Plot Summary
Leaving the Unremembered Home
Simon packs for Shadowhunter Academy with jokes on his T-shirts and a lie arranged by the warlock Magnus: a fictitious scholarship. He remembers what his mother cannot, including the time she cast him out after he became a vampire.
Though she now sends him off with love, he cannot live beside her while carrying that unacknowledged wound. His sister Rebecca's good-luck card gives him one comfort. At the New York Institute, his friends gather to say goodbye.
Clary's tears and Jace's awkward warmth stir scraps of affection, while Isabelle's guarded farewell exposes how much he cannot remember about their relationship. Simon leaves with Catarina Loss, a warlock who opens a Portal to Idris, hoping distance and training might make him feel whole again.
Simon’s departure is driven less by ambition than by the strain of being loved by people who remember a version of him he cannot fully access. His mother’s affection cannot undo the rejection he still carries, because the injury is real to him even when it has vanished from her experience. At the Institute, the same mismatch appears in sharper form: Clary, Jace, and Isabelle recognize their shared history, while Simon meets them through emotional fragments. The Academy promises a clean task, becoming a warrior, but his decision also postpones an intimate problem. Leaving is both an act of self-preservation and an attempt to earn back a place he already fears he has lost.
A Rotten Welcome to Idris
Catarina leads Simon through Idris's green countryside to the Academy, a castle-like school concealed beyond the forest. Up close, its leaning tower, broken stained glass, and cobwebbed windows make its grandeur look precarious.
Dean Vivianne Penhallow admits that renovations have failed, teachers have quit, and the kitchens have no supplies. She leaves Simon with Julie Beauvale, who takes him to a room already occupied by George Lovelace. George is perched on a stool because a possum is hiding in the wardrobe.
Simon attacks it with a tennis racket, misses, hits himself, and sends the animal fleeing. The three teenagers collapse into laughter. For the first time since leaving New York, Simon finds relief in being among ordinary, inept students rather than people waiting for him to become a remembered hero.
The Academy’s first lesson is accidental: its students are not yet the polished fighters Simon associates with Shadowhunters. The possum turns the school’s prestige into a physical joke, and Simon’s clumsy failure places him on equal footing with George and Julie. That equality matters because Simon has been measuring every relationship against memories he cannot reproduce. The building works similarly. From a distance it offers a beautiful, coherent identity; at close range it reveals rot, missing resources, and neglected rooms. Simon’s new beginning is therefore stripped of fantasy almost immediately. The laughter that follows does not solve his disorientation, but it gives him a small, unearned moment of belonging.
Bloodlines Set the Classroom
At dinner, Simon learns that the Academy divides students into an advanced stream for Shadowhunter bloodlines and a basic stream for mundanes. Julie and Jonathan Cartwright treat Simon as an exception because he once helped save the world, while George is assured that his Lovelace ancestry will carry him through.
Their confidence unsettles Simon: the hierarchy rewards family before knowledge, and the younger mundane students look less like recruits than children with nowhere better to go. The school's practical failures continue.
Training master Delaney Scarsbury measures Simon for ill-fitting gear, mocks his narrow shoulders, and gives him a dagger that Simon promptly lodges in a desk. His early lessons make clear that remembered heroism has not given his present body any skill, and he has no special status he can comfortably claim.
The two streams turn inherited identity into an institutional rule. Simon is praised as an exception, but that praise does not dismantle the system; it merely exempts him from its most visible insult. His discomfort recognizes the cost of being singled out as worthy only because of a past achievement. George’s presumed privilege exposes the same contradiction from the other side: the school treats ancestry as proof of aptitude before either student has demonstrated what they can do. Scarsbury’s treatment of Simon then brings the hierarchy into the body, where clothing, strength, and weapon handling become public measures of belonging. Simon cannot rely on reputation without feeling fraudulent, so training forces the question of who he is now.
