Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
First & Then

First & Then

A bookish senior accepts a football star's homecoming invitation, but can either risk being known?
by Emma Mills 2015 272 pages
3.91
17k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

A Life Without Plot

College looms while Foster settles into Devon's home

Seventeen-year-old Devon Tennyson hands her college counselor a careless essay about school lunches and admits she has no clear reason to attend college beyond parental expectation. She sees herself as ordinary, with few activities to distinguish her from other applicants.

At home, her cousin Foster has been living with Devon's family since his father died and his mother, Elizabeth, became unable to care for him. Devon resents the new responsibility even as her parents try to make Foster feel welcome.

Her closest companion is Cas Kincaid, a football player she has loved quietly for years, while Temple Sterling's celebrated running back, Ezra Lynley, remains a distant figure on the field. The counselor pushes Devon to find an activity, and Foster's presence begins changing the routine she thought she understood.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Devon's problem is not simply low achievement. She has adopted the belief that a meaningful life must first look impressive to other people, then feels ashamed that hers does not. Foster unsettles this self-protective stance because his needs cannot be converted into a college credential or neatly managed as an extracurricular. Her Austen-inspired habit of imagining herself as a heroine offers both wit and distance: she can observe her life as a story before she risks acting inside it.

A Ball Finds Foster

Ezra notices a talent Devon never expected

In freshman-heavy gym class, Devon reluctantly partners with Ezra, who treats her with brusque indifference. Foster joins them for a football drill, botches a throw, then unexpectedly launches a remarkable kick.

Ezra sees more than luck in the distance and accuracy, coaches Foster through repeated attempts, and urges him to try out for the freshman team. Devon accompanies Foster to the field, where coaches confirm his unusual ability and give him a place at practice. Foster admits that no one back home had cared about his kicking.

His new chance therefore means more than football: it gives him a skill adults and teammates can recognize. Ezra's decision to train him also creates the first connection between the distant star player and Devon's awkward, newly arrived cousin.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Foster's talent arrives through accident, but recognition turns it into a possible identity. His restrained response to praise suggests a child accustomed to keeping expectations low, so the invitation to practice carries emotional weight beyond its athletic promise. Ezra, meanwhile, reveals character through attention rather than warmth. He notices what others miss and offers instruction without making Foster perform gratitude. Devon's surprise exposes how thoroughly she has mistaken Foster's oddness for incapacity.

Varsity's New Kicker

Foster rises as Devon enters football's orbit

Foster's kick earns him a varsity opportunity, rare for a freshman, and he converts extra points in his first game. Ezra continues training him, while Jordan Hunter welcomes him among the players. Devon watches from the sideline carrying equipment for the school newspaper, a role Rachel Woodson has arranged to strengthen her college applications.

Rachel asks her to help investigate whether high-school football has become a contest for individual statistics, and points to Ezra's extraordinary record as evidence.

Devon also spends time with Marabelle Finch, a pregnant younger student whose directness and odd humor resist easy judgment. Foster begins seeking Marabelle out, while Devon notices Ezra's patient attention to him. The football field, once a place where Devon watched from the margins, now links her to people and conflicts she had barely understood.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The rise of Foster and Devon's newspaper assignment place two kinds of performance beside each other. Foster's ability earns immediate, public recognition; Devon's college profile requires her to manufacture evidence of involvement. Rachel's suspicion of football's statistics culture complicates the local reverence for Ezra, while Marabelle complicates Devon's tendency to classify people before knowing them. The section builds a social web through specific acts of attention: Ezra coaches Foster, Devon observes, and her observations begin to change her judgments.

The Party Upstairs

Foster hosts friends and kisses Marabelle

Devon's parents throw Foster a party to celebrate his place on the team, and Devon fears nobody will come. Marabelle arrives first, followed by Ezra, who is close enough to Foster to settle comfortably beside him.

Football players, popular girls, and Foster's science-club peers eventually fill the house, and Foster moves among them with an ease Devon did not know he possessed. Upstairs, he and Marabelle trade questions about their families and discover a shared comfort in blunt honesty.

