Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Malice
Malice

Malice

A friend kills a novelist and casts himself as the victim. A detective dismantles the lie.
by Keigo Higashino 1996 288 pages
4.06
36k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.1
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Paperweight and Phone Cord

Nonoguchi kills his childhood friend, then fakes an alibi

Nonoguchi1 arrives at Hidaka3's house on April 16, finding the author packing for his imminent move to Vancouver. In the nearly empty office, Hidaka3 casually admits he poisoned the neighbor's cat to protect his property value before prospective tenants visit.

Their talk is cut short when Miyako Fujio6 arrives, still demanding that Hidaka3 retract the novel based on her dead brother's life. Nonoguchi1 excuses himself, leaves a bottle of Dom Pérignon champagne with Rie,4 and exits through the front door. But instead of leaving, he circles to the back garden, waits until both Fujio6 and Rie4 have departed, and climbs through the unlocked office window.

When Hidaka3 returns to the room, Nonoguchi1 bludgeons him from behind with the brass paperweight, then strangles him with the telephone cord. Before fleeing, he sets Hidaka3's computer to auto-fax a manuscript file to his own apartment at precisely 6:13 p.m., creating the skeleton of a false alibi.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The murder scene establishes the book's central tension between surface and depth. Nonoguchi's account of the visit seems warm and ordinary: two old friends chatting, cherry blossoms, champagne for the newlyweds. But every detail he records will later prove to be weaponized: the cat story paints Hidaka as cruel; the Fujio visit establishes the legal threat; the champagne bottle was a backup murder weapon. The reader, unknowingly, is being trained to see Hidaka through Nonoguchi's distorting lens. The physical violence of the murder is rendered almost clinically, reflecting Nonoguchi's emotional detachment from the act itself. For him, the real violence is not the killing but the reputation-destruction he has planned for afterward.

Lights Out at Hidaka's

Kaga, a former colleague, arrives and a false account begins

After killing Hidaka,3 Nonoguchi1 returns home. His editor Oshima9 arrives at six. At exactly 6:13, Hidaka3's computer dials Nonoguchi1's apartment; Nonoguchi1 picks up and, with Oshima9 nearby, performs a one-sided conversation, pretending Hidaka3 is asking him to come at eight.

They eat at a family restaurant, then Nonoguchi1 travels to Hidaka3's darkened house. Finding no lights and no answer at the intercom, he phones Rie4 at the Crown Hotel. She rushes over, unlocks the office door, and they discover Hidaka3's body sprawled on the floor. While Rie4 collapses in shock, Nonoguchi1 discreetly erases the fax transmission log from the computer.

When the police arrive, one detective introduces himself: Kyoichiro Kaga,2 Nonoguchi1's former colleague from his teaching days. Nonoguchi1 begins writing a detailed account of events, a narrative he will feed to Kaga2 to steer the entire investigation.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Nonoguchi's performance during the body's discovery is a masterclass in manipulation. He orchestrates the scene so that Rie becomes the primary discoverer, his own presence merely supportive. His call to the hotel, the wait at the café, the return exactly as she arrives: every beat is choreographed to appear spontaneous. The arrival of Kaga, his former colleague, is the first variable Nonoguchi didn't control, and his quick decision to write the 'account' reveals his adaptive intelligence. He recognizes that a detective who knows him personally can be manipulated differently than a stranger: through the illusion of candor, the faux-vulnerability of sharing private thoughts. The weapon he chooses now is not the paperweight but the pen.

The Missing Cigarette Butts

A single cigarette exposes the murder's true timeline

Kaga2 reads Nonoguchi1's account and notices discrepancies. Hidaka3 was a heavy smoker, yet only one cigarette butt was in the ashtray: the one he smoked during Nonoguchi1's visit. If Hidaka3 had worked for hours after Nonoguchi1 left, there should have been several more.

Kaga2 also discovers that pressing redial on Hidaka3's phone calls Vancouver, where Hidaka3 called that morning, not Nonoguchi1's apartment as it should if they had spoken at six. Furthermore, why turn off every light in the house but leave the computer monitor glowing? The monitor's light would have been visible through the curtains, undermining the illusion that no one was home.

