Plot Summary
A Fake Date, A Real Past
Sports publicist Madison Westfield poses as the girlfriend of A.J. Bernard, her longtime friend, hoping to shield him from her powerful father’s retaliation after A.J. explores leaving Chicago. She is also starting over: a planned Colorado PR resort collapsed, so she accepts a job with Cincinnati’s Queen City Chaos, where her brother Easton plays.
The new quarterback is not the promising rookie she expected. It is Quentin Undergrove, her former fiancé, who vanished from her life ten years ago. Quentin has left Pittsburgh for a chance to play under his uncle, the Chaos’s new coach, and quietly hopes Madison will help repair his hostile public image. She has no idea he is coming until she sees him on the practice field.
The Tire Beside the Field
At practice, Madison’s first instinct is to protect Easton, who resents Quentin and his uncle’s influence over the team. Quentin’s uncle, Coach David Undergrove, warns him not to provoke Easton, while Quentin makes clear that he still wants Madison close. The Chaos’s marketing director then assigns her to manage Quentin full time, asking her to soften his reputation and help him win over Cincinnati.
After their first sharp confrontation, Madison finds a flat tire in the parking lot. Quentin changes it despite her protests, then takes her to dinner. Their banter slips toward familiarity, but Madison keeps reminding herself that he is both her client and the man who once left her without explanation.
Flowers for a Lost Crush
Madison builds Quentin a strict image plan: community events, better social media, new friendships, and dates that might make him seem settled. When she mentions that her brother Tobias and his friend Xander are marrying, Quentin sends her armfuls of flowers and a freezer full of ice cream as mock condolences for her former crush on Xander.
The gesture draws out a story she rarely tells. At nineteen, Madison shared a room with Quentin at her family’s mountain house, confided in him about Xander, and unexpectedly fell for the attentive young quarterback.
Her friend Bea arrives to help with the PR work and sees that Quentin’s teasing has revived more than professional friction. Madison insists the past is over, but cannot make the claim feel true.
Austen Behind the Shirts
Madison arranges a date with a local charity organizer, but Quentin’s attempt to explain the PR setup leaves the woman feeling deceived. He brings the untouched dessert to Madison instead, and their reminiscences about the mountain summer turn intimate.
As his publicist, Madison also joins him on a house search and directs a staged photo session for sponsors. She catches sight of well-worn Jane Austen novels hidden behind his shirts.
Quentin explains that he began reading Madison’s favorites after she told him about them, using the books to feel near her while they were apart. Later, he massages her aching shoulders and admits he still thinks about their first summer together. Madison leaves before the attraction can overrule her professional boundaries.
The Kiss at West Field
At the opening of Easton and his wife Wren’s restaurant, Quentin behaves like the local star Madison is trying to create, signing autographs and charming the guests. When the two end up alone in a back hallway, he kisses her, and she responds before Wren and Fiona interrupt them. Wren challenges Madison to admit what she wants instead of hiding behind work.
Later, Quentin presses her to say whether she loves A.J. Madison finally confesses that their public relationship is fabricated to deter her father from punishing A.J. for considering another team. She and Quentin agree to keep their renewed intimacy secret, since he is her client and she fears the damage a workplace scandal could do to her career.
The Rules Give Way
Madison and Quentin begin a secret affair, initially treating sex as a way to satisfy their attraction without promising a future. Madison sets the terms, even tying Quentin to the bed so she can test whether he will surrender control. Their reunion awakens the tenderness she has tried to bury, and Easton notices that she spent the night at Quentin’s home.
He warns her that their father’s old feud could hurt them both, but Madison defends Quentin and reveals that A.J. is not truly her partner. Meanwhile, Bea shows Madison the Virginia property she hopes to turn into a retreat for athletes and public figures in crisis. When Bea asks Quentin to invest, he offers to fund the entire purchase, but asks to tell Madison himself.
The Price of Leaving
Before Madison can decide whether to leave Cincinnati for the Virginia retreat, Quentin tells her what happened after their mountain summer. His father returned from prison and drew Quentin into a painful attempt at reconciliation.
When that relationship collapsed, Quentin spiraled, missed classes and practices, and lost his chance to play. Madison’s father, Kenneth Westfield, offered him a transfer and another shot at football on the condition that he stay away from Madison.
Kenneth threatened to cut Madison off from her family and education if she chose Quentin, and Quentin, ashamed and convinced he would ruin her life, accepted the deal without letting her decide for herself. Madison is devastated that he kept the truth from her, but recognizes the fear and desperation behind his choice. She tells him she still loves him, though she needs time.
