Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Scarred Regrets

Scarred Regrets

A mafia enforcer falls for a judge’s daughter targeted by rivals; can love survive his violence?
by Adelaide Forrest 2021 484 pages
4.11
3k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

A Door Without a Lock

Seven-year-old Paolo shields his sister from abuse

At seven, Paolo De Luca has learned to read danger in footsteps and keep scraps of food for his little sister, Francesca. Their parents leave them in the care of Brad, a police officer who abuses Paolo while the adults around them look away. Paolo gives Francesca a green butterfly pendant and teaches her how to escape through their bedroom window if he cannot protect her.

One morning, he finds both parents dead, then sees Brad arrive without surprise. Paolo gets Francesca out through the window and runs with her into the city. The siblings cannot trust the police, so Paolo becomes her shelter, scavenging food and finding places to sleep while promising himself he will keep her safe.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Paolo’s childhood turns care into a survival skill. The butterfly is not simply a pretty object: it gives Francesca a small possession untouched by the adults’ corruption, while the secret knocks and escape route make protection a daily practice. Paolo’s promise to keep her safe also creates a trap for him. He measures his worth by whether harm reaches Francesca, so any failure will become more than grief. The adults’ indifference matters as much as Brad’s violence; the children are abandoned not only by their parents but by the systems meant to protect them.

The Empty Front Door

Irina learns love can vanish without warning

At ten, Irina Ryan wants to help her father, Ed, with his charitable work at Fresh Start, the children’s center he funds. Her mother, Maya, instead insists that Irina learn the polished, ornamental role expected of a judge’s daughter. During an argument, Ed and Maya expose the bitterness beneath their marriage, and Maya leaves the house with her security guard.

She does not return that night, then disappears from Irina’s life. Ed interprets his daughter’s grief and volatile moods as evidence that something is wrong with her, and sends her to therapy. Irina absorbs the judgment as a verdict on her character. Sleep becomes refuge from feelings she cannot manage, and she grows up unsure whether her emotional needs are legitimate.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Irina’s early wound is not only abandonment; it is the uncertainty surrounding it. Maya’s affection depends on whether Irina performs the daughter she wants, while Ed’s protection can feel like another form of control. The child is caught between adults who make decisions about her identity instead of asking what she wants. Therapy offers support, but her father’s language risks turning distress into defect. This history clarifies why Irina later works so fiercely for children whose needs adults dismiss, and why rejection can feel to her like proof that she was never worth staying for.

The Butterfly Turns Red

Francesca’s overdose sends Paolo toward the Bellandis

Years on the streets, Paolo earns money through dangerous errands and protects Francesca as best he can. After five men assault them, he carries the guilt of failing to shield her, even though he was badly outnumbered.

Later, he finds her unconscious beside a syringe and discovers she has no pulse. Grief turns immediately to vengeance: Paolo tracks down the dealer who supplied her heroin and stabs him, then attacks another man before Bellandi enforcers overpower him.

Franco Bellandi recognizes the boy’s fighting instinct and offers him a place in the crime family, with training in exchange for service. Paolo insists on keeping a list of people connected to Francesca’s suffering. Franco gives him a new name, Scar, and a purpose built around revenge.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Francesca’s death converts Paolo’s protective identity into a weapon. He cannot save the person he loves, so he seeks a system that can punish those he believes responsible. Franco offers structure, training, and belonging, but the bargain reinforces Paolo’s conviction that usefulness is the price of being kept. The list gives grief an apparent direction, allowing him to postpone the helplessness of mourning. Naming him Scar makes injury into identity: the visible marks of his past become the role through which he can act, while the boy beneath them remains convinced that tenderness only invites loss.

A Stranger at Indulgence

A grieving advocate catches Scar’s attention

As an adult, Irina runs Fresh Start, matching vulnerable children with homes and support. When fifteen-year-old Zachariah is found dead after the center failed to protect him from the city’s drug trade, Irina drinks alone at Indulgence, grieving another child she could not save. Scar approaches her, and their attraction is immediate, but her touch makes him recoil.