Kaga2 interviews Oshima9 at the family restaurant, confirming the timing. He grows increasingly convinced that Nonoguchi1 staged the phone call using Hidaka3's computer fax software, and that the murder occurred much earlier than Nonoguchi1 claims.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Kaga's detection method relies on the tiny, human details that a less observant investigator might dismiss. The single cigarette represents Hidaka's interrupted life: the man who couldn't write a page without smoking somehow wrote twenty-seven without lighting up. The un-redialed phone number tells a story of absence. The glowing monitor in a darkened house embodies the contradiction at the heart of the crime: a killer meticulous enough to turn off every light but careless enough to leave a beacon burning. These details are not forensic triumphs but psychological ones. Kaga is less interested in proving a case than in understanding a person, which is why he recognizes that Nonoguchi's eagerness to share his account is itself suspicious.

The Ghostwriter's Archive Found

Manuscripts suggest Nonoguchi was Hidaka's ghostwriter

Kaga2 obtains a search warrant and confronts Nonoguchi1 at his apartment. He lays out his theory: Nonoguchi1 killed Hidaka3 shortly after five o'clock, then used the computer's scheduled fax to create the illusion of a six-thirteen phone call.

The tip-off was Nonoguchi1's own question about the time of death on the first night, a question someone who had spoken to the victim at six should not need to ask. Nonoguchi1 surrenders without resistance. During the search, detectives find eight spiral-bound notebooks and multiple floppy disks containing manuscripts that closely correspond to Hidaka3's published novels, with slight variations suggesting they are original drafts.

They also find story outlines for the remainder of Hidaka3's current serial, The Gates of Ice. The implication seems clear: Nonoguchi1 was Hidaka3's ghostwriter, and some rupture in that arrangement led to murder.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The discovery of the manuscripts marks the point where Kaga's investigation seems to confirm the ghostwriter theory, but the reader familiar with the genre should feel unease. Everything fits too neatly: the notebooks in matching spiral bindings, the floppy disks with every installment of the serial, the outlines for future chapters. A real ghostwriter might keep some records, but this comprehensive archive feels curated. Nonoguchi's silence about his motive is strategic: by refusing to explain himself, he forces the police to construct their own narrative from the evidence he planted. The arrest is what he wanted. He is not a man caught; he is a playwright watching his script performed.

The Hospital-Bed Confession

Nonoguchi claims an affair, blackmail, and stolen novels

Nonoguchi,1 now hospitalized after collapsing during interrogation (his cancer has returned), requests permission to write his own confession. In it, he claims that years ago he fell in love with Hidaka3's first wife, Hatsumi.5 Together they plotted to kill Hidaka,3 but on the night of the attempt, Hidaka3 was waiting.

He caught Nonoguchi,1 confiscated the knife, and revealed he had videotaped the break-in. Hidaka3 then blackmailed Nonoguchi1 into becoming his ghostwriter, threatening to expose both the attempted murder and the affair.

For years, Nonoguchi1 wrote novels published under Hidaka3's name, including the award-winning An Unburning Flame. Hatsumi,5 consumed by guilt, eventually committed suicide by stepping in front of a truck. When Hidaka3 prepared to move to Canada with his new wife, Nonoguchi1 snapped and killed him in a moment of rage.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Nonoguchi's confession is a work of fiction nested within a mystery novel, blurring the line between literary creation and criminal deception. The story borrows from melodrama: forbidden love, a thwarted murder, years of silent suffering. Hatsumi becomes the tragic heroine, Hidaka the cold villain, Nonoguchi the broken romantic. What makes this confession so effective is its emotional coherence. Even if details strain credulity, the psychological portrait of a man destroyed by blackmail and lost love resonates. Readers, like detectives, are seduced by narrative. The confession works because it satisfies our need for stories to make sense, for violence to have proportionate causes. That it is entirely false is the book's most disturbing revelation.

Kaga's Four Questions

A pen callus reveals the manuscripts were recently fabricated

Despite the confession's apparent completeness, Kaga2 feels unsettled. Four questions nag at him: Why would Hidaka3 risk blackmailing a man who could simply confess and implicate him? Why didn't Nonoguchi1 resist after Hatsumi5's death removed his incentive to protect her?

Would the videotape and knife really have secured a conviction? And could their relationship have genuinely evolved into collaboration after such betrayals? Then Kaga2 notices something physical: a thick pen callus on Nonoguchi1's middle finger. Nonoguchi1 uses a word processor, not pen and paper.

The callus suggests he recently wrote a massive quantity by hand, likely those 'old' notebooks. The manuscripts are not decades-old originals but recent fabrications. Kaga2 realizes the entire ghostwriter narrative may be an elaborate deception, and he reopens his investigation into the two men's shared past.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The pen callus is the detail that shifts the entire investigation. In mystery fiction, the physical clue often solves the crime. Here, it solves the meta-crime: the fabrication of motive. The callus functions as a temporal fingerprint, proving the notebooks are recent productions rather than decades-old juvenilia. Kaga's four questions reveal his growing sophistication as a reader of human behavior. He no longer asks 'does this evidence prove guilt?' but 'does this story make psychological sense?' The ghostwriter narrative required Hidaka to behave with reckless stupidity (blackmailing a potential confessor) and Nonoguchi with saintly forbearance (protecting his beloved's reputation even after her death). Real hatred is rarely so noble.

What the Bullies Remember

Former classmates recall Hidaka, not Nonoguchi, was bullied

Kaga2 tracks down middle school classmates. A barber named Hayashida remembers Nonoguchi,1 nicknamed 'Gooch,' as a teacher's pet who got bullied. But a former bully named Takahashi offers a different account: it was Hidaka3 who was the primary target of Fujio7's sadism.

Hidaka3 was the one wrapped in cellophane and abandoned in the gym; it was Hidaka3 who had acid poured on him from a window. Nonoguchi,1 by contrast, had joined Fujio7's gang and served as his errand boy and informant, feeding Fujio7 information about Hidaka3's movements and private comments.

Takahashi also reveals that during the assault on the Catholic school girl, Fujio7 had an accomplice present, though Takahashi denies knowing who it was. Kaga2 begins to see a very different picture: Hidaka3 was the victim, and Nonoguchi1 was one of the perpetrators.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Takahashi's testimony inverts the moral order of Nonoguchi's confession. The bullied becomes the bully's accomplice. This inversion is more psychologically credible than the victim narrative: shame makes people hide their worst acts, not their suffering. Nonoguchi's collaboration with Fujio explains the otherwise inexplicable dynamic between the two men. Hidaka had every reason to despise Nonoguchi for feeding information to his tormentors. Instead, as an adult, Hidaka helped him. That generosity, coming from someone who had every right to withhold it, would be unbearable to a man like Nonoguchi. Each act of kindness was an accusation, each introduction to an editor a reminder of debts that could never be repaid.

A Mother's Contempt Lingers

Nonoguchi's mother taught him to despise his own neighborhood

Kaga2 interviews more people from Nonoguchi1's past. A neighbor, Mrs. Hirosawa, recalls Nonoguchi1's mother openly disparaging the neighborhood as beneath their family, even calling the local school a place for her son to 'slum it.' Young Nonoguchi1 became a truant, refusing to attend school.

It was Hidaka3 who came every morning to walk him to class, a kindness Nonoguchi1's mother resented rather than appreciated. A childhood playmate, Matsushima, confirms Nonoguchi1 never saw Hidaka3 as an equal: Hidaka3 was always the leader, Nonoguchi1 the reluctant follower who spoke ill of him behind his back.

A high school friend, Mitani, remembers Nonoguchi1 constantly complaining about his low-class town and the hell of being forced to live there. The seed of hatred was planted early, watered by class anxiety and maternal contempt.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The portrait that emerges from the childhood interviews is of a hatred with no legitimate grievance. Nonoguchi's mother taught him to despise his surroundings, and by extension everyone in them. Hidaka's daily kindness, walking the truant boy to school, was reinterpreted through this lens as condescension, an attempt to drag him down. This is the psychology of resentment in its purest form: the inability to receive generosity without converting it into insult. Nonoguchi's high school friend Mitani captures the pathology perfectly: Nonoguchi spoke of his town as hell and his neighbor's kindness as a conspiracy. The seed of malice was planted in the fertile soil of maternal snobbery, watered by social isolation, and flowering decades later into murder.

One Boy at the Workshop

The aging fireworks maker remembers only one boy visiting

Nonoguchi1's confession claimed that his novel A Circle of Fire, which Hidaka3 allegedly stole and published as An Unburning Flame, was inspired by childhood visits to a neighborhood fireworks maker. Kaga2 locates Heikichi Tsujimura,8 now ninety-one and wheelchair-bound but mentally sharp.

Shown a middle school yearbook, Tsujimura8 identifies only one boy who visited his workshop: Kunihiko Hidaka.3 He has never seen Nonoguchi.1 This testimony shatters a cornerstone of Nonoguchi1's narrative. If Nonoguchi1 never visited the fireworks maker, his claim to have originated that story collapses.

The implication is devastating: it was Hidaka3 who visited Tsujimura,8 Hidaka3 who transformed those memories into a novel, and Nonoguchi1 who later fabricated the story to claim authorship. The plagiarism arrow points in the opposite direction: Nonoguchi1 stole from Hidaka3's life to construct his false past.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Tsujimura's testimony is devastating precisely because it is so small. The entire literary career of Kunihiko Hidaka does not hinge on whether one boy or two visited a fireworks workshop. But for Nonoguchi's narrative, the detail is fatal. His claim to have originated An Unburning Flame required him to have experienced what Hidaka experienced. The old man's memory strips away that pretense. More than contradicting a single fact, this testimony demonstrates method: Nonoguchi did not invent his false past from whole cloth but appropriated Hidaka's actual memories, repurposing real biographical details as his own fictional history. This is the essence of his crime: not just killing the man, but colonizing his life.

The Case Kaga Failed

Kaga's failure as a teacher illuminates the nature of malice

Kaga2 reflects on the event that ended his teaching career. As a young homeroom teacher, he discovered a bullying ring in his class targeting a boy named Maeno. He tried to help by teaching Maeno kendo for confidence and having him deliver homework to the hospitalized ringleader to reverse the power dynamic.

The bullying appeared to stop. But on graduation day, the gang caught Maeno alone, beat him savagely, and urinated on him. Maeno then broke into Kaga2's locker, took a throwing knife, found the ringleader at an arcade, and stabbed him repeatedly.

When police asked the bullies why they tormented Maeno, their only answer was that they just didn't like him. Kaga2 has carried this failure ever since, and in Nonoguchi1's case, he recognizes the same irrational, inexhaustible malice that no logic can explain and no kindness can cure.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Kaga's personal story serves multiple functions. Structurally, it explains his sensitivity to bullying dynamics and his refusal to accept easy narratives about victimhood. Thematically, it provides the book's moral vocabulary: the word 'malice' is explicitly linked to the bullies' inability to articulate why they tormented Maeno. 'Just because' is not an evasion but a confession: hatred without cause is the purest hatred. The parallel between Maeno's case and Nonoguchi's is instructive. Maeno, the victim, turned to violence after years of abuse. Nonoguchi, the accomplice to bullying, turned to violence against the person who showed him kindness. The asymmetry is the point. Some people are destroyed by cruelty; others are destroyed by generosity.

Shadow of One Tree Only

Garden landscaping and cat poison expose the staged evidence

Kaga2 re-examines the videotape that supposedly captured Nonoguchi1's break-in seven years ago. He studies the shadow of the cherry tree cast across the lawn by a streetlamp and realizes something critical: there is only one tree shadow.

Rie4 confirms that when she moved in, there had originally been two cherry trees standing side by side in the garden; one was removed before her marriage. If the video had truly been shot seven years earlier, it would show two shadows. The tape was filmed recently, staged by Nonoguchi1 on a night when Hidaka3 was out drinking.

Kaga2 also traces the cat poisoning: tests on the exhumed cat and pesticide residue in Nonoguchi1's apartment planters match. Nonoguchi1 killed the cat himself, then wrote the scene into his false account to establish Hidaka3's cruelty in Kaga2's mind, a textbook technique of character assassination disguised as helpful testimony.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The cherry tree shadow is the most elegant clue in the book because it operates on multiple levels. Literally, it dates the videotape. Symbolically, the missing tree represents Hidaka's absent voice: he cannot testify to the tape's falseness because Nonoguchi silenced him. The cat revelation is equally layered. Nonoguchi's decision to kill an innocent animal solely to plant a false character trait in a detective's mind demonstrates something essential about his pathology: other living beings are merely props in his narrative. The cat's owner, the woman in the garden, was also a prop, her grief weaponized to make Hidaka seem monstrous. Nonoguchi treats the world as raw material for his stories.

The Girl in the Polaroid

A photograph shows Nonoguchi's role in a schoolgirl's assault

Among Hidaka3's research materials, Kaga2 finds a CD-ROM containing scanned photographs. One is the Polaroid taken during Masaya Fujio7's assault on the middle school girl. It shows two boys: Fujio7 operating the camera, and a second boy pinning the victim down. That second boy is Osamu Nonoguchi.1

Hidaka3 had obtained the photo years ago while researching Forbidden Hunting Grounds but never showed it to anyone. He protected Nonoguchi1's secret even as Miyako Fujio6 threatened legal action. Nonoguchi1's true fear was not that Hidaka3 would expose him, for Hidaka3 never had, but that court proceedings might force the photo into evidence.

With his terminal cancer removing all long-term consequences, Nonoguchi1 decided to kill Hidaka3 and simultaneously destroy his reputation, stealing credit for his novels and painting him as a blackmailing plagiarist.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The Polaroid is the book's darkest object. It freezes a moment of profound violation: a girl being assaulted, Nonoguchi holding her down, Fujio documenting the crime. The photo's existence represents everything Nonoguchi tried to bury: his cowardice, his complicity, his willingness to harm others to protect himself. Hidaka's decision to keep the photo secret, to never use it against the man who helped torment him, is an act of extraordinary restraint. But for Nonoguchi, Hidaka's mercy was indistinguishable from threat. The photo existed; therefore it could be revealed. The only way to achieve permanent safety was to destroy the man who held the secret and simultaneously destroy his credibility so thoroughly that no one would believe him if he ever spoke.

The Word Is Malice

Kaga lays bare the truth: a hatred without cause

Kaga2 visits Nonoguchi1 in the hospital, where the murderer awaits cancer surgery. For over an hour, Kaga2 lays out the reconstructed truth: the fabricated manuscripts, the faked videotape, the staged childhood memories, the poisoned cat, the stolen apron and photograph, the true dynamics of middle school bullying, and the Polaroid showing Nonoguchi1 pinning down the girl during Fujio7's assault.

Kaga2 explains that Nonoguchi1's scheme was never about escaping punishment but about perverting justice itself: destroying Hidaka3's legacy, stealing his literary achievements, and making himself the wronged victim. Why?

Kaga2 answers his own question: there is no sufficient reason, only the same word the bullies used. Malice. Pure, irreducible hatred. Nonoguchi1 remains silent throughout, offering neither confirmation nor denial. As Kaga2 leaves, he notes that Nonoguchi1 will survive surgery and face trial, the ultimate failure of a plan designed to let him die a sympathetic figure.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The final confrontation is notable for what does not happen: Nonoguchi does not confess, does not break down, offers no explanation. His silence is the final evidence of Kaga's thesis. A man who spent months fabricating an elaborate false confession cannot speak the simple truth because the truth is too ugly: he hated Hidaka for being kind to him. The epilogue's irony is sharp: Nonoguchi agreed to surgery, meaning he will live to stand trial. His plan required him to die before the truth emerged, a sympathetic cancer victim driven to desperate murder. Instead, he will survive to be judged not for a crime of passion but for a premeditated campaign of posthumous destruction. His final failure is biological.

