Key Takeaways
Treat ecological crisis as a shared present, not a future to escape.
Stay in the present. Haraway argues that ecological catastrophe cannot be answered by imagining a safe future that will somehow arrive, or by declaring that everything is already lost. Staying with the trouble means meeting ongoing damage through situated, collective action, while acknowledging that some losses cannot be reversed. She calls the ability and obligation to respond with others response-ability. The book’s context is stark: it cites projections of more than 11 billion people by 2100, alongside mass extinction and sharply unequal burdens on poor and wealthy communities.
Reject easy exits. Technological rescue fantasies and despair both encourage passivity. Haraway instead asks readers to work with actual people, animals, and places, without guarantees of success or a clean beginning.
What's useful here is the shift from prediction to responsibility. Climate risk is often discussed through distant targets and end-of-century scenarios, which can make present choices feel abstract. Haraway's emphasis restores attention to who is already exposed, who benefits, and who can act. That is compatible with practical adaptation planning, where local knowledge and near-term decisions matter. The caution is that staying present should not become an excuse to understate systemic danger. Urgency needs both clear forecasts and the grounded work of responding to their unequal consequences.
Study life as a web of partnerships, not a contest among sealed individuals.
Life is made together. Sympoiesis means making-with: living systems form through relationships rather than arising as self-contained units. Haraway uses the term holobiont for a symbiotic assemblage whose members develop through their associations. One striking example is Mixotricha paradoxa, a termite-gut organism composed of several kinds of cells and hundreds of thousands of bacterial partners. The Hawaiian bobtail squid offers another: it develops a light-producing organ only through interaction with Vibrio bacteria.
Partnership is not perfection. These relationships can be beneficial, costly, or unstable. Lynn Margulis's work on symbiogenesis, the emergence of new forms through lasting associations, helps Haraway question evolutionary accounts focused almost entirely on competition among individuals.
This perspective resonates with microbiome research and with distributed cognition, the idea that thinking can depend on bodies, tools, and other people. It replaces the isolated organism with a more realistic picture of mutual dependence. The key nuance is that interdependence does not mean harmony. A symbiosis can involve exploitation, conflict, or unequal benefit, and the book explicitly resists treating cooperation as automatically good. The holobiont is therefore most powerful as a prompt to ask which relationships sustain life, which constrain it, and how those arrangements change.
Use stories to trace responsibility across species, technologies, and places.
Follow the threads. Haraway uses string figures as a model for thinking and storytelling: participants receive, alter, and pass on a pattern. Her shorthand, sf, gathers science fiction, speculative fabulation, science fact, and string figures as ways to follow connections without pretending they form a complete map.
Pigeons make the method concrete. In Beatriz da Costa's PigeonBlog, racing pigeons carried compact sensors that recorded air pollution as they flew through Southern California. The project joined birds, pigeon fanciers, artists, engineers, and environmental advocates. Earlier Coast Guard research found pigeons particularly good at spotting people and equipment in open water. These examples show that animals are not merely symbols or instruments. Their capacities emerge through specific partnerships, and those partnerships raise practical questions about benefit, risk, and consent.
The story-based method resembles participatory research: knowledge improves when affected communities help shape what gets measured and why. PigeonBlog also makes pollution visible in places standard monitoring can miss. Its limits are instructive. A striking demonstration is not the same as a validated public-health dataset, and the birds bear physical costs even when their handlers care for them. The project is strongest as a way to provoke attention and collaboration, not as a substitute for rigorous monitoring or careful animal-welfare review.
Name the systems driving damage instead of blaming humanity as one.
Make responsibility specific. The Anthropocene names the planetary effects of human activity, but Haraway argues that the term can make all humans seem equally responsible. The Capitalocene instead points to capitalism's histories of extraction and accumulation. The Plantationocene draws attention to plantations, forced labor, colonial displacement, and simplified landscapes. These are overlapping lenses, not interchangeable labels.
