Key Takeaways
Track the rules: persecution often takes hold before violence becomes unmistakable
A world narrows by decree. In Prague, eight-year-old Misha first watches German soldiers arrive as a spectacle. Soon Jews lose jobs, schools, parks, shops, radios, musical instruments, and the right to ride at the front of a tram. The yellow star makes identity visible to strangers, and neighborhood boys use it as an excuse to attack him. Each new restriction makes ordinary life smaller and makes the next restriction seem possible.
Then force enters the home. Misha's father, a lawyer and Jewish community leader, is arrested by SS officers and dies within weeks in Terezin's Small Fortress. The family is told he died of kidney failure. By the time Misha is deported in 1942, persecution has already taken his father and his childhood's belief that home is safe.
The sequence matters. Persecution appears not as one sudden rupture but as a bureaucratic narrowing of who may work, learn, travel, and belong in public. That pattern helps explain how violence can become embedded in daily routines before every bystander understands its destination. Misha's childlike attention to trams, parks, and school makes the loss measurable: oppression is not an abstraction when it determines which door a boy may enter. The book also shows that exclusion can be met with silence, fear, or occasional kindness, not only open endorsement.
A camp called safe can still be a corridor to death
Relief can mislead. By 1942, Misha is so worn down by hunger, harassment, and restrictions in Prague that leaving for Terezin feels like a possible escape. The Nazis describe the destination as safe and productive. The family's journey instead passes through an overcrowded collection hall, where people sleep on straw, queue for thin soup, and are assigned numbers before deportation.
Arrival is not rescue. Terezin is an old fortress crammed with prisoners, many elderly and sick. Jews run much of its daily administration, but the Nazis control the camp and can order transports east. Misha initially feels relief at leaving Prague, then learns that residents can be sent away again without warning. The camp offers moments of friendship and activity, but never security from deportation or death.
The book resists a common narrative shortcut: treating any move away from immediate danger as salvation. Misha's relief is emotionally credible because Prague has become unbearable, yet the reader can see how little either he or his mother knows about the destination. That gap between a person's limited information and an institution's concealed purpose is central to coercion. The camp's Jewish administration adds another layer: responsibility for daily survival is delegated to prisoners, while the power to determine life and death remains with the Nazis.
Treat a parent's ingenuity as strategy, not mere optimism
Care becomes practical work. Misha's mother sells braided belts, finds employment, protects what possessions she can, and repeatedly seeks ways to keep her children off deportation lists. Some valuables she hides with acquaintances or sends abroad, though much is eventually lost. Her hope is not passive: it is paired with exhausting labor, information gathering, and decisions made under severe constraints.
A teddy bear changes the odds. In 1944, she is scheduled for deportation with Misha and Marietta. Her workshop supervisor persuades an SS officer to remove the family from the list because she is the best maker of the teddy bears ordered for the officer's daughters. Her skill matters, as do her supervisor's intervention and the officer's decision. No single act guarantees safety, but her persistence creates another chance.
This story makes resilience concrete rather than mystical. The mother's determination is expressed through work, planning, and relationships, not an unbroken positive attitude. It also avoids implying that effort alone controls outcomes: the exemption depends on a supervisor's advocacy and an SS officer's choice. That distinction matters because survivor stories can accidentally turn survival into a personal achievement test. Here, competence helps, but the machinery of persecution retains power over the result.
Build routines that defend dignity when the world denies it
Room Seven has rules of its own. In Terezin, Misha joins the Nesharim, the boys living in Room Seven of the L417 children's home. Their young leader, Franta, is their madrich, or counselor and guide. He insists on making beds, checking for insects, cleaning bathrooms, and keeping one another clean. The work is demanding, especially when the boys lack soap and adequate food, but it protects health in a crowded room.
Respect is also a survival practice. When boys mock Misha for dirty nails, Franta explains that garden work has made them dirty and forbids the insult. He warns that contempt among prisoners would help the Nazis weaken them. The boys also attend the unofficial lessons called the Program, since formal schooling is banned. Their routines preserve learning, mutual respect, and a sense that they remain people, not just inmates.
