Plot Summary
A Girl Without Color
Nearly twelve, Alice Queensmeadow is an outsider in Ferenwood, where magic shows itself as brilliant color and her white hair and skin are mistaken for emptiness. Her father left three years earlier, and Alice misses the one parent who made her feel cherished.
Her mother relies on Alice to gather ferenberries but rarely makes her feel wanted; her three little brothers offer little companionship. Alice has built her hopes around the annual Surrender, where children display their magical talent and receive a life-changing task.
She plans to win with a dance her father taught her to love. Then a stranger approaches on the road. Alice hears the astonishing music of his heartbeat, panics, and punches him before running home, not knowing he is Oliver Newbanks, the schoolmate who once humiliated her.
Alice’s longing for a task is not simply ambition. It is an attempt to turn exclusion into a choice: if Ferenwood will not recognize her as one of its own, she hopes achievement can make belonging unavoidable. Her dance carries the emotional inheritance of her father, so the Surrender is also a bid to recover the world she had before he left. The first encounter with Oliver establishes her alertness to other people’s inner lives, but it also shows how easily fear and old wounds govern her judgments. Alice’s confidence is real, yet it protects a child who has been left feeling unchosen.
Oliver Comes Back
The stranger returns to Alice’s family’s pig shed and identifies himself as Oliver, though Alice first mistakes him for an impostor and attacks him with a shovel. She remembers him as the boy who called her ugly at school, an insult that helped get her expelled after she retaliated.
Oliver now has a Surrender talent for persuasion and can learn a person’s deepest secret. He admits he needs Alice’s help, then reveals that he knows where her father is. Their bargain would require Alice to give up her own Surrender, so she refuses.
Her mother’s answer to Alice’s worry about leaving makes clear that the household can manage without her. Alice decides she will perform anyway, choosing a future of her own even if it means finding her father alone.
Oliver approaches Alice with leverage rather than trust, repeating the imbalance that has shaped much of her life: others decide what she is worth, then expect her cooperation. Alice’s refusal marks an important boundary. She will not exchange the only future she has imagined for a promise from a boy who once wounded her and still withholds information. Her mother’s practical reassurance is meant to soothe, but Alice hears it as evidence that she is dispensable. That misunderstanding is painful, yet it clarifies her motive. She chooses the Surrender not because she loves ceremony, but because she needs a life that belongs to her.
The Black Surrender
At the spring ceremony, Alice watches other children sing, climb invisible air, and repair broken objects before she dances. The audience waits for a more obvious display of magic, and the Elders give her the unprecedented score of zero. Alice runs from the square, believing she has no task and no place in Ferenwood. Oliver follows and insists that dancing is not her true talent.
He finally admits that bringing her father home is his assigned task, and that Alice is necessary to complete it. His maps and a magical box reveal a door leading to Furthermore, a land Alice was taught did not exist. She agrees to travel with him, driven by the chance to find her father and by the shame she cannot bear to face at home.
The zero score converts Alice’s private fear of being worthless into a public verdict, but the ceremony’s judgment is also profoundly limited: it measures talent only when talent is performed in a form the Elders know how to recognize. Alice has mistaken her dance, a source of joy and connection, for the magic she must demonstrate. Oliver’s revelation offers rescue and repeats his controlling habit of rationing the truth. Yet his task makes their needs interdependent. Alice’s decision to leave is partly desperate, but it also begins the move from seeking Ferenwood’s approval to acting on her own convictions.
Slumber's Hungry Welcome
Oliver drops Alice through the box’s doorway into knee-deep water in Slumber, the nighttime entrance to Furthermore. There, rules matter more than common sense: visitors must avoid food, wait for the sun to sleep, and move carefully through a village that appears only in darkness.
Alice’s curiosity nearly exposes them when she lingers with Seldom, a striking local who gathers a crowd to inspect her unusual appearance. To get them away, Alice invents a story that she controls the sun and has lost her color from working too close to it.
Oliver quietly uses persuasion to make the crowd accept the tale. Afterward, he explains that Furthermore is dangerous and that its residents may eat visitors for their magic. Alice recognizes that his hand-holding and evasions have been efforts to keep them safe, and agrees to trust his guidance.
Slumber forces Alice to confront a world where her difference attracts attention rather than merely quiet contempt. Her invented explanation is an act of improvisation, but it also marks the beginning of her departure from the promise that once protected her from lies. Oliver’s persuasion saves them, while his failure to explain the danger beforehand deepens her resentment. Their truce is therefore practical before it is intimate: Alice accepts that she cannot navigate this land alone, and Oliver must learn that keeping someone safe is not the same as treating them as a partner. The contrast between Ferenwood’s restraint and Furthermore’s opportunism sharpens both children’s vulnerabilities.
