Key Takeaways
Stop treating environmental concern as proof that behavior will change.
Good intentions meet friction. The author opens with two ordinary failures: a snowbound composter ends up sending food scraps to the garbage, and a climate-conscious professor takes a taxi when winter makes biking harder and the bus inconvenient. The point is not hypocrisy. A person can care, understand the consequences, and still face barriers that outweigh intention in the moment.
Awareness is not action. Energy workshops improved participants' knowledge and attitudes, yet almost none lowered their water-heater settings. By contrast, participants given free water-efficient shower heads installed them more often. The book cites an estimate that household and travel changes could cut US carbon emissions by 7.4% over a decade, a faster contribution than waiting for major infrastructure shifts.
What's striking is how this reframes the familiar gap between values and conduct: inconsistency may reveal a badly designed situation, not a defective person. That shift matters in public policy, where moralizing can alienate the very people a program needs to reach. At the same time, the focus on behavior should not shrink responsibility to consumers alone. Individual actions can matter, but their reach depends on services, regulations, and infrastructure that make those actions feasible.
Choose measurable actions with high impact, real uptake potential, and room to grow.
Start with the outcome. Community-based social marketing, or CBSM, begins by choosing the specific action that would produce an environmental result. In Canada, residential space heating accounted for 63% of household energy use, while lighting accounted for 4% and air conditioning 2%. Those figures suggest why a campaign centered on light bulbs may miss larger opportunities in a cold climate.
Rank actions carefully. The book weighs each behavior by its environmental impact, the likelihood people will adopt it, and how widely it is already practiced. Low existing participation leaves more room for gains. Each behavior should also be non-divisible and end-state: “install an efficient thermostat” is incomplete if nobody programs it, and “add insulation” is too broad if attic and exterior-wall work have very different costs and obstacles.
This is a form of portfolio thinking: scarce attention and funding should go where expected benefit is substantial, adoption is plausible, and current coverage is low. It also corrects a common planning error, which is selecting a visible action because it is familiar rather than because it matters most. The ranking is only as good as its data, however. Local climate, housing, and access to contractors can change both impact and feasibility, so a national priority list should guide local inquiry, not replace it.
Research the friction before prescribing the fix.
Replace hunches with evidence. Barrier and benefit research identifies what prevents a particular audience from acting and what might motivate action. The book recommends building understanding through existing research, unobtrusive observation, focus groups, and surveys. When time and money are scarce, brief intercept interviews can still ask people who do and do not perform the behavior what makes it difficult and what they value about it.
Look inside the behavior. Composting, for example, involves more than owning a bin. A household must collect scraps, carry them outside, maintain the pile, and eventually use the compost. In research described in the book, non-composters were more likely to see composting as unpleasant, inconvenient, and time-consuming. Winter inconvenience distinguished seasonal composters from year-round composters. A single failed step can derail the whole routine.
The method resembles user research in product design: observe what people actually do, locate the point of failure, and tailor the intervention to that point. It also disciplines expert intuition, which can mistake a plausible explanation for a tested one. Focus groups reveal language and unexpected obstacles, but they cannot establish how common a view is. Surveys add breadth, while observed behavior helps counter the tendency for people to overstate what they do or expect to do.
Make the sustainable choice easier than its competing habit.
Change both sides. A program should lower the barriers to the action it wants and raise the barriers to the less desirable alternative. A biking campaign might provide safer routes, workplace showers, and secure bike parking, while also making solo driving less convenient through parking charges or traffic measures. Simply praising biking leaves the convenience of driving untouched.
Match tools to obstacles. CBSM is a practical process for choosing a behavior, learning its barriers and benefits, selecting tools suited to those findings, testing the strategy, and measuring what happens at scale. A prompt can address forgetfulness; a commitment can help someone who already sees the value but has not started; a structural change is needed when the barrier is physical or logistical. The tool should follow the diagnosis, not the planner's favorite technique.
