Key Takeaways
Educate desire, not just belief: people become what they love.
Love comes before theory. Smith challenges the idea that people are chiefly minds collecting information. He calls humans homo liturgicus, or liturgical animals: embodied people whose deepest orientation is desire for some picture of the good life. Beliefs matter, but they do not alone determine what feels worthwhile or shapes everyday choices. A person may know the right principles yet still be drawn toward a rival vision of success, comfort, or belonging.
Formation takes time. George Orwell’s account of English class prejudice shows why. School lessons in Greek faded, while the visceral sense that working-class people were inferior endured. Smith’s point is not that teaching ideas is useless, but that education also forms habits, loyalties, and imagination. Christian education, therefore, should ask not only what students know, but what kind of people they are learning to become.
What's striking is the distinction between knowing a value and being disposed to live by it. Contemporary work on embodied cognition likewise treats thought as intertwined with perception, emotion, and practiced action, rather than as a detached command center. This makes Smith's educational challenge practical: a curriculum can praise solidarity while its routines reward status competition. Still, formation is not mechanical. People interpret practices differently, resist them, and inhabit several communities at once. The framework is strongest as a warning against assuming that information reliably becomes character, not as a claim that ideas or individual agency have little power.
Audit ordinary routines for the kingdoms they quietly train you to want.
Habits carry a direction. Smith distinguishes thin practices, such as a routine mainly serving a practical purpose, from thick practices that shape identity and a sense of what matters. The boundary can blur: exercise might simply support health, or it might serve a larger ideal of appearance, discipline, or family life. Repetition forms habits, and those habits can guide behavior before deliberate reflection begins.
Ask what they produce. A baseball player repeats drills until the body responds without pausing to calculate each move. Smith uses this kind of practiced response to explain how cultural routines can also shape desire. His proposed practices audit asks people to examine where their time goes, which routines influence their attitudes, and what vision of a good life those routines serve. Even an apparently small habit can contribute to a larger pattern of allegiance.
The useful move here is from moral self-description to behavioral evidence. People often say they value community, rest, or generosity, but recurring schedules reveal which goods receive protected time. This resembles behavioral economics, where choices under real constraints can disclose priorities more reliably than stated preferences. The caution is that a habit's meaning cannot always be inferred from its outward form. The same commute, meal, or exercise routine may serve very different ends. Smith's audit works best as a prompt for interpretation and conversation, rather than as a quick system for labeling other people's lives.
Read malls, stadiums, and campuses as formative institutions, not neutral scenery.
Practices tell a story. Smith uses cultural exegesis to mean interpreting the vision of human flourishing embedded in a culture's repeated practices. He calls identity-shaping practices directed toward ultimate concerns liturgies. These need not occur in a church. They can be secular in appearance while teaching participants what deserves love, loyalty, and sacrifice.
Look beyond messages. The mall's architecture, displays, and shopping rituals invite visitors into a consumer ideal; sports ceremonies can bind spectators to national identity; university initiation and social life can teach status-seeking and treat learning as a tool for career success. The point is not that every participant absorbs the same lesson, or that these places have no benefits. It is that cultural institutions can educate desire through shared spaces, images, and routines, even when nobody gives a lecture about their values.
This lens extends cultural criticism beyond explicit slogans to environments, rituals, and incentives. In sociology, institutions shape conduct partly by making some actions easy, visible, and socially rewarded while rendering others awkward or costly. Smith's account captures that quiet force. Its risk is overreading: a stadium ceremony or campus tradition may have multiple meanings, and participants are not passive vessels. A sound cultural reading therefore asks both what a practice seems designed to normalize and how different people actually experience it. The method is a strong invitation to investigate, not proof that every institution has one coherent intention.
Notice when shopping turns ordinary dissatisfaction into a promise of redemption.
Consumerism diagnoses and sells. Smith's mall tour makes shopping look like a pilgrimage: carefully designed spaces, repeated seasonal rituals, idealized images, and products presented as routes to fulfillment. The promise works partly by implying that something is wrong with the shopper, then offering a purchase as repair. The good life appears to mean looking attractive, feeling carefree, and acquiring the right things.
The promise keeps moving. A new purchase may bring pleasure, but its shine fades, and the next product renews the hope. Meanwhile, people can learn to judge themselves and others by marketable images, while the labor and resources behind products remain out of sight. Smith argues that the church can mimic this pattern when it treats religious goods or experiences as appealing commodities. The deeper question is not simply what people buy, but whether buying has become their imagined route to belonging and hope.
The analysis connects consumer desire to a broader cycle of aspiration, comparison, and short-lived satisfaction. Research on materialism and well-being often finds that prioritizing wealth and status is associated with poorer social and emotional outcomes, though the relationship is complex and does not make every purchase harmful. Smith's account is especially useful because it notices how commerce offers not just objects but identities and social belonging. Its critique also needs a distinction between manipulative marketing and ordinary exchange. A purchase can meet a real need; the concern is the larger story that acquisition can cure human discontent.
Let worship shape belief through bodies, repetition, and shared story.
Practice precedes formulation. Smith reverses the common idea that a complete set of Christian beliefs comes first and worship merely expresses it. Early Christians gathered, prayed, sang, and shared the Eucharist before the canon and formal doctrines were settled. The practices were a setting in which the community learned how to understand God and the world. This is the priority of worship to worldview, not a rejection of thought or doctrine.
The body can learn. In a Tenebrae service, candles are extinguished as the story of Jesus' final words is heard, leaving the congregation in darkness before a sudden sound marks the desolation. Smith says such sensory participation can communicate the gravity of Good Friday in a way a lecture alone may not, including for children or people with limited access to abstract ideas. Scripture, creeds, and reflection remain important, but they grow within a practiced life of faith.
The claim resembles learning-by-doing: repeated participation gives people shared habits and emotional associations that help make later explanations intelligible. Ritual studies also emphasize that communal acts can create belonging, not merely transmit propositions. Smith's example usefully challenges the assumption that serious learning must be mainly verbal. Yet a powerful ritual is not automatically a truthful one. The same embodied force can serve rival purposes, and participants may misunderstand or reject what a service intends. Reflection and teaching are therefore not rivals to ritual; they help communities examine and articulate what their practices are forming.
Treat material creation as a meeting place with God, not a disposable shell.
The material matters. Smith calls the sacramental imagination the understanding that God can meet people through created, physical things. Christian worship uses water, bread, and wine, ordinary elements that connect spiritual claims to bodies, labor, agriculture, and the wider created world. The sacraments intensify this sense of creation as a means of grace, rather than treating matter as an obstacle to spiritual life.
Avoid two reductions. A supernaturalism that longs to escape the body and a naturalism that sees only matter both flatten the world, Smith argues. The Christian account instead affirms creation as good and sees it as more than a collection of useful objects. The bread and wine also recall human work: grain and grapes become food through cultivation and craft. This links worship to the value of ordinary life and cultural labor, not just to private religious experience.
This view offers a theological counterweight to habits of treating nature as raw material and the body as a problem to manage. It also has an environmental implication: if created things are received as gifts rather than mere inputs, care and restraint become part of spiritual attention. The account is not a claim that every object has the same sacred status or that material processes are harmless. Food production, for instance, can involve exploitation. A sacramental outlook gains ethical force when gratitude for matter is joined to scrutiny of how it is made, distributed, and used.
Make worship rehearse a shared kingdom, not merely private spiritual comfort.
The service forms a people. Smith reads Christian worship as a sequence of practices that teaches a social vision. The calendar trains memory and hope; gathering answers a call into community; greeting practices hospitality; confession and pardon acknowledge shared failure and received grace. Baptism marks entry into a people whose identity can challenge inherited divisions of status and family. The creed locates belief in a common story and tradition.
The table points outward. In the Eucharist, people share a meal that remembers Jesus, anticipates a renewed creation, and demands attention to reconciliation. The offering links worship to the distribution of resources, while the sending connects the gathered community to work in the world. Taken together, these practices present flourishing as communal, embodied, and oriented toward justice and peace, rather than as an individual's private escape from ordinary life.
The strength of this reading is its refusal to separate spirituality from social organization. A community that sings together, confesses wrongdoing, shares food, and promises care for children is rehearsing obligations, not only expressing beliefs. Such practices can make abstract ideals concrete and create forms of solidarity. But liturgical performance is not the same as social achievement. A congregation can recite welcome while remaining segregated, or celebrate shared bread while ignoring poverty. The practices provide a standard by which a community can judge itself, but their credibility depends on whether its life beyond worship begins to reflect them.
Build Christian education from the church's practices, not a religious overlay.
Formation is the mission. Smith argues that a Christian college should not simply teach the same goals as other universities while adding Christian ideas or moral advice. Its purpose should include forming disciples whose learning and work are shaped by the church's practices and vision of human flourishing. He calls this an ecclesial university: an educational institution nourished by the worship and life of the church, while still pursuing serious scholarship across fields.
Connect the settings. Smith proposes closer ties among parish worship, campus chapel, classroom, dormitory, and neighborhood. A class on hospitality, for example, could pair philosophical study with service among people facing homelessness or displacement. Students would encounter the subject as a lived relationship as well as an idea. This model could produce graduates whose choices differ from conventional definitions of success, a risk Smith sees as part of taking Christian formation seriously.
Smith identifies a real institutional tension: universities are judged by credentials and career outcomes, while formation often sounds too vague to assess. His alternative becomes more persuasive when practices are connected to intellectual rigor rather than used to replace it. Service can deepen learning, but it can also become paternalistic if communities are treated as teaching material for students. An ecclesial educational model therefore needs reciprocal partnerships, open inquiry, and accountability to those affected by its work. The challenge is not simply to add spiritual activities, but to make the institution's everyday incentives consistent with its stated ends.
Give Sunday worship weekday reinforcement through shared disciplines and chosen abstentions.
Formation needs a rhythm. Smith recognizes that a weekly service competes with far more hours spent in other cultural settings. His answer is not withdrawal from culture altogether, but selective abstention from practices whose aims conflict with Christian discipleship, paired with constructive alternatives. He draws on monastic life for two resources: regular shared worship and intentional limits on participation in dominant routines.
Practice through the week. Communities might share meals, observe Sabbath, pray daily, welcome neighbors, fast, or serve together. Smith's example of friends meeting regularly for food and conversation shows how ordinary life can sustain mutual care and forgiveness. These practices work best when connected to the church's gathered worship, rather than treated as substitutes for it. The aim is a durable pattern of life that resists consumer urgency and cultivates habits of attention, hospitality, and dependence.
The emphasis on rhythm reflects a basic insight from behavior change: infrequent intentions struggle against environments encountered every day. Shared practices can provide cues, accountability, and a sense of belonging that private resolutions lack. Smith's idea of selective abstention is more subtle than blanket rejection of culture, because it asks which specific patterns should be refused and what life-giving alternatives can replace them. The hard question is who decides. Communities need room for conscientious disagreement and careful attention to material realities, since the same practice may be accessible to some people and costly or impossible for others.
Analysis
Smith's central achievement is to shift the question of Christian education from what information students receive to what forms of life their institutions make plausible. The claim that people are shaped by love, habit, and embodied participation gives a coherent bridge between philosophical anthropology, cultural criticism, worship, and schooling. His mall, stadium, and university readings make an abstract thesis visible: environments teach through rhythms and rewards, even without announcing a doctrine. The alternative is not anti-intellectual. It places thought inside a life of practices that trains attention and desire.
The book is strongest when it treats liturgy as a diagnostic lens rather than a claim that every routine has one fixed meaning. Its analysis of consumer life is particularly sharp because it connects self-image, social comparison, acquisition, and hidden production. Its account of worship also resists reducing religion to private belief by emphasizing shared time, food, memory, confession, and obligation. Together these arguments suggest that institutional reform cannot be achieved by adding Christian content to unchanged routines.
Several cautions sharpen rather than defeat the thesis. First, formative influence is not uniform: people reinterpret rituals, move among communities, and sometimes resist the expectations of institutions. Second, the distinction between Christian formation and indoctrination requires more than good intentions. A university committed to shaping desire must also protect intellectual challenge, make its norms discussable, and remain answerable to people outside its community. Third, worship can embody ideals while congregations fail to enact them socially. Ritual should therefore be treated as a resource for critique and repair, not evidence that a community is already just. The book's most useful practical implication is an institutional audit: examine what a school, church, or household repeatedly rewards, who belongs comfortably, and what kind of flourishing its routines make imaginable. Beliefs remain essential, but their force depends partly on the worlds people practice together. Education, in this account, is never just preparation for life. It is rehearsal for a particular kind of life.
Review Summary
Desiring the Kingdom receives mostly positive reviews for its thought-provoking ideas on Christian formation and worship. Readers appreciate Smith's emphasis on practices and liturgy in shaping desires and worldviews. Many find his critique of modern Christian education insightful, though some disagree with specific applications. The book is praised for its philosophical depth but criticized for academic language and repetitiveness. Some reviewers note Smith's progressive leanings as a point of contention. Overall, the book is considered paradigm-shifting for many, offering a fresh perspective on Christian discipleship and cultural engagement.
People Also Read
Glossary
Homo liturgicus
Humans formed through worshipSmith's term for humans understood as embodied, desiring creatures whose deepest commitments are shaped through repeated practices. People are not defined only by what they think or profess to believe. Their loves and sense of the good life are cultivated through routines, institutions, stories, and rituals, including both religious worship and cultural practices.
social imaginary
Shared practical world-understandingA socially shared, largely pre-reflective sense of how the world works and what a good life looks like. It is carried less by formal theories than by images, stories, habits, and practices. Smith uses the term to describe the background understanding that shapes action before people explain their beliefs in explicit propositions.
thick practices
Identity-forming repeated actionsPractices that do more than accomplish a practical task. They help shape a person's identity, values, and sense of what matters. A routine may be thick when it expresses and reinforces a larger commitment, such as community, status, or a particular vision of flourishing. The distinction from thinner habits is useful but not always clear-cut.
liturgies
Rituals directing ultimate desireSmith uses liturgy broadly for repeated practices that shape identity and orient people's deepest loves toward a vision of the good life. Liturgies include formal Christian worship, but can also include cultural routines organized around consumption, national identity, or education. They form desire through embodied participation, often without explicit teaching.
cultural exegesis
Reading values in practicesA way of interpreting cultural institutions by examining their practices, spaces, and routines to discern the vision of human flourishing they carry. Instead of asking only what a film, university, or market says, cultural exegesis asks what kind of person its repeated activities encourage people to become and what goods they teach people to pursue.
sacramental imagination
Creation as a means of graceAn understanding that God can meet people through created, material things. Water, bread, and wine are central examples in Christian worship, where ordinary elements become particular means of grace. The idea affirms the goodness of embodied life and creation, resisting both the view that matter is spiritually worthless and the view that reality is only material.
ecclesial university
University rooted in church lifeSmith's proposed model of Christian higher education as an institution connected to and nourished by the church's worship and practices. It pursues scholarship while also forming students as disciples, rather than merely adding religious ideas to conventional academic goals. Its distinctive character comes from the kind of community and life it cultivates.
telos
An orienting end or goalA Greek term Smith uses for the end toward which a person, practice, or institution is directed. In this book, a telos is often a picture of human flourishing or the good life. Practices carry a telos by encouraging particular desires and habits, whether or not participants explicitly state the goal.
adaptive unconscious
Automatic, nonconscious mental activityA term associated with psychologist Timothy Wilson's account of mental processes that operate outside deliberate awareness. These processes can interpret situations, guide reactions, and shape behavior efficiently. Smith draws on the concept to explain how repeated embodied practices can form dispositions without requiring constant conscious decisions.
FAQ
What is Desiring the Kingdom: Worship, Worldview, and Cultural Formation by James K.A. Smith about?
- Core thesis: Smith argues that humans are fundamentally "liturgical animals" whose desires and loves are shaped by embodied practices, especially worship.
- Worship as formation: Christian worship is presented as the primary means by which a Christian worldview and identity are formed, rather than through intellectual assent alone.
- Cultural critique: The book analyzes how secular cultural practices (like consumerism and nationalism) function as "secular liturgies" that shape our desires and identities.
- Educational implications: Smith calls for Christian education to be re-envisioned as a formative, worship-centered process that shapes the whole person.
Why should I read Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith?
- Reframes Christian faith: The book challenges the idea that Christianity is mainly about beliefs, presenting it instead as an embodied, affective practice centered on worship.
- Cultural awareness: It equips readers to recognize and resist the formative power of secular cultural practices that shape desires contrary to Christian discipleship.
- Practical formation: Smith provides a theological and philosophical framework for understanding how Christian worship forms desire and imagination.
- Vision for education: The book offers a hopeful, concrete vision for Christian education as liturgical formation, nurturing whole persons.
What are the key takeaways from Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith?
- We are what we love: Human beings are primarily shaped by what they desire, not just by what they think or believe.
- Worship shapes worldview: Christian worship practices form our imaginations and desires, giving rise to doctrines and worldviews.
- Secular liturgies are formative: Everyday cultural practices act as liturgies that shape our loves and identities, often unconsciously.
- Education as formation: Christian education should focus on shaping desires and loves through embodied practices, not just transmitting ideas.
What does James K.A. Smith mean by "we are what we love" in Desiring the Kingdom?
- Desire over intellect: Smith argues that our core identity is shaped by what we ultimately love or desire, rather than by what we think or believe.
- Love as teleological: Our loves are always aimed at some vision of the good life, which directs our actions and habits.
- Formation through practices: These desires are formed and directed by embodied, habitual practices—liturgies—that train our hearts and imaginations.
How does Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith critique the "worldview" approach in Christian education?
- Limits of cognitive focus: Smith critiques the worldview model for being too intellectualist, focusing on ideas while neglecting the affective and embodied dimensions of human identity.
- Believer vs. lover: He argues that even the "person-as-believer" model is too head-centered, failing to account for the formative power of practices.
- Social imaginary emphasis: Smith proposes focusing on the Christian "social imaginary"—the embodied, pre-theoretical understanding shaped by worship practices.
What is a "social imaginary" according to Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith?
- Definition: A social imaginary is the noncognitive, affective, and embodied way people imagine their social world, carried in images, stories, and practices.
- Shift from worldview: Smith suggests moving from the concept of worldview to social imaginary to better capture how people are formed by practices and rituals.
- Christian social imaginary: Christian worship practices embody a distinct social imaginary that forms disciples' desires and imaginations toward the kingdom of God.
How does James K.A. Smith define "liturgies" in Desiring the Kingdom, and why are they important?
- Liturgies as ultimate rituals: Liturgies are ritual practices of ultimate concern that form identity by shaping our desires toward particular visions of the good life.
- Secular and sacred: Smith expands liturgy beyond religious rituals to include secular cultural practices (like shopping or sports) that function as pedagogies of desire.
- Formation through liturgies: Liturgies shape us at a bodily and affective level, often unconsciously, making them central to understanding cultural formation and discipleship.
What are some examples of secular liturgies analyzed in Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith?
- The mall as liturgy: Smith describes the mall as a liturgical space with rituals and icons that form desires around consumerism and competition.
- Nationalism and entertainment: He analyzes rituals like the national anthem at sports events as liturgies that shape allegiance and identity.
- University rituals: Practices like Freshers’ Week and fraternity life are examined as liturgies that form students’ desires and identities, often promoting consumerism and competition.
How does Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith describe the relationship between Christian worship and worldview?
- Primacy of worship: Worship is prior to worldview; Christians first participate in embodied practices that form their desires, from which doctrines and worldviews emerge.
- Worship as pedagogy: Christian worship educates the heart and imagination through rituals, shaping a Christian social imaginary.
- Sacramental imagination: Worship affirms the goodness of creation and materiality, engaging believers in material signs that mediate God’s grace.
What is the "sacramental imagination" in Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith, and why is it significant?
- Materiality of worship: The sacramental imagination recognizes that Christian worship is deeply embodied and material, involving senses and physical elements.
- Resisting dualisms: It counters both gnostic (matter is evil) and naturalistic (world is empty of divine presence) views, affirming creation as charged with God’s glory.
- Formation through sacramentality: This imagination forms believers to see the world as sacramental, where ordinary things become means of grace.
What vision for Christian education does James K.A. Smith propose in Desiring the Kingdom?
- Formation over information: Christian education should focus on shaping desires and imaginations through participation in Christian practices, not just imparting a Christian perspective.
- Ecclesial university: Smith envisions Christian colleges as extensions of the church’s worship and formation practices, integrating liturgical formation into pedagogy.
- Counter-formation: Christian education must intentionally provide a counter-pedagogy to secular liturgies, cultivating love for God and neighbor.
How can Christian worship practices inform pedagogy and faculty development according to Desiring the Kingdom by James K.A. Smith?
- Embodied learning: Pedagogy should extend the embodied, affective formation of worship by incorporating practices that engage students’ whole selves.
- Integration of worship and learning: Worship practices provide a formative matrix that fuels imagination and desire, which can be amplified in classroom learning.
- Faculty as ecclesial scholars: Christian scholarship and teaching should emerge from participation in worship, making faculty ecclesial scholars formed by the church’s social imaginary.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.