Key Takeaways
Treat power as a current to channel, not property to hoard
Power has two operating modes. Old power resembles stored currency: it is concentrated among institutions and experts, and usually asks people to obey or buy. New power flows from many people sharing, creating, and organizing. Its leaders succeed by directing that energy, not simply owning it. The contrast appears in Harvey Weinstein’s protected Hollywood hierarchy and #MeToo, which spread as people shared stories and supported one another.
Tools do not determine ethics. PatientsLikeMe illustrates the promise of peer learning: patients used shared experiences and data to explore options their doctors had not discussed. ISIS used similar peer-to-peer methods to recruit people into violence. Connectivity expands people’s capacity to act, for better or worse.
What's striking is that power here is not simply authority or influence. It is also the ability to coordinate action across people who may never meet. That makes the current metaphor useful: a current can energize a community, but it can also overwhelm safeguards. Patient communities can help people ask sharper questions, while medical decisions still require careful evaluation of evidence and individual risk. The distinction is important because participation is a source of capability, not proof of truth or virtue.
Judge participation by who gains power, not by the platform's tools
Separate structure from culture. A model describes what people are allowed to do: consume, comply, or help create. Values describe who is trusted, how decisions are made, and whether information is shared. NASA invited 3,000 people from 80 countries to solve research problems. One semi-retired telecommunications engineer improved solar-storm forecasts from one to two hours at 50% accuracy to eight hours at 75%. Some NASA scientists resisted, not because they lacked technology, but because outside contributions threatened their identity as experts.
Use both dimensions. Black Lives Matter distributed participation and encouraged supporters to adapt its message. Facebook also depends on user activity, yet retains corporate control over its platform. Expertise remains essential where errors carry serious costs, so crowds are not a universal substitute for specialists.
This distinction prevents a common category error: a platform can look participatory while leaving authority and rewards concentrated. The same technology can support shared governance or simply recruit users to produce value for an owner. Conversely, expertise and hierarchy can protect quality when consequences are severe. The useful question is not whether an organization uses social media or crowdsourcing, but whether its underlying arrangements give contributors meaningful influence. That test also reveals why participation can be real in one part of an institution and cosmetic in another.
Make ideas spread through action, relationships, and remixing
Design for participation. An ACE idea invites people to act, connects them with peers, and leaves room for them to adapt it. The Ice Bucket Challenge did more than promote ALS awareness: people filmed themselves, nominated friends, and personalized the challenge. Between June and September 2014, more than 17 million related videos appeared on Facebook, and the ALS Association raised $115 million.
Peers move behavior. In a 2010 Facebook voting experiment, a basic reminder did not raise turnout compared with no message. Adding pictures of friends who had voted increased estimated turnout by 60,000 people; another 280,000 people were indirectly influenced through friends’ posts. The mechanism was social proof, not simply a louder message.
The shift from memorable messages to participatory formats is a shift from attention to behavior. People can treat an action as a signal of belonging, then pass it through relationships that already carry trust. This resembles network diffusion: influence is often strongest when an idea travels through several ordinary connections rather than relying on one celebrity broadcast. Still, participation is not a truth filter. A remixable idea can spread misinformation as efficiently as public health advice, so design needs both reach and responsible context.
Open the door cheaply, then give newcomers a path to matter
Start with a connected core. Connected connectors are people who share a worldview, know one another, and can bring others in. GetUp began by making it easy for Australians to email politicians on issues they cared about. Anna Hazare’s anti-corruption campaign first generated 80,000 text messages; when organizers switched to free missed calls, support rose to 35 million. The small change removed the cost and effort of participating.
Build a ladder, not a stunt. People may begin by sharing or signing, then take on deeper roles such as organizing, funding, creating, and shaping a community. Crowds also grow around dramatic moments. A movement can create urgency, seize an existing storm, or turn opposition into a rallying point, as GetUp did when politicians attacked it.
