Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
The Thorns Remain

The Thorns Remain

A divorced writer courts his rival's wife for revenge, while their daughters become friends.
by Jennifer Hartmann 2021 493 pages
4.14
6k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

Prologue

Evan begins by describing vengeance as the force that gave his wounded life direction. He believes revenge can replace grief with purpose, then admits that its promises are hollow and that innocent people will be caught in its path. The woman he never expected is already present in his account, a warning that his campaign will not leave him untouched.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The prologue gives revenge the shape of both companion and addiction: it makes Evan feel purposeful by keeping him attached to the injury that defines him. His confession that others will suffer complicates the familiar fantasy of retaliation as justice. The promised unexpected woman also turns the revenge plot inward. Evan may imagine that he is targeting one man, but his own framing signals that the cost will be measured in relationships, not merely in the punishment of his enemy.

The Lexus Scratch

Evan turns an affair into a seduction plan

Seventeen months after his marriage collapsed, Evan Campbell, a divorced father and thriller writer, is still fixated on Benjamin Grant, the attorney who had an affair with his wife, Katrina. Evan plans to hurt Benjamin by seducing Benjamin’s wife, Josie, and has studied her public posts and gym routine to arrange an opening.

He deliberately scratches Josie’s Lexus, then approaches her at the gym under the pretense of reporting the damage. His rehearsed charm fails: Josie laughs at his supposed mistake, rejects his flirtation, and leaves him uncertain how to proceed. Her sharpness and bad mood do not match the shallow, privileged target he imagined. Evan has begun the scheme, but his first encounter already unsettles his assumptions.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Evan converts humiliation into a project because action feels safer than mourning. The scratched car is more than an excuse to meet Josie: it is his first deliberate act of deception, carried out in daylight and disguised as responsibility. Yet Josie’s refusal to behave like his imagined trophy wife interrupts the script before it can become emotionally real. His failure is important because it gives her room to appear as a person rather than a weapon. The scene establishes the book’s central tension: Evan seeks control through a plan, while genuine attachment begins precisely where his control falters.

The Birthday Reckoning

A false loss and public exposure forge his grudge

Before the gym scheme, Evan and Katrina had spent years trying for another child. A positive test briefly promised to complete their family, but after Katrina returned from work pale and crying, she told him she had miscarried. She withdrew from Evan, and he did not know how to reach her. Months later, their daughter Summer repeated that she had overheard Katrina discussing abortion.

Evan followed Katrina to Benjamin’s law office and saw them kiss. On Katrina’s birthday, he exposed her messages to relatives and friends, then handed her divorce papers. She left for Tennessee, while Summer stayed with him. Evan’s grief hardened into a mission: make Benjamin lose what Evan had lost.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Evan’s rage grows from a sequence of losses that he cannot interpret: the supposed miscarriage, Katrina’s withdrawal, and the public proof of her affair. His birthday ambush turns private betrayal into social punishment, showing that his revenge began before he targeted Josie. The scene also plants a crucial uncertainty about the pregnancy, which Evan treats as settled because he has no reason to doubt Katrina’s account. His desire to punish Benjamin is therefore built not only on heartbreak but on incomplete knowledge, an unstable foundation for the certainty he later claims.

Two Girls Make Contact

A playground turns revenge into family access

At a neighborhood playground, Evan discovers Josie watching her eight-year-old daughter, Olivia, while his nine-year-old Summer takes the swings. The girls quickly become friends, and Evan joins their play rather than approaching Josie with another pickup line. Josie teases him about his earlier gym behavior, accepts his apology, and enters her number into his phone so they can arrange a playdate.

The girls soon ask for sleepovers, giving Evan a welcome route into Josie’s household. At home, Summer notices that her father is still consumed by his ex-wife and admits she worries about him. Her concern forces Evan to see that his private anger is already shaping his daughter’s life, even as he uses their new friendship to advance his plan.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The daughters’ friendship creates an intimacy that neither adult can manufacture or fully control. Evan sees the playdates as useful access, but Summer’s concern exposes the cost of his fixation at home. His role as a loving, attentive father is not separate from his revenge plot; it is the moral standard against which his choices are measured. Josie’s number also arrives through a legitimate parental connection, making Evan’s deception harder to isolate from the genuine warmth that develops around it. The family bridge is both an opportunity for revenge and the first proof that other people are already involved.