He flees when she kisses him, then uses her license plate to learn her identity. Discovering that she is Judge Ryan’s daughter, he also recognizes Maya Regas in her face. Maya is already dead, and Scar was the one who killed her. He begins watching Irina from a distance, unable to reconcile the woman who nurtures children with the daughter of a name on his list.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Their first meeting joins two forms of grief: Irina’s responsibility for children in a city that keeps taking them, and Scar’s private history of violence and loss. Attraction does not smooth over their injuries; it exposes them. Her touch triggers his body before he can choose how to respond, while his retreat gives shape to her familiar fear of being unwanted. His investigation turns desire into surveillance, a method of closeness that preserves distance and control. The concealed fact about Maya makes his attraction ethically unstable from the start, even as Irina’s public work challenges the contempt he initially directs toward her.

The Scars Beneath Silk

Irina’s self-harm reveals what Scar cannot touch

Ivory, Scar’s friend and bodyguard charge, arranges a lunch that brings him back to Fresh Start. He watches Irina work among the children, then begins following her home at night, insisting to himself that he is keeping her safe. When she invites him inside and undresses, he sees the scars on her thighs and demands to know who caused them.

Irina admits she made them herself to feel something through her numbness. Scar turns their encounter into a controlled sexual exchange and tells her to come to him rather than hurt herself. The next day, however, he publicly dismisses her at the gym, and Irina takes sleeping pills and cuts herself. Scar finds her unconscious, stays until she wakes, and admits that loving her is what he fears most.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The intimacy here is built through control, but it does not erase the danger of control. Irina’s self-harm is an attempt to regulate unbearable emotional numbness, not an invitation for another person to take ownership of her pain. Scar recognizes the impulse because he also uses physical pain to quiet his mind, yet his response makes desire and care difficult to separate. His public rejection then repeats the abandonment Irina fears, and her self-injury makes that consequence unmistakable. The episode establishes that attraction alone cannot make them safe; each must learn to distinguish chosen intensity from the harm they already know.

Grant’s Almost Claim

Scar’s jealousy turns desire into damage

Irina’s childhood friend Grant Dumas returns to Chicago and offers the steadiness Scar refuses to promise. Scar interrupts their closeness, then warns Grant away and beats him when he will not withdraw.

Irina confronts Scar, but he answers her anger with possessive attention, and their attraction becomes a cycle of sex, rejection, and pursuit. When she prepares to spend an anniversary of her mother’s disappearance with Grant, Scar tells her not to go, then takes her home and leaves after rough sex, convinced she deserves better.

For six months, Irina dances at Indulgence to provoke him but never leaves with another man. One night, when she is drunk and nearly accepts a stranger’s offer, Scar intervenes and carries her to a hotel, still unable to admit what she means to him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Grant represents emotional continuity: he has known Irina long enough to recognize her grief and does not need danger to feel close to her. Scar’s response is to control access rather than speak honestly, converting fear of loss into aggression. Irina’s dancing is not simple flirtation; it is a test of whether Scar will choose her when she stops making the choice easy. His repeated interventions keep her near him while withholding commitment, reproducing the uncertainty that already destabilizes her. Their chemistry is real, but the section makes clear that possession without trust can become another form of abandonment.

Four Guns at Home

Murphy’s men kill Bryan and seize Irina

A year later, Irina’s father is presiding over the prosecution of crime boss Tiernan Murphy, making her valuable as leverage. Four armed men break into her apartment while her bodyguard, Bryan, is with her. Bryan shoots one attacker and urges Irina toward the fire escape, but she cannot get the window open before the leader reaches her.

Irina throws her phone and a jar of chia pudding at him, then strikes another attacker with a fireplace poker, killing him. The leader, Darragh O’Brien, breaks Irina’s arm and drugs her. Bryan is still alive when she reaches him, but a gunman shoots him dead. The kidnappers leave a message identifying her as a Bellandi target, turning her abduction into a direct challenge to Matteo’s organization.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The kidnapping strips away the apparent safety of Irina’s professional life and shows how quickly care becomes a point of leverage in organized violence. Bryan’s defense gives her a chance to resist, but it cannot overcome the attackers’ numbers. Irina’s improvised weapons matter because they preserve her agency without making her invulnerable; she can fight back and still be captured. Her attempt to protect Bryan, like her later defense of another girl, shows that she responds to danger by placing herself between others and harm. The kidnappers exploit precisely this quality, treating her loyalties as a route into her father’s decisions.