Low-friction entry makes collective action accessible to people who lack time, money, or formal political connections. But an easy first step is only an opening, not evidence of lasting commitment. A useful participation pathway offers increasingly consequential roles without treating people as units in a conversion funnel. It also recognizes that not everyone should be pushed toward leadership. Durable movements need both a broad base of occasional supporters and a smaller group willing to take on the labor of organizing.
Keep platforms accountable to contributors, users, and everyone affected
Map the internal bargain. A new power triangle consists of the platform owner, ordinary participants, and super-participants, the highly active contributors who create or govern much of the platform’s value. Reddit’s volunteer moderators were super-participants. After years of ignored requests for better tools, the sudden firing of a trusted staff liaison helped trigger a blackout across hundreds of subreddits.
Look beyond the platform. The circle test asks how a platform affects people outside its core community as well. When Uber announced fare cuts without consulting drivers, protests followed. Lyft also cut fares, but sought driver input and supported ideas such as referral bonuses and driver meetups. A platform can make life easier for customers while shifting costs onto workers, neighborhoods, or public institutions.
The platform model depends on contributors, but dependence does not guarantee they have bargaining power. Volunteer moderators, drivers, and creators may produce essential value while the owner controls rules, data, and revenue. That asymmetry makes consultation alone inadequate: durable communities need transparent decisions, useful tools, and ways to contest changes. The circle test widens the frame further by asking who bears indirect costs. A platform's success should not be measured only by user growth or convenience.
Pair participation with real value, but don't confuse viral with vital
Participation adds a third return. The participation premium is added value created when an exchange combines a useful return, a larger purpose, and meaningful influence over what is made. Star Citizen raised more than $100 million from over a million backers before delivering its promised game universe. Many supporters valued the community, learning, and chance to influence development as well as the eventual product.
Participation has limits. Xiaomi invited users to test and improve its phone software, drawing millions of interactions. But crowdfunding can favor causes with vivid stories over less visible public needs. It may also favor people who already have strong networks or the skill to attract attention. A viral campaign can provide a powerful burst of money without ensuring fair allocation, accountability, or sustained impact.
Participation can create genuine value before a product is complete: people learn, form relationships, and feel ownership of a shared project. Those benefits are real, but they should be distinguished from financial return and delivery obligations. Emotional investment can make supporters less likely to demand oversight, as the Star Citizen story suggests. Crowdfunding also changes who receives resources by making visibility a condition of success. A compelling story can unlock neglected support, yet popularity is not a reliable measure of social importance.
Lead by making the crowd capable, not by making yourself central
Use three leadership levers. A leader signals what matters, structures real opportunities to participate, and shapes norms the group can sustain without constant orders. Barack Obama’s 2008 campaign paired volunteer initiative with clear roles and a detailed organizing manual. Donald Trump also mobilized a decentralized online crowd, but used it to advance authoritarian values, a pattern the authors call the Platform Strongman.
Good intentions are not enough. Starbucks’ Race Together campaign asked baristas to initiate conversations about race without giving them adequate agency or preparation. Black Lives Matter took a different approach: its founders built a movement with multiple leaders and deliberately centered people often marginalized within established movements. The contrast shows how structure and legitimacy affect whether participation feels empowering or imposed.
A leader can be charismatic and still distribute power, or use a crowd to consolidate it. The distinction lies less in rhetoric than in who gains the ability to act and set norms. Signaling without structure can become theater; structure without trust can feel coercive. Leaderful movements also face a real coordination challenge: broad participation creates more voices, but not automatic agreement. Strong leadership makes space for agency while establishing enough shared purpose and process to keep collective effort from dissolving into conflict.
Blend participation with expertise, structure, and disciplined control
Ask whether opening up has a real purpose. An organization should consider whether crowd participation serves its strategy, whether it has credibility with the people it invites, how much control it can surrender, and whether it can sustain the relationship. Britain’s research agency NERC invited the public to name a research ship, then rejected the winning name, Boaty McBoatface, because it preferred a more conventional choice.