The Bow Remembers
During sword practice, Simon is paired with Marisol, a younger mundane student who had cried when Scarsbury first appeared. Simon tries to go easy on her, but Marisol, orphaned and trained in fencing since childhood, defeats him cleanly and leaves him sprawled in the dirt.
Running and horseback lessons deepen his humiliation; Simon falls behind, and his horse wanders into the woods until evening while George worries about him. Then Scarsbury hands him a bow. Simon finds the balance, releases three arrows into their targets, and remembers being human when he first killed a demon.
His accuracy gives him a rare sense of pleasure in his living body. At dinner, his stories about the past attract admiration, but Jon's disgust at the thought of a Downworlder biting Shadowhunters leaves Simon wary of that new attention.
Marisol’s victory corrects Simon’s assumption that shared mundanity makes him the more capable or protective one. Her history, and her refusal to be patronized, give her competence a concrete source rather than a magical exception. Simon’s failures with running and riding make the loss of his vampire strength tangible, while archery offers a different kind of continuity: a practiced human skill connected to a choice he once made under pressure. The pleasure comes not from becoming superhuman again but from feeling effort in a body that can tire. Yet the attention that follows is unstable. His classmates admire the story of his past while reducing it to a spectacle, especially when Jon reacts to his former vampirism with revulsion.
Jordan's Grief Returns
That night, Simon's scattered memories return in a rush. He remembers Jordan, the roommate who took him in after his mother shut him out, listened to him, and treated him as more than a vampire to manage. The memory also brings back Jordan's death and the pendant Simon held afterward. Simon had known the fact, but not felt its weight; now grief arrives as if the loss has happened again.
He bolts from bed, unable to breathe, and tells George what he has remembered. George does not demand an explanation. He puts a steady hand on Simon's shoulder and stays beside him in the dark. Simon's pain is not cured, but George's quiet presence keeps him from bearing the returned memory alone.
The memory does not simply restore information; it restores attachment. Simon knew Jordan was dead as a fact, but the remembered acts of care make that fact emotionally legible: Jordan offered shelter and companionship when Simon was rejected and feared. In this sense, Simon experiences bereavement twice, first through the original loss and then through the return of the feelings that memory loss had suspended. His distress also complicates the goal of becoming his former self. Recovery is not a clean return to a heroic identity; it means taking on grief he had not been able to carry before. George’s response matters precisely because he does not interpret or repair the pain. He offers presence instead.
Simon Chooses the Mundane Stream
At dinner, Julie and Jon dismiss werewolves as lesser beings, and Simon thinks of Jordan. He challenges their contempt for Downworlders and for mundane students, then walks to Vivianne and asks to join the mundane stream rather than remain an honored exception among the elite.
Catarina helps him move to the basement, where black slime coats the walls. As they pack, she explains that she came to teach in memory of her friend Ragnor, despite her distrust of Shadowhunters.
Simon tells her that becoming a Shadowhunter cannot erase the person he was as a vampire. The next day, George arrives with his suitcase and broken tennis racket, choosing the same stream. Beatriz stays in the advanced classes but makes clear that she still wants to be Simon's friend.
Simon’s choice changes the terms on which he wants to belong. Rather than accept a place granted as a special favor, he aligns himself with students the Academy classifies as lesser. His protest is not abstract: Julie and Jon’s talk of werewolves makes prejudice personal through his memories of Jordan. Catarina’s explanation of her own motive creates a parallel. She teaches among Shadowhunters not because she trusts their institution, but because loyalty to Ragnor matters more than her resentment. Simon similarly refuses to treat his former vampire life as disposable simply because the Academy offers him a new identity. George’s decision to follow turns Simon’s moral choice into a shared risk, while Beatriz’s friendship shows that changing groups need not mean severing every bond.
Isabelle Claims Her Place
Isabelle arrives at the Academy as a guest lecturer, but her real purpose becomes clear when she tells the assembled students that Simon is her boyfriend and warns them not to target him. Her public claim unsettles both of them.
