Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Punished by Rewards

Punished by Rewards

The Trouble with Gold Stars, Incentive Plans, A's, Praise and Other Bribes
Why rewards can weaken motivation, creativity, and trust, and what to build instead.
by Alfie Kohn 1993 398 pages
4.17
4k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Key Takeaways

Stop paying for behavior you want people to own

A lab in miniature. Kohn opens with college students training hungry rats to press a lever for cereal. He joked that the rats had trained the students to feed them, then questioned what this kind of experiment says about people. The everyday version, which he calls pop behaviorism, is the idea that people can be steered by promising something desirable for doing what someone else wants. The problem is not the cereal, money, or affection itself. It is making access to something conditional on compliance.

Compliance is not commitment. A child may tidy up for a treat, an employee may chase a bonus, and a student may read for a prize. Those actions show that incentives can change behavior in the moment. They do not show that the person has become responsible, curious, or committed to doing the task without payment.

Analysis

The rat story captures a central distinction between predicting behavior and understanding human agency. A lever press is an observable outcome; it says little about whether the learner understands a reason, endorses a goal, or would act similarly in a different setting. That distinction matters in modern organizations, where a metric can be optimized without improving the underlying work. The argument is strongest when incentives replace explanation and participation. It is less persuasive as a blanket objection to every external condition: fair pay, clear expectations, and immediate safety instructions are not all equivalent to bribery.

Use rewards cautiously: they can speed output while degrading thinking

Quantity is not quality. Research reviewed by Kohn suggests that rewards may increase output on simple, repetitive tasks, but often fail on work requiring judgment, learning, or creativity. In one experiment, students solving a candle-and-box problem took nearly 50 percent longer when promised money, especially when the solution was less obvious. Other studies found poorer creative work, less systematic problem-solving, and more errors among people expecting prizes.

A narrow target. Rewards encourage people to find the safest route to the payoff, not to explore the task. A student chasing points may pick an easier assignment; a worker paid for speed may prioritize volume over accuracy. Incentives can therefore improve what is counted while weakening qualities that are harder to count, including originality and careful thought.

Analysis

This is a useful warning against treating performance as one-dimensional. A faster answer, a larger count, or a higher score can coexist with weaker learning or quality. In measurement systems, the chosen indicator tends to draw attention toward itself, so the design question is not merely whether a reward works, but what behavior it makes easiest to optimize. Still, the evidence does not mean every incentive harms every task. The book itself recognizes that straightforward work may respond differently. The practical lesson is to identify the actual objective before selecting a motivator.

A promised prize can erase the pleasure it was meant to recruit

Motivation has different sources. Intrinsic motivation means doing an activity because it is satisfying or interesting in itself. Extrinsic motivation means doing it to obtain a separate payoff or avoid a penalty. Kohn argues that a promised reward can shift a person from the first kind toward the second, leaving the task less appealing once the reward disappears.

The interest cost. In a study, preschoolers who expected a special certificate for drawing later chose to draw less than children who had not been promised one. In another, children praised or given movie tickets for drinking a new yogurt beverage liked it less afterward than children who received no reward. The incentive succeeded at getting the immediate action, yet changed how the activity felt. A reading prize may produce more completed books while making reading itself feel like work.

Analysis

The argument draws attention to a subtle cost: rewards do not merely add a reason to act, they can change the perceived meaning of the activity. This resembles the way people distinguish an activity pursued for its own value from one used as a means to something else. It also helps explain why a short-term increase can be mistaken for durable motivation. The caveat is that interest fluctuates for many reasons, and a single reward does not determine a person's relationship to an activity forever. Kohn's case is about predictable risk, not automatic damage in every instance.

Build trust instead of making colleagues compete for scarce recognition

The carrot has a sharp edge. A reward is conditional: someone receives it only if another person decides the criteria were met. Missing an expected bonus can feel like a penalty, while winning a scarce award makes peers potential rivals. Kohn describes how competition for incentives can weaken cooperation, encourage suspicion, and make employees hide difficulties rather than ask for help.

Relationships affect results. A student rewarded for tutoring another child may begin to judge that child by how quickly the lesson helps secure the prize. Similar dynamics can emerge among coworkers when individual rankings determine who gets recognition. Groups may also turn on a classmate or colleague blamed for costing everyone a collective reward. These systems can produce compliance, but they make trust and shared problem-solving harder.

