Plot Summary
Five Million, Seven Sessions
Kindergarten teacher Mickey Morris learns from her father Adam’s obituary that he has died and has not named her among his loved ones. She is minding Ian, a five-year-old whose mother has failed to collect him, when Adam’s lawyer, Tom Samson, explains that Mickey stands to inherit $5.5 million, but only after seven therapy sessions.
That same evening, Mickey takes Ian to the address on his school file and finds his uncle Chris instead. Chris admits he cannot care for the boy, so Mickey leaves him with a phone number and insists he take responsibility for the night. Adam’s money is not a simple gift: he has made access to it depend on Mickey facing a past she has spent years avoiding.
The inheritance turns grief into a task with a price tag, forcing Mickey to confront the contradiction she has built her life around: she wants nothing from her absent father, yet his attention still has power over her. The therapy condition is both an attempt at repair and an intrusion, because Adam has arranged care without asking whether she wants it. Ian’s abandonment by his mother echoes Mickey’s childhood, and her decision to stay with him reveals the tenderness she hides behind isolation. She can recognize a child’s need more easily than her own.
An Urn Changes Hands
At Adam’s funeral, his younger daughter Arlo, a psychologist known to her family as Charlotte, is already managing the ceremony and her grieving mother, Leonora. When Adam’s first wife, Deborah, seizes his urn and condemns the man who harmed her, Arlo calms the confrontation and persuades her to put it back. Her skill earns an offer from her mentor, Punam, to return to their practice after a professional suspension.
Later, after Arlo sleeps with Tom, the lawyer tells her that Adam changed his will and left her nothing. Arlo cannot accept that the father she cared for through his final illness would exclude her, so she begins searching for an explanation, clinging to the belief that his choice must have been loving rather than cruel.
Arlo’s public composure is not proof that she is emotionally settled. At the funeral, she converts expertise into action, containing Deborah’s anger and organizing the room, because caretaking gives her a role when grief leaves her unsure who she is. The inheritance news punctures that role. If Adam’s decision was deliberate, then Arlo must reconsider the story that her sacrifices made her indispensable to him. Her reflex is to defend his character, which protects both her memories and the structure of her identity.
A Classroom Goes Quiet
Mickey’s attempt to protect Ian from the child-welfare system puts her job at risk. On Monday, school administrators suspend her without pay for driving him off school grounds after Jean, the principal, had instructed her to call authorities.
Mickey cannot accept that the classroom she has devoted twelve years to is no longer hers, and she falls among the toys while arguing with the substitute. She begins the required therapy with Arlo, trying to present herself as stable and asking to compress all seven sessions into a short course.
When Arlo asks about people in her life, Mickey insists adults act from self-interest and keeps her father at a distance. The session makes her defensive, but it also starts the work she had hoped to finish without being changed by it.
The suspension removes more than income: it strips Mickey of the daily structure that organizes her attention and gives her a socially acceptable reason to care for others. Her collapse amid classroom toys makes that dependence visible before she can name it. In therapy, she treats the intake as a performance and tries to control the timetable, repeating the same strategy she uses with alcohol: contain the discomfort, meet the requirement, and leave unchanged. Arlo’s questions unsettle her certainty, though her distrust is not merely cynicism. It is a survival rule formed in a childhood where adults were unreliable.
Chris Calls After Dark
After her first session, Mickey is at a café when Chris calls because Ian cannot stop vomiting. She goes to the house and finds Chris panicking, convinced the child may have a deadly infection.
Mickey cools Ian, gives him small drinks, and settles him with a stuffed rabbit; Chris watches, relieved to have someone who knows what to do. Over Scotch afterward, they admit that both grew up with fathers who left. Chris explains that his sister Evelyn had promised to return soon after leaving Ian with him, while Mickey tells him about the inheritance and her suspension.
Their shared history makes the conversation intimate, and Chris’s attention draws Mickey toward a family-shaped closeness she does not know how to trust. She leaves with his invitation to keep coming back.
