Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Mistakes Were Made

Mistakes Were Made

A senior's hookup with her best friend's mother begins a romance their family ties could ruin.
by Meryl Wilsner 2022 352 pages
3.91
52k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Family Weekend, One Night

A bar hookup collides with a college visit

At Keckley’s Family Weekend, senior Cassie Klein escapes the campus festivities for a bar and meets Erin Bennett, a striking older woman visiting Virginia. Their flirtation becomes a hurried, enthusiastic hookup in Erin’s rental car. Cassie expects a clean goodbye, but learns Erin is in town to see her daughter, who attends Keckley too.

Erin drives Cassie back to campus, and neither asks where the other lives. The next morning, Cassie is still unaware of Erin’s family connection. She has treated the encounter as consequence-free precisely because Erin was a stranger; that assumption is about to collapse when Cassie’s best friend, Parker, calls and asks her to join breakfast with her mother.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The opening makes anonymity feel like permission. Cassie’s bluntness is not merely sexual confidence; it is a way of limiting risk by refusing to imagine a future with the person she desires. Erin, recently divorced and visiting her daughter, also accepts the temporary logic of the encounter. Their mistake is not that either woman lacks agency, but that they believe circumstance has made their choices self-contained. The car becomes a brief sealed world, yet the college campus outside it already connects their lives. The scene plants the story’s central pressure: desire can be spontaneous, but its consequences enter relationships that neither person can keep separate.

Breakfast With the Daughter

Parker introduces Cassie to the woman from the car

Parker brings Cassie to breakfast with her mother, and Cassie recognizes Erin at once. Both conceal their panic while Parker remains unaware of their night together. Cassie teases Erin beneath the table, but Erin asks her to stop because she is trying to protect a fragile relationship with Parker.

The conversation reveals Cassie’s aerospace ambitions and that she once dated Seth, the boyfriend Parker briefly pursued before learning he already had a girlfriend. Later, Erin sees a childhood photograph showing Cassie with Acacia, Parker’s roommate and Cassie’s closest friend since childhood.

Erin realizes Cassie is not a random classmate but someone embedded in Parker’s new life. She still attends Parker’s concert that evening, hoping the three of them can behave like ordinary family and friends.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The breakfast turns private pleasure into a question of loyalty. Erin’s restraint is not simply prudishness: she fears that any disruption could deepen Parker’s sense that the divorce has already cost her a stable family. Cassie, by contrast, uses teasing to keep the situation playful and therefore manageable. The photograph of Cassie and Acacia gives the coincidence history, placing Cassie inside a chosen family long before she entered Parker’s circle. The Seth connection complicates any easy moral accounting. Each woman has a different reason to protect Parker, but neither has yet learned how to do so without hiding part of herself.

The Concert Bathroom

Erin follows Cassie downstairs despite knowing the stakes

At Parker’s a cappella concert, Erin sits beside Cassie and lets flirtation become touch. When Cassie slips away, Erin follows her to a single-person restroom. She tells herself they should stop, then kisses Cassie and lets the encounter grow intimate before insisting they return to the audience. Together they cheer for Parker, who is delighted by their support.

Afterward, Parker reunites with her father, Adam, whose stiff greeting makes Erin tense. Cassie, already raw about her own absent parents, answers Adam’s questions with a sharp joke about her mother’s alcoholism. Acacia steers Cassie away. Later, Cassie makes out with Acacia’s brother, Emerson, hoping to distract herself from Erin, but the brief escape does not quiet her thoughts.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Erin’s decision to follow Cassie is a decisive repetition: the first hookup could be dismissed as an uninformed accident, but this encounter happens after she knows the relationship to Parker. Her self-control exists, yet she uses it only after taking what she wants. The concert setting sharpens the contradiction because both women are visibly supporting Parker while privately crossing a boundary that could hurt her. Cassie’s joke about her mother reveals how humor protects a history she rarely shares. Emerson offers distraction, not intimacy. The scene shows that physical chemistry is becoming emotionally consequential even before either woman is willing to name it.

The Number in Parker’s Phone

Drunk Cassie texts Erin, then hides the evidence

Weeks later, Cassie finally tells Acacia that she slept with Parker’s mother, then made out with her again at the concert. Acacia laughs at first, but recognizes Cassie is no longer treating Erin as a disposable encounter. At a party, Cassie takes Parker’s phone to prevent her from drunk-texting Sam, then secretly copies Erin’s number and disguises it in her contacts.