Routine here is not a productivity hack; it is a small institution built inside an institution designed to humiliate. Cleanliness has a direct health purpose in a crowded room, while Franta's defense of Misha establishes a social rule: hardship does not grant permission to degrade one another. The approach is powerful precisely because it joins material care to moral language. It cannot cancel the camp's violence, and it should not be mistaken for control over the wider system, but it gives the boys a shared standard for how to treat each other.
Measure your contribution by the opening it creates, not the goal it scores
A role can be decisive without being glamorous. When Misha first joins the Nesharim's soccer games, hunger and poor conditioning leave him clumsy and breathless. He assumes he is letting the team down. Franta teaches the boys to trust one another's different strengths instead of expecting every player to do everything.
The turning point is a tackle. In the championship match against Room One, Misha anticipates the opponent's move and knocks the ball free. A teammate converts the turnover into a goal, and the Nesharim win. Misha does not score, but his action changes the match. The team chant helps him settle his breathing and remember that he is playing with others, not alone. Soccer returns a sense of competence that deprivation had obscured.
The match offers a precise model of contribution: value often lies in changing what becomes possible for someone else. Misha's tackle is visible, but its meaning depends on teammates being ready to use the chance. This is a useful counterweight to individual achievement stories, especially in settings where results are collective and capacities differ. The camp's deprivation also matters. Misha's early mistakes are not evidence of a fixed lack of talent; his body has been weakened by hunger. Performance cannot be separated from the conditions in which it occurs.
Let survival complicate judgment without erasing moral differences
Scarcity changes the moral landscape. In Terezin, boys call taking food from camp supplies schlojsing, their word for stealing. Misha initially objects, remembering how his father stopped him from pocketing a toy train part in Prague. In the camp, he sees a girl conceal a carrot and learns that food has already been taken from prisoners through the Nazi-controlled confiscation system called the Schleuse.
The word does not erase the act. Misha's friends explain that food can disappear into their pockets while they work, and he eventually does the same. He also gives a roll to a hungry man who asks for help. The book does not pretend every choice is simple, or equate a starving child's theft with the organized dispossession carried out by the Nazis. It shows how deprivation can make old rules feel different without making cruelty and survival equivalent.
The tension is ethically valuable because it refuses both easy condemnation and easy absolution. Misha's remembered lesson from his father still matters, but the conditions around him have changed: food is scarce, and the system has already stripped prisoners of their belongings. Naming the act does not settle its morality; context changes what a choice costs and what it protects. At the same time, keeping the scale of power in view prevents a false equivalence between a child's attempt to eat and institutionalized theft.
Let art sustain people, but ask who benefits from its display
Performance creates a shared world. Misha joins Brundibar, a children's opera in which siblings and their animal friends unite against a cruel organ-grinder. Rehearsals, music, set-making, and an audience give prisoners a reason to gather and a way to feel joy together. For Misha, singing with the cast resembles being part of the soccer team, but the performance offers a different kind of solidarity.
The same culture can be staged as evidence. The Nazis permit music and plays while banning ordinary schooling. Before a Red Cross visit, they clean streets, plant flowers, improve the appearance of the camp, and coach prisoners to perform complaints as jokes. The visitors see a deceptive picture of Terezin. The opera remains meaningful to the children and audience, but its presence does not prove that the camp is humane.
Art's value is not canceled by its exploitation. Brundibar can provide genuine pleasure and collective expression even within a camp where performance is also useful to Nazi propaganda. This distinction avoids two errors: treating cultural life as proof of decent conditions, or dismissing it as merely a propaganda prop. The Red Cross episode makes the stakes of looking especially clear. A visitor's impression depends not only on what is visible, but on who controls the scene and whether prisoners can speak freely.