Roses, Loss, and Music

Josie reveals the life beyond her polished home

As the families spend time together, Evan learns that Olivia’s father, Adam, was Josie’s first love and that their matching nautical-star tattoos preserve a bond he cannot fully understand. Josie explains that her father introduced her to roses, and one climbing bush remains a living reminder of him and Adam.

Her ease with music surprises Evan even more: she plays guitar and sings, while her social-media image suggests a conventional wealthy housewife. She also tells him that both parents died when she was young and that her sister Carrie’s cancer has returned. These disclosures replace Evan’s caricature with a woman who has endured repeated grief and still makes room for her daughter, her friends, and the things she loves.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Josie’s stories give her apparent domestic comfort a history that Evan’s social-media research could not reach. The roses carry family memory, while the tattoo and guitar connect love to practices that survive a person’s absence. Evan is drawn to these details partly because they resemble his own grief, but they also expose how little he knows about the woman he plans to use. Her vulnerability does not make her passive; she continues to nurture Olivia, maintain friendships, and play music. That combination challenges Evan’s assumption that pain must either harden a person or make them easy to manipulate.

The Husband's Open Door

Benjamin welcomes the man plotting to betray him

Josie invites Evan to her end-of-summer party, where he meets Benjamin face-to-face and must shake the hand of the man he blames for his ruined marriage. Benjamin does not recognize him as Katrina’s husband and warmly welcomes him as Summer’s father. When Josie’s former boyfriend, Emmett, grabs her during the party, Evan intervenes, and Josie later explains their brief past.

Benjamin’s affection toward her looks practiced but convincing. At a later dinner, he describes how he once helped Josie when she was a struggling young mother, then admits that work and fertility problems have strained their marriage. Evan hears the polished story while hiding the fact that he has entered this household to make it suffer.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Benjamin’s welcome creates an unsettling asymmetry: Evan knows exactly whom he is greeting, while Benjamin sees only a new family friend. Their handshake gives Evan a chance to act out his grievance while concealing it. At the same time, Benjamin’s account of helping Josie complicates Evan’s preferred image of him as a simple villain. The story does not absolve Benjamin, but it shows that his marriage contains its own history of care and disappointment. Evan’s capacity to listen without revealing himself becomes another form of manipulation, even when the conversation makes him see the couple as more human.

The Market Dance

A proposal and Halloween loosen Evan's defenses

At the autumn farmers’ market, Evan brings Josie and the girls to meet his college friends Logan and Amber. While Summer and Olivia dance, Logan proposes to Amber, and Evan feels envy give way to genuine happiness for his friends. Josie steadies him with a touch, then he brushes cotton candy from her lip, leaving both aware of the charge between them.

By Halloween, their daughters’ friendship has become routine, and Josie plays along when a neighbor mistakes her and Evan for a couple. They trick-or-treat, share sweets around Evan’s bonfire, and laugh over his habit of stealing Summer’s peanut-butter cups. For the first time in months, Evan enjoys an evening without rehearsing his grievance, and that relief frightens him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The market and Halloween scenes shift Evan’s emotional attention from what he has lost toward what is happening in front of him. Logan’s proposal first exposes his loneliness, then gives him a chance to celebrate another person’s happiness without converting it into resentment. Josie’s small gesture and their playful domestic ease create a kind of closeness that his revenge plan cannot explain. The bonfire matters because Evan is not merely attracted to Josie; he is beginning to value shared ordinary life. His fear of feeling good reveals how thoroughly he has mistaken suffering for loyalty to the past.

The Guitar Breaks

Josie's music draws him into an uncontrolled collapse

After watching Josie sing and play guitar, Evan buys a new instrument and invites her to play with him while their daughters are at school. Their music brings back a part of him he had abandoned after Katrina left. Later, singing alone in his room, Evan breaks down, tears through the house, and smashes the guitar.