Simon catches up with her in the hall and admits he cannot be the boyfriend she remembers, because he lacks too many of their shared memories and cannot recreate their old relationship on command. Isabelle argues that becoming a Shadowhunter is not the same as becoming special, and presses him to decide why he wants the life.
Simon concedes that he had hoped training would turn him back into the hero his friends remember. He apologizes for giving Isabelle that hope, but she leaves angry and hurt, unwilling to keep waiting on his terms.
The encounter breaks Simon’s fantasy that training can function as a machine for restoring his former self. Isabelle’s public declaration expresses both courage and a wish to make their relationship real again, but it also exposes how much Simon has been performing toward an imagined standard. His refusal is painful because it is not a rejection of Isabelle’s importance; it is an attempt to stop using her faith as a promise he cannot make. Isabelle’s challenge shifts the central question from whether Simon can regain lost memories to whether he has a reason of his own to become a Shadowhunter. Her departure leaves that question unresolved, and forces Simon to face the damage caused by a hope he offered before understanding himself.
George's Borrowed Name
After Isabelle leaves, Simon hides in the bathroom and tells George that he feels like a fraud: everyone expects a hero, but he cannot remember how he earned that reputation. George answers with his own secret.
He was adopted by a mundane family with a Shadowhunter surname, so the bloodline that earned him a place in the advanced stream is not his. He hid the truth because he wanted to stay with the other trainees and knew they looked down on mundanes. Simon's decision to transfer made George brave enough to confess and move streams too.
George then reminds Simon that neither of them can control what they are called, but they can choose what they do. Simon begins to see the Academy not as a route back to his old identity, but as a place to discover what he values now.
George’s disclosure reveals that the Academy’s bloodline categories are not merely unfair to outsiders; they can misrecognize the people they claim to include. George has been accepted for a heritage he does not possess, while Simon has been exceptionalized for actions he cannot remember. Both are trapped by reputations that precede their present choices. Their parallel does not erase their differences, but it lets Simon see that uncertainty is not proof of worthlessness. George’s blunt, comic loyalty offers a counterweight to the Academy’s labels: he follows Simon because of what Simon does, not because of a pedigree or legend. The shift in Simon is modest but decisive. He stops expecting training to restore a finished self and begins treating it as a process of choosing.
The Soup Goes to the Woods
George's encouragement gets Simon out of the bathroom and back into the Academy's ordinary absurdities. He and George nearly collide with Catarina, who is hauling a covered tureen through the corridors.
Vivianne has decided not to order fresh supplies until the Academy finishes its endless brown soup, so Catarina plans to bury the remaining batch in the woods. Simon takes one handle and George follows as the three of them carry the heavy dish outside.
The school remains shabby, its meals remain a problem, and Simon still does not know exactly why he wants to become a Shadowhunter. But he is no longer trying to solve that uncertainty by turning himself into someone else. He walks beside friends, helps with the mess in front of him, and asks whether the woods contain bears.
The ending refuses a grand proof of Simon’s new identity. Instead, it gives him a practical, faintly ridiculous task: carry the Academy’s unwanted soup into the woods. The gesture links him to Catarina and George through cooperation rather than remembered history, romantic expectation, or inherited status. The school has not been repaired, and Simon has not resolved his vocation; the unresolved conditions are part of the point. He can act without first knowing what his entire life means. His question about bears preserves his anxious humor, but now it accompanies participation rather than retreat. The story closes on a small movement from self-judgment toward shared work, making belonging something Simon practices before he can define it.
Analysis
The story treats identity as a conflict between remembered reputation and present action. Simon's friends remember a shared past that he cannot fully inhabit, so their affection can feel like pressure to reproduce a self that no longer exists in his experience. The Academy initially seems to offer a solution: become a Shadowhunter, become heroic, and perhaps become recognizable again. Its daily realities undermine that fantasy. Simon struggles with weapons and horses, discovers that Marisol can defeat him, and finds genuine pleasure in archery not because it restores supernatural power but because it lets him feel his living body at work.
