Plot Summary
A Sylph Falls From Blue
Evie has traded her dangerous life at the International Paranormal Containment Agency for high school, diner shifts, and weekends with her boyfriend, Lend. Then a cloudlike being snatches her outside school and carries her into the sky. Terrified, Evie presses her hand to it and accidentally draws away a spark of its life force.
They crash through trees, and the being escapes, weakened but alive. Back at Lend’s house, Evie discovers that Raquel, her former guardian and an IPCA supervisor, had not arranged the abduction. Raquel explains that the creature is a sylph, an air elemental, and asks Evie to help the agency. Evie’s ordinary life has barely begun before the paranormal world finds her again.
The opening makes normality feel less like a safe destination than a role Evie has not learned to inhabit. Soccer and school bore her, yet her reflexive use of power frightens her because it offers both protection and pleasure. The sylph’s appearance also establishes an important uncertainty: danger has returned, but its cause is not yet clear. Raquel’s arrival places Evie between a familiar institution she distrusts and an ordinary life that feels emotionally thin.
The Boy Who Opens Doors
Raquel offers Evie voluntary contract work, promising that she can refuse any assignment and avoid the faeries whose magic once controlled her life. Evie’s boyfriend Lend and his father, David, oppose the idea, while Evie resents being left with a life that feels small and unneeded. Then Jack appears through a faerie door, despite having no visible paranormal glamour.
Raquel explains that he can use the Paths, the dangerous routes between worlds, without a faerie guide. Evie is intrigued by his impossible talent and by the chance to help paranormals, but she does not accept immediately. After a dream conversation with Vivian helps her name what she misses, Evie agrees to work on her own terms.
Evie’s return to IPCA is driven less by loyalty than by a need to matter. Her argument with Lend exposes their unequal relationship to risk: he sees the agency’s harms, while she remembers the people it once helped her protect. Jack’s unexplained talent makes freedom look possible without faerie dependence, but his casual boundary-crossing also makes him difficult to trust. Evie chooses action before she has resolved the moral conflict behind it.
A Ghost in Central Processing
Evie’s first assignment takes her back to IPCA’s Center, where a poltergeist is terrifying staff and disrupting files. The disturbance leads her into Central Processing, once home to Lish’s aquarium, and the empty room brings back the pain of losing her mermaid friend. The ghost reveals himself as Steve, a vampire who died after choosing death over containment.
Evie talks with him rather than trying to destroy him, and he finally releases his hold on the Center. A faerie appears in the hallway afterward, and Raquel asks Evie to stay for her safety. Jack disappears, leaving Evie at the Center for two nights. Lend eventually extracts her, and Evie hides why she had been unreachable.
The mission turns Evie’s former workplace into a physical archive of grief. She can see through the poltergeist’s frightening tricks, but the vanished aquarium hurts more than any illusion because it makes Lish’s absence seem institutional and final. By listening to Steve instead of treating him as a target, Evie acts differently from the agent she used to be. Yet her silence with Lend shows that choosing a new role has not taught her how to share its costs.
Sweden’s River Takes Its Toll
For a mission to locate a suspected troll colony in Trollhättan, Sweden, Jack opens a door that drops Evie into the Göta älv river. A fossegrim lures her underwater with music and nearly drowns her before she drains a portion of its energy and escapes. The river then feels strangely legible to her, as though its currents have become companions.
Shivering and soaked, Evie follows a small girl with a tail through the town, hoping to identify the trolls’ address. The locals close in around her, invisible until her sight catches their disguises. Jack cannot see them at first, and the trolls seize Evie before he slips away through a door. Their leader accuses her of being a vampire who hunts troll children.
The river attack makes Evie’s new power bodily rather than theoretical. She survives by taking energy again, and the resulting ease she feels in water unsettles her as much as the danger did. Jack’s failed landing leaves her exposed, while the trolls’ ability to disappear turns her special sight into a liability: it identifies her as an intruder before she understands their situation. The sequence keeps survival and belonging entangled.
Trolls Choose Their Protector
The troll leader, Birgitta, explains that her people bought the houses in Trollhättan after a dam destroyed their former homes; they have harmed no humans and fear IPCA will remove them anyway. Their children are being killed by a vampire who preys on trolls, so Evie agrees to help find him. She locates the vampire alone, but his unnatural strength overwhelms her and he nearly bites her.
