Plot Summary
Paul Slater Returns
A recurring nightmare sends sixteen-year-old Susannah Simon running through a fogbound corridor with Jesse, the ghost she loves, until Paul Slater appears and leaves her falling into darkness. The next morning, Paul turns up at her Carmel school as a new student. He dismisses her fear about their last encounter, when he left her and Jesse trapped in a dangerous spirit realm, and hints that she does not understand what she is.
Suze refuses his offer of friendship and tells Father Dominic, the school's priest and fellow mediator, that Paul is trouble. Father Dominic urges her to give him a chance. Suze keeps quiet about Jesse, but Paul has already made her ordinary school year feel unsafe.
The dream turns Suze's private fear into a map of the novel: Jesse offers comfort, but neither he nor Suze knows the way out, while Paul represents knowledge that may be dangerous rather than liberating. His arrival collapses the boundary between her secret supernatural work and school life. Father Dominic's faith in second chances contrasts with Suze's experience-based caution. Neither position is simply foolish: his generosity preserves the possibility of change, while her suspicion registers the cost of trusting someone who has already endangered her.
A Ghost at Dinner
Suze's first day brings trouble at home as well. Her stepbrother Brad plans an unsupervised hot tub party and threatens to expose Jesse's nightly visits if Suze tells their parents. She punches Brad, earns detention, and walks home rather than accept a ride from Paul. That evening, her older stepbrother Jake brings college friend Neil Jankow to dinner.
Suze alone can see the angry young man hovering behind Neil. She introduces herself as a mediator, someone who helps unsettled dead people move on, and learns the ghost is Craig, Neil's brother. Craig resents seeing Neil alive and insists that the wrong brother survived a sailing accident. His bitterness makes a simple conversation into a warning.
The dinner table puts Suze's two kinds of secrecy side by side. Brad can exploit what the family does not know about Jesse, while the ghost's presence makes the living family oblivious in a more literal way. Craig's grievance is not yet a clear threat; it is an injured person's rigid story about fairness. His athletic identity makes his death especially difficult for him to accept, while Neil's silence hints at a different burden. Suze's work begins with listening, but the scene shows how quickly empathy can become dangerous when a ghost's account of events is incomplete.
The Brother Who Lived
Craig tells Suze that he and Neil were aboard a catamaran when a storm overturned it, and that Neil, whom he considers clumsy and weak, should have died instead. Jesse fears Craig may try to harm his brother, but Suze resists involving Father Dominic. At school, Paul presses a more enticing possibility: a dead person's soul might take over a living body.
He questions what Suze has been taught about her duties and claims to possess historical evidence about people like them. Curious despite her distrust, Suze agrees to visit his grandfather's house after classes. The invitation ties her urgent wish to understand her own abilities to Paul's private agenda, even before she knows what he intends to show her.
Paul's offer works because Suze's curiosity is not vanity; it is a need for an explanation that her trusted adult mentor cannot provide. His challenge to the idea of mediation as a fixed duty has intellectual force, but he presents that challenge while controlling what information she receives. Craig's resentment supplies a practical urgency, since Suze wants to protect Neil as well as help the dead. The two plots therefore converge on a question of responsibility: whether power is something Suze should obey, investigate, or refuse. Her decision to go is neither simple recklessness nor simple courage.
The Shifter's Price
In Paul's bedroom, Suze examines clippings and a thesis by archaeologist Oliver Slaski, which describes ancient spirit guides called shifters. Paul says he and Suze belong to that group, able to travel into the realm of the dead rather than merely speak with ghosts. He urges her to test the ability by picturing the corridor from her nightmares.
Suze refuses, then asks whether a soul can enter another person's body. Paul withholds the papers, draws her close, and kisses her. She briefly responds before forcing him off and fleeing. At the front door, a dead biker blocks her escape at Paul's apparent command. Suze strikes him with a shoe and runs, shaken by both Paul's coercion and her own attraction.
The archival discovery gives Suze a name for an ability she has never been able to place, but Paul immediately turns knowledge into leverage. The closeness of their exchange matters: he binds a revelation about identity to a kiss, making intellectual discovery difficult to separate from desire and pressure. Suze's momentary reciprocation complicates her anger without making the encounter consensual in its entirety. The biker ghost confirms that Paul can recruit the dead, shifting him from an unnerving classmate to someone with power over the very beings Suze is meant to help.
