Key Takeaways
Two gay men choose adoption, then build a family through uncertainty
The plan was never tidy. Dan and Terry begin the adoption process after two years together, still arguing over music in the car and unsure how to explain their relationship to strangers. Their trip to Portland is not a serene march toward parenthood. It is a nervous visit to an agency seminar where most couples are grieving infertility, while the men experience adoption as an unexpected opportunity they once assumed would be closed to them.
The process takes over. They face paperwork, medical exams, home inspections, fees, and the prospect that a birth mother may never choose them. Then, only a short time after entering the agency pool, they are selected by Melissa, a young woman living on the streets. Their careful timeline collapses. The story follows not a perfect plan, but a family taking shape through improvisation, conflict, and decisions made before anyone feels fully ready.
The memoir's strongest narrative choice is to leave the mess visible. Parenthood is often retold as if desire, readiness, and love arrived in the correct order. Here, they do not. That candor makes the story useful beyond adoption: major commitments often begin before uncertainty has been resolved, and practical systems can turn an abstract wish into a real obligation. Still, one couple's fortunate match cannot establish that every adoption route is equally accessible or humane. The value lies in showing how commitment develops inside an imperfect process, not in offering a universal formula for choosing parenthood.
Choose openness so adoption does not require erasing a child's origins
A different adoption model. In open adoption, the birth mother helps choose the adoptive family, and the child can grow up knowing who their birth parents are. Melissa and Dan and Terry agree on ongoing contact, with a minimum of four visits and two photo exchanges each year, plus monthly phone calls. Those numbers set a floor, not a limit; the adults can agree to more contact.
Truth replaces secrecy. Closed adoption can leave children with unanswered questions about their origins, while open adoption makes their family history part of ordinary life. For two men raising a child, pretending the baby was biologically theirs was never plausible. The agency also argued that contact gives birth mothers information about how their children are doing, rather than leaving them to wonder in isolation. Openness is not simply access to records. It is a relationship that has to be maintained.
What's striking is that openness redistributes knowledge, not just visits. The child does not have to wait until adulthood to discover a hidden history, and the birth mother is not required to vanish for the adoptive family to feel legitimate. This resembles a broader principle in identity formation: people benefit when important parts of their life story can be discussed without shame. Yet contact is not automatically beneficial in every circumstance. A workable arrangement depends on boundaries, reliability, and the child's needs, not on treating openness as a virtue that excuses poor judgment.
Admit your reasons for wanting children, then test them against parenthood's costs
Motives come mixed. Dan describes wanting a meaningful project, fearing an empty old age, and even hoping children would make future weight gain seem understandable. A book deal also nudged the adoption timetable forward, though he says the wish for a child predated it. These jokes puncture the polished story that parents act only from selfless instinct. The couple also recognizes what parenting would cost: less spontaneous sex, fewer parties, and a narrower freedom to travel or indulge.
Honesty is not a permission slip. The comic motives sit beside a serious question: are they prepared to put a child's needs ahead of the adult benefits they imagine? Their decision is not presented as pure, but neither is it presented as a way to repair their relationship or make a child fulfill their unrealized ambitions. They examine the trade-offs and proceed knowing that no motive guarantees a good outcome.
The candor is valuable because idealized accounts can make parents feel defective when their motives include loneliness, identity, or the desire for a fuller life. Naming those motives allows them to be examined instead of disguised. At the same time, describing children as a hobby or defense against mortality risks turning a person into an adult's self-improvement project. The ethical distinction is whether the child is welcomed as an independent person, rather than assigned responsibility for giving the parent purpose. The memoir's humor exposes that tension, but the real test is the daily willingness to meet needs that do not serve the parent's original hopes.
Measure adoption risk with evidence, not the internet's worst-case lists
Fear outruns the facts. Melissa tells the agency she drank during the first part of her pregnancy and used drugs before learning she was pregnant. A couple she chose before Dan and Terry turns her down over the risk of fetal alcohol syndrome, or FAS. The men search online and find sweeping warnings, long symptom lists, and claims that even one drink can endanger a fetus. The lists make them imagine that the baby will be severely harmed.
Experts narrow the question. Specialists review Melissa's account and the ultrasound, which shows normal development. They judge the chance of FAS to be low, while refusing to promise that the child will have no health or learning problems. They also explain that the medical evidence is more uncertain than the websites suggest. Dan and Terry accept the match, not because risk disappears, but because individualized medical advice gives them a better basis for deciding than frightening generalizations do.
This episode captures how online information can convert uncertainty into apparent certainty. A symptom list may be accurate in isolation yet misleading when readers cannot assess probability, context, or alternative causes. The clinicians' refusal to guarantee a healthy child is as important as their reassurance. That is calibrated judgment, not dismissal of risk. The lesson should not be stretched into a claim that prenatal drinking is safe. It is narrower and more useful: high-stakes decisions deserve evidence interpreted for the specific case, with uncertainty stated plainly.