This two-sided design is more realistic than asking one option to win on inspiration alone. It treats behavior as a choice among alternatives shaped by time, cost, safety, and habit. The approach also makes a political issue visible: altering the less sustainable option may distribute costs unevenly. Parking fees, for instance, can burden people without viable transit. Effective design therefore needs to ask not only whether friction changes behavior, but who bears that friction and what alternatives are genuinely available.
Turn a voluntary small promise into a durable identity cue.
A promise can alter self-image. A commitment is an expressed pledge to perform an action. In a classic study described in the book, only a small fraction of residents accepted a large, intrusive road-safety sign. When residents first agreed to a modest safety request, 76% later accepted the larger sign. The initial act can help people see themselves as the kind of person who supports the cause, making consistent follow-through more likely.
Make it specific and freely chosen. Written, public commitments can be especially effective, but pressure can undermine them. In Toronto-area trials, signs alone did not reduce engine idling. Signs combined with short personal conversations, a voluntary pledge, and a window reminder reduced the frequency of idling by 32% and its duration by 73%. Asking when someone expects to act, then offering a helpful follow-up, can turn general intention into a concrete plan.
Commitment links social psychology to the practical problem of getting from intention to a first action. It can also support identity formation: people often learn what they value partly by noticing what they choose to do. The ethical boundary is essential. A pledge should be an invitation, not a trap, and the requested action should be realistic. Public commitments can strengthen follow-through, but visibility should be optional, especially where social exposure or privacy carries a cost.
Show people what peers approve, not just what peers do.
Two norms send different signals. A descriptive norm tells people what others commonly do. An injunctive norm communicates what others approve or disapprove of. In a university shower study, only 6% followed a water-saving sign on its own. When one person visibly modeled turning off the water while soaping, compliance rose to 49%; with two models, it reached 67%.
Do not advertise the problem. A hotel message about towel reuse raised reuse from 37% with a general environmental appeal to 49% when it reported the behavior of guests in that specific room. But a message that makes a harmful behavior look common can normalize it. The book describes park signs about widespread wood theft that increased theft, even though only a small share of visitors had taken wood. Praise can also prevent high performers from slipping toward the average.
Norms work partly because they answer two questions people rarely ask aloud: what is ordinary here, and what will earn respect? That makes them powerful, but also easy to misuse. A campaign can unintentionally turn a rare offense into an apparently accepted custom by repeatedly publicizing it. The distinction between prevalence and approval is therefore more than academic. Strong messages identify the desired behavior as both socially supported and actually practiced, without implying that harmful conduct is the community standard.
Make successful sustainable behavior visible enough to travel through networks.
People trust people they know. Social diffusion is the spread of a new behavior through observation and conversation, especially among people who know or identify with one another. Brochures about soil erosion failed to persuade farmers in the 1930s, while practical assistance to a few local farmers gave neighbors a chance to see and discuss new methods. Adoption followed observation of results, not just exposure to advice.
Show who has tried it. The Redwood River project used farm visits and a booklet showing participating farmers, their conservation practices, and directions to their properties. In five years, 159 participants carried out 350 conservation practices, contributing to reported annual reductions of more than 158 tons of soil and phosphorus. Stickers on recycling bins can make otherwise hidden actions, such as backyard composting, visible to neighbors.
Diffusion turns an intervention into a relationship rather than a broadcast. A trusted peer can demonstrate that a practice is workable in the local setting, which addresses uncertainty that general information cannot. Visibility also creates feedback: people see that the behavior exists nearby and may feel it is socially available to them. But social networks are not automatically inclusive. Programs that rely on early adopters should consider whose experience is represented and whether trusted messengers reach groups outside the most connected circles.
Put reminders exactly where forgotten actions need to happen.
A prompt is a timely cue. It is a visual or auditory reminder for an action someone is already willing to take. It is not meant to manufacture motivation. A broad slogan about protecting the planet may be easy to overlook, while a clear cue placed beside a faucet, recycling bin, or store shelf can meet a person at the moment of choice.