After drinking, she sends Erin a sexual message. Erin calls back angrily, assuming the sender is a stranger, and Cassie listens without identifying herself. Parker and Acacia arrive before Cassie can respond. Back at the dorm, Cassie deletes the call and messages before Acacia can inspect her phone. The secret survives, but now Cassie has deliberately reopened contact.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The phone turns secrecy into an action rather than a passive omission. Cassie first takes responsibility for Parker’s phone, then exploits that trust to reach Erin, reproducing the very boundary confusion she fears being judged for. Her silence during Erin’s call is revealing: Cassie wants to be known and desired, but cannot risk the humiliation of being recognized as the sender. Acacia’s laughter gives way to care, making her a witness to Cassie’s changing attachment. The deletion protects Cassie from immediate exposure, not from consequence. She has moved from a one-night mistake into a pattern of choices that requires active concealment.

A Ticket to New Hampshire

Parker’s invitation puts both women under one roof

As Thanksgiving ends, Parker tells Cassie that she and her parents have bought her a ticket to spend winter break in New Hampshire. Cassie resists the expense and the prospect of living with Erin, but the ticket is nonrefundable.

When Cassie calls to challenge the arrangement, Erin hides her own anticipation behind a cutting dismissal, insisting she has barely thought about Cassie. The remark wounds Cassie, and Erin later apologizes by text. Three weeks afterward, Cassie arrives with Parker.

Erin greets her warmly, and dinner passes with familiar jokes, though Parker’s teasing about Cassie’s mystery caller revives the secret. Cassie helps clear the table, and the easy domestic rhythm between her and Erin proves more dangerous than their earlier, hurried encounters.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ticket transforms attraction from an elective meeting into sustained proximity. Erin’s harsh phone performance is an attempt to manage desire by making herself undesirable, but it repeats a learned form of conflict avoidance: she chooses cruelty over honest limits. Her apology matters because it acknowledges harm without yet resolving the underlying contradiction. Cassie’s resistance to being treated as a charity case reflects a deeper fear of dependence, even as she accepts Parker’s family’s generosity. In the house, ordinary care becomes charged. Dinner, cleanup, and shared jokes create a sense of belonging that neither woman intended to invite.

Christmas Without Perfection

Cassie calms Erin before Adam insults her ambition

Preparing for Erin’s large Christmas Eve gathering, Cassie helps cook and clean while Parker complains that her mother turns hosting into an exhausting performance. Cassie persuades Erin to stop treating every unfinished task as a disaster, and the two share a relaxed lunch.

At the party, Adam offers Cassie an unsolicited graduate-school recommendation, then implies her gender could help her admission. Erin confronts him and defends Cassie’s ability on its own merits. Erin later learns her late mother disliked the party’s labor, despite teaching Erin to reproduce its polished standards.

That night, Erin gives Cassie Christmas pajamas alongside Parker, then kisses her after apologizing for Adam. Parker returns from the bathroom before they can go further, and Erin leaves Cassie’s room without explaining the kiss.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Cassie sees that Erin’s perfectionism is inherited labor disguised as personal preference. By helping her pause, Cassie does more than offer reassurance; she gives Erin permission to question the family standards she has mistaken for love. Adam’s condescension exposes the same pattern in a different register, treating Cassie as a category rather than a capable person. Erin’s defense is meaningful because she acts publicly, without asking Cassie to minimize the insult. The Christmas kiss then overturns Erin’s attempt at emotional distance. A domestic gift shared with Parker suggests inclusion, while the kiss creates a second, secret relationship inside that family scene.

The Shower Apology

Erin’s cruelty gives way to intimacy and rules

After the Christmas kiss, Cassie confronts Erin in her home office. Erin calls the kiss a mistake, then attacks Cassie’s relationship with her absent mother to force her away. Cassie leaves furious. When Erin later finds her showering, she enters the bathroom and gives a direct apology, admitting she used the subject of Cassie’s mother to hurt her.