Time's Pocketbook
At Border Control, Oliver persuades Ted Adventure to issue Alice a ruler filled with six months of time, then leads her through the shifting sky into Still. After surviving its motion-sensitive inhabitants, they reach Tim, a childlike figure who embodies Time.
Tim explains that Alice’s father was imprisoned for taking more time than allotted, and that solitary confinement stripped him of his color, making escape physically impossible. Oliver had used a magical pocketbook to trace the father’s lost pocket, but Tim exposes the deeper deception: Oliver has never met Alice’s father, despite claiming he had spoken to him.
Alice learns that Oliver needs her color magic to restore the prisoner. Hurt by his manipulation and overwhelmed by the news, she ends their partnership and runs into the forest, leaving Oliver behind.
The pocketbook turns absence into evidence: a lost object can be tracked even when its owner cannot. But the discovery also strips Alice of the comforting story that her father has been waiting just within reach. Oliver’s lie is motivated by fear and urgency, yet its effect is still a betrayal, because he has made Alice’s grief serve his mission without informed consent. The colorless prison gives Alice’s own appearance a new meaning: what Ferenwood misreads as an absence of magic is also the condition imposed on her father. Her decision to flee is impulsive, but the breach between them is not trivial. Trust cannot be restored by good intentions alone.
The Fox Takes an Arm
Alone, Alice instinctively changes the forest’s colors, revealing the talent she has long denied: she can recolor the world, though not herself. A paper fox appears and seems to understand her request to find her father.
Alice follows it into Print, a two-dimensional village whose rules begin flattening her body. The fox drags her deeper, and she escapes only after it tears off her right arm, leaving part of her body paper-thin. She stumbles back to Still, where Oliver finds her.
He admits her arm cannot grow back but believes a painter may create a replacement. Alice tells him what happened; both recognize their own role in the rupture, and they forgive each other. Rather than abandon him again, Alice accepts that they must face the next danger together.
Alice’s power first appears in the place where she has felt most powerless: she can transform nearly everything except the body that marks her as different. That limitation explains why she has treated her gift as mockery rather than possibility. The fox offers a tempting alternative to Oliver, a guide who seems to understand her without judgment, but her trust is shaped by anger and longing, not knowledge. Losing an arm makes the cost of acting alone undeniable. The reunion does not erase the betrayal; it makes mutual responsibility visible. Oliver must stop withholding, and Alice must recognize how hurt can make recklessness feel like independence.
Three Doors, One Choice
The paper fox returns with companions and attacks Alice and Oliver. It warns that Alice’s father is also suspected of spying on Furthermore, then claims Oliver must be taken as a meal for his many lies.
As the foxes overpower Oliver, Alice’s fear unlocks her full color magic: she turns the surrounding world black, blinding the creatures long enough to reach him. She snaps her ruler, activating its emergency power and stopping time. Three doors appear, offering to repair her arm, save Oliver, or find her father.
Alice chooses Oliver and falls through the door with him. They land in an unfamiliar passage, alive but without her allotted time. Her choice deepens their bond, while the broken ruler leaves them vulnerable to arrest for time theft.
The emergency doors make Alice’s priorities concrete. She cannot preserve every need at once, so she chooses the person whose care has become mutual rather than transactional. Her power arrives through terror, but its first deliberate use is protective: she darkens the world to interrupt the foxes’ control. The choice costs her time and likely legal safety, just as the earlier journey cost her an arm. These consequences complicate any easy celebration of bravery. Alice’s agency is not a guarantee that she can escape harm; it is the capacity to act in the midst of harm and accept what her decisions demand.
A Feast in Left
Following a confusing intersection, Alice and Oliver reach Left, a village built among giant trees and hanging eggshell homes. Paramint, its delighted guardian, welcomes them after waiting decades for visitors and offers them baths, gifts, food, and a place to sleep.
Alice enjoys the rest, but a song from Ancilly, a local attendant, hints at a woman who survived a fall from the village. The next morning Paramint reveals that Alice’s broken ruler has made her a time thief and celebrates that the authorities will notice Left again.
He also plans to serve the children at a feast. Alice wakes Oliver, who has been made ill by the food, and helps him escape. Trusting Ancilly’s song, they fall from the branches and land safely below, where a leaf-cloaked stranger offers help.