Analysis

The relational critique is especially important because many difficult tasks depend on people sharing incomplete information, admitting mistakes, and asking for assistance. A reward system that makes those actions risky can undermine the conditions for good performance. This is not simply a matter of morale: withholding information makes coordination less reliable. Yet collaboration should not be romanticized as effortless. Teams still need accountability, clear responsibilities, and ways to address poor contributions. The question is whether those processes help people solve problems together or turn evaluation into a contest for approval.

Give feedback that informs, not praise that recruits an audience

Approval can become leverage. Kohn does not argue that adults should stop expressing warmth or appreciation. He questions praise used as a deliberate tool to shape behavior. General compliments can make people dependent on another person's judgment, increase pressure to keep succeeding, or sound patronizing. Praise may also shift attention from the work to the evaluator's approval.

Make the response useful. A more constructive comment identifies what happened without issuing a broad verdict about the person. Instead of labeling someone a natural writer, a teacher might point to a detail in the story that changed its ending. Specific feedback helps the recipient assess the work against meaningful criteria. It can also be offered privately, without comparing one person with classmates or coworkers. The aim is not silence, but information and encouragement without turning approval into a prize.

Analysis

This distinction connects well to the difference between feedback that supports learning and evaluation that signals status. Specific information can help someone revise; a sweeping compliment may offer little guidance while making the evaluator's approval central. The advice also respects individual interpretation: the same comment can feel encouraging to one person and controlling to another. That makes attentive relationships more important than memorizing a script. A limitation is that even detailed feedback carries judgment, especially when delivered by someone with power. Tone, timing, and the recipient's freedom to respond matter.

Repair the work system before trying to bribe better performance

Look upstream. A bonus cannot fix a confusing job, inadequate training, weak communication, or a structure that prevents employees from acting on what they know. Kohn urges managers to investigate why performance is poor before offering incentives. Pay should be fair and adequate, but tying extra compensation to a manager's rating can direct attention toward pleasing the evaluator rather than improving the work.

The evidence is sobering. A review of 330 comparisons from 98 studies found no statistically significant overall productivity effect from financial incentives. The small studies that did show gains mostly measured short-term quantity on simple tasks, not quality. Kohn instead emphasizes work people can find worthwhile, supportive relationships among colleagues, and real discretion in how tasks are done. Incentives often serve as a substitute for this harder work of management.

Analysis

This argument shifts analysis from individual effort to system design, a move familiar in quality improvement: recurring failures may reflect the process that produces them, not a lack of motivation in the people inside it. It also clarifies that opposing incentive pay does not mean opposing compensation. Fair wages and performance-contingent bonuses are different policies with different meanings. The evidence on incentives is mixed across task types and measures, so the book's broad critique should not be mistaken for proof that money never affects behavior. Its more durable point is that pay cannot replace sound job design.

Reduce grades so students can focus on what they are learning

Grades redirect attention. Kohn argues that when students are preoccupied with marks, they focus on how well they appear to be doing rather than on what they are trying to understand. That performance focus encourages easier tasks, avoidance of mistakes, and studying for the test instead of building durable knowledge. An A can function as a reward; an F can function as a punishment.

Assessment can teach. Grades are also unreliable summaries: the same work may receive different marks from different evaluators, while a letter alone tells students little about what to improve. Kohn recommends replacing frequent grades with substantive comments, reducing rankings, and involving students in deciding what good work looks like. The goal is not to abandon standards. It is to make assessment serve revision and understanding rather than sorting students into winners and losers.

Analysis

The distinction between learning goals and performance goals is valuable because visible achievement can conceal shallow engagement. A student may collect excellent marks while avoiding intellectual risk, or earn a lower mark while making important progress. That does not make assessment unnecessary: students need evidence of what they understand and where they are stuck. The key design issue is whether assessment supplies usable information or mainly assigns status. Schools also face external demands, such as admissions and standardized reporting, so reducing grades requires alternatives that communicate learning clearly.

Respond to misbehavior by investigating its cause, not buying obedience

Behavior is a clue. A child who keeps leaving bed may be overtired, not tired enough, anxious, or seeking time with a parent. A student who avoids work may be confused or disengaged. Rewards and punishments can change what happens immediately without revealing which problem needs solving. They may secure obedience, but obedience is not the same as responsibility or care.