Josie returns and finds him among broken dishes and scattered roses, his hand bleeding from a thorn. Rather than flee from his anger, she holds him on the floor, then helps clean the damage and bandages his hand. The next day, she sends him a replacement guitar. Evan resumes writing, but her kindness also makes his revenge plan feel less defensible.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The guitar gives Evan a physical route back to an identity that predates his grievance, so its destruction is an attempt to silence more than music. Josie’s response matters because she neither excuses the wreckage nor abandons him inside it: she helps him face the aftermath. Her gift is not a cure, but it makes continuation possible. Roses and thorns turn the scene’s injury into a concrete image of beauty entangled with pain. Evan begins to discover that accepting care can feel more threatening than anger, because care asks him to remain present rather than retreat into vengeance.

Hands Across Thanksgiving

Their grief turns friendship into dangerous intimacy

At Thanksgiving dinner with Josie’s family, Evan speaks more openly about Katrina’s affair and the pregnancy he believes she ended. Josie tells him that Adam died in a motorcycle accident and that, after his death, she once drove into a tree during a period of grief. Their shared losses draw them close on the patio.

Evan lends her his jacket, and they hold hands while discussing the lives they might have chosen. He asks whether she is happy with Benjamin, but her husband interrupts before she can answer. Later, Josie sends Evan a video of herself playing guitar on a beach with Olivia, bringing to life the freedom she had described. Evan recognizes how deeply he wants that future with her, though he still hides his motive.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The Thanksgiving conversation converts shared bereavement into a language of recognition, but recognition is not the same as honesty. Evan offers Josie the truth about his pain while withholding the identity of the man responsible for it. Their handholding therefore carries two meanings at once: genuine comfort and an intimacy shaped by concealment. Josie’s imagined beach life makes her desire for autonomy visible, while Evan’s attention to it risks turning her dream into another instrument of his plan. The interruption leaves her marital question unanswered, preserving uncertainty rather than allowing Evan to mistake closeness for permission.

The Kiss in Snow

Josie's doubt gives Evan the opening he fears

During a snowy evening at Evan’s house, Josie joins him, Logan, and Amber for games while Summer and Olivia play nearby. Outside, she admits that something between her and Evan has changed and that she is unsure she loves Benjamin. Evan hears both an opening and a warning. When Josie asks him to name what he is thinking, he kisses her instead.

She responds, then recoils as the reality of her marriage returns and goes back inside. Evan is left in the snow with the knowledge that their attraction is no longer theoretical. The kiss intensifies the conflict between his stated goal of hurting Benjamin and his growing wish to be with Josie for reasons that have nothing to do with revenge.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The snow muffles the world around them, but it does not erase the ethical conditions of their encounter. Josie’s uncertainty is not a declaration of freedom, and Evan’s choice to kiss her converts a vulnerable conversation into action before either has resolved what that action means. Her retreat is therefore not simple indecision; it is an attempt to recover the boundary that the kiss has crossed. For Evan, the moment makes desire harder to disguise as strategy. He is beginning to recognize that the plan can no longer contain the feelings it was designed to exploit.

The Bedroom Before Christmas

Evan stops before desire becomes another betrayal

At Josie’s holiday party, the tension between them returns. She tells Evan they should stop seeing each other, but they kiss in her bedroom, and he brings her to orgasm with his fingers before she leaves. Evan then hides in Benjamin’s bathroom, where Benjamin discovers him but does not understand what happened.

Emmett recognizes Evan as Campbell, Katrina’s former husband, and the secret of his identity is no longer safe. The encounter gives Evan the physical revenge he once wanted, yet it leaves him ashamed rather than triumphant. He understands that he has drawn Josie into the same kind of betrayal that destroyed his own marriage, even though she still does not know why he first approached her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The bedroom scene is the point where Evan’s revenge becomes morally legible to him as repetition. He has not simply crossed a marital boundary; he has used the trust Josie placed in him without giving her the information she would need to choose freely. His shame is sharpened by the setting: Benjamin’s home turns the act into a private echo of the original affair. Emmett’s recognition adds external risk, but the deeper danger is already internal. Evan can no longer claim that his scheme is a clean punishment aimed at Benjamin alone.

