Key Takeaways
Make discernment about whom you can serve, not how perfectly you can express yourself.
Turn outward first. Schmitz argues that decisions become distorted when the main question is which career, relationship, or lifestyle will maximize personal fulfillment. He calls this outlook expressive individualism: the belief that a person becomes fully themselves by finding a role that displays their identity. Drawing on sociologist Robert Bellah, he presents vocation as its counterweight: a call beyond the self, toward God and other people.
Look for a real need. A seminarian once observed that his peers spent so much time examining their own motives that they stopped looking outward. Schmitz’s practical alternative is to notice where someone needs help, then consider what abilities or time could meet that need. The goal is not to erase personal gifts, but to use them in service rather than treating self-expression as life’s final purpose.
What's striking is the shift from choosing a role as a personal brand to asking what a role makes possible for other people. That resembles relational theories of identity, which argue that people become themselves through commitments and relationships, not only through private preference. Service can also make a decision more concrete: needs are observable, while the promise of perfect self-expression is difficult to test. Still, service should not become a command to ignore one's limits or accept exploitation. Sustainable care requires attention to both the recipient's needs and the giver's capacities.
Let a good path beat the fantasy of a perfect one.
More options can burden choice. Schmitz uses Barry Schwartz’s paradox of choice to explain why abundance can make decisions harder. A shopper once faced a few basic kinds of jeans; now, an enormous range of cuts and fits can make every option feel like a compromise. With more possibilities comes a higher expectation that the perfect choice must exist.
Good enough can be good. The same pressure can infect decisions about work, relationships, and vocation. Instead of choosing a sound path, someone may keep comparing possibilities in search of the one that promises maximum happiness. Schmitz warns that the ideal of the perfect can crowd out a genuinely good option. Discernment, in his account, is not endless reflection. It requires making a choice and moving into action.
Choice research helps explain the trap: when options multiply, comparison costs rise, and people can become more dissatisfied with the option they select. The useful correction is not to settle for harm or mediocrity, but to distinguish a sound decision from an imagined, flawless one. A practical standard is whether an option meets the important requirements and can be chosen responsibly, rather than whether it defeats every alternative. This is especially helpful when no decision can reveal the future in advance.
Keep holiness fixed while allowing your role and daily assignment to change.
Separate three callings. Schmitz describes vocation at three levels. The first is the universal call to holiness, understood as bringing one’s will into alignment with God’s. This destination does not change. The second is a primary way of life, such as marriage, priesthood, religious life, or single life. The third is the changing work or response called for today.
Roles serve the deeper aim. Schmitz does not define marriage or religious life as a list of tasks. He asks what central relationships will shape a person through love and self-giving. A spouse, a religious community, or neighbors may become the principal setting in which someone learns to serve. These particular paths can change, but they are not the ultimate purpose. In this Catholic framework, the constant aim is holiness, pursued through different relationships and daily responsibilities.
The three-level distinction prevents a common category error: treating a job or marital status as the whole of a person's purpose. It also gives change a place in a coherent life. Developmental psychology similarly distinguishes enduring values from the roles people occupy at different stages. One useful caution is that the categories are not equally clear for everyone. People may face involuntary singleness, changing family responsibilities, or uncertain religious commitments. The framework is most humane when it offers direction without implying that every life must fit a simple, settled label.
Do not mistake God's guidance for a demand to choose misery.
Difficulty is not proof. Schmitz challenges the idea that God must want whatever a person likes least. That assumption, he says, can come from mistrust: God is imagined as a harsh authority rather than a loving Father. He argues that a person's genuine joy can be compatible with God's will, much as a parent's joy includes seeing a child flourish. That does not make every desire wise or good, but it rules out suffering as an automatic test of faithfulness.
Trust can take time. In the biblical story Schmitz recounts, Gideon asks for signs before accepting a difficult mission. Schmitz also describes his own long prayer about priesthood. He believes the answer came when he could accept it freely, rather than feeling forced into a decision before he was ready.
This insight addresses a subtle form of religious anxiety: interpreting every preference as suspect and every hardship as a divine instruction. A healthier account of moral agency can treat enjoyment as meaningful information without treating it as conclusive evidence. The distinction matters because a choice may be difficult for good reasons, while an easy choice may still be unwise. The section's emphasis on trust offers emotional relief, but discerning a desire still requires testing it against responsibilities, ethical constraints, and its effects on others.
Use your past and present to choose the next faithful step.
