Plot Summary
Infertility and Family Expectations
Leia Sital, a brilliant, sensitive woman, faces the heartbreak of infertility after surviving ovarian cancer as a teen. Her Indian immigrant family, especially her mother, tries to comfort her, but their well-meaning words only deepen her sense of loss. Surrounded by siblings and friends who are building families, Leia feels isolated, her dreams of motherhood slipping away. Her sister Asha, ever hopeful, pushes Leia to date, but Leia hides behind her PhD studies, using academia as a shield from vulnerability. The ache of not fitting into her family's expectations, and the cultural weight of marriage and children, leaves Leia feeling both invisible and exposed, desperate for a sense of belonging and purpose.
A Chance Encounter at the Bar
Adrian Astor, a recently separated father of twins, returns to the US after a failed marriage in London. Burdened by guilt and uncertainty about uprooting his children, he seeks solace in a bar, where he notices Leia—her sadness mirroring his own. Their banter is playful, masking deeper wounds. Both are drawn to each other's vulnerability, finding comfort in the anonymity of the night. They exchange fake names, "Ley" and "Thor," and agree to leave their real lives behind for a few hours. The chemistry is undeniable, and for the first time in years, both feel seen and understood, if only for a fleeting moment.
Night of Escapism
Leia and Adrian escape to a secluded field, stargazing and weaving a fantasy life together—married, with twins, happy. Their playful roleplay becomes intimate, each indulging in the dream of a life they fear they'll never have. The night turns passionate, their connection deepening as they share their bodies and secret hopes. For Leia, it's a chance to pretend she's not broken; for Adrian, a respite from the pain of divorce. As dawn approaches, reality intrudes. Adrian, unable to risk further complications for his children, gives Leia a wrong number, ending their night with a bittersweet goodbye, both changed by what they shared.
Fantasy Under the Stars
The next day, Leia is left reeling, replaying the night in her mind. She confides in her best friend Amara, who encourages her to reach out, but Leia discovers the number Adrian gave her is fake. The rejection stings, confirming her fears that happiness isn't meant for her. Meanwhile, Adrian is haunted by their night, but prioritizes his children's stability over his own desires. Both try to move on, but the memory of their connection lingers, coloring their relationships and choices. The fantasy they created under the stars becomes a touchstone for what real love could feel like, if only circumstances were different.
Unspoken Goodbyes
Two years later, Leia is still single, focused on her PhD and working as a nanny. At Amara's wedding, she's shocked to see Adrian—now revealed as Amara's cousin and a new professor at her college. The realization that he's the man she's been unable to forget, and that he has children, devastates her. She feels betrayed, believing she was just a fling while he was still married. Adrian, equally stunned, tries to explain, but Leia shuts him out, determined to keep her distance. The pain of their unfinished story resurfaces, threatening to unravel the careful life Leia has built.
Two Years and Regret
Leia's academic advisor retires, and Adrian is assigned as her new supervisor. Forced into close proximity, they struggle to maintain professionalism. Old wounds reopen as they navigate their roles—professor and student, employer and nanny, former lovers. Adrian wants a clean slate, but Leia insists on boundaries, refusing to acknowledge their past. Both are haunted by what might have been, their unresolved feelings simmering beneath the surface. The tension is palpable, and their attempts to move forward are complicated by jealousy, misunderstandings, and the ever-present demands of family and culture.
Fate Reunites at a Wedding
Through a twist of fate, Leia is hired as the nanny for Adrian's twins, Lucy and Colton. The children are struggling with the aftermath of their parents' divorce, and Leia's warmth and empathy begin to heal their wounds. Adrian is torn—grateful for Leia's positive influence, but tormented by his desire for her. Their professional relationship blurs as they share intimate moments, both with the children and each other. The boundaries they set begin to crumble, and the possibility of a second chance at love emerges, even as the risks grow ever greater.