Proximity matters. In a Perth water-efficiency project, prompts attached to household devices reduced water use by 23%; an informational pamphlet alone had no effect. Recycling-bin lids that showed what belonged inside increased beverage recycling by 34% and reduced contamination. The book's practical test is simple: make the prompt noticeable, self-explanatory, and close in both time and place to the behavior.
Prompts are a small example of designing for limited attention rather than expecting perfect memory. Their value is greatest when motivation already exists and the action is easy to forget or misremember. They are less suited to problems involving cost, safety, or missing infrastructure. A reminder to ride a bus cannot compensate for a route that does not serve the destination. The strongest cue is therefore often part of a larger system that has already made the action possible.
Make messages vivid, credible, practical, and emotionally manageable.
Earn attention before asking for action. Effective communication makes an issue concrete and personal, speaks to a defined audience, and comes from a credible source. In a home energy assessment, describing air leaks in vivid terms helped make an otherwise invisible problem easier to grasp. Messages should name clear steps, since people cannot act reliably on vague instructions. Personal contact, modeling, and feedback can make communication more persuasive than a brochure alone.
Pair threat with agency. Warning people about environmental harm without showing what they can do can prompt avoidance rather than action. The book recommends presenting a threat alongside feasible responses and a sense that collective action matters. Feedback can reinforce effort: in one study, households receiving monthly comparisons with their previous energy use reduced consumption by nearly 5% relative to comparison households.
The communication strategy combines attention, trust, comprehension, and efficacy rather than treating message exposure as success. That is a useful correction to campaigns that count impressions but never test conduct. Vividness can make invisible consequences memorable, yet vivid appeals can also distort risk if they substitute emotional force for proportion. A good message therefore connects a concrete image to a credible explanation and an achievable response, while evaluation checks whether the audience understood and acted.
Remove structural inconvenience before blaming people or buying compliance.
Convenience is part of motivation. A behavior can remain unpopular even when people support it if it is costly, unpleasant, or difficult to access. The City of Boulder addressed transit concerns by offering taxi rides when a worker faced an emergency or felt unsafe traveling late at night. Curbside organic collection removes several hurdles of backyard composting by supplying containers and making collection resemble familiar recycling routines. One pilot cited in the book found participation by 99% of households.
Use incentives with care. User fees for garbage can shift behavior when recycling and yard-waste services are free. San Jose saw landfill waste fall 46% after introducing charges based on container size. Yet incentives must be visible, timed to the choice, and designed for avoidance or unintended effects. The book cautions that replacing internal motivation with a reward can make behavior harder to sustain if the reward disappears.
This insight joins behavioral design with service design: the public's experience of a policy is often the policy itself. Convenient collection, safe routes, and usable equipment can outperform appeals to virtue because they alter the effort required at the point of action. Incentives add another lever, but they cannot repair a broken service or an unfair choice set. Their design should include safeguards against shifting costs onto households with fewer options and should distinguish durable motivation from short-term response.
Pilot against a control, measure behavior, then scale what works.
Treat programs as testable designs. Before a broad rollout, a pilot compares a strategy with a control group that does not receive it. Random assignment helps separate the program's effect from pre-existing differences or outside events. The book emphasizes measuring behavior directly where possible, through observations, utility records, or product sales, rather than relying only on awareness or self-reports.
Refine before scaling. Compare baseline and follow-up results in both groups, account for their starting differences, and include delivery costs. The author reports revising one pilot six times before it produced the desired change. After a successful test, ongoing evaluation can reveal whether a repetitive behavior fades. Sharing both successful and unsuccessful results helps other communities adapt proven strategies instead of paying to repeat avoidable mistakes.
Piloting makes environmental programming resemble adaptive management: act, observe, revise, and retain what evidence supports. It protects public resources and replaces the comforting but weak proxy of campaign visibility with an outcome that matters. A control group is not a luxury when conditions can change independently of the program. Still, even a successful local trial may not transfer unchanged elsewhere. Scaling should preserve the tested mechanism while checking whether local infrastructure, incentives, and populations alter its effects.
