Key Takeaways
Treat a devoted friend as a possible life partner, not a supporting character
Friendship can organize a life. Rhaina Cohen’s friendship with M brought the intensity, care, and daily closeness she had associated with romance, despite neither friend wanting sex with the other. Andrew and Toly built a life around their friendship through shared homes, work, and major decisions. Cohen calls relationships like these platonic partnerships: committed friendships that function as central partnerships without necessarily being romantic or sexual.
The past offers precedents. Medieval sworn brothers could pledge lifelong support in church, share households, and sometimes choose each other as heirs. Women in nineteenth-century Boston marriages also built lasting shared lives. These examples show that today’s sharp ranking of spouse above friend is not timeless or inevitable.
The central shift is from asking whether a friendship resembles marriage to asking what the people involved actually promise and provide. That functional lens makes intimacy legible without requiring a sexual explanation. History strengthens the argument by showing that relationship categories change with social expectations, though historical examples cannot prove that past arrangements were identical to today’s. The useful implication is modest but powerful: a friendship need not imitate a spouse to deserve seriousness. Its own commitments can be the point.
Spread emotional needs across relationships instead of demanding one person do everything
One person is a fragile system. Contemporary couples are often expected to provide sex, friendship, emotional counsel, caregiving, companionship, and more. Cohen describes this as one-stop-shopping coupledom. When one relationship must meet every need, its ordinary shortcomings can feel catastrophic, while friendships are left underused.
Kami and Tilly show another arrangement. Tilly helped Kami raise her children, offered emotional support, and stayed present through her daughter’s serious medical needs. That friendship gave Kami somewhere to vent before her husband came home, easing pressure on their marriage. Research described in the book also links satisfaction with support outside marriage to lower stress during marital conflict. A broader relationship portfolio can strengthen a couple rather than compete with it.
This is a systems insight as much as a relationship insight: concentrating every function in one person creates a single point of failure. Distributing support can make each tie more durable because no one bond must carry the whole emotional load. The caution is that more relationships also require time, coordination, and negotiation. Tilly and Kami’s arrangement works because the support is trusted and reciprocal in meaning, even when their contributions differ. The lesson is not to divide care mechanically, but to stop treating one relationship as the only legitimate place to seek it.
Separate the need for attachment from the need for sex
Closeness has more than one route. Psychologist Lisa Diamond’s interviews with eighty women who identified as lesbian, bisexual, or unlabeled found that seventy had experienced an emotionally intense, largely nonsexual friendship. Diamond called these passionate friendships. They could include constant companionship, cuddling, hand-holding, and preoccupation, without necessarily involving sexual desire.
Stacey and Grace illustrate the distinction. Stacey, who later understood themself as asexual, found in Grace a primary person and teammate, despite their relationship not fitting a conventional sexual partnership. Cohen also explains that psychologists distinguish sexual desire from attachment, the bond built through time, presence, and touch. People vary in which forms of physical closeness feel intimate. Sex can matter deeply, but it is not the only evidence of love or partnership.
The distinction helps disentangle experiences that cultural language often bundles together: attraction, desire, attachment, and commitment. That can be especially clarifying for people whose relationships do not match familiar scripts, including asexual people and friends whose affection is misread. It also resists the opposite mistake of declaring sex irrelevant. For many couples, sex is meaningful and wanted. The more accurate claim is that sexual activity is neither a universal measure of intimacy nor a prerequisite for a durable bond.
Question whether male discomfort signals a boundary or inherited policing
Masculinity narrows the emotional range. Art, a gay Christian, and Nick, a straight Christian, built a committed friendship while Nick questioned assumptions about what men are allowed to do together. Nick initially worried that vacationing or showing affection with Art would make others think he was gay. The sociologist Eric Anderson calls fear of being perceived as gay homohysteria.
They learned to investigate discomfort. Their practical questions were: Is the concern moral, cultural, or personal? Nick found that some unease came from his upbringing, while some touch genuinely felt unpleasant because of sensory overload. This helped him set real boundaries without treating every discomfort as proof that affection was wrong. Their friendship also challenged the expectation that men should reserve emotional intimacy for romantic partners.
The three-part inquiry is useful because it avoids two simplistic responses: obey every discomfort, or dismiss every discomfort as prejudice. A feeling can signal a genuine limit, a learned social rule, or both. Separating these sources gives people room to choose rather than react automatically. The framework also exposes how gender norms can redirect care: when men are discouraged from emotional openness with friends, partners may inherit an unfair share of their support needs. Examining the norm does not require every man to become physically demonstrative.
