Key Takeaways
Define anarchy as self-organized order, not social collapse.
A positive definition. Anarchy, in Marshall’s account, means life without rulers, not life without cooperation or shared expectations. Anarchists imagine a decentralized society made up of voluntary associations of free and equal people. The goal is to let people manage their common affairs themselves, rather than hand that authority to a State.
A long, uneven current. Marshall traces related ideas through Taoism, Greek philosophy, Christian radicals, medieval revolts, and the English Diggers. He distinguishes these precursors from modern anarchism, which took coherent form around the late eighteenth century. William Godwin gave its first sustained philosophical case; Pierre-Joseph Proudhon was the first to claim the anarchist name. The tradition remains varied, not a fixed doctrine.
The distinction turns a familiar insult into a useful question: what produces order, and who gets to direct it? Anarchism’s answer is not that rules vanish, but that people can make and revise arrangements together. That is a stronger claim than simple anti-government feeling. It also carries a burden: informal norms can pressure dissenters as forcefully as formal law. The distinction matters only if self-management protects real disagreement, not merely agreement without an official ruler.
Separate everyday cooperation from the State’s claim to rule.
Two different things. Marshall stresses that society is the web of relationships through which people cooperate, share knowledge, and meet needs. The State is a particular institution claiming supreme authority over a territory, including the power to make and enforce laws. Anarchists reject the State, not society itself. Most seek to strengthen voluntary associations and local self-management.
Order without rulers. Marshall points to stateless communities whose lives were regulated through custom, reciprocity, and social approval. He notes that these communities were not perfect or free of pressure, and that some were marked by age or gender hierarchy. He also presents the State as a relatively recent development, associated with economic surplus, unequal property, and organized force. Stateless life is therefore historically possible, but not automatically just.
This separation challenges the assumption that coordination requires command from above. It also avoids the opposite mistake of treating every community as naturally harmonious. The book’s examples make a persuasive case that the State is one historical form of organization, not society’s only possible foundation. Yet the line between State and society can blur: customary rules, family roles, and social approval also distribute power. A serious anarchist analysis has to examine those relationships, not just formal institutions.
Interrogate laws and elections for whose interests they actually protect.
Law carries force. Anarchists see law as more than a neutral guide: it is a rule backed by the State’s power to punish. Godwin argued that a general law cannot fit every particular case and often preserves the interests of those who make it. Kropotkin grouped laws around the protection of property, government, and persons, arguing that even protective rules can serve the powerful.
Representation has limits. Anarchists prefer democracy to monarchy, but question whether representatives can genuinely act for others or whether a majority may justly dictate to a minority. Proudhon’s brief experience in the French National Assembly strengthened his view that parliamentary life separates officials from the people. Lysander Spooner challenged the claim that the US Constitution bound citizens who had never consented to it.
The critique is most useful as a test, not a blanket verdict: who writes a rule, who enforces it, and who can challenge its effects? The book itself recognizes that some State institutions can protect people from other concentrations of power. That nuance prevents a simple equation of every law with oppression. But a vote alone does not settle questions of consent, unequal influence, or minority rights. The anarchist challenge is to make authority answerable, limited, and ultimately unnecessary.
Make liberty reciprocal, or it becomes another person’s domination.
Freedom has two sides. Anarchists value freedom from imposed restraint and freedom to develop one’s capacities. But they reject the idea that liberty means doing anything one wants regardless of the effect on others. Bakunin’s central point is that a person’s freedom depends on the freedom of others; liberty without equality can become a license for the strong to command.
Equal does not mean identical. Anarchists disagree about distribution. Collectivists would reward work, while communists would distribute according to need. Both generally seek conditions in which everyone can develop, without demanding identical lives or talents. Individualist anarchists warn that a community can crush personal choice; social anarchists warn that isolated individuals can leave competition and inequality intact. Their shared aim is a society where individuality and solidarity support each other.