Cassie opens the shower door, and their apology turns into sex. Afterward, they agree not to have sex while Parker is home and to end the arrangement when Cassie’s visit ends. The rules promise containment, but they are already built around attraction rather than separation. The next morning, they kiss over coffee before Parker wakes, beginning a clandestine affair inside the house.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This encounter joins accountability to desire without pretending one cancels the other. Erin names the deliberate cruelty she used to protect herself, while Cassie accepts an apology without mistaking it for a guarantee of safety. Their rules are an effort to make intimacy ethically manageable, but the conditions expose their weakness: they regulate visibility and duration, not attachment. The shower is also a setting of mutual vulnerability, where Erin must look directly at Cassie rather than rely on polished hospitality or a distant phone persona. Their morning kiss shows how quickly a negotiated exception can become a daily expectation.

Midnight Lets the Secret Slip

Acacia’s accidental disclosure makes Erin pull away

Cassie and Erin keep finding private moments, including kisses in the kitchen and a night together in Erin’s bed. On New Year’s Eve, Cassie slips upstairs to FaceTime Acacia. Acacia, unaware Erin is nearby, refers to Cassie’s desire to kiss Parker’s mother; Erin appears on screen and realizes Acacia knows about the affair.

She sends Cassie back to the party, then tells herself the arrangement can continue as long as Parker remains unaware. The next morning, Erin asks Cassie to kiss her rather than discuss the disclosure.

Their closeness resumes, and Erin works at the hospital while Parker complains that her mother misses a family tradition. Cassie gently defends Erin. Soon afterward, Cassie catches a cold, and Erin cares for her through the fever before driving her to the airport.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Acacia’s mistake makes the hidden relationship socially real: someone beyond the two participants can now interpret their behavior and connect it to Parker. Erin responds by retreating into compartmentalization, treating silence as protection rather than recognizing that it leaves Cassie alone with the risk. Their renewed morning kiss is affectionate, but it does not repair the asymmetry. Cassie’s defense of Erin to Parker shows how intimacy has already shaped her loyalties. The illness shifts their dynamic from furtive pleasure to caretaking, a form of closeness that is harder to dismiss as purely sexual. Erin’s practical devotion offers warmth, but also deepens the impending separation.

A Goodbye at Security

An airport kiss carries their affair into distance

Before Cassie leaves New Hampshire, Erin keeps watch over her recovery and gives her a long good-morning kiss despite the risk of catching the illness. At the airport, Cassie jokes to cover the awkwardness of saying goodbye, but they kiss again before she passes through security.

Erin later texts that Cassie has made her sick, and Cassie answers with concern as well as teasing. The exchange keeps their connection alive across hundreds of miles.

For Valentine’s Day, Cassie sends lilies to Erin’s hospital, where colleagues speculate that a young cardiology intern is the admirer. Erin tells Cassie she loves the flowers, then video-calls her. Their conversation turns into mutual phone sex, making distance both obstacle and channel for a more deliberate intimacy.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The airport farewell changes the affair’s form rather than ending it. In person, Cassie and Erin can rely on touch; apart, they must decide whether to sustain contact with words, images, and attention. Cassie’s flowers are a bid to make Erin smile, not merely an attempt to arrange another hookup. Erin’s willingness to call and later participate in phone sex confirms that desire is reciprocal, even if the relationship remains unnamed. Their joking tone makes vulnerability bearable, but it also postpones harder questions about what they want. Distance creates privacy while leaving the emotional stakes intact.

The Empty Best Friend Seat

Parker’s new romance leaves Cassie feeling discarded

After Valentine’s Day, Erin worries when Parker misses their regular Sunday call and turns the fear over in therapy. She finally tells her therapist the full story of Cassie, then shares a partial account with her best friend Rachel.

At Keckley, Cassie watches Parker spend more time with Sam and less with her and Acacia. When Parker eventually invites Cassie and Acacia to a movie night, Cassie needles her about the new relationship.

Parker retaliates by criticizing Cassie’s guardedness and lack of romantic experience, and Cassie answers that Parker knows nothing about her life now. Their friendship breaks into anger. Cassie leaves, feeling replaceable again, while Erin still has no evidence that Parker knows about the affair and no honest way to ask.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The conflict reveals that Cassie’s bravado is most fragile around friendship, not sex. Seth’s betrayal and her earlier abandonment by peers have taught her to anticipate being discarded, so Parker’s withdrawal feels like confirmation rather than a temporary shift in attention. Parker’s attack is also shaped by hurt; she uses Cassie’s vulnerability as a weapon because she feels excluded and cannot name why. Erin’s therapy marks a contrasting movement toward disclosure, even as her central fear remains unresolved. Both relationships suffer from the same strategy: withholding difficult truths until silence begins to look like rejection.