The Basement Choice

Irina offers herself to protect Madison

Murphy keeps Irina in a basement with twenty-eight women and girls awaiting trafficking. He offers her relative comfort if she becomes his mistress, threatening instead to sell her with the others. Irina refuses.

When Darragh tries to remove Madison, a frightened seventeen-year-old she has befriended, Irina attacks him despite her broken arm. He beats and injures her until she can barely stand. Rather than watch him take Madison, Irina tells him to take her instead.

Darragh carries her upstairs and sexually assaults her while Madison remains behind. Meanwhile, Grant offers to fund mercenaries and marry Irina in exchange for helping rescue her, but the Bellandis distrust his plan. Scar pushes the search forward, knowing Irina’s captors may move her again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Irina’s choice is morally courageous but psychologically costly. She acts to prevent a younger captive from being assaulted, yet the coercion that follows makes it easy for her to misread sacrifice as consent and later blame herself. The book’s distinction between choice under threat and free consent is crucial: Irina can make a decision without making the violence that follows her responsibility. The basement also widens the story beyond romance. Her rescue cannot mean safety for her alone if dozens of other women remain trapped, and her instinct to protect one person reflects the work she has built her life around.

The Pendant Comes Home

Scar finds Irina among the trafficked women

After several days of searching, Scar and the Bellandis locate the captives at a storage facility. The women surge out of a shipping container as the rescuers open it, and Scar searches through them for Irina.

He finds her badly injured, barely responsive, and held by Madison, who explains that Irina protected her. Scar gives Irina the green butterfly pendant he has worn since Francesca’s death, then carries her to the waiting vehicle. On the drive, Irina drifts in and out of consciousness while Scar begs her to stay awake.

At the Bellandi estate, the doctor confirms she is alive and begins treating her severe injuries. Scar remains beside her, but the woman who wakes is withdrawn, frightened of touch, and unable to recognize the safety around her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The pendant links Scar’s original grief to the person he has nearly lost, but it cannot restore Irina to who she was before the assault. The rescue succeeds physically while leaving the deeper crisis unresolved. Madison’s testimony gives Scar a first glimpse of Irina’s courage, yet courage is not a substitute for care or consent. His closeness now has to change: the man who once used dominance to avoid vulnerability must learn that protection means responding to her fear rather than overpowering it. The section refuses the easy romance convention in which rescue itself heals trauma; survival is only the beginning of the work.

The Railing’s Edge

A suicide attempt forces Scar to choose openly

Irina blames herself for what happened and initially believes she consented because she offered herself to save Madison. Samara, who has survived abuse herself, helps her understand that coercion is not consent.

Irina remains unable to sleep or eat, and her psychiatrist warns that she needs careful support. When Scar learns that Darragh is still alive, Irina secretly climbs onto the estate’s upper railing, intending to fall. Scar reaches her before she lets go, catches her when she jumps, and stays with her through the aftermath.

He administers a sedative so she can sleep and commits himself to keeping her alive. For two days she rests while the doctor treats her, and Scar finally stops pretending he can remain untouched by what happens to her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Irina’s suicide attempt is not a sudden reversal of character but the culmination of trauma, self-blame, exhaustion, and the conviction that the threat will never end. Samara’s intervention gives Irina language for what she endured, but the emotional truth does not vanish once it is named. Scar’s rescue forces him to confront the cost of his prior distance: he cannot claim to love Irina while treating her survival as someone else’s responsibility. His choice to stay is meaningful, though not a cure. The section frames recovery as an ongoing relational commitment, one that must include professional care and Irina’s own agency.

A Shelter Takes Shape

Irina rebuilds purpose while Darragh keeps hunting

As her body heals, Irina’s psychiatrist explains her borderline personality disorder to Scar and Ed, including her fear of abandonment, emotional extremes, and risk of self-harm. Scar stays close while Irina gradually eats, sleeps, and resumes making decisions.

With Sadie, she begins planning a women’s center beside the Bellandi gym, with shelter, counseling, self-defense, and eventually addiction treatment. Darragh disrupts that fragile progress by calling Irina and sending a box containing a bloodied collar, a severed finger, and hair from a woman who resembles her.

