Plot Summary
A Foot Rebuilt
In September 1940, eleven-year-old Ada Smith1 enters hospital for an operation on the clubfoot her mother, Mam,10 never had treated. Susan,2 the woman caring for Ada1 and her little brother3 Jamie,3 tries to prepare Ada1 for surgery while hiding a letter from Lady Thorton.4 After the operation, Jamie3 brings the news: Mam10 died in a bombing at her London munitions factory.
Ada1 feels numb, but the word orphan sends her into panic. She assumes she and Jamie3 will be sent away and she will lose the people and animals who have become hers. Susan2 eventually explains that she meant funeral arrangements, not new homes, and that she intends to become their legal guardian. By December, Ada's foot has healed enough for her to stand and walk in ordinary shoes.
Ada has learned to treat pain and uncertainty as conditions she must master alone. Her fear of losing Jamie is therefore more immediate than grief for Mam, whose abuse has made love feel like something Ada must earn. Susan's careful clarification does more than settle a practical question: it begins to replace Ada's expectation of abandonment with dependable care. The operation also challenges the identity Mam imposed on her. Recovery gives Ada physical possibility, but it cannot instantly undo the shame and vigilance formed during years of neglect.
The Pony Is Hers
Susan2 brings Ada1 and Jamie3 back to their Kent village and into a cottage lent by Lady Thorton.4 Ada's1 first morning there, she runs to the stables and finds Butter, her beloved pony, and Fred,11 the groom, glad to have her back. She learns that Stephen White's9 younger brother and sisters were killed when bombs struck their London home; Stephen9 leaves to join his father at sea.
These losses make the village's fragile comforts feel newly precious. At Christmas, the Thortons4 welcome Ada's1 family, and their disastrous wartime dinner finally makes her laugh. On Boxing Day, she rides in a paper chase, falls at a ditch, and gets back on. Susan2 then gives her the deed to Butter, turning Ada's1 work and affection into a lasting claim.
Ada's return is not a simple homecoming. Her healed foot allows her to run to Butter, yet Stephen's news forces her to see that survival does not spare the people she loves. The Thortons' imperfect Christmas matters because Ada can join their laughter without first knowing every rule of their world. Butter's deed answers an older fear: that what she loves can be taken away without warning. The gift is material, but its psychological force is larger. Susan recognizes that safety for Ada requires more than reassurance; it also requires giving her genuine agency.
A German in the Cottage
When the government takes over Thorton House for war work, Lady Thorton4 moves into the cottage and fills Ada's1 bedroom with furniture and belongings without asking. Soon Lord Thorton8 brings Ruth Schmidt,6 a Jewish teenager from Dresden whose parents12 are interned, to live there while Susan2 tutors her in mathematics.
Ada1 sees Ruth's6 German birth as evidence of danger and watches for a spy's wireless set. Ruth's6 refusal to eat pork and her anger when Lady Thorton4 opens a letter from her mother12 reveal a life Ada1 does not understand.
Susan2 explains that Ruth's6 family is Jewish and that Hitler's persecution is not a matter of choosing a different religion. Ada1 remains suspicious, but her certainty that everyone can be sorted into friend and enemy has begun to fail.
The cottage becomes a small version of a country at war: scarce space, contested authority, and fear shaped by labels. Ada's suspicion is not innate cruelty. She has survived by reading danger quickly, and wartime propaganda offers an apparently useful shortcut: German means enemy. Ruth's letter exposes the human cost of that shortcut, while Lady Thorton's intrusion into Ada's room shows that control can also come from people trying to help. The section asks Ada to distinguish a real threat from the habits of fear that once kept her alive.
A Saddle Between Them
Ruth6 stays guarded, but Ada1 learns more about the family she left behind12 and the grandmother she cannot reach. Against Lady Thorton's4 orders, Ada1 lets Ruth6 ride Butter, first on Ada's1 twelfth birthday and then on other days when they can slip away. Riding gives Ruth6 a rare hour outside the suspicion surrounding her, while her advice helps Ada1 loosen her rigid riding style and speak more honestly about her damaged foot.
Susan2 also makes space for Ruth's6 Passover meal, setting out parsley, salt water, and wine so Ruth6 can remember her family. When Ada1 takes Ruth6 to look at the stars, she cannot fix Ruth's6 fear, but she offers company rather than interrogation. The girls begin to imagine themselves as sisters.