History matters. Haraway traces planetary transformation to more than the steam engine: earlier networks of sugar, metals, plantations, slavery, and Indigenous dispossession also reorganized land and labor. She proposes the Chthulucene as a different kind of story, centered on ongoing multispecies relations rather than human mastery. The point is not to find one perfect name, but to identify causes clearly enough to change them.
Naming distributes responsibility, and that has political consequences. Environmental accounting that treats every consumer or nation as equivalent can hide the uneven histories behind emissions and land use. Haraway's terms help bring colonialism and economic organization into the frame. Still, no single label explains every ecological crisis, and capitalism itself operates through different institutions and histories. The book is most persuasive when its names work as lenses rather than total theories. They sharpen inquiry, but they cannot replace local evidence about who caused harm and who can repair it.
Expand kinship without surrendering reproductive freedom or ignoring ecological limits.
Kin need not mean ancestry. Haraway urges readers to make kin beyond conventional genealogy, creating durable obligations among people and other beings. Her deliberately provocative call to make kin rather than babies addresses the strain that growing human numbers place on shared habitats. It does not justify coercive population control. The book stresses that reproductive freedom includes the ability to have children, the ability not to, and access to health, safety, housing, and usable contraception.
Responsibility is unequal. Population policies have often burdened poor and marginalized people while serving states and powerful groups. Haraway argues that avoiding the ecological issue is also inadequate. The challenge is to address human numbers without turning people into abstract statistics or making reproduction a duty imposed by governments or movements.
This is one of the book's most ethically difficult arguments. Reproductive justice rightly resists policies that treat marginalized bodies as problems to manage, while ecological analysis cannot ignore the effects of consumption, land use, and population together. Haraway's emphasis on freedom and unequal responsibility helps hold these truths in view. The slogan can nevertheless be misread as a universal prescription, especially where communities face histories of genocide or forced sterilization. Its defensible meaning depends on voluntary choices, material support, and attention to who consumes most.
Repair damaged places through coalitions rooted in local histories.
Repair is a shared craft. Haraway's examples connect environmental knowledge with art, community practice, and political action. The Crochet Coral Reef brings mathematics and fiber art together: thousands of participants in 27 countries crocheted forms inspired by threatened reefs. In Madagascar, the Ako Project created illustrated books about local lemurs in Malagasy and English, supporting children's knowledge of their own biodiversity.
History cannot be skipped. On Black Mesa, coal mining depleted water and damaged Diné lands while many local households lacked reliable electricity. Navajo-Churro sheep recovery, weaving, and Indigenous-led environmental justice work link cultural renewal to ecological repair. These projects do not erase colonial histories or restore everything that was lost. They build practical alliances that may make particular places more livable.
These cases show why environmental action can benefit from formats beyond technical reports. Craft, children's books, and cultural practice can make ecological relationships tangible and invite participation. The Black Mesa example also guards against romanticizing community projects: local coalitions work under economic pressure and inherited injustice, not outside them. A useful standard is whether a project strengthens local decision-making and material capacity, rather than merely borrowing Indigenous knowledge or displaying environmental concern. Different places need different alliances, and their methods should not be treated as interchangeable.
Ask what beings can do together, not what they can do alone.
Curiosity changes the encounter. Philosopher Vinciane Despret studies how animals and people can bring out abilities in one another. In the Negev desert, ornithologist Amotz Zahavi observed Arabian babblers whose social behavior challenged familiar accounts of animal altruism. Rather than forcing the birds into a preset explanation, he asked what mattered in their lives and adjusted his attention to their behavior.
Politeness is a method. Despret uses the word for an inquiry that gives other beings room to surprise the observer. On farms, she and Jocelyne Porcher found breeders who treated listening to cows and pigs as part of competent work. The animals and humans shaped each other's actions. Their capacities were not simply waiting, fully formed, to be measured.