A Divorce Finally Explained

Erin tells Parker why leaving Adam mattered

After another uneasy call with Parker, Erin decides to explain the divorce rather than wait for her daughter to ask. She tells Parker that she stayed too long in a marriage shaped by expectations, and left because she wanted to model a life chosen for genuine happiness.

Erin does not blame Adam or ask Parker to take sides. Parker listens, says she is glad her mother told her, and asks more about Erin’s work on a free clinic. Their exchange gives them a more honest footing, even though Cassie remains outside the conversation.

For Cassie, the distance persists until she attends another a cappella concert and sees Parker again. She then travels to Boston for an aerospace laboratory interview, still uncertain whether California is the only future she wants.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Erin’s conversation with Parker is a parental act of repair that avoids recruiting her daughter into the divorce. Instead of making Adam the villain, Erin explains the cost of living by inherited expectations and accepts responsibility for taking too long to speak. Parker’s curiosity about the clinic signals that she is beginning to regard her mother as a person with aspirations, not only as the parent who disrupted her family. Yet the conversation also clarifies the limits of Erin’s progress: she can speak honestly about her marriage while still concealing Cassie. The unresolved secret remains a test of whether her new candor can survive personal risk.

A Best Friend Returns

Cassie turns down Gwen and stays through Parker’s breakup

Cassie interviews with United Aerospace Laboratories in Boston, then receives an offer for a summer position. At a campus party, Gwen openly offers to take her home, but Cassie refuses because she does not want to complicate things with Parker, even though she cannot yet admit how much Erin matters.

Parker later invites her to another party, and the three friends begin cautiously sharing space again. When Parker and Sam break up, Acacia asks Cassie to stay with Parker while she is away.

Cassie refuses to leave when Parker orders her out, insisting that she will remain because she loves her friend. They study, watch television, apologize for their earlier cruelty, and rebuild the friendship. Cassie’s choice to stay marks a shift from preemptive abandonment toward showing up.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Cassie’s refusal of Gwen is a quiet but significant act of loyalty. She does not frame it as romantic fidelity; she simply recognizes that the choice would damage a friendship she wants to preserve. When Parker is heartbroken, Cassie offers the steadiness she once feared no one would offer her. Their reconciliation works because neither claims innocence: Cassie admits her relational uncertainty, while Parker acknowledges using her new relationship to avoid a painful conversation. The sequence redefines vulnerability as behavior rather than confession. Cassie becomes trustworthy not by having perfect insight into her feelings, but by staying present when retreat would be easier.

A Boston Job, A New Orbit

Work, graduation, and the move redraw Cassie’s future

Cassie tells Erin about the Boston job after receiving the offer, and Erin drives from New Hampshire to celebrate with her. Their reunion becomes a night together, followed by a quiet morning that feels less like a hookup than a shared life.

As graduation approaches, Cassie’s chosen-family ties with Acacia and Parker deepen, and the Webbs surprise her at a celebratory meal because they refuse to let her graduate without them. Cassie has not yet committed to graduate school, despite long imagining Caltech.

Erin gives her a motorcycle for graduation, making regular travel between Boston and Nashua possible. Cassie moves toward a Boston summer and begins considering MIT as well as California, not only for Erin but because she has built relationships and work she does not want to flee.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The career plot gives Cassie a concrete alternative to escape. For years, Caltech has represented distance from a childhood defined by neglect and other people’s pity; Boston instead gathers meaningful work, chosen family, and a relationship she has not yet admitted she wants. The job offer is earned through ability, while the motorcycle symbolizes mobility without requiring disappearance. Erin’s gift could be read as generous or dangerously influential, so the narrative balances it with Cassie’s own reasons for reconsidering her plans. Her future becomes more complex, not smaller: staying near people she loves is an act of choice rather than evidence that she has abandoned ambition.

The Kitchen Door Opens

Parker’s acceptance lets Cassie risk saying what she wants

During a summer visit, Adam walks in on Erin and Cassie kissing in the kitchen and condemns Erin for seeing Parker’s friend. Parker arrives, sends her father away, and reveals that she has known about the relationship since Valentine’s Day.

She explains that Acacia helped her understand how happy Erin and Cassie make each other. Cassie, overwhelmed, rides off rather than facing what the revelation means. After speaking with Acacia and receiving a brief check-in from Parker, she returns to Erin’s house with purple swim fins as an awkward promise to try the frightening things Erin loves.