Trust grows here through shared practice rather than a sudden confession. On horseback, Ada and Ruth meet as capable riders before they meet as a London evacuee and a German refugee. Each offers the other a form of recognition that the household cannot yet provide: Ruth treats Ada's scar without shame, and Ada treats Ruth's longing for family as real. Susan's Passover meal extends that recognition into the home. The girls' friendship does not erase political danger or grief; it creates a relationship sturdy enough to hold both without reducing either girl to them.
The Last Dawn Ride
Jonathan Thorton,7 Maggie's5 older brother and an RAF pilot, returns briefly and keeps a promise by taking Ada,1 Maggie,5 and Ruth6 out riding before dawn. A grouse startles Oban, Jonathan's7 thoroughbred, into a gallop.
Instead of fighting the horse, Ada1 lets herself move with him and discovers the exhilaration of running freely. Months later, a telegram reports that Jonathan's7 plane exploded over the Channel. His family holds a memorial because there is no body to bury, and Ada1 sees how grief alters everyone in the cottage.
Jamie3 helps her understand that Mam's10 constant anger was not caused by Ada's foot or behavior. Ada1 also learns that she is allowed to mourn Jonathan,7 even though the Thortons4 have lost more. Her childhood explanations begin to loosen.
The dawn ride gives Ada a bodily experience of freedom just before the war makes that freedom vulnerable again. Her choice to stop resisting Oban is not recklessness; it is a new ability to respond to the present rather than anticipate punishment. Jonathan's death then makes the cost of attachment unmistakable. Ada's insight about Mam is equally important: Jamie's memory separates Mam's anger from Ada's self-blame. Together, these moments shift courage from a performance of invulnerability into something more honest, the ability to feel fear and grief without making herself responsible for everything that happens.
Ruth Saves Oban
During the potato harvest, Ada,1 Jamie,3 Maggie,5 Ruth,6 and the farm workers spend long days gathering food and earning potatoes and wages. Later, when a bout of food poisoning incapacitates the adults, Oban collapses with colic. Ruth6 recognizes the danger and makes Ada1 help keep him walking through the night, preventing him from rolling and worsening the injury.
Oban survives. Soon Ruth6 receives word that her grandmother has died in a German camp, and Lady Thorton4 responds by offering Ruth6 the use of Oban. Her decision acknowledges Ruth's6 skill and begins to loosen her distrust. Ada1 and Ruth6 ride together again, this time openly. Ruth's6 grief remains, but she no longer has to prove her belonging before she can share the horses.
The colic episode reverses the household's usual arrangement: the adults are absent, and the refugee child everyone feared becomes the person with the knowledge to save a life. Ruth's competence is practical, urgent, and earned through family experience; it cannot be dismissed as sentiment or goodwill. Ada's willingness to follow her instructions marks a deeper trust than their secret rides. Lady Thorton's later offer of Oban does not repair the loss of Ruth's grandmother, but it changes the terms of hospitality. Ruth is no longer merely tolerated; her expertise and attachment are recognized.
A Christmas Reunion
At Christmas, Lord Thorton8 brings Ruth's parents12 home after helping secure their release from internment. Their reunion gives Ruth6 back her immediate family, though she has lost her grandmother and cannot return to Dresden. The Thortons4 also give Ada1 Oban, Jonathan's7 horse, along with a letter describing the courage Jonathan7 saw in her.
Ada1 accepts the horse only long enough to give him to Ruth,6 who is leaving for secret mathematics work with her father12 and Lord Thorton8 rather than going straight to Oxford. When Ada1 later calls Lady Thorton4 a terrible mother for her harshness toward grieving Maggie,5 Ruth6 challenges her to see grief beneath the anger. Ada1 apologizes. Maggie5 returns to school, but their conflict remains unresolved.
This Christmas offers reunion without pretending to restore what war has destroyed. Ruth's parents return, but her grandmother and former home do not; the family must build a future from what remains. Ada's transfer of Oban is an act of chosen kinship, not charity. She refuses the idea that ownership must mean possession. Her confrontation with Lady Thorton is less successful at first because Ada mistakes painful protection for lack of love. Ruth's correction matters: empathy requires her to question her own certainty, not merely defend those she already understands.
Pneumonia in London
After Ruth6 leaves for war work and Maggie5 returns to school, Susan2 falls dangerously ill with pneumonia. Ada1 blames herself for failing to notice how high Susan's2 fever has become, then panics when Dr. Graham14 takes Susan2 to a London hospital.
Lady Thorton4 arranges care for Jamie3 and brings Ada1 with her to visit. While Susan2 is treated, Lady Thorton4 shows Ada1 the city she knows, then takes her to Elsa Street, Ada's1 former home. The street has been erased by bombing.