Left demonstrates how hospitality can be sincere and still become dangerous when a community’s needs are organized around exploitation. Paramint’s joy at receiving visitors is real; so is his willingness to turn them into a meal. Alice’s time there restores her body and spirits, which makes the threat harder to recognize. Ancilly’s song conveys knowledge indirectly because direct dissent has been punished. Alice learns to read kindness without treating it as proof of safety, and to act on clues that arrive in forms she would once have dismissed. Her rescue of Oliver also confirms that their partnership now runs both ways.
Isal's Painted Exit
The stranger identifies herself as Isal, the former seamstress Ancilly had warned them about. Isal explains that she was pushed from the village for opposing its rulers’ sacrifice of visitors, and that the ground below the trees saved her.
She also recognizes Oliver’s Tibbin, the personal clue assigned to each visitor, and warns that Furthermore’s authorities likely expected the children to fail. When Alice asks for help finding a painter, Isal directs them to enter one of her paintings, but warns that refusal will leave them trapped in it forever.
Authorities arrive at the door before they can hesitate. Alice chooses a canvas that reminds her of home and pushes Oliver through with her. They emerge in a gray, snowy settlement and meet its irritable painter.
Isal is the story’s counterexample to a system that treats compliance as virtue. She has been punished for refusing to help sacrifice outsiders, yet her exile gives her a vantage point from which to understand the machinery surrounding Alice and Oliver. The Tibbin, meant to look like aid, becomes evidence that the authorities can shape a visitor’s route and anticipate failure. Alice’s choice of a painting is a leap made under pressure, but it is also a choice of emotional orientation: she reaches for an image associated with home while accepting that safety cannot be guaranteed. Isal offers a path, not protection from its cost.
The Prison Without Color
The gray settlement is Ink, a prison village where Alice discovers that the painter is her father. He has been serving a sentence for time theft, while also facing suspicion of espionage for asking about Furthermore’s magic.
His punishment strips him of color and isolates him; his assigned labor is painting replacement limbs for injured prisoners. Alice learns that Oliver’s task was to bring her father home, but Oliver had never reached him. Her father had returned to Furthermore because he hoped its unfamiliar magic could give Alice color.
He had not left because he stopped loving her. Alice’s own power can restore color, and her father paints her missing arm. Together, they return Ink’s color before Oliver opens the magical doorway back to Ferenwood.
The reunion revises Alice’s central wound without pretending it never happened. Her father did leave, and his choice subjected her to years of grief; yet his reason was an attempt to answer the very pain she had hidden from him. Love here is neither omniscient nor harmless. It can motivate sacrifice while producing consequences the beloved never consented to bear. The revelation also transforms Alice’s talent from a failed means of self-correction into a power capable of restoring a community. Her father’s labor and her magic answer each other: he makes forms, she gives them color. The rescue is collaborative, not a reward for solitary heroism.
Home, Still Changed
After nearly a year away, Alice, her father, and Oliver return to Ferenwood in winter. Alice expects her mother to punish her for leaving and failing the Surrender, but her mother instead embraces her and admits she knew why her husband had gone: he sought color for Alice. Grief made her blame Alice, and she apologizes for treating her cruelly.
Alice accepts that love can wound as well as comfort. She also learns that her black Surrender card does not exile her; it gives her another chance the following year. Oliver returns home, but promises to join Alice on her next task. With her father beside her and her friendship with Oliver secure, Alice faces the future without needing to prove she deserves a place in it.
The homecoming resolves the opening’s fear of abandonment through disclosure rather than a magical cure. Alice’s mother names the resentment she concealed, making it possible for Alice to understand her cruelty without excusing it. The black card, once a symbol of rejection, becomes a second opportunity because Alice had mistaken institutional failure for permanent exclusion. She returns with her family restored, but not to the unchanged child who left: she has learned that belonging need not depend on looking like others or earning a spectacular task. Her invitation to Oliver carries the adventure forward as companionship, not escape from an unlivable home.
Analysis
Furthermore makes social value visible by attaching it to color, talent, and usefulness. In Ferenwood, Alice’s lack of pigment is read as lack of magic; at the Surrender, her dance fails because the Elders cannot recognize what it means. Her journey does not simply prove that the community was wrong about her. It changes the question from whether Alice can become acceptable to whether she can understand and use the power she already has.