Analysis

The title 'Malice' names the book's central obsession: the irrational, self-annihilating hatred that drives Osamu Nonoguchi1 to destroy not just his childhood friend's life, but his entire posthumous legacy. The novel functions as a psychological excavation, peeling back layers of fabricated narrative to expose a hatred so old and so baseless that it can only be described as malice, the same word the bullies used when asked why they tormented their victims. 'Just because' is not an evasion but a confession: hatred without cause is the purest hatred.

The book's structural brilliance lies in its use of unreliable narration. Nonoguchi1's first account seems helpful and transparent; his 'confession' appears to reveal the darkest truth. Only when Kaga2 systematically dismantles each layer does the reader realize that both documents were performances, designed not to evade justice but to pervert it. Nonoguchi1 wanted to be caught, but caught for a sympathetic crime: the victim of plagiarism driven to murderous rage. He sought to commit a second, reputational murder from beyond the grave.

Higashino uses the mystery form to examine how childhood wounds determine adult pathologies. The bullying that Hidaka3 endured and Nonoguchi1 facilitated created an unpayable debt. Every act of kindness Hidaka3 showed, walking him to school, helping his career, only deepened Nonoguchi1's shame and resentment. The book suggests that for some personalities, receiving generosity is more painful than receiving cruelty, because it confirms their own inferiority. Nonoguchi1's terminal cancer merely removed the final inhibitions on a hatred that had been ripening for decades.

The novel also comments on the nature of justice and truth. Kaga,2 haunted by his own failure as a teacher, pursues the case beyond what his superiors require because he understands that a false motive is itself an injustice. His parallel story about Maeno illustrates how bullying creates cycles of violence, but also how intervention can either heal or worsen wounds. Ultimately, Malice is a study in how the stories we tell about ourselves can become weapons, and how some hatreds have no origin in anything the victim did, only in the bottomless well of the hater's own self-loathing.

Summary in 60 Seconds
When novelist Kunihiko Hidaka is strangled in his Tokyo home, childhood friend Osamu Nonoguchi provides police a meticulous account of finding the body. Detective Kyoichiro Kaga, once a teaching colleague, notices a lone cigarette in a chain smoker's ashtray and a glowing monitor in a darkened house. Nonoguchi confesses, then claims he was Hidaka's ghostwriter, blackmailed over an affair. Kaga proves the manuscripts are forgeries. Old classmates reveal Nonoguchi was the bully's accomplice, not its victim; Hidaka was the one tormented. A Polaroid among Hidaka's files shows Nonoguchi restraining a girl during an assault, a photo Hidaka hid to protect him. Facing terminal cancer, Nonoguchi killed Hidaka to destroy his legacy while casting himself as victim. In the hospital, Kaga reveals the truth: no ghostwriting, no affair, no blackmail. Only malice, hatred without cause. Nonoguchi stays silent. He survives surgery and faces trial, his plan to die a sympathetic figure destroyed.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.06 out of 5
Average of 36k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Malice is widely praised for its unconventional mystery structure, revealing the killer early and focusing instead on the elusive "why" behind the murder. Readers appreciate the clever layered twists, the cat-and-mouse dynamic between Detective Kaga and the suspect, and the exploration of themes like jealousy, bullying, and authorship. Some critics find the pacing slow or characters underdeveloped, and a few feel the motive doesn't fully satisfy. Overall, most readers find it an intelligent, engaging puzzle that subverts genre expectations.

Your rating:
4.52
110 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Osamu Nonoguchi

Children's writer and former teacher

A children's book author who left teaching to pursue writing full-time. He is the childhood friend of the murder victim3 and one of the discoverers of the body. On the surface, he presents himself as cooperative and helpful, even writing detailed accounts for the police. Beneath his mild-mannered exterior lies a complex psychology shaped by his mother's class snobbery, childhood social isolation, and lifelong feelings of inadequacy next to his more successful friend. He is intelligent, calculating, and harbors creative ambitions that have never been fully realized. His relationship with Hidaka3 is marked by deep ambivalence: surface gratitude masking profound resentment that has festered since childhood. He suffers from recurrent cancer and faces his own mortality with a desperate need to settle old scores before time runs out.