This approach connects animal studies with experimental design: what researchers do can alter the behavior they record. It also offers a rigorous alternative to both anthropomorphism and the assumption that animals are passive objects. The discipline is to remain open to surprise while still testing interpretations carefully. Trusting an animal's apparent signals is not proof of knowing its inner life. Despret's contribution is methodological humility, not a license to replace evidence with sentiment.
Let mourning preserve lost worlds as evidence, not merely sadness.
Loss has a history. Haraway draws on extinction scholar Thom van Dooren, who treats extinction as a prolonged unraveling of relationships and ways of life, not just the disappearance of a species. His account of grieving crows challenges the idea that mourning belongs only to humans. An orchid that resembles a pollinating bee also carries the trace of a relationship now largely absent from its environment.
Remembering can guide action. Haraway calls for practices that bring the dead and the missing into active presence. In her imagined communities, Speakers for the Dead keep lost beings and their histories part of decisions about the living. Mourning does not undo extinction. It can help people understand what has changed and what obligations remain.
Conservation often measures success through surviving populations, but attention to relationships adds another dimension: a species may persist while its habitat, partners, or characteristic behaviors disappear. Grief can keep those losses from becoming invisible and can sustain long-term commitment. It should not, however, dictate a single restoration target. Ecosystems change, and historical baselines are contested. Mourning is most useful when it deepens evidence-based care instead of turning the past into an idealized world that must be recreated.
Treat speculative futures as ethical rehearsal, not environmental prediction.
Imagine obligations across generations. The Camille Stories follow five generations of a human child joined in symbiosis with monarch butterflies. Their communities settle in damaged places, make kin in unconventional ways, and work to restore the butterflies' migration routes between North America and Mexico. The story imagines human numbers falling from 10 billion around 2100 to 3 billion by 2400, while acknowledging ongoing extinctions, conflict, and failure.
This is a thought experiment. The speculative child is not a forecast or a practical blueprint for genetic engineering. Camille's life asks what long-term care might require when one person's choices connect them to other species, lands, and communities. The story offers a shared imaginative project, inviting readers to revise its futures rather than accept them as settled.
Speculative fiction can make abstract ethical questions bodily: what would a lifetime obligation to another species demand of education, family, travel, and politics? That makes the Camille stories useful as scenario work, where assumptions can be examined before policies are proposed. The premise also carries risks. Choosing a child's animal partner could turn care into a burden of identity, and a planned population decline could slip toward coercion. The story acknowledges conflict, but readers should test its imagined institutions as carefully as its ecological aspirations.
Analysis
Staying with the Trouble is best read as a linked set of essays and stories, not a step-by-step environmental program. Haraway moves from pigeons and scientific practice to evolutionary biology, Indigenous struggles, intimate medical histories, and speculative fiction. The apparent sprawl is part of the argument: ecological problems do not respect disciplinary boundaries, so neither should thought. A pigeon fitted with a sensor, a Navajo weaver, a pollinating bee, and a hormone molecule can belong to one account of responsibility without becoming equivalent actors.
The book's strongest intellectual move is to make relation the starting point. Symbiosis challenges the picture of organisms as independent units; multispecies stories then extend that insight into politics and ethics. This does not mean every association is reciprocal or benign. The examples repeatedly involve asymmetry, labor, exploitation, and loss. Their ethical value lies in making those conditions visible rather than promising harmony.
Haraway's names for historical periods are useful provocations. Anthropocene highlights planetary change, while Capitalocene and Plantationocene bring economic and colonial histories into view. Chthulucene shifts attention toward ongoing life among human and nonhuman beings. None is a complete causal account. Their force is diagnostic: each changes what evidence and responsibility become noticeable.
The book's ambition also produces real tensions. Its call to address human numbers sits beside a firm defense of reproductive freedom, a pairing that demands careful political safeguards. Its biological examples support interdependence, but the idea of a holobiont as a single evolutionary unit remains debated. And its vivid speculative imagery can inspire attention while distracting from material policy if taken as a plan. The Camille stories are therefore most convincing as ethical rehearsal. Overall, the book asks readers to replace both heroic control and resigned despair with situated, accountable participation in damaged worlds.