A Ride Turns Dangerous
Barefoot and injured by the hot pavement, Suze reaches the Sea Mist Cafe, where Neil works for his father. He offers her a ride home, and Craig follows them into the car. Suze learns that Neil survived seven hours in the stormy water and believes his family considers him the less-valued brother. She tells Neil the accident does not prove he deserved to die.
Craig, furious at hearing this, grabs the steering wheel and pushes Neil's foot onto the accelerator, nearly sending the car into a crowded street. Suze and Neil escape a collision, and Craig vanishes. When she finally reaches home, her blistered feet can barely support her. Jesse treats them and stays beside her, offering kindness without asking what caused the injuries.
Suze's attempt to comfort Neil gives Craig's private resentment a public consequence. His attack transforms the question of who deserved survival into immediate physical danger, and the near-crash exposes the limits of treating ghosts as harmless because they lack bodies. Neil's guilt and Craig's certainty are both shaped by family comparison, but Suze refuses to let either become a verdict on whose life matters. Jesse's care offers a quieter kind of intimacy than Paul's attention: practical, respectful, and free of a demand for anything in return.
Roses and Secrets
While Suze is confined to bed, CeeCee calls to rally her for the class vice-presidential campaign, where Paul is her opponent alongside popular candidate Kelly Prescott. Then a bouquet from Paul arrives with an apology. Suze has not told Jesse that Paul returned, much less about the visit to his house, and the flowers make concealment impossible.
Jesse learns the truth and reacts with anger, especially to Paul's claim that he and Suze share powers beyond ordinary mediation. Suze insists that she went seeking knowledge, not romance, and that Paul is lonely as well as dangerous. Jesse does not accept her defense. Their argument leaves Suze unsure whether his anger comes from concern, jealousy, or both.
The roses make private choices visible. Paul turns an apology into a public claim on Suze, while Jesse's anger reveals how much emotional attention he has been withholding. Suze tries to defend Paul without excusing his conduct, a distinction made harder by her own unresolved response to him. Her explanation that Paul is lonely also shows her tendency to interpret harmful behavior through unmet need. The campaign provides a mundane counterpoint: classmates see an election and a romance, while Suze is trying to manage a supernatural conflict no one else can perceive.
The Rectory Decision
After returning to school, Suze learns from Father Dominic that Jesse has agreed to move from her house to the rectory. Jesse had told the priest about their earlier kiss, and Father Dominic believes distance is necessary, leaving Suze convinced that Jesse does not return her feelings. Paul finds her grieving and tries to draw her closer; she refuses another kiss, despite wanting comfort.
Their encounter spills into the crowded breezeway, where Paul abruptly lashes out at Kelly Prescott and a school novice, then leaves campus facing suspension. With Paul gone from the election, Suze wins the vice presidency. The victory feels hollow: she has gained a student office just as she believes she is losing the person she most wants beside her.
This section turns romantic uncertainty into apparent rejection. Jesse delegates the painful news to Father Dominic, and the choice confirms Suze's fear that she has misread their intimacy. Paul's pursuit offers immediate reassurance, but Suze's refusal shows a growing ability to distinguish being wanted from being safe or loved. His public explosion then punctures his polished self-presentation and reveals how little control he has over frustration. Suze's election is a comic, concrete consequence of his departure, yet it cannot repair the private loss that dominates her attention.
The Hot Tub Brawl
At Brad's crowded party, Paul comes to Suze's room and returns a hair clip, using it to imply that she had been in his bed. Jesse attacks him, and their fight crashes through the house and out onto the deck, wrecking a china cabinet and the sliding glass door. As Jesse holds Paul under the hot tub water, Craig appears and pins Neil beneath it too.
Suze has no force strong enough to release them, so she grips their clothes and deliberately enters the foggy spirit corridor. There she confronts Paul and Craig, and Craig finally opens one of the corridor's doors and disappears. Suze pictures the party again and returns to consciousness, where Jesse and the others are trying to revive her.
