Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
This Is How It Always Is

This Is How It Always Is

A family relocates for their transgender child, but can a fresh start survive the secret?
by Laurie Frankel 2017 338 pages
4.28
200k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

The Fifth Walsh Child

Rosie hopes a daughter will answer an old grief

Rosie Walsh, an emergency physician, and her writer husband, Penn, already have four sons: Roo, Ben, and twins Rigel and Orion. They try once more for a girl, and Rosie follows folk remedies with the cheerful skepticism of someone who cannot quite resist hope. As labor begins, she repeats the name she has carried since childhood: Poppy, the name of her younger sister, who died of cancer when Rosie was twelve.

Poppy had dreamed of having a little girl whose hair she could braid. Rosie wonders whether her own growing family is partly an attempt to keep that lost child near. The baby arrives quickly, healthy and unmistakably a boy. They name him Claude, while Rosie’s imagined daughter remains between them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The birth establishes the novel’s central tension before Claude can express any preference: a child arrives into a family already carrying an imagined identity. Rosie’s wish is loving, but it is also burdened by grief and by the fantasy that another child might repair an earlier loss. The novel does not reduce her desire for a daughter to pathology; it lets affection and projection coexist. Claude’s birth therefore begins not with a simple mismatch between expectation and reality, but with the more ordinary parental habit of seeing a future for a child before that child can speak.

A Date Before Everything

Penn waits through residency and writes their first fairy tale

The story looks back to the first evening Penn met Rosie, when his sudden certainty about her arrived before he could explain it. Rosie tells him that her sister Poppy died young, and Penn responds with attention rather than pity. Their courtship unfolds around her punishing emergency-room residency: Penn reads and writes in the hospital waiting room, then stays awake with her through shifts and learns the rhythms of her work.

He eventually tells Rosie a fairy tale about Prince Grumwald, a lonely royal looking for a life that feels earned. Years later, he tells versions of Grumwald’s continuing story to their sons. For Penn, storytelling is both courtship and care, a way to remain beside people when he cannot solve what hurts them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

This backward glance explains why the family’s later crises are narrated through stories. Penn does not use fiction to deny suffering so much as to stay present when practical answers fail. Rosie’s medical work seeks causes, diagnoses, and interventions; Penn’s stories offer companionship without claiming to cure. Their relationship is built from those complementary instincts. The contrast will sharpen when their child’s future demands decisions neither medicine nor imagination can settle alone.

The Girl Scientist

Claude keeps choosing dresses despite household bewilderment

Claude is precocious from infancy, speaking early, making elaborate cakes, and inventing stories. At three, he says he wants to grow up as a girl scientist, then wonders whether becoming a girl would mean starting childhood again.

Rosie and Penn answer warmly but do not yet grasp the question beneath the play. At Ben’s birthday, Claude makes a musical and wears the princess dress he has decorated for the performance. When Rosie insists he change for preschool, he eventually obeys, then asks for a dress of his own and wants to learn laundry and ironing so he can keep it clean.

His parents treat dresses as dress-up at first, but Claude returns to them whenever he comes home. His persistence turns a passing costume into a pattern they cannot explain away.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Claude’s questions are both imaginative and exact. The concern about starting over exposes how a young child tries to make identity fit a literal timeline, while the request to learn laundry shows that clothing is becoming part of daily life rather than pretend play. Rosie and Penn’s acceptance matters, but their easy reassurance also delays their recognition of how much the outside world may constrain Claude. Their affection is genuine; their understanding is still catching up.

A Child Disappears

School rules and classmates make Claude smaller on the page

Kindergarten brings rules Claude has not faced at home. His teacher isolates him for bringing a peanut-butter sandwich and objects to the purse he uses as a lunch tote. Claude begins changing out of dresses before school, saying classmates and his teacher think he is strange.

At Halloween he chooses Prince Grumwald, represented by a homemade foil figure with a story bursting from its mouth. The principal praises his invention but worries over his drawings: Claude appears smaller in each picture, sometimes nearly impossible to find.

Rosie and Penn consult Mr. Tongo, a hospital social worker who urges them to observe rather than force a label. When they ask what would make him happy, Claude says he wants to be a night fairy. His parents still do not know what that means.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The drawings give visible form to what Claude cannot yet articulate. He is not simply resisting a dress code; he is learning to make himself less noticeable in order to stay safe. The school’s apparently neutral rules, from lunch policies to gendered expectations, have unequal effects because Claude’s ordinary self-expression is read as disruption. Mr. Tongo’s advice slows the parents’ impulse to define him, but it also makes clear that observation is not passive. They must notice what the world is teaching their child.