Jack arrives with a baseball bat, giving Evie time to attach an ankle tracker while IPCA transporters take the vampire into containment. Evie then lies to the agency, claiming the trolls were merely passing through, so they can remain in their homes. The choice protects the colony but deepens her secrecy from Lend and IPCA.
Birgitta’s account forces Evie to distinguish a community’s identity from the agency’s category for it. The trolls resemble the threats IPCA expects, but their history and conduct contradict that expectation. Evie’s lie is an act of protection, though it repeats the very secrecy that is damaging her closest relationships. Her restraint toward the vampire matters too: she brings him in alive despite the growing temptation to use her power against him.
Halloween Turns on Carlee
At Halloween, Evie leaves a date with Lend to find Jack at a party in a cemetery, where she expects trouble. The unusually powerful vampire she helped capture has escaped containment and appears in the dark. He compels Evie’s school friend Carlee, then uses her as a shield while threatening Evie. When he bites Evie, she drains part of his soul; Lend arrives and knocks him away before she can take more.
IPCA recaptures the vampire, but Evie is shaken by how much she wanted to continue. That night, Arianna tells Evie how a vampire named Felix changed her and how she killed him to stop him attacking another girl. Her account makes Evie confront the difference between defending someone and surrendering to appetite.
The attack collapses Evie’s private fear into a visible moral crisis: her power can stop a predator, but it also gives her a rush she cannot dismiss as purely defensive. Lend saves her from the immediate fight without knowing that he may have interrupted her own loss of control. Arianna’s history complicates easy judgments about violence. Her protective act does not erase the horror of what happened to her, just as Evie’s good intentions cannot guarantee that power will remain harmless.
The Queen’s Burning Lake
When Georgetown rejects Evie, the future she had organized around college and Lend suddenly seems to vanish. Jack takes her into the Faerie Realms, where she sees the Dark Queen’s human servants carrying her and understands the cruelty beneath the court’s beauty. Jack throws firebombs at the Queen’s ship, setting the vessel and the silver lake alight.
As they flee, the damaged faerie Fehl attacks Evie, blaming her for her condition. Evie uses Fehl’s true name to freeze her, but Reth arrives before Evie can decide what to do next. He takes them away and warns Evie that her choices have consequences. Her rejection, her anger at the faeries, and Jack’s appetite for destruction now converge in a place she never wanted to enter.
The rejection letter strips away Evie’s borrowed plan for becoming ordinary, and Jack fills the resulting vacancy with spectacle and vengeance. The Dark Queen’s enthralled servants give Evie evidence of real cruelty, but the firebombing converts witness into retaliation before she can choose a response. Her command over Fehl gives her a form of control she rarely possesses, yet Reth’s arrival reminds her that faerie power is layered with obligations she does not understand.
A Father at NASCAR
Reth brings Evie to a NASCAR race and identifies the disheveled faerie Lin as her father. Lin barely recognizes her and cannot say where her human mother went. Reth explains that the faerie courts created Evie as an Empty One, a being able to move energy and open gates between worlds.
She is not half-faerie, he says, but something less mortal, made for the courts’ purposes. The revelation deepens Evie’s fear that she belongs nowhere. She forces Lin to return to Faerie and never come back, then tells Lend that she has known he is immortal since prom. Convinced that she will die while he lasts forever, Evie ends their relationship and leaves with Jack.
The parentage revelation offers biological origins without offering care. Lin’s indifference is more destabilizing than a clear rejection because it confirms that Evie was treated as an assignment rather than a child. Reth’s explanation gives her a category, but that category is built around what others need her to do. Evie responds by reclaiming one choice, sending Lin away, then makes another choice for Lend without asking him what future he wants.
Jack Leaves Her Nowhere
Jack brings Evie to Vivian’s bedside, then admits that he arranged the attacks and setbacks to push Evie into draining enough paranormal energy to open a gate. He wants her to send the faeries to hell, arguing that their cruelty and his own captivity justify it. Evie recognizes that condemning an entire people would turn her into the kind of force she fears, and refuses.
Jack abandons her in the Faerie Paths, where breaking contact should mean endless isolation. Evie survives by concentrating on memories of Lend, Raquel, David, and Arianna until the darkness becomes a route toward them. She falls out of the Paths into Lend’s arms, injured but alive, and finally understands home as the people she chooses.