The message makes clear that he is targeting women as substitutes for Irina and may still be nearby. Scar increases her protection, while Irina refuses to let fear erase the work she wants to do.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The center gives Irina a future organized around more than recovery from what was done to her. Its services arise directly from the gaps she has witnessed: women need somewhere safe after violence, but also practical tools and treatment for the ways trauma can lead to addiction. Darragh’s message threatens to turn her into a passive object again, while the planned center lets her convert fear into a public purpose. Scar’s protection is necessary in a dangerous city, yet Irina’s insistence on continuing her work prevents care from becoming confinement. Recovery here means reclaiming choice, not simply returning to the past.

The Last Name

Scar confronts the abuser he never escaped

Before facing Darragh, Scar travels with Ryker to Arizona to find Brad, the police officer who abused him as a child and remains the final name on his revenge list. Scar confronts Brad in a motel and kills him, ending the pursuit that has shaped his adult life. Back with Irina, he finally explains the childhood abuse, years on the streets, Francesca’s addiction, and the loss that followed.

He also tells her he had a vasectomy because he fears passing on the damage in his family. Irina answers that she wants to adopt children, not necessarily have biological ones. Their shared history no longer has to remain hidden, and Scar begins to believe a future with her might be possible.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Brad’s death closes a chapter of revenge, but the more consequential act is Scar’s disclosure. For years, he has treated his past as evidence that he is unfit for intimacy; telling Irina makes that history something shared rather than a private sentence. Her response to the vasectomy challenges his assumption that love depends on reproducing a family line. Adoption gives them a future based on chosen care, a direct counterpoint to the neglect both experienced as children. The violence remains part of Scar’s life, but it no longer has to be the only language through which he understands his worth.

Emerald Vows

Scar makes Irina his wife by her choice

When Irina insists on returning to Fresh Start, Scar agrees only with strict conditions: security, an early curfew, and his control over her public plans. He also demands marriage, forcing her to challenge the proposal’s possessive terms.

Irina asks for the words she needs to hear, and Scar tells her that he loves her before arranging a priest and an emerald engagement ring shaped by butterflies. They marry at the Bellandi estate, with their friends watching.

The vows make their commitment public, while their private bond still depends on negotiating control and consent. Irina enters the marriage believing Scar has finally chosen her without reservation. The happiness is brief, because a secret about her mother is about to fracture their trust.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The proposal exposes both the appeal and the risk of Scar’s devotion. His conditions reflect a need to control danger, but Irina makes him confront that protection cannot replace her consent. Her demand for an explicit declaration also matters: she needs more than proof through surveillance or sacrifice. The wedding joins their lives, yet it does not resolve the moral debts hidden beneath them. The emerald ring and butterfly design offer a visible promise of freedom and belonging, but the next revelation tests whether their intimacy can survive truth. The book places romantic commitment beside an uncomfortable question: can love remain trustworthy when one partner has withheld a defining fact?

Blood at the Gate

A family secret opens the estate to attack

After the wedding, Irina’s father reveals that Scar killed Maya, Irina’s missing mother, as part of his revenge for Francesca’s death. Scar admits he would not change what he did, and Irina feels betrayed by him and by the Bellandis who knew. As she struggles to leave, she remembers Darragh’s reference to a little liar and realizes Madison’s story may be false.

Madison proves the suspicion by stabbing a guard and opening the estate gates to Murphy’s attackers. Scar and Yavin arm themselves while Ivory, Luna, and the others escape through tunnels beneath the house. Explosions tear through the estate. Irina refuses to accept that Scar is gone, turns back through the tunnels, and finds Darragh threatening the women.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The revelation about Maya collapses the difference Irina had tried to maintain between Scar’s violence and the violence that shaped her own family. His honesty now cannot undo the concealment, and his refusal to regret the killing deepens the wound. At the same time, Madison’s betrayal shows how Irina’s compassion has been exploited by someone she trusted. The attack literalizes the consequences of both secrets: the estate, the Bellandis’ supposed sanctuary, becomes a battlefield. Irina’s return through the tunnels is a decisive shift from being protected to acting under threat, even while she has not yet forgiven Scar.

The Axe and the Head

Irina and Scar end Darragh’s hold together

In the tunnels, Irina and Aoife fight Darragh while Ivory protects Luna. Scar arrives through the wreckage and helps bring him down, but Irina takes the axe and mutilates Darragh before Scar cuts off his head. The violence is hers as well as his; she chooses how to answer the man who violated her.