Commit beyond the stunt. Lego’s recovery included sustained engagement with adult fans, who represented only 5% of its market but spent about 20 times as much as an average family with children. Fan ideas became products through a company review process, and successful designs could earn a share of sales. The crowd contributed creativity; the company supplied standards and manufacturing capacity.
The lesson is not to hand every decision to a crowd. Participation works best when the organization knows what outsiders can contribute and is honest about which choices remain its responsibility. Lego structured a route from fan creativity to commercial production, while NERC invited public judgment without accepting its result. That difference makes trust fragile: people can tolerate boundaries more readily when they are clear in advance. Openness is not a substitute for expertise; it is a way to put expertise in productive contact with knowledge beyond institutional walls.
Give workers the ownership, information, and peer support founders expect
Autonomy needs operating support. The founder feeling is workers’ desire for meaningful ownership, information, flexibility, and varied responsibilities, even when they work inside a larger organization. Dutch home-care network Buurtzorg organized nurses into self-managing teams of 10 to 12, supported by shared technology and coaches rather than layers of managers. It grew to about 10,000 nurses in 850 teams, with a back office of only 45 people.
Give professionals room to do the work. A cited KPMG study found roughly 50% fewer care hours alongside improved care quality and employee satisfaction. Nurses could see team budgets, make local decisions, and ask peers across the network for help. Their independence was supported by shared learning and coordination, not by leaving each team on its own.
Buurtzorg suggests that autonomy is most effective when accountability sits close to the work and colleagues can share knowledge across teams. This is different from simply removing managers or installing a new management software system. The model also depends on the skill and professional judgment of nurses, so it cannot be copied mechanically into every workplace. Organizations should distinguish genuine discretion from transferred risk: giving employees responsibility without resources, security, or influence can turn the language of ownership into a way to make workers absorb costs.
Build participation into institutions, not just into their marketing
Make participation part of the system. A full-stack society gives people recurring ways to shape the platforms, services, workplaces, and governments that shape their lives. Dutch publication De Correspondent launched with 19,000 member subscribers and invited readers to contribute expertise before articles were written. In Taiwan, civic hackers broke complex budget tables into quick transcription tasks, attracting 9,000 contributors in a day; online discussion later helped inform rideshare regulation.
Make influence consequential. Users need information, meaningful input, and ways to challenge decisions, not only opportunities to like or share. The authors also point toward community ownership and more transparent platform algorithms. Yet participation can favor people with more time and access, so public input should strengthen fair representation and expert responsibility, not erase them.
The central institutional challenge is to turn episodic engagement into ongoing capacity. A reader who helps a journalist find evidence, or a citizen who can inspect a budget, is more than an audience member: that person can improve the institution's knowledge and legitimacy. Still, the promise depends on whether contributions alter decisions. A polished interface can make participation feel vivid while leaving authority untouched. Strong systems disclose their boundaries, show what happened to public input, and keep open channels for those least able to participate.
Analysis
The book’s strongest contribution is its insistence that participation is not merely a communication tactic. It is a source of productive capacity, a form of legitimacy, and a contested distribution of power. A crowd can identify a solar forecasting solution, help a company design products, support a political campaign, or create a recruitment network for violence. The tool itself does not settle the moral question. Governance, incentives, and norms do.
That argument also clarifies why the book treats new and old power as complementary rather than as a simple historical replacement. Crowds contribute dispersed knowledge and energy, while institutions can provide expertise, coordination, standards, and continuity. NASA’s open challenges and Lego’s fan programs work when outside contributions meet internal capacity. NERC’s ship contest fails when an invitation is mistaken for a willingness to share authority. The distinction is between participation that is operationally meaningful and participation used as decoration.
The unresolved tension is that participation can distribute agency without distributing ownership. A platform may rely on unpaid creators or workers while retaining control of revenue, data, and rules. A movement may welcome broad involvement yet give disproportionate influence to people with time, confidence, and existing networks. A funding campaign may mobilize generosity while directing money toward stories that attract attention rather than needs that matter most. Participation therefore requires more than access. It requires mechanisms for accountability, fair representation, and scrutiny of who benefits.