Seeing the rubble confirms that Ada1 cannot return to the life she remembers, and Lady Thorton4 acknowledges the danger Ada1 once lived through. Susan2 recovers with hospital treatment. When Ada1 returns home, she understands that Lady Thorton4 cared for her and Jamie3 while Susan2 was away.
Susan's illness reactivates Ada's oldest fear: that the adult she depends on will disappear and leave her responsible for everyone. Her guilt over the missed symptoms shows how care has become confused with control; Ada believes vigilance can prevent any loss. Lady Thorton counters that belief by making decisions Ada cannot make, including taking Susan to hospital. The ruined street supplies a concrete answer to Ada's longing to revisit the past: the place is gone, and so is the possibility of returning unchanged. Accepting care becomes an act of trust, not surrender.
The Train for Maggie
Later, while Ada1 and Lady Thorton4 fire-watch, German bombers attack the village. A Messerschmitt crashes into the main street, killing its pilot. The sight leaves Lady Thorton4 unable to speak or respond, and Ada1 recognizes a grief that has trapped her.
Using the money she saved from potato picking, Ada1 travels alone to Maggie's5 school and persuades the headmistress to call home. She tells Maggie5 that her mother needs her and brings her back. Lady Thorton4 weeps in Maggie's5 arms, and the household begins to care for them both.
Ada1 has acted without permission because she knows that safety is not always the same as what someone needs. She no longer faces fear by trying to control every outcome; she chooses a useful response and accepts help afterward.
The downed pilot turns fire-watching from rehearsal into immediate encounter. Ada cannot prevent the crash, and she cannot make Lady Thorton's grief orderly. What she can do is recognize that Maggie's presence matters more than the school's rules. Her journey is a mature echo of earlier disobedience: once she broke rules to escape an unsafe life, now she breaks them to restore a relationship. The novel does not cure grief or make war meaningful in every personal sense. It shows Ada learning to act within uncertainty, while allowing others to love and care for one another.
Epilogue
In May 1943, Ada,1 Jamie,3 Susan,2 Lady Thorton,4 and Maggie5 travel to Becky Montgomery's13 village for Ada's1 birthday. At Becky's13 grave, Susan2 unexpectedly meets Mrs. Montgomery, who had assumed Susan2 no longer wanted contact. Ada1 and Jamie3 tell her how they came to love Becky13 through Susan's2 stories.
Mrs. Montgomery invites them to her garden to share memories, and Ada1 invites her to visit Butter. Susan2 accepts the possibility of friendship where she once expected rejection. The family keeps widening, not by replacing the dead, but by making room for the people who still remember them.
The final visit gives grief a social form. Becky is absent, but the grave brings Susan and Mrs. Montgomery into the same place, where old assumptions can finally be tested. Susan had treated silence as proof that Becky’s family did not want her; Mrs. Montgomery had interpreted Susan’s absence the same way. Ada helps them interrupt that mutual withdrawal by speaking plainly about the affection she and Jamie feel. The scene echoes the novel’s larger movement from isolation toward chosen connection. Memory does not undo loss, but it can become a reason to reopen a door.
Analysis
The novel traces a movement from survival through control toward connection. Ada1 begins by treating her body, her brother,3 and every practical danger as problems she must manage alone. That strategy made sense in Mam's10 flat, where neglect taught her that adults might not protect her. In the village, however, the same vigilance keeps Ada1 from accepting care. Susan's2 guardianship, Ruth's6 friendship, and Lady Thorton's4 flawed but real protection force her to revise that expectation through repeated actions rather than reassuring promises.
War complicates every bond. Bombs kill people Ada1 knows, separate Ruth6 from her family,12 and make grief a daily condition rather than a single event. The story does not claim that loss is redeemed by courage or that suffering automatically produces wisdom. Instead, it attends to the small choices that remain possible: feeding an animal, sharing a horse, learning a new word, telling the truth, or crossing a distance to bring someone home. Ada's physical recovery is likewise neither miracle nor erasure. Her foot improves, but the scar remains; her fear persists, but it no longer dictates every decision.
The book's central insight is relational: care is not the same as control, and belonging does not require people to be easy, alike, or unafraid. Ada1 learns to accept help without surrendering judgment, to challenge adults without assuming they are enemies, and to mourn without measuring whose grief counts most. Her victory is not the end of the war. It is the enlarged ability to live among other people while the war, and its uncertainties, continue.