The Bellandis later capture Madison, and Irina kills her with Darragh’s own knife. Aboveground, Matteo is found alive beneath the rubble, shielded by Simon, who dies in his place. The estate is destroyed, and the family’s victory comes with a profound loss. Irina and Scar leave the battle together, but neither the marriage nor the city is untouched by what they have done.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Irina’s revenge reverses the helplessness of captivity, but it does not make violence clean or restorative. She acts with agency, yet the act is shaped by the world that trained her to equate safety with force. Scar’s participation makes their partnership literal, although he must not confuse supporting her choice with owning it. Madison’s betrayal complicates Irina’s earlier role as protector, while Simon’s sacrifice reveals the cost paid by people outside the couple’s private struggle. The destroyed estate removes the physical center of Bellandi security. What remains is a family bound not by an intact home, but by shared mourning and the decision to rebuild.

A Different Kind of Shelter

Irina turns survival into a lasting public mission

After the estate’s destruction, the Bellandis regroup at a safehouse, and Irina refuses to let the murders reduce her work to an afterthought. She develops the women’s center on the property beside Sadie and Enzo’s gym, planning housing, counseling, self-defense classes, and support for survivors dealing with addiction.

The project grows from the same commitment that first drew her to Fresh Start, but now includes women who have experienced the violence she once tried to keep at a distance.

Scar supports her work while learning that loving her means allowing her to move beyond his protection. Their marriage remains intense and imperfect, yet Irina begins to build a life in which care is not only private or romantic. It becomes a structure other people can use.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The new center is the story’s most substantial answer to the cycle of harm. It does not promise to defeat trafficking or erase trauma; it creates concrete places where people can recover, learn, and regain choices. Irina’s vocation therefore changes scale without abandoning its origin in individual children. Scar’s growth is measured not by becoming gentle in every context, but by recognizing that protection cannot be the whole shape of their relationship. The couple’s shared future is strongest when Irina’s work remains hers. Their love matters, but it is not allowed to substitute for institutions, community, or sustained care.

Epilogue

Five months later, Matteo pours Simon’s ashes into the foundation of the rebuilt Bellandi home, making his friend part of the place he died protecting. A year and a half after that, Irina and Scar bring Eleni, a girl from Fresh Start, into their family through adoption. Irina’s work has grown into Rebirth, a center for women seeking safety and recovery.

She and Scar also mark their bond with matching half-heart tattoos, the jagged edges fitting together when they press their hands side by side. The ending gives them not an untouched life, but a home built around chosen children, remembered losses, and the work of making safety real.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The epilogue widens the meaning of survival beyond the couple. Simon’s ashes become part of the foundation, so grief is neither hidden nor allowed to stop the living from building. Eleni’s adoption gives Irina and Scar a way to offer the care they lacked as children, without treating biology as destiny. Rebirth turns Irina’s private recovery into an institution that can support others. Even the matching tattoos resist the fantasy that love makes two people identical: their separate halves remain visibly jagged, but they can be brought together by choice. The future is not repair to an old innocence. It is a deliberate structure made from loss and responsibility.

Analysis

Scarred Regrets places two forms of survival beside each other. Irina builds institutions that catch children before the city abandons them; Scar survives by turning himself into an instrument of retaliation. Both approaches begin in real neglect, but each has a cost. Irina’s care can become over-responsibility, making her believe every harmed child is a personal failure. Scar’s vigilance can become control, allowing him to confuse watching someone with being trustworthy. Their romance is compelling precisely because attraction does not magically solve these habits. Irina needs the freedom to make choices after having that freedom violently taken from her, while Scar must learn that protection without consent resembles another cage.

The novel also insists on a morally important distinction between agency and blame. Irina chooses to take Darragh’s attention away from Madison, but the choice is made under threat and does not make the assault consensual. Her later self-blame shows how trauma can turn a desperate attempt to protect someone into an accusation against oneself. Samara’s support and Dr. Lawrence’s care give Irina language and practical safeguards, while Scar’s presence matters only when it supports rather than replaces that work.