Poppy Takes Her Name

A new name lets the child return to school as herself

After the family meets with school staff, Rosie and Penn prepare for Claude to attend class in a skirt and fairy wings. The night before, Penn tells a story in which Grumwald promises to support Princess Stephanie, and Claude understands that his parents will stay beside him even if school goes badly.

Claude then chooses the name Poppy, honoring Rosie’s dead sister because he loves her and wants to be close to his mother. At school, the teacher introduces Poppy as a fairy girl and invites questions.

The children ask about tights and hair, then move on. Older students are less kind, and Poppy retreats to the library or bathroom at recess and lunch. As her hair grows, however, she becomes more confident, makes friends, and begins to feel at home in the name.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Choosing Poppy’s name is not a tidy resolution; it binds a child’s self-understanding to a family memory without making the two identical. School offers a brief lesson in how children can accept what adults fear, but older students quickly demonstrate the limits of that welcome. Poppy’s growing confidence comes from repeated, practical experiences of being recognized, not from a single declaration. Her parents must learn that supporting her requires more than saying yes at home.

The Gun Next Door

A violent playdate makes Wisconsin feel unsafe

Poppy’s childhood friend Nicky invites her over, but his father, Nick Calcutti Sr., rejects her and displays a gun in his home. Poppy calls Rosie, who races over with Penn and the boys. Nick insults Poppy, warns the family away, and shoves Penn when he refuses to leave Nicky alone with him.

The family gets out without violence, but the threat stays with them. Soon Rosie treats Jane Doe, a transgender college student beaten after a fraternity party; a gunshot wound is only one of her injuries, and the student dies.

Rosie recognizes that tolerance around Madison cannot guarantee safety. She maps possible places to move and chooses Seattle, where the family hopes Poppy can live more openly. Roo resists leaving his friends and farm, but the family goes.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The two Wisconsin incidents transform a private parenting dilemma into a question of physical safety. Nick’s gun makes prejudice an immediate threat; Jane Doe’s injuries show that violence can arrive even in a supposedly accepting community. Rosie’s decision to move is an act of care, but it also imposes a cost on Roo, whose losses are real even if Poppy’s danger is more urgent. The family’s choice is not between a good option and a bad one. It is between risks they cannot fully measure.

A Life Kept Quiet

Seattle gives Poppy friends but encourages family secrecy

In Seattle, Poppy quickly bonds with Aggie Granderson, the unruly girl next door, and joins a close circle of friends. The girls share sleepovers, games, and private rituals; Poppy becomes socially confident in a way Claude never was.

Rosie and Penn decide not to explain Poppy’s history to new neighbors, following Mr. Tongo’s advice that her body is private information. The choice protects her from intrusive questions, but the family removes old photographs from the walls so no one will ask about the child they once called Claude.

Roo notices the contradiction and resents that a move supposedly made for openness has produced another secret. Meanwhile, each sibling adjusts differently: Ben thrives academically, the twins find new companions, and Roo loses the leadership roles that once defined him.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Privacy protects Poppy from being treated as a public lesson, yet concealment gradually asks the whole family to edit its past. The photographs make that cost concrete: preserving Poppy’s childhood and protecting her present seem to conflict. Roo’s anger is not simply intolerance; it is also grief over a move and a family story in which his own losses feel secondary. The novel keeps both truths in view, resisting the comforting fiction that love automatically makes every family decision fair.

The Future at Dinner

Puberty blockers divide Rosie and Penn over what comes next

As Poppy grows older, the Grandersons ask what will happen at puberty. Rosie explains that puberty blockers can delay unwanted physical changes, while Penn has read accounts from transgender children who describe the treatment as lifesaving.

Rosie worries about limited long-term evidence and about making decisions before Poppy understands their consequences; Penn fears that waiting could allow irreversible changes that Poppy will later regret. Their disagreement widens beyond medicine. Penn sees intervention as a way to protect the girl Poppy knows herself to be, while Rosie insists that no one can yet know exactly what Poppy will want.

At the same time, Roo’s frustration deepens. His school project about LGBTQ people in the military is crude and fails, but beneath the provocation lies a concern about prejudice that his parents do not initially recognize.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The parents’ dispute is not a contest between acceptance and rejection. Both are trying to protect Poppy, but they locate danger in different places: Penn fears bodily change that cannot be reversed, while Rosie fears intervention that forecloses a choice. Their uncertainty is intensified by unequal expertise. Rosie knows medicine but lacks definitive evidence; Penn has found testimony that is emotionally persuasive but cannot settle the clinical questions. Roo’s failed project parallels this conflict: an important argument can be obscured by the way it is presented.