Old Friends in Seattle
In Seattle for a sponsor photo shoot, Quentin meets Madison’s friends, including Nick, whose easy flirtation with her makes Quentin jealous. He lets that jealousy disrupt the work, and Madison reminds him that he must trust her judgment if he wants her to manage his public image.
The visit also brings Quentin face to face with Tobias and Xander, his former college friends who stopped speaking to him after he abandoned Madison. Tobias hears the full story of Kenneth’s threats and agrees to speak with him again.
Xander learns that Madison has forgiven Quentin and, after a guarded start, begins to welcome him back into their circle. The old friendships do not instantly return to what they were, but Quentin is no longer facing the Westfields alone.
Lucky Number Thirteen
Before the Chaos home opener, Quentin gives Madison a check for the full funding Bea needs for the retreat, hoping to support the dream that may take her away. The crowd instead gives him a loud welcome, and his first game confirms that Madison’s campaign has helped fans see him as their quarterback.
During the game, news breaks that A.J. has reconciled with his ex-wife, Maya, ending Madison’s need to pose as his girlfriend. Madison and Bea decide they do not want to move to Virginia after all.
They will stay in Cincinnati and build a PR firm together, with Cooper Rawlings among their early investors. Madison returns Quentin’s check rather than take money that would tie her to a plan she no longer wants. She and Quentin can now imagine a future in the same city.
Kenneth Crashes Dinner
At a dinner at Easton and Wren’s home, Kenneth and Madison’s mother arrive uninvited. Quentin and Madison have been keeping their relationship quiet, but they return from a walk with Easton laughing together, and Quentin kisses Madison before noticing her father in the hall.
Kenneth attacks Quentin as beneath his daughter and boasts that he bought him off a decade earlier, confirming the secret Quentin had just explained privately. Tobias arrives and is furious, but Madison asks him to listen before condemning Quentin.
She also clarifies that A.J. was never a real romantic partner. Kenneth leaves without softening, and the family closes ranks around Madison and Quentin. What had been a private old wound is now an open challenge to Kenneth’s authority over his children.
The Hits Keep Coming
At the next game, Kenneth’s Blaze defense repeatedly hits Quentin, escalating from hard tackles to dangerous late blows that the officials ignore. Madison realizes her father is using the game to damage Quentin’s career, not simply to win.
She confronts Kenneth at halftime and warns him to stop, but he denies wrongdoing and threatens to destroy Quentin. On the field, Easton loses control when he sees Quentin take another brutal hit. He charges toward the Blaze sideline, confronts their father, and is ejected for unsportsmanlike conduct.
Madison leaves the stands to check on Easton while Bea and Wren watch Quentin’s evaluation. In the locker room, Easton admits he acted out of years of anger at Kenneth’s treatment of the family, and Madison promises she will not let their father’s actions go unanswered.
A Case Against the Coach
After the game, Madison, Easton, and Tobias weigh how to challenge Kenneth without letting him dismiss them as spiteful children. They plan to review game footage, document the ignored penalties, and ask A.J. whether he witnessed suspicious treatment of his own team.
Quentin tells them they need not risk themselves for him, but Madison sees the incident as part of a larger pattern of abuse. Easton later reveals that Liam Montgomery, the Blaze offensive coordinator, may have evidence of Kenneth’s misconduct, including improper payments and pressure on staff and officials.
He has not yet taken it to the league, but the family now has reason to believe Kenneth’s power rests on more than reputation. The investigation could protect future players, though exposing it will intensify the conflict.
The House He Saved
Quentin takes Madison to a renovated Cincinnati house whose details match the home she once described wanting: a character-filled exterior, a welcoming kitchen, Austen-like stained glass, and closets designed for two.
He has bought and restored it while waiting to learn whether she still wanted that life with him. In a private sitting room, he proposes with a simple ring engraved with a reference to her favorite Austen novel. Madison accepts, and they marry two days later at the courthouse, surrounded in person by Easton, Wren, Bea, Cooper, and Coach David, with their Seattle friends joining by video.
The ceremony is small because football season cannot wait, but the choice is not small. Madison and Quentin make public the commitment they once lost to Kenneth’s interference.
No More Westfield Bargain
Soon after the wedding, Kenneth appears at Quentin and Madison’s apartment and tries to shame her for marrying him. Madison stands beside her husband, tells her father she is done being controlled, and refuses to let Quentin take the bait when Kenneth insults him. The next day, Easton shares what Liam has gathered: evidence of player manipulation, hidden bonuses, referee kickbacks, and threats against coaches.
