Plot Summary
Thirty-Three Unanswered Calls
At eighteen, Lia learns that her former best friend, Cassie, has been found dead in a motel room. Her stepmother, Jennifer, urges her to see her therapist, but Lia insists she is fine and turns to the routines that make her feel in control: counting food, hiding how little she eats, and pursuing a lower weight.
Six months earlier, after two hospital stays, she moved in with her father, David, Jennifer, and nine-year-old Emma. Now Lia retrieves her discarded phone and finds thirty-three calls from Cassie, beginning Saturday night.
The messages move from apology and loneliness to panic. Lia had ignored them because Cassie once blamed her for everything and ended their friendship. Now there is no answer to give, and guilt joins the illness already narrowing Lia’s life.
The opening makes grief inseparable from the mechanics of Lia’s illness. Numbers promise a kind of certainty, but the call count turns measurement into accusation: thirty-three is no longer a neutral fact she can control. Lia’s denial is not simple indifference. She has protected herself from another rejection by refusing contact, and the cost becomes unbearable only when Cassie can no longer revise the past. The family’s worried attention also exposes a paradox: Lia wants to be seen, yet experiences concern as surveillance. The story begins where those needs collide, with silence that cannot be undone.
The Blood Oath
Lia’s memories trace her bond with Cassie back to third grade, when the new girl arrived across the street and welcomed Lia into her room. They became inseparable, especially after Cassie was bullied for developing earlier than her classmates.
Lia challenged the bully, took a punch, and helped bring Cassie back into the group. As they grew older, each girl found ways to punish her changing body. Cassie binged and purged; Lia restricted food and cut herself.
Instead of interrupting the pattern, Lia praised Cassie’s thinness and made their shared rituals feel like loyalty. At fourteen, they swore to become the skinniest girls at school, mixing blood as if the promise were a game. Cassie later tried to seek help, but Lia’s competition kept pulling her back.
The childhood history complicates Lia’s guilt without absolving her. She once risked a beating to defend Cassie, so loyalty is not a pose; it is a value she has repeatedly acted on. But the girls’ intimacy also makes harm feel like proof of belonging. Their oath converts private self-punishment into a shared project, giving each disorder the emotional cover of friendship. Lia’s later shame grows from recognizing that care and sabotage lived side by side: she wanted to save Cassie, yet feared losing the one person who made her feel understood. The bond is powerful precisely because it is neither wholly protective nor wholly destructive.
Room 113
A message on the family answering machine sends Lia away from school and toward the Gateway Motel. The caller, Elijah, says Cassie asked him to find someone named Lia, but Lia gives him a false name and denies knowing her. Elijah lives next door to the room where Cassie was found.
He explains that he discovered her after returning from a night out, checked for a pulse, and called emergency services; the motel’s security cameras support his account. Lia cannot bear to see the room and walks back to her car without revealing who she is.
Elijah still has no way to deliver Cassie’s message. Lia leaves the motel with no new certainty about how Cassie died, but she has met the person who was present at the end and whom Cassie tried to reach through her.
The motel visit brings Lia’s private guilt into contact with an actual witness, but she evades the very connection she sought. Her false name lets her approach Cassie’s last hours while postponing the risk of being recognized as the person who ignored the calls. Elijah’s account offers a plain, verifiable sequence, yet Lia cannot absorb it; the room itself becomes more powerful than the facts. His presence also introduces a counterpoint to the controlled world of her family and treatment: he is improvisational, materially precarious, and attentive to strange experiences without immediately turning them into rules. Lia’s refusal to identify herself preserves her isolation even as she begins to seek company.
The Wake and the Waffle
At Cassie’s wake, Lia believes she sees her friend rise from the coffin, accept the green sea-glass they once treated as magical, and vanish. The vision leaves her shaken, but Elijah finds her outside and takes her to a diner. He helps her steady herself by noticing the room around them, and Lia stays long enough to drink hot chocolate and share fries.
She remembers Cassie’s affection for waffles, a small pleasure that briefly makes the dead girl more than a body or a mystery. Back home, Cassie appears again, and Lia admits to herself that she encouraged their shared eating-disorder rituals and helped Cassie resist treatment. The haunting therefore brings not only fear, but memories of the part Lia played in their friendship’s damage.
The wake refuses to separate mourning from perception. Lia’s vision may be supernatural or may express a mind under extreme physical and emotional strain; either way, it dramatizes her inability to accept a final, inert version of Cassie. Elijah’s grounding is effective because it does not argue Lia out of grief. He directs her attention back to the diner’s ordinary details, allowing her body to re-enter the present for a moment. The waffle memory works differently: it restores Cassie’s appetites, humor, and particularity against the public spectacle of the coffin. Together, these moments make remembrance both a source of comfort and a demand for honest accountability.
A School Full of Rumors
At school, students trade lurid explanations for Cassie’s death while a counselor tries to organize a memorial without discussing how it happened. A classmate accuses Lia of having failed Cassie, and Lia erupts, exposing how closely the accusation strikes. A detective later confirms that Cassie called Lia that night, then asks whether Lia knows why.
Lia says she and Cassie were no longer friends and claims she had not seen her phone. At a session with Dr. Parker, Lia asks permission to attend the funeral and receives it, provided a parent accompanies her. She destroys the phone and its stored messages, then visits Elijah with pizza and asks him to go to the burial. He agrees after she beats him at a game of hearts.
Public mourning becomes another arena in which Lia is judged, categorized, and pressured to perform an acceptable response. The school’s memorial plans protect students from the disturbing facts, but that protection also leaves rumor free to fill the silence. Lia’s outburst reveals how little distance she can maintain between guilt and defensiveness: she wants the truth acknowledged, yet cannot yet admit her own part in it. Destroying the phone is an attempt to erase the evidence, not the memory. Her request to Elijah marks a small change. Instead of denying the link between herself and Cassie, she asks someone else to accompany her into a ritual she knows she cannot face alone.
The Last Burial
Lia and Elijah reach the cemetery late, and he gives her his jacket before they climb the hill through the cold. During the service, Lia remembers helping Cassie bury a pet mouse as a child, when Cassie’s father dismissed her grief.
The memory sharpens the difference between the childhood rituals they invented and the formal ceremony now unfolding. Lia’s mother, Chloe, arrives, and Lia tries to hide behind Elijah rather than speak to her. He refuses to keep the two women apart, and Lia introduces him to Chloe.
Their exchange is tense, but Lia agrees to visit her mother afterward. As the coffin is lowered, Lia watches instead of fleeing. The decision does not resolve her grief, but it brings her into the presence of both families she has been avoiding.
The cemetery gathers several forms of unfinished mourning: Cassie’s parents’ loss, Lia’s childhood memories, and the estrangement between Lia and Chloe. The childhood burial of Pinky gives Lia a model of care that is small, improvised, and chosen, unlike the public ceremony’s prescribed words. Elijah’s role is not to speak for Lia but to prevent avoidance from becoming the only available action. Her agreement to visit Chloe is similarly modest. It does not signal reconciliation or trust; it creates an opening in a relationship organized around control and resistance. Watching the coffin descend matters because Lia stays present while knowing she cannot repair what has happened.
The Cause of Death
At Chloe’s house, Lia finds Cassie’s mother outside in the cold, grieving alone. The sight sends her inