Key Takeaways
Train analysis, imagination, and judgment as one practical thinking system.
Three mental operations. Adair describes effective thinking as a blend of analysing, synthesising, and valuing. Analysis breaks a situation into parts and tests relationships. Synthesis combines elements into a new whole, often using imagination to see possibilities that are not yet real. Valuing judges what matters, what is acceptable, and what counts as success. A logic puzzle calls heavily on analysis; designing a new service needs synthesis; choosing between options also requires judgment. The hospital manager who wanted to dismiss doctors over 55 after receiving a handful of complaints shows what happens when evidence is analysed poorly and alternatives are not weighed.
Build the weaker skill. People often favour one mode, but real decisions need all three. Adair argues that solitary thought and discussion with others can reveal different blind spots.
The model is useful because it treats thinking as more than logical calculation. Contemporary decision science similarly distinguishes generating possibilities from evaluating them, while judgment depends on both evidence and values. A team with varied strengths can compensate for individual blind spots, but only if members can question one another without penalty. The framework is less a diagnostic instrument than a reminder: a person may be excellent at dissecting evidence yet poor at imagining alternatives, or imaginative but careless about feasibility. Its practical value lies in asking which mental operation is missing, rather than branding someone simply smart or uncreative.
Let difficult choices incubate, then test the intuition that emerges.
The Depth Mind. Adair uses this term for unconscious or subconscious mental work that continues while attention is elsewhere. He presents it as a resource for combining memories, analysing a problem, and forming an intuitive judgment. Hotelier Conrad Hilton recalled raising a bid for a Chicago hotel from $165,000 to $180,000 after waking with a persistent sense that his first figure was too low. The nearest competing bid was $179,000. The book also describes a 2006 University of Amsterdam experiment in which participants distracted by puzzles made better choices among cars than participants who consciously deliberated.
Prepare, pause, assess. The point is not to trust every hunch. First supply the mind with relevant facts, then take a break when practical, and finally check the result against evidence and consequences.
Incubation offers a valuable alternative to endless conscious rumination. In cognitive science, solutions can benefit from a pause when the problem has been adequately understood and competing details are crowding working memory. But the metaphor of a helpful inner processor should not turn intuition into an authority. A hunch may reflect accumulated expertise, or an unexamined bias. The car experiment, as summarized here, supports a possibility, not a universal rule that distraction beats deliberate thought. The strongest practice is therefore a two-part one: let less conscious processing contribute, then make its conclusion answerable to explicit criteria.
Use a decision process to manage uncertainty, not pretend to eliminate it.
A repeatable sequence. Adair's five-step approach moves from clarifying the objective to gathering relevant information, developing feasible options, choosing, and implementing and evaluating the result. The sequence is a guide, not a rigid march: thought may circle back when new facts appear. More data is not automatically better. The book notes that useful information tends to arrive quickly at first, then additional research yields smaller gains while consuming more time.
Judge the process and outcome. Before choosing, consider risks, foreseeable consequences, and possible knock-on effects that cannot be predicted with confidence. Identify the Point of No Return, the stage when reversing course becomes more costly than continuing. Adair distinguishes a wrong decision, which can follow a sound process but turn out badly, from a bad decision made by ignoring available warnings. Evaluate implementation so experience can improve the next choice.
This framework resembles decision theory's separation of process quality from outcome quality. A good process cannot control luck, but it can make assumptions visible and reduce avoidable errors. The distinction matters because people often judge a decision solely by how it ended, encouraging hindsight bias and timid choices. The information plateau is also a useful guard against analysis that becomes a socially acceptable form of delay. Still, a checklist cannot determine how much evidence is enough in every context. Reversibility, deadlines, and the cost of error should shape how much investigation a decision deserves.
Create several workable options before narrowing the choice.
Escape the false binary. Adair warns that decision makers often frame a choice as either one course or another before exploring what else might work. The lobster pot model is his image for filtering a broad set of possibilities down to a small number of feasible options and then to a final choice. Alfred Sloan, the General Motors president, reportedly sent meetings back to generate more options when only two had been presented.
Filter before selecting. Feasibility matters: an attractive idea that cannot meet the objective or available constraints is not a real option. Elimination can be easier than proving one option best, so first remove choices that fail essential requirements. Then compare the survivors against priorities such as cost, risk, and likely results. A wider initial search helps prevent the first plausible answer from quietly becoming the only answer.
Generating alternatives reduces framing effects: when people see only two options, they tend to debate which is less bad instead of asking whether the choice itself is incomplete. The method also separates divergent thinking, which expands possibilities, from convergent thinking, which filters them. This separation is valuable in teams, where premature criticism can close discussion before unusual proposals appear. Yet option generation has a cost. Under severe time pressure, or when further options are unlikely to change the outcome, continued brainstorming can become avoidance. The practical test is whether another option could materially improve the decision.
Separate chosen-path obstacles from system faults, then trace causes.
Two kinds of problems. An obstacle is a difficulty encountered on a path someone has chosen. A climber who decides to summit a mountain may face a storm; changing the objective can remove that particular problem. A systems problem is different: something is performing below its expected norm, such as a process producing defective goods. Adair's bridge model gives decision making and problem solving a shared structure: define the issue, develop workable options, and select a course.
Find the point of deviation. For systems problems, ask who, what, where, when, why, and how to locate when normal performance changed. At Plastec, cracked containers were traced to both a new supplier and inadequately cleaned storage vats. The combined causes contaminated the plastic. Correcting the process stopped the recurring fault. Treating only the visible symptom would have left the system vulnerable.
The distinction prevents a common diagnostic mistake: treating every difficulty as a technical defect when the real issue may be the goal, plan, or assumptions behind it. The systems approach also aligns with root-cause analysis, where investigators map how conditions combine rather than searching for one culprit. Plastec's example makes that point concrete: neither change alone explained the failure as well as their interaction. In complex organizations, however, causes can be distributed across incentives, handoffs, and policy. The W5H questions help locate evidence, but they need patient investigation and a willingness to revise the initial problem definition.
Lead by balancing the task, the team, and each person's needs.
Three overlapping needs. Adair's three-circle model describes the demands present in any working group: accomplish the shared task, maintain the team, and attend to individuals. These needs affect one another. A team that cannot cooperate will struggle to deliver; a team that delivers while disregarding its members may erode commitment and cohesion.
Share decisions with judgment. Involving people can improve a decision and make implementation more motivating, but participation takes time and gives the leader less control over the result. The appropriate level depends on urgency and the team's relevant knowledge. At Fort Dunlop, after a takeover, managers asked employees for cost-saving ideas. A junior worker's suggestion to switch off every other factory light saved the company £100,000 a year. The example shows why listening should not be reserved for formal decision meetings.
The model is a compact form of stakeholder thinking. It counters the tendency to treat people as instruments for task completion, while also resisting the opposite error of making harmony the only measure of leadership. The Fort Dunlop case illustrates distributed knowledge: workers closest to a routine process may notice waste invisible to senior management. Participation is not automatically beneficial, though. Consultation without influence can breed cynicism, and consensus may be too slow in a crisis. Leaders need to make clear what is open to input, who owns the final decision, and how the group will learn from the outcome.
Suspend criticism to generate ideas, then expose the assumptions behind them.
Make room for unusual ideas. Brainstorming is a method for separating idea generation from evaluation. Participants hold back criticism, aim for many suggestions, and build on one another's contributions before selecting feasible ideas. This can counter functional fixedness, the habit of seeing an object only through its familiar use. Adair describes a paper clip being reimagined as, among other things, a picture hook or a small tool. At Pilkington Brothers, a brainstorming session produced 29 ideas in under five minutes, three of which were incorporated into a solution for an inspection problem.
Question invisible limits. The nine-dot puzzle is difficult when people unconsciously assume the lines must stay inside the dots' implied square. In business, Hoover's free-flight promotion rested on an assumption that few customers would navigate its restrictions. About 200,000 people did, and the scheme cost the company roughly £48 million.
The useful sequence is not uncritical optimism, but delayed evaluation: protect the fragile stage of possibility, then apply scrutiny. This is especially important in groups, where status differences can make one dismissive response silence further contributions. The Hoover episode shows why creativity needs a second discipline: assumptions about customers, costs, and incentives must be tested before an idea becomes policy. Brainstorming's emphasis on quantity can help widen the search, but raw idea counts are not proof of quality. A sound session needs a clear problem, a later selection process, and a way to test promising proposals.
Turn experience into judgment through deliberate review and honest criticism.
Learn on purpose. Adair treats thinking skill as something developed through self-directed practice, not simply acquired by holding a managerial title. He recommends studying people whose judgment is worth emulating, assessing personal strengths and gaps, and examining significant decisions and innovations in one's own field. A written case study can distill a poor decision into a few lessons; a notebook can preserve principles, examples, and questions for future use.
Choose a fitting field. Interests, aptitudes, and temperament influence which work allows a person to develop. Technical knowledge still matters because practical thinking is applied within a particular domain, not performed in a vacuum. Seek criticism of decisions and problem solving, sift it for evidence, and compare intended results with what actually happened. Experience becomes more useful when it is paired with principles and reflection, rather than left as a collection of unexamined successes and mistakes.
This is a strong account of deliberate learning: experience supplies cases, while reflection extracts patterns that can guide future action. It also recognizes that transferable thinking skills depend on domain knowledge; a method cannot replace understanding the material being judged. The advice to seek criticism is demanding because feedback can be biased, political, or poorly informed. Its value depends on separating the substance of a critique from its delivery and checking claims against outcomes. The goal is not to imitate a supposedly perfect thinker, but to build a practical repertoire suited to a person's work and limitations.
Analysis
Adair's central contribution is procedural rather than predictive. He does not promise that a sequence of steps will reveal the correct decision. Instead, he gives readers a way to notice what kind of thinking is missing: clearer analysis, a broader set of possibilities, explicit values, more relevant information, or a review of implementation. That is a realistic ambition in managerial life, where uncertainty and consequences make certainty unavailable.
The book's strongest ideas reinforce one another. The three mental functions explain why logical analysis alone is insufficient. The decision sequence turns those functions into usable practice. The bridge model carries a similar structure into problem solving, while the three-circle leadership model reminds readers that a technically sound choice can still fail if it damages teamwork or ignores individual needs. Stories such as Plastec's contaminated process and Hoover's expensive promotion make the abstract lesson memorable: causes and assumptions often hide in combinations, not in the obvious surface explanation.
A contemporary reading should treat some claims cautiously. The author's Depth Mind is a helpful name for incubation and tacit processing, not a guarantee that unconscious judgment is more accurate. The reported car-choice experiment offers an intriguing example, but cannot justify replacing deliberate analysis across all complex decisions. Similarly, brainstorming can widen a search, yet the quality of an idea still depends on evidence, expertise, and careful evaluation.
The practical strength of the book is its insistence that process and outcome are different. A sound decision can turn out badly because of chance; a reckless process can occasionally succeed by luck. Reviewing decisions by their reasoning, implementation, and consequences supports learning without confusing luck with competence. The lasting lesson is a disciplined flexibility: use frameworks to organize thought, but adapt them to urgency, knowledge, people, and the possibility of changing course.
Review Summary
Reviews for Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies are mixed. Some readers find it basic and outdated, lacking new insights for those familiar with the topic. Others appreciate its practical steps and ideas, particularly for new managers. The book covers mind functions, decision-making, and problem-solving, including brainteasers. While some praise its comprehensive approach and easy-to-follow content, others criticize the translation quality and outdated information. Overall, it's considered a quick read with some valuable advice, but may not be suitable for those seeking advanced strategies.
People Also Read
Glossary
Depth Mind
Unconscious problem processingAdair's term for the subconscious or unconscious activity that continues while conscious attention is elsewhere. He argues that it can combine memories, analyse a difficult situation, and produce intuition or new ideas. He recommends preparing carefully, allowing time away from a problem, and then testing any insight rather than treating it as automatically correct.
lobster pot model
Filter possibilities into choicesAdair's image for narrowing a broad set of ideas into a manageable number of feasible options and then into a final choice. The model cautions against jumping directly to two alternatives. Options are filtered against the objective and practical constraints, with unsuitable choices eliminated before the remaining candidates are compared.
Point of No Return (PNR)
Commitment becomes costly to reverseThe stage in a decision when changing course costs more than continuing with the current choice. Adair borrows the term from aviation, where a point in a journey makes returning to the starting place less practical than proceeding. Identifying a decision's PNR helps people notice when they can still review or revise a commitment.
bridge model
Shared structure for decisionsAdair's common framework for decision making and problem solving. It organizes discussion around defining the objective or problem, generating feasible options, and choosing the best course or solution. Like a bridge with distinct supports, it gives individuals and teams a shared sense of what stage they are addressing, even when their thoughts move back and forth.
three circles
Task, team, and individual needsAdair's model of the overlapping needs present in work groups: completing the task, maintaining the team, and meeting individual needs. Each area affects the others. For example, weak cooperation can impair task performance, while attention to shared achievement can strengthen cohesion and members' sense of contribution.
W5H Formula
Questions for locating causesA diagnostic set of questions used to investigate a systems problem: who, what, where, when, why, and how. Adair recommends using these questions to locate the deviation between expected and actual performance, then identifying possible causes. The aim is to correct underlying causes where possible, rather than merely treating visible symptoms.
functional fixedness
Seeing only familiar usesThe tendency to perceive an object or resource only in terms of its customary purpose. Adair uses brainstorming exercises, such as imagining new uses for a paper clip or scissors, to loosen this constraint. Temporarily setting aside the familiar function can help people notice alternative uses and connections.
Information Overload Syndrome
Stress from excessive incoming dataAdair's label for the strain managers experience when incoming information exceeds their ability to process it. The book cites a survey in which managers reported feeling unable to cope with growing volumes of data. Its practical response is to distinguish relevant information from merely available information and to stop research when added data has little value.
five-step approach
Sequence for making decisionsAdair's practical sequence for decision making: clarify the objective, gather relevant information, generate feasible options, choose, and implement and evaluate. He presents it as an organizing guide rather than a rigid algorithm. The steps help identify omissions while allowing thought to move backward when new information or consequences call for reconsideration.
FAQ
What is "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair about?
- Focus on Applied Thinking: The book explores the three essential forms of applied thinking—decision making, problem solving, and creative thinking—and how they overlap and differ.
- Practical Frameworks: It provides practical frameworks and step-by-step processes for making effective decisions, solving problems, and generating creative ideas.
- Leadership Emphasis: The book is especially geared toward leaders and managers, emphasizing the intellectual leadership required to guide teams and organizations.
- Self-Development Approach: Adair encourages readers to master practical thinking processes and develop their own thinking skills for both personal and professional growth.
Why should I read "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair?
- Improve Decision Quality: The book offers proven methods to enhance the quality and effectiveness of your decisions in both work and life.
- Sharpen Problem-Solving Skills: It teaches strategies to tackle obstacles and systems problems, making you a more resourceful and resilient thinker.
- Boost Creativity: Adair provides techniques to unlock creative thinking, including brainstorming and "thinking outside the box."
- Leadership Development: The book is a valuable resource for anyone in a leadership role, helping you engage teams and share decision-making for better outcomes.
What are the key takeaways from "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair?
- Five-Step Decision Process: Adair outlines a classic five-step approach—define the objective, collect relevant information, generate feasible options, make the decision, and implement/evaluate.
- Three Functions of the Mind: Effective thinking involves analyzing, synthesizing, and valuing, all of which can be developed and balanced.
- Depth Mind Principle: The subconscious (Depth Mind) plays a crucial role in complex decision making and creativity; learning to harness it can improve outcomes.
- Importance of Sharing Decisions: Involving others in decision making increases motivation and the quality of decisions, but requires balancing control and freedom.
How does John Adair define decision making and problem solving in "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies"?
- Decision Making: Defined as choosing a course of action, usually involving a choice between options, with the aim of achieving a specific objective.
- Problem Solving: Focused on finding solutions to obstacles or challenges, often requiring rearrangement or rethinking of existing elements.
- Distinction: Decisions typically lead to changes and new problems, while problem solving is about overcoming obstacles created by previous decisions.
- Overlap: Both processes use similar mental frameworks and benefit from structured approaches.
What is the five-step decision-making process in "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair?
- Define the Objective: Clearly state what you are trying to achieve; writing it down helps clarify your aim.
- Collect Relevant Information: Gather and sift through information, distinguishing between what is available and what is truly relevant.
- Generate Feasible Options: Move beyond simple alternatives to create a range of possible solutions, then narrow them down to the most workable.
- Make the Decision: Use selection criteria (must, should, might) and assess risks and consequences before choosing the best option.
- Implement and Evaluate: Take action, identify the point of no return, and review the decision to learn for future situations.
What is the "Depth Mind" principle in "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair, and how can it be used?
- Subconscious Processing: The Depth Mind refers to the subconscious or unconscious part of the mind that continues to analyze, synthesize, and value even when you are not consciously thinking about a problem.
- Source of Intuition: It is responsible for hunches, insights, and creative breakthroughs, often providing solutions after a period of incubation.
- Practical Application: Adair suggests building in time to "sleep on" decisions, keeping a notebook for sudden ideas, and trusting your Depth Mind in complex situations.
- Development: Awareness and deliberate engagement with the Depth Mind can enhance decision making, problem solving, and creativity.
How does "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair recommend generating creative ideas and overcoming mental roadblocks?
- Brainstorming Technique: Adair advocates for brainstorming, both individually and in groups, suspending judgment to encourage free-flowing ideas.
- Guidelines for Creativity: Emphasizes welcoming unusual ideas, striving for quantity, combining and improving on others' suggestions, and avoiding premature criticism.
- Overcoming Functional Fixedness: Encourages looking beyond the obvious uses or solutions, challenging assumptions, and thinking in new dimensions.
- Addressing Roadblocks: Identifies common obstacles such as lack of facts, conviction, starting point, perspective, or motivation, and offers strategies to overcome them.
What does "thinking outside the box" mean in "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair, and how is it applied?
- Origin of the Phrase: Adair introduced the phrase "thinking outside the box" with the nine dots problem, illustrating the need to break free from self-imposed constraints.
- Challenging Assumptions: It involves questioning unconscious assumptions and exploring solutions beyond traditional boundaries.
- Lateral Thinking: Encourages looking for solutions in adjacent fields or through deliberate changes in perspective, as opposed to only following logical, step-by-step reasoning.
- Practical Examples: The book provides real-world cases where thinking outside the box led to innovative solutions or, conversely, where failure to do so resulted in costly mistakes.
How does "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair suggest leaders should share decisions with others?
- Three Circles Model: Leaders must balance task needs, team maintenance, and individual needs, recognizing that group dynamics affect decision quality.
- Planning Continuum: Leaders can choose how much to involve the team, from making decisions alone to full delegation, depending on time and team competence.
- Motivation and Buy-In: Sharing decisions increases motivation and commitment but may reduce control over outcomes; leaders must judge the right balance.
- Practical Checklists: The book provides checklists for involving teams in defining objectives, gathering information, generating options, and reviewing decisions.
What are the key problem-solving strategies in "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair?
- Unified Bridge Model: Adair presents a model that applies to both decision making and problem solving—define the problem, generate options, choose the best solution.
- Asking the Right Questions: Effective problem solvers use targeted questions to clarify problems, test assumptions, and evaluate solutions.
- Systems Problems Approach: For problems involving deviations from the norm, the strategy is to pinpoint the deviation, identify causes, and address root issues.
- Avoiding Single-Cause Fallacy: Recognizes that complex problems often have multiple causes, requiring thorough analysis and elimination of possibilities.
How does "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair recommend developing your own thinking skills?
- Self-Development Focus: Emphasizes that thinking skills are largely self-taught and require conscious effort and reflection.
- Learning from Mentors: Suggests identifying and emulating the thinking skills of people you admire, both personally and professionally.
- Field Alignment: Advises choosing a field that matches your interests, aptitudes, and temperament to maximize your natural thinking strengths.
- Continuous Learning: Recommends reading, case study analysis, seeking feedback, and maintaining a personal notebook of principles and lessons.
What are the best quotes from "Decision Making and Problem Solving Strategies" by John Adair and what do they mean?
- "If one wants to be successful, one must think; one must think until it hurts." – Roy Thompson. This highlights the effort and persistence required for effective thinking.
- "A problem properly defined is a problem half-solved." – Emphasizes the importance of clear problem definition as the foundation for effective solutions.
- "Not to decide is to decide." – English proverb. Reminds readers that inaction is itself a form of decision, often with its own consequences.
- "Creativity is so delicate a flower that praise tends to make it bloom, while discouragement often nips it in the bud." – William Ploner. Stresses the need for a supportive environment to foster creativity.
- "Knowledge is only a rumour until it is in the muscle." – Papua New Guinea proverb. Underlines the importance of applying and practicing knowledge, not just acquiring it.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.