The party converts the novel's separate pressures into one crisis: family secrecy, Paul's possessiveness, Jesse's protectiveness, and Craig's grievance all collide in a house full of witnesses who cannot see the ghosts. Suze's first deliberate shift is not a demonstration of mastery but a desperate intervention with real physical risk. The corridor, once a nightmare imposed on her, becomes a place she chooses to enter for someone else's safety. Craig's departure remains mysterious, but the decisive change is Suze's agency: she acts without waiting for Paul to teach her or Jesse to rescue her.
The Shifter's Warning
After the party, Suze faces the wreckage and her family's anger, while Paul is taken for treatment with a broken nose. At the Father Serra festival the next day, she shares a booth with CeeCee, who has begun to suspect that Jesse is a ghost. Paul's elderly grandfather arrives with his nurse and, briefly lucid, tells Suze that his real name is Slaski and that he too is a shifter.
He warns that moving through the shadow realm can consume the person who does it, and urges her not to repeat his mistake. Before Suze can ask more, he resumes his confused performance and is wheeled away. The warning unsettles Paul's confident account of their powers just as Suze must decide whom to trust.
The revelation destabilizes the tidy version of power Paul offered. His grandfather's warning comes from lived experience, yet it is delivered in a brief, compromised moment that leaves Suze without proof or instruction. The scene refuses the comforting assumption that ability automatically confers wisdom: both Slaski and Paul possess knowledge, but their uses of it differ. CeeCee's growing belief gives Suze a possible human confidante, while the festival's public bustle contrasts with the private danger of what she has learned. The unresolved warning preserves uncertainty rather than turning the supernatural into a simple rulebook.
A Kiss Beside the Grave
Suze slips away from the festival and finds Jesse in the mission cemetery, standing beside the headstone that marks where he was buried. She assumes he left because he does not love her. Jesse explains that he feared staying after their kiss would keep her from a life with someone who could grow old beside her, not that he regretted caring for her.
Suze tells him that their kiss mattered to her and that she does not measure their bond by ordinary milestones. Jesse draws her close and kisses her again. Their reunion resolves the painful silence between them, though it does not erase the practical difference between a living girl and a ghost or answer every danger raised by Paul's claims.
The cemetery makes the romance's central obstacle impossible to evade: Jesse's grave is both a literal fact and the future Suze cannot share with him. His withdrawal is not indifference but an attempt to protect her from a life constrained by his death. That motive does not spare her the pain of being excluded from the decision. Suze's answer is not a denial of the difference between them; she insists that the relationship's meaning cannot be reduced to social visibility or conventional milestones. The kiss restores mutuality, but the ending leaves their circumstances genuinely unresolved.
Analysis
Haunted treats supernatural ability less as a gift than as an unsettled job description. Suze knows the practical task of mediating, but Paul challenges the limits she has accepted and offers a larger identity with no trustworthy manual. His historical evidence appears to promise certainty; Slaski's warning later reveals that knowledge can be incomplete, self-serving, or dangerous. Suze's first shift matters because she chooses it under pressure to protect Neil, not because she has adopted Paul's account of what she is.
The ghost plots also turn questions of fairness into questions of power. Craig believes athletic achievement should have decided who survived, while Neil absorbs the family comparison that makes his survival feel undeserved. Suze refuses to let either man's worth be measured by performance. Her work requires compassion, but compassion alone cannot prevent Craig from harming someone; she must combine understanding with decisive action.
The romantic triangle is not simply a choice between a safe boy and a dangerous one. Paul makes Suze feel desired and intellectually recognized, yet he uses closeness to pressure her. Jesse offers steadfast care but withholds explanation, believing that distance will protect her. Both men act from motives that include concern, but neither can decide Suze's future for her without causing pain. The closing reunion restores mutual feeling without solving the gap between a living teenager and a ghost. That unresolved difference gives the happy moment its emotional honesty: affection can be real while its practical conditions remain difficult.
Review Summary
Haunted receives mixed reviews, with an average rating of 4.14/5. Fans praise the developing relationships and character growth, particularly between Suze and Jesse. However, some criticize the shift in focus from ghost stories to romance and Paul's controversial character. Readers enjoy Suze's sass and style but find her occasionally frustrating. The book is seen as a turning point in the series, introducing new elements about mediator powers. While nostalgic for some, others feel it hasn't aged well, especially regarding consent issues with Paul.
