uganda helped reduce the share of money diverted, especially where people could read the coverage.
The proposal reverses the familiar institutional gaze. Monitoring low-level workers is easy to administer, but can create a culture of suspicion while leaving consequential decisions unexamined. Targeted, unpredictable audits can make accountability credible without normalizing surveillance of everyone. The boundary matters: monitoring needs clear limits, due process, and independent review, or anti-corruption tools can become tools of control. Oversight must itself be overseen.
Judge leaders by their decisions, not lucky outcomes or polished stories
Results can flatter bad judgment. The Minnesota Twins struggled under manager Tom Kelly before winning the 1991 World Series. Their earlier record looked poor, but Kelly was rebuilding with a limited payroll. A decision judged only by its immediate result might have cost the team the manager who helped produce its later success. The reverse also occurs: leaders can take credit for favorable outcomes they did not cause.
Audit the reasoning. Review how decisions were made, what evidence was available, and whether warnings were ignored, not just whether the outcome was good. The Challenger shuttle's safe launches had not made damaged O-rings harmless; scrutiny of successful flights might have exposed the danger sooner. The book's final lesson is institutional: do not wait for a rare, reluctant savior. Build systems that recruit decent leaders, constrain abuse, and learn from both failures and apparent successes.
Outcome bias is especially dangerous in leadership because luck can imitate skill, while a sound decision can still end badly in a complex world. Process audits preserve information that a win-loss record erases. They also make it harder for leaders to rewrite their own history. Yet process review should not become hindsight prosecution: evaluators must distinguish what was knowable at the time from what became obvious afterward. Accountability is strongest when it rewards good judgment, not merely good fortune.
Analysis
The book's central contribution is to replace a one-line theory of power with a sequence of linked filters. First, some people are more drawn to authority than others. Then institutions and selection procedures determine which applicants advance. Human biases can favor familiar appearances, confidence, or aggression over competence. The rules and norms surrounding office shape behavior, while power itself can reduce empathy and encourage risk-taking. Finally, oversight determines whether abuses are detected, punished, or learned from. This layered account explains why replacing a single leader rarely solves a recurring problem.
Its most useful methodological lesson is to ask what evidence is missing. Abraham Wald's aircraft analysis illustrates survivorship bias: examining only planes that returned would have misidentified where armor was needed. The same logic applies to leadership. Failed candidates, deterred applicants, unreported abuses, and unexamined decisions are part of the causal story, not background noise. The book also distinguishes causes that are often collapsed together: power may corrupt, attract the corruptible, magnify opportunity, or make misconduct more visible. These mechanisms call for different remedies.
The account is strongest when it connects personal incentives to institutional design. Recruitment, random oversight, rotation, process audits, and human contact are concrete interventions, not appeals to virtue alone. Its evidence is less decisive when broad evolutionary claims are used to explain modern preferences, or when findings from small laboratory studies are generalized to political leadership. Some causal claims remain contested, and a few proposed tools carry their own risks, especially surveillance and psychological screening.
The practical conclusion is not that good people are powerless or that all authority is corrupt. It is that ethical leadership should not depend on exceptional character. Institutions can widen access, reduce opportunities for collusion, expose decision-makers to consequences, and judge choices in context. That shifts the burden from hoping for a Cincinnatus to designing power so that ordinary decency has a chance to survive it.
Review Summary
Corruptible receives mostly positive reviews for its exploration of power and corruption. Readers praise Klaas's engaging writing style, extensive research, and balanced approach. The book examines whether power corrupts or corrupt people seek power, offering insights into leadership selection and systemic reforms. Some criticize the overload of information and anecdotes, while others appreciate the practical solutions proposed. Reviewers highlight the book's relevance to current political climates and its potential to change readers' perspectives on power dynamics in society.
People Also Read
Glossary
Survivorship bias
Learning from survivors onlyA distortion that occurs when analysis includes only cases that remain visible or succeed, while excluding those that failed or disappeared. Abraham Wald showed that bullet holes on returning planes identified damage they could survive, not necessarily the planes' most vulnerable areas. The missing aircraft were essential evidence.