The Secret Gets Out

A leaked essay turns private history into school gossip

Roo’s resentment erupts when his parents confront him about his failing history project and a forged signature. He accuses them of hypocrisy for keeping Poppy’s past private, then later explains that his fights with a classmate were meant to answer anti-gay insults, not express prejudice.

Ben, hoping to prove his love to Cayenne, has already told her the family secret; Rigel and Orion share it with a boy seeking help, and Roo has blurted it during a fight. None causes the exposure.

A school employee’s husband mistakenly carries Roo’s essay about his family to work, where it reaches the mother of Poppy’s classmate. Gossip spreads. Poppy leaves class, withdraws from friends, shaves her head, and returns to the name Claude, convinced he must become a boy again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The novel carefully separates the many disclosures from the actual leak. That distinction matters: the family’s secrecy has become fragile, but the children who speak do so from different motives, including loyalty and a wish to help. The essay’s accidental circulation shows how little control a family has over information once it enters institutions. Poppy experiences exposure not as clarification but as the collapse of both available selves. Claude’s return is therefore less a settled identity than a desperate attempt to make the shame and confusion stop.

Claude Goes Away

Rosie takes her child to a remote Thai clinic

Claude refuses school and shuts himself in his room. Penn researches surgery, while Rosie argues that their child needs time rather than another adult decision. When her employer, Howie, threatens her place in the practice, Rosie agrees to volunteer at a clinic in northern Thailand and takes Claude with her.

The journey is difficult, and the clinic is unlike any hospital Rosie knows: it lacks basic equipment, supplies, and reliable transport. Rosie works beside K, a mechanic who also serves as midwife, medic, translator, and community support.

Claude, still bald and miserable, is assigned to teach English to local children. In Bangkok, he notices transgender women moving through public life without the scrutiny he has known at home. He is not ready to feel hopeful, but the distance gives him room to see another way of living.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The trip is both retreat and encounter. Rosie takes Claude away from a school that has become unbearable, but she cannot make the journey a cure or guarantee that home will feel safe afterward. At the clinic, her professional certainty is stripped of machines and familiar procedures; she must improvise with what is available. Claude faces a parallel displacement. Seeing gender variance treated differently does not resolve his identity, but it loosens the assumption that his experience has only one possible meaning.

Finding the Middle Way

K helps Rosie and Claude imagine more than two choices

Claude’s students trade local folktales for the stories he knows, and he begins retelling Grumwald and Princess Stephanie in new forms. Rosie learns that K is a transgender woman whose family and community accept her without treating her body as the whole story.

K describes life as continual change and teaches Rosie to look beyond the choice between hiding Poppy and forcing an immediate decision. In Chiang Mai, Claude sees a public restroom marked for people who do not fit the usual male or female categories.

Rosie recognizes that both her fear and Penn’s certainty have narrowed the options. Penn calls from Seattle with news that he has sold his book about Grumwald. Rosie decides to return home, support Poppy without erasing Claude, and keep helping at the clinic when she can.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

K does not give Rosie a prescription; she changes the frame in which Rosie understands the problem. The middle way is not a compromise that splits the difference between boy and girl. It is a practice of living while identity and knowledge remain unfinished. Claude’s retellings enact the same principle: familiar stories survive by changing, not by being preserved untouched. The gender-inclusive restroom is a small, practical sign that a third route can be built, rather than merely imagined.

A Happy Middle

Poppy returns to school and makes peace with Aggie

Back in Seattle, Poppy attends the fifth-grade Valentine’s dance with her hair still short and her confidence uncertain. Jake Irving apologizes for joining the classmates who mocked her, then asks her to dance; Poppy accepts, and his ordinary kindness begins to repair their connection. In the bathroom, Aggie admits she is hurt that Poppy kept the secret from her.

Poppy explains that she is not simply a boy or a girl, but something more complicated, and Aggie accepts that they can still be friends. Rosie and Penn dance together while their children tease them afterward. Penn’s Grumwald book now has a publisher, but the family’s relief is not a final cure or fixed ending. They leave Poppy room to change, decide, and keep becoming.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending offers repair without pretending that a dance or apology can undo months of humiliation. Jake’s invitation and Aggie’s renewed friendship matter because they restore ordinary participation: Poppy can be seen, speak, and choose whether to dance. The parents’ own dance echoes that modest recovery, but the novel refuses a fairy-tale finality. Its resolution is a renewed capacity to stay together without demanding that Poppy settle every question first. The family’s future remains open, which is precisely what makes the happiness credible.