Mickey’s care for Ian is practical rather than sentimental: she reads his fever, adjusts the sleeping bag, and offers comfort without asking the child to perform gratitude. That competence lets Chris see a side of her she tries to conceal from adults. Their conversation creates intimacy through parallel absences, but it also exposes how quickly Mickey can confuse being useful with being safe. Her attraction to Chris is bound up with the domestic scene she longs for and fears: a child, dinner, and a person who might notice if she disappeared.
The Café Turns on Tom
Arlo takes Mickey to a social café exercise, hoping conversation with strangers will loosen her distrust. Tom joins their table, and Mickey recognizes him as Adam’s lawyer. Instead of practicing small talk, she presses him about his loneliness and past affairs until he breaks down crying in public.
Arlo stops the exercise, then tells Mickey that she used private information to humiliate him. Mickey admits it did not make her feel better. That night, ashamed and drunk, she finds Tom asleep in his office and apologizes while drinking mouthwash from a bottle.
He sees how unwell she is, but before he can help, she collapses. Mickey wakes in hospital with an IV, her belongings beside Tom, who has stayed and told staff he is her father so she would not be alone.
Mickey’s public attack is an experiment in proving that people are selfish, but its real target is her own hope that someone might behave differently. Tom’s tears refuse the role she assigned him, leaving her with the shame of having harmed a vulnerable person rather than exposed a villain. The collapse makes her drinking impossible to keep at the level of private habit. Tom’s decision to stay complicates her rule that closeness always ends in betrayal, but kindness alone cannot resolve the illness she is hiding.
A Birthday Ends in Glass
Mickey invites Daria, Tom, Chris, and Ian to celebrate her birthday, wanting a small gathering without admitting how much she wants company. She drinks throughout the day and arrives at dinner already impaired. When her guests notice, Mickey tries to keep drinking rather than acknowledge what is happening. She loses control of a glass decanter, which shatters and sends a shard into Ian’s eye.
Tom carries Mickey away while Chris and the others get Ian emergency care; doctors save the eye, though Ian must wear a patch. Mickey later calls Arlo in tears and recounts the accident. The injury destroys her claim that alcohol only harms herself. It also leaves Ian hurt by the adult who had once made him feel safe.
The birthday gathering briefly assembles the relationships Mickey wants, but alcohol turns the room into a test she cannot pass. Ian’s injury makes the cost concrete and relational: her intoxication has reached a child who trusted her. Her shame is intensified by the contrast between her professional identity as a protective teacher and her conduct at home. The event does not magically produce recovery. It does, however, break through the argument that drinking is a harmless private choice, forcing Mickey to look at consequences she can no longer explain away.
The Beneficiary Is Family
Arlo searches for the person Adam named in his will, visits Deborah’s hair salon, and learns that Mickey has struggled with drinking since college. Still desperate to learn why she was cut out, Arlo breaks into Tom’s office and steals a confidential estate file.
It identifies the beneficiary as Michelle Kowalski, also known as Mickey Morris. Arlo now knows that her client is her half-sister, but she hides the discovery and keeps treating her, even probing whether Mickey deserves the inheritance.
In session, Mickey describes Adam’s drinking, his cruelty toward Deborah, and his warmth toward her as a child. She admits that she misses him despite resenting him. Arlo’s private grief and professional ambition now distort a relationship that should have been ended or disclosed.
The file transforms two parallel grief stories into a family relationship, but Arlo responds by concealing rather than revealing the fact that should change the work. Her behavior is not driven only by money. She wants proof that Adam’s choice has a comprehensible meaning, and she uses therapeutic access to search for it. Mickey’s account of her father likewise resists a clean verdict: the same man could play with her and terrorize her mother. Their shared history begins not as solidarity but as an ethical breach shaped by competing needs.
Fifteen Thousand for Rybka
Mickey tries to stop drinking abruptly, then discovers how severe the withdrawal has become. Meanwhile, Evelyn threatens to complain to the school unless Mickey pays her $50,000 over Ian’s injury and Mickey’s decision to take him home. Mickey cannot borrow from Tom and backs away from a high-interest loan, but desperation wins elsewhere: she takes Daria’s cat, Rybka, and pawns her for $15,500.