The family prepares for a league investigation, knowing that Kenneth’s influence may make accountability difficult. Madison leans on Bea rather than carrying the crisis alone, while she and Quentin begin building their life together. Their conflict with Kenneth is not yet settled, but his private power is no longer unquestioned.
Epilogue
Madison, Bea, and their new assistant, Penny, are running a busy Cincinnati PR firm while developing plans for the athlete retreat they once hoped to build in Virginia. The league has suspended Kenneth pending an investigation, and Liam has taken over the Blaze while the accusations are reviewed. At home, Quentin texts Madison about dinner and the cookie dough ice cream he has bought for her.
Their marriage has settled into daily rituals, but they are still planning a larger celebration for the friends who could not attend the courthouse wedding. Madison is no longer waiting for life to become safe before she enjoys it. She and Quentin are making a future while the family reckoning continues.
The ending gives Madison two kinds of resolution without pretending that one cancels the other. Her father’s suspension signals institutional consequences, but the investigation remains open, so justice is still a process rather than a finished verdict. At the same time, Madison’s work and marriage no longer wait on Kenneth’s approval. The small domestic exchange about dinner and ice cream matters because it contrasts with the grand public machinery of football, reputation, and scandal. The lovers’ repaired bond is expressed through ordinary care, while the firm and retreat plans give Madison a professional future she chose for herself. Romance becomes part of a life she is building, not a substitute for it.
Analysis
Rival Hearts links romantic repair to the problem of who gets to make decisions for other people. Quentin’s original disappearance looks like abandonment to Madison because it is abandonment in practice, even though he believes he is sacrificing himself for her. Kenneth exploits Quentin’s economic insecurity and Madison’s dependence on family resources, converting protection into control. The story’s moral pressure comes from the difference between intending to spare someone pain and allowing them the agency to choose their own risk. Quentin’s later honesty cannot undo the years he withheld, but it gives Madison the information necessary to forgive without pretending the injury never happened.
Madison’s public relations work offers a second version of this question. She knows how to shape an image, but Quentin’s campaign only succeeds when the person beneath the image participates. His community appearances and new friendships matter because they are actions, not manufactured slogans. The novel distinguishes reputation repair from deception: public perception can be guided, but lasting trust requires conduct that survives scrutiny. Madison’s own fake relationship with A.J. is a strategic performance, yet it also reveals how readily she uses other people’s needs to avoid confronting her own.
Football functions as both livelihood and family inheritance. Kenneth treats the game as a system through which he can extend his authority; Easton and Quentin experience it as a workplace where skill and safety should matter more than a coach’s grudges. The violent game makes that conflict visible in bodies, penalties, and consequences. The league’s later investigation broadens the story from romantic reconciliation to institutional accountability, while leaving its outcome unresolved at the close.
The ending refuses to make love a rescue that cancels every other ambition. Madison and Quentin marry, but Madison also builds a firm with Bea, maintains friendships, and confronts her father on her own terms. Their domestic tenderness is meaningful because it follows a choice, not an escape from choice. The book’s strongest promise is not that old wounds vanish. It is that people can stop repeating the structures that made those wounds possible.
People Also Read
Characters
Madison Westfield
Guarded career fixerMadison is a gifted sports publicist, the daughter of influential football coach Kenneth Westfield, and sister to Tobias and Easton. She is accustomed to anticipating other people’s crises and managing the consequences before they arrive. That competence gives her control, but it also lets her postpone her own needs and treat vulnerability as a practical liability. Her ambition is not simply to succeed in football publicity. She wants to build work that helps people recover from public crises without being swallowed by them. Madison’s history with Quentin makes her sharper and less trusting around him, while her loyalty to family and friends repeatedly tests the boundaries she tries to set. Her central tension is between taking responsibility for everyone and allowing herself to choose a life of her own.
Quentin Undergrove
The returning quarterbackQuentin is a veteran quarterback whose move from Pittsburgh to Cincinnati makes him an unpopular outsider before he takes a snap. He is Coach David Undergrove’s nephew and grew up amid parental abandonment, which left him wary of depending on anyone. Beneath his rough public image is a thoughtful man who remembers intimate details, reads Madison’s favorite novels, and tries to repair harm through concrete acts. His past choices show how shame can disguise itself as sacrifice: he believed disappearing would protect Madison, though he denied her the right to choose. He is ambitious about football, but his deeper desire is to belong somewhere and be trusted there. Madison’s return forces him to pursue both goals through patience rather than escape.