The Academy's division between Shadowhunter blood and mundane recruits gives this personal struggle an institutional mirror. Simon is treated as an exception, while George is misclassified through his surname. Both cases reveal a culture that confuses lineage and legend with character. Simon's decision to join the mundane stream is therefore more than a protest against rude classmates. It rejects the comfort of an honorary status built on past achievements and places him among the people the institution discounts. His memory of Jordan makes this rejection ethical as well as personal: prejudice against werewolves is no longer an abstract claim about a group, but an insult to someone he loved.
Isabelle's confrontation brings the emotional cost of that change into focus. Simon cannot promise to become the boyfriend she remembers, and his honesty wounds her even as it ends the pretense that training can restore their relationship on demand. George's confession then offers a grounded alternative to inherited identity. He chooses Simon's company because of what Simon does now, not what his name or reputation implies. The final act of carrying soup into the woods is deliberately small. Simon has no settled answer about becoming a Shadowhunter, but he can help his friends with a concrete problem. The story locates growth not in a completed transformation, but in the choices a person makes while still uncertain.
Review Summary
Welcome to Shadowhunter Academy received mostly positive reviews, with readers praising Simon's character development and the return to the Shadowhunter world. Many enjoyed the humor and new characters, particularly George Lovelace. Some criticized the novella for being too short or rehashing familiar themes. Fans appreciated seeing beloved characters again and looked forward to the series continuation. A few readers felt the Shadowhunter concept was becoming repetitive. Overall, the novella was well-received as a promising start to Simon's journey at the Academy.
People Also Read
Characters
Simon Lewis
Memory-shaken traineeSimon is a human trainee with the memories of a former vampire life returning in uneven fragments. He is funny, observant, and inclined to deflect discomfort with jokes, but his humor cannot hide how painfully he compares himself with the person his friends remember. His ties to Clary, Jace, and Isabelle matter deeply even when he cannot recall their shared past, while the memory of his former roommate Jordan gives his grief a newly personal weight. Simon wants to become a Shadowhunter, at first because he hopes to recover his old heroic identity. His strongest instinct, however, is to question unfairness when he sees it. He is learning to build a self through present choices rather than trying to reproduce someone else's memories.
George Lovelace
Comic, loyal roommateGeorge is Simon's roommate, a warm and irreverent trainee who can turn a disastrous possum encounter into a shared joke. His easy humor does not mean he is careless: he worries when Simon disappears into the woods and stays beside him when grief overwhelms him. At first George appears to fit naturally among Shadowhunter trainees, and his teasing makes Simon feel less like a famous stranger and more like a friend. He is alert to the Academy's social rules and uneasy with the contempt shown toward mundanes. George's loyalty is active rather than sentimental; when Simon makes a difficult choice, George considers what that choice costs and decides where he wants to stand.
Isabelle Lightwood
Fearless former girlfriendIsabelle is a formidable Shadowhunter, skilled with weapons and accustomed to moving through a room as if she owns its attention. She is Simon's girlfriend from the history he only partly remembers, and she is both protective of him and wounded by the distance between their memories. Her composure often conceals strong feeling; rather than quietly endure uncertainty, she acts boldly, even when the action exposes her vulnerability. Isabelle wants Simon to choose her as himself, but she also hopes he can recover the person she once knew. Her directness forces him to confront the difference between wanting to be loved and wanting to become a particular, idealized version of himself.