Analysis
The book's deepest contribution is methodological: it changes the unit of environmental planning from a message to a behavior in context. A campaign is not successful because it explains climate change clearly, attracts attention, or expresses admirable values. It succeeds when people perform a specified action, at a meaningful scale, and continue doing so at a defensible cost. That standard links social psychology to program evaluation and public administration.
Its five-part logic is sequential but not mechanical. First, planners choose actions that matter environmentally and remain open to adoption. Then they investigate the friction and incentives surrounding those actions. Only after that do they select tools, test a strategy, and evaluate outcomes. The sequence guards against two common errors: choosing a behavior because it is easy to promote, and choosing a tactic because it is familiar. The examples make the approach memorable because they are ordinary: the frozen compost bin, the overlooked shower sign, and the local farmer whose working practice persuades neighbors more than a brochure.
The strongest ethical implication is that barriers are not merely excuses. Inconvenience, safety, cost, and access are features of the environment in which choice occurs. Treating them as design problems can replace blame with practical problem-solving. Yet this strength also marks a limit. A focus on individual action can obscure the institutions and infrastructure that shape which actions are possible. The book's own attention to convenience, incentives, and structural barriers helps resist that reduction, but practitioners should keep power, affordability, and unequal exposure to policy costs in view.
The framework is most useful when treated as a disciplined learning cycle, not a guaranteed recipe. A pilot can demonstrate that an intervention worked in one setting, not that it will work everywhere. Direct measurement, comparison groups, and continuing evaluation help distinguish durable change from temporary response. The larger lesson is demanding but hopeful: effective sustainability work depends less on perfect persuasion than on understanding real behavior, making better choices feasible, and being willing to change the program when evidence says it is not working.
Review Summary
Fostering Sustainable Behavior receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.86/5. Readers appreciate its accessible overview of community-based social marketing and practical tools for promoting sustainable behaviors. Some find it repetitive but valuable for understanding behavior change program design. Critics note that the content may not be groundbreaking for those with psychological backgrounds. The book is praised for its case studies and application of theories, though some question the effectiveness of the author's website. Overall, it's considered essential reading for those interested in promoting sustainable choices and behaviors.
People Also Read
Glossary
Community-Based Social Marketing
Evidence-led community behavior changeA practical approach to encouraging sustainable behavior that combines social science with community-level action. It involves selecting a specific behavior, researching its barriers and benefits, designing a strategy using suitable behavior-change tools, testing the strategy on a limited scale, and evaluating results during broader implementation. Direct contact and local context are central to the approach.
End-state behavior
Action producing the outcomeThe specific action that directly produces the intended environmental result. Buying an efficient product is not end-state if it must still be installed or configured before it saves energy. Defining the end-state prevents programs from mistaking an earlier step, such as making a purchase, for the behavior that actually reduces resource use.
Barrier and benefit research
Evidence about action and resistanceResearch used to identify what makes a particular behavior difficult or worthwhile for its target audience. The book recommends reviewing prior studies, observing behavior, holding focus groups, and surveying a representative sample. Findings help planners distinguish actual obstacles and motivators from personal assumptions, then tailor an intervention to the behavior and community.
Commitment
A voluntary pledge to actAn expressed agreement to perform a specified behavior. A commitment may be verbal or written, private or public, and can include a planned time for action or a follow-up. The book explains that pledging can strengthen follow-through by encouraging consistency between a person's stated intention and later behavior. It should remain voluntary rather than coerced.
Descriptive norm
What people commonly doA signal about the behavior that is typical within a group or setting. It can encourage adoption when it shows that a desired action is common among relevant peers. It can backfire when it makes an undesirable action appear widespread, or when people doing better than average reduce their effort after learning that they outperform others.
Injunctive norm
What people approve or rejectA signal about which behaviors a group considers acceptable, admirable, or unacceptable. Unlike a descriptive norm, it communicates social approval rather than prevalence. It can support sustainable action by conveying that people value or expect the behavior. Pairing approval with descriptive information can also help prevent high-performing individuals from drifting toward the average.