She gives Evelyn $10,000, then learns that Evelyn plans to move Ian to Trail. Mickey’s attempt to keep the family together has become another betrayal, and Chris rejects her claim that she should decide what is best for Ian. When Arlo later finds the pawnshop, she realizes Mickey has crossed a line she cannot explain away as an accident.
Mickey’s crisis is not a straight descent but a series of choices made under bodily distress and financial panic. Withdrawal narrows her attention to immediate relief; Evelyn’s demand adds a deadline and exploits Mickey’s fear of losing her livelihood. Taking Rybka repeats the pattern Mickey has been trying to disown, turning affection for Daria into a resource to be converted into cash. Her wish to protect Ian is genuine, but it also lets her impose herself on a family without consent. Good intentions do not cancel the damage.
Two Daughters Take the Mic
At Adam’s headstone unveiling, Arlo abandons her prepared remarks and admits to the crowd that her father was cruel, that he cut her from the will, and that she has been treating the beneficiary without revealing their connection.
Mickey, present among the mourners, steps forward and identifies herself as Adam’s older daughter. She describes the debt, drinking, and abuse that drove her and Deborah from their home, then condemns the family’s celebration of him. Her accusation leaves Arlo exposed and Leonora in tears.
Mickey leaves with a flask, drinks among the graves, then empties it into the snow and throws it away. Still not sober, she goes directly to an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting, where a stranger lends her a sweater and she chooses to stay.
The ceremony forces private versions of Adam into the same public space. Arlo stops protecting the polished father she remembers; Mickey refuses to let that memory erase the family he abandoned. Neither account cancels the other, and the daughters’ clash exposes the limits of inherited loyalty. Mickey’s decision to pour out the flask is not a cure, but her next action matters: she enters a meeting while still intoxicated instead of retreating into isolation. The movement from public accusation to a room of strangers marks the first modest shift from proving a point to asking for help.
Reinstated, Then Stepping Away
After the unveiling, Mickey’s mother Deborah confronts her estrangement and Mickey begins apologizing without demanding immediate forgiveness. Arlo, meanwhile, faces Laura Hedman’s mother and admits to Punam that she ended Laura’s final session early after Laura signaled profound despair.
The lawsuit had cleared Arlo, but she now recognizes that her avoidance and self-justification have not. Tom agrees to represent Mickey at the school inquiry. Arlo attends as a character witness, praises Mickey’s care for her students, and admits to the panel that she herself acted dishonestly for personal gain.
The board votes to reinstate Mickey. Rather than return to the classroom as if nothing happened, Mickey requests sick leave, deciding that getting well must take priority over resuming the work that once gave her life its structure.
The inquiry gives both women a public test of accountability. Arlo’s testimony matters because she does not preserve her reputation at Mickey’s expense; she names her own misconduct and uses what she has learned about Mickey’s teaching to support her. Mickey’s reinstatement could have restored the identity she clung to, but she refuses to mistake employment for recovery. Arlo’s reckoning with Laura also unsettles the distinction she has maintained between professional competence and private grief. Neither woman is absolved by confession. Each begins to accept responsibility without pretending that responsibility means total control.
A Cat Comes Home
Once the inheritance is released, Mickey returns Rybka to Daria and gives Evelyn the remaining money she had promised. Evelyn refuses to keep it and plans to put it toward Ian’s future. Mickey apologizes to Chris and Ian, then accepts that Ian will leave with his mother for Trail, even though losing him hurts.
She also meets Deborah, acknowledges the harm her drinking caused, and tells her she will enter residential treatment in January. Arlo quits practicing psychology and moves in with Leonora, whose own efforts to build a life after Adam’s death have begun to change their relationship.
The sisters do not settle their conflict or become instant family. Instead, Mickey takes the first steps toward sustained care, while Arlo stops using work as a substitute for examining herself.