Kenneth Westfield
The controlling coachKenneth is Madison, Tobias, and Easton’s father, a powerful football coach accustomed to treating family and players as parts of a larger legacy. He prizes control, public standing, and performance, often mistaking obedience for loyalty. His children’s careers give him influence over their lives, and he is quick to use that influence when he feels challenged. Kenneth can present his decisions as protection or strategy, but his need to dictate outcomes leaves little room for his children’s separate identities. His relationship with Madison is especially tense because she is both professionally capable and increasingly unwilling to accept his version of what is best for her.
Easton Westfield
Protective tight endEaston is Madison’s younger brother and a tight end for the Chaos. He is warm, generous, and well liked, but his gentleness should not be mistaken for passivity. His new coach’s connection to the Undergrove family makes him wary, especially because he has spent years watching his father use football to control the Westfields. Easton’s loyalty to Wren and Madison gives him a strong protective streak, and that same instinct can push him toward reckless confrontation. He wants to be judged by his play and character, not treated as a pawn in a family feud. His growing professional relationship with Quentin tests whether he can separate the quarterback from the uncle who coaches them both.
Tobias Westfield
Madison’s watchful brotherTobias is Madison’s older brother, a professional football player and one of Quentin’s former college friends. Protective of Madison, he has never forgotten how Quentin’s disappearance hurt her, and his anger is sharpened by the guilt of having once trusted Quentin. He is also capable of revising his judgment when he learns what Kenneth concealed. Tobias’s commitment to his fiancée Scarlett and his desire to protect his siblings give him a steadier perspective than his father’s version of family loyalty.
Beatrix Xavier
Madison’s trusted co-strategistBea is Madison’s closest friend, fellow publicist, and partner in a long-planned business venture. She brings strategic calm to Madison’s fast-moving instincts and is willing to step into difficult client work when Madison needs support. Her ambitions are tied to helping people rebuild after public crises, not just restoring their market value. Bea is observant about Madison’s feelings but does not try to make decisions for her. Her history with Cooper and his brother Rob complicates the boundaries of their shared professional and personal circle.
A.J. Bernard
Madison’s football allyA.J. is a celebrated quarterback, Madison’s longtime friend, and the former husband of Maya. His divorce and devotion to football have strained his family life, even as he remains a caring father to their daughters. A.J. trusts Madison with both professional advice and personal worries, and their friendship gives them a reason to help each other navigate the public gaze. He is a contrast to Quentin in temperament: polished and widely liked, but no less vulnerable to the demands of football and family.
Wren Westfield
Easton’s grounded partnerWren is Easton’s wife, a business owner who helps run West Field and knows when Madison is hiding behind work. Practical and affectionate, she supports Madison without letting her evade difficult questions. Wren’s relationship with Easton offers Madison an example of a partnership built through trust and daily effort. She is also willing to stand up to Kenneth when his behavior threatens her family.
Xander Xavier
The old college friendXander is Tobias’s close friend, a professional football player, and Bea’s brother. Madison once had a long-standing crush on him, and Quentin’s involvement with her helped fracture their friendship. Xander is protective of the people he loves and slow to forgive a serious injury to someone in his circle. His loyalty can make him formidable, but it also reflects a strong sense of responsibility. He is engaged to Harper and shares a history with Quentin that predates the family conflict.
Coach David Undergrove
Quentin’s demanding uncleDavid is Quentin’s uncle and the Chaos’s head coach. He and Kenneth have a long rivalry rooted in their playing careers and competing ideas about football. David took Quentin in as a teenager and remains both a source of family belonging and a demanding authority figure. He believes in Quentin’s ability, but expresses that belief through pressure and high expectations. His coaching choices shape the tension between Quentin and Easton.
Cooper Rawlings
A teammate with a daughterCooper is Quentin’s teammate, a friend who reaches out when Quentin arrives in Cincinnati, and a devoted father to his daughter Lizzy. He is blunt, gruff, and more emotionally perceptive than his manner suggests. His co-parenting relationship with Lizzy’s mother is an important part of his life, and his history with Bea’s former partner makes their closeness complicated. Cooper values loyalty and family, but is still working out how much room he can make for a new relationship.
Scarlett Westfield
Tobias’s perceptive fiancéeScarlett is Tobias’s fiancée and a close friend to Madison. She helps create a welcoming space for Madison in Seattle and understands how family conflict can strain romantic relationships. Her calmness and direct care make her a dependable ally, particularly when the Westfields’ conflicts reach their wider circle.