Review Summary
Staying with the Trouble receives mixed reviews, with praise for its innovative ideas on ecological regeneration and multispecies coexistence. Readers appreciate Haraway's creative language and concepts like "chthulucene" and "making kin." However, some find her writing style dense and repetitive. Critics raise concerns about her advocacy for population control. Overall, the book is seen as thought-provoking, offering a unique perspective on addressing environmental challenges, though its academic tone may limit accessibility for some readers.
People Also Read
Glossary
response-ability
Capacity to answer responsiblyHaraway's term for the learned ability to notice how beings affect one another and to respond to those relationships. It is not identical to universal blame: responsibilities differ with people's positions, powers, histories, and connections. The term emphasizes that ethical action is made in concrete encounters, not derived from abstract rules alone.
sympoiesis
Collective making-withA term for systems and forms of life produced through ongoing relationships among multiple participants. Sympoietic processes do not depend on a single, self-contained maker or a fixed boundary. Haraway uses the idea to think about organisms, ecosystems, knowledge, and political action as historically situated collaborations capable of unpredictable change.
holobiont
Symbiotic living assemblageA symbiotic assemblage of organisms that live and develop in relation to one another. Haraway uses the term for dynamic associations rather than a solitary host surrounded by secondary guests. A holobiont can include partners with different interests and degrees of dependence; symbiosis does not automatically mean that every participant benefits equally.
Chthulucene
Multispecies time of becoming-withHaraway's name for an ongoing time and place in which human and nonhuman beings make worlds together amid ecological damage. It counters stories that place humanity alone at the center of planetary history. The term stresses entanglement, mortality, and the possibility of partial flourishing, not a return to an untouched past or a guaranteed future.
Capitalocene
Capital-driven planetary transformationA proposed name for planetary changes shaped by capitalism's systems of extraction, production, and accumulation. Haraway uses it to challenge accounts that assign equal responsibility to humanity as a whole. The term draws attention to historically specific economic relations, while remaining incomplete if treated as the sole explanation for environmental change.
Plantationocene
Plantation-shaped ecological transformationA term for transformations associated with plantation systems and their legacies, including monoculture, coerced and displaced labor, colonial control, and ecological simplification. It directs attention to how agricultural landscapes and human communities were reorganized for extraction. Haraway presents it as one useful name among several overlapping accounts of planetary change.
string figures
Patterns passed through collaborationA practice and metaphor for making, receiving, changing, and passing patterns among participants. Haraway uses string figures to describe storytelling, scholarship, and multispecies relationships in which no participant controls the whole pattern. The practice highlights connection and invention, while recognizing that threads can be dropped, altered, or tangled.
sf
Speculative, factual, and relational storytellingHaraway's shorthand gathers science fiction, speculative feminism, science fact, speculative fabulation, and string figures. It describes a way to follow real relationships while imagining other possible worlds. Rather than separating factual inquiry from storytelling, sf treats both as practices that shape attention, knowledge, and the futures people can work toward.
symbiogenesis
Evolution through lasting associationAn evolutionary process in which organisms form sustained associations that generate new biological forms or capacities. Haraway draws especially on Lynn Margulis's account of symbiogenesis to emphasize the role of intimate relations among organisms, including microbes. The concept challenges explanations that rely exclusively on competition among already formed individuals.
symanimagenesis
Becoming-with living and deadA term in the Camille stories for a form of becoming-with that joins living beings to ancestors and the dead through shared practices and relationships. In the story, Mexican communities use it to describe relations between monarch butterflies and the visiting dead. It names a worlding that cannot be reduced to biological symbiosis alone.
FAQ
1. What is [Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene] by Donna J. Haraway about?
- Multispecies entanglement focus: The book explores how humans and other species are deeply entangled in complex relationships, emphasizing the practice of "making kin" to live and die well together on a damaged planet.
