Plot Summary
Prologue
Professor Mary Ellen Pearson leaves her evening seminar alone after her usual companion departs early. Crossing the lot, she sees a man run toward her, then watches two men in a white four-wheel-drive strike him with a metal object and haul his limp body into the vehicle.
Fear locks Pearson behind a light pole. The truck speeds away, and only after it vanishes can she scream. She does not know the victim’s identity, but the attack becomes the first visible piece of a crime whose explanation will reach far beyond Denver.
Pearson’s paralysis makes the opening more than a crime scene: it establishes the helplessness that will haunt Vicky when she learns how Todd died. The witness sees enough to carry the image but not enough to identify the attackers, a gap that mirrors the larger mystery’s dependence on partial records and delayed testimony. Her scream comes only after the violence is over. The novel begins with a moral burden, then asks whether careful listening and investigation can turn that burden into evidence before another person is silenced.
The Missing Ancestor’s Book
Vicky Holden, an Arapaho attorney who has struggled to win important tribal work since returning to Wyoming, expects a routine legal assignment when cultural director Dennis Eagle Cloud calls her to the reservation.
Elder Charlie Redman explains that he saw an Arapaho warrior’s pictograph ledger at a Denver museum as a boy in 1920. The museum’s inventory, prepared under the federal repatriation law known as NAGPRA, does not list it. Vicky initially doubts the tribe can compel an explanation about an object last seen so long ago.
Dennis makes clear that the issue is trust, not only legal leverage, while Charlie asks her to pursue the people’s history. Vicky accepts without promising success, knowing the request tests whether her community believes she can serve it.
The assignment places Vicky between two kinds of authority. Her legal training measures what can be proved under a statute; Charlie’s standing as a storyteller rests on memory transmitted across generations. Dennis’s challenge exposes the risk in treating those systems as interchangeable: a story can be credible to a community yet inadmissible as evidence. Vicky’s acceptance is less a confident professional choice than a decision to let responsibility outrank her skepticism. The ledger matters because the tribe’s past has been catalogued by institutions that can omit, mislabel, or possess what they do not understand.
A Fiancée’s Warning
Before leaving for Denver to meet museum curator Rachel Foster, Vicky is stopped by Annemarie Jemson, the fiancée of graduate student Todd Harris. Annemarie has not reached Todd for days. When he visited the reservation the previous weekend, he seemed frightened, said he had to return to Denver, and warned her not to discuss his trouble.
He had gone looking for Father John O’Malley, the mission priest who recently left the reservation. Vicky gives Annemarie contact information and promises to find Todd.
At the museum, Foster denies that an Arapaho ledger ever belonged to its collection and dismisses Charlie’s childhood memory. Vicky also challenges an exhibit that excludes Arapahos from the Sand Creek Massacre, sensing that the historical dispute affects the tribe’s claim to Colorado land.
The story’s two investigations begin to braid together before Vicky recognizes their connection. Annemarie brings a private fear into the same city where Vicky is pursuing a public record, while the museum’s version of Sand Creek shows how historical interpretation can determine present-day claims. Foster’s dismissal makes Vicky’s lack of documentary proof feel like a personal and political disadvantage. Yet the warning about Todd is specific enough to resist being filed as ordinary relationship anxiety. Vicky’s promise to look for him turns professional travel into an obligation to a young man whose danger is still invisible to her.
Todd in the Morgue
After the museum meeting, Vicky finds Todd’s apartment building filled with uncollected mail and learns that neither his neighbors nor his grandparents have seen him recently. A news report describes a young man’s body recovered from the South Platte River.
Vicky calls Detective Steve Clark, her old friend from law school, and insists on identifying the victim herself. At the morgue she recognizes Todd despite the beating that disfigured his face. Clark says heroin and a pager were found on him, and suspects a drug killing.
Vicky rejects the explanation because Todd had worked hard to finish his history degree and support his younger brother. Father John, arriving in Denver after hearing the news, joins Vicky at Todd’s grandparents’ home, where the family’s grief makes the investigation immediate and intimate.
The body forces Vicky to confront the limits of affection as evidence. She knows Todd’s habits, loyalties, and ambitions, but Clark has physical findings that point toward a different story. The conflict is not simply between a grieving woman and a skeptical detective; it is between personal knowledge and institutional pattern recognition, each capable of being wrong. Father John’s return gives Vicky companionship without removing the pain. His presence also revives the restrained attachment between them, a relationship complicated by his vows and by the reason he left the mission.
