Key Takeaways
When shelves are empty, whoever controls access becomes the real economic power
Shortage made access currency. In the Soviet economy, money could not reliably buy scarce goods. A Moscow teacher named Irina Makarova spotted toilet paper at a station and bought twenty rolls, even though she had gone out hoping to find chicken. Next time, she might find chicken instead. Survival depended on connections, timing, and knowing who controlled the goods.
A hidden system kept life moving. People called personal networks svyazi, or connections, and used blat to obtain goods and favors through those networks. These practices ranged from finding a doctor to diverting supplies from state warehouses. The shadow economy was not separate from official life: workers, managers, and officials used state institutions to trade what the official system could not provide.
What's striking is that these networks were both an adaptation and a source of unequal power. They solved immediate coordination problems that central planning could not handle, much as informal networks often do when formal systems fail. But access through personal ties favors insiders and makes rules unpredictable. The same mechanism can help a family find medicine and help a powerful manager capture public goods. Informality is not inherently virtuous or corrupt; its effects depend on who controls the bottleneck and whether anyone can challenge that control.
Free markets arrived before rules, so connections converted public weakness into private fortunes
Reform opened doors unevenly. Gorbachev’s cooperative laws allowed private businesses and even cooperative banks, but they did not create dependable courts, transparent accounting, or reliable enforcement. Smolensky, once a construction boss who printed Bibles illegally, began with a cooperative building cottages. He then used a legal opening to start Bank Stolichny, partly to escape the state bank’s control over his money.
The state remained the prize. In the final Soviet years, the government controlled most capital, resources, and foreign trade. Entrepreneurs made quick profits by exploiting gaps between official prices and market prices, or by obtaining access to public credit and accounts. The result was a rough early capitalism in which personal connections often mattered more than open competition, and the boundary between business and state property remained blurred.
The sequence of reform matters as much as the reforms themselves. Opening markets can unleash initiative, but when enforcement is weak, the best-connected actors can turn the transition into a contest over access rather than productivity. This is a useful distinction between creating private ownership and creating a market order. The book also avoids treating every early entrepreneur as a simple criminal: many operated in a legal vacuum created by the state itself. That context explains behavior, but it does not erase the costs imposed on people without connections.
Prices can coordinate millions of choices better than Gosplan's paper targets
Planning lost its signal. At Gosplan, the central agency that set Soviet production targets, mathematician Vitaly Naishul saw planners alter calculations to fit desired conclusions. The system appeared to command factories, but managers were bargaining, hoarding supplies, and trading favors across the bureaucracy. Its plans covered tens of thousands of goods, yet still failed to match what people wanted.
Shortages exposed the design flaw. A state-set car price could be far below the cost of production, while demand exceeded supply and buyers waited years. In the late Soviet period, reform-minded economists including Anatoly Chubais studied economist János Kornai’s account of shortages and Friedrich Hayek’s argument that prices carry information. Prices can signal scarcity across many producers and consumers without one office directing every adjustment.
The case for prices here is not that markets are automatically fair, but that they process dispersed information more quickly than a central plan can. This insight applies beyond economics: complex systems often need feedback from participants closest to the problem. Yet a price signal does not answer questions of power, access, or basic need. A market can allocate efficiently while leaving essential goods unaffordable. The book’s strongest implication is therefore institutional: price freedom needs rules that prevent private control from replacing public planning with private command.
Privatization broke state ownership, but gave insiders and financiers the first move
Ownership changed rapidly. After the Soviet collapse, Anatoly Chubais helped distribute privatization vouchers to nearly the whole population. About 144 million people collected them. Citizens could trade vouchers for shares, but many lacked reliable information or immediate cash. In the first large factory sale, Bolshevik Biscuit sold for about $654,000, a fraction of the value of comparable companies abroad.
Insiders kept leverage. Chubais accepted a plan giving workers and managers control of 51 percent of many companies because he believed privatization would otherwise stall. The choice moved assets out of state hands, but it also left many former factory directors in control. Vouchers widened formal ownership; they did not ensure that citizens could evaluate shares, govern companies, or protect their interests.