The butterfly and the list of names embody the couple’s opposing relations to memory. The pendant carries tenderness forward; the list turns the past into targets. Irina’s center combines these impulses in a more constructive form. It cannot undo violence, but it can create shelter, treatment, and skills where previously there was neglect. The ending’s adopted family and rebuilt home do not restore innocence or erase the dead. They show a future made deliberately, with grief acknowledged and care extended beyond the couple. The book’s strongest claim is not that love cures damage, but that love can become accountable: it can listen, make room for choice, and help build places where other people might survive.

Summary in 60 Seconds
As a child, Paolo DeLuca escapes an abusive home with his sister Francesca, but after she dies from an overdose, he joins the Bellandi crime family and becomes Scar, a ruthless enforcer driven by revenge. Years later, he meets Irina Ryan, a judge’s daughter who runs a center for vulnerable children. Their attraction grows amid Scar’s possessiveness and Irina’s struggles with self-harm and abandonment. When rival crime boss Murphy’s men kidnap Irina for trafficking, she protects another captive and is assaulted before Scar’s crew rescues her. Scar supports her recovery, and they marry, but Irina discovers he killed her missing mother, Maya. Murphy’s attack destroys the Bellandi estate; Irina and Scar kill Darragh, while Irina kills the traitorous Madison. Simon dies saving Matteo. The couple rebuilds their life and Irina’s women’s center, later adopting a girl from Fresh Start.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.11 out of 5
Average of 3k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Scarred Regrets is a dark, emotional romance that has deeply affected readers. Most praise its intense storytelling, complex characters, and powerful themes of trauma and healing. Scar and Irina's journey from broken individuals to a united couple resonates strongly. While some found it too dark or frustrating at times, the majority consider it a standout in the series. Readers appreciate the author's careful handling of sensitive topics and the characters' growth. The book's emotional impact and gripping plot have left a lasting impression on many.

Your rating:
4.7
79 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Irina Ryan

The children’s advocate

Irina is the daughter of Judge Ed Ryan and the director of Fresh Start, where she helps vulnerable children find safe homes and practical support. Her polished public composure conceals intense emotional shifts, a fear of abandonment, and a habit of trying to regulate distress through strict routines and self-harm. She is driven by the conviction that children should not be left to navigate danger alone, a conviction rooted in her own difficult childhood. Irina can be generous without being passive: she argues with officials, challenges powerful men, and makes decisions according to her own ethics. Her work is both a vocation and a way of making care tangible. She longs to be loved without being controlled, though she often struggles to believe that such love is possible.

Scar (Paolo De Luca)

The scarred protector

Known as Scar in the Bellandi organization, Paolo is a towering enforcer, skilled hacker, and bodyguard whose visible injuries reflect a childhood shaped by abuse. He trusts action more readily than intimacy: he protects, watches, and retaliates, while struggling to accept comfort or affection. Francesca’s safety once gave his life its central purpose, and grief sharpened that purpose into vengeance. Scar believes his history has made him unfit to love, so he repeatedly pushes Irina away even as he becomes obsessed with her safety. Beneath his brutality is a careful observer who notices changes in people and remembers what matters to them. His challenge is not simply to feel love, but to offer care without confusing it with possession.

Francesca De Luca

The sister he protects

Francesca is Paolo’s younger sister and the person around whom his childhood revolves. Gentle and vulnerable in the unstable home they share, she finds comfort in small kindnesses and in the green butterfly pendant Paolo gives her. Their bond is built on routines of protection, shared food, and the promise of escape. Francesca’s needs shape Paolo’s sense of duty long after they are children, and her presence explains why he equates love with vigilance. She is more than a reason for his anger: she represents the tenderness he is afraid to recover.

Ed Ryan

The principled judge

Ed is Irina’s father, a respected Chicago judge and the founder of the charitable work that becomes Fresh Start. He believes in public service and the law, but his determination to remain principled can make him emotionally distant when Irina needs comfort. He loves his daughter and wants her to be safe, yet often tries to define what is best for her rather than inviting her into the decision. His relationship with Irina carries both real affection and the strain of their different ideas about duty, protection, and independence.

Maya Regas

The absent mother

Maya is Irina’s mother, raised in the Regas family and accustomed to a world where women are expected to fit the plans made by powerful men. In Irina’s childhood, Maya can be warm and affectionate, but also cold when she feels overlooked or opposed. Her unhappy marriage to Ed shapes the atmosphere in which Irina learns to anticipate rejection. Maya’s unresolved history with her family and her longing for a different life leave a lasting absence in Irina’s emotional world.