The Witness Remembers
At Todd’s grandparents’ crowded home, a young man mentions that Todd had recently spent time with a Lakota woman named Julie. Vicky and Father John decide to learn more, despite Clark’s warning that Denver is not the reservation and the inquiry could be dangerous.
At the university, staff refuse to discuss Todd, and Ojibway student Tisha Runner denies knowing Julie. Vicky then meets Professor Mary Ellen Pearson, who recognizes her from the parking-lot attack she reported to police.
Pearson says two men beat the fleeing victim with a metal object and forced him into a white four-wheel-drive. She had not known the victim was Todd. Pearson also identifies Todd’s adviser as Professor Emil Coughlin, giving Vicky a new lead beyond the police’s drug theory.
Pearson’s account transforms a remembered glimpse into corroboration, but it still cannot explain the motive or identify the attackers. Vicky’s progress depends on people who initially withhold information, often because the police, the university, or the city feels unsafe to them. Tisha’s denial is especially important: it reads as fear rather than indifference, though Vicky cannot yet know why. The scene also shows Vicky’s investigative method taking shape. She moves between institutions and personal networks, treating hesitation itself as information while resisting the temptation to mistake suspicion for proof.
Coughlin’s Convenient Story
Vicky visits Emil Coughlin at his mountain home. The professor describes Todd as an intensely driven student and reveals that his thesis mapped Arapaho villages and battle sites in Colorado.
Todd had recently researched southeastern Colorado, including Sand Creek, where Coughlin expected his findings to challenge historian Bernard Good Elk’s claim that only Cheyennes were present. Coughlin says Todd shared a Denver apartment with a woman named Julie, whom no one else has identified. He also denies that the museum ever held an Arapaho ledger.
Vicky notices his confidence about Todd’s research but leaves without learning what troubled the student. The combination of Julie, Sand Creek, and the missing ledger now suggests that Todd’s academic work may connect the two cases.
Coughlin supplies information that is useful and curiously complete: he can describe Todd’s research, his roommate, and the political significance of the thesis, while insisting the ledger is nonexistent. His polished manner encourages Vicky to accept his account as expertise rather than examine its omissions. The thesis gives the mystery a concrete bridge between scholarship and murder. Todd was not merely studying a past event; he may have found evidence capable of altering how that event is remembered and who can claim its consequences. Knowledge here carries both intellectual value and material risk.
The Missing Computer
When Vicky returns to Todd’s apartment, police tape surrounds the building and officers have carried away bags of evidence. Inside, furniture is overturned, papers are scattered, and the kitchen has been searched. Clark believes the intruders wanted drugs or cash, but Vicky spots the clean outline where Todd’s computer had stood.
His thesis and any backup files are missing. Father John agrees the theft deserves attention, though he worries that pursuing Julie could expose Vicky to the same danger. They visit Denver’s rare-book district posing as buyers.
Dealer Richard Loomis indicates that a complete Plains Indian ledger would command a great price, and Vicky sees that dealers know one may be available. That night Bernard Good Elk confronts her, disputes the Arapaho account of Sand Creek, and urges her to stop.
The computer changes the logic of the crime. A robbery aimed at narcotics could explain the staged evidence, but it does not readily explain why a killer would remove a student’s research. Vicky begins to treat the thesis as an object with its own value, not merely a record of Todd’s thoughts. Loomis’s response strengthens that possibility, while Good Elk’s pressure reveals that the dispute has consequences for living communities. His threat also complicates Vicky’s moral confidence: persistence may serve justice, but it can endanger people who have not chosen to become witnesses.
The Smedden Collection
Investigator Pat Michaels tells Vicky that curator Rachel Foster lost her family fortune after her brother’s failed property ventures, though he finds no evidence she has broken the law. At Todd’s memorial Mass, Vicky sees Tisha Runner slip away and hears Coughlin emphasize that Todd’s thesis should not be lost.
Foster then offers a 1920 museum bulletin as an explanation for Charlie’s memory: a private collector may have loaned a ledger for an exhibition. The bulletin never names one.
Vicky requests the library sign-in sheets and learns Todd repeatedly consulted the Smedden Collection, a box of nineteenth-century papers from Kiowa County, where Sand Creek lies. The file listing its contents cannot be found. The missing file turns an undocumented family recollection into a traceable gap in the museum’s archive.