Analysis

This novel locates its deepest conflict not in a child’s identity alone, but in the adults and institutions that demand a settled answer before a child can safely live. Rosie and Penn are loving parents whose methods differ because they imagine different dangers. Penn fears irreversible bodily change; Rosie fears that intervention may impose an answer and that social hostility will turn a private life into public scrutiny. Neither position is foolish, and neither is sufficient. Their arguments are sharpened by the gap between medical knowledge and the uncertain, long-term choices they face.

The book’s recurring stories make that uncertainty legible. Grumwald’s adventures do not function as coded lessons with one correct interpretation. They change as the children change, and Claude’s retellings in Thailand demonstrate that meaning can be inherited without being fixed. The family’s task is similar: preserve love and memory while allowing the person they love to become someone they could not predict.

The novel also distinguishes privacy from secrecy. Protecting Poppy’s bodily privacy can be an act of respect; hiding the family’s photographs and history places an increasingly heavy burden on everyone. The accidental leak does not prove that disclosure is always safer. It shows that secrecy cannot control the world indefinitely, especially when several children must carry it. Roo’s resentment further complicates the family’s moral arithmetic: care for one child can be necessary and still leave another feeling abandoned.

Thailand offers no magical cure. The clinic exposes Rosie’s limits as a physician, while K’s presence and the gender-inclusive bathroom expand the imaginable choices. The final dance is deliberately modest. Poppy is not promised a painless future, nor are her parents given certainty about puberty or treatment. Instead, they regain the ability to stay present, repair relationships, and leave room for the next decision. The novel’s most persuasive hope is not a perfect ending. It is a family capable of making a life while the story remains unfinished.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Rosie and Penn Walsh, parents of four boys, welcome a fifth child, Claude, though Rosie had long imagined a daughter named Poppy. As Claude grows, he repeatedly chooses dresses and says he wants to be a girl. With their support, Claude takes the name Poppy and begins living as a girl, but hostility at school and a threatening neighbor prompt the family to move from Wisconsin to Seattle. There, Poppy thrives, while her parents keep her history private. Their disagreement over puberty blockers deepens, and the secret spreads through school gossip. Poppy withdraws and returns to the name Claude. Rosie takes Claude to a clinic in Thailand, where a transgender midwife and new experiences broaden their sense of what is possible. Back home, Poppy reconnects with classmates and explains her identity to Aggie. Rosie and Penn accept that they cannot settle Poppy’s future for her, and commit to supporting her as it unfolds.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.28 out of 5
Average of 200k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

This Is How It Always Is receives mostly positive reviews for its heartfelt exploration of raising a transgender child. Readers praise the complex family dynamics, emotional depth, and thought-provoking themes. Many find the writing beautiful and the characters well-developed. Some criticize the plot as unrealistic or too perfect, while others appreciate the hopeful tone. The book sparks discussions about parenting, acceptance, and gender identity. Overall, it's seen as an important, compassionate story that offers insight into a challenging topic.

Your rating:
4.64
206 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Poppy / Claude

Youngest child seeking selfhood

The youngest of Rosie and Penn’s five children, Poppy is imaginative, quick-witted, and intensely attentive to how other people understand her. Her changing name and presentation are part of a larger effort to make sense of a self that does not fit the simple categories adults and classmates expect. She is also a child, with the ordinary needs for friendship, play, safety, and parental reassurance that can be obscured when others treat her identity as a debate. Her curiosity about stories, science, and the natural world gives her ways to think beyond the immediate pressure to define herself.

Rosie Walsh

Doctor and watchful mother

An emergency physician and mother of five, Rosie meets uncertainty with observation, practical action, and a powerful instinct to protect. Her sister’s death shaped the hopes she carried into motherhood, though Rosie does not always recognize how grief influences her expectations. Medicine has trained her to seek evidence and make decisions under pressure, but parenting offers no reliable diagnostic test for what a child will need years later. Rosie is direct, capable, and loving, yet she can mistake caution for safety or assume that moving a family will resolve a danger. Her challenge is to remain attentive without taking over her child’s choices.

Penn Walsh

Storyteller and devoted father

Penn is a writer, husband, and hands-on father whose instinct is to turn experience into stories. He notices emotional patterns and uses fairy tales to help his children make sense of fear, change, and family life. His patience during Rosie’s residency establishes him as a steady partner, while his imaginative confidence can sometimes outrun the evidence. Penn wants to protect his youngest child from pain and is drawn to solutions that promise transformation. At his best, he understands that stories create possibilities rather than dictate endings; at his most anxious, he risks treating the story he hopes for as certainty.