Jack’s betrayal reveals how thoroughly he has converted suffering into a moral license for revenge. Evie is tempted because his grievance is real, but she refuses to confuse injury with authority over an entire people’s fate. The Paths literalize her fear of abandonment, while her escape depends not on mastering them but on recognizing attachment as a direction. Home becomes relational and chosen, not a birthplace or a court’s claim.
Home Is a Chosen Place
Back at David’s house, Arianna splints Evie’s broken arm and reveals she has prepared applications to nearby colleges, offering possibilities Evie had refused to consider. Lend takes Evie to the pond and challenges her assumption that his immortal soul dictates the life he must live.
He wants to continue his studies, build a future, and make those choices with her, rather than be treated as though he has already become his mother. Evie admits that fear of being left made her hide the truth and decide for him. Lend asks her to meet him between the mortal and paranormal worlds they both inhabit. Evie agrees to honesty and accepts that their future cannot be guaranteed, only chosen together.
The resolution does not solve mortality or erase the differences that frightened Evie. Instead, it corrects her central mistake: she had treated Lend’s possible future as settled fact and concealed information to control the outcome. Arianna’s college applications offer a practical counterpart to that emotional shift, replacing one brittle plan with several real options. The ending defines commitment as continuing choice, not certainty that loss can be prevented.
Analysis
Supernaturally asks whether a person can build a self while other people keep trying to define what that self is for. Evie has been raised by institutions, pursued by faerie courts, and loved by people whose possible futures frighten her. Each group offers a different explanation of her value: IPCA sees a useful ability, the faeries see a means to open gates, and Jack sees a weapon against his captors. Even affection can become coercive when Reth treats his judgment as more trustworthy than Evie’s own. The novel’s central ethical pressure comes from the fact that these claims are not equally false. IPCA does protect some people, the faeries have committed genuine cruelties, and Evie’s power can stop immediate harm. Yet a good end does not grant unlimited authority over another life. Her most important restraint is refusing to condemn an entire species to hell, even when anger and personal injury make that choice emotionally persuasive.
The parallel character arcs sharpen this argument. Vivian recognizes that pain did not erase her responsibility for the lives she took. Arianna’s history shows how victimization can coexist with agency, including the choice to prevent another person’s suffering. Jack, by contrast, converts his own abuse into a plan that would impose permanent punishment on others. Evie stands at the intersection of these possibilities. Her power makes moral abstraction impossible because taking a soul is intimate, physical, and pleasurable to her. The story does not pretend that restraint makes her harmless or that love resolves every danger. It instead treats self-limitation as an active choice.
Evie’s romance with Lend is shaped by the same problem. She hides his immortality because she fears that knowledge will make him leave, then assumes that his future is already determined. His insistence that he can choose his life restores the agency she tried to protect by taking it away. The ending’s home is therefore not a fixed location or a promise against loss. It is a relationship in which people are allowed to know the truth and decide together what comes next.
Review Summary
Supernaturally received mixed reviews from readers. Many enjoyed the humor and unique paranormal elements, praising Evie's character development and the introduction of Jack. However, some felt the sequel lacked the spark of the first book, with a slower plot and less engaging romance. Critics noted Evie's increased angst and occasional selfishness. Despite these concerns, fans appreciated the expanded worldbuilding and character depth. Overall, readers found it an entertaining, if somewhat uneven, continuation of the series, with most looking forward to the final installment.
People Also Read
Characters
Evie
The reluctant bridgeEvie is a sharp, funny teenager who can see through paranormal disguises and has spent much of her life being told where she belongs. She craves ordinary pleasures such as school, lockers, and romance, yet becomes restless when that life leaves her feeling useless. Her instinct is to help, but her unusual power makes every act of defense ethically complicated. Evie is especially afraid of abandonment, so she sometimes hides facts or makes decisions for people she loves. Her wit protects her from fear without curing it. She is most herself when she recognizes that belonging comes through mutual choice, not through an institution, a prophecy, or a supernatural origin.