The book’s practical test is consequently demanding: does the crowd gain real capacity, can the institution sustain a relationship with it, and do people outside the platform benefit or bear costs? This makes new power a governance problem as much as a leadership or marketing problem. The most durable systems are not those that maximize engagement at any price. They are those that connect shared activity to consequential decisions, distribute value transparently, and retain enough structure to protect quality and the public interest.
Review Summary
New Power receives mostly positive reviews for its insightful analysis of how technology and social media are reshaping power dynamics. Readers appreciate the numerous examples and case studies illustrating the shift from "old power" to "new power" structures. Some find the book repetitive or politically biased, while others praise its framework for understanding modern movements and organizations. Critics note that the book sometimes oversimplifies complex issues, but many readers consider it essential for understanding today's connected world and its impact on business, politics, and society.
People Also Read
Glossary
Old power
Concentrated authorityA model of power held by a relatively small number of people or institutions. It is commonly guarded, hierarchical, and leader-driven, and it depends on resources, expertise, or control that others do not possess. People are typically asked to comply with rules or consume what the institution provides.
New power
Crowd-generated influenceA form of power produced through the activity of many people. It is participatory, peer-driven, and capable of spreading quickly through networks. Organizations using it depend on people sharing, creating, funding, or shaping activity. Its central challenge is to channel participation while deciding how authority and value are distributed.
ACE idea
Idea built to spreadAn idea designed to travel through active participation rather than passive exposure. It gives people a concrete action, connects them with peers or a shared identity, and allows them to adapt or extend the idea. The Ice Bucket Challenge used these qualities by inviting personal videos, nominations, and customized versions.
New power compass
Map of models and valuesA framework that classifies organizations along two dimensions: whether their operating model enables broad participation, and whether their values favor openness and collaboration or hierarchy and control. It helps distinguish an organization that genuinely distributes power from one that uses participatory tools while keeping authority concentrated.
New power triangle
Three roles within platformsA model of the relationships inside a participatory platform. It includes the platform owner or steward, ordinary participants, and super-participants who contribute heavily or help govern the community. Tensions arise when these groups have different interests, especially around decision-making, recognition, working conditions, and the distribution of value.
The circle test
Check effects beyond usersA way to assess a platform by examining its effects on both the people inside its community and the wider groups around it. It asks whether the model benefits or harms workers, public institutions, competitors, communities, and society, rather than judging success only by convenience, growth, or user satisfaction.
The participation scale
Levels of community involvementA way to describe how deeply people take part in a platform or movement. Engagement can range from consuming and sharing material to affiliating, funding, adapting, producing, and shaping the community itself. Effective organizers create accessible entry points and opportunities for people who want more responsibility.
Participation premium
Added value from involvementThe additional value created when a transaction combines a material return, a sense of higher purpose, and the ability to participate in making or shaping something. Participants may value relationships, learning, and influence alongside the product or financial return. These benefits do not guarantee delivery, fair governance, or financial success.
Platform Strongman
Authoritarian crowd leaderA leader who uses participatory platforms and decentralized networks to mobilize a crowd while advancing authoritarian values or concentrating power. The crowd may feel energized and influential, even as the leader directs its activity toward exclusion, coercion, or concentrated authority.
Full-stack society
Participation across institutionsA society in which people have meaningful, ongoing opportunities to shape the systems affecting their lives, including technology, work, health care, education, and government. The idea calls for connected cultural and structural change, not a single application or occasional consultation.
Participation farms
Platforms harvesting user activityDigital platforms that gather and profit from the routine activity of large populations while keeping control and much of the resulting value in the hands of a few owners. The term highlights the gap between language about sharing and community, and arrangements in which users have little say over governance, data, or rewards.
FAQ
What's New Power about?
- Explores power dynamics: New Power by Jeremy Heimans and Henry Timms examines the shift from traditional, hierarchical forms of power (old power) to more decentralized, participatory forms (new power).