Secrets and Professional Boundaries
As Leia and Adrian grow closer, jealousy flares—both from within and from those around them. Adrian's ex-wife, Alice, returns, intent on reclaiming her family and undermining Leia. The children, caught in the crossfire, become distant, their pain manifesting as anger and withdrawal. Leia's role as both nanny and academic protégé becomes precarious, her reputation and future at risk. The secrecy of their relationship takes its toll, and the pressure mounts as cultural expectations, professional ethics, and personal desires collide. Both must decide what they're willing to sacrifice for love.
Nanny to the Astor Children
Despite the chaos, Leia's relationship with Lucy and Colton flourishes. She becomes a source of stability and comfort, helping them navigate their grief and confusion. Through shared books, games, and heart-to-heart talks, Leia earns their trust and affection. Adrian witnesses the transformation, his admiration for Leia growing. The children's acceptance becomes a beacon of hope, suggesting that a blended family might be possible. Yet, the specter of Alice's manipulation and the threat of scandal loom, threatening to undo the fragile happiness they've found.
Children, Guilt, and Healing
Alice's interference escalates, poisoning the children against Leia and reigniting old insecurities. Leia is devastated by their rejection, questioning her place in their lives and her worthiness of love. Adrian is caught between loyalty to his children and his love for Leia, struggling to protect both. The family fractures, each member grappling with guilt and longing for reconciliation. Through honest conversations and acts of vulnerability, they begin to heal, learning that forgiveness is possible, and that love can endure even the deepest wounds.
Jealousy and Unresolved Feelings
As the truth about Adrian and Leia's relationship comes to light, they face judgment from colleagues, family, and the community. Leia's academic career is threatened, and Adrian is forced to resign. The children, realizing the depth of Leia's love, seek her forgiveness, and the family begins to mend. Adrian proposes, determined to build a life with Leia despite the obstacles. Together, they confront their fears, choosing each other and the messy, beautiful future they can create. Their love, once a secret, becomes a source of strength and pride.
Parental Pressures and Cultural Clashes
With their relationship public, Leia and Adrian must win the blessing of Leia's traditional Indian parents. Through heartfelt conversations, cultural rituals, and the support of their extended families, they bridge the gap between worlds. Adrian embraces Leia's heritage, participating in elaborate wedding preparations and ceremonies. The children, now fully part of Leia's heart, help convince her parents of their love. The family's acceptance is hard-won, but ultimately, love and understanding prevail, proving that happiness can be found at the intersection of tradition and change.
The Ex-Wife Returns
Alice, unable to accept Adrian's new life, makes one last attempt to destroy Leia's reputation and happiness. She manipulates the children, spreads rumors, and tries to derail Leia's academic achievements. But the family, now united, stands firm. Leia's integrity and resilience win the day, and Alice is forced to let go. The ordeal cements the bonds between Leia, Adrian, and the children, and they emerge stronger, ready to face whatever challenges the future may bring.
Sabotage and Heartbreak
In the aftermath of Alice's sabotage, Leia faces her darkest hour—estranged from the children, her career in jeopardy, and her family's approval uncertain. Yet, through the unwavering support of Adrian, her sister, and her best friend, Leia finds the strength to persevere. She defends her dissertation, clears her name, and reclaims her place in the family. The experience teaches her the value of self-worth, the importance of forgiveness, and the enduring power of hope.
The Kids' Rejection
With Alice gone, Leia and Adrian focus on rebuilding trust with Lucy and Colton. Through patience, honesty, and unconditional love, they repair the bonds that were broken. The children, recognizing Leia's devotion, welcome her as a true mother. The family, once fractured, becomes whole, embracing their unique story and the love that binds them. Together, they look to the future, ready to face life's uncertainties as a united front.