Social diffusion
Spread through trusted networksThe spread of a new behavior through observation and interpersonal communication, especially among people who trust or identify with one another. Early adopters can demonstrate that a practice works in a local setting, while conversation helps others assess its risks and benefits. Making otherwise hidden behaviors visible can support both diffusion and community norms.
Prompt
A cue to remember actionA visual or auditory reminder intended to help someone perform an action they are already inclined to take. Prompts do not primarily build motivation or change attitudes. They are most effective when noticeable, easy to understand, and placed close in time and location to the behavior, such as instructions attached to a recycling container.
FAQ
1. What is "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" by Doug McKenzie-Mohr about?
- Introduction to CBSM: The book introduces Community-Based Social Marketing (CBSM) as a practical, research-based approach to promoting sustainable behaviors at the community level.
- Behavior Change Focus: It emphasizes that real progress toward sustainability depends on changing individual and collective behaviors, not just raising awareness.
- Step-by-Step Framework: The book outlines a five-step process for designing, piloting, and implementing effective behavior change programs.
- Evidence-Based Methods: Drawing on social psychology and real-world case studies, it demonstrates why traditional information campaigns often fail and how CBSM can achieve measurable results.
2. Why should I read "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" by Doug McKenzie-Mohr?
- Practical Guidance: The book provides actionable, step-by-step instructions for designing and implementing programs that actually change behavior, not just attitudes.
- Widely Endorsed: It is highly recommended by professionals, academics, and organizations worldwide for its clarity, effectiveness, and real-world impact.
- Applicable Across Sectors: Whether you work in energy, water, waste, transportation, or conservation, the CBSM approach is adaptable to a wide range of sustainability challenges.
- Bridges Theory and Practice: The book translates social science research into practical tools and strategies that can be used by anyone, from students to seasoned professionals.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" by Doug McKenzie-Mohr?
- Behavior Change is Essential: Achieving sustainability requires changing actual behaviors, not just increasing knowledge or shifting attitudes.
- Information Alone is Insufficient: Traditional campaigns that rely solely on information or economic incentives rarely lead to significant behavior change.
- CBSM’s Five Steps: The CBSM process—selecting behaviors, identifying barriers and benefits, developing strategies, piloting, and broad-scale implementation—is critical for effective programs.
- Use of Social Science Tools: Techniques like commitment, social norms, prompts, incentives, and making behaviors convenient are far more effective than mass media campaigns.
4. How does Community-Based Social Marketing (CBSM) work according to "Fostering Sustainable Behavior"?
- Five-Step Process: CBSM involves (1) selecting impactful behaviors, (2) identifying barriers and benefits, (3) developing tailored strategies, (4) piloting interventions, and (5) broad-scale implementation and evaluation.
- Community-Level Focus: CBSM emphasizes direct, personal engagement at the community level, rather than relying on mass media or generic messaging.
- Barrier Removal: The approach is grounded in identifying and removing specific barriers to action, both internal (e.g., lack of knowledge) and external (e.g., inconvenience).
- Iterative and Evidence-Based: Strategies are tested and refined through pilots before being rolled out widely, ensuring effectiveness and cost-efficiency.
5. What are the main reasons traditional information campaigns fail, according to "Fostering Sustainable Behavior"?
- Weak Link to Behavior: Studies show that increasing knowledge or changing attitudes does not reliably lead to behavior change.
- Overlooks Barriers: Information campaigns often ignore practical, psychological, or structural barriers that prevent action.
- Economic Self-Interest Overestimated: Simply highlighting financial benefits is usually insufficient to motivate sustainable behaviors.
- Lack of Personal Engagement: Mass media and printed materials lack the direct, personal contact that is proven to be more effective in changing behavior.
6. What are the five steps of Community-Based Social Marketing (CBSM) as described in "Fostering Sustainable Behavior"?
- Step 1: Selecting Behaviors: Identify and prioritize specific, non-divisible, end-state behaviors that have high impact, high probability of adoption, and low current penetration.
- Step 2: Identifying Barriers and Benefits: Use literature reviews, observations, focus groups, and surveys to uncover what prevents or motivates people to adopt the target behavior.
- Step 3: Developing Strategies: Design interventions using proven behavior change tools (e.g., commitment, prompts, social norms) tailored to the identified barriers and benefits.
- Step 4: Piloting: Test the strategy on a small scale, compare with a control group, and refine based on results before wider implementation.
- Step 5: Broad-Scale Implementation and Evaluation: Roll out the refined strategy community-wide and rigorously evaluate its impact on actual behavior.
7. How do you select which behaviors to target in a CBSM program, according to "Fostering Sustainable Behavior"?
- Sector and Category Analysis: Start by identifying which sectors (e.g., residential, commercial) and categories (e.g., space heating, water use) have the greatest impact.
- Non-Divisible, End-State Behaviors: List behaviors that are specific, cannot be further divided, and directly produce the desired outcome.
- Assess Impact, Probability, and Penetration: Evaluate each behavior for its potential environmental impact, likelihood of adoption, and current adoption rate.
- Prioritize for Maximum Effect: Focus on behaviors with high impact, high probability, and low current penetration to maximize program effectiveness.
8. What methods does "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" recommend for identifying barriers and benefits to sustainable behaviors?
- Literature Review: Begin by reviewing existing research, reports, and case studies relevant to the target behavior.
- Observations: Watch people engaging (or not engaging) in the behavior to identify practical obstacles and sub-actions.
- Focus Groups: Conduct group discussions with both active and inactive participants to explore perceptions, motivations, and challenges.
- Surveys: Use structured surveys to quantify the prevalence and importance of different barriers and benefits across the target audience.
9. What are the key behavior change tools described in "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" and how are they used?
- Commitment: Secure verbal or written pledges to act, ideally making them public and durable, to increase follow-through.
- Social Norms: Highlight and reinforce the desired behavior as normal and approved within the community to encourage adoption.
- Prompts: Use visual or auditory reminders placed close to the point of action to help people remember to act.
- Incentives: Offer rewards or remove disincentives to motivate behavior, ensuring they are closely linked to the action and visible.
- Convenience: Remove external barriers and make the desired behavior as easy and accessible as possible.
10. How does "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" recommend developing and testing strategies for behavior change?
- Tailor to Barriers and Benefits: Select behavior change tools that directly address the specific barriers and benefits identified in research.
- Focus Group Feedback: Present proposed strategies to focus groups for feedback and refinement before piloting.
- Pilot Testing: Implement the strategy on a small scale with a control group, measure actual behavior change, and calculate return on investment.
- Iterative Refinement: Revise and retest the strategy as needed until it reliably produces the desired behavior change before scaling up.
11. What are some of the most impactful quotes from "Fostering Sustainable Behavior" and what do they mean?
- “Nature bats last.” – Emphasizes that environmental limits are non-negotiable, and humanity must adapt to sustainability sooner or later.
- “Behavior change is the cornerstone of sustainability.” – Highlights that real progress depends on changing what people actually do, not just what they know or believe.
- “If you only have a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.” – Warns against using one-size-fits-all solutions; strategies must be tailored to specific barriers and contexts.
- “Our deeds determine us as much as we determine our deeds.” – Suggests that engaging in sustainable actions shapes our identity and future choices.
12. What are the most common challenges and solutions for implementing CBSM, according to "Fostering Sustainable Behavior"?
- Organizational Resistance: Agencies may be accustomed to information-intensive campaigns and resist adopting CBSM; building internal support and demonstrating effectiveness is key.
- Time and Resource Constraints: CBSM requires upfront investment in research and piloting, but saves time and money in the long run by increasing program success.
- Overcoming Preconceptions: Staff and managers may believe they already know the barriers; the book stresses the importance of humility and evidence-based research.
- Scaling and Sharing Success: The book advocates for piloting, rigorous evaluation, and sharing results (including failures) to accelerate learning and adoption of effective strategies.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.