Brad Bennett

The abusive officer

Brad is a police officer who uses his authority to exploit Paolo and Francesca’s vulnerable family. His badge gives the children a reason to expect protection, then becomes part of the threat they must escape. Brad embodies the gap between a public role and private conduct.

Franco Bellandi

The crime-family patron

Franco is the Bellandi patriarch who recognizes Paolo’s capacity for violence and offers him a place in the organization. He sees talent and usefulness where others see a damaged street child, but his offer is an exchange, not simple rescue. Franco gives Paolo training, a new identity, and a route into power, while reinforcing the belief that a person earns security through service. His pragmatic view of loyalty shapes the world Scar enters.

Matteo Bellandi

The Bellandi boss

Matteo leads the Bellandi organization and is Scar’s commander. He is strategic, disciplined, and accustomed to weighing individual danger against the safety of the larger family. His marriage to Ivory gives him a private life he fiercely protects, while his command of the city requires him to make hard decisions under pressure. Matteo values loyalty, but he is willing to build alliances when the survival of his people depends on it.

Ivory Bellandi

The fearless confidante

Ivory is Matteo’s wife, Scar’s friend, and the person who often sees his emotional evasions clearly. She meddles in his life because she believes he deserves connection, and she is one of the few people whose affection he can tolerate. As a mother, she is protective without losing her humor or independence. Ivory also becomes a trusted presence for Irina, offering warmth while respecting that recovery cannot be forced.

Grant Dumas

The steadfast old friend

Grant is Irina’s childhood friend and a major donor to Fresh Start. He has known her through grief and emotional difficulty, and he offers the history and steadiness Scar cannot initially provide. Grant’s affection is genuine, though his desire to protect Irina can lead him to make plans on her behalf. He represents the possibility of a safer, more conventional relationship, but he must reckon with the difference between loving Irina and deciding what she needs.

Darragh O’Brien

The stalking captor

Darragh is one of Tiernan Murphy’s men, a violent trafficker whose fixation on Irina turns her into both a target and a possession in his mind. He uses threats and cruelty to control captives, and he treats resistance as an excuse to escalate his violence. His stalking reaches beyond Irina to the people and institutions around her, making him a persistent danger rather than a single encounter. Darragh’s entitlement stands in direct opposition to Irina’s insistence that her body and choices belong to her.

Madison

The guarded teenager

Madison is a seventeen-year-old Irina meets among the women held by Murphy’s organization. Frightened and exhausted, she initially clings to Irina as a source of safety. Her presence draws out Irina’s protective instincts and exposes the difficult choices people make under coercion. Madison carries her own history and motives, which make it hard for Irina and the Bellandis to know how much trust to place in her.

Bryan

The devoted bodyguard

Bryan is assigned to protect Irina when the threat against her grows. He takes his responsibility seriously and acts quickly when armed men enter her home. His loyalty gives Irina a chance to resist, even as the attackers overwhelm them.

Samara

The survivor-mentor

Samara is a friend within the Bellandi circle who understands the aftermath of sexual violence from her own experience. She offers Irina practical tenderness and helps her separate coercion from consent. Samara does not assume that recovery follows a neat timetable; she stays close, listens, and encourages Irina to lean on other people when self-reliance becomes another form of isolation.

Enzo

The loyal enforcer

Enzo is one of Matteo’s trusted men and a close friend to the Bellandi family. He participates in security and rescue efforts, and his loyalty is personal as well as professional. Enzo is direct with Scar when Scar’s self-protective habits threaten Irina, and he expects the people he loves to take responsibility for one another.

Ryker

The relentless tracker

Ryker is a Bellandi operative skilled at finding people and extracting information. He understands trauma and self-destructive coping better than most, which lets him challenge Scar without mistaking cruelty for strength. His methods can be brutal, but his loyalty to the group is steady. Ryker often becomes the practical link between a threat being discovered and the family acting on it.

Calix Regas

The newly found cousin

Calix is Irina’s cousin through Maya’s family and an ally of the Bellandis. He is capable in a fight, sharp in conversation, and warmer than his family history might suggest. His connection to Irina gives her a link to the maternal relatives she barely knew, while his friendship with Rafael places him among people whose loyalty has been tested by danger.