The distinction between ownership and governance is crucial. A voucher can create a legal claim without creating the skills, information, or institutions needed to exercise it. The reformers faced a genuine political constraint: preserving the privatization process may have required concessions to factory insiders. Still, speed had distributional consequences. When buyers know more than sellers and courts cannot enforce obligations, a formally broad transfer can concentrate practical control. The book makes the policy trade-off vivid without pretending that a cleaner alternative was easy to execute.
Easy money rewarded trading state distortions, not building productive businesses
The quickest profits came from imbalances. Soviet-era prices, scarce goods, inflation, and state credit created opportunities for arbitrage, meaning buying cheaply in one market and selling at a higher price elsewhere. Andrei Melnichenko, still a university student, exchanged rubles and dollars for commodity traders. During inflation, borrowed rubles lost value quickly, creating large gains for those who could move money fast.
Paper promises multiplied the risk. Sergei Mavrodi’s MMM sold investment certificates with spectacular promised returns, paying early investors with money from newcomers. Millions were deceived when the scheme collapsed. Berezovsky’s AVVA also raised money from the public for a promised car factory, but used funds to acquire a stake in Avtovaz. The cases differed in structure, but both show how financial engineering could outpace productive investment and public understanding.
A financial boom teaches people what the system rewards. When money can be made faster through currency bets, state accounts, or paper claims than through building a business, talent migrates toward extraction. That is not simply a moral failing by individual traders; it is a design problem in incentives and oversight. The cases also should not be collapsed into one category: MMM was a pyramid scheme, while AVVA presented a real industrial ambition that did not materialize as promised. Both depended on investors having little power to verify claims.
The oligarchs bought political insurance, then used television to help choose Russia's president
Business needed political protection. In 1994, bankers and industrialists met at a private club on Sparrow Hills and discussed rules against using media or law enforcement to attack one another. The agreement soon failed. Some members built private security services and gathered compromising material on rivals, known as kompromat.
Television became leverage. Berezovsky gained influence over the national Channel 1, while Gusinsky built NTV, an independent channel that gained public trust through its coverage of the Chechen war. In 1996, both backed Boris Yeltsin against Communist candidate Gennady Zyuganov. Their channels gave Yeltsin favorable coverage, while campaign operatives used misleading propaganda and hidden financing. Many journalists supported Yeltsin sincerely, fearing a return to Communist rule, but the alliance weakened the distinction between independent reporting and political campaigning.
The media story complicates any easy opposition between censorship and freedom. NTV’s reporting could challenge state narratives, yet ownership also gave its backer political leverage. During an election framed as a choice between political systems, journalists could plausibly view advocacy as defense of their own freedom. That motive matters, but so does the precedent: once a channel becomes a campaign instrument, future governments can treat it as a political asset rather than an independent institution. Editorial autonomy needs protections that survive changes in ownership and political fear.
Loans for shares traded public assets for Yeltsin's survival and oligarch loyalty
A political bargain became a sale. In 1995, the cash-strapped government accepted loans from selected banks in exchange for shares in major companies as collateral. Everyone expected the government to default, allowing the lenders to sell the shares and keep control. The auctions were widely shaped by the intended buyers, and foreign competitors were often excluded.
The prizes were enormous. Potanin gained Norilsk Nickel for a bid barely above the opening price. Khodorkovsky’s Menatep secured Yukos, and Berezovsky gained Sibneft. Chubais supported the arrangement partly because he feared a Communist victory and wanted business leaders invested in Yeltsin’s reelection. The assets were later sold back to the winning insiders at near-original prices. The state raised little, while the new owners gained vast resources.
This episode shows how an economic decision can become a commitment device in politics. The oligarchs acquired property, while Yeltsin gained powerful allies with a direct stake in his survival. Chubais believed the bargain protected reform from reversal, but it also made the state dependent on private fortunes and media power. The arrangement’s defenders could point to urgency and the risk of Communist restoration. The deeper cost was institutional: once the government selects winners through opaque deals, future actors learn that influence can outperform competition.
When the 1998 debt pyramid cracked, elites protected themselves and households paid
Borrowing hid a fiscal crisis. Russia’s short-term government bonds, known as GKOs, expanded from about $3 billion outstanding at the end of 1994 to about $70 billion by mid-1998. Much of the borrowing paid off earlier debt rather than funding the budget. At the same time, falling oil prices and investor flight weakened the ruble and drained Central Bank reserves.
The collapse spread quickly. On August 17, 1998, Russia defaulted on domestic debt and devalued the ruble. The government also imposed a moratorium on some foreign debt payments, giving banks time to avoid immediate obligations. Ordinary depositors had no comparable shield. SBS-Agro’s clients lost access to savings, while the middle class saw businesses, jobs, and purchasing power vanish. The crisis exposed how private bets and public guarantees had become entangled.
The crisis illustrates the danger of financing long-term political and economic promises with short-term liabilities. A currency peg, high-yield debt, and foreign borrowing can appear stable while confidence holds, then fail together when investors retreat. The moratorium reveals a distributional asymmetry: powerful borrowers could negotiate breathing room, while households had little recourse. Yet the book also shows that the government feared a total banking collapse, not merely elite losses. In a crisis, the hard question is not whether to intervene, but whose balance sheet gets protected first.
Putin did not end oligarchy; he transferred its wealth-power bargain to the state
The new ruler changed the terms. After Vladimir Putin came to power, he pressured media magnates Gusinsky and Berezovsky to leave Russia and told remaining tycoons not to challenge the Kremlin. In 2003, Mikhail Khodorkovsky was arrested, Yukos was broken apart, and valuable assets went to state-owned Rosneft. The first generation’s conspicuous billionaires gave way to a quieter circle of officials and security-service associates with business interests.
Formal institutions remained fragile. Courts, elections, companies, and news outlets continued to exist, but the Khodorkovsky trials showed how political power could shape legal outcomes. The system did not dissolve the connection between wealth and government. It changed who controlled the connection, moving from visible private tycoons to a more centralized state and its allies.
The shift from private oligarchs to state-linked elites is not the same as eliminating oligarchy. It changes where decisions are made and how visible the beneficiaries are. Centralization can reduce open conflict among competing magnates, but without independent courts and political checks it can also make selective enforcement easier. The book’s closing warning is institutional rather than nostalgic: neither Yeltsin’s freewheeling privatization nor Putin’s managed order established impartial rules. Stability without constraints may quiet the contest while preserving its underlying bargain.
Analysis
The book’s central argument is about sequence. Soviet command structures weakened, private initiative surfaced, and reformers released prices and property before Russia had institutions capable of protecting competition. This sequence gave adaptable entrepreneurs room to build businesses, but it also made access to the state a more valuable asset than productive capacity. The oligarchs were not simply outsiders who captured a finished system. They emerged from the old economy’s shortages, patronage networks, ministries, youth organizations, and security structures, then used those same connections in the new one.
The narrative resists a clean division between heroic reformers and villains. Chubais and Gaidar faced real urgency: shortages, collapsing authority, and the possibility of political reversal. Their rapid transfer of ownership was not irrational in context. But the choice to prioritize speed over institutional safeguards created predictable vulnerabilities. Vouchers spread formal claims without equalizing knowledge or power; loans for shares converted a political alliance into private control of public assets. The system’s failures were therefore not merely the sum of individual greed. They were built into the incentives and enforcement gaps.
The book’s strongest explanatory thread is the repeated conversion of public weakness into private advantage. First it appears in informal access to scarce goods, then in state credit and financial arbitrage, then in privatization, media ownership, and finally political influence. The 1998 crash reveals the cost of this structure: private actors relied on public guarantees, but households had few protections when the guarantees failed. Putin’s centralization altered the cast and reduced the visibility of private kingmakers, yet the Khodorkovsky case suggests that legal form alone cannot create rule of law when political authority can decide whom it reaches.
One limitation of the narrative is that its compelling individual portraits can make structural outcomes seem more dependent on a handful of personalities than they were. Still, those portraits clarify how institutions are made and broken through decisions that appear tactical at the time. The durable lesson is not that markets should have waited indefinitely, but that market creation and institution-building are not separate projects. Each defines whether the other produces competition or capture.
Review Summary
The Oligarchs is praised for its comprehensive account of Russia's transition from communism to capitalism in the 1990s. Readers appreciate Hoffman's detailed research and engaging storytelling, though some find it overly long. The book offers valuable insights into the rise of Russian oligarchs and their influence on politics. It is considered essential reading for understanding contemporary Russia, despite occasional repetition and dense financial details. Many reviewers highlight its relevance to current events and Putin's rise to power.
Glossary
blat
Favor-based accessA Soviet-era practice of using personal relationships and reciprocal favors to obtain scarce goods or services that could not reliably be purchased through official channels. It might help someone get food, medical attention, or an institutional place. The practice grew because state distribution failed, but it also gave special influence to people who controlled useful connections.
svyazi
Personal connection networksThe networks of friends, relatives, colleagues, and acquaintances people relied on to obtain goods, services, and opportunities in the Soviet shortage economy. These ties operated across households, workplaces, and regions. They were a practical alternative to unreliable official distribution, but access depended on social position and could reinforce insider advantage.
beznalichnye
Non-cash accounting fundsA Soviet accounting form of money used by enterprises and institutions, recorded in accounts rather than held as banknotes. It could be transferred between organizations but generally could not be used as cash for wages or personal spending. Because cash was scarce and more valuable, the gap between the two forms created opportunities to convert state subsidies into spendable money.
soft budget constraint
Rescue despite poor performanceEconomist János Kornai’s term for a system in which firms expect the state to keep supplying resources even when they perform badly. Because enterprises are not allowed to fail, they have weaker incentives to control costs or satisfy consumers. The book uses the concept to explain why subsidies and production targets sustained shortages and shoddy goods.
voucher
Claim on privatized propertyThe informal name for the Russian privatization check distributed to citizens after the Soviet collapse. It had a stated face value and could be exchanged for shares in state enterprises, deposited in investment funds, or sold. The voucher program involved millions of people, but many sold cheaply or lacked the information and power to protect their interests.
loans for shares
Loans secured by state-company sharesA 1995 scheme in which selected banks lent money to the Russian government and received shares in major companies as collateral. The government was widely expected not to repay the loans, allowing lenders to take control of the shares. Auctions were often shaped to favor the banks involved, transferring valuable assets to a small group at low prices.
GKOs
Short-term ruble government bondsThe Russian acronym for short-term government obligations, generally denominated in rubles and issued for periods such as three or six months. High yields made GKOs attractive to banks and investors, but the government increasingly used new issues to pay off maturing debt. By 1998, the growing debt burden helped make default unavoidable.
authorized banks
Banks handling state accountsCommercial banks selected to hold and distribute government funds in the years when Russia lacked a functioning central treasury. These banks were meant to pass money to regions, enterprises, or public programs. Some used the funds for their own short-term investments, delaying or replacing the required payments and profiting from their privileged access.
state capture
Private influence over public decisionsA term used in the book for the process by which businesses and powerful financial groups shape government decisions to serve their own interests. In 1990s Russia, this went beyond lobbying: oligarchs gained influence over privatization, state accounts, media, and political outcomes. It describes a government whose choices are steered by those who possess wealth and access.
khozyain
Practical domain managerA Russian term for a person seen as the responsible manager or master of a household, enterprise, city, or other domain. In the book, it captures Yuri Luzhkov’s self-image as a hands-on administrator who took responsibility for Moscow and expected authority to match that responsibility. The term also points to a leadership style centered on personal control rather than impersonal rules.
FAQ
1. What is The Oligarchs: Wealth and Power in the New Russia by David E. Hoffman about?
- Chronicle of Russia’s transformation: The book details Russia’s tumultuous shift from Soviet socialism to market capitalism in the 1980s and 1990s, focusing on the rise of a new class of powerful businessmen known as oligarchs.
- Profiles of key figures: Hoffman follows six central figures—Boris Berezovsky, Anatoly Chubais, Vladimir Gusinsky, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Yuri Luzhkov, and Alexander Smolensky—tracing their personal journeys and influence.
- Themes of power, corruption, and reform: The narrative explores how these men exploited systemic weaknesses, manipulated political power, and shaped the new Russian economy, while also facing internal rivalries and state backlash.
- Historical and political context: The book situates their rise within the collapse of the Soviet Union, chaotic privatization, the 1998 financial crisis, and the consolidation of power under Vladimir Putin.
2. Why should I read The Oligarchs by David E. Hoffman?
- Insight into Russian capitalism: The book offers a rare, detailed look at the birth of Russia’s oligarchic capitalism, revealing the mechanisms of wealth accumulation and political influence in a post-communist society.
- Humanizing complex figures: Hoffman provides in-depth portraits of the major oligarchs, making the broader economic and political analysis accessible and compelling through personal stories.
- Relevance to modern Russia: Understanding the oligarchs’ rise is essential for grasping contemporary Russian politics, the origins of Putin’s regime, and ongoing struggles over power and wealth.
- Lessons on reform and institutions: The book highlights the risks of rapid economic reform without strong institutions and rule of law, offering broader lessons for other societies in transition.
3. Who are the main oligarchs profiled in The Oligarchs and what roles did they play in Russia’s transformation?
- Boris Berezovsky: A mathematician turned media and oil magnate, Berezovsky was a key power broker, instrumental in Yeltsin’s 1996 reelection, and later clashed with Putin, leading to his exile.
- Anatoly Chubais: The architect of Russia’s privatization, Chubais managed the controversial loans-for-shares auctions and sought to build market institutions as a reformist technocrat.
- Vladimir Gusinsky: Founder of Media-Most and NTV, Gusinsky pioneered independent media but was eventually forced out by the Kremlin, highlighting the risks of media ownership.
- Mikhail Khodorkovsky: Builder of Yukos oil, Khodorkovsky’s aggressive business tactics and later push for transparency made him both a symbol of oligarchic capitalism and a target for Putin.
- Yuri Luzhkov and Alexander Smolensky: Luzhkov, as Moscow’s mayor, blended business and politics, while Smolensky’s banking empire collapsed in the 1998 crisis, illustrating the fragility of Russia’s financial system.
4. What was the economic and political context in Russia during the rise of the oligarchs, according to David E. Hoffman?
- Soviet stagnation and shortages: The late Soviet era was marked by chronic shortages, a thriving shadow economy, and reliance on personal connections (blat) to navigate daily life.
- Perestroika and glasnost reforms: Gorbachev’s reforms in the 1980s allowed limited private enterprise and loosened ideological controls, creating openings for entrepreneurial activity.
- Collapse and chaos: The Soviet Union’s collapse led to a power vacuum, economic turmoil, and the rapid privatization of state assets amid weak legal and political institutions.
- Opportunity for oligarchs: This environment enabled a handful of savvy businessmen to amass wealth and influence by exploiting systemic gaps and forging political connections.
5. How did privatization and the “loans-for-shares” scheme work in Russia, as described in The Oligarchs?
- Mass privatization and vouchers: The government distributed vouchers to citizens, which could be exchanged for shares in former state enterprises, but most ended up in the hands of a few.
- Loans-for-shares auctions: The state borrowed money from private banks, offering shares in major companies as collateral; when the government defaulted, the banks kept the shares at bargain prices.
- Rigged and insider-driven: Auctions were often manipulated, with banks acting as both organizers and bidders, excluding outsiders and ensuring oligarchs acquired valuable assets.
- Concentration of wealth: These schemes rapidly transferred Russia’s industrial crown jewels to a small group, fueling the rise of the oligarchs and deepening inequality.