Work through the problem. Kohn recommends reconsidering whether a demand is reasonable, explaining why a necessary limit exists, listening to the child, and making a plan together. If a child hurts someone, repair and an honest discussion may teach more than isolation or loss of privileges. A child rewarded for generosity may learn to act generously when watched, but not to see helping as a personal value. The longer aim is thoughtful judgment, not merely fewer complaints from adults.

Analysis

This approach resembles functional assessment: before trying to suppress a behavior, ask what purpose it serves and what conditions sustain it. The shift matters because identical actions can have different causes, so a single consequence is unlikely to teach the right lesson in every case. Collaborative problem-solving also treats children as participants rather than objects to manage. The challenge is that adults often operate under time pressure, and some boundaries, especially around immediate safety, cannot wait for a full discussion. Firm limits can coexist with explanation, respect, and attention to the reason behind the behavior.

Offer real choices and teach people how to use them

Choice is a capacity. Kohn treats autonomy as more than picking between two options selected by someone else. People need meaningful influence over what they do and how they do it, along with the skills to make decisions responsibly. A classroom vote that adults can ignore, or a workplace suggestion scheme with no real authority, offers the appearance of choice without its substance.

Freedom needs structure. Students can choose among worthwhile projects, decide with peers how to investigate a question, or help establish classroom agreements. Employees can have discretion over methods and problem-solving. Children can help plan routines and work through conflicts. These practices require guidance, not abandonment. In a nursing-home study described by Kohn, residents given more say over aspects of daily life became more active and were more likely to survive the following 18 months. The principle is to share real decisions while supporting people as they learn to handle them.

Analysis

Autonomy matters here both instrumentally and ethically. It can improve engagement, but it also recognizes people as agents whose participation is valuable in itself. That dual purpose gives the argument force beyond productivity: a democratic classroom or workplace is not just a better device for extracting effort. At the same time, choice is not an all-purpose solution. Some decisions require expertise, and some constraints are unavoidable. The meaningful test is whether authority is explained, limited to what is necessary, and open to participation where people affected by the decision can contribute.

Analysis

Kohn's central contribution is to make the reward look less like a neutral tool and more like a relationship: one person sets terms, another performs, and the payoff carries a judgment about what counts. This reframing links psychology to education, management, and family life without claiming that every incentive has the same effect. His most persuasive evidence concerns tasks where quality depends on exploration, autonomy, or sustained interest. In these cases, rewards can change the goal from learning or craftsmanship to securing approval, and this altered goal helps explain poorer performance as well as weaker commitment.

The book also identifies a feedback loop in institutions. Adults assume people need incentives, build systems around incentives, and then interpret incentive-dependent behavior as proof of that assumption. Grades produce grade-focused students; pay plans encourage attention to compensation; controlling discipline can cultivate resistance or dependence. This is a powerful systems argument because it asks not only whether an intervention works, but what kind of person and relationship it creates.

There are limits to the case. The evidence summarized is varied, much of it experimental, and effects depend on task design, the salience of the reward, and the recipient's interpretation. Some repetitive work may respond to incentives in the short term, while some external requirements are unavoidable. Kohn's own distinction between fair compensation and pay-for-performance helps avoid a caricature, but his rhetoric can still make the boundary between supportive structure and control appear cleaner than real institutions allow.

The practical conclusion is not that adults should never set expectations or recognize effort. It is that they should stop mistaking observable compliance for durable motivation. When people struggle, examine the work, relationships, reasons, and available choices before escalating the incentive. The deeper standard is whether the arrangement develops competence and responsibility, rather than merely producing the desired action while someone is watching.

Summary in 30 Seconds
External rewards can raise output on simple tasks while reducing creativity, judgment, and lasting interest. In one review of 330 comparisons from 98 studies, financial incentives produced no significant overall productivity gain. Grades and praise can shift attention toward approval rather than learning. Better results come from fair pay, useful feedback, meaningful choice, supportive relationships, and investigating problems before offering prizes.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.17 out of 5
Average of 4k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Punished By Rewards challenges the effectiveness of rewards and praise in education, parenting, and the workplace. Kohn argues that extrinsic motivators undermine intrinsic motivation and creativity. Many readers found the book eye-opening and transformative, though some felt it was repetitive and lacked practical alternatives. The book's core message resonated with parents and educators, prompting them to reconsider their approaches. While some disagreed with certain points, most appreciated Kohn's well-researched arguments against behaviorism and the pervasive use of rewards in society.