This account treats freedom as relational rather than as a private possession. It exposes a weakness in definitions that count formal permission as liberty while ignoring dependence, poverty, or another person’s power to command. The book’s range of economic views also shows that equality is not one settled formula. Still, mutual freedom does not by itself resolve every conflict over scarce goods or competing needs. The principle is a compass, not a complete procedure for deciding difficult cases.
Keep economic experiments plural instead of imposing one anarchist blueprint.
Several routes, shared suspicion. Mutualists, collectivists, communists, syndicalists, and individualists disagree over ownership, exchange, and distribution. Proudhon’s mutualists proposed worker-owned property, free credit, and exchange based on labour. Bakunin’s collectivists favoured common ownership of production, with distribution according to work. Kropotkin’s anarcho-communists wanted common ownership and distribution according to need.
Workplace self-management. Anarcho-syndicalists see trade unions not only as tools for better conditions but as training grounds for workers to manage production themselves. Individualist anarchists, meanwhile, fear that collective ownership could subordinate a person to the group. Marshall argues that these currents need not harden into rival creeds. Different communities could try different arrangements, provided participation remains voluntary and no system becomes a new authority.
This pluralism is more than tolerance. It is a way to keep a movement from turning one theory of the future into a compulsory program. The different proposals also expose genuine trade-offs: needs-based sharing, labour-based reward, and market exchange each answer different concerns. Local experimentation may reveal what works under particular conditions. But it cannot eliminate conflicts that cross local boundaries, such as resource use or unequal bargaining power. Voluntary variation still needs fair ways to negotiate shared problems.
Build libertarian habits now, because methods shape the society they create.
Practice the alternative. Godwin put his faith in persuasion, education, and small circles of discussion rather than a sudden seizure of power. His school plan gave children more freedom to learn according to their interests. Later anarchists developed affinity groups, co-operatives, and workers’ associations as ways to practise self-management before any wider social change.
The means are a warning. Bakunin’s secret revolutionary groups were meant to guide a free society, yet their hidden hierarchy contradicted that goal. Landauer offered a different emphasis: the State is sustained by relationships people repeat, and can be weakened by building different relationships. The practical lesson is to create organizations that are transparent, voluntary, and accountable, rather than trusting a future promise to erase today’s command structure.
Prefiguration, building parts of the desired society in the present, is a demanding standard because it makes political conduct part of political theory. It also helps explain why anarchists distrust vanguard parties: secrecy and command can become durable habits, not temporary tools. Yet small groups are not automatically egalitarian. Charisma, informal status, and hidden decision-making can still concentrate influence. Accountability, open disagreement, and the ability to leave are essential safeguards, not bureaucratic distractions.
Treat revolution as self-management, not merely a change of rulers.
Spain’s brief experiment. After Franco’s uprising in 1936, workers and peasants established collectives across thousands of villages and took over industries, especially in Catalonia. Anarchist unions helped organize production and services, while local assemblies managed community affairs. The scale was striking: the CNT had more than a million members by the end of 1936, and millions of people encountered some form of collective management.
War narrowed the choices. The collectives faced shortages, military pressure, conflict with other Republican forces, and the growing influence of Communists. CNT leaders entered government and accepted greater centralization in the name of winning the war. The experiment was then crushed by Franco. Marshall presents Spain as evidence that self-management can operate at scale, but also as a warning that wartime alliances can displace the social transformation they were meant to defend.
Spain gives the book’s argument its clearest practical test: workers did not merely demand control; they ran farms, factories, and services. That achievement challenges the claim that ordinary people cannot coordinate complex work. Its defeat, however, does not prove that anarchist organization alone would have won under military attack. The deeper lesson is about priorities under pressure: once victory is defined only as winning the war, institutions of command gain leverage over the society the revolution sought to create.
Beware transitional states: emergency power rarely behaves like a temporary tool.
Russia’s warning. In 1917, anarchists hoped the soviets, councils of workers and soldiers, could embody popular self-rule. In parts of Ukraine, Nestor Makhno’s forces supported autonomous communes and collective production. The Bolsheviks instead centralized authority in the Communist Party, restricted rival groups, and eventually crushed both the Makhnovist movement and the 1921 Kronstadt uprising.