This discovery narrows the mystery without resolving it. The 1920 bulletin gives the museum a plausible defense, but its silence about the ledger is not proof that Charlie misremembered. Todd’s repeated visits to one collection create a stronger evidentiary trail, while the absent file suggests that the archive itself may have been altered. The scene makes institutional memory feel physical: a missing folder can conceal as effectively as a locked cabinet. Foster’s financial history offers a tempting motive, but Pat’s inability to connect her to wrongdoing reminds Vicky that motive is not proof.
Julie’s Hidden Diskette
A second body is recovered from the South Platte, and Clark identifies the victim as Julie Clearwater, the Lakota woman who had stayed in Todd’s apartment. Vicky goes to the Denver Indian Center, where Tisha admits she arranged Julie’s lodging and hid her after Todd warned that the apartment was unsafe.
Todd had given Julie a diskette to deliver to Father John if anything happened to him. Julie meant to pass it to the priest at the memorial Mass but was too frightened to appear. Tisha gives Vicky the envelope, then flees rather than speak to police.
At a campus computer lab, Vicky and Father John open the file: Todd’s thesis describes the massacre and cites No-Ta-Nee’s ledger in the Denver museum collection. The document proves Todd believed the book existed, though it does not reveal where it is now.
The diskette converts Todd’s scholarship into evidence while preserving the danger that shaped his final choices. He entrusted the file to Julie not because she was a close confidante, but because a temporary roommate might attract less suspicion. Tisha’s fear is understandable, yet her retreat leaves her exposed and deprives police of a witness. Vicky now has documentary support for Charlie’s account, but the thesis cannot replace the object itself. The proof intensifies the stakes: the ledger is no longer only a recovered cultural possession, but a source that someone has reason to suppress.
The Rancher’s Record
Vicky and Father John follow Todd’s research to Eads, where a county librarian locates James J. Smedden in old directories and directs them toward his descendants. At the Lawler ranch, Smedden’s elderly great-granddaughter recalls that he gave papers to the Denver museum when his ranch failed.
She lends them his account book. Its final page lists a donation to the museum in 1903: an Indian picture ledger taken from an Arapaho warrior at the Sweetwater battle. The entry supports Todd’s thesis, but the artifact is not with the family.
Returning to Denver, Vicky finds Marcy’s home violently searched. The next morning Detective Clark tells her Tisha has also been killed. Vicky now understands the attackers are pursuing the ledger itself, and suspects Todd hid it at St. Francis Mission.
The ranch record supplies what memory and scholarship could not: a chain of custody connecting an Arapaho ledger to a named donor and the museum. Yet the book remains missing, and each new piece of evidence has arrived after another person was harmed. Marcy’s wrecked home turns Vicky’s investigation from professional risk into a threat to anyone who shelters her. Tisha’s death makes that cost undeniable. Vicky’s conclusion about the mission is an inference, not yet a discovery, but it follows Todd’s last known journey and his trust in Father John.
Coughlin Takes the Flight
Vicky brings Todd’s diskette and the Smedden account book to Clark, who finally takes the ledger theory seriously and alerts FBI agent Ted Gianelli in Wyoming. Father John, driving back to the mission, independently realizes Todd likely concealed the artifact in the mission archives.
Vicky boards a flight to Riverton, intending to reach the book first, but Coughlin takes the seat beside her. He admits stealing the ledger and removing the museum’s paper records after Todd discovered it.
He says his associates killed Todd and Julie, and that a Japanese collector is waiting to buy the intact book. Coughlin has sent Richard Loomis and Skip Bearing to the mission, where Father John has already arrived. To keep him alive, Vicky must take Coughlin to St. Francis.
The confession collapses the false trails into a single motive: Coughlin’s private collecting and financial appetite have turned a scholarly discovery into a commodity worth protecting with violence. His account also shows how easily academic authority can disguise possession as stewardship. Vicky has evidence and has reached the police, but the truth does not immediately protect her or Father John. The plane becomes a sealed space where her legal skills have little force. Her decision to comply is not surrender; it is an attempt to keep the priest alive long enough for outside help to matter.
A Fight in the Archives
At St. Francis, Loomis keeps Father John at gunpoint while Skip searches the mission offices for the ledger. Coughlin brings Vicky in, expecting the priest to reveal its hiding place. When Skip strikes Vicky, Father John attacks him.
Loomis aims his pistol, but Vicky knocks him off balance with a telephone and grabs the fallen weapon. FBI agent Gianelli and reservation officers rush in after Clark’s warning, arresting Coughlin and Loomis and taking Skip for medical care.
Once the room is secure, Father John leads Vicky and Gianelli to a small archives room. In a box of elders’ stories, beneath a leather wrapping, they find No-Ta-Nee’s pictograph ledger. Vicky opens it and recognizes the Arapaho account of the journey to Sand Creek and its survivors.
The rescue depends on coordinated acts of resistance rather than a single heroic intervention. Father John’s physical defense gives Vicky time to disarm Loomis, while Clark’s decision to involve Gianelli brings authority to the mission before the attackers can escape. The ledger’s location completes Todd’s protective choice: he hid it among the community’s own records, where it could remain close to the people whose story it carried. Vicky’s careful handling of the book contrasts with the criminals’ language of price and resale. The object is recovered as evidence, but also recognized as a living inheritance.
The Story Comes Home
Gianelli takes the ledger as evidence, but Vicky expects it to return to the Arapaho community after the case. In the weeks that follow, the tribe negotiates with the Denver museum for the sacred and cultural objects it can reclaim under NAGPRA.
Todd’s thesis is accepted for publication, preserving his map of Arapaho villages and battlefields. Vicky tells Father John that the tribe has also asked her to pursue the Colorado lands promised to the Sand Creek tribes. Father John reveals that the provincial has approved converting the old mission school into an Arapaho museum.
Vicky proposes an Arapaho woman as its director, and they imagine No-Ta-Nee’s ledger as the first artifact visitors will encounter. The work does not undo the killings or guarantee land, but the story will no longer depend on memory alone.
The ending answers the opening’s absence with institutional change, not a claim that the past has been repaired. The museum will provide a place where Arapaho objects can be held and interpreted within the community, while Todd’s publication carries his research beyond the life cut short. Vicky’s new legal work extends the case from recovering artifacts to challenging the stalled distribution of promised land. Her bond with Father John remains shaped by his priesthood and their restraint, but they now share a durable project. The resolution is therefore practical and unfinished: custody, scholarship, and advocacy offer forms of continuity without pretending to erase loss.
Analysis
The novel makes historical recovery a present-tense mystery. An elder’s memory, a student’s thesis, a museum’s inventory, and a rancher’s account book each preserve a different portion of the truth, but none is sufficient alone. Vicky has to translate among them: oral history must become a lead, scholarship must become corroboration, and a handwritten donation entry must become evidence that law enforcement can act on. This structure refuses the idea that archives are neutral. Collections are built through acts of acquisition, and what institutions omit or mislabel can shape the public story as powerfully as what they display.
The Sand Creek dispute gives that archival problem political weight. Whether Arapahos were present is not merely a scholarly disagreement; it bears on land claims and on which descendants are recognized as entitled to redress. Good Elk’s position arises from a genuine competition between communities seeking justice, while Coughlin exploits that tension for private gain. The distinction matters. The book does not reduce every conflict to a simple opposition between Native people and white institutions; it shows how scarcity, professional reputation, and unequal control over evidence can set communities against one another.
Vicky’s development concerns the difference between conviction and proof. She is right to resist the drug narrative, but her intuition alone cannot expose the killer or protect the people around her. Her progress comes when she listens to Charlie, follows Todd’s research trail, and brings documentary evidence to Clark. John’s support is equally active: he questions her assumptions, risks himself beside her, and ultimately recognizes where Todd hid the artifact. Their bond remains restrained, but shared work gives their care a practical form.
The recovered ledger and the planned museum do not undo Todd’s, Julie’s, or Tisha’s deaths. They do change who will hold the story and where it can be studied. The ending offers continuity rather than closure: cultural objects return, scholarship survives, and Vicky takes up the longer struggle for promised land. Justice begins with preserving evidence, but it remains an unfinished public obligation.
Review Summary
The Story Teller receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its complex plot, well-developed characters, and insightful portrayal of Arapaho culture. Many compare it favorably to Tony Hillerman's works. The mystery revolves around a missing Arapaho ledger book and murders connected to it. Readers appreciate the historical context and the dynamic between Father John O'Malley and Vicky Holden. Some criticize the predictable aspects and slow pacing, but overall, fans of Native American-themed mysteries find it engaging and informative.
People Also Read
Characters
Vicky Holden
Arapaho legal advocateVicky is an Arapaho attorney who returned to Wyoming after years of education and legal work in Denver. She wants her training to serve her community, but she is painfully aware that tribal leaders have rarely trusted her with consequential matters. Her strongest habits are scrutiny and persistence: she notices the missing computer, questions the museum’s records, and tests each explanation against what she knows of Todd and her people. Those qualities make her an effective investigator, though grief and loyalty can cause her to treat intuition as certainty. Her relationship with Father John is intimate but restrained, shaped by affection, his vows, and her reluctance to ask him to choose between her and his calling.
Father John O’Malley
Mission priest and allyJohn O’Malley is the Jesuit pastor of St. Francis Mission, a recovering alcoholic who has rebuilt his life through faith, work, and commitment to the Arapaho community. He once hoped for an academic career in history, so Todd’s curiosity about the past speaks directly to him. John is practical without being cynical, willing to challenge Vicky when she risks acting on an unproved theory, yet unable to abandon her when danger grows. His priesthood is not a disguise for emotional distance: he cares deeply for Vicky while trying to honor vows he chose freely. His struggle is to serve the people without confusing sacrifice with self-erasure.
Todd Harris
Arapaho history studentTodd is a disciplined graduate student whose thesis maps Arapaho villages and battle sites in Colorado. His work grows from a desire to understand how dispossession shaped the present, and he hopes his education will help his people. He is also a devoted older brother, conscious that his younger sibling looks to him as an example. Todd’s careful research and his trust in Father John reveal a young man who seeks both documentary accuracy and moral guidance. His academic ambition is not abstract: he wants the people’s presence in Colorado to be recognized as fact. His choices draw the story’s separate conflicts into one line of inquiry.
Charlie Redman
Arapaho storytellerCharlie Redman is an elder entrusted with preserving Arapaho history through oral storytelling. His account of seeing No-Ta-Nee’s ledger as a child gives Vicky the first lead, although it cannot initially satisfy the evidentiary standards of the museum or the courts. Charlie’s authority comes from disciplined memory and responsibility to descendants, not from institutional credentials. He asks Vicky to act because he believes ancestral knowledge deserves protection in the present. His role is not simply to supply a clue: he represents a living archive whose stories can be dismissed by outsiders precisely because they have not been preserved in the forms those outsiders recognize.
Emil Coughlin
Historian and adviserCoughlin is a prominent ethnohistorian who advises Todd and consults on the museum’s Plains Indian collections. He is polished, confident, and skilled at making expertise sound like a complete answer. His public manner suggests a scholar who values access to artifacts and the authority to interpret them. He has a taste for expensive possessions and a professional life shaped by status, money, and proximity to wealthy collectors. Around younger scholars, he can present himself as mentor while keeping his private judgments concealed. His importance lies in the tension between scholarly authority and personal ownership: he treats knowledge of cultural objects as a form of power.
Steve Clark
Denver homicide detectiveSteve Clark is a homicide detective and Vicky’s old friend from their university years. He is observant, methodical, and accustomed to reading crime scenes through patterns established by previous cases. That experience initially pulls him toward a drug-related explanation for Todd’s death, even as Vicky insists the evidence has been staged. Their disagreement is sharpened by mutual respect and personal history: Steve wants to protect Vicky, but he also resists letting friendship substitute for proof. He is not indifferent to Native victims; rather, his certainty in familiar investigative frameworks can delay his recognition of an unfamiliar motive. His willingness to revise his view becomes essential.
Rachel Foster
Museum curatorRachel Foster runs the Denver Museum of the West with pride in its organization and public reputation. She comes from a once-wealthy Denver family whose fortune collapsed, and she has rebuilt her life through museum work. Her sharp manner reflects both professional authority and defensiveness when Vicky questions the collection. Rachel relies on recognized scholars to verify artifacts and is invested in their judgments, especially those of Bernard Good Elk. Her actions show how institutions protect their credibility, sometimes by treating uncertainty as an accusation. She is a gatekeeper to the records Vicky needs, but her role is not identical to the scholars and collectors who use the museum’s holdings for their own ends.
Bernard Good Elk
Cheyenne historianGood Elk is a respected Cheyenne historian whose interpretation of Sand Creek excludes the Arapaho presence. He has built a public argument around that position and sees Vicky’s search as a threat to both his scholarship and his people’s claims. His anger is intensified by the history of competing tribal interests and by his conviction that outside authorities have repeatedly distorted Native history. He pressures Vicky to stop, believing her inquiry will damage the Cheyenne effort to reclaim artifacts and land. His character embodies a genuine political conflict: two communities can share histories of dispossession while still contesting how those histories are represented.