Self-selection bias
People choose themselves into rolesA distortion that arises when people who volunteer for or pursue a role differ systematically from those who do not. If aggressive or dominance-seeking people are especially attracted to a position, its eventual occupants will not represent the general population. Recruitment design can change who enters that pool.
Reverse dominance hierarchy
A group restrains would-be rulersAnthropologist Christopher Boehm's term for a social arrangement in which group members collectively prevent any individual from establishing lasting dominance. Hunter-gatherer practices such as ridicule, sharing credit, ostracism, and, in extreme cases, force could pull an aspiring strongman back toward equality.
Dark triad
Three manipulative personality traitsA cluster of three personality traits: Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy. Machiavellianism involves strategic manipulation and moral indifference; narcissism involves self-importance and a need for recognition; psychopathy is associated with low spontaneous empathy, impulsivity, and aggression. Each trait exists by degree, and their combination can aid manipulation.
Rice theory
Farming shapes cooperative normsA theory that long histories of rice cultivation encouraged more interdependent social habits than wheat cultivation, which requires less coordination. Research described in the book found regional differences in Chinese social behavior and thinking that tracked rice and wheat histories. The theory offers a cultural explanation, not a claim that agriculture determines individual character.
Dirty hands problem
Choosing among morally harmful optionsA political and ethical dilemma in which leaders may have to choose between options that all carry serious moral costs. A leader might authorize harm to prevent a larger catastrophe, yet remain responsible for the harm authorized. The concept explains why decisions in office can look worse without proving that the decision-maker became more corrupt.
Sortition
Selecting people by lotteryThe selection of public participants by chance rather than election, appointment, or competition. Ancient Athens used a machine called a kleroterion to assign citizens to civic duties. Modern proposals use randomly selected assemblies or shadow boards to advise officials and provide oversight, while leaving specialized or elected roles intact.
Psychological distance
How remote harm feelsThe felt separation between a decision-maker and the people affected by a decision. The book describes four dimensions: social distance, or how unfamiliar the people are; temporal distance, or how long before effects occur; spatial distance, or physical separation; and experiential distance, or whether harm is imagined rather than witnessed.
Status Syndrome
Health tracks social controlMichael Marmot's term for the relationship between social position and health outcomes identified in the Whitehall II study of British civil servants. Lower rank was associated with higher mortality, while the combination of high demands and low control was especially damaging. The findings suggest that control over work matters alongside stress and income.
Power Approach and Inhibition Theory
Power changes approach and cautionA theory developed by Dacher Keltner, Deborah Gruenfeld, and Cameron Anderson about how power shifts behavior. People with greater power tend to act more readily, pursue rewards, take risks, and promote themselves. People with less power tend to be more cautious, reactive, and attentive to threats. The theory helps explain why power can alter judgment and empathy.
FAQ
What's Corruptible about?
- Exploration of Power Dynamics: Corruptible by Brian Klaas examines how power affects individuals and societies, questioning whether power corrupts or if corrupt individuals are drawn to power.
- Historical and Contemporary Examples: The book uses stories like Jeronimus Cornelisz from the Batavia and the Tongan boys on ‘Ata to illustrate contrasting human behaviors in power and survival situations.
- Four Main Questions: Klaas seeks to answer whether worse people get power, if power makes people worse, why unfit people control us, and how to ensure incorruptible individuals wield power justly.
Why should I read Corruptible?
- Insightful Analysis: The book challenges the notion that "power corrupts," encouraging readers to reflect on authority and morality.
- Real-World Relevance: With examples from various countries and historical contexts, it is timely for those interested in governance and ethics.
- Engaging Storytelling: Klaas combines rigorous research with storytelling, making complex ideas accessible and thought-provoking.
What are the key takeaways of Corruptible?