Family, Forgiveness, and Reconciliation
With the past behind them, Leia and Adrian celebrate their love with a proposal under the stars—the place where their story began. Surrounded by family and friends, they commit to a life of partnership, blending cultures, traditions, and dreams. Their wedding is a joyful fusion of Indian and Western customs, a testament to the power of love to transcend boundaries. The children, now secure in their place in the family, rejoice in the happiness of their parents.
Defending Love and Reputation
Leia's successful dissertation defense marks the end of one chapter and the beginning of another. With her academic reputation restored and her family's blessing secured, she and Adrian look forward to a future filled with possibility. Together, they navigate the challenges of blended family life, career ambitions, and cultural expectations, always choosing love and understanding. Their journey, marked by hardship and triumph, becomes a beacon of hope for those who dare to follow their hearts.
Proposal Under the Stars
Five years later, Leia and Adrian are happily married, raising their daughter Riya alongside Lucy and Colton. Their home is filled with laughter, love, and the blending of cultures. Leia's parents, once skeptical, have embraced Adrian and the children as their own. The family gathers for meals, celebrations, and quiet moments under the stars, grateful for the journey that brought them together. Leia and Adrian's love, forged in adversity, stands as a testament to the power of faith, resilience, and the belief that happiness is worth fighting for.
Characters
Leia Sital
Leia is a brilliant, compassionate woman shaped by early trauma—her battle with ovarian cancer and subsequent infertility. Her Indian heritage and family's expectations weigh heavily on her, fueling both her ambition and her sense of inadequacy. Leia's longing for motherhood and belonging is palpable, and she often hides behind her academic pursuits to avoid vulnerability. Her journey is one of self-acceptance, learning to embrace love despite fear, and redefining what it means to be whole. Through heartbreak, betrayal, and reconciliation, Leia's resilience and empathy become her greatest strengths, allowing her to build a family and a future on her own terms.
Adrian Astor
Adrian is a devoted father, brilliant academic, and reluctant heir to a vast family fortune. Haunted by the failure of his marriage and the responsibility of raising twins, he is both pragmatic and deeply romantic. His encounter with Leia awakens a longing for connection and happiness he thought he'd lost. Adrian's struggle is one of balancing duty and desire, learning to prioritize his own needs without sacrificing those he loves. His journey is marked by growth, vulnerability, and the courage to fight for love, even when it means risking everything.
Lucy Astor
Lucy, Adrian's daughter, is deeply affected by her parents' divorce. She retreats into books and silence, using reading as a shield against pain. Her bond with Leia is transformative, helping her rediscover joy and trust. Lucy's journey is one of healing, learning to accept change, and opening her heart to a new family dynamic. Her sensitivity and intelligence make her both vulnerable and wise beyond her years.
Colton Astor
Colton, Lucy's twin, copes with upheaval through humor and gaming. He is quick to bond with Leia, drawn to her warmth and understanding. Colton's loyalty to his sister and his willingness to forgive make him a bridge between family members. His journey is about learning to express his emotions, stand up for those he loves, and embrace the complexities of blended family life.
Alice
Alice is a complex figure—once a devoted mother, now consumed by jealousy and a sense of loss. Her attempts to sabotage Adrian and Leia's relationship stem from her inability to accept change and her fear of being replaced. Alice's actions cause pain, but they also force the family to confront their wounds and grow stronger. Her journey is a cautionary tale about the dangers of bitterness and the necessity of letting go.
Asha
Asha, Leia's older sister, is both nurturing and pragmatic. She runs a successful nanny agency and is fiercely protective of Leia, pushing her to pursue happiness and not settle for less. Asha's own struggles with marriage and motherhood inform her advice, and her unwavering support is a lifeline for Leia. She represents the importance of sibling bonds and the power of tough love.
Amara
Amara is Leia's confidante and cheerleader, unafraid to challenge her or push her out of her comfort zone. Her own journey to happiness inspires Leia, and her loyalty is unwavering. Amara's humor, insight, and willingness to intervene at critical moments make her an indispensable part of Leia's support system.