Roo Walsh-Adams

Restless eldest brother

Roo is the eldest son, socially confident and accustomed to leading teams, clubs, and school activities. He values belonging and visible achievement, so family upheaval costs him more than he readily admits. His humor can be sharp, and his teenage anger often arrives before he can explain the hurt beneath it. Roo is protective of his siblings but also resentful when their needs reshape his life. He is learning how masculinity, loyalty, and courage are judged by peers, and his attempts to meet those expectations do not always match what he actually believes.

Ben Walsh-Adams

Thoughtful middle brother

Ben is gifted, bookish, and perceptive, often the family member who can explain a complicated fact when others are talking past one another. His intelligence does not spare him the uncertainty of adolescence, particularly when affection and loyalty become difficult to manage. He is deeply attached to his siblings and often tries to solve emotional problems with careful reasoning. Ben’s habit of thinking ahead can become a refuge from taking risks, while his wish to be loved can make him less cautious than he believes himself to be.

Rigel Walsh-Adams

Inventive twin brother

Rigel is one of the younger twins, energetic, crafty, and devoted to knitting, costumes, and elaborate games. His humor and practical creativity make him a vivid presence in the crowded Walsh-Adams household. He often acts in tandem with Orion, but he has his own sense of fairness and responsibility. Rigel’s loyalty to his siblings is instinctive, and he can shoulder blame to protect his twin. His playfulness helps the family keep affection alive even when difficult conversations have left everyone tense.

Orion Walsh-Adams

Unruly twin brother

Orion is Rigel’s twin, a mischievous performer who experiments with costumes, props, and physical comedy. He often speaks or acts before thinking, especially when a funny remark or dramatic entrance presents itself. Beneath the chaos is a boy who cares about his siblings and wants to be included in the family’s games and stories. Orion’s impulsiveness can have consequences, but his willingness to help and his capacity for affection are as real as his appetite for spectacle.

Carmelo

Rosie’s candid mother

Carmelo, Rosie’s mother and the children’s grandmother, lives in Phoenix and visits the family in Wisconsin and Seattle. Glamorous, outspoken, and unsentimental about convention, she gives her grandchildren room to experiment without making them defend themselves. Her own loss of a child gives her a clear sense of how limited time can be, and she urges Rosie to value a child’s present happiness. Carmelo’s support is warm but not overbearing; she knows when to comfort, when to challenge, and when a blunt joke is better than a lecture.

Mr. Tongo

Unconventional counselor

A social worker and therapist connected to Rosie’s hospital, Mr. Tongo approaches families with a mix of playfulness and serious attention. His odd props and exuberant manner can unsettle Penn, but his questions help the parents distinguish their fears from their child’s needs. He does not insist that a young child adopt a permanent label. Instead, he asks Rosie and Penn to watch closely, make room for uncertainty, and consider how school and community shape a child’s sense of safety.

Aggie Granderson

Poppy’s neighbor and friend

Aggie is the spirited younger daughter of Rosie and Penn’s Seattle neighbors. She is noisy, inventive, adventurous, and difficult to contain within conventional ideas of how a girl should behave. Her friendship with Poppy begins in imaginative play and grows into an intimate bond built on shared games, secrets, and trust. Aggie is blunt about her feelings and expects honesty from the people she loves. Her own awkwardness and eccentricity make her a companion rather than a perfect ally, which gives their friendship emotional weight.

Marginny Granderson

Neighbor wary of disclosure

Marginny is Aggie’s mother and Rosie’s new neighbor in Seattle. Friendly and socially attentive, she wants her daughters to treat Poppy naturally, but she also prefers not to explain Poppy’s history to them. Her instinct is to avoid confusion and let the children form their own understanding. That approach is meant kindly, though it creates questions about when privacy becomes secrecy. Marginny is important because she gives Rosie a close friend whose good intentions do not always align with the family’s needs.

Frank Granderson

Neighbor learning to ask

Frank is Marginny’s husband and Aggie’s father. He is sociable, prone to nervous overexplaining, and initially unsure how to respond to Poppy’s family history. His awkwardness can produce intrusive questions, but he is capable of recognizing when he has caused discomfort and of apologizing. Frank helps create the neighborhood setting that gives Poppy friendship and ordinary social life, while his questions reveal how difficult it can be for adults to balance curiosity with a child’s right to privacy.

Nicky Calcutti

Claude’s early friend

Nicky is a quiet boy who was Claude’s first close friend outside the family. He prefers calm, parallel play to loud games, and his easy companionship helps Claude feel accepted before school becomes difficult. Nicky’s home life is complicated by his parents’ separation, leaving him caught between adults who do not always protect him from their conflict.