- Old vs. New Power: The book contrasts old power, which is closed and leader-driven, with new power, which is open, participatory, and peer-driven.
- Real-world examples: It provides case studies like the #MeToo movement and platforms like Airbnb to illustrate how new power operates in practice.
Why should I read New Power?
- Understanding modern dynamics: The book helps you grasp the evolving landscape of influence and participation in society.
- Practical insights: Offers actionable strategies for individuals and organizations to mobilize communities and leverage new power dynamics.
- Cultural relevance: With the rise of social media and grassroots movements, the concepts are increasingly relevant for understanding contemporary activism and engagement.
What are the key takeaways of New Power?
- Power is participatory: Power is shifting towards participatory models, where collective action and community engagement are paramount.
- Importance of community: Building and nurturing communities is essential for mobilizing new power effectively.
- Navigating old and new power: Provides guidance on blending old and new power strategies, recognizing their usefulness in different contexts.
What are the best quotes from New Power and what do they mean?
- “The future will be a battle over mobilization.”: Success will depend on the ability to mobilize people effectively.
- “New power operates like a current.”: New power is fluid, dynamic, and collective, unlike the static nature of old power.
- “The goal with new power is not to hoard it but to channel it.”: Sharing and collaboration are more effective than control and exclusivity.
What is the difference between old power and new power according to New Power?
- Old power is exclusive: Characterized by being held by a few in hierarchical structures with controlled access and influence.
- New power is inclusive: Open and participatory, allowing many individuals to contribute and shape outcomes collectively.
- Mechanisms of operation: Old power operates through top-down control, while new power thrives on peer-to-peer engagement.
How do ideas spread in a new power world according to New Power?
- Meme drops vs. sound bites: Ideas spread laterally and are remixed by communities, unlike traditional top-down sound bites.
- Actionable, connected, extensible: Successful ideas encourage participation, foster community, and allow for customization.
- Examples of successful campaigns: Campaigns like the Ice Bucket Challenge illustrate viral spread through social networks.
What is the "participation premium" mentioned in New Power?
- Definition of participation premium: Added value from engaging individuals, combining economic returns with purpose and community involvement.
- Components of the premium: Calculated as (Something in Return + Higher Purpose) x Participation, enhancing value through involvement.
- Real-world applications: Examples like Star Citizen show how backers feel ownership and community, enhancing their experience.
How can organizations transition from old power to new power according to New Power?
- Assessing strategy: Evaluate if embracing new power aligns with strategic goals and adds value.
- Building legitimacy: Establish trust and credibility with the community, investing in relationships.
- Embracing flexibility: Be willing to relinquish control and allow for unexpected outcomes, fostering participation.
What role do super-participants play in new power communities according to New Power?
- Definition of super-participants: Most active and engaged community members, contributing significantly to content and culture.
- Influence on community dynamics: Shape norms and drive engagement, acting as leaders within the community.
- Recognition and rewards: Effective communities recognize and reward super-participants, ensuring they feel valued.
How does New Power address the challenges of misinformation and hate in the digital age?
- Dual nature of new power: Acknowledges new power can amplify both positive change and negative elements like hate and misinformation.
- Need for counter-narratives: Emphasizes creating alternative narratives to counteract harmful ideologies.
- Call for responsibility: Advocates for collective responsibility to ensure new power is used constructively.
What are some successful examples of new power in action according to New Power?
- #MeToo movement: Exemplifies new power by allowing individuals to share stories and mobilize action without a central leader.
- Airbnb's community engagement: Successfully engages hosts and guests, creating a participatory culture.
- Lego's transformation: Embraced its adult fan community, transitioning from old power to new power by valuing super-participants.
What is the future of new power according to the authors of New Power?
- Full-stack society vision: Envisions a future with meaningful participation in all life aspects, requiring cultural and structural shifts.
- Emphasis on collaboration: Future relies on collaborative efforts bringing diverse voices together to address social issues.
- Innovative platforms: New technologies like blockchain can facilitate equitable participation, reshaping power distribution.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.