Cassie admits she wants a real relationship. Erin clarifies that her remarks to Rachel were an attempt to deny her own feelings, not reject Cassie. They confess their love, and Cassie explains that Boston and MIT are becoming real possibilities.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The exposure forces the three central relationships into the same room, ending the convenience of compartmentalization. Adam’s disapproval matters less than the possibility that Parker has been deceived, but Parker’s response is not simple absolution: she names the lie and chooses to understand its emotional context. Cassie’s flight is consistent with her oldest defense, leaving before someone can reject her. Her return with the swim fins makes vulnerability physical and slightly absurd, which suits a character who struggles to speak plainly about need. Erin’s clarification resolves the misheard conversation, while their mutual declaration shifts desire into an explicit, shared commitment.

Epilogue

Four years later, Parker asks Cassie why she and Erin are still unmarried. Cassie realizes she would gladly marry Erin but has never treated marriage as necessary. Erin has been planning a proposal of her own, prompted by Cassie’s casual certainty that they belong together.

At their lake house on the Fourth of July, Erin kneels beside the dock and offers Cassie a ring set with aquamarine and meteorite. Cassie accepts, then surprises Erin by proposing in return. Their friends and family watch as both women slide rings onto each other’s hands, turning a relationship once hidden from Parker into a future openly shared.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The paired proposals make commitment reciprocal rather than a rescue one person grants the other. Cassie’s uncertainty about marriage is not uncertainty about Erin; Erin understands that distinction and gives the moment personal meaning through the aquamarine and meteorite. Cassie’s spontaneous counterproposal completes a pattern established much earlier: she is awkward with emotional language but becomes brave when she acts. The lake house, friends, and family replace the secrecy of the first encounters with a chosen public witness. The ending does not imply that marriage cures their earlier conflicts. Instead, it celebrates their capacity to state a desire plainly and let the other answer.

Analysis

Mistakes Were Made builds its romance around a problem of boundaries, not a simple conflict between desire and morality. Cassie and Erin are consenting adults, but their choices are entangled with Parker, who is both Erin’s daughter and Cassie’s friend. The novel lets that entanglement matter. Keeping the affair secret protects the characters from immediate conflict, yet secrecy itself becomes a source of betrayal, especially for Cassie, who already expects friends to leave when she is inconvenient.

The alternating perspectives expose different defenses. Cassie jokes, boasts, and insists that sex need not imply commitment; this gives her control over rejection, but also delays recognition of what she feels. Erin turns care into performance, from the immaculate holiday party to the rules she uses to contain the affair. Her self-denial is not inherently virtuous, because it repeatedly becomes an excuse for cruelty or evasion. Both women confuse control with safety until direct honesty becomes less frightening than continuing to manage each other through hints.

Parker’s role prevents the age gap and secrecy from being treated as decorative obstacles. Her feelings about the divorce, her new relationship, and her friendship with Cassie develop independently of the romance. The story’s emotional repair depends on Cassie showing up when Parker is hurt and Erin finally explaining her choices without making Parker responsible for them. Acacia’s loyalty matters for the same reason: support is not passive approval, but the willingness to tell a friend what she is avoiding.

The aerospace motif gathers these ideas into Cassie’s future. For years, movement has meant escape from a neglected childhood. Her developing attachment to Boston does not cancel her ambition; it changes what freedom can mean. The novel’s final happiness rests less on a grand declaration than on a series of difficult acts: apologize without deflecting, remain present, explain the truth, and choose a future with room for both work and love.

Summary in 60 Seconds
College senior Cassie Klein meets Erin Bennett during family weekend and has an impulsive hookup, only to discover Erin is the mother of her best friend, Parker. They try to keep their attraction secret, but another kiss at Parker's concert and a winter break together deepen the connection. At Erin's New Hampshire home, they begin a clandestine affair, setting rules to hide it from Parker. After Cassie returns to college, distance and secrecy strain her friendships, while Erin finally explains her divorce to Parker. Cassie repairs her friendship with Parker and accepts a summer aerospace job in Boston. When Parker's father catches Erin and Cassie kissing, Parker reveals she has known about them and supports their relationship. Cassie and Erin admit their love and plan a future together. Four years later, Erin proposes at their lakehouse, and Cassie proposes back.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.91 out of 5
Average of 52k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Mistakes Were Made received mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.92 out of 5. Many readers praised the steamy romance and chemistry between the main characters, Cassie and Erin. The age gap and forbidden romance aspects were generally well-received. Some appreciated the character development and emotional depth, while others found the relationship dynamics uncomfortable or problematic. The book was noted for its high level of sexual content and humor. Criticisms included pacing issues, underdeveloped plot, and concerns about the power dynamics in the relationship.