Nick Calcutti Sr.

Threatening playdate father

Nicky’s father is domineering, openly prejudiced, and accustomed to treating his own beliefs as rules for others. He keeps a gun visible and uses his authority in the home to intimidate. His presence forces Rosie and Penn to confront the possibility that social disapproval can become a physical danger.

K

Clinic’s resourceful medic

K works at the northern Thai clinic as a mechanic, midwife, medic, translator, and trusted community member. She has accumulated practical medical knowledge through necessity and experience, often finding workable solutions where equipment and supplies are absent. K is composed under pressure, generous with patients, and attentive to the whole person rather than a single diagnosis. Her understanding of gender and community offers Rosie and Claude a perspective beyond the strict categories they have encountered at home.

Jane Doe

Injured college patient

Jane Doe is a college student whom Rosie treats in the emergency room after a brutal assault. Her injuries confront Rosie with the difference between a community’s reputation for tolerance and the safety its vulnerable members actually experience. The patient’s story becomes an urgent measure of the risks Rosie is trying to understand.

Chad Perry

Fraternity student in crisis

Chad is a student at the fraternity party where Jane Doe is attacked. His actions emerge from a volatile mix of attraction, shock, and panic, making him part of the chain of events that leaves the patient critically injured. He is a reminder that moments of apparent tenderness can turn dangerous when fear and prejudice take over.

Howie

Demanding medical partner

Howie is one of Rosie’s partners at the Seattle family practice. He is ambitious about the clinic’s public profile and expects colleagues to contribute beyond seeing patients. His demands frustrate Rosie, who sees patient care and family responsibilities as sufficient work, but his pressure also shapes her decision to accept an overseas volunteer assignment.

Plot Devices

Grumwald’s Endless Tale

Stories make room for change

Penn invents the story of Prince Grumwald and tells it to Rosie and the boys in installments. The fairy tale grows alongside the family, gaining Princess Stephanie and new adventures as the children change. It gives the family a shared language for loyalty, fear, and transformation, but it is not a simple code in which every character maps neatly onto one child. In Thailand, Claude retells the story to students, mixing it with the local tales they share with him. That exchange shows that stories survive through revision. Penn eventually publishes a version, turning a private family practice into a book that can continue beyond the household.

Names and Photographs

Identity meets family memory

Names and pictures make identity tangible throughout the novel. Rosie has carried Poppy’s name since childhood, and the name becomes part of Claude’s self-understanding. At the same time, the family’s photographs preserve earlier versions of their children and their shared life. In Seattle, Penn puts the childhood pictures away because he fears they will expose Poppy’s history, while Rosie grieves the loss of seeing the family displayed together. These objects show that remembering can be both loving and dangerous. A name can affirm belonging, while a photograph can preserve a past that the present cannot yet explain to strangers.

The Unfinished Map

Safety becomes a family choice

After Nick Calcutti’s threat and Jane Doe’s assault, Rosie studies a map of the United States and marks places where she believes her family might be safer. The map turns an emotional argument into a practical search, with climate, work, schools, space, and community all competing for attention. Seattle emerges as a place with both a job and a more visible queer community, but moving cannot guarantee safety or erase the cost to Roo. The map therefore does not provide a perfect answer. It makes the parents’ guess concrete and shows how a decision made for one child reshapes the lives of all five.

Privacy and Secrecy

Protection has a hidden cost

Rosie and Penn initially keep Poppy’s history from their new neighbors and classmates, partly to protect her from scrutiny and partly because they do not know how to explain it. The decision helps Poppy become known simply as herself, but it also requires the family to conceal photographs and monitor what the children say. Because several siblings carry the information, the secret strains their relationships and eventually circulates beyond their control. The novel distinguishes a child’s right to bodily privacy from the family’s burden of hiding its own history. That distinction becomes central when Poppy’s classmates learn what the adults hoped to keep quiet.

Thailand’s Middle Way

A third path becomes imaginable

The Thai clinic and its surrounding community challenge the binary choices Rosie and Penn have been making. K’s experience, the local stories Claude exchanges with students, the temples, and a restroom designed for people who do not fit standard categories all offer alternatives to concealment or forced certainty. These encounters do not solve the family’s medical questions or guarantee acceptance back home. Instead, they alter how Rosie thinks about change: identity can remain in motion, and support can be built before every question is answered. The middle way becomes a practical ethic of listening, adapting, and deciding together when the time is right.

FAQ

Synopsis & Basic Details

What is This Is How It Always Is about?