Kyoichiro Kaga

Detective and former teacher

A methodical homicide detective who previously worked as a middle school teacher at the same school as Nonoguchi1. He left teaching after a tragic failure: one of his bullied students stabbed his tormentor after graduation, an event that haunts him and shaped his understanding of bullying's deep psychological wounds. He approaches investigations with patience and precision, willing to question his own assumptions and revisit settled conclusions. Unlike many detectives, he reads deeply and thinks about character motivation. His personal connection to Nonoguchi1 creates both advantages (insight into his character) and dangers (potential for bias). He is driven by a need to understand not just who committed a crime, but why, believing that motive is the key to genuine justice rather than mere conviction.

Kunihiko Hidaka

Murdered bestselling novelist

A commercially successful Japanese author who won a major literary prize and was preparing to move to Vancouver with his new wife4 when he was found murdered in his home office. He grew up in the same neighborhood as Nonoguchi1 and was known from childhood as an exceptionally kind and principled person who stood up for the weak. He walked a truant classmate to school every morning, protected victims of bullying, and maintained a strong sense of justice even when it made him a target. As an adult, he achieved significant literary success, winning major awards. His novel based on their middle school years brought him into conflict with the family of a former bully. His relationship with Nonoguchi1 appeared genuinely friendly on the surface; he helped Nonoguchi1 enter the publishing world.

Rie Hidaka

Hidaka's new wife, former editor

Married to Hidaka3 for only one month before his death. She was previously his editor at a publishing house, where their relationship began through discussions about his novels. Practical, emotionally resilient, and fiercely defensive of her late husband's reputation when the media and public turn against him following the ghostwriter allegations. She has a spine of steel beneath her small, youthful appearance, and refuses to accept the narratives constructed to defame the man she loved.

Hatsumi Hidaka

Hidaka's deceased first wife

Hidaka3's wife of twelve years who died in a traffic accident five years before the main events. Her memory becomes central to Nonoguchi1's narrative, in which he claims they had a secret affair and together conspired to kill Hidaka3. She is described by those who knew her as shy, gentle, and devoted to her husband. Her death, which the police ruled an accident, is later recast by Nonoguchi1 as a suicide driven by guilt, though this too is revealed to be a fabrication designed to serve his false confession.

Miyako Fujio

Sister of a depicted bully

The sister of Masaya Fujio7, the real-life model for the antagonist in Hidaka3's novel Forbidden Hunting Grounds. She campaigns to have the book recalled and rewritten, believing it defames her brother's memory and violates her family's privacy. Her persistent legal threats inadvertently create the pressure that triggers Nonoguchi1's fear that a certain photograph from their middle school days might come to light during court proceedings.

Masaya Fujio

The middle school bully

The ringleader of severe bullying during Nonoguchi1 and Hidaka3's middle school years. Large, physically imposing, and charismatic in his cruelty, he orchestrated brutal attacks on weaker students. He assaulted a girl from a Catholic school with an accomplice and took a Polaroid photograph of the crime. He later became a woodblock artist but was stabbed to death by a prostitute, an ending faithfully depicted in Hidaka3's novel.

Heikichi Tsujimura

Elderly fireworks maker

A retired fireworks maker, now over ninety and wheelchair-bound but mentally sharp. As a child, Hidaka3 visited his workshop near the local shrine and was fascinated by the craft. This childhood experience later inspired the novel An Unburning Flame. When questioned by Kaga2, he identifies only one boy from the yearbook as having visited: Hidaka3, not Nonoguchi1, fatally undermining Nonoguchi1's claim to have originated the story.

Yukio Oshima

Nonoguchi's devoted editor

A young editor at the publishing house that produces Nonoguchi1's children's books. He admires Nonoguchi1 and is genuinely excited to learn of his connection to the famous Kunihiko Hidaka3. He unwittingly becomes a crucial part of Nonoguchi1's alibi when Nonoguchi1 schedules their manuscript meeting to coincide with the fake phone call from the dead man's computer.