Review Summary
The War I Finally Won is a beloved sequel that continues Ada's story during World War II. Readers praise the emotional depth, character development, and historical accuracy. The book explores themes of family, trust, and overcoming trauma. Many consider it even better than the first, with compelling new characters and a powerful narrative. Reviewers consistently mention being moved to tears by the poignant storytelling. The audiobook narration also receives high praise. Overall, it's described as a must-read, heartwarming middle-grade novel that resonates with readers of all ages.
People Also Read
Characters
Ada Smith
Cautious, stubborn survivorAda is an observant London girl who has had to protect herself and her younger brother Jamie3 from neglect. Her untreated clubfoot, isolation, and limited schooling have taught her to expect pain and to hide what she does not know. She is resourceful, fiercely loyal, and eager to be useful, but often mistakes vigilance for responsibility. Horses give her a way to experience competence and freedom without having to explain herself. As she forms new bonds, she begins to question the shame and fear she inherited from her mother10, and to imagine a future larger than mere survival.
Susan Smith
Patient, brilliant guardianSusan is the Oxford-trained mathematician who takes responsibility for Ada1 and Jamie3 after they are evacuated from London. Reserved and grieving the loss of her closest friend, she initially doubts her ability to care for children, yet responds to their needs with steadiness and practical warmth. She teaches them, makes a home from wartime shortages, and respects Ada's1 need to understand what is happening. Susan's quiet competence contrasts with Ada's1 fear that care must be earned. Her own history of family rejection gives her a particular understanding of how deeply a child can mistake another person's failure to love.
Jamie Smith
Ada's bright younger brotherJamie is Ada's1 younger brother, affectionate, imaginative, and more willing than she is to trust the people around them. He loves his cat Bovril, animals, stories, and the small rituals of their new home. Though he depends on Ada1, he also sees things she cannot yet accept, including the possibility that Susan2 loves them and that Mam's10 anger was not Ada's1 fault. His openness gives Ada1 a counterweight to her suspicion, while his need for protection keeps her fiercely engaged with the life they are building.
Lady Eleanor Thorton
Commanding wartime organizerLady Thorton leads the village's Women's Voluntary Service and manages evacuation arrangements with brisk authority. She is proud, socially privileged, and accustomed to making decisions for others, which can make her seem cold or intrusive. Beneath that command is a strong sense of duty and a deep attachment to her family and community. She has little experience with practical domestic work and must confront what she does not know. Ada's1 frankness challenges her assumptions, while Lady Thorton's actions gradually reveal that protection can coexist with fear, grief, and imperfection.
Margaret Thorton
Ada's steadfast village friendMaggie is Lady Thorton's4 daughter and Ada's1 closest friend in the village. She is lively, affectionate, and more socially confident than Ada1, but boarding school and the war leave her isolated from the people she loves. Her relationship with her mother4 is shaped by worry on both sides: Maggie wants to be treated as a daughter, while Lady Thorton4 tries to protect her through rules. Maggie shares horses, secrets, and everyday companionship with Ada1, giving Ada1 a first experience of friendship that does not depend on being useful.
Ruth Schmidt
Jewish refugee and scholarRuth is a sixteen-year-old Jewish refugee from Dresden who lives with the Smiths1 while preparing for university examinations. Intelligent, disciplined, and guarded, she focuses on mathematics because education is both a personal ambition and a way to help her family12. Her reserve protects her from the pain of separation, but it can also make her seem contemptuous or distant. Ruth's love of horses and directness about Ada's foot gradually create a bond between the girls. She challenges Ada's1 assumptions about Germans, faith, and what it means to be an enemy.
Jonathan Thorton
Maggie's RAF brotherJonathan is Lady Thorton's4 son and Maggie's5 older brother, a pilot in the Royal Air Force. His humor and ease make the Thortons'4 grand world less intimidating to Ada1. He takes an interest in her as a person rather than as a charity case, and his love of riding gives them common ground. Jonathan carries the strain of wartime flying without making his family responsible for managing it. His moments at home reveal the generosity and uncertainty beneath his confident manner.
Lord Thorton
A discreet wartime mathematicianLord Thorton is Jonathan7 and Maggie's5 father, a large, reserved man with mathematical expertise and influential wartime connections. He recognizes Susan's2 education and finds work that lets her remain with Ada1 and Jamie3. He also brings Ruth6 into the household despite his wife's4 objections, trusting that her mathematical ability and refugee experience matter to the war effort. His secrecy frustrates Ada's1 curiosity, but his actions show a willingness to use privilege and authority to help people whom fear might otherwise exclude.