Treat a birth mother as a decision-maker, not a delivery mechanism
Melissa keeps agency. She is not a sentimental symbol of sacrifice. She is a young woman with a life on the street, strong attachments to her animals, and her own views about names, visits, and what she wants her son to know. She chooses Dan and Terry, sets her terms, gives the baby the name David Kevin Pierce, and asks that her family eventually be allowed to meet him if she reconnects with them.
The handoff is painful. When the time comes to leave the hospital, Melissa sobs as Terry carries the baby away. The men see her grief directly, rather than hearing a softened story about a birth mother who simply disappeared. They understand that the adoption rests on trust and on a real loss for her. They preserve her surname, agree to contact, and recognize that she remains part of their child's life even after the legal transfer.
The story resists the familiar rescue narrative in which adoptive parents appear as heroes and the birth mother becomes a brief obstacle or blessing. Melissa's choices and grief remain visible, even though the adults have unequal resources and the adoptive couple ultimately takes the baby home. That imbalance makes ethical safeguards essential: consent should be informed, expenses should not become leverage, and a birth parent's wishes should not be confused with an obligation to surrender. Respect does not mean assuming every request can be met. It means taking the person and the consequences of the decision seriously.
Polite tolerance can still leave gay families unsure they belong
Neutral faces hide uncertainty. At the Portland seminar, Dan scans a room of straight couples, wondering which people disapprove of two men adopting. He cannot tell whether a courteous smile signals acceptance, indifference, or concealed prejudice. The book connects that ambiguity to a wider political climate in which opposition to gay people is often framed as concern for children or compassion for gay people themselves.
Families are already real. The memoir reports a federal estimate of six to fourteen million children then being raised by gay or lesbian parents. The limited research available to the author suggested those children were doing well, yet the political debate often treated gay families as hypothetical. Dan and Terry's experience makes the stakes concrete: the question is not only whether gay men may adopt, but whether established families can live without being treated as provisional.
The account identifies a distinctive burden of stigma: when hostility becomes socially impolite, the targeted person must interpret a blank expression without reliable evidence. That can foster vigilance, but suspicion also has a cost, since it can make genuine allies hard to recognize. The memoir does not offer a simple solution; it shows why individual courtesy cannot substitute for legal and institutional acceptance. The reported estimate and research findings also belong to their historical moment, and should not be mistaken for a complete modern evidence review. Their lasting point is that policy debates affect children already living in these families.
Let repeated care, not one cinematic feeling, define becoming a parent
Love is not instantaneous. When Dan first holds the newborn at the hospital, he feels almost nothing and worries that something is wrong with him. Terry, by contrast, is visibly moved. A heart murmur briefly raises fears for the baby's health, making emotional distance feel like self-protection. The memoir refuses the familiar scene in which a parent sees a newborn and is instantly transformed.
Care builds the bond. At home, parenting becomes bottles, diapers, late nights, medical questions, and learning what the baby's cries and habits mean. Terry performs much of that work while Dan continues earning money. Dan notices that his sense of fatherhood grows through participation and time, not through biology or a legal document alone. A parent identity takes shape in ordinary acts, repeated until the child and adults recognize a shared life.
This portrayal is a useful counterweight to the expectation that attachment must arrive as a dramatic emotional revelation. Caregiving can be both an action and a relationship: repeated responsiveness gives adults and children a history together. That perspective can ease shame for parents who feel numb, anxious, or slower to bond. It should not become a new rule that love must be earned through labor, or imply that biological parents are less real. The memoir's more precise insight is that legal status, emotion, and daily care do not always synchronize, and family life gives them time to converge.
Refuse respectability tests that make gay parenthood conditional
No perfect representatives. A gay activist tells Dan and Terry that gay parents should be older, long-term partners, professionally successful, monogamous, and especially unthreatening while adoption faces political opposition. He and Terry do not fit that idealized profile. Dan has written frankly about sex, and neither man wants to pretend that parenting requires disowning a complicated past. They continue with the adoption rather than waiting to become a model couple for skeptical observers.
Visibility changes the argument. Opponents can portray gay parents as dangerous more easily when gay families remain abstract. A real child, cared for by two ordinary men, challenges that story through daily life rather than slogans. But Dan also resists the burden of having to prove that every gay parent is exemplary. The point is not that a family's choices are beyond scrutiny. It is that parenthood should not depend on passing a special moral test that straight parents are rarely asked to take.
Respectability can be a tactical response to discrimination: presenting an impeccable public image may reassure institutions and protect vulnerable families. Its danger is that it accepts the premise that a minority group must earn rights through exceptional behavior. The memoir argues for ordinary visibility, not a demand that every queer person become a public example. That distinction matters. Representation can weaken stereotypes, but legal protections should not depend on one family's ability to perform perfect domesticity. A fair standard evaluates caregiving and safety consistently, rather than treating identity itself as evidence of risk.
Analysis
The book's central achievement is to make adoption both intimate and political without reducing either dimension to the other. Dan Savage tells the story through comedy, including fights over music, awkward agency interviews, and his own less-than-heroic motives. The humor is not decoration. It lets the narrative question the sentimental scripts adults use to explain family, while still giving the birth mother's grief and the couple's fear real weight.
Its account of open adoption is especially persuasive because the principle is embodied in practical choices: Melissa selects the family, negotiates contact, names her son, and remains visible at the moment of separation. The book shows how openness can protect a child's access to personal history and give a birth parent knowledge rather than silence. It does not prove that every open arrangement works. Contact requires boundaries, and the adults' hopes may change over time. The memoir's case is strongest as an argument against treating secrecy as the default, not as evidence that openness removes conflict.
The narrative also exposes unequal standards. Fertile people can become parents without proving their fitness in advance, while adoptive applicants submit to financial, medical, and domestic scrutiny. Gay men face another layer: their private lives are often treated as relevant evidence about their capacity to care for a child. The account makes that double standard legible without claiming Dan and Terry are flawless parents.
Because the book was published in 1999, its legal descriptions, political references, and research summaries are historical. They should not be used as current legal or scientific guidance. The story remains valuable for its method: it puts policy inside a lived family, where questions about rights become questions about a child, a birth parent, and the adults who undertake care. Its deepest contribution is not a recipe for adoption, but a refusal to make family legitimacy depend on biology, secrecy, or respectability.
Review Summary
The Kid receives generally positive reviews for its humor, honesty, and insight into the adoption process for a gay couple. Readers appreciate Savage's frank writing style and personal reflections, though some find his language too explicit. The book offers a touching account of becoming parents through open adoption, addressing political and social issues along the way. While a few readers criticize aspects of the adoption or Savage's views, most find it an engaging and informative read that balances humor with serious topics.
People Also Read
Glossary
Open adoption
Ongoing birth-family contactAn adoption arrangement in which the birth mother helps select the adoptive family and maintains agreed contact with the child and adoptive parents. Contact may include visits, phone calls, and photos. In the book, the agreement sets minimum levels of contact, while leaving room for the adults to arrange more.
disruption
An adoption that falls throughAdoption-agency language for a planned placement that does not proceed, often because a birth parent changes their mind or the adoptive family withdraws. In the memoir, another gay couple's adoption is disrupted after the birth mother's family pressures her to keep the baby. The experience shows how emotionally painful an uncertain placement can be.
birthparent letter
Adoptive-family introductionA letter written by prospective adoptive parents for birth mothers considering families for their children. Dan and Terry describe their lives, relationship, home, relatives, and hopes for parenting. The agency includes the letter with photographs and other material so a birth mother can decide which family she wants to meet.
DG kids
Children needing extra supportDan Savage's shorthand for children in state care who have experienced abuse or neglect and may have physical, emotional, or developmental needs. The phrase reflects the memoir's informal, sometimes uncomfortable language about adoption. The author describes how many prospective parents seek healthy infants, leaving older children and children with special needs harder to place.
Susan Scenario
Imagined birth-mother matchThe name Dan gives to his imagined best-case explanation for how a birth mother might choose two gay men: a young woman from a fundamentalist family becomes pregnant, rejects her parents' preferred plans, and selects Dan and Terry. The fantasy helps him write their introduction letter, but the actual birth mother, Melissa, has a different background.
Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
Effects of prenatal alcohol exposureA pattern of possible physical and developmental effects associated with alcohol exposure during pregnancy. In the book, fear of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome leads Dan and Terry to seek specialist advice about Melissa's drinking before she knew she was pregnant. The doctors describe the risk in this specific case as low, while cautioning that no assessment can guarantee a child's future health.
DINK
Two incomes, no childrenAn acronym for a couple with two incomes and no children. Dan uses it to describe the comfortable, flexible life he and Terry might have continued: travel, leisure, and shared spending without parenting responsibilities. The term frames the choice to adopt as a deliberate trade-off rather than an inevitable step in adulthood.
Younger Brother Dynamics
Relentless sibling-style teasingDan's description of how he and Terry turn conflict into prolonged teasing, persistence, and playful fighting, which sometimes continues after it stops being fun. He connects the pattern to both men being younger brothers. The concept helps explain their arguments without presenting the relationship as free of real hurt.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.