The novel’s magic is also a study of systems. Ferenwood regulates magic into currency and civic duty, while Furthermore has spent its magic so extravagantly that it regulates visitors through time, confusing laws, and predatory customs. Neither society offers an uncomplicated ideal. Ferenwood’s stability can conceal emotional neglect, while Furthermore’s abundance turns possibility into danger. Alice survives by learning to distinguish generosity from safety and rules from justice.
The relationships carry the same tension between care and control. Oliver’s persuasion can protect Alice, but his lies deny her the right to choose with full knowledge. Her mother’s grief explains some of her harshness without excusing the harm it causes. Her father’s love motivates his dangerous search for color, yet Alice must learn that being loved does not require her to become someone else. The resolution therefore gives her more than a rescued family: it gives her a new understanding of agency. Alice can be different, flawed, frightened, and still capable of making consequential choices. Her color magic matters most not when it alters her appearance, but when she uses it to restore a world and defend the people she has chosen.
Review Summary
Furthermore receives mixed reviews with an overall 3.89/5 rating. Readers consistently praise Tahereh Mafi's whimsical, poetic writing style and vivid descriptions, though many find the plot confusing and the world-building unclear. Alice's character earns appreciation for her sass and confidence, while Oliver divides opinion. Common criticisms include the rushed ending, overly flowery prose, and unclear magic system. Several reviewers note disappointment that Alice's disability is "fixed" rather than permanent. The middle-grade fantasy draws frequent comparisons to Alice in Wonderland, with readers split between finding it enchantingly imaginative or frustratingly convoluted.
People Also Read
Characters
Alice
Ferenwood's restless outsiderAlice is a nearly twelve-year-old girl whose pale skin and hair make her conspicuous in a culture that treats color as evidence of magic and worth. She is curious, physically exuberant, blunt, and proud, with a deep appetite for exploration and a sharp sensitivity to rejection. Her father’s affection has given her a strong inner sense of beauty, but his absence and her mother’s emotional distance leave her hungry for recognition. Alice often mistakes self-reliance for refusing help, especially when shame or grief takes hold. Beneath her stubbornness is a capacity for tenderness: she notices the lives of plants, listens closely to people, and wants to protect those she loves.
Oliver
Persuasive, guarded companionOliver Newbanks is a year older than Alice and possesses a talent for persuasion, along with an uncanny knowledge of other people’s private secrets. He is clever, resourceful, and accustomed to managing danger by controlling what others believe. That talent has made him capable, but it has also left him uncertain whether anyone could like him without being influenced. His confidence can look like arrogance, especially when he withholds information or assumes he knows best. Alice’s refusal to be persuaded unsettles him because it forces him to face her judgment without his usual advantage. He is drawn to the strange freedoms of Furthermore, yet he also longs for the possibility of honest connection.
Alice's Father
A beloved mapmakerAlice’s father is a thoughtful, imaginative man who once helped map Ferenwood and taught Alice to attend to the world through music and movement. His warmth gave his daughter a sturdy sense of being loved, and his absence becomes the grief around which her childhood reorganizes itself. He is curious about the lands beyond Ferenwood and willing to follow questions that others would leave alone. Alice remembers him as a friend as much as a parent, someone who challenged her harsh judgments of herself and encouraged her to see possibility in difference. His work as a mapmaker reflects his wish to make unfamiliar paths navigable.
Alice's Mother
A grieving, rigid parentAlice’s mother is a practical woman carrying grief she does not know how to express. She manages the household and depends on Alice to gather ferenberries, yet her worry and frustration often come out as threats, criticism, or silence. She is not naturally patient with children, and her strained relationship with Alice is sharpened by the father’s disappearance. Her love exists alongside real failures of care, which makes Alice’s longing for her approval especially complicated. The mother’s severity reflects a person trying to maintain daily life while avoiding pain, but avoidance leaves her daughter to interpret silence as indifference.
Tim
The keeper of timeTim is a childlike figure whose age changes with the hour and who oversees the rules surrounding time in Furthermore. He is precise, surrounded by numbers, and attached to a legal order that treats time as a regulated possession. His manner is gentler than the system he represents, and he attempts to explain its rules clearly even when the truth is devastating. Tim’s friendship with Oliver shows that kindness can exist inside a harsh society without making that society just. He serves as an interpreter of the laws that have trapped Alice’s father.