Read survival as contingent, not as proof of who deserved rescue
A transport is a moving threat. In the memoir, a transport is a Nazi-organized deportation, first carrying Jews from Prague to Terezin and later taking prisoners east, often toward Auschwitz-Birkenau. Misha's family receives repeated summonses, and at times his mother manages to get them removed from a list. Other families are less fortunate, even when they work, help others, or have connections.
Small accidents can decide who remains. When Misha's mother secures an exemption in October 1944, guards still send prisoners from the assembly hall. The family survives partly because the first rooms are full, so they wait in a nearly empty room farther down the corridor. A few months earlier, a boy's family escapes a transport through a connection. These outcomes reflect effort, access, timing, and chance, not a measure of human worth.
The narrative makes survival visible as a combination of action and contingency. Misha's mother repeatedly intervenes, but the family also benefits from decisions and circumstances beyond her control. This matters for how readers interpret survivor testimony: those who live are not necessarily the most courageous, deserving, or capable, and those who die are not less so. The book's attention to lists, room assignments, and chance encounters shows how arbitrary outcomes can emerge from systems that present themselves as orderly.
Keep a future in view without mistaking hope for evidence of safety
Hope gives the family somewhere to look. After liberation, Misha's mother remembers the natural world, books, clean homes, and the possibility of rebuilding a life. During the war, Misha also imagines soccer, school, Prague, and ordinary meals. Such hopes do not tell him what will happen; they keep the present from becoming the only imaginable world.
The title holds both truths. A sun still exists somewhere, even when the people trapped in Terezin cannot reach it. Misha sometimes mistakes optimism for evidence that conditions are improving, especially when the camp looks cleaner or a rumor promises the war will soon end. His mother's hope is more durable when paired with clear-eyed planning. It sustains action, but never makes the danger less real.
Hope works here as orientation, not prediction. It preserves an image of life beyond the camp without guaranteeing that any particular person will get there. That distinction keeps the title from becoming a sentimental promise. The memoir also shows how hope can mislead when it is treated as evidence: cleaner streets and reassuring rumors do not make the camp safe. Its strongest form is therefore neither denial nor certainty, but the ability to imagine a future while continuing to respond to the present.
Tell traumatic history honestly, including how memory reconstructs it
The story makes its limits visible. In the afterword, co-writer Todd Hasak-Lowy explains that Michael could recall only fragments of events from childhood decades earlier. The book's scenes draw on interviews, documents, research, and other survivors' accounts. Dialogue is reconstructed, some recurring experiences are combined into scenes, and the boy named Jiri was created because Michael could no longer identify a real friend.
Point of view sets boundaries. The narrative stays with what Misha could know at the time. He does not learn the true circumstances of his father's death during the story, so that information is not inserted into his experience as if he knew it then. This method creates immediacy, but it also asks readers to distinguish remembered fact from literary reconstruction. The afterword offers that distinction rather than pretending the memoir is an unmediated transcript.
The disclosure strengthens the book's claim to seriousness. A memoir written in a child's present-tense voice can feel immediate, but immediacy is an artistic effect, not proof that every sentence was remembered word for word. By explaining its methods, the afterword gives readers tools to hold emotional truth and documentary uncertainty together. The boundary around what Misha knew also has ethical force: adding later knowledge would alter the child's lived experience, even when that later knowledge is historically important.
Liberation ends captivity, not grief, illness, or unfinished growing
Freedom arrives in a damaged body. When Soviet tanks enter Terezin in May 1945, Misha is finally free to leave. His first private response is not simple celebration but an overwhelming hunger for real food, followed by the ache of wanting to tell his dead father what has happened. Liberation ends the camp's immediate control, not the losses accumulated inside it.
Home does not restore the old world. Misha returns to Prague with his mother and sister, but most of the Nesharim are gone. Franta survives and writes that the boys' closeness should not make Terezin seem like a good place. Misha's family later rebuilds elsewhere, while the memoir keeps the losses in view. His next task is ordinary and unfinished: catch up on years of missed schooling and learn how to live beyond the camp.