- Chthulucene as a new epoch: Haraway introduces the Chthulucene as an alternative to the Anthropocene and Capitalocene, highlighting tentacular thinking and sympoiesis as ways to understand ongoing multispecies connections.
- Interdisciplinary storytelling: The text weaves together feminist theory, science studies, ethnography, biology, and speculative fiction to address ecological crises and imagine multispecies futures.
- Practical and speculative approach: Haraway combines grounded ethnographic examples with speculative fabulations to envision new kin-making practices for survival and flourishing.
2. Why should I read [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway?
- Urgency of ecological crises: The book offers a critical framework for understanding and responding to the intertwined ecological, social, and political troubles of our time, such as mass extinctions and climate change.
- Innovative conceptual tools: Haraway provides new concepts like the Chthulucene, sympoiesis, and tentacular thinking to help readers rethink human-nonhuman relations beyond domination and separation.
- Ethical and political engagement: Readers are encouraged to cultivate response-ability, care, and multispecies kinship as ethical practices for staying with the trouble rather than escaping or denying it.
- Rich, accessible examples: The book is filled with vivid ethnographies, art projects, and speculative narratives that make complex ideas accessible and inspire creative action.
3. What are the key takeaways from [Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene] by Donna J. Haraway?
- Rejecting human exceptionalism: Haraway challenges the idea that humans are separate from or superior to other species, urging a shift toward multispecies justice and kinship.
- Embracing sympoiesis: The concept of "making-with" highlights the importance of collective, distributed processes in living and becoming, rather than self-contained autonomy.
- Staying with the trouble: Instead of seeking escape or easy solutions, the book advocates for facing ecological and social crises with care, creativity, and collaborative action.
- Speculative and practical kin-making: Through both real-world examples and speculative stories, Haraway demonstrates how making kin across species and differences is essential for survival and flourishing.
4. What are the best quotes from [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway and what do they mean?
- "Make kin, not babies!" This quote encapsulates Haraway’s call to expand kinship beyond biological reproduction, emphasizing responsibility and care across species.
- "It matters what stories make worlds; what worlds make stories." Haraway highlights the power of narrative in shaping realities and possibilities for multispecies futures.
- "Staying with the trouble requires learning to be truly present." This quote urges readers to engage deeply with the complexities and urgencies of the present, rather than seeking escape.
- "We are all compost, not posthuman." Haraway uses this phrase to reject fantasies of transcendence, emphasizing material, earthly entanglements and ongoingness.
5. How does Donna J. Haraway define the Chthulucene in [Staying with the Trouble] and how does it differ from the Anthropocene and Capitalocene?
- Chthulucene as multispecies time: The Chthulucene is a tentacular, multispecies epoch of ongoingness and entanglement, named to evoke chthonic (earthly, underworld) powers that are generative and unruly.
- Critique of Anthropocene: Haraway critiques the Anthropocene for centering human exceptionalism and a geological framing that obscures specific relations and responsibilities.
- Capitalocene’s focus: The Capitalocene highlights capitalism, colonialism, and economic power as drivers of ecological destruction, rather than generic human impact.
- Chthulucene as hopeful alternative: The Chthulucene foregrounds sympoiesis and collaborative worlding, moving beyond blame to foster multispecies kinship and survival.
6. What does "making kin" mean in [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway?
- Kin beyond genealogy: Making kin involves creating relationships that go beyond biological reproduction or traditional family ties, including multispecies, technological, and political connections.
- Ethical and political practice: It is a deliberate, ongoing practice of response-ability, care, and accountability to others—human and nonhuman—to sustain life and flourishing.
- Challenging dominant narratives: Making kin disrupts individualism, human exceptionalism, and capitalist exploitation by fostering alliances and collaborations across differences.
- Speculative and practical examples: Haraway uses both real-world ethnographies and speculative fabulations to show how making kin can be enacted in diverse contexts.