  • Family navigates gender identity: The story centers on the Walsh-Adams family as they navigate the complexities of raising their youngest child, Claude, who identifies as a girl named Poppy.
  • Challenges to societal norms: The novel explores the family's journey as they grapple with societal expectations, personal truths, and the challenges of raising a child who defies traditional gender norms.
  • Love and acceptance prevail: At its core, the book is about the power of family love and acceptance, as the Walsh-Adams family learns to support Poppy's transition while navigating their own fears and uncertainties.

Why should I read This Is How It Always Is?

  • Unique perspective on gender: The novel offers a fresh and nuanced perspective on gender identity, challenging readers to reconsider their own assumptions and biases.
  • Emotional family story: It's a deeply emotional and relatable story about family, love, and the challenges of raising children in a complex world.
  • Thought-provoking themes: The book explores thought-provoking themes of identity, acceptance, and the importance of authenticity, making it a compelling read for anyone interested in social issues.

What is the background of This Is How It Always Is?

  • Contemporary societal context: The novel is set in a contemporary world where discussions about gender identity are becoming more prevalent, reflecting current social and cultural conversations.
  • Focus on family dynamics: The story is grounded in the everyday realities of family life, exploring the challenges and joys of raising multiple children and navigating complex relationships.
  • Exploration of personal journeys: The book delves into the personal journeys of each family member, highlighting their individual struggles and growth as they adapt to changing circumstances.

What are the most memorable quotes in This Is How It Always Is?

  • "Is it always 'or'? Is it never 'and'?": This quote from Stephen Sondheim's Into the Woods encapsulates the novel's exploration of the complexities of identity and the desire to embrace multiple truths.
  • "I am large, I contain multitudes.": This quote from Walt Whitman's "Song of Myself" reflects the novel's theme of embracing the multifaceted nature of identity and the human experience.
  • "For the moment's all there is, my darling.": This quote, spoken by Carmelo, highlights the importance of living in the present and cherishing the joy of the moment, especially in the face of uncertainty.

What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Laurie Frankel use?

  • Character-driven narrative: Frankel employs a character-driven narrative, focusing on the internal thoughts and emotions of her characters to create a deeply personal and relatable story.
  • Humorous and poignant tone: The novel blends humor and poignancy, using wit and sarcasm to explore serious themes while maintaining an engaging and accessible tone.
  • Multiple perspectives: The story is told from multiple perspectives, allowing readers to gain a deeper understanding of each character's unique experiences and challenges.

Hidden Details & Subtle Connections

What are some minor details that add significant meaning?

  • The spoon under the bed: Rosie's attempt to influence the baby's gender by placing a wooden spoon under the bed highlights her internal conflict between logic and superstition, and her deep desire for a daughter.
  • The names of the dolls: The children's dolls, named after flowers, connect to Rosie's sister Poppy, who also had a doll named Clover, emphasizing the theme of remembrance and the enduring impact of loss.
  • The recurring mention of "red": The color red appears in various contexts, from red meat to red hair, subtly foreshadowing the passion and intensity of the characters' emotions and experiences.

What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?

  • Penn's airport stories: Penn's early stories about people at airports foreshadow his later ability to observe and understand the complexities of human emotions and relationships, which he uses to support his family.
  • The suit of armor: The recurring image of the suit of armor outside the prince's room, initially filled with roses and later with stories, foreshadows the power of storytelling and the importance of self-discovery.
  • The "tea-length" dress: Claude's initial concern about his dress being "tea-length" foreshadows his later exploration of gender expression and the challenges he faces in navigating societal expectations.

What are some unexpected character connections?

  • Heather's persistent questions: Heather, the neighbor, serves as a foil to Rosie, highlighting the societal pressures and judgments that the family faces, and her questions become a recurring reminder of the outside world's scrutiny.
  • Mr. Tongo's unconventional wisdom: Mr. Tongo, the therapist, provides unexpected insights and support, challenging the family's assumptions and offering a fresh perspective on their situation.
  • The children's shared stories: The children's shared stories and games, such as the "Penis Man" and the "Banana Ass Hulk," reveal their unique ways of processing their emotions and experiences, creating a sense of family unity.

Who are the most significant supporting characters?

  • Carmelo: Rosie's mother, Carmelo, provides a source of unconditional love and acceptance, particularly for Poppy, and her own experiences with loss and resilience offer a valuable perspective.
  • Aggie: Poppy's best friend, Aggie, represents the importance of genuine friendship and acceptance, and her unwavering support helps Poppy navigate the challenges of her identity.
  • Mr. Tongo: The therapist, Mr. Tongo, offers unconventional wisdom and guidance, challenging the family's assumptions and helping them navigate the complexities of Poppy's transition.

Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis

What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?

  • Rosie's desire for a daughter: Rosie's deep-seated desire for a daughter, stemming from her sister's death, drives her to try various methods to influence the baby's gender, revealing her emotional vulnerability.
  • Penn's need for narrative: Penn's tendency to view life through the lens of narrative reveals his need to find meaning and order in the chaos of family life, and his desire to create a story that will protect his children.
  • Roo's struggle for identity: Roo's anger and resentment stem from his unspoken fear of being overshadowed by Poppy's transition, and his need to assert his own identity within the family.

What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?

  • Rosie's internal conflict: Rosie's struggle to reconcile her scientific mind with her emotional desires and fears highlights the psychological complexities of motherhood and the challenges of accepting the unknown.
  • Penn's avoidance of reality: Penn's reliance on storytelling and metaphor reveals his tendency to avoid the harsh realities of life, and his struggle to reconcile his idealized vision of family with the complexities of his children's lives.
  • Poppy's search for self: Poppy's journey is marked by a complex interplay of self-discovery and external pressures, as she grapples with her identity and the challenges of navigating a world that often fails to understand her.

What are the major emotional turning points?

  • Claude's first expression of gender identity: Claude's early statements about wanting to be a girl mark a major emotional turning point, forcing his parents to confront their own assumptions and biases.
  • The move to Seattle: The family's relocation to Seattle represents a significant emotional shift, as they leave behind familiar surroundings and embark on a journey of self-discovery and acceptance.
  • The unravelling of secrets: The revelation of Poppy's past to her peers and the subsequent fallout create a major emotional turning point, forcing the family to confront their fears and insecurities.

How do relationship dynamics evolve?

  • Rosie and Penn's partnership: Rosie and Penn's relationship evolves from a spontaneous love affair to a deep partnership, as they learn to navigate the challenges of parenting and supporting each other through difficult times.
  • The sibling bond: The sibling bond between the Walsh-Adams boys is tested and strengthened as they navigate the complexities of Poppy's transition, learning to support and accept each other despite their differences.
  • Poppy and Aggie's friendship: Poppy and Aggie's friendship evolves from a simple bond to a complex relationship, as they navigate the challenges of identity and acceptance, learning to support each other through difficult times.

Interpretation & Debate

Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?

  • Poppy's future identity: The novel leaves Poppy's future identity open-ended, suggesting that her journey of self-discovery is ongoing and that her identity may continue to evolve.
  • The long-term impact of blockers: The long-term effects of hormone blockers on Poppy's physical and emotional development remain ambiguous, highlighting the uncertainties and complexities of medical interventions.
  • The family's future: The novel's ending leaves the family's future open-ended, suggesting that their journey of acceptance and understanding is ongoing and that they will continue to face new challenges and opportunities.

What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in This Is How It Always Is?

  • The decision to keep Poppy's past a secret: The family's decision to keep Poppy's past a secret from their new community is a controversial one, raising questions about the ethics of secrecy and the impact on Poppy's sense of self.
  • The use of hormone blockers: The novel's exploration of hormone blockers raises questions about the ethics of medical interventions and the potential long-term effects on children's development.
  • The portrayal of gender roles: The novel's portrayal of traditional gender roles and the challenges of defying them can be seen as both empowering and problematic, sparking debate about the complexities of gender identity and expression.

This Is How It Always Is Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means

  • Poppy's return to school: Poppy's return to school after a period of absence marks a significant moment of self-acceptance and resilience, as she embraces her identity and faces her peers with newfound courage.
  • The family's ongoing journey: The novel's ending emphasizes that the family's journey of acceptance and understanding is ongoing, and that they will continue to face new challenges and opportunities as they navigate the complexities of their lives.
  • The power of storytelling: The novel's ending highlights the power of storytelling as a means of understanding and connecting with others, and the importance of sharing one's truth to create a more inclusive and accepting world.

About the Author

Laurie Frankel is the bestselling author of five novels, including the upcoming "Family Family" and the widely acclaimed "This Is How It Always Is." Her work often explores complex family dynamics and contemporary social issues. Frankel's personal experience as the parent of a transgender child informs her writing, particularly in "This Is How It Always Is." Based in Seattle, she brings an East Coast sensibility to her work. Frankel is known for her compassionate storytelling and ability to tackle difficult subjects with humor and sensitivity. Beyond writing, she is passionate about baseball, theater, and reading, and she practices yoga and makes soup.

Download PDF

To save this This Is How It Always Is summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.44 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this This Is How It Always Is summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.42 MB     Pages: 40
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...