The ending refuses the clean arc in which rescue makes suffering narratively complete. Misha's hunger, grief, and educational absence persist after the gates open, while the loss of friends changes what return to Prague can mean. Franta's correction is especially important: a community can create real care inside a terrible place without redeeming that place. The book's final measure of recovery is not a heroic transformation, but the return of ordinary choices, including the possibility of deciding what to do next.
Analysis
This memoir's central achievement is its management of knowledge. The reader follows Misha as a child, so danger arrives first as an odd rule, a missing parent, a frightening journey, or a friend who fails to return. The reader often understands more than he does, but not everything. That imbalance creates suspense without turning the child into a retrospective lecturer. It also makes the mechanics of persecution legible: power works through uniforms and violence, but also through schedules, confiscations, lists, and the restriction of ordinary movement.
The book's emotional architecture depends on care at several scales. Misha's mother practices care through planning, paid work, and repeated appeals. Franta builds it through routines, discipline, and a collective identity among the boys. These forms are not interchangeable. The mother sees a family whose survival depends on escaping; Franta sees a room of children who must learn to function together under confinement. Their conflict over the blanket shows how protective love can produce opposing judgments, without making either adult indifferent to Misha.
The memoir also avoids turning survival into a moral verdict. Skill and solidarity matter, but they do not defeat the deportation system. A well-timed exemption, a useful craft, a crowded room, or a guard's decision can shape who lives. That randomness is essential to the book's account of history, as is the afterword's explanation of how the narrative was reconstructed. The vivid scenes create emotional access; the disclosure of composite episodes and recreated dialogue prevents that vividness from masquerading as a verbatim record. The result is not simply a story of endurance. It is an account of how a child experiences a changing world, how others help him remain human inside it, and how survival leaves unresolved obligations to remember accurately.
Review Summary
Somewhere There Is Still a Sun is a powerful Holocaust memoir by Michael Gruenbaum, co-authored with Todd Hasak-Lowy. The book offers a unique perspective through the eyes of young Misha in Nazi-occupied Prague and Terezin concentration camp. Readers praised its emotional impact, accessible writing for young adults, and ability to convey hope amidst tragedy. Many found it educational and moving, appreciating the focus on relationships and survival. Some felt it was less graphic than other Holocaust accounts, making it suitable for younger readers while still conveying the horrors of the time.
People Also Read
Glossary
Nesharim
Room Seven's boys' groupHebrew for eagles, Nesharim is the name used for the boys living together in Room Seven of the L417 children's home at Terezin. Under Franta's leadership, they form a community with shared routines, lessons, soccer, and mutual responsibilities. The group gives the boys a sense of identity and belonging within the camp.
madrich
Counselor and guideA Hebrew term for a youth counselor, guide, or teacher. Franta serves as the madrich for the boys in Room Seven. His role includes organizing the household, enforcing hygiene and cooperation, leading activities, and helping the boys manage life in the camp. A female counselor is called a madricha.
Program
Unofficial camp lessonsThe name used for the lessons Jewish children attend in Terezin when formal schooling is forbidden. The classes cover subjects such as mathematics, history, literature, and English, and are organized discreetly. Work assignments can excuse some boys from attending, while children sometimes help conceal the lessons from Nazi authorities.
Schleuse
Confiscation and processing checkpointA German term used for the checkpoint through which prisoners' belongings pass when they arrive at Terezin. The Nazis inspect and confiscate valuables, so items sent with prisoners may not reach them. In the memoir, the boys also use the term to describe the system that diverts possessions away from the people who brought them.
schlojsing
Camp slang for taking foodThe boys' camp slang for secretly taking food, such as a bread roll from a delivery or a carrot from a garden. Misha initially understands the act as stealing, but sees how hunger and the camp's confiscation system change its meaning for prisoners. The term does not make every choice simple or erase differences in power.