Maya
A.J.’s former wifeMaya is A.J.’s ex-wife and the mother of their daughters. Their divorce followed years of strain caused in part by A.J.’s intense commitment to football. Though she keeps much of her private life separate from him, her choices continue to shape A.J.’s hopes and his efforts to become a more present father.
Fiona
A local charity leaderFiona is a local community figure whom Madison considers as a possible match for Quentin. She is warm, socially connected, and genuinely interested in him, making the publicity setup more complicated than Madison expects.
Elaina Undergrove
Quentin’s devoted auntElaina is David’s wife and the aunt who helped raise Quentin after his mother left him in their care. Her affection gives Quentin a rare sense of stability, and she treats him as family rather than an obligation.
Liam Montgomery
The Blaze’s tactical coordinatorLiam is the Blaze’s offensive coordinator and a friend of Easton’s from college. A former quarterback, he studies the game obsessively and thinks in detail about how each decision affects a team. His position gives him a close view of the coaching culture around Kenneth, and his sense of professional responsibility weighs against the personal risks of speaking up.
Nick
Madison’s flirtatious friendNick is a Seattle Phantom long snapper and a friend of Madison’s. A former Ivy League player, he is sociable and affectionate with the people around him. His attention toward Madison exposes Quentin’s jealousy and tests whether Quentin can trust her rather than compete for control.
Joss Marks-St. George
The photographer friendJoss is a photographer and a friend of Madison’s who creates sponsor content for Quentin. She is perceptive about the chemistry between them and comfortable teasing Madison about it. Her home and professional network help make the Seattle shoot both useful and emotionally revealing.
Lizzy Rawlings
Cooper’s beloved daughterLizzy is Cooper’s young daughter. She is close to Bea and helps explain why Cooper values Bea’s presence in his home. Her needs keep Cooper’s decisions grounded in the daily responsibilities of fatherhood.
Plot Devices
The Public Girlfriend Arrangement
A shield against KennethMadison and A.J. present themselves as a couple to discourage Kenneth from punishing A.J. for exploring a move away from his team. The arrangement also lets Madison appear unavailable to players who treat her family connections as an opportunity. It creates a public misunderstanding around her relationship with Quentin and gives both of them an excuse to avoid naming their feelings. Once A.J.’s own family situation changes, the cover becomes unnecessary, clearing a path for Madison to choose a relationship openly.
Madison’s PR Plan
A career built through visibilityMadison’s lists and campaigns translate Quentin’s private qualities into public evidence. She manages his social accounts, arranges community appearances, coaches him through sponsorships, and introduces him to teammates and local supporters. The work is not merely cosmetic: Quentin has to show up, cooperate, and build actual relationships for the image to hold. Because Madison is also his former fiancée, each professional task becomes a test of whether she can trust him. The campaign’s success gives the fans a reason to welcome him, while its intimacy brings their old connection back into daily life.
The Austen Books
A private record of longingQuentin keeps the Jane Austen novels Madison once named as her favorites. His private reading becomes evidence that he carried her with him through their years apart, even when he did not contact her. The books join the romance’s central contrast between outward silence and inward attachment: Madison believes she was forgotten, while Quentin quietly preserves a small ritual of closeness. Their importance returns when Quentin chooses a home and proposes in a setting that reflects Madison’s tastes, turning remembered preferences into a concrete promise rather than a vague declaration.
The Westfield Football Feud
Family conflict made publicKenneth and David’s rivalry begins in their playing careers and carries into coaching, affecting Quentin’s arrival and Easton’s place on the Chaos. Kenneth’s influence over players, staff, and the public image of football allows a private family conflict to become a professional threat. The feud is also the mechanism through which Kenneth once separated Quentin and Madison. When he later turns the Blaze’s play against Quentin, the conflict moves from memory into immediate physical danger, prompting the family to seek evidence and formal accountability.
The PR Retreat
A future beyond crisisMadison and Bea imagine a retreat where athletes and public figures can step away from scrutiny, recover their footing, and plan a response to scandal, injury, or personal upheaval. The idea grows from Madison’s experience helping Tobias through public trouble and from her professional knowledge of image repair. Their search for property and investors gives Madison a goal outside her family’s football world. When Quentin offers substantial funding, Madison has to distinguish support from obligation and decide what kind of future she wants. The venture ultimately points toward a Cincinnati based business rather than an immediate move away.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.