No More Vengeance

A neighbor's counsel makes Evan confess his love

On Christmas Eve, Evan’s neighbor Oliver advises him that a life driven only by resentment needs a different purpose. Evan goes to the gym and tells Josie he has fallen for her, then promises to leave her alone. On Christmas night, Benjamin arrives at Evan’s house with dessert and confronts him after Emmett revealed his identity.

Benjamin accuses him of using Summer to enter the family; Evan admits his anger but cannot turn the conversation into victory. Benjamin leaves without exposing the secret to Josie. Alone afterward, Evan recognizes that the revenge he treated as survival has made him complicit in the harm he once condemned. His confession to Josie has been honest about his feelings, but not yet about the scheme that began them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Oliver’s advice offers Evan a replacement for revenge, not an absolution from what he has done. The gym confession marks a genuine emotional turn, but its incompleteness matters: Evan names love while still withholding the origin of their relationship. Benjamin’s confrontation forces him to see that his actions have affected Summer and Olivia, not just two adults. The scene makes accountability more demanding than regret. Evan can recognize that vengeance has failed him, yet still owes Josie the truth that would let her judge the relationship on her own terms.

The Truth at Last

A reunion ends when he reveals the revenge scheme

Months later, Evan meets Josie at a bar and learns that her marriage has ended. Their attraction returns, and they leave together. Before they have sex, Evan stops and tells her that he damaged her car deliberately, targeted her because Benjamin had slept with Katrina, and intended to seduce her as revenge.

He also admits that his feelings became real but does not use them to excuse the deception. Josie is devastated, calls his conduct a betrayal, and leaves. She later obtains a restraining order. Evan’s decision to confess prevents one more night built on a lie, but honesty arrives after he has already taken from Josie the ability to choose how their relationship began.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The confession is both a moral correction and a delayed transfer of power. Evan finally gives Josie the information he withheld, but only after the scheme has shaped her feelings and choices. His willingness to stop before sex shows growth, yet it cannot undo the manipulation that preceded it. Josie’s anger is not an obstacle to the romance; it is a necessary assertion of agency. The restraining order makes the consequence concrete, separating Evan from the person whose trust he treated as collateral. His remorse matters only if he accepts that she is entitled to refuse him.

The Shot and the Secret

Benjamin reveals Mason before a gunshot changes everything

After three weeks without contact, Summer and Olivia secretly arrange a reunion at the playground. Their fathers remain distant, but the girls’ friendship resumes at once.

That evening, a drunken Benjamin visits Evan and reveals that Katrina never had an abortion: she carried the pregnancy and raised Mason in Tennessee as her boyfriend’s child. Benjamin, who is sterile, confirms that Mason is Evan’s son. The revelation is still settling when Benjamin draws a gun during their argument.

Summer comes outside, startling him, and the gun fires into her chest. Evan reaches his daughter as Benjamin calls for help, and the revenge campaign that once seemed like a private grievance becomes a life-threatening catastrophe for the child Evan most wanted to protect.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Two withheld truths collide: Katrina’s concealed pregnancy and Evan’s long effort to make Benjamin suffer. Mason’s existence reframes a loss Evan had mourned for years, while the gunshot makes the cost of his revenge immediate and irreversible. Summer’s presence is accidental, but her exposure is not narratively arbitrary; Evan’s choices have drawn Benjamin into his home and his family. The scene refuses the comforting separation between personal motives and collateral damage. A parent’s love may be sincere, yet sincerity cannot shield a child from the consequences of the parent’s conduct.

Summer Wakes Again

Her survival exposes two families' buried damage

At the hospital, doctors operate on Summer and place her in a medically induced coma. Evan calls Katrina and Josie, who arrive and help him endure the wait. Summer survives the surgery and later wakes, asking after her family and best friend. Evan learns that Mason is his son and meets him for the first time; Summer quickly recognizes him as her brother.