Your rating:
4.57
594 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Glossary

Pop behaviorism

Behavior controlled by incentives

Kohn's term for the everyday belief that the reliable way to change someone's behavior is to promise a benefit for compliance or impose a cost for refusal. He distinguishes this popular practice from formal behaviorist research and argues that it can secure immediate action while neglecting motives, relationships, and lasting commitment.

Intrinsic motivation

Interest in the activity itself

The desire to engage in an activity because it is interesting or satisfying in its own right, rather than because it leads to a separate reward. Kohn treats intrinsic motivation as a key source of sustained engagement, learning, and quality, while recognizing that the concept is difficult to define and measure precisely.

Extrinsic motivation

Action for an external payoff

Motivation to do an activity in order to obtain something separate from the activity, such as money, grades, praise, or a privilege, or to avoid a penalty. Kohn argues that salient, expected rewards can redirect attention toward the payoff and weaken interest in the task itself.

Self-determination

A sense of chosen action

The experience of having meaningful influence over one's actions and decisions, rather than feeling directed or pressured by another person. In the book, self-determination supports intrinsic motivation and personal responsibility. It is fostered through real choices, respectful explanations, and opportunities to take part in decisions.

Introjection

Rules absorbed without examination

A form of internalization in which a person takes in a rule or expectation but does not fully examine or make it their own. The person may then feel pressured from within, much as they were pressured from outside. Kohn contrasts this with integration, where the person understands a value and endorses it with a sense of agency.

Integration

Values made personally one's own

A deeper form of internalization in which a person understands the reason for a value or rule and accepts it as consistent with their own considered commitments. In the book's account, integration differs from simply obeying or absorbing a rule. It depends on autonomy-supportive relationships and meaningful opportunities to reflect and choose.

Overjustification effect

Reward reduces later task interest

The finding that offering an expected external reward for an activity someone already finds appealing can reduce that person's later interest in doing the activity without the reward. Kohn reviews experiments involving children's drawing and other tasks, while noting that researchers debate the precise explanation and measurement of the effect.

FAQ

What's Punished by Rewards about?

  • Critique of Behaviorism: Punished by Rewards by Alfie Kohn critiques the use of rewards, such as grades and praise, as motivators in education, parenting, and the workplace. Kohn argues that these practices undermine intrinsic motivation and can lead to negative outcomes.
  • Focus on Intrinsic Motivation: The book emphasizes the importance of fostering intrinsic motivation, which is the natural desire to learn and engage in activities for their own sake. Kohn believes that rewards can diminish this motivation, leading to a lack of genuine interest in tasks.
  • Real-World Implications: Kohn discusses how the reliance on rewards affects relationships, learning, and performance, ultimately suggesting that a shift away from behaviorist practices is necessary for true engagement and success.

Why should I read Punished by Rewards?

  • Challenging Conventional Wisdom: The book challenges widely accepted beliefs about motivation, making it essential for educators, parents, and managers who want to understand the deeper implications of their practices.
  • Evidence-Based Arguments: Kohn supports his claims with extensive research and examples, providing readers with a well-rounded understanding of the negative effects of rewards.
  • Practical Alternatives: The book offers alternatives to reward-based systems, encouraging readers to adopt strategies that promote intrinsic motivation and healthier relationships.

What are the key takeaways of Punished by Rewards?

  • Rewards Undermine Motivation: Kohn argues that rewards can diminish a person's natural interest in an activity, leading to a cycle of dependency on external validation.
  • Control and Compliance: The use of rewards is fundamentally controlling, which can lead to resentment and a lack of genuine engagement.
  • Focus on Relationships: Building genuine relationships based on trust and respect is more effective than using rewards to elicit compliance.

What are the best quotes from Punished by Rewards and what do they mean?

  • "Do this and you'll get that.": This phrase encapsulates the behaviorist approach to motivation, suggesting that people will only engage in tasks for the sake of rewards. Kohn argues that this mindset undermines intrinsic motivation.
  • "Rewards punish.": Kohn highlights the paradox that rewards, while intended to motivate, can actually lead to feelings of resentment and control.
  • "Children have an intrinsic desire to learn.": This statement reinforces Kohn's belief that learning should be driven by curiosity and interest rather than external incentives.