6. What role did the shadow economy and the concept of “blat” play in the rise of the oligarchs in The Oligarchs?
- Shadow economy as survival: Chronic shortages led to a vast unofficial economy where goods and services were traded outside official channels, fostering entrepreneurial skills.
- Blat as social currency: Personal connections (blat) were essential for obtaining scarce goods or favors, creating informal networks of power and resource allocation.
- Foundation for oligarchic power: The oligarchs emerged from this environment, using their networks and savvy to exploit the system’s weaknesses and turn informal influence into formal economic and political power.
- Legacy in new capitalism: These practices persisted into the post-Soviet era, shaping the culture of business and politics in Russia’s new economy.
7. How did media ownership and control factor into the power of oligarchs like Berezovsky and Gusinsky in The Oligarchs?
- Media as a political tool: Oligarchs invested heavily in television channels (ORT and NTV) to influence public opinion and political outcomes, supporting allies and attacking rivals.
- Control over news and advertising: Berezovsky centralized advertising revenues and controlled news content, while Gusinsky built a reputation for independent journalism, especially during the Chechen war.
- Battleground for influence: Media ownership became a key arena for power struggles, with smear campaigns and kompromat (compromising material) used to sway politics.
- Conflict with the Kremlin: As Putin consolidated power, he targeted independent media, using legal and financial pressure to bring outlets under Kremlin control.
8. What was the significance of the 1998 Russian financial crisis in The Oligarchs and how did it affect the oligarchs?
- Crisis overview: The ruble crash and government default on bonds triggered a banking collapse and economic turmoil, exposing the fragility of Russia’s financial system.
- Impact on oligarchs: Many, including Smolensky, Gusinsky, and Khodorkovsky, faced severe financial stress as their banks and companies suffered liquidity shortages and loss of foreign credit.
- Political and public backlash: The crisis undermined trust in both the government and oligarchs, fueling public resentment and political instability.
- Turning point for power: The crisis marked the end of the wild 1990s capitalism and paved the way for Putin’s rise and the reassertion of state control.
9. How did the oligarchs influence Russian politics, particularly during Boris Yeltsin’s 1996 reelection campaign, according to David E. Hoffman?
- Formation of the Davos Pact: Leading oligarchs formed an alliance to support Yeltsin’s reelection, pooling resources and media control to counter the Communist threat.
- Media dominance: They used their control of major television channels and newspapers to launch a massive pro-Yeltsin campaign and discredit opponents.
- Financial and strategic support: Oligarchs funded campaign operations, provided strategic advice, and helped organize a modern, Western-style campaign.
- Kingmakers in politics: Their influence made them central players in Russian politics, shaping electoral outcomes and government policy.
10. What was the “bankers’ war” and how did it shape the oligarchs’ relationships and Russia’s economy in The Oligarchs?
- Definition and trigger: The bankers’ war was a fierce power struggle among leading oligarchs in 1997, sparked by the contested auction of Svyazinvest, the state telecom company.
- Media and political battles: Oligarchs used their media empires to attack rivals and influence public opinion, while engaging in behind-the-scenes political maneuvering.
- Fracturing alliances: The conflict fractured the oligarchic alliance, paralyzed reform efforts, and weakened the government’s ability to manage the economy.
- Prelude to crisis: The instability contributed to the conditions leading up to the 1998 financial crisis.
11. What are the key takeaways from The Oligarchs by David E. Hoffman?
- Intertwining of wealth and power: The book shows how oligarchs gained not just wealth but political influence, becoming kingmakers and power brokers in post-Soviet Russia.
- Privatization’s dark side: Rapid privatization without transparency led to corruption, concentration of wealth, and political instability.
- Fragility of reform: Infighting among oligarchs and weak institutions made economic reform difficult and unstable.
- Media’s critical role: Control of television and newspapers was a crucial tool for influencing politics and public opinion, but also made oligarchs targets for state retaliation.
12. How did Vladimir Putin’s rise change the relationship between the Russian state and the oligarchs, as described in The Oligarchs?
- Putin’s consolidation of power: Putin initially relied on oligarchs but soon moved to control or neutralize them, reasserting state authority over business and
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.