Annemarie Jemson
Todd’s worried fiancéeAnnemarie is Todd’s fiancée, living on the reservation and preparing for a future she believes they will share. When Todd visits unexpectedly and warns her that his trouble may be dangerous, she respects his request for silence but becomes increasingly alarmed when he disappears. Her fear is mixed with loyalty: she does not want to expose him, yet she turns to Vicky when she can no longer reach him. Annemarie’s limited knowledge shows how affection can leave someone close to a crisis without giving them the facts needed to act. She gives Vicky the first personal warning that Todd’s absence is more than ordinary graduate-school stress.
Tisha Runner
Ojibway student and witnessTisha is an Ojibway student who works part time at the Denver Indian Center. She meets Julie through campus and helps her find a place to stay, acting from ordinary generosity rather than knowledge of the danger around Todd. Fear makes her initially deny knowing Julie, and later drives her to avoid the police. She nevertheless contacts Vicky and passes on Todd’s envelope, choosing a trusted personal connection over a formal institution. Tisha’s hesitation is not cowardice but a realistic response to violence and uncertainty. Her choices show how vulnerable witnesses weigh the need to help against the risk of becoming the next target.
Julie Clearwater
Lakota newcomerJulie is a Lakota woman from the Rosebud Reservation who has recently arrived in Denver seeking work and a place to stay. Tisha connects her with Todd’s apartment, where she becomes part of the uncertain circle surrounding his final days. Julie is young, displaced, and unfamiliar with the city, but she is not merely a passive victim of circumstance: she protects the information Todd entrusted to her and tries to carry it to Father John. Her position between reservation life and urban isolation makes her vulnerable to the very networks Vicky is trying to understand. Through Julie, the story shows how quickly a temporary act of shelter can become a dangerous responsibility.
Mary Ellen Pearson
Professor and eyewitnessPearson is an elderly professor of Plains Indian culture whose routine walk across campus puts her in the path of violence. She is frightened by what she witnesses, yet she reports it and later gives Vicky a detailed account. Her testimony is shaped by the limitations of a brief nighttime view: she remembers the vehicle and the beating but cannot identify the attackers. She also understands academic life well enough to know how institutions can dismiss people they consider inconvenient. Pearson’s account links Todd’s murder to the opening attack and demonstrates that courage may consist of preserving an imperfect memory until someone knows how to use it.
Dennis Eagle Cloud
Tribal cultural directorDennis works on cultural preservation and the return of Arapaho objects through NAGPRA. He brings Vicky into the ledger case because he wants the museum to account for everything it once held, not merely the items its current inventory acknowledges. His impatience with Vicky’s initial legal caution reflects the urgency of a community that has repeatedly had to prove its own knowledge to outsiders. Dennis understands that trust can be damaged when an institution offers a tidy list that omits an object an elder remembers seeing. He is a practical advocate for collective ownership and cultural continuity.
Pat Michaels
Private investigatorPat is a private investigator who has worked with Vicky during her years in Denver. He is resourceful, candid, and comfortable tracing people through the unglamorous details of their past. His research into Rachel Foster supplies a possible financial motive, though he cautions Vicky that the curator has a strong professional record. Pat understands the danger of the case before Vicky is willing to step back, and his warning reflects real concern rather than a desire to control her. He gives her information but cannot make her accept his judgment about risk.
Marcy Aker
Vicky’s Denver friendMarcy is Vicky’s former law-school and firm colleague, and she offers Vicky a place to stay during the Denver investigation. Since separating from her husband, she has left legal practice for work at a clinic and seeks belonging through spiritual groups and new friendships. Her search for meaning sometimes leads her to romanticize Native identity, creating friction with Vicky, who knows the hardship behind the culture Marcy admires. Still, their old affection survives awkwardness. Marcy’s home becomes a refuge, and her vulnerability reminds Vicky that the consequences of the investigation extend beyond the people directly named in it.
Richard Loomis
Rare-book dealerLoomis operates a small shop specializing in Native American books and artifacts. He understands the market for rare objects and quickly recognizes that an intact ledger could be worth far more than ordinary inventory. His guarded manner makes him difficult to read, but his business depends on connecting valuable items with buyers willing to pay. He represents the commercial network that can move a cultural object out of public reach, one page at a time. His presence in the story links academic collecting to a wider trade in artifacts.
Skip Bearing
Lakota studentSkip is a Lakota student at the University of Colorado who appears in the same campus and rare-book circles as Todd and Julie. He is physically imposing, guarded, and quick to defend his privacy when Vicky asks about Julie. His involvement in those circles makes him one of several people whose silence could come from fear, loyalty, or self-interest. Skip’s role reminds Vicky that students on the margins of large institutions may know more than they are willing to disclose, while offering no easy way to distinguish a frightened witness from a dangerous one.
Ted Gianelli
Wyoming FBI agentGianelli is a local FBI agent trusted by Father John. He responds when Steve alerts him that the stolen ledger may be at St. Francis, coordinating with reservation police to protect the people there. His presence provides the investigative reach needed when the case crosses state lines and involves a valuable artifact. Gianelli is practical and direct, focused on securing evidence and taking statements. He understands that the object must be handled as both cultural property and evidence in a murder investigation.
Doyal Harris
Todd’s grandfatherDoyal is Todd’s elderly grandfather, who helped raise Todd and his younger brother after their parents died. He faces the loss of a grandson with the restraint and communal dignity expected of an elder, while relying on family and friends to support him and Mary. His grief anchors the consequences of the murder in a household rather than an abstract case file.
Mary Harris
Todd’s grandmotherMary is Doyal’s elderly wife and one of the grandparents who helped raise Todd. Her age and frailty make the news especially painful, but she remains part of the close network of relatives and community members who gather around the family. Her presence reminds Vicky that Todd’s choices and his death are held within a larger kinship circle.
Father Geoff Schneider
Mission priest’s assistantGeoff is Father John’s assistant at St. Francis Mission. His planned time off is repeatedly delayed as John travels, and his family emergency eventually requires John to return to the mission. Geoff’s responsibilities show how a small mission depends on a few people sharing a continuous burden of care.
Father James Stanton
Jesuit financial officialStanton is the Jesuit official who evaluates Father John’s proposal to turn the old mission school into a museum. He prioritizes financial risk and institutional limits, and he doubts both the project’s budget and John’s ability to withstand pressure. His resistance makes the museum’s future depend on more than local need or good intentions.
Plot Devices
No-Ta-Nee’s ledger
The disputed historical recordThe pictograph ledger is an Arapaho account of the people’s movement to Sand Creek, the attack, and the survivors. Charlie Redman remembers seeing it displayed in Denver in 1920, while Todd’s thesis cites it as part of the museum collection. Its absence from the current inventory drives Vicky’s inquiry, and its historical significance threatens interpretations that exclude Arapahos from the massacre. The book is also valuable on the rare-art market, giving the case a financial motive alongside its political and cultural stakes. Its eventual hiding place and recovery are central plot revelations.
NAGPRA inventory
A legal path to returnThe Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act provides a legal framework for tribes to seek the return of certain sacred, funerary, and culturally significant objects held by museums. The Denver Museum’s inventory is meant to identify its Arapaho holdings, but the missing ledger raises the question of whether the list is complete. The law gives Vicky a reason to meet the curator and a professional channel for negotiation, while its limits make the book’s older history difficult to challenge. The repatriation process also connects the individual mystery to a broader effort to restore cultural objects to their communities.
Todd’s thesis diskette
Evidence preserved in hidingTodd’s thesis documents Arapaho villages and battle sites in Colorado, including Sand Creek, and cites No-Ta-Nee’s ledger as a museum source. The original computer disappears from Todd’s apartment, suggesting someone wants his research removed. A backup diskette survives because Todd gives it to Julie, who entrusts it to Tisha for delivery to Father John. The file supports Charlie’s memory and helps Vicky persuade Detective Clark to take the historical motive seriously. It does not reveal the ledger’s location, so it advances the investigation without replacing the need to find the artifact itself.
The planted drug trail
A misleading crime narrativeHeroin and a pager found on Todd’s body lead Detective Clark to suspect a drug deal. Autopsy evidence strengthens that theory, while bruising and fresh-looking needle marks leave room for doubt. The apparent drug connection directs police attention away from the museum, the thesis, and the ledger. Vicky’s knowledge of Todd and the missing computer challenges the easy explanation, but she must gather evidence before Clark will reconsider. The device shows how fabricated or selectively interpreted evidence can shape an investigation and keep a true motive hidden even from a competent detective.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.