Akshay and Pooja Sital
Leia's parents embody the hopes and fears of first-generation immigrants—desiring success and stability for their children, but struggling to reconcile tradition with change. Their initial resistance to Adrian is rooted in love and fear, but through witnessing Leia's happiness and the family's resilience, they learn to embrace a new definition of family. Their journey is one of growth, humility, and the realization that love transcends boundaries.
Silas
Silas, Adrian's best friend, provides steady support and practical advice. His own experiences with love and loss mirror Adrian's, and his presence is a grounding force. Silas's loyalty and willingness to challenge Adrian help him navigate the complexities of love, fatherhood, and responsibility.
Lex Windsor
Lex, Leia's friend and confidant, offers humor and perspective. His platonic affection for Leia and his own struggles with family expectations provide a counterpoint to the main romance. Lex's presence highlights the importance of chosen family and the value of friendship in overcoming adversity.
Plot Devices
Dual Narration and Time Jumps
The novel employs a dual narrative structure, alternating between Leia and Adrian's points of view. This allows readers to experience the depth of each character's longing, regret, and hope. Time jumps—most notably the two-year gap after their first encounter—heighten the sense of missed opportunities and fate's intervention. The structure mirrors the characters' emotional journeys, emphasizing the impact of timing, choice, and circumstance.
Symbolism of Stars and Fantasy
The recurring motif of stargazing and fantasy roleplay serves as a metaphor for the characters' longing for a different life. The stars represent possibility, perspective, and the vastness of the unknown. Their shared fantasy of marriage and family becomes a touchstone, guiding them through hardship and reminding them of what's possible when they dare to hope.
Cultural Conflict and Reconciliation
The tension between tradition and modernity is a central plot device, driving conflict and character growth. Leia's Indian heritage and Adrian's Western background create obstacles, but also opportunities for understanding and transformation. The negotiation of cultural rituals, family expectations, and personal desires is handled with nuance, illustrating the challenges and rewards of blending worlds.
Foreshadowing and Parallelism
The novel uses foreshadowing and parallelism—such as the proposal under the stars mirroring their first night together—to create a sense of inevitability and closure. The repetition of key phrases, settings, and gestures reinforces the idea that some loves are destined, and that the past continually shapes the present.
External Antagonists and Internal Growth
The external threats—Alice's sabotage, professional scandal, family disapproval—serve to catalyze internal growth. Each challenge forces Leia and Adrian to confront their fears, insecurities, and priorities. The resolution of these conflicts is less about defeating an antagonist and more about choosing love, forgiveness, and self-acceptance.
Analysis
Professor Astor is a contemporary romance that transcends the boundaries of genre by weaving together themes of love, loss, cultural identity, and personal growth. At its core, the novel is a meditation on the power of vulnerability—the courage to hope for happiness even when life seems determined to deny it. Through Leia and Adrian's journey, Catharina Maura explores the complexities of blended families, the weight of tradition, and the resilience required to build a life on one's own terms. The story's emotional arc is marked by heartbreak and healing, betrayal and forgiveness, culminating in a celebration of love's ability to bridge divides—be they cultural, generational, or self-imposed. The novel's modern relevance lies in its honest portrayal of infertility, divorce, and the challenges faced by first-generation immigrants, offering readers both representation and hope. Ultimately, Professor Astor teaches that happiness is not a gift bestowed by fate, but a choice made daily, in defiance of fear and in pursuit of joy.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Professor Astor receives mixed reviews averaging 4.03 stars. Readers praise the Indian cultural representation, strong communication between characters, and the single-dad professor romance. However, many criticize the nickname "Thor" as overused and cringeworthy, the insta-love dynamic with "hubby/wifey" terminology, and weak character development. The student-teacher trope felt underutilized to some. Positive reviews highlight the lack of miscommunication, the protagonist's relationship with the twin children, and authentic desi culture portrayal. Critics found it boring, rushed, and poorly written.