People Also Read
Characters
Susannah Simon
The stubborn mediatorSuze is a sixteen-year-old New Yorker adjusting to a new California family, a Catholic school, and the strange work of helping ghosts. Direct and physically brave, she often meets danger with sarcasm because fear feels less manageable when spoken plainly. Her loyalty makes her protective of the dead and the living, but it can also tempt her to carry problems alone rather than trust friends or Father Dominic. She wants to understand what she is, not simply accept an assigned role, and Paul's offer of knowledge presses on that desire. Her feelings for Jesse reveal a softer vulnerability than her combative public manner suggests.
Jesse de Silva
The devoted ghostJesse is the nineteenth-century ghost who shares Suze's home and protects her with old-fashioned courtesy and formidable strength. He is principled, reserved, and more comfortable acting than explaining himself. His affection for Suze is complicated by the gulf between his death and her living future, a concern that makes his silences especially painful to her. Jesse does not possess a modern vocabulary for emotional negotiation, so he can mistake withdrawal for kindness. His loyalty is unmistakable, but his protectiveness sometimes leaves Suze feeling managed rather than trusted.
Paul Slater
The dangerous mentorPaul is a charismatic new student who shares Suze's unusual connection to the dead and claims to know far more about it than she does. He is clever, socially assured, and skilled at using charm to control a conversation. Beneath his confidence is a marked hunger for recognition and closeness, though he often seeks both through provocation rather than trust. His interest in Suze mixes intellectual ambition with attraction, making it difficult for her to separate his information from his motives. Paul challenges her assumptions, but his methods make every offer of help feel like a bargain.
Craig Jankow
The competitive brotherCraig is Neil's accomplished older brother, defined by athletic discipline, sailing, and a forceful belief in his own abilities. He is proud and impatient with weakness, especially when he sees it in his brother. His intense competitiveness makes it difficult for him to accept events that contradict his sense of how the world should reward effort. Craig's sharp-edged manner can conceal grief, but it also makes him dangerous when he feels wronged.
Neil Jankow
The quiet survivorNeil is Craig's younger brother and Jake's college friend. Soft-spoken and courteous, he is less socially forceful than Craig and appears to carry the weight of comparison within his family. He works in his father's restaurant and treats Suze with kindness even when she arrives distressed and disheveled. Neil's restraint is not weakness; it allows him to listen without immediately turning pain into accusation. His relationship with Craig exposes how family members can absorb blame for circumstances they did not control.
Father Dominic
The patient priestFather Dominic is the principal of Suze's school and a mediator who offers counsel grounded in compassion and faith. He wants to believe that people can change, which leads him to encourage Suze to give Paul a chance. His generosity is sincere, but it sometimes makes him underestimate the danger Suze recognizes. As Jesse's trusted adviser, he tries to protect both young people, though his decisions can leave Suze feeling excluded from her own relationships.
CeeCee Webb
The perceptive best friendCeeCee is Suze's close friend, a thoughtful school-paper editor who values evidence and asks questions other people avoid. Her albino appearance and practical manner distinguish her from the school's social crowd, but she is not content to remain on the edges of Suze's life. She helps with Suze's campaign and notices when the visible explanation for an event does not fit. CeeCee's loyalty is active rather than unquestioning: she wants the truth because she takes her friendship seriously.
Adam
The loyal campaignerAdam is Suze and CeeCee's friend, an easygoing classmate with a generous streak and a lively interest in campaigning. He helps build Suze's run for vice president and joins CeeCee in supporting her, often using humor to cut through tension. His affection for CeeCee is apparent, though he tends to express it indirectly. Adam is a grounding presence in Suze's school life, even when he cannot see the supernatural events shaping it.
Brad Ackerman
The reckless stepbrotherBrad is one of Suze's stepbrothers, a socially confident teenager who plans a forbidden party while their parents are away. He enjoys provoking Suze and uses a secret about Jesse to keep her from interfering. His bravado and poor judgment create trouble for the whole family, although his party also brings the novel's supernatural conflicts into one public space.
Jake Ackerman
The laid-back elder brotherJake is Suze's oldest stepbrother, newly in college and more relaxed than his father would like. He brings Neil home as a friend and becomes involved in Brad's party plans. Jake's easygoing manner can shade into irresponsibility, particularly when money and family expectations collide. He is not hostile to Suze, but his priorities often leave her to manage the consequences of the household's younger members.