7. How does Donna J. Haraway explain "sympoiesis" in [Staying with the Trouble] and why is it important?
- Definition of sympoiesis: Sympoiesis means "making-with" and refers to collective, distributed processes of living and becoming that are not self-contained but co-produced by multiple agents.
- Contrast with autopoiesis: Unlike autopoiesis (self-making), sympoiesis emphasizes openness, entanglement, and interdependence among organisms and systems.
- Biological and philosophical roots: The concept draws on Lynn Margulis’s work on symbiogenesis and Karen Barad’s agential realism, offering a framework for understanding multispecies assemblages.
- Ethical and political implications: Sympoiesis calls for response-ability and care in multispecies worlds, encouraging collaborative survival strategies in the face of ecological crises.
8. What is the significance of string figures and "sf" (science fiction, speculative fabulation, etc.) in [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway?
- Metaphor for entanglement: String figures, like cat’s cradle, symbolize the complex, dynamic, and relational webs that connect species, humans, and environments.
- Practice of thinking and making: Playing string figures is a form of speculative fabulation and collaborative storytelling that models sympoietic processes.
- "sf" as a method: "sf" stands for science fiction, speculative feminism, speculative fabulation, science fact, and string figures, all braided together to track threads of multispecies worlding.
- Invitation to readers: The metaphor invites readers to engage in making and unmaking relations, staying with the trouble through playful, thoughtful, and material practices.
9. How does [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway critique the Anthropocene and Capitalocene?
- Anthropocene critique: Haraway argues that the Anthropocene centers a problematic figure of "Species Man" and human exceptionalism, which is insufficient for understanding complex multispecies entanglements.
- Capitalocene as alternative: She favors the term Capitalocene to emphasize the roles of capitalism, colonialism, and plantation economies in shaping ecological destruction and social injustice.
- Limits of both terms: Both Anthropocene and Capitalocene risk being too big and deterministic; Haraway calls for more situated, relational stories like the Chthulucene.
- Need for new narratives: The book advocates for new, more situated, and relational stories to foster multispecies flourishing and justice.
10. How does Donna J. Haraway address feminist and indigenous perspectives in [Staying with the Trouble]?
- Feminist theory integration: The book draws on feminist science studies to critique human exceptionalism, dualisms, and to promote situated knowledges and response-ability.
- Indigenous cosmopolitics: Haraway highlights indigenous knowledge systems and struggles, emphasizing their contributions to multispecies kinship and ecological justice.
- Decolonial alliances: The text advocates for coalitions that respect specific histories and urgencies, challenging universalizing narratives and supporting decolonial practices.
- Gender and kinship: It explores non-binary gender, queer kinship, and reproductive justice as central to reimagining multispecies futures.
11. What role do pigeons and pigeon fanciers play in [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway?
- Multispecies collaboration: Pigeons and their human fanciers exemplify companion species relationships, showing how humans and animals co-produce skills, knowledge, and social worlds.
- Ethnographic insights: Haraway draws on detailed ethnographies of pigeon racing communities to illustrate practices of care, love, and mutual transformation.
- Technoscientific projects: The PigeonBlog project, involving artists and scientists, uses pigeons as bio-sensors, blending art, science, and activism in multispecies collaborations.
- Metaphor for kin-making: Pigeons serve as a metaphor for sympoiesis and tentacular thinking, highlighting the entangled, ongoing, and playful nature of multispecies kinship.
12. What are the Camille Stories in [Staying with the Trouble] by Donna J. Haraway and what do they illustrate?
- Speculative fabulations: The Camille Stories are fictional narratives imagining multispecies children born in a damaged world, bonded with butterflies, fungi, and other critters.
- Exploration of kin-making: They illustrate diverse practices of making kin, bodily modifications, and sympoietic relations in speculative futures.
- Engagement with ecological and social issues: The stories address climate change, mining, indigenous struggles, and multispecies flourishing in
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.