Apel
Roll-call assemblyA German term for the camp roll call, when prisoners gather and are counted. In Room Seven, the boys must be prepared and present on time. The routine can be exhausting and frightening, especially when an unusually large count or a mass gathering signals that the Nazis may be preparing a new action.
transport
Scheduled deportation convoyIn the memoir, a transport is a Nazi-organized deportation of Jewish prisoners. Misha's family is first transported from Prague to Terezin. Later transports take prisoners from Terezin eastward, often toward Auschwitz-Birkenau. A summons gives a family a reporting time, while the destination and likely fate are often concealed or falsely described.
bashta
Grassy fortress-wall playing fieldThe boys' name for a grassy section of Terezin's inner fortress wall where they play soccer. The raised area offers room to run and a view beyond the camp walls. For Misha and the Nesharim, it becomes a rare outdoor space for competition, practice, and shared recreation.
FAQ
What is Somewhere There Is Still a Sun by Michael Gruenbaum about?
- Holocaust memoir for youth: The book is a memoir recounting Michael Gruenbaum’s experiences as a Jewish boy during the Nazi occupation of Prague and his time in the Terezin concentration camp.
- Personal and historical narrative: It blends Michael’s personal memories with historical context, explaining Nazi rules, transports, and daily life in ghettos and camps.
- Focus on childhood resilience: The story is told from a child’s perspective, capturing confusion, fear, and the resilience of youth during the Holocaust.
- Family and survival: It details the impact of the Holocaust on Michael’s family, including loss, survival, and the struggle to rebuild after liberation.
Who is Michael Gruenbaum, the author of Somewhere There Is Still a Sun, and what is his background?
- Holocaust survivor and author: Michael Gruenbaum was born in Prague in 1930 and was deported to Terezin at age twelve, surviving the Holocaust along with his mother and sister.
- Family history: His father was active in Prague’s Jewish community but was arrested and killed in the Small Fortress at Terezin.
- Post-war life: After the war, Michael emigrated to the United States, attended MIT, served in the army, and had a successful career in city planning.
- Memoir’s perspective: The book reflects on his childhood experiences and the legacy of the Nesharim, the group of boys he lived with in Terezin.
Why did Michael Gruenbaum wait seventy years to write and publish Somewhere There Is Still a Sun?
- Emotional readiness: Michael only felt able to share his traumatic experiences as he reached an advanced age, indicating the emotional difficulty of recounting the Holocaust.
- Inherited memorabilia: After his mother’s death, he inherited an album of memorabilia from Terezin, which inspired him to preserve and eventually share his story.
- Publishing journey: He initially wrote a children’s picture book, but after facing publishing challenges, he collaborated with professional writers to create a memoir for middle-grade readers.
- Desire to educate: Michael wanted to serve as a bridge for young readers to understand the Holocaust through his personal story.
What were the living conditions and daily experiences in the Terezin concentration camp as described in Somewhere There Is Still a Sun?
- Children’s Home and Room 7: Michael lived in a crowded room with about forty boys, under the guidance of a leader named Franta, with strict routines and limited personal space.
- Daily routines and rules: The boys had to maintain cleanliness, participate in unofficial schooling (“the Program”), and take on jobs like gardening.
- Community and resilience: Despite harsh conditions, the boys formed a close-knit group called the Nesharim, supporting each other through activities like soccer and theater.
- Constant fear: The threat of transports to death camps and the loss of friends and family were ever-present realities.
Who were the Nesharim in Somewhere There Is Still a Sun, and what was their significance?
- Group of child survivors: The Nesharim (“eagles” in Hebrew) were a group of boys in Room 7 at Terezin, including Michael, who formed a strong community.
- Symbol of hope and unity: Their team spirit and brotherhood helped them survive the harsh conditions, with a chant “Rim, rim, rim, tempo Nesharim” boosting morale.
- Led by Franta: Under Franta’s leadership, the Nesharim maintained discipline, camaraderie, and a sense of normalcy through sports and cultural activities.
- Legacy of resilience: Only eleven of the eighty boys survived, making their story a testament to the power of friendship and resilience.
What role did Franta play in the lives of the boys in Somewhere There Is Still a Sun?