Your rating:
4.77
38 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Cassie Klein

The restless engineer

A sharp, sexually confident Keckley senior, Cassie wants to build aircraft or spacecraft and has pursued Caltech as a route toward freedom. She grew up with an unreliable mother and an absent father, but resists being reduced to that history. Her humor, bravado, and competence help her control how much other people can know. With Acacia, she has the security of a lifelong bond; with Parker, she discovers that a newer friendship can matter just as much. Cassie is often quicker to act than to understand what she feels. Her central tension is between escape and attachment: she wants independence, yet fears that needing people will give them the power to leave her.

Erin Bennett

The dutiful doctor

A physician, divorced mother, and devoted host, Erin has spent years trying to meet standards inherited from family and marriage. She loves Parker fiercely but worries that her work and the divorce have damaged their closeness. Erin’s polish can conceal anxiety; she often avoids conflict until avoidance becomes unkindness. Therapy and friendship with Rachel help her ask what she wants, while her attraction to Cassie challenges the careful separation she maintains between desire and responsibility. Erin is thoughtful and capable, but not automatically self-knowing. Her struggle is to distinguish genuine care from self-erasure, and to model honesty without expecting perfection from herself or her daughter.

Parker Bennett

The searching daughter

Erin and Adam’s daughter, Parker is a first-year student at Keckley, a talented artist, and a new member of a close campus circle. She loves both parents but carries hurt about their divorce, especially when old family traditions change. Parker can be persuasive, affectionate, and funny, yet she sometimes uses silence or sharpness when she feels excluded. Her friendships with Cassie and Acacia give her a home at college, while her relationship with Erin is shaped by their resemblance and their tendency to clash. Parker is still figuring out what she wants from art, love, and adulthood, and she does not always know how to ask for closeness directly.

Acacia

The loyal anchor

Cassie’s closest friend since childhood, Acacia is a direct, energetic presence who knows Cassie’s defenses almost as well as Cassie does. She is also Parker’s roommate and friend, which places her between two people she loves when their secrecy and hurt begin to overlap. Acacia is willing to tease, challenge, and comfort, but loyalty does not make her neutral. She has her own relationship and ambitions, including learning to ride a motorcycle. Her role is not simply to advise Cassie; she demonstrates what durable friendship looks like when someone is difficult, frightened, or wrong.

Adam Bennett

The self-assured ex

Erin’s former husband and Parker’s father, Adam remains part of family gatherings and college visits. He and Erin can cooperate around Parker, but his confidence often hardens into condescension, especially when he assumes he knows what another person needs. His treatment of Cassie reveals the limits of his perspective and recalls the strain that shaped Erin’s marriage. Adam is important less as a romantic rival than as a measure of how differently Erin now responds to a familiar kind of dismissal.

Rachel

The candid confidante

Erin’s longtime best friend, Rachel is openly pansexual, perceptive, and far less restrained about pleasure than Erin is. She encourages Erin to date and to stop treating other people’s expectations as binding rules. Her humor can be pointed, but her loyalty is steady; she notices when Erin is hiding something and knows when to press or back off. Rachel offers a model of self-acceptance that Erin admires even when she is not ready to follow it.

Seth

The faithless ex

Cassie’s former boyfriend, Seth is charming enough to draw a campus friend group toward him after their breakup. His betrayal leaves Cassie wary of trusting romantic attention and helps explain why she initially treats sex as safer than emotional commitment.

Sam

Parker’s new love

A member of Parker’s a cappella circle, Sam becomes the focus of Parker’s romantic attention. Her relationship with Parker affects how much time Parker spends with Cassie and Acacia, bringing existing insecurities in the friendship to the surface. Sam is more a catalyst than a viewpoint character, but her presence helps expose what the friends have left unsaid.

Gwen

The guarded provocateur

A graduate student and former resident adviser, Gwen is self-possessed and blunt. She once intervenes when Cassie is too drunk to look after herself, and later makes her attraction to Cassie clear. Gwen’s confidence contrasts with Cassie’s habit of pursuing immediate distraction, making her a meaningful test of what Cassie actually wants.