Stephen White
Ada's first London friendStephen is a boy from Ada's1 London neighborhood who helped her and Jamie3 escape the limits of their former life. He understands the conditions they came from and shares their early experience of evacuation. After devastating losses in the Blitz, he joins his father at sea rather than remain in the village. His grief is quiet and difficult for Ada1 to reach, but his return with Susan's2 photograph of Becky13 shows his instinct to preserve what matters to other people.
Mam
Ada and Jamie's motherMam is Ada1 and Jamie's3 mother, a London factory worker whose treatment of Ada1 has left the girl expecting rejection and blame. She is a powerful presence in Ada's1 memory, especially through her cruel judgments about Ada's foot. Ada1 struggles to separate Mam's anger from her own sense of worth. The children have sharply different feelings about her, and that difference helps reveal how each has survived the same difficult home in a different way.
Fred Grimes
The Thortons' trusted groomFred cares for the horses at the Thortons'4 stables and teaches Ada1 to ride and work. He values practical skill, loyalty, and hard labor, and initially shares the village's distrust of Ruth6. His respect for good horsemanship eventually gives Ruth6 another route into the community. Fred's steady presence helps Ada1 feel needed without treating her as fragile.
Herr and Frau Schmidt
Ruth's refugee parentsRuth's parents are Jewish refugees from Dresden who are separated from her in British internment. Her father is a statistician whose expertise connects the family to Lord Thorton's8 wartime work. Her mother is determined and resourceful, having persisted in finding a country that would accept them. Their reunion with Ruth6 makes visible the family life she has tried to keep at a distance, and their knowledge of horses gives them an immediate bond with Ada1.
Becky Montgomery
Susan's cherished friendBecky was Susan's2 closest friend and the original owner of Susan's2 home and pony Butter. Although Ada1 never meets her, Beery's memory helps explain Susan's2 grief and the care she has learned to offer. Her photograph and the stories Susan2 tells connect the present household to a friendship that shaped Susan's2 life.
Dr. Graham
The village doctorDr. Graham treats Jamie3 after his fall and recognizes when Susan2 needs hospital care. His calm medical decisions give the family help that Ada1 cannot provide on her own.
Rose
A hard-working Land GirlRose works the Thortons'4 farm in place of men serving in the military. She keeps the young potato pickers focused, but also recognizes their labor by explaining that they will receive wages and food.
Mrs. Elliston
A practical farm neighborMrs. Elliston and her husband manage the Thortons'4 farm. She feeds the young potato pickers and speaks honestly about her initial distrust of Ruth6, then judges her by her work.
Plot Devices
Ada's clubfoot surgery
A body learns possibilityAda's1 untreated clubfoot is both a physical obstacle and a wound shaped by Mam's10 contempt. Surgery gives her a functional foot, but recovery does not erase the years of pain or the belief that she is defective. Learning to walk, run, climb, and ride turns physical rehabilitation into a gradual challenge to shame. The device matters because the improvement is real but incomplete: Ada1 still limps at times, and her changing body cannot instantly change her expectations of herself.
Butter and Oban
Trust learned through ridingThe two horses offer Ada1 and Ruth6 space to act with competence before they can easily speak about fear or grief. Butter is Ada's1 first lasting responsibility and a source of belonging; Oban connects the girls to Jonathan7 and later to one another. Riding gives Ada1 a physical language for courage, while Ruth's6 horsemanship earns respect that prejudice had withheld. The horses are not merely symbols: their care involves work, risk, skill, and decisions that change the girls' relationships.
Blackouts and fire-watching
Fear made into a dutyBlackout screens shape daily life in the village, while fire-watching puts Ada1 and the other volunteers high in the church steeple to watch for raids and fires. For Ada1, the duty initially feels like a way to keep Jamie3 safe by staying alert. Repeated shifts expose the limits of that bargain: watching cannot prevent every danger. The steeple also brings her into contact with the sky and with other people's fears, making it a recurring place where she practices remaining present without pretending she is unafraid.
Maps and the dictionary
Tools for an unfamiliar worldSusan's2 maps and Ada's1 dictionary make the world legible to a child whose education and freedom have been restricted. Ada1 uses definitions to examine words such as guardian, ward, mercy, and belief, while maps help her understand England, the Channel, and the routes between homes. These tools do not supply simple answers. Instead, they reveal how much meaning depends on context and how often Ada1 must revise what she thinks she knows. The dragon imagery also gives her a playful way to mark the edges of the known.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.