- Leader and mentor: Franta (Francis Maier) was the madrich (counselor) of Room 7, acting as a father figure and guide for the boys.
- Coach and organizer: He organized soccer teams, play rehearsals, and educational activities, helping the boys maintain hope and a sense of childhood.
- Moral support: Franta emphasized unity and humanity, teaching the boys to survive “as human beings, not as animals,” despite Nazi attempts to dehumanize them.
- Source of discipline: He enforced cleanliness and order, instilling values that helped the boys cope with camp life.
How does Somewhere There Is Still a Sun by Michael Gruenbaum portray the impact of Nazi rules and restrictions on Jewish life?
- Increasing restrictions: The book details Nazi-imposed rules such as wearing yellow stars, restricted shopping hours, and bans on owning radios or musical instruments.
- Social isolation: Jewish children were expelled from schools, and families were forced into ghettos, losing access to public spaces and facing harassment.
- Material loss: The Gruenbaum family lost possessions multiple times due to confiscations, bombings, and forced auctions.
- Psychological toll: The constant erosion of rights and dignity is depicted as a gradual but devastating process.
What were “transports” in Somewhere There Is Still a Sun, and why were they so significant?
- Definition of transports: Transports were Nazi-organized deportations of Jews from ghettos or camps like Terezin to extermination camps such as Auschwitz.
- Fear and uncertainty: Receiving a summons for a transport meant imminent deportation, often to death, causing widespread fear and anxiety.
- Survival and loss: Many families and friends were lost during transports, and the book describes the emotional toll and the struggle to avoid or survive them.
- Turning points: The Gruenbaum family’s receipt of a transport summons marked critical moments in their journey.
How did Michael Gruenbaum’s family survive the transports to death camps, according to Somewhere There Is Still a Sun?
- Mother’s ingenuity: Michael’s mother used her connections and resourcefulness to get the family removed from transports to Auschwitz and other death camps.
- Coded communication: A postcard from Aunt Louise, with handwriting slanting down, served as a secret code indicating danger, helping the family understand the severity of their situation.
- Narrow escapes: The memoir recounts several close calls and the emotional toll of knowing many others were not as fortunate.
- Combination of luck and courage: Their survival was due to a mix of quick thinking, bravery, and fortunate circumstances.
What is the significance of the children’s opera Brundibar in Somewhere There Is Still a Sun?
- Symbol of hope and resistance: Brundibar was a children’s opera performed by the kids in Terezin, including Michael, symbolizing the fight against evil.
- Cultural life in the camp: Despite horrific conditions, the Nazis allowed cultural activities like Brundibar, providing the children with a sense of normalcy and community.
- Emotional impact: The opera’s themes resonated with the children, representing their own struggles and hopes.
- Bittersweet memories: Performing Brundibar brought both joy and sadness, especially as many performers later disappeared in transports.
How does Somewhere There Is Still a Sun by Michael Gruenbaum address the psychological and emotional impact of life in Terezin?
- Constant fear and uncertainty: Michael describes the ever-present threat of transports, the loss of friends, and the difficulty of maintaining hope.
- Moments of joy: Activities like soccer, performing in Brundibar, and sharing small treats provided brief escapes and a sense of childhood.
- Emotional struggles: The memoir captures feelings of sadness, anger, and confusion, such as guilt over food or the pain of losing friends.
- Resilience and adaptation: Despite trauma, the children found ways to support each other and retain their humanity.
What are the key takeaways and messages from Somewhere There Is Still a Sun by Michael Gruenbaum?
- Resilience in adversity: The memoir shows how hope, friendship, and creativity can survive even in the darkest circumstances.
- Power of community: The Nesharim’s solidarity and support for one another highlight the human need for connection and belonging.
- Necessity of remembrance: By sharing his story, Michael underscores the importance of bearing witness to history to honor victims and educate future generations.
- Humanity in hardship: The story stresses maintaining dignity and compassion, even when faced with unimaginable suffering.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.