The future stays hidden. Schmitz says people often ask for a complete forecast because uncertainty feels like danger. Yet a person can examine what has already happened, recognize the situation they are in now, and identify the lasting aim of becoming holy. That is enough to take a next step, even if it does not reveal every step after it.
Own the decision. When Schmitz was unsure about attending seminary, his father told him he was free to choose an ordinary college if he did not yet know he was being asked to do otherwise. The lesson is that uncertainty does not always conceal a secret instruction. Schmitz warns that wanting God to make every choice can be a way to avoid responsibility or blame God if the outcome is hard. Choosing is part of the dignity of discernment.
This is a practical alternative to both paralysis and false certainty. In decision theory, people often act under incomplete information; the rational task is to make the best choice available, not to demand impossible certainty. Looking at past patterns can reveal what has proved meaningful or damaging, while the present supplies constraints a fantasy cannot. The approach also separates responsibility from control: a person can own a decision without guaranteeing its outcome. Past experience is informative, though not destiny, since people and circumstances can change.
Check grace, duties, and prayer before asking for a dramatic sign.
Start with three questions. Schmitz recommends asking whether one is in a state of grace, meaning, in his Catholic framing, not consciously separated from God by mortal sin; whether one is carrying out the responsibilities of the day; and whether one has prayed. He also describes prevenient grace as God's initiative in drawing someone back, including through the sacrament of confession.
Practice ordinary yeses. Daily responsibilities are not merely distractions from a major calling. Schmitz treats them as chances to respond faithfully in the present. He recommends setting aside about twenty minutes each day simply to be with God, rather than making the time another task list. His point is that regular prayer and ordinary follow-through build readiness for larger commitments. He says these practices keep a person connected and responsive, not busy decoding coincidences.
The three questions translate a large spiritual aspiration into repeatable checks. Their structure resembles a pre-flight checklist: address basic conditions before taking on a more complex decision. Regular prayer can also create reflective space, making it easier to notice motives that constant activity obscures. The sacramental language is specifically Catholic, and the recommended practice should not be mistaken for a universally accepted method of decision-making. Nor can a routine guarantee that a person will never misunderstand a situation. Its value lies in forming attention and steady commitment.
Test a choice for goodness, availability, wisdom, and genuine desire.
Screen the possible path. Schmitz uses the image of a door to organize four checks: Is the choice morally good? Is it actually available? Is it wise for this person, given their history and aims? Do they want to take it? A choice that fails the first test should be rejected. A good choice may still be unavailable because it depends on someone else's consent or decision.
A closed door is information. One man proposed to two different women, and both relationships ended after the women initially accepted. Schmitz told him that his willingness did not settle the question; the other person's decision mattered too. Likewise, a religious community may decide not to accept an applicant. Discernment includes receiving these limits, not treating every rejection as proof of personal failure or as a coded message.
The sequence usefully separates moral permission, practical feasibility, judgment, and motivation. Those are different questions, and confusing them can produce wasted effort or needless self-blame. The open-door test is especially strong because it treats other people's agency as real evidence, not an obstacle to be spiritually explained away. Yet availability alone does not establish that a choice is wise, and desire can be mixed or unstable. The framework works best as a disciplined conversation, not as a machine that outputs certainty.
Choose one vocation at a time, then gather evidence by acting.
Commit to the question in front of you. Schmitz advises people not to remain in a relationship while treating religious life as a simultaneous backup plan, or to enter a formation community while privately pursuing a competing romantic possibility. His recommendation is to discern the commitment actually being considered, rather than keeping incompatible futures alive indefinitely.
Action makes the question clearer. Reflection has limits when no new information is arriving. Schmitz suggests taking practical steps: speak with a trusted person, visit a community, or ask someone on a date. These actions reveal facts that imagination cannot supply. The point is not to rush into a permanent commitment. It is to move from abstract speculation toward a real test, then use what happens to decide what to do next.
This advice counters the belief that more private thought always produces better judgment. In fields from career counseling to experimental science, information often comes from trying a bounded action and observing the result. A trial can expose incompatibilities, clarify attraction, or show what a commitment demands. The caution is that some situations genuinely involve overlapping obligations or unresolved feelings. Acting should therefore mean a clear, ethical experiment, not making promises to multiple people while postponing accountability.
Start becoming holy where you are, including through wounds and ordinary work.
Do not wait for the perfect role. Schmitz argues that holiness is not reserved for people with flawless personalities, dramatic prayer lives, or church jobs. He describes saints as people whose struggles did not prevent God from shaping their lives. In his account, being holy means responding to God amid real limitations, not first eliminating every weakness.