Catarina Loss
Warlock teacher and allyCatarina is a blue-skinned warlock who escorts Simon to Idris and teaches at the reopened Academy. Wry and practical, she has little patience for Shadowhunter self-importance and is alert to the ways their institutions marginalize Downworlders. Her initial reserve toward Simon comes from what she assumes about his past and his new place among Shadowhunters. Yet her loyalty to her friend Ragnor draws her into teaching despite that distrust. Catarina becomes a useful adult presence for Simon because she can recognize the contradictions in his identity without demanding that he resolve them. Her dry humor makes care feel less like a ceremony and more like something one can simply do.
Clary Fray
Simon’s steadfast friendClary is Simon's close friend and a Shadowhunter whose relationship with him reaches back to childhood. She is openly emotional when he leaves, making the distance between their shared past and his incomplete memories visible. Clary is determined and creative, and she treats Simon as someone she knows even when he cannot fully return that recognition. Her presence helps show that Simon's loss affects more than his understanding of himself; it changes how he can participate in old friendships.
Jace Herondale
Confident warrior friendJace is a highly capable Shadowhunter and one of Simon's closest friends, though Simon's memory gaps leave their bond difficult to inhabit. He offers to train Simon in New York and masks concern with swagger and teasing. His casual confidence contrasts with Simon's uncertainty, but moments of awkward affection suggest that their friendship has been built through more than bravado.
Magnus Bane
Warlock and helpful friendMagnus is a powerful warlock, Alec's partner, and a friend to Simon's New York circle. He helps Simon perceive the Institute and arranges the papers that make the Academy story believable to Simon's mother. His glittering style and talkative manner soften the seriousness of his magic, while his practical help gives Simon a way to leave without explaining a painful history his mother cannot remember.
Alec Lightwood
Quiet Shadowhunter allyAlec is a reserved Shadowhunter and Magnus's partner. Simon finds him difficult to read and worries that he may have offended him without remembering why. Alec's quiet presence at the farewell contrasts with the more expressive reactions around him, underscoring how little Simon can rely on familiar social cues.
Simon's mother
Loving, wounded parentSimon's mother loves him and is proud to let him leave for what she believes is a military academy. Their relationship carries an injury that she does not remember, while Simon still does. Her ordinary warmth therefore becomes painful as well as comforting: he knows she means her affection, yet he cannot simply forget the moment when fear made her reject him.
Rebecca Lewis
Simon’s loyal sisterRebecca is Simon's sister and a source of uncomplicated loyalty. Her good-luck card accompanies him to the Academy, recalling the comfort she offered when his family life became frightening and uncertain. Even when Simon feels caught between lost memories and present relationships, Rebecca's affection gives him something steady to carry.
Jordan
Former roommate and friendJordan is Simon's former roommate and a member of the Praetor Lupus, a group connected to werewolves. Simon remembers him as patient, generous, and willing to see him as a person rather than a problem. Their bond gives Simon's reflections on Downworlders a personal grounding and makes Jordan's place in his life emotionally significant.
Vivianne Penhallow
Overwhelmed academy deanVivianne is the young dean responsible for reopening Shadowhunter Academy. She is formal and determined to keep the institution functioning, even as repairs, staffing, and food supply problems mount around her. Her earnest effort to welcome students contrasts with the school's neglected condition and the harshness of its old traditions.
Julie Beauvale
Proud elite traineeJulie is a Shadowhunter trainee from a respected family, sharp in manner and attracted to the glamour of famous Shadowhunters. She is quick to treat bloodline as evidence of superiority and sees Simon as an exceptional case rather than a challenge to the system. Her confidence makes the Academy's class divisions visible in daily conversation.
Beatriz Velez Mendoza
Warm, perceptive traineeBeatriz is an older trainee from a Shadowhunter family, known for her warmth and open smile. She welcomes Simon and recognizes the courage in his choices, even when she does not follow him into the mundane stream. Her friendliness offers a counterexample to Julie and Jon's elitism, showing that the Academy's assumptions do not dictate every student's loyalties.