Let sustained care, not romance or biology, establish family
Parenting is a practice. Natasha chose to have a child on her own. Her friend Lynda offered to support the birth, then became a steady caregiver to Natasha’s son, Elaan, who had significant disabilities. Lynda accompanied medical appointments, helped make treatment decisions, and shared daily care. Years later, she sought legal recognition as Elaan’s second parent. Because the law did not provide a straightforward route for unmarried friends, the family had to pursue a declaration of parentage.
Function can matter more than form. Lynda and Natasha’s case challenged the assumption that co-parents must be romantic partners. The book also notes that family law has increasingly recognized intended and caregiving relationships, while research cited on diverse family structures finds that children can thrive in warm, stable homes of different forms.
The story shifts the question from adult couple status to a child’s actual network of care. That is a consequential reframing, especially when legal protections determine who can make medical decisions or provide security. It also invites a practical distinction: affection alone does not automatically make someone a parent; sustained responsibility, shared expectations, and the child’s welfare matter. Any policy built around caregiving should therefore assess duties and reliability, not simply expand labels without safeguards.
Build later-life care with trusted friends before crisis makes choices
A spouse is no guarantee. Barb and Inez met at work, became part of one another’s family lives, and eventually shared a home for companionship, finances, and mutual care. After Inez’s health scare, they arranged legal authority for one another to make medical decisions. Their friendship also helped them support Ann, a friend with cancer who had no close family. They accompanied her through treatment and ensured she was not alone at the end of her life.
The need is growing. The book describes more older adults living without a spouse or close family able to provide care. Sharing a home can reduce isolation and expenses, but it does not erase the cost of long-term care or guarantee that friends can meet every medical need. Planning should include legal documents, explicit conversations, and a wider circle of support.
Barb and Inez make care visible as an everyday practice, not a benefit automatically delivered by marriage or kinship. Their example also turns friendship from an emotional luxury into a form of infrastructure. Yet informal care has limits: friends can age together, have their own health crises, or lack the resources for intensive support. Strong planning combines chosen relationships with accessible professional care and clear legal authority. The point is not that friends should replace public services, but that policy and planning should stop assuming every older person has an available spouse or child.
Give friendship loss the rituals and time grief requires
A friendship can be mourned while it continues. Cohen describes her bond with M changing after M moved overseas and built a different life. The friendship did not end outright, but the former daily intimacy and imagined shared future receded. Psychologist Pauline Boss calls a loss without a clear ending ambiguous loss, which can make it difficult to recognize and grieve.
Death makes the invisibility harsher. Joy cared for her best friend Hannah through years of ovarian cancer treatment and was devastated when Hannah died. Workplace leave rules did not recognize Joy as family, and people around her sometimes treated her continuing grief as excessive. Kenneth Doka’s term disenfranchised grief describes sorrow that receives little social recognition or support. Joy created a yearly ritual by baking a cake Hannah had hoped they would make together.
Grief reveals which relationships a culture has taught people to count. When the loss is a friend, the mourner may have to explain both the depth of the bond and the legitimacy of the pain, adding isolation to sorrow. The distinction between ambiguous and disenfranchised loss helps identify two separate burdens: uncertainty about what has changed, and a community that does not know how to respond. Personal rituals can preserve memory, but they should not become a substitute for bereavement policies that recognize meaningful caregiving relationships.
Make law recognize caregiving and interdependence beyond marriage
Marriage bundles status and rights. The book describes more than a thousand federal rights and benefits tied to marriage, including health coverage, inheritance, and certain tax protections. Cohen calls the legal preference for marriage marital supremacy. People in committed friendships may have to pay for extensive legal documents, rely on one-off exceptions, or risk exclusion from medical decisions and family leave.
Separate protection from marital status. One proposal is a designated beneficiary agreement, a relatively simple form that lets two adults select specific health and financial rights without marrying. Another is to review each law and grant its benefits according to the function it serves, such as caregiving or financial dependence. These approaches could protect friends, relatives, and partners without requiring every relationship to adopt marriage’s social meaning.
The strongest policy argument here is not that marriage should lose its protections, but that its useful protections should not be the exclusive route to them. Function-based rules can match benefits to actual caregiving and dependency more precisely than marital status. Still, implementation must handle competing claims, consent, and abuse without making ordinary support prohibitively bureaucratic. Flexible options, clear defaults, and accessible legal tools offer a better starting point than forcing every meaningful bond into one institution.
Analysis
The book’s central contribution is to expose how relationship labels operate as social infrastructure. A spouse is not merely a beloved person: the label carries public recognition, default legal authority, rituals, and a shared cultural story. Friendship is often expected to remain private and optional, even when friends organize their lives around one another. Cohen’s portraits make that mismatch concrete, from Lynda’s years of parenting before being legally recognized to Joy’s struggle to mourn Hannah without workplace leave.
The book is strongest when it makes an unfamiliar possibility recognizable through lived detail. Shared routines, medical advocacy, co-parenting, and aging together are more persuasive than abstract claims that friendship matters. Historical examples further unsettle the idea that today’s categories are natural, while the interviews demonstrate how much people’s desires can exceed those categories.
The argument is not that platonic partnerships should replace romantic relationships. Its more useful claim is that society confuses one culturally familiar form with the only valid form. That confusion can harm couples too, by concentrating too many expectations in one bond and weakening wider networks. Yet the portraits are not a representative sample, and successful examples cannot establish that friendship-centered households will work for everyone. They do establish that such relationships exist, can be durable, and deserve fair consideration.
The practical challenge is to make commitment discussable before crisis. Friends considering shared homes, caregiving, or parenting need candid conversations about money, boundaries, decision-making, and what happens if circumstances change. At the civic level, laws can protect the functions of care without requiring romance as proof. The deepest invitation is not to choose friendship over romance, but to examine which defaults have chosen on people’s behalf, and to build a life whose supports match its actual relationships.
Review Summary
The Other Significant Others explores the importance of deep friendships and platonic partnerships, challenging societal norms that prioritize romantic relationships. Readers appreciate Cohen's examination of diverse, unconventional relationships and her call to reimagine connection. Many found the book thought-provoking and relatable, praising its research and storytelling. Some critics felt it was repetitive or lacked depth in certain areas. Overall, the book resonated with those seeking to understand and validate non-romantic significant relationships, though opinions on its execution varied.
People Also Read
Glossary
compulsory coupledom
couplehood treated as mandatoryA social expectation that a long-term romantic relationship is necessary for a normal, successful adult life. The concept helps explain why single people can be treated as incomplete and why friendships may be seen as secondary, even when they provide lasting commitment, intimacy, and care.
platonic partnerships
committed nonsexual partnershipsCohen’s term for friendships that occupy a central, long-term partnership role without necessarily being romantic or sexual. The relationships she describes can involve shared homes, caregiving, co-parenting, major life decisions, and integration into each other’s families. The term names a range of arrangements, not a standardized relationship contract.
other significant others
important nonspousal relationshipsA term associated in the book with psychologist Eli Finkel for people besides a romantic spouse who are significant sources of support and connection. These relationships can include close friends and family members. Recognizing them challenges the assumption that one romantic partner should provide the full range of emotional and practical support.
relationship escalator
expected path of coupledomThe culturally familiar progression by which a serious romantic couple is expected to increase exclusivity and shared roles, often moving toward cohabitation, joint finances, marriage, and parenting. The metaphor emphasizes that these steps can acquire momentum and feel like requirements, even when a couple has not deliberately chosen each one.
passionate friendships
intense, often nonsexual friendshipsPsychologist Lisa Diamond’s term for friendships marked by unusually strong emotional involvement. Her interviews found examples of inseparability, preoccupation, cuddling, and hand-holding. Some included sexual desire, but many did not. The category illustrates that attachment and intense affection can exist without necessarily indicating a person’s sexual orientation.
homohysteria
fear of seeming gaySociologist Eric Anderson’s term for the fear that others will perceive a person, especially a man, as gay, combined with concern about the stigma attached to that perception. The fear can restrict male friendship by discouraging emotional disclosure, physical affection, and visible devotion between men.
ambiguous loss
loss without clear endingPsychologist Pauline Boss’s term for a loss that lacks a clear, socially recognized conclusion. A friendship that has weakened without ending can create this kind of uncertainty. Because there may be no decisive event or public ritual, the person experiencing the loss may struggle to name it and receive support.
disenfranchised grief
unrecognized or unsupported griefGrief that is not openly acknowledged, socially supported, or accommodated by institutions. It can follow the death of someone whose relationship to the mourner is not recognized, such as a close friend. The mourner may lack leave, rituals, or understanding from others despite having experienced profound loss.
marital supremacy
law privileging marriageLegal and institutional preference for marriage over other committed relationships. It describes how rights and benefits often attach automatically to spouses while close friends and unmarried partners may need costly legal arrangements to gain similar authority or protection. The term highlights unequal recognition, not an argument that marriage should be denied its protections.
designated beneficiary agreement
selectable legal protectionsA Colorado legal arrangement described in the book that lets two adults register selected rights in areas such as health care and finances. Unlike marriage, it uses an à la carte approach, allowing people to choose which protections apply and whether they apply reciprocally. It offers a model for recognizing interdependence without requiring a romantic relationship.
FAQ
What's The Other Significant Others about?
- Exploration of Friendships: The book focuses on the importance of friendships, particularly in adulthood, and how they can be as significant as romantic relationships.
- Challenging Norms: It critiques societal expectations that prioritize romantic relationships over friendships, advocating for a broader understanding of intimacy and connection.
- Personal Narratives: Through interviews and personal stories, the book illustrates the diverse forms of platonic love and commitment, highlighting friendships that provide emotional support and companionship.
Why should I read The Other Significant Others?
- Broaden Your Perspective: The book invites readers to reconsider the importance of friendships in a culture that often prioritizes romantic relationships.
- Relatable Experiences: Many readers may find their own experiences reflected in the stories shared, making it a relatable and affirming read.
- Insightful Analysis: Rhaina Cohen combines personal anecdotes with sociological insights, offering a well-rounded exploration of friendship dynamics.
What are the key takeaways of The Other Significant Others?
- Friendship as Central: The book emphasizes that friendships can be as significant and fulfilling as romantic relationships.
- Redefining Relationships: Cohen introduces the concept of "other significant others," referring to friends who play vital roles in each other's lives.
- Cultural Critique: It critiques societal norms that prioritize coupledom and romantic love, advocating for a broader understanding of fulfilling relationships.
How does The Other Significant Others redefine friendship?
- Platonic Partnerships: Cohen introduces the term to describe deep, committed friendships that resemble romantic relationships in their emotional intensity.
- Emotional and Practical Support: The book illustrates how these partnerships can provide the same level of support as romantic relationships.
- Challenging Traditional Norms: By highlighting the importance of friendships, Cohen challenges the belief that romantic relationships are the only valid form of deep connection.
What are some examples of platonic partnerships in The Other Significant Others?
- Andrew and Toly: Their friendship includes cohabitation, emotional support, and shared life goals, challenging the notion that such closeness must be romantic.
- Kami and Tilly: This friendship showcases how two women prioritize each other, even in the face of romantic relationships.
- Natasha and Lynda: Their journey into co-parenting illustrates how platonic partnerships can evolve into family structures.
How does The Other Significant Others address societal expectations around relationships?
- Critique of Compulsory Coupledom: Cohen critiques the societal pressure to prioritize romantic relationships over friendships.
- Historical Context: The book provides historical examples of how friendships were once viewed as significant and fulfilling.
- Encouragement for Change: By sharing stories of individuals who have built fulfilling lives centered around friendships, Cohen encourages readers to challenge traditional norms.
What is the significance of the term "other significant others" in The Other Significant Others?
- Redefining Relationships: The term refers to friends who play crucial roles in each other's lives, providing emotional support and companionship.
- Challenging Norms: It challenges the belief that romantic relationships are the only valid form of deep connection.
- Broadening Perspectives: The concept invites readers to consider various forms of love and support outside traditional romantic frameworks.
How does The Other Significant Others relate to modern issues of loneliness and connection?
- Friendship Recession: The book addresses the growing loneliness epidemic, highlighting the lack of meaningful social connections.
- Health Implications: Research shows that social connections are crucial for mental and physical well-being.
- Cultural Shift: Cohen advocates for a cultural shift that prioritizes friendships alongside romantic relationships.
How does The Other Significant Others explore the intersection of friendship and caregiving?
- Friendship as Caregiving: The book illustrates how friends often take on caregiving roles for one another.
- Shared Responsibilities: Stories of friends navigating caregiving together emphasize mutual support.
- Legal Recognition: The book advocates for legal frameworks that recognize the caregiving roles friends play.
What role do friendships play in mental health according to The Other Significant Others?
- Combatting Loneliness: Strong friendships can significantly reduce feelings of loneliness and isolation.
- Emotional Support: Friendships provide essential emotional support during difficult times.
- Health Benefits: Research shows that friendships can lead to better physical health outcomes.
How does The Other Significant Others suggest we can improve our friendships?
- Open Communication: Discussing expectations and needs within friendships can strengthen bonds.
- Intentionality: Being intentional about nurturing friendships can lead to deeper connections.
- Challenging Norms: Recognizing the value of platonic love can enhance the quality of friendships.
What are the best quotes from The Other Significant Others and what do they mean?
- “The richest relationships are often those that don’t fit neatly into the preconceived slots we have made for the archetypes we imagine would populate our lives.”: Encourages embracing the complexity of relationships.
- “What do you mean? I already have all of that—with Toly.”: Highlights the depth of platonic love fulfilling emotional needs.
- “Friendship is an upstart category, for it to usurp the place of kinship or even intrude upon it is an impertinence.”: Reflects societal discomfort with friendships challenging traditional family structures.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.