Isal
A solitary, golden figureIsal is a reserved woman whose golden-leaf cloak makes her appear both beautiful and formidable. She has endured exclusion for refusing to accept the customs of the community around her, and she has learned to survive beyond its reach. Her speech is measured, her warnings direct, and her generosity never sentimental. Isal understands that an offer of help can carry a cost, so she gives Alice and Oliver a route forward without pretending it is safe. Her presence offers Alice an image of difference that is neither a defect nor a spectacle.
Paramint
Left's eager hostParamint is the guardian of Left’s visiting door, a meticulously dressed old man who has spent decades preparing to welcome outsiders. His excitement is sincere, and he takes pride in making guests feel honored through food, clothing, and ceremony. That hospitality is inseparable from the village’s harsher customs, leaving Alice and Oliver to discover that warmth does not ensure safety. Paramint’s character embodies the danger of judging a person only by their manners: he can be generous in one moment and complicit in violence the next.
Ancilly
A watchful attendantAncilly is a warm, capable attendant who helps Alice bathe, dresses her in a beautiful gown, and communicates through a song linked to the village’s forgotten history. Her tenderness is sincere, but she must speak cautiously in a place where dissent can carry severe consequences. Ancilly’s care gives Alice a rare moment of comfort, while her indirect warning teaches her to listen for meaning hidden inside ordinary kindness.
Seldom
A curious Slumber localSeldom is a striking resident of Slumber whose attention draws a crowd around Alice. He is intrigued by her unusual appearance, but his curiosity turns her into a public spectacle. His brief encounter tests Alice’s ability to improvise under pressure and gives Oliver a chance to use persuasion.
Ted Adventure
Slumber's border officialTed Adventure works at Border Control, where he registers visitors and issues their time-filled rulers. His bureaucratic routine is played for comic effect, but the questions he asks reveal the strict system Alice and Oliver are entering.
Mr. Lottingale
A Surrender ElderMr. Lottingale is one of Ferenwood’s Town Elders and presides over the Surrender ceremony. He represents the public authority that evaluates children’s talents, though Alice experiences his ceremony as impersonal and humiliating.
Kate Zuhair
The year's top SurrendererKate Zuhair earns the highest Surrender score before Alice receives her own result. Her success establishes the competitive standard Alice believes she has failed to meet.
Oliver's Parents
A distant familyOliver’s parents are part of the family life he describes as emotionally uncertain. His talent for persuasion has complicated the way he relates to them, leaving him unsure how much they truly know one another.
Alice's Brothers
Three younger siblingsAlice’s unnamed triplet brothers are ten years old and share the crowded family home with her. Their games and youthful needs leave Alice feeling more like an overlooked extra than a close companion.
Plot Devices
The Surrender
Talent becomes a taskAt twelve, Ferenwood children perform their magical talent before the Town Elders and receive a task in exchange. The performance is meant to reveal potential, but the ceremony also imposes a narrow public measure of what counts as useful magic. Alice builds her hopes around it because a task promises purpose and a route beyond her painful home life. Her zero score appears to close that route, while the black card quietly preserves the possibility of trying again.
Color magic
Difference becomes powerIn both Ferenwood and Furthermore, color is bound to magic and vitality. Alice has very little visible pigment, so her community assumes she has little magic, and she resents the talent she can use on the world but not on herself. Her ability to alter color becomes essential to restoring life and escaping danger. The same system that makes her look deficient to others gives her a power no one around her has learned to value.
The time ruler
Time is measured and spentVisitors to Furthermore receive a ruler filled with a limited amount of time. Its weight signals how much remains, and losing or borrowing time can lead to arrest. Alice’s ruler also carries an emergency aid, but using it breaks the container and scatters her allotted time. The device turns the abstract pressure of a journey into a physical risk, while its emergency instruction forces Alice to choose between immediate danger and long-term safety.
The pocketbook
Lost pockets expose the pastThis magical book contains pockets belonging to people who have lost them, with each entry linked to where and when it was found. Oliver uses it to trace the pocket Alice’s father left behind and learn where he had been. The book makes private histories physically searchable, but its pages belong to real people and resist careless handling. It gives Oliver a practical lead while also revealing how little he actually knows about Alice’s father.
Furthermore's passageways
Each door changes the rulesMagical doors, changing skies, and villages with their own contradictory laws structure the journey through Furthermore. Alice and Oliver must learn local rules as they encounter them, from Slumber’s sunless entry to Still’s motionless inhabitants and Print’s dangerous flatness. The passages reward curiosity but punish assumptions, turning travel into a sequence of ethical and practical choices. They also make the land feel intentionally designed to test visitors, not merely to transport them.
Furthermore Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.