Jonathan Cartwright
Muscular, status-minded traineeJonathan, usually called Jon, is a strong trainee who likes to present himself as close to the famous Jace Herondale. He helps Simon and talks confidently about Shadowhunter customs, but his friendliness sits beside a condescending attitude toward mundanes and Downworlders. That contradiction makes him an early example of how charm can coexist with prejudice.
Marisol
Young, determined traineeMarisol is a young mundane trainee without parents, recruited to fight and already skilled with a sword. Her quiet, guarded manner gives way to decisive action in training. She refuses Simon's attempt to go easy on her, making her independence and competence clear from their first match.
Delaney Scarsbury
Brutal training masterScarsbury is the Academy's imposing training master, responsible for turning inexperienced recruits into fighters. His blunt comments and demanding exercises make physical weakness a public matter, and his teaching offers little reassurance to students who are already struggling.
Ragnor Fell
Catarina’s remembered friendRagnor is a warlock and a former Academy teacher whose affection for the school influences Catarina's decision to teach there. His example connects her present work to a history of Downworlders contributing to an institution that has not always welcomed them.
Plot Devices
Simon’s memory gaps
Past without full accessSimon remembers parts of his earlier life but cannot summon the full emotional and factual record of his relationships. This divides him from friends who still know their shared history and makes his present actions feel measured against an absent person. Memories return unevenly: the recollection of Jordan brings grief, while memories of Isabelle and Clary complicate affection with uncertainty. The gaps do not merely conceal backstory. They shape Simon's decisions, including his move to the Academy and his attempt to become someone his friends will recognize. As memory resurfaces, it adds pain as well as connection, showing that recovering a past is not the same as being able to return to it.
The two Academy streams
Bloodline becomes rankThe Academy separates trainees with Shadowhunter ancestry from mundane recruits, assigning them different courses and levels of prestige. The split gives the institution a visible way to classify students, but its logic is unstable: Simon is treated as an exception because of past deeds, while George is assumed to belong because of a surname. The mundane students are described as less capable before their abilities are tested, and the school even houses them in worse quarters. Simon's transfer challenges the hierarchy by making him choose solidarity over special treatment. The streams turn a policy into a recurring test of who is considered worthy before they have a chance to prove themselves.
Mundane Ascension
Training with mortal stakesMundane recruits can train toward becoming Shadowhunters, but they do not begin with the runes and abilities available to Shadowhunter-blooded students. Their path includes dangerous trials and the possibility of death during Ascension if they are not suited to it. This makes the Academy's promises morally complicated: a chance to join the Shadowhunters is also a demand that young people risk their lives to earn acceptance. The prospect shapes Simon's and George's understanding of what they have chosen, even though the story does not take them to the Ascension itself. It keeps their classroom status tied to a future decision that could permanently change their lives.
The neglected Academy
Prestige meets disrepairThe Academy appears majestic from a distance, with towers, stained glass, and a setting deep in Idris's forest. Up close, it is cold, structurally unsafe, short of teachers and food, and coated in slime in its lower rooms. Its condition gives Simon's training a daily, physical texture: the students contend with bad equipment, a missing food supply, and the indignity of a school that cannot meet its own standards. The contrast also mirrors the gap between Shadowhunter ideals and the institution's treatment of its recruits. The Academy is not simply a backdrop for learning; its failures shape how students experience the hierarchy it claims to prepare them to serve.
George’s assumed ancestry
Identity hidden by pedigreeGeorge is placed among the advanced trainees because the Academy assumes that his Lovelace surname means he has Shadowhunter blood. He conceals that he was adopted and is not a Shadowhunter, partly because he wants to remain among his peers and partly because he sees how the school treats mundanes. His eventual admission parallels Simon's unease about being praised for a past he cannot remember. The revelation exposes how much the Academy relies on labels rather than knowledge of the people it trains. It also gives George a reason to follow Simon into the mundane stream: Simon's actions help him risk being known honestly.
Tales from the Shadowhunter Academy Series Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.