Plot Devices

The Computer Fax Trick

Creates Nonoguchi's false alibi

Nonoguchi1 sets Hidaka3's computer to auto-fax a manuscript to his own apartment at precisely 6:13 p.m., then answers his cordless phone when it rings and pretends to converse with Hidaka3 while his editor Oshima9 sits nearby. The trick is designed to establish that Hidaka3 was alive after six o'clock, narrowing the window of suspicion. Nonoguchi1 deliberately leaves small flaws in the scheme (the glowing monitor, the wrong redial number) so that a competent detective will eventually see through it, triggering his arrest and the discovery of the planted manuscripts, all part of his larger plan to be caught for a sympathetic crime rather than his true, shameful motive.

The Fabricated Manuscripts

Frames Hidaka as a plagiarist

Eight spiral-bound notebooks and multiple floppy disks filled with stories that closely mirror Hidaka3's published novels, but with slight variations designed to make them appear as original drafts from which Hidaka3 allegedly copied. Nonoguchi1 writes these by hand over several months, producing the thick pen callus that ultimately betrays him. The manuscripts are planted in his apartment to be discovered during the police search, constructing the false narrative that Nonoguchi1 was Hidaka3's long-suffering ghostwriter, forced to produce bestselling novels without credit or fair compensation.

The Staged Videotape

Fakes evidence of Nonoguchi's break-in

A videotape ostensibly recorded seven years earlier by Hidaka3's hidden garden camera, showing Nonoguchi1 in black clothing sneaking through the office window. In reality, Nonoguchi1 filmed himself climbing through the window on a night when Hidaka3 was out drinking, using the real house key hidden behind a flowerpot. The tape was planted among Hidaka3's belongings being sent to Canada, where it would be 'discovered' after the murder. Kaga2 exposes the fraud by examining the cherry tree shadow: the tape shows only one tree, but seven years ago, there were two cherry trees standing side by side in the garden.

The Polaroid Assault Photo

Reveals Nonoguchi's true secret

A Polaroid photograph taken by Masaya Fujio7 during the middle school assault of a Catholic school girl. The image shows Fujio7 behind the camera and a second boy holding the victim down. That second boy is Osamu Nonoguchi1. Hidaka3 obtained the photo years ago while researching his novel but never showed it to anyone, protecting the secret of the man who had once fed information about him to bullies. Kaga2 finds a scanned copy on a CD-ROM among Hidaka3's research materials. The photo explains Nonoguchi1's true motive: he killed Hidaka3 not to escape blackmail but to prevent the photo from surfacing during Miyako Fujio6's threatened lawsuit, and to destroy Hidaka3's credibility so thoroughly that no revelation could harm him.

The Poisoned Cat

Establishes false character evidence

Nonoguchi1 kills his neighbor's pet cat by leaving poisoned meatballs in Hidaka3's garden, then writes a scene in his initial account in which Hidaka3 casually confesses to the cruel act. The purpose is purely literary: to establish Hidaka3 as cold and ruthless in Detective Kaga2's mind before any other evidence emerges, a technique Nonoguchi1 understands from his own writing experience as 'establishing character.' When Kaga2 later discovers the truth of the cat killing, it becomes the key that unlocks the entire scheme: if Nonoguchi1 was willing to kill an innocent animal merely to plant a false impression, his entire narrative must be treated as a work of fiction designed to defame the victim.

About the Author

Keigo Higashino is one of Japan's most popular and bestselling fiction authors, comparable in fame to James Patterson or Tom Clancy in the United States. Born in Osaka, he began writing while working as an engineer, winning the prestigious Edogawa Rampo Prize in 1985 at just 27. He later won the Mystery Writers of Japan award and the coveted Naoki Prize for The Devotion of Suspect X, which sold over 800,000 copies. His novels have been adapted into numerous films and TV series, rivaling the adaptation count of Michael Crichton.

Download PDF

To save this Malice summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.35 MB     Pages: 22

Download EPUB

To read this Malice summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.41 MB     Pages: 32
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
600,000+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...