Katrina admits she hid Mason partly to hurt Evan after his public humiliation of her, and Evan sees their matching pursuit of revenge without excusing either choice. He begins to release his hatred of Katrina. Josie stays beside him through the crisis, but the catastrophe does not erase the betrayal between them or restore trust automatically.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Summer’s survival gives the family a future, but the hospital does not make the past harmless. Katrina’s admission reveals that both former spouses used children as leverage in response to injury, a parallel that forces Evan to confront the pattern rather than simply condemn her. His recognition of that symmetry begins a more difficult kind of forgiveness: one that acknowledges harm without pretending the harm did not happen. Mason’s introduction also transforms an abstract missing child into a person Evan can hold and care for. Hope here is practical, grounded in recovery and responsibility.

Rain, Then Goodbye

Josie returns, but insists on healing alone

After the hospital crisis, Josie waits on Evan’s porch in the rain, and they finally sleep together. Emmett later tells Evan that he helped steer Benjamin and Katrina together, hoping to separate Josie from Benjamin and win her himself. The revelation shows Evan that he was not the only person who treated other people’s marriages as tools.

Josie and Evan reconnect physically, but she then tells him she needs to rebuild her own confidence and power before she can trust a relationship with him. Evan accepts her decision rather than bargaining for another chance. Their separation is painful, but it gives Josie room to pursue a life that is not defined by either husband or lover.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The rain reunion offers warmth after the hospital’s terror, but the intimacy cannot function as proof that the underlying damage is resolved. Emmett’s confession widens the moral field: manipulation has circulated through several people, each claiming a desire or injury as justification. Josie’s decision to leave is therefore not a rejection of feeling but a refusal to make feeling substitute for self-recovery. Evan’s acceptance is a small but meaningful change in conduct. For once, he does not treat access to a woman as a prize he can secure by persistence.

Music Through the Year

Evan writes their history while Josie builds a life

Over the next year, Evan raises Summer and Mason, continues writing, and turns his history of betrayal and revenge into a novel that becomes a bestseller. Josie returns to music, performing her own songs in public. Evan attends one show without approaching her; months later, she appears at his book signing and leaves a message in a copy of his book before departing.

He does not chase her, believing that she should decide what comes next. The distance is not empty: Evan has made his choices visible to readers, while Josie has built a life around a talent she once treated as a hobby. Their separate growth prepares a meeting that neither can force.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The year apart gives the novel’s romantic resolution an ethical condition: both characters must become more than the roles they played in each other’s crisis. Evan’s book turns self-accusation into public accountability, while Josie’s performances make her artistic ambition concrete. His restraint at the signing contrasts with his original plan to engineer access to her. The message she leaves is an opening, not a guarantee, and his decision not to pursue her preserves the choice that his earlier deception denied her. Their reunion can mean something because neither has simply resumed the old arrangement.

The Rose Returns

Josie chooses a future after forgiving his lies

After leaving the signing, Josie returns to the parking lot and finds Evan before he drives away. She gives him a rose and explains that she needed time to recover her own strength, but has chosen to build a life with him. Evan asks what her message in his book meant, and Josie makes her decision explicit: she forgives him and wants to grow alongside him.

He tells her he loves her, and she returns the feeling. Their renewed relationship is not presented as a reward they were owed; it is a choice made after distance, accountability, and independent growth. At last, Evan can imagine a future that is not organized around punishing Benjamin or reliving Katrina’s betrayal.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Josie’s return completes the book’s movement from engineered access to chosen intimacy. Evan does not win her through persistence; he waits while she determines what she wants, and she comes back with a decision of her own. The rose carries its old association with grief and injury, but it now rests in an open hand rather than a fist clenched around its thorns. Forgiveness here does not cancel the past or declare Evan deserving. It allows the characters to make a future without letting the original harm dictate every subsequent choice.

Epilogue

On a beach at night, Josie and Evan play guitar while Summer, Olivia, and Mason dance nearby. The adults have made the beach and music an annual tradition, and the children’s laughter gives the evening its own soundtrack.