- Power Attracts Certain Individuals: Power often attracts those who are corruptible, challenging the idea that power itself is the root of moral decay.
- Importance of Systems: Systems significantly influence behavior; good systems promote ethical leadership, while bad systems enable corruption.
- Human Nature and Hierarchies: Understanding ingrained social hierarchies can help reform systems for better outcomes.
What are the best quotes from Corruptible and what do they mean?
- “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”: This quote encapsulates the exploration of power and morality, serving as a starting point for Klaas's investigation.
- “The real Lord of the Flies is a tale of friendship and loyalty.”: It suggests that cooperation can lead to positive outcomes, even in dire circumstances.
- “Hierarchy is like fire. It can be used to cook food or to burn people.”: This metaphor highlights the dual nature of power structures, emphasizing the importance of context in evaluating leadership.
How does Corruptible define corruptibility?
- Corruptibility as a Trait: It is the susceptibility to engage in unethical behavior when given power, manifesting in various ways.
- Influence of Environment: Corruptibility is influenced by the environment and systems, meaning even well-intentioned people can become corruptible.
- Psychological Insights: Traits like narcissism and Machiavellianism can predispose individuals to seek power and act unethically.
How does Corruptible address the question of whether power makes people worse?
- Power as a Magnet: Klaas argues that power attracts those predisposed to unethical behavior, rather than transforming good people into bad ones.
- Psychological Research: Studies show individuals with dark triad traits are more likely to pursue power, suggesting the problem lies with individuals.
- Context Matters: The context in which power is exercised plays a crucial role in determining ethical or unethical actions.
What role do systems play in shaping behavior according to Corruptible?
- Systems Influence Actions: Systems and structures significantly shape behavior; supportive systems encourage ethical behavior, while corrupt systems enable unethical actions.
- Examples of Effective Systems: Klaas provides examples of successful systems promoting accountability and ethical leadership.
- Reforming Systems: He advocates for reforms that create environments attracting incorruptible individuals to power, including checks and balances and transparency.
How does Corruptible explore the nature of hierarchies?
- Hierarchies as Inherent: Hierarchies are a natural part of human social structures, rooted in evolutionary history.
- Positive and Negative Aspects: Effective hierarchies facilitate cooperation, while dysfunctional ones lead to abuse and corruption.
- Reforming Hierarchies: Understanding hierarchies is essential for reform, promoting inclusive leadership to reduce power risks.
What psychological insights does Corruptible provide about corruptible individuals?
- Personality Traits: Traits like narcissism and Machiavellianism are linked to a higher likelihood of seeking power and unethical behavior.
- Empathy Deficits: Individuals with dark triad traits often lack empathy, leading to harmful decision-making.
- Learning to be Bad: Corruptible individuals learn to exploit systems, becoming effective at manipulating others and maintaining power.
How can we ensure that incorruptible people get into power according to Corruptible?
- Recruitment Strategies: Implement recruitment strategies prioritizing integrity, using blind processes and diverse panels.
- Creating Accountability: Establish systems of accountability and transparency to deter corruptible individuals from seeking authority.
- Cultural Change: Foster a culture valuing ethical leadership, promoting environments that attract incorruptible leaders.
What methods does Klaas suggest to reduce corruption in Corruptible?
- Better Recruitment Practices: Actively recruit incorruptible individuals, using psychological evaluations and diverse hiring panels.
- Sortition for Oversight: Use random selection to create citizen assemblies for oversight and advice to officials.
- Randomized Integrity Tests: Implement tests for authority figures to deter corrupt behavior by creating a culture of accountability.
How does Corruptible relate to historical examples of power?
- Cincinnatus as a Model: Cincinnatus is used as a model for principled leadership, prioritizing the common good over personal ambition.
- Madoff’s Ponzi Scheme: Bernie Madoff's case highlights the dangers of unchecked power and the importance of oversight.
- Rajneesh Movement: The movement illustrates how power can lead to extreme corruption and abuse, serving as a cautionary tale.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.