Make the present a gift. Schmitz uses the example of Jan Tyranowski, a Polish tailor who remained single and organized a parish prayer group. The young Karol Wojtyla, who became Pope John Paul II, initially found him off-putting, then came to value his influence. The story illustrates how a person's ordinary work and chosen availability can serve others profoundly. Schmitz also says that someone working outside the Church can pursue holiness in that setting; changing circumstances is not a prerequisite for beginning.
The emphasis on holiness amid imperfection resists the fantasy that transformation begins only after someone becomes polished, certain, or professionally religious. It also gives ordinary work and singleness moral weight without treating either as a lesser life. The story of Tyranowski shows how influence can travel through small, local acts rather than public status. A necessary nuance is that sanctifying a wound does not mean preserving a harmful condition or refusing help. Growth can include treatment, boundaries, and change, as well as patient acceptance.
Analysis
The book's central move is to change the question beneath decision-making. Instead of asking which option will maximize the chooser's self-expression, it asks what kind of person the chooser is becoming, whom they can serve, and what response is appropriate now. This reframing links a theological account of vocation to ordinary decision practice. The argument moves from purpose, to the levels at which vocation operates, to habits of discernment, and finally to practical tests for choices. Its stories keep the framework from becoming purely abstract: a rejected proposal shows that another person's agency can close a path, while Jan Tyranowski's example gives significance to work and service that might otherwise appear unremarkable.
The strongest practical contribution is its rejection of both endless analysis and false certainty. Schmitz treats action as a way to learn, not merely as the final stage after perfect deliberation. That resembles experimental approaches to decisions: take a responsible step, observe the world, and update. The distinction between a stable ultimate aim and changing daily tasks also helps prevent one job, relationship, or setback from carrying the entire weight of a person's identity.
The book's theological confidence is also its boundary. Its guidance assumes a Catholic understanding of God, grace, sin, prayer, and holiness. Readers outside that tradition can still use its distinctions between values, roles, daily duties, and available choices, but may not accept its claims about divine communication. Even within the tradition, the instruction that God speaks clearly needs careful interpretation. Moral prohibitions may be clear while questions about marriage, work, or vocation remain ambiguous. The framework is most useful when clarity means acting responsibly with the knowledge available, not expecting unmistakable supernatural instructions.
Ultimately, the book presents discernment less as solving a hidden puzzle than as building a life of faithful responsiveness. It makes room for personal desire, but places desire within service, moral limits, and responsibility. Its most persuasive promise is not that every choice will be obvious or painless. It is that a person's purpose need not be postponed until the future is certain.
Review Summary
"How to Make Great Decisions" receives high praise from readers for its practical advice on discernment and decision-making. Many appreciate Fr. Mike's conversational style and ability to simplify complex topics. Reviewers find the book's message life-changing, especially for young adults and those in transition. While some wish for more depth, most agree it's a quick, insightful read that offers valuable guidance on aligning one's will with God's. The book's concise nature is both a strength and a weakness, with some finding it profound and others wanting more elaboration.
People Also Read
Glossary
Expressive individualism
Self-expression as life’s aimA cultural outlook, discussed through sociologist Robert Bellah, that treats fulfillment as finding a career, relationship, or way of life that expresses one's personal identity. Schmitz contrasts it with vocation understood as a call beyond the self, toward God and the needs of other people.
Paradox of choice
Options that complicate choosingBarry Schwartz's concept, as presented in the book, that a large number of options can make decisions more difficult and raise expectations that the best possible option must be found. Schmitz applies it to life choices, where searching for a perfect path can keep someone from choosing a genuinely good one.
Three levels of vocation
Three scales of callingSchmitz's framework separates vocation into a universal call to holiness, a primary way of life such as marriage or religious life, and the changing responsibilities or responses called for each day. The distinction keeps a person's ultimate spiritual aim separate from roles that may change and tasks that change frequently.
Prevenient grace
Grace that moves firstA Catholic theological term for God's grace acting before a person has earned or initiated a return to God. Schmitz uses it to explain that even someone conscious of serious sin can be drawn toward confession and reconciliation because God is already reaching out.
The door
A test for a decisionSchmitz's image for evaluating a possible choice. The decision is examined for whether it is morally good, actually available, wise in light of the person's situation, and genuinely desired. The image emphasizes that a path can be good but closed, especially when another person's consent or an institution's decision is involved.
State of grace
Reconciled relationship with GodIn the book's Catholic usage, being in a state of grace means living in relationship with God and not being conscious of mortal sin. Schmitz includes this as one of three daily questions for discernment and points to confession as a way of returning to that relationship.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.