Evan and Josie share raspberry wine after the guitars fall quiet, then dance together to his loud metal music. Their family is not built by erasing grief or pretending the past was harmless. It is built from repeated choices to stay present, to make music, and to let joy occupy the same life as memory.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The beach brings together the book’s recurring forms of repair: music, chosen family, shared ritual, and pleasure that does not require forgetting. The children are not merely witnesses to Evan and Josie’s romance; their original friendship made the adults’ meeting possible, and their continuing presence keeps that history visible. The guitars also return the characters to selves they had set aside under grief and fear. By ending with an ordinary toast and a dance rather than a grand declaration, the epilogue locates happiness in practice. Freedom is something they keep choosing together.

Analysis

The novel’s central moral problem is not whether betrayal hurts, but what a person permits pain to justify. Evan’s first response to Katrina’s affair is to make revenge into a vocation. He can write about motives and consequences, yet he initially refuses to apply that attention to the people caught in his own plan. Josie becomes the clearest test of this contradiction: Evan recognizes her grief and offers comfort while concealing that he has deliberately entered her life to injure her husband.

The story also distinguishes forgiveness from innocence. Evan’s confession does not restore Josie’s trust, and her decision to leave him for a time is not framed as punishment. She needs to recover the capacity to choose without making a new relationship carry the weight of her old grief. Evan’s work is to stop treating love as possession or reward and to accept the boundary she sets. Their eventual reconciliation matters because it comes after that boundary has been honored.

Children make the adults’ private ethics public. Summer notices Evan’s despair, while her friendship with Olivia draws both families together. Later, Evan’s choices bring Benjamin to his home, where Summer is shot. The accident cannot be reduced to a neat moral equation, but it makes the language of collateral damage impossible to sustain. Katrina’s concealed pregnancy and her own retaliatory motives further show how adults transmit unresolved injury through family decisions.

Roses, music, and writing offer different forms of memory. The rose holds beauty and injury together; the guitar lets Evan and Josie recover identities beyond marriage; Evan’s novel turns his humiliating actions into testimony rather than self-exoneration. The story ultimately argues that people cannot choose the injuries life gives them, but they remain responsible for what they do next. Love becomes credible not because the characters deserve it, but because they choose honesty, restraint, and repair.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After his wife Katrina leaves him for attorney Benjamin Grant, thriller writer Evan Campbell plans to retaliate by seducing Benjamin’s wife, Josie. Their daughters become friends, giving Evan a way into Josie’s life. As he grows close to her, he falls for her and abandons his original aim, but only after their attraction has led to a secret encounter. Months later, before they can begin again, Evan confesses how he targeted her. Josie leaves and gets a restraining order. Benjamin then reveals that Katrina had their son, Mason, and that she hid him from Evan. During an argument at Evan’s home, Benjamin’s gun accidentally shoots Summer. She survives, and Evan meets Mason. Josie and Evan reconnect, but she takes a year to build her own life. They reunite after she forgives him, choosing a future together with their children.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.14 out of 5
Average of 6k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

The Thorns Remain is a polarizing romance novel that elicits strong emotions from readers. Many praise its intense, slow-burn plot centered on revenge and redemption, with complex characters and unexpected twists. The book is narrated from the male protagonist's perspective, which some found refreshing. Critics noted its slow pacing and controversial themes like cheating. Overall, readers appreciated the emotional depth, character growth, and thought-provoking exploration of forgiveness, though some found the drama excessive and the ending unsatisfying.

Your rating:
4.5
112 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Evan Campbell

The wounded novelist

Evan is a thriller writer, a devoted father to Summer, and a man whose confidence and humor can disguise how thoroughly betrayal has narrowed his life. He thinks in stories, uses jokes to deflect discomfort, and often mistakes analysis for control. His anger gives him energy but also encourages him to treat other people as pieces in a plot he believes he can manage. Fatherhood keeps exposing the difference between what he intends and what his choices cause. His central psychological struggle is learning to acknowledge pain without making retaliation the measure of his worth.

Josie Grant

The rose-tending musician

Josie is Olivia’s mother, Benjamin’s wife, and a warm, socially capable woman whose polished household does not reveal the depth of her private history. Roses connect her to her father and first love; guitar and songwriting preserve another part of her identity. She is generous with people in distress, but generosity does not mean she lacks boundaries. Her grief has made security appealing, while her creative ambitions keep pressing against a life organized around other people’s needs. Josie’s defining tension is between caring for those she loves and recovering the authority to choose for herself.

Summer

Evan's clear-eyed daughter

Summer is Evan’s nine-year-old daughter, an imaginative, affectionate child who enjoys anime, games, and time with her father. Their private truth-telling ritual gives her a way to speak openly, and her perceptiveness often makes Evan’s attempts to hide his sadness futile. She is enthusiastic about friendship and quick to welcome Olivia into her life. Summer’s needs help ground the adults’ conflicts in daily consequences: she needs stability, honesty suited to her age, and parents who do not make her carry their pain.

Benjamin Grant

The polished attorney

Benjamin is Josie’s husband and a successful defense attorney whose wealth, confidence, and ease in social settings make him seem secure. He is accustomed to being welcomed and listened to, and his polished manner can conceal emotional distance. His marriage has its own history of tenderness, fertility struggles, and disappointment, complicating Evan’s simple image of him as a villain. Benjamin’s presence tests how easily charm can be mistaken for character and how a person’s regrets coexist with the harm they have caused.

Katrina

Evan's former first love

Katrina is Evan’s high-school sweetheart, former wife, and Summer’s mother. Their long relationship once felt secure enough that Evan built his identity around it. Katrina is not defined solely by her role as an ex-wife: she has her own desires, disappointments, and responses to a marriage that has changed. Her decisions affect both children and keep Evan connected to a past he would rather simplify into a single betrayal. As a co-parent, she remains part of the family’s future even when trust between the adults is damaged.

Adam

Josie's first love

Adam is Olivia’s father and Josie’s first great love. Their shared nautical-star tattoos and the music he taught her remain part of how Josie understands attachment, memory, and the person she was before later losses. His importance in the story comes through Josie’s recollections and the practices she keeps, rather than through present-day action.

Olivia

Summer's new best friend

Olivia is Josie’s eight-year-old daughter, sociable and playful, with a strong affection for her mother and an immediate rapport with Summer. She brings the two households into contact through ordinary childhood wishes for playdates and sleepovers. Her friendship with Summer gives both girls a source of joy independent of the adults’ complicated relationships.

Mason

A boy in Tennessee

Mason is a toddler in Katrina’s Tennessee household. At first Evan knows him only through Summer’s stories and brief glimpses, so the child is part of a distant family life Evan does not understand. His presence becomes emotionally important through the siblings’ connection and the adults’ unfinished history.

Emmett

The opportunistic partner

Emmett is Benjamin’s business partner and a former suitor of Josie. He is observant, self-interested, and proud of his ability to identify leverage in other people’s relationships. His interest in Josie persists beyond the brief period they dated, and his presence at family gatherings creates discomfort. Emmett represents a colder form of manipulation than Evan’s: he treats patience and information as tools for obtaining what he wants.

Logan

Evan's loyal college friend

Logan is Evan’s longtime friend from college and one of the people who can challenge him without abandoning him. His relationship with Amber gives Evan a close view of durable affection and mutual commitment. Logan is blunt, protective, and willing to offer practical counsel when Evan’s self-deception becomes obvious.

Amber

The tattooed fiancé

Amber is Logan’s partner and Evan’s outspoken friend. Her humor is bold, her loyalty direct, and her protective instincts toward Evan can become a blunt warning when she sees him risking more harm. She offers the book’s clearest contrast to Evan’s guarded loneliness: affection, in her life, is vivid and openly expressed.

Hana Park

The perceptive former fling

Hana is a woman Evan has dated casually. Kind and emotionally perceptive, she recognizes that his attention is elsewhere before he can admit it to himself. Her advice about hardship and happiness reflects her own outlook, and her willingness to step back shows care without entitlement.

Carrie

Josie's devoted sister

Carrie is Josie’s sister, a mother of twin boys and a close source of support. She knows Josie’s history and can help her examine difficult choices without taking those choices away from her. Her own health challenges add pressure to Josie’s already crowded emotional life.

Delilah

Josie's grieving confidante

Delilah is Josie’s close friend, navigating the end of her own relationship while trying to support Josie. She is flirtatious, impulsive, and candid about her loneliness. Her friendship gives Josie a companion who understands the instability of rebuilding life after a marriage changes.

Oliver

The eccentric neighbor

Oliver is Evan’s thoughtful, eccentric neighbor, engaged to Sydney. His unusual life has made him deliberate about observing people and learning how emotions shape their choices. When Evan describes a fictionalized version of his predicament, Oliver offers a perspective that helps him question the purpose driving him.

Sydney

Oliver's bright partner

Sydney is Oliver’s warm, expressive partner and a neighbor in Evan’s community. Her open emotional style helps Oliver understand intimacy, and her playful presence adds a lively counterpoint to Evan’s more guarded friendships.

Sandra

Katrina's supportive mother

Sandra is Katrina’s mother, living in Tennessee. She helps care for the children and remains a family connection during the long-distance years. Her presence reminds Evan that his past marriage is tied to a wider family network.

Lorna Gibson

The knowing neighbor

Lorna is Evan’s elderly neighbor, a widow who rewards his help with homemade treats and watches the children’s neighborhood closely. Her assumptions about Evan’s romantic life create a brief comic interruption, while her familiarity gives the community a sense of continuity.

Plot Devices

The deliberate car scratch

A manufactured first meeting

Evan deliberately marks Josie’s Lexus, then reports the damage as if it were an accident so he can approach her at the gym. The small injury to the car establishes the larger deception: he plans to use a credible pretext to enter her life and reach Benjamin. The scratch remains visible for months, becoming a physical reminder of the scheme after Evan’s feelings have changed. Its ordinary appearance contrasts with the hidden intention behind it.

The Say It ritual

A shortcut past concealment

Josie and Adam once used a simple ritual to make each other voice whatever thought had carried them away. She introduces it to Evan, and it becomes a recurring invitation to name grief, longing, or fear before either person can smooth it into polite conversation. The ritual creates intimacy, but it also exposes how much Evan is still withholding. Its value lies not in guaranteeing honesty, but in making silence visible.

Roses and thorns

A memory made tangible

Josie’s rose garden connects her to her father and to Adam, while a proverb about roses and thorns gives the characters a shared language for beauty mixed with pain. Evan first reads the image through his own wrecked marriage, then encounters it during his breakdown and in later exchanges with Josie. The flower’s thorns are not a decorative metaphor alone: they cut his hand, and the wound makes the cost of holding on physically visible.

The returning guitar

A route back to self

Evan sold his guitar after his marriage ended, treating music as another part of himself that had become unusable. Josie’s playing awakens his interest again; their shared songs lead him toward writing and, later, toward an uncontrolled breakdown. When he smashes the instrument, Josie gives him another one. The guitar marks his movement between numbness and expression, making recovery something he practices rather than merely thinks about.

The girls' friendship

A bridge between households

Summer and Olivia become friends at the playground and keep asking for playdates, sleepovers, and time together. Their bond gives Evan and Josie repeated, socially plausible reasons to meet, which Evan initially exploits as access to Benjamin’s family. But the girls’ affection is independent and genuine, and it survives adult conflict. Their friendship therefore functions both as the route that draws the parents together and as a responsibility that exposes the consequences of the parents’ choices.

About the Author

Jennifer Hartmann is a contemporary romance author based in northern Illinois. She lives with her family and draws inspiration from everyday life for her emotionally charged stories. Hartmann's writing style is known for its angst and ability to evoke strong feelings in readers. She enjoys exploring the complexities of love and relationships in her novels. When not writing, Hartmann indulges in various interests, including traveling, watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and enjoying sunsets with a glass of wine. Her love for animals is evident in her desire to pet dogs, and she has a particular fondness for tacos.

Download PDF

To save this The Thorns Remain summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.41 MB     Pages: 28

Download EPUB

To read this The Thorns Remain summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.52 MB     Pages: 35
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...