Eleni

The resilient child

Eleni is a girl who comes into Irina’s orbit through the children’s services Irina supports. She is bright, awkward, and still growing into her long limbs, with a lively presence that draws affection from the adults around her. Her needs connect the work of Fresh Start to the idea of a family built through care rather than inheritance.

Simon

The loyal shield

Simon is one of Matteo’s most trusted men and a steady presence in the Bellandi security circle. He works without seeking attention and is especially important when the family faces coordinated danger. His loyalty is expressed through action, making him part of the practical foundation on which Matteo’s leadership depends.

Dr. Theresa Lawrence

Irina’s steady therapist

Dr. Lawrence is Irina’s longtime psychiatrist. She understands Irina’s emotional patterns and helps her family respond to trauma without treating recovery as something that can be demanded. She advocates for careful medication, safety, and patient-led healing.

Megan

Fresh Start’s right hand

Megan is Irina’s assistant at Fresh Start and helps keep the children’s center running. She is a trusted colleague who cares about the children and shares the daily burdens of the work. Her life beyond the center also becomes vulnerable to the danger surrounding Irina.

Luna

The Bellandi child

Luna is Matteo and Ivory’s young daughter. Her presence brings out Scar’s gentler instincts and gives the Bellandi household a daily reminder of what its adults are trying to protect.

Plot Devices

The Green Butterfly Pendant

A token across grief

Paolo gives Francesca a green butterfly pendant as a rare beautiful thing in their harsh childhood. He keeps it after her loss, making it a private memorial and a reminder of what he could not protect. When Scar gives the pendant to Irina during her rescue, the object links his sister’s memory to a new attachment. It does not erase either woman’s history; instead, it makes Scar’s grief visible in the relationship he has tried to avoid. The butterfly becomes an image of survival that Irina and Scar must define for themselves.

Scar’s Revenge List

Grief given targets

After Francesca’s death, Scar keeps names of people he believes contributed to her suffering. The list turns helpless grief into a sequence of actions and helps Franco Bellandi recruit him by offering training and access to vengeance. It also shapes Scar’s work for the Bellandis, since he can apply the technical skills he develops to locate people who once seemed beyond reach. The final name connects his childhood abuser to his adult life, forcing him to decide what remains when revenge is complete.

Fresh Start and Rebirth

Care made practical

Fresh Start is Irina’s center for helping children find stable homes, sponsors, and educational opportunities. It gives her work a visible purpose and provides the setting where Scar sees the care she offers beyond her privileged background. After her assault, that mission expands toward Rebirth, a planned center for women who need shelter, counseling, self-defense, and support with addiction. The institutions make compassion concrete: not a feeling alone, but funding, rooms, staff, and services that can help people regain control of their lives.

The Hidden Surveillance

Protection becomes intrusion

Scar watches Irina from his vehicle and installs cameras to monitor her safety. His surveillance begins as an excuse to remain near her without risking intimacy, then becomes a tool for recognizing threats and tracing Darragh’s calls. The same mechanism that helps protect Irina also raises questions about consent and control. Scar’s story requires him to learn that watching over someone is not the same as listening to her, and that security cannot be the only form his love takes.

The Butterfly as a Name

A private bond made visible

Scar calls Irina Butterfly because her green eyes recall Francesca’s pendant. The nickname begins as a personal association rooted in grief, then becomes a sign of the intimacy he cannot openly acknowledge. Darragh’s use of possessive language tries to turn the image into a claim over Irina, while Scar and Irina gradually make it their own. Tattoos, a wedding ring, and their matching half-heart marks give the private name a changing meaning: not ownership imposed by force, but connection negotiated between two people.

About the Author

Adelaide Forrest is an author who discovered her passion for writing at a young age. She has a degree in Psychology and previously worked at a therapeutic riding facility before becoming a stay-at-home mom. In 2019, she pursued her lifelong dream of becoming an author. Forrest has a vast collection of over 300 book concepts and is known for her Bellandi Crime Syndicate series. She lives in New York with her family, who are central to her life. Forrest maintains an active online presence, engaging with readers through her website and social media platforms, where she provides updates on her work and interacts with her audience.

Other books by Adelaide Forrest

Download PDF

To save this Scarred Regrets summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.41 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this Scarred Regrets summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.47 MB     Pages: 37
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 24,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...