Repair in this section is deliberately partial. Mickey restores what she can, returns the cat, pays Evelyn, and says goodbye to Ian, but none of these actions purchases closeness or erases the injury. Her apology to Deborah becomes credible because she pairs it with a plan for treatment rather than asking words to do all the work. Arlo’s resignation is similarly a beginning, not a redemption. Both women relinquish roles that had organized their lives: Mickey the indispensable teacher, Arlo the expert who fixes everyone else. Their next steps remain uncertain, which is precisely why they matter.
Epilogue
Five weeks into an eight-week residential program, Mickey is learning routines, attending treatment, and sharing a room with other patients. Arlo visits, and the sisters walk together through the grounds, awkwardly trading observations about the spring weather. Mickey offers Arlo half of the inheritance, believing they both paid dearly for Adam’s choices.
Arlo resists taking it, but their conversation shifts from accusation toward an imperfect shared understanding: their father harmed them in different ways, and neither can repair the other by herself. They keep walking through muddy ground, holding on to each other when the path gets difficult.
The epilogue avoids making recovery look like a finished transformation. Mickey is still in treatment, still anxious about visitors, and still unsure whether she and Arlo can become close. Her offer to split the money is not a neat settlement of their father’s debts; it is an attempt to recognize a shared injury without claiming that money can measure it. Arlo accepts neither a simple sisterhood nor an easy absolution. Their physical need to steady each other on the muddy path gives the ending its modest force: connection is possible, but it remains a practice, not a guarantee.
Analysis
Favourite Daughter treats recovery not as a revelation that explains everything, but as a sequence of decisions made after self-explanations stop working. Mickey’s drinking begins as a tool for controlling the volume of painful memory; once it injures Ian, the private coping mechanism becomes a public responsibility. Her progress is therefore measured less by declarations of sobriety than by concrete acts: entering a meeting, returning Rybka, accepting medical leave, and choosing residential treatment. The setbacks matter because the story refuses to make insight equivalent to change.
The novel’s central family question is not whether Adam loved either daughter, but whether love can be separated from harm. Mickey and Arlo inherit different versions of him, and both resist evidence that threatens their own. Mickey’s anger protects her from longing; Arlo’s devotion turns caregiving into proof that she mattered. Their conflict exposes how children can remain organized around a parent long after that parent has left, and how grief may loosen old loyalties without instantly replacing them.
Arlo’s professional misconduct mirrors the family dynamic rather than standing apart from it. She knows how to interpret other people but uses that expertise to manage her own uncertainty, treating Mickey while concealing their connection and hoping the work will resolve an inheritance dispute. Her eventual public admission does not erase the breach; it begins accountability. Likewise, Mickey’s apology cannot compel forgiveness from Deborah, Chris, or Daria. The book’s hard-won optimism rests on this distinction: people can change, but change is not a clean slate. It is repeated attention to the harm one causes, to the care one accepts, and to the relationships one cannot control.
Review Summary
Favorite Daughter by Morgan Dick receives mixed but mostly positive reviews, averaging 3.64 stars. Readers praise the complex family dynamics, emotional depth, and realistic portrayal of alcoholism and grief between estranged half-sisters Mickey and Arlo. Many appreciate the flawed, messy characters and hopeful ending, though some find them unlikeable. The novel explores themes of abandonment, addiction, and forgiveness. Critics note contrived plot points, rushed character development, and ethical concerns. While some found it emotionally shallow or slow-paced, most readers were engaged by the compelling premise and authentic depiction of trauma and recovery.
People Also Read
Characters
Mickey Morris
The guarded kindergarten teacherMickey is a dedicated kindergarten teacher whose patience with children contrasts with her suspicion of adults. She has built independence into a defense: if she expects betrayal, she can tell herself she never needed anyone. Her relationship with her father left her with competing memories of affection, fear, and abandonment, while alcohol helps her blunt feelings she cannot comfortably name. Mickey notices what vulnerable children need and responds with practical tenderness, yet struggles to extend that attention to herself. Her blunt humor and vivid inner life mask a fragile sense of worth. She is not simply cynical or self-destructive; she is someone trying to live by rules that once helped her survive but now keep her isolated.
Arlo
The therapist who needs helpArlo, born Charlotte and nicknamed by her father, is a young psychologist who is accustomed to reading other people and organizing their pain into workable steps. Her confidence rests partly on genuine skill and partly on the belief that understanding others can protect her from her own grief. She is devoted to her father and has spent much of her life caring for him, making it difficult to separate love from obligation. Arlo is perceptive, ambitious, and capable of real compassion, but she can mistake insight for ethical permission. Her professional language offers order when family life feels unstable. Beneath it is a daughter still trying to earn a secure place in her father’s affections.
Adam Kowalski
The father remembered differentlyAdam is the father shared by Mickey and Arlo, though the two daughters know different versions of him. He is remembered as playful and affectionate by one, and as a volatile drinker who abandoned his first family by the other. His charm and failures coexist, complicating any effort to make him wholly loving or wholly cruel. Even when absent, his decisions shape how both women understand money, loyalty, and their own worth.
Chris
The uncertain uncleChris is Ian’s uncle, a finance professional who has taken in his young nephew despite feeling unprepared to parent. His confidence at work does not translate into confidence with children, and he worries that his own absent father has left him without a model. Mickey’s practical help draws him into a tentative friendship with her. His kindness is real, but he has limits and can be clumsy when trying to express concern.
Ian
The watchful five-year-oldIan is Mickey’s kindergarten student, a quiet observer with a strong imagination and a love of Lego starfighters. He notices changes in adults more quickly than they expect and asks direct questions when they try to hide their feelings. His mother’s instability and his uncle’s inexperience leave him needing dependable care. Ian’s attachment to Mickey grows through small routines, games, and the attention she gives him.
Deborah
Mickey’s fiercely loving motherDeborah is Mickey’s mother and Adam’s first wife. She has endured a painful marriage and worked to create a life beyond it, including building her own hair salon. Her care for Mickey is deep, but she has also had to set boundaries when her daughter’s choices became damaging. Deborah’s brisk humor and directness can look like hardness; beneath them is a woman trying to love without surrendering her own stability.
Leonora
Arlo’s grieving motherLeonora is Adam’s second wife and Arlo’s mother. She often relies on appearance, routines, and possessions to manage uncertainty, and she has long made choices within the constraints of her marriage. Her grief reveals a more vulnerable side than Arlo expects. Leonora’s efforts to imagine a life independent of Adam unsettle her daughter, who has relied on their shared devotion to him as a source of identity.
Tom Samson
The conflicted estate lawyerTom is the lawyer responsible for Adam’s estate and the person who explains the unusual conditions attached to Mickey’s inheritance. He is lonely, self-aware enough to recognize some of his worst habits, and trying to change them through therapy. His choices are not consistently wise or ethical, particularly where grief and attraction intersect. Tom can be awkwardly sincere, and he sometimes offers practical care when others fail to do so.
Daria
The blunt neighbor and friendDaria is Mickey’s neighbor, an accomplished artist who lives simply and speaks with disarming directness. She does not indulge Mickey’s excuses, but her candor is balanced by affection and hospitality. She invites Mickey to walk, asks hard questions about her drinking, and offers companionship without demanding that Mickey become someone else first. Daria’s independence is genuine, though she is less solitary than she once believed.
Evelyn
Ian’s overwhelmed motherEvelyn is Chris’s younger half-sister and Ian’s mother. She became a parent while still a child herself and has struggled to sustain the responsibilities that followed. Her choices can be selfish and hurtful, but they are also shaped by immaturity, financial strain, and a wish to escape a life that overwhelmed her. Evelyn’s relationship with Chris is complicated by old family disappointments and competing ideas about what Ian needs.
Punam
Arlo’s exacting mentorPunam is an experienced psychologist and Arlo’s supervisor. She recognizes Arlo’s talent while questioning whether talent alone makes her ready to practice. Her mentorship combines support with scrutiny, especially around professional boundaries, risk, and the emotional residue of difficult cases. Punam’s questions are sometimes uncomfortable, but they arise from a genuine concern for clients and for the therapist Arlo is becoming.
Jean Donoghue
The rule-bound principalJean is Mickey’s school principal. She is practical, policy-minded, and eager to leave when Ian’s mother fails to arrive. Her decision to let Mickey stay with the child shows both her willingness to rely on Mickey and the institution’s limits when a situation becomes complicated.
Laura Hedman
Arlo’s troubled former clientLaura is a young woman Arlo once treated for severe anxiety and depression. She tries hard to meet expectations and often presents herself as more capable than she feels. Her relationship with Arlo becomes a lasting source of professional and personal distress, exposing the limits of reassurance when a client’s risk is not fully understood.
Jennifer Hedman
Laura’s grieving motherJennifer is Laura’s mother, carrying grief that has narrowed her world and sharpened her anger. She approaches Arlo with a mixture of accusation and vulnerability, showing how bereavement can hold a person between the wish to forgive and the need to name a failure.
Vera
The plainspoken social workerVera is a hospital social worker who speaks plainly and does not force Mickey to answer questions before she is ready. Her unpolished manner and practical concern make her a steady presence during a frightening moment, offering options without pretending she can decide Mickey’s future for her.
Roger
The welcoming meeting regularRoger is an older attendee at an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting. He recognizes Mickey from the café and offers her his sweater when she arrives cold and unsteady. His welcome is simple, giving her a way to remain in the room without requiring her to explain herself first.
Plot Devices
The conditional inheritance
Money tied to therapyAdam’s will places $5.5 million in trust for Mickey, with access dependent on completing seven psychotherapy sessions within three months. The condition creates the novel’s central pressure: Mickey must attend therapy to receive money she does not know whether she wants, while Arlo’s father has placed both daughters inside a plan neither chose. The money gives grief a deadline and tempts characters to treat emotional change as a transaction. It also makes professional boundaries crucial, since the inheritance connects the therapist, the client, and the family history.
Alternating viewpoints
Two histories, one fatherThe novel alternates between Mickey and Arlo, allowing readers to see how the same father produced sharply different memories and loyalties. Mickey’s early chapters emphasize abandonment, poverty, and her mother’s struggle; Arlo’s show the intimacy of caregiving and the family life built after Adam left. The separate viewpoints delay the full shape of their connection while making their judgments legible. Once the sisters’ relationship emerges, neither account simply cancels the other, and the reader must hold both tenderness and harm in view.
Mickey’s hidden bottle
A private coping ritualMickey carries vodka in an ordinary water bottle and uses it to steady herself through work, loneliness, and difficult memories. Because the container looks harmless, it lets her preserve the story that her drinking is controlled and invisible. As her life grows less stable, she drinks in riskier settings, substitutes mouthwash when liquor is unavailable, and experiences dangerous withdrawal when she stops abruptly. The bottle therefore tracks a change from concealment to consequence, linking her coping strategy to the harm it causes other people.
The estate file
A secret turns personalThe confidential estate paperwork identifies Mickey as the beneficiary under both her birth name and the name she uses as an adult. Arlo steals the file while searching for the reason she was excluded from the will. It gives her the knowledge that Mickey is her half-sister, but instead of ending their therapy relationship, she keeps the secret and allows her own financial grief to influence her work. The file shifts Arlo from a grieving daughter seeking answers into a professional with privileged knowledge she has no right to exploit.
Keepsakes and ashes
Grief made physicalAdam’s urn, the family photograph, his shoes, and a small amount of his ashes give the characters objects to handle when their memories become difficult to bear. Arlo tries to preserve her father through belongings and an ash-filled locket; Mickey encounters him through an old photograph and childhood memories. These objects do not provide a stable account of who Adam was. Instead, each one exposes how memory is selected, protected, and revised as the daughters begin to compare their experiences.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.