Foster tells her he likes her, and they kiss. Devon later learns that Ezra and Marabelle are stepsiblings, a connection Ezra has kept private. Watching Foster claim a life among new friends forces Devon to revise her assumption that he needs her to manage every social situation.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The party reverses Devon's expectation of who will struggle to belong. She prepares to rescue Foster from an empty room, only to find him making connections on his own terms. His exchange with Marabelle is awkward but reciprocal, unlike the polished social performances Devon thinks she lacks. The stepsibling revelation also reframes Ezra's private loyalty: Foster is not merely a promising player to him. Yet Devon still reads these relationships from doorways, half witness and half participant.

Reeding Becomes Real

A campus visit gives Devon a future to want

Rachel helps Devon rebuild her résumé and sends her to assist in freshman English, where Devon discovers that she can guide a struggling student through a difficult essay. The school trip to Reeding University makes college tangible: Devon tours its buildings, sits in on a class, and imagines a life beyond Temple Sterling.

On the beach, she talks with Ezra about loving football even when it brings frustration, and recognizes how little she understands his interior life. After the trip, Devon's parents tell her that Elizabeth has surrendered her parental rights and they plan to adopt Foster.

Devon feels relief, anger, and guilt at once. Foster takes the news quietly, and when Devon calls Ezra, he comes over to sit with them. His presence gives Foster companionship without demanding that he explain his feelings.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Reeding matters because desire finally precedes duty. Devon can imagine a future there before she knows exactly what she will do, a shift from merely obeying the presumed route to choosing it. Her teaching work similarly reveals competence through service rather than résumé language. The adoption news makes belonging more complicated: Devon is relieved Foster will remain safe, but understands that permanence arrives through his mother's rejection. Ezra's quiet visit models support that neither fixes nor interrogates grief.

Mud on the Goalpost

A missed kick unsettles Foster and his new place

In a rain-soaked game, Foster misses an extra point, and Temple Sterling loses. At home he throws down his muddy cleats and snaps at Devon when she tries to comfort him, insisting that a better kick could have changed the result.

His frustration shows how seriously he has begun to take his responsibility to the team. Devon continues her newspaper work and tutoring, helping a freshman revise an essay, while Rachel publishes a sharp article questioning Ezra's motives for transferring schools.

Ezra answers Devon's questions thoughtfully, then asks her to attend Homecoming with him. Cas also assumes he and Devon will go together, but Devon tells him she has accepted Ezra. She cannot yet say what she feels for Ezra, but the choice makes her old, unspoken arrangement with Cas harder to maintain.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Foster's mistake matters because he has invested the role with purpose. His anger is not vanity so much as fear that he has failed a team that gave him a place. Devon's growing competence outside football parallels that development: she helps another student without needing to be the best in the room. Ezra's invitation and Cas's presumption expose the emotional cost of habit. Devon has treated closeness with Cas as a permanent arrangement, and choosing differently forces that assumption into view.

Sam's Empty Place

A teammate's death exposes old family grief

Temple Sterling learns that Sam Wells, captain of neighboring Lake Falls, has died in a car crash after drinking. Ezra knew Sam from football camps, and Devon finds him outside the visitation, unable to enter.

He blames Sam for making a preventable choice, then breaks down as Devon holds him and lets him count to steady himself. Foster attends the service and later questions why mourners speak only of the good in someone who made a dangerous mistake. His thoughts turn to Elizabeth and to Devon's father, whom he believes could have helped her before her addiction worsened.

Devon cannot settle the accusation, but understands that Foster finds blame easier to bear than helplessness. The death leaves both boys carrying private histories into a game that is supposed to be ordinary.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Sam's death turns a local rivalry into a confrontation with responsibility and loss. Ezra's anger protects him from the helplessness of mourning, while his counting provides a concrete ritual when language fails. Foster approaches grief differently: he resists the social pressure to make the dead innocent and uses that resistance to approach his mother's failures. His accusation toward Devon's father is painful partly because it offers a target for grief. Devon's role is not to adjudicate the past, but to stay present while Foster tests what he can say.

Lake Falls Goes Quiet

Ezra accuses Foster after a costly loss

Against Lake Falls, Ezra plays brilliantly until the coaches bench him at halftime to avoid appearing to exploit the death of their captain. He erupts at the decision, and Lake Falls rallies to take the lead. With seconds left, Foster misses a long field goal, giving Lake Falls the win.

Ezra accuses him of missing deliberately; Devon pulls Foster away and tells Ezra that his own anger and self-importance have made him unfair. The next morning, Ezra apologizes to Foster, who forgives him but says Devon is the person he looks up to.

Devon remains hurt by Ezra and later refuses to continue with their Homecoming plan after an awkward gym-class encounter. Her anger protects her from an attraction she cannot yet trust, but it also closes the door she wanted Ezra to open.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The game forces the characters to distinguish performance from moral worth. Ezra cannot accept that a loss might be shaped by context, and he transfers his frustration onto the youngest player on the field. Devon's defense of Foster is a genuine act of loyalty, but her later rejection of Ezra shows how quickly protection can become avoidance. Foster's forgiveness is not proof that Ezra was right; it reflects Foster's capacity to recognize distress without erasing harm. Devon still struggles to offer that same distinction.

Homecoming's Wrong Pairings

Devon sees the crushes she has misread

At Homecoming, Devon attends without a date, while Foster goes with Gwin Holtzer. She sees Ezra standing close to Lindsay Renshaw and retreats outside, believing she has lost him. Cas arrives with Gwin's younger sister Gracie, and in the hallway he tells Devon that he knows she has loved him for years.

Devon refuses to confirm it, recognizing that Cas's concern has often allowed him to enjoy her devotion without returning it. Jordan dances with her and offers uncomplicated kindness.

The evening breaks Devon's reliance on imagined endings: Cas will not become her partner simply because she has waited, and Ezra's intentions cannot be inferred from a dance-floor tableau. She leaves the dance with Foster, still hoping to keep him safe while unsure what she wants for herself.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The dance compresses Devon's romantic illusions into visible pairings, but the deeper rupture comes from Cas naming her feelings as though they were public property. His awareness has not amounted to reciprocation; it has let him manage her attachment without confronting its cost. Devon's refusal is an early act of self-respect, even though it is delivered through embarrassment rather than calm certainty. Jordan's friendship offers a countermodel to romance as validation: care can be real without promising possession.

The Pool Rescue

Devon dives in when Stanton holds Ezra under

After the dance, Devon drives Foster and Gwin to a party at Ezra's house, intending only to collect them later. In the crowded backyard, Stanton Perkins forces Ezra underwater while other guests mistake the struggle for horseplay. Devon drops her phone, kicks off her shoes, and jumps into the pool in her formal dress.

She kicks Stanton hard enough to release Ezra, then struggles to keep Ezra afloat because he cannot swim. Foster steps between them and tells Stanton not to insult his sister; Emir Zurivic's arrival keeps Stanton from escalating.

Ezra is safe, but Devon flees before he can speak to her. Inside the house she discovers that Marabelle lives there part-time as Ezra's stepsister. Seeing Lindsay comfort Ezra, Devon realizes that her jealousy is not about losing Cas alone: she wants the closeness she sees between Lindsay and Ezra.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The rescue converts Devon's emotional uncertainty into decisive physical action. She does not calculate whether Ezra deserves help or whether the crowd will approve; she sees danger and enters it. The scene also reverses familiar roles: Foster protects Devon, while Emir uses quiet authority to stop a bully. Devon's discovery of her jealousy is less a romantic revelation than an admission of desire. Yet she still retreats, showing that acting bravely in water is easier for her than remaining present for an intimate conversation.

The Letter's True Cause

Ezra explains the grief behind his transfer

In the days after the party, Devon avoids Ezra and Lindsay, while trying to return to schoolwork and her tutoring sessions. Rachel brings her a letter Ezra has sent to the Herald, correcting the claim that he transferred to improve his football statistics.

He moved because his mother remarried and his stepfather wanted to live near his daughter, Marabelle. Ezra also explains that his older brother Nick died in a crash caused by their father driving drunk, which is why Sam's death struck him so hard.

He apologizes for his conduct against Lake Falls. Devon is angry that Ezra trusted a newspaper before trusting her, but the letter gives her the context she lacked. At the district game that night, Foster participates in a fake field-goal play, then collapses after a hit.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Ezra's letter revises the story Devon and the town have told about him. The transfer was not a scheme for visibility, and his anger at Lake Falls came from a personal history he had kept sealed. Public disclosure is imperfect intimacy: Ezra can write what he struggles to say face-to-face, but Devon still feels the cost of being excluded. The concussion makes the competing meanings of family immediate. Foster's body is suddenly vulnerable, and Devon must act without the distance that books and speculation usually provide.

Three Hundred Seconds

Foster names his hurt, and Devon chooses Ezra

At the hospital, scans indicate that Foster has a concussion, and he reveals why hospitals terrify him: after his father died, his mother once failed to collect him from one. He says he felt like no one's son until Ezra used his name on the field. Devon admits Foster's pain belongs in their family now, and they hold each other while he cries.

Ezra arrives and leads them through a slow count that makes the next few minutes bearable. In the waiting room, Lindsay admits she asked Ezra to Homecoming to provoke jealousy, not because she loved him; she also makes clear that Ezra's feelings are for Devon.

Later, Ezra explains his shame about his father's role in Nick's death and admits he wanted Devon to like him from their first gym class. They kiss. Foster is discharged the next morning, says Marabelle has ended their tentative relationship, and rides home with Devon, who now thinks of him as her brother.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The hospital brings the novel's separate forms of abandonment into one room. Foster can hate his mother and still believe she loved him; Devon can hear that contradiction without trying to resolve it for him. Ezra's counting turns endurance into a shared practice, and Devon's hand in his marks a shift from interpreting him to meeting him. Their kiss does not erase shame or grief. It follows disclosure and mutual care, while Foster's ride home gives the ending its deepest resolution: family is not a blood fact alone, but a relationship they have chosen to inhabit.

Analysis

First and Then treats adolescence as a contest between the story a person tells about themself and the relationships that keep interrupting it. Devon begins with a familiar self-description: she is ordinary, underqualified, and waiting for a more convincing life to begin. Her attachment to Jane Austen gives her an elegant way to understand emotion, but it can also turn real people into roles. Cas becomes the expected beloved, Ezra the difficult romantic lead, and Devon herself the heroine who waits for a reversal. The plot advances when those templates fail. Cas's affection does not become love, Ezra's reserve conceals grief rather than contempt, and Foster's social awkwardness coexists with talent, desire, and moral clarity.

Football functions as both opportunity and public judgment. Foster finds belonging through an ability no one in his former home valued, while Ezra's record makes him a symbol onto which classmates project envy and suspicion. The Lake Falls game sharpens the novel's ethical question: does compassion require changing the outcome, or does fairness mean letting the contest stand? Ezra's fury is shaped by personal loss, but understanding the source does not erase the harm he causes Foster. The story allows explanation without treating it as absolution.

Family is similarly presented as a practice rather than a simple inheritance. Foster can resent his mother and still long to believe she loved him. Devon's parents offer him safety, but Devon must move from resenting that responsibility to choosing kinship herself. Her development is not a transformation into someone exceptional by conventional measures. It is the discovery that attention, teaching, loyalty, and courage already constitute meaningful action. The ending's happiness is deliberately modest: no grief disappears, no future is guaranteed, but Devon and Foster return home with a clearer sense of who belongs beside them.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Seventeen-year-old Devon Tennyson feels unremarkable and has no clear plans beyond applying to college. She resents the responsibility of sharing her home with her cousin Foster, whose mother can no longer care for him. When Foster's unexpected kicking talent earns him a place on the football team, star running back Ezra Lynley takes him under his wing, drawing Devon into their world. Devon accepts Ezra's invitation to homecoming, though she has long believed she is in love with her friend Cas. After a teammate dies in a drunk-driving crash, Ezra's grief fuels an outburst against Foster, and Devon pulls away. At a party, she rescues Ezra from an assault and recognizes her feelings for him. Foster later suffers a concussion and reveals his fear of abandonment. Ezra helps the family through the hospital wait, then explains his brother died in a crash caused by their drunk father. Devon and Ezra kiss. Foster recovers, ends things with Marabelle, and returns home with Devon, who now sees him as her brother.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.91 out of 5
Average of 17k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

First & Then is a widely beloved YA contemporary romance, averaging 3.91 stars. Most readers praise its charming characters, slow-burn romance, and heartwarming family dynamics, particularly the relationship between Devon and her cousin Foster. The Pride & Prejudice parallels and Friday Night Lights football atmosphere are frequently highlighted. Ezra, the brooding love interest, is a standout favorite. Critics note underdeveloped subplots, an anticlimactic ending, and early judgmental characterization from Devon. Overall, readers describe it as feel-good, funny, and emotionally resonant.

Your rating:
4.75
33 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Devon Tennyson

The observant almost-heroine

Devon is a witty, bookish seventeen-year-old who measures herself against the larger-than-life heroines of Jane Austen and worries that being ordinary makes her unworthy of attention. She is close to Cas, but her loyalty often keeps her from questioning what she wants. Her instinct is to watch, interpret, and privately narrate other people rather than risk being exposed herself. Yet she is also perceptive and capable of practical kindness: she helps Foster navigate school, supports Marabelle, and tutors a freshman. Devon's central drive is to discover a future that belongs to her, not merely one prescribed by parents or admissions forms. Her growth depends on learning that honest involvement matters more than a polished story about herself.

Foster

The unconventional cousin

Foster is Devon's fourteen-year-old cousin, living with her family after a childhood marked by bereavement and instability. He speaks with startling literalness, asks questions others avoid, and is often oblivious to ordinary social rules. His quirks can exhaust Devon, but they are also expressions of a mind that refuses to disguise what it notices. Football gives him a rare arena in which his natural kicking ability can earn trust, while his attachment to Devon's family grows at a pace he does not announce. Foster wants to contribute rather than merely be protected. His directness exposes how adults and teenagers use politeness to avoid painful truths, and his need for belonging is deeper than his odd habits suggest.

Ezra Lynley

The guarded football star

Ezra is Temple Sterling's celebrated running back, a disciplined athlete whose quiet intensity is often mistaken for arrogance. He is not naturally conversational and rarely performs the easy charm people expect from a star, but he pays close attention to skill, effort, and loyalty. His football ability gives him a clear future, while his reserve keeps classmates from seeing how much family history shapes him. Ezra mentors Foster with patience and treats football as a demanding commitment rather than a source of uncomplicated happiness. Devon first reads him through reputation and appearance, then gradually notices his humor and tenderness. He is drawn to people who are honest with him, even when that honesty makes him uncomfortable.

Cas Kincaid

Devon's longtime almost

Cas is Devon's best friend and a senior football player whose easy sociability contrasts with Ezra's reserve. He is energetic, funny, and generous with affection, often making Devon feel indispensable. That warmth, however, can blur the difference between friendship and romantic commitment. Cas likes being admired and enjoys the familiar closeness he shares with Devon, but he does not always consider what that closeness costs her. His interest in Lindsay brings the unspoken imbalance into sharper focus. Cas is neither a villain nor a secret ideal partner; he is a decent, imperfect teenager whose comfort with Devon has allowed both of them to postpone an honest reckoning.

Marabelle Finch

The candid young mother

Marabelle is a younger student who is pregnant and works with children at a beauty pageant school. Her manner is quiet and eccentric, and she often speaks as if the baby's needs are the clearest facts in the room. She can seem detached, but her choices show firm conviction: she intends to raise her child and wants him included in ordinary school life. Her friendship with Devon grows through small, unforced encounters, while Foster's directness appeals to her in a different way. Marabelle is not defined only by pregnancy; she has a history, family relationships, and work she cares about. Her unconventional humor gives her a way to face scrutiny without surrendering her decisions.

Lindsay Renshaw

The generous social sun

Lindsay is warm, athletic, and naturally attentive to people who might otherwise be left out. She becomes close to Cas and takes a genuine interest in Devon, inviting her to shop and imagining a shared college future. Her sunny manner is not the same as superficiality; she is capable of noticing hurt and admitting when she has caused it. Lindsay's instinct to smooth social tensions sometimes leads her to indirect choices, but her generosity is real. She represents the possibility that popularity need not require cruelty, and her friendship helps Devon see that affection can be offered without turning every relationship into a competition.

Jordan Hunter

The team's easy anchor

Jordan is a charismatic varsity player admired for his confidence, athletic skill, and ability to make others feel welcome. He is close to Ezra and Cas, but his loyalty does not depend on choosing sides in their rivalry. Jordan sees the insecurity beneath both a star's reserve and a friend's charm, and he offers Devon reassurance without demanding anything from her. He understands that team decisions carry social as well as athletic consequences. His warmth gives him influence, though he sometimes uses humor to soften truths rather than confront them directly. Jordan's presence shows how friendship can be both playful and observant.

Rachel Woodson

The relentless applicant

Rachel is a brilliant, intensely organized student editor determined to earn admission to the most selective universities. She treats every activity as a possible credential and expects others to keep pace with her ambition. Her sharpness can make her seem dismissive, but she also recognizes Devon's interpersonal strengths and gives her concrete ways to develop them. Rachel's reporting shows both her intellectual diligence and the limits of turning complex people into arguments. She believes research grants the right to interpret, a conviction that the events surrounding Ezra challenge. Her drive is impressive, but it leaves little space for uncertainty or motives that cannot be measured.

Isobel Wentworth

The college counselor

Isobel Wentworth is Devon's counselor, a practical adult who pushes her to examine whether college is truly her own goal. She does not let Devon hide behind a weak essay or a shrug, and she arranges a visit to Reeding so that Devon can make an informed choice. Her questions are pointed but not punitive. Isobel seems to understand that a student's lack of ambition may be confusion rather than laziness, and her guidance helps Devon imagine options beyond the expected path. She functions as an adult who takes Devon seriously enough to challenge her.

Kathy Tennyson

Foster's steady guardian

Kathy is Devon's mother and Foster's aunt, a caring adult who works to make him feel at home without always knowing how to reach him. She notices his needs, arranges support, and takes pride in his football progress. Her efforts sometimes put Devon in the role of caretaker without asking first, creating friction between mother and daughter. Kathy's instinct is to provide safety and routine, while Foster's history requires patience with what cannot be repaired quickly. She represents the practical labor of care: meals, rides, appointments, and repeated assurances that someone will remain.

Devon's father

The quieter parent

Devon's father is Foster's paternal uncle and one of the adults who gives him a stable home. He supports Foster's football opportunity and participates in the family's decision to make his place permanent. His affection tends to appear through practical gestures and steady presence rather than long emotional conversations. Foster's suspicions about whether he could have helped Elizabeth create a painful strain between them, though Devon cannot know exactly what her father understood at the time. He embodies the limits of well-intended care: protection matters, but it does not grant complete access to another person's past.

Elizabeth

Foster's troubled mother

Elizabeth is Foster's mother, whose addiction and grief have made her unable to provide the dependable care he needs. Devon remembers her as fragile and distant, while Foster's silence suggests a history more intimate and complicated than outsiders can see. He does not stop being attached to her simply because he has been hurt. Elizabeth's absence shapes his ideas about abandonment, loyalty, and whether love can coexist with failure. She remains largely outside the present action, but her choices influence nearly every question Foster has about family.

Emir Zurivic

The watchful outsider

Emir is a student who moved to Temple Sterling from elsewhere and carries a reputation built partly from rumors. He is observant, dryly funny, and more socially perceptive than Devon initially assumes. He treats risk with a calm that makes other students cautious around him, yet he is capable of unexpected generosity. Emir recognizes the labor involved in taking someone into a family because his own family has depended on such help. His guarded manner is not indifference; it is a form of control over what he chooses to disclose.

Stanton Perkins

The volatile lineman

Stanton is a powerful defensive player whose resentment of Ezra turns team politics personal. He speaks cruelly about teammates and uses his size to dominate social situations. His hostility makes the football team's fractures visible before anyone names them.

Sam Wells

Lake Falls captain

Sam is Lake Falls' senior captain and a football player Ezra knew from training camps. His place in the neighboring school's team connects Temple Sterling's season to a community beyond its own rivalries.

Gracie Holtzer

The polished freshman

Gracie is a socially confident freshman whose immaculate appearance draws attention from classmates. She can be assertive and protective, and her interest in Foster challenges Devon's assumption that she is merely performing for an audience.

Plot Devices

Jane Austen as a lens

A private narrative frame

Devon repeatedly compares her life to the courtships and social judgments in Jane Austen's novels. This habit gives her a vocabulary for longing, embarrassment, and the gap between what people feel and what they admit. It also lets her keep emotional distance by treating herself as a character whose ending can be predicted. As Devon encounters Foster's grief, Ezra's guardedness, and Cas's affection, the literary framework becomes less a script than a tool for recognizing where her assumptions fail. Her growth is marked by acting before she can compose the perfect interpretation.

Football and statistics

Public measure of private worth

Football gives Foster a route into school life and gives Ezra a public identity that shapes how others treat him. Statistics, team hierarchy, recruiting, and the town's attention all turn athletic performance into a judgment of character. Rachel's article questions whether Ezra's transfer was calculated, while the players' responses reveal competing ideas of fairness, loyalty, and recognition. Games also make private tensions visible: Foster's missed kicks matter because he wants to help, and Ezra's response to losing exposes the grief he has concealed.

The college application

A test of chosen ambition

Devon's application process begins as a demand imposed by her parents and counselor. Essays, activities, and résumé advice make her feel that an ordinary life is insufficient. The Reeding visit changes the device's meaning: she sees a place she genuinely wants to attend and begins choosing effort for herself. Her work as a tutor provides a counterpoint to application culture, showing her a kind of usefulness that cannot be reduced to a line on a form. College becomes less an escape from home than a future she can claim.

The counting ritual

Grief made bearable in minutes

Ezra counts when grief or fear threatens to overwhelm him, turning an abstract crisis into a small, finite task. Devon first encounters the habit when he cannot face a visitation, and later it becomes a way for Ezra to help Foster endure the hospital. The ritual does not solve loss or promise that the next moment will feel better. Its power lies in giving someone a manageable action and company while pain continues. The counting connects Ezra's private coping mechanism to the care he offers others.

Ezra's letter to the Herald

A private truth made public

Ezra's letter corrects Rachel's interpretation of his transfer and explains why Sam Wells' death struck him so deeply. By publishing the truth, he accepts the risk of being judged in exchange for trying to repair a relationship. The letter also dramatizes the limits of Devon's observational method: she has noticed Ezra's behavior but lacked the family history that gives it meaning. His written confession opens a path toward intimacy, though it cannot replace speaking directly to Devon.

About the Author

Emma Mills is a Young Adult author based in St. Louis, Missouri, celebrated for her warm, witty, and emotionally resonant storytelling. Beyond writing, she holds a PhD in cell biology, demonstrating a remarkable range of intellectual pursuits. She is well known in the online community through her YouTube channel, Elmify, where she has cultivated a dedicated following. Mills also co-created and co-hosted the educational YouTube channel How to Adult, which ran until 2016. Her novels are praised for their authentic teenage voices, charming romance, and genuine heart, earning her a devoted readership within the YA community.

Download PDF

To save this First & Then summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.32 MB     Pages: 23

Download EPUB

To read this First & Then summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.37 MB     Pages: 30
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...