Emerson

Acacia’s older brother

Acacia’s older brother is a familiar part of Cassie’s chosen family. He is affectionate and teasing, and his presence offers Cassie the easy comfort of a long-standing bond. Their brief physical closeness comes from Cassie’s attempt to distract herself, not from a romance she has been seeking.

Mama Webb

Cassie’s chosen mother

Acacia’s mother, known to Cassie as Mama Webb, has provided food, shelter, boundaries, and a steady welcome since Cassie was a child. Her care is practical rather than sentimental, giving Cassie an experience of family that contrasts with the instability of her home life.

Mr. Ben

Cassie’s chosen father

Acacia’s father is a quiet, dependable presence in Cassie’s life. His raised eyebrow or disappointed sigh can set a boundary without withdrawing affection. He represents a form of adult steadiness Cassie has lacked elsewhere.

Caleb

Parker’s steady friend

A longtime friend of Parker’s, Caleb appears at campus gatherings and holiday events. His easy familiarity with the group helps show how deeply Parker’s college and hometown circles overlap.

Lila

Parker’s campus friend

Lila is one of Parker’s college friends and joins the group for meals and winter activities. Her presence helps establish the lively network Parker is building at Keckley.

Madison

The genderqueer classmate

Madison is part of Parker’s wider friend group and joins the winter sledding trip and campus gatherings. They are direct and comfortable in their identity, adding to the novel’s picture of young queer community.

Plot Devices

Family Weekend

The coincidence that binds

Keckley’s Family Weekend brings Cassie and Erin together before either knows how closely their lives are connected. The encounter first appears to offer the freedom of anonymity, then becomes the source of ongoing conflict when Erin’s daughter turns out to be Parker, Cassie’s friend. This event drives the novel’s secrecy, forces the characters to weigh desire against loyalty, and repeatedly returns them to the question of whether their relationship can exist without harming Parker.

The Shared Holidays

Proximity disguised as hospitality

Parker’s invitation brings Cassie into Erin’s New Hampshire home for winter break. Cooking, hosting, gift-giving, and family traditions create an intimacy that neither woman can dismiss as a single hookup. The household also supplies practical limits: Parker is often nearby, so Cassie and Erin must hide their affection or risk discovery. Christmas and New Year’s intensify the contrast between the warmth of family rituals and the secret relationship unfolding inside them.

Phones and Messages

Distance made intimate

Cassie’s stolen contact, Erin’s calls, Valentine’s flowers, FaceTime dinners, and later messages let the relationship continue when the women are far apart. The devices also create danger: an accidental appearance on a video call reveals that Acacia knows, and Parker later sees a message that helps her understand the affair. Phones therefore serve both as private bridges and as vulnerable records of what the characters are trying to conceal.

The Rocket Ship Necklace

A future made tangible

Erin gives Cassie a rocket ship necklace after hearing Parker tease her about becoming an astronaut. It connects Cassie’s fascination with aerospace to Erin’s attentive understanding of her ambitions. Cassie keeps wearing it, making the gift a small, visible link between the women even when their relationship remains unnamed. The necklace carries affection without requiring either woman to explain what the relationship means, which is precisely why it becomes emotionally charged.

The Boston Career Choice

Ambition becomes a choice

Cassie’s aerospace job offer and graduate-school options give her a future beyond the childhood dream of reaching California. Her work is not a romantic favor, and Erin is careful not to demand that she stay nearby. Boston nevertheless places Cassie within reach of Erin, Parker, and Acacia, challenging Cassie to distinguish a genuine ambition from a desire to escape. The choice ties professional independence to the possibility of belonging without requiring Cassie to abandon either.

About the Author

Meryl Wilsner is an author who specializes in writing happily ever afters for queer women. They have published two books: "Something to Talk About" and "Mistakes Were Made." Originally from Michigan, Wilsner has lived in various parts of the United States before settling back in their home state. They are known for their love of all four seasons, button-down shirts, and giraffes. Wilsner's writing focuses on creating positive and inclusive representations of LGBTQ+ relationships in contemporary romance. Their work has gained attention for its exploration of diverse queer experiences and characters.

Download PDF

To save this Mistakes Were Made summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.38 MB     Pages: 25

Download EPUB

To read this Mistakes Were Made summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.47 MB     Pages: 32
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...