How does Alfie Kohn define intrinsic motivation in Punished by Rewards?

  • Natural Desire to Learn: Kohn describes intrinsic motivation as the inherent drive to engage in activities for their own sake, without the need for external rewards.
  • Contrast with Extrinsic Motivation: He contrasts intrinsic motivation with extrinsic motivation, which relies on external rewards to encourage behavior.
  • Importance of Autonomy: Kohn emphasizes that fostering an environment where individuals feel autonomous and self-directed is crucial for maintaining intrinsic motivation.

What are the negative effects of rewards according to Punished by Rewards?

  • Diminished Interest: Kohn argues that rewards can lead to a decrease in interest in the task itself, as individuals begin to focus on the reward rather than the activity.
  • Reduced Quality of Work: The emphasis on rewards can lead to a decline in the quality of work, as individuals may choose easier tasks to secure the reward.
  • Strained Relationships: The use of rewards can create tension and competition among peers, undermining collaboration and trust.

How does Alfie Kohn suggest we motivate children without using rewards?

  • Foster Intrinsic Motivation: Kohn advocates for creating environments that nurture children's natural curiosity and desire to learn.
  • Encourage Autonomy: Providing children with choices and opportunities for self-directed learning can help maintain their intrinsic motivation.
  • Focus on Meaningful Learning: Kohn encourages educators and parents to emphasize the value of learning for its own sake, rather than framing it as a means to an end.

What alternatives to rewards does Alfie Kohn propose in Punished by Rewards?

  • Informational Feedback: Kohn suggests providing constructive feedback that focuses on the quality of work rather than using praise as a reward.
  • Collaborative Learning: Encouraging teamwork and collaboration can foster a sense of community and shared responsibility, reducing the need for competition.
  • Emphasizing Process Over Product: Kohn advocates for valuing the learning process itself rather than the end result.

How does Alfie Kohn address the use of praise in Punished by Rewards?

  • Praise as a Controlling Mechanism: Kohn argues that praise can be just as controlling as tangible rewards, leading to dependency on external validation.
  • Negative Impact on Self-Esteem: While praise is often intended to boost self-esteem, Kohn suggests that it can have the opposite effect by making individuals feel judged.
  • Encouragement Over Praise: Kohn advocates for using encouragement and constructive feedback instead of praise.

What does Alfie Kohn say about the relationship between rewards and creativity in Punished by Rewards?

  • Rewards Kill Creativity: Kohn argues that rewards can stifle creativity by narrowing focus and discouraging risk-taking.
  • Extrinsic Motivation Limits Exploration: When individuals are motivated by rewards, they are less likely to explore new ideas and take creative risks.
  • Intrinsic Motivation Fuels Creativity: Kohn believes that intrinsic motivation is crucial for creativity, as it encourages individuals to engage deeply with their work.

How can educators foster intrinsic motivation according to Punished by Rewards?

  • Encourage Autonomy: Kohn emphasizes the importance of providing students with choices and control over their learning.
  • Create Meaningful Learning Experiences: The book advocates for designing lessons that are relevant and engaging to students.
  • Focus on Mastery and Understanding: Kohn encourages educators to prioritize mastery and understanding over grades and performance metrics.

How does Alfie Kohn suggest we address behavioral issues without using rewards or punishments in Punished by Rewards?

  • Mutual Problem Solving: Kohn advocates for a collaborative approach to addressing behavioral issues, where adults and children work together to find solutions.
  • Focus on Communication: The book highlights the need for open communication between adults and children.
  • Encourage Responsibility: Kohn suggests that children should be given opportunities to take responsibility for their actions.

About the Author

Alfie Kohn is a prominent author, speaker, and critic of traditional education and parenting practices. He has written fourteen books and numerous articles on human behavior, education, and parenting. Kohn is known for his controversial views on competition and rewards, arguing against their effectiveness in motivating and teaching children. His work has been widely discussed and debated in academic and popular circles. Time magazine described him as a leading critic of education's focus on grades and test scores. Kohn lives near Boston with his family and maintains an active online presence through his website.

Download PDF

To save this Punished by Rewards summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.30 MB     Pages: 20

Download EPUB

To read this Punished by Rewards summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.46 MB     Pages: 25
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...