Lend
The visible-hearted elementalLend is Evie’s boyfriend, a shape-shifter whose true body resembles living water and whose human appearance is a glamour. He is curious about paranormal life but also devoted to study, planning a future through biology and zoology. His warmth extends beyond Evie: he treats paranormals as people rather than specimens, which helps David’s community feel accepted. Lend distrusts IPCA because he has seen how its methods harm those it claims to protect. He can become protective to the point of arguing for Evie, but his deepest need is honesty and the freedom to make his own choices. His steadiness contrasts with Evie’s fear that love must end in loss.
Jack
The impossible pathfinderJack is a human boy with an uncanny ability to open doors onto the Faerie Paths. He is acrobatic, irreverent, curious, and almost impossible to keep on topic. His jokes and theatrical confidence make him seem carefree, but his knowledge of the Faerie Realms suggests a childhood shaped by danger and improvisation. Jack offers Evie access to places and experiences beyond her routine, and their shared sense of being outsiders creates an uneasy bond. He often ignores boundaries and treats danger as entertainment, forcing Evie to decide how much of his adventurousness she can tolerate.
Reth
A beautiful faerie strategistReth is an elegant faerie with a long, painful history with Evie. He can be attentive and protective, but his affection is inseparable from a belief that he understands her destiny better than she does. He speaks in riddles, uses enchantment, and frames coercion as care, making it difficult for Evie to trust either his tenderness or his warnings. Reth moves within the political world of the faerie courts and is burdened by its schemes, though he rarely explains himself plainly. His power lies partly in his beauty and partly in his ability to make Evie doubt her own reading of him.
Raquel
Reforming agency chiefRaquel is Evie’s former guardian and a senior IPCA supervisor who combines practical competence with a guarded maternal affection. She is trying to reform an organization whose old policies caused real harm, and she recruits Evie because the agency needs her abilities. Raquel respects Evie’s wish for independence in principle, although urgency and her own sense of responsibility sometimes push her to overstep. Her relationship with David remains emotionally charged, and their old disagreements reveal that both care about protecting paranormals, despite very different ideas of how to do it.
Arianna
The undead fashionistaArianna is Evie’s vampire roommate, a former fashion student with sharp opinions, dark humor, and a talent for design. She avoids human blood and helps David maintain a safe place for paranormals, but immortality has left her isolated from the life she expected to have. Her online games and fashion sketches offer outlets for creativity, though she often retreats behind sarcasm when she feels unwanted. Arianna understands the difference between a person’s choices and the circumstances imposed on them, but she does not want pity. Her frankness challenges Evie to see vampires as individuals rather than as a single frightening category.
David
Paranormal sanctuary keeperDavid is Lend’s father and the owner of On the Hoof, a diner that doubles as a refuge and meeting place for local paranormals. A former agency operative, he distrusts institutions that claim authority over supernatural lives and prefers community protection to containment. David is generous, patient, and unusually willing to keep caring for people even when they cannot return his love in the same form. His relationship with Cresseda exposes the cost of loving someone whose nature is fundamentally different from his own. He provides Evie with safety without demanding that she become ordinary.
Vivian
The haunted mirrorVivian is another Empty One and a former adversary whose loneliness and history with the faeries echo Evie’s fears. She appears to Evie in dreams, where their uneasy connection can become intimate without erasing old harm. Vivian is candid about the selfishness that can hide inside a claim to be helping others. Her presence gives Evie a rare companion who understands the seduction and danger of taking souls. She is also linked to the losses Evie carries, making comfort between them inseparable from guilt.
Nona
The rooted guardianNona manages On the Hoof and is a huldra, a tree spirit who moves through the diner with the calm authority of someone rooted in a larger world. She supports David’s refuge and assures Evie that the girl is safe under her care. Nona is patient but secretive, and her dealings with unfamiliar paranormals make Evie question what she knows. Her presence connects the town’s everyday routines to older elemental communities. She rarely offers explanations simply to ease someone else’s anxiety.
Carlee
Evie’s human school friendCarlee is Evie’s cheerful, makeup-loving friend at school and one of the few people in Evie’s daily life who is not paranormal. She talks openly about crushes, parties, and school gossip, giving Evie a glimpse of the ordinary teenage friendship she has wanted. Carlee is trusting and generous, sometimes following excitement before considering its risks. Her presence reminds Evie that the human world is not merely a background for supernatural danger; it contains friendships Evie wants to protect.
Cresseda
The distant water motherCresseda is Lend’s mother, a water elemental whose nature makes sustained human relationships difficult. She appears irregularly and is difficult for David and Lend to understand, even though both love her. Her distance shapes Lend’s questions about his own nature and gives Evie a vivid example of how immortality might strain a relationship across time. Cresseda is less a conventional parent than a reminder that love does not always make two lives compatible.
Fehl
A damaged faerie pursuerFehl is a faerie whose courtly beauty has been disrupted by violence and the consequences of earlier schemes. She is angry, volatile, and intent on recovering the favor of her queen. Her pursuit of Evie turns the abstract politics of the faerie courts into a personal danger. Fehl’s resentment is real, but it does not make her harmless, and Evie must decide whether to answer aggression with her own power.
Birgitta
Troll community leaderBirgitta leads the trolls of Trollhättan, a community that has built a life inside human society after losing its former home. She is proud, watchful, and unwilling to trust an agency that may classify her people as threats regardless of their conduct. Her plea for protection centers on the vulnerability of the troll children.
Lin
The erratic faerieLin is a faerie whose disheveled appearance and distracted behavior sharply contrast with the polished figures Evie expects from the courts. He is volatile, difficult to engage, and more interested in the spectacle around him than in other people. His presence hints at the strain of crossing between faerie and human worlds.
The Swedish vampire
Predatory vampireThe vampire Evie encounters in Sweden is unusually strong and driven by a bitter belief that other paranormals are responsible for what happened to him. He targets troll children, then turns his attention toward Evie when he senses something unusual in her. His long existence has hardened grievance into a worldview, making him dangerous even when he speaks as if he has reasoned everything through.
Lish
The absent mermaid friendLish was Evie’s friend and colleague at the Center, a mermaid whose aquarium once brought color and life to Central Processing. Evie’s memories of her shape how the girl understands loss and the costs of IPCA’s failures. Lish remains an emotional presence even when she is not part of the present action.
Plot Devices
Glamour-piercing sight
See Through GlamoursEvie can see the paranormal reality beneath glamours, including disguises that make creatures appear human or invisible. This ability once made her valuable to IPCA, which used her to identify and contain paranormals. In the story it also lets her recognize the sylph, distinguish a vampire from its glamour, and discover the trolls surrounding her. The sight is powerful but not neutral: it separates Evie from classmates who cannot see what she sees, and it can make ordinary encounters feel charged with hidden danger.
Empty One energy channel
Borrowed Soul EnergyAs an Empty One, Evie can draw energy from paranormal beings through physical contact. The ability can save her life, as when she escapes the sylph and the fossegrim, but it also produces a dangerous sense of exhilaration and desire for more. After these encounters, Evie notices changes in her relationship to air and water, while a vampire’s attack brings the temptation close to a moral breaking point. The power turns defense into an ongoing question about consent, restraint, and who gets to decide when another being’s life force is expendable.
The Faerie Paths
Interworld RoutesThe Faerie Paths are dark passages linking places and worlds. Travelers generally need to remain connected to a guide, since losing that contact can leave them stranded in the emptiness. Faeries navigate the Paths naturally, while Jack has learned to open doors through walls and reach destinations without a faerie escort. The Paths make rapid missions possible and let the story move between school, the Center, Sweden, and Faerie. Their darkness also gives physical form to Evie’s fear of isolation, and her eventual way out depends on locating a place through personal connection.
Lend’s iron pendant
Iron Against EnchantmentLend gives Evie a silver heart pendant set with pink stones, its heart made of iron to protect her from faerie influence. The gift expresses his instinct to care for her in a practical, personal way. Iron also prevents Evie from entering the Faerie Paths while she wears it, forcing her to remove it before an assignment. The pendant therefore carries two meanings at once: it is a token of love and a physical safeguard, but using it to participate in IPCA work requires Evie to set that protection aside.
Names, gates, and home
Power Through ConnectionFaerie names can give a person power to command their bearer, while gates connect worlds in a way that ordinary doors do not. Evie’s ability to open gates is tied to her unusual nature, but she does not fully understand or control it. Jack tries to turn that power into a weapon against the faeries. The Paths finally reveal a different use: Evie finds her way out by concentrating on memories of the people who make a home for her. The device shifts from coercion and escape to the idea that identity is shaped by chosen bonds.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.