David Ackerman
The observant younger brotherDavid is Suze's thirteen-year-old stepbrother, bright and socially self-conscious. He knows more about her private life than the rest of the family, though he does not understand its supernatural dimensions. His interest in people and patterns makes him a useful observer, while his age puts him in the middle of conflicts he cannot control.
Andy Ackerman
The family peacemakerAndy is Suze's stepfather and the practical center of the Ackerman household. He cooks elaborate family meals and expects everyone to gather together, believing that shared routines help make a family. His warmth is genuine, though his sons' impulsive choices repeatedly test his patience. Andy represents the stable home Suze is still learning to inhabit.
Suze's mother
The protective journalistSuze's mother is a local television journalist who has rebuilt her family life with Andy. She loves Suze and wants her daughter prepared for college and adulthood, sometimes mistaking practical advice for the help Suze needs. Because she does not know about Suze's work with ghosts, she interprets unusual behavior through ordinary teenage concerns.
Oliver Slaski
The elderly scholarOliver Slaski is Paul's elderly grandfather, cared for at home and usually presented as confused and physically frail. His family has obscured parts of his past, leaving others to underestimate what he may understand. He is a quiet presence in Paul's household, a reminder that the younger generation's certainty can rest on an incomplete account of history.
Kelly Prescott
The popular candidateKelly is the polished, popular student who runs for class president and recruits Paul as her running mate. Accustomed to winning, she uses campaign spectacle and social influence to secure support. Her rivalry with Suze brings ordinary school politics into a story otherwise dominated by ghosts.
Sister Ernestine
The strict school nunSister Ernestine is a formidable nun at Suze's mission school, where she helps enforce order and organize school events. Her stern presence gives the academy a traditional authority that contrasts with Suze's impatience and irreverence.
Plot Devices
The Fogbound Corridor
A map of hidden dangerThe corridor first appears in Suze's recurring nightmare, with doors, fog, and a drop into darkness. Its imagery gives shape to a realm between the living world and whatever lies beyond it. At first, Suze experiences the place as a trap associated with Paul and Jesse; later, she deliberately enters it to intervene in a crisis. The corridor therefore changes function as Suze's understanding changes. It is both a supernatural location and a measure of agency, showing the difference between being stranded in a power and choosing to use it.
Mediation and Shifting
Access to the spirit worldSuze's established work as a mediator lets her see and speak with ghosts and help them move on. Paul introduces the disputed idea that she is also a shifter, able to enter the realm of the dead while alive. The distinction drives the novel's central mystery: Suze wants reliable knowledge of her nature, while Paul uses partial teaching to draw her toward his influence. Her first deliberate journey comes only when a crisis leaves her no other way to stop harm. The ability provides a practical solution, but the warning from Slaski keeps its cost uncertain.
Slaski's Research
A contested origin storyPaul shows Suze archival clippings and a thesis by archaeologist Oliver Slaski, connecting ancient spirit guides with people he calls shifters. The documents lend weight to Paul's claims and answer a question Suze has carried for years. Yet the research is not neutral proof: Paul selects what to show and interprets it in a way that makes him indispensable. Slaski's later warning complicates that interpretation by presenting the same ability as potentially destructive. The papers thus serve as both exposition and a test of trust, forcing Suze to distinguish evidence from the motives of the person presenting it.
Craig's Resentment
Grief turned into dangerCraig's belief that Neil should have died in his place gives the ghost plot its immediate moral and physical stakes. His competitive self-image makes survival seem like a mistake that must be corrected, and Suze's attempts to reassure Neil provoke him rather than calm him. The resentment escalates from bitter conversation to interference with Neil's car and, later, a direct threat at the party. Craig's story gives Suze a reason to test her developing ability, while also showing that helping a ghost move on may require confronting the living person's safety first.
The Class Election
A public mirror for private conflictThe vice-presidential race sets Suze and Paul in competition within the ordinary social world of school. Kelly's popularity and campaign tactics create pressure for CeeCee and Adam to organize on Suze's behalf, while Suze's interest in the election remains secondary to her supernatural and romantic problems. Paul's public outburst abruptly removes him from the race and gives Suze the win, turning a school result into a consequence of his emotional volatility. The campaign also exposes the gap between how classmates perceive Paul and Suze and what they know about each other's private lives.
The Mediator Series Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.