A disputed lesson. Marxists argued that a workers’ State was needed to defend the revolution before it could wither away. Anarchists replied that a State equipped to command would build interests and institutions of its own. The Bolshevik experience strengthened that warning. Yet Russia faced civil war, foreign intervention, and economic collapse, conditions that complicate any simple comparison between theory and outcome.
The episode highlights a structural risk: emergency powers create people and institutions whose position depends on keeping those powers. This is stronger than a claim that particular leaders were simply hypocritical. It does not establish that every temporary authority must become permanent, but it shifts the burden of proof. Any proposal for transitional command needs clear limits, independent accountability, and a credible route back to local control. Without these, the means can quietly redefine the end.
Use nonviolent resistance when force would reproduce the hierarchy being opposed.
Refuse complicity. Tolstoy argued that governments rest on organized violence, so participating in courts, armies, and coercive administration makes citizens part of that violence. His alternative was non-resistance to violence, combined with civil disobedience and persuasion. Gandhi developed satyagraha, a form of disciplined nonviolent resistance that seeks to confront injustice without treating opponents as enemies to be destroyed.
Not every anarchist agrees. Bakunin, Kropotkin, and Malatesta accepted some revolutionary force, while Tolstoy rejected violence even in revolution. Gandhi’s path was not an immediate plan to abolish the State; he also worked through India’s independence movement. The tradition therefore contains a live disagreement about force, but shares a concern that violent methods can reproduce the domination they claim to end.
Nonviolence is not passivity here. It is a strategy that withdraws cooperation, exposes the force behind authority, and makes political participation visible. Its strength is ethical and practical: it resists turning opponents into targets. Its limits matter too. Nonviolent campaigns can face brutal repression, and moral pressure does not guarantee a response. The useful question is not whether one tactic fits every struggle, but whether a tactic expands people’s capacity to govern themselves or narrows it.
Extend the critique of hierarchy into gender, ecology, and daily life.
More than the State. Emma Goldman argued that freedom must reach into sexuality, marriage, and women’s control over their own lives. Later anarcho-feminists made the personal political by examining power in intimate relationships. Bookchin’s social ecology widened the critique further, connecting domination among people with the domination of nature and calling for ecologically grounded communities.
A mixed inheritance. Anarchist movements have not consistently lived up to these ideals. Proudhon held deeply patriarchal views, while Gandhi’s sexual ethic was restrictive. Still, feminist, peace, Green, and counter-culture movements have taken up anarchist concerns about hierarchy, direct action, and participation. The legacy is strongest when it is used to inspect anarchist practice itself, not merely to condemn distant States.
This expansion makes anarchism a lens for everyday relations, not only a theory of government. It also forces the tradition to face its own contradictions: a movement can oppose political domination while tolerating male authority at home or treating nature as raw material. Linking these forms of power can reveal shared patterns, but they should not be collapsed into one problem. Economic exploitation, patriarchy, and ecological damage have distinct mechanisms and require specific remedies.
Analysis
Marshall’s book is both a history and an argument: it traces a libertarian current from ancient Taoism, Greek thought, Christian dissent, and popular revolts into modern anarchist movements, then tests its claims against revolutions and social experiments. Its great strength is refusing to reduce anarchism to bomb-throwing or to a single economic program. The succession from Godwin and Proudhon through Bakunin, Kropotkin, Goldman, Tolstoy, and Gandhi shows a family of disagreements organized around one central question: can people coordinate without giving some of them durable power over others?
The most persuasive part is the historical warning about transitional authority. Russia and Spain suggest that organizations built to defend a revolution can displace its participatory aims, especially when war makes command seem indispensable. The argument is not that coordination is unnecessary, but that coordination should remain accountable to those affected by it. Contemporary research on shared-resource governance, especially Elinor Ostrom’s work, supports a more nuanced possibility: communities can manage common resources without either privatization or a centralized State when they establish clear rules, monitoring, conflict-resolution procedures, and nested cooperation. This complements anarchist self-management while showing that durable freedom requires institution-building, not merely the removal of institutions.
Marshall’s panoramic method also has a cost. By tracing anarchist sensibilities across millennia, he sometimes blurs the difference between historical precursors and a modern movement with specific social conditions. His own examples of sexist, nationalist, or coercive anarchists also show that anti-State politics does not automatically produce equality. The strongest reading, then, treats anarchism not as a guaranteed natural order but as a demanding practice: distribute decision-making, protect dissent, and continually examine how power reappears in informal relations. Its enduring relevance lies less in a perfect blueprint than in the disciplined refusal to let emergency, expertise, or good intentions become permanent permission to rule.
Review Summary
Demanding the Impossible is a comprehensive history of anarchism, praised for its thorough coverage of anarchist thinkers, movements, and ideas. Readers appreciate Marshall's balanced approach and engaging writing style. The book is noted for its exploration of anarchism's philosophical roots and its influence on modern political thought. While some find it dense and occasionally repetitive, many consider it an essential reference for those interested in anarchism. Critics note a bias towards pacifism and a lack of diversity in represented voices.
People Also Read
Glossary
Anarchy
Order without rulersA social condition without a State or imposed political rulers. In Marshall’s account, it does not mean chaos or the absence of cooperation. Anarchists envision people organizing their shared affairs through voluntary associations, local self-management, and freely formed agreements.
Mutual aid
Cooperation as survivalKropotkin’s term for cooperation among members of a species or society. In Mutual Aid, he argues that cooperation is a major factor in survival and development, countering the view that evolution is driven mainly by competition between individuals. He extends the idea to human communities and anarchist social organization.
Mutualism
Reciprocal worker exchangeProudhon’s proposed economic arrangement based on voluntary agreements, worker possession of tools and workplaces, and the exchange of goods according to the labour needed to produce them. Mutualists also proposed free credit and federated associations. The aim was to avoid both capitalist exploitation and centralized State ownership.
Collectivism
Common production, work-based distributionAn anarchist economic position associated especially with Bakunin. It calls for common ownership and control of land and productive resources by associations of producers, while generally distributing goods according to work contributed. It rejects both private ownership that enables exploitation and a centralized State that manages the economy.
Anarcho-communism
Common ownership by needA form of anarchism that combines a society without government with common ownership of productive resources and goods. Kropotkin argued that work is interconnected and its value cannot be precisely separated, so distribution should respond to people’s needs rather than wages, prices, or individual labour calculations.
Anarcho-syndicalism
Unions as self-managementA strategy and social vision in which workers’ unions organize the struggle against employers and prepare to manage production themselves. Syndicates are meant to serve both as instruments of direct action and as foundations for a future society organized through federations, workers’ control, and voluntary cooperation.
Propaganda by the deed
Action meant to provoke changeA strategy used by some nineteenth-century anarchists who believed that dramatic acts of revolt could communicate revolutionary ideas and encourage wider resistance. It became associated with bombings and assassinations, although anarchists disagreed sharply about its usefulness. Many later rejected individual violence as destructive and politically counterproductive.
Satyagraha
Disciplined nonviolent resistanceGandhi’s method of resisting injustice through truth, non-cooperation, and deliberate nonviolent action. Rather than seeking to destroy an opponent, satyagraha aims to confront injustice while refusing to participate in it. Gandhi used the method in campaigns against colonial rule and other forms of coercion.
Social ecology
Ecology against hierarchyMurray Bookchin’s approach linking environmental destruction to social hierarchy and domination. It argues that the exploitation of nature is connected to relations in which some people dominate others. Social ecology proposes decentralized communities, ecological balance, and democratic participation as alternatives.
Temporary Autonomous Zone
Briefly liberated social spaceHakim Bey’s term for a temporary space of freedom that appears within or alongside the dominant order. Rather than trying to seize permanent power, participants create an autonomous gathering or practice, enjoy it, and disperse before authorities can fully control it. The idea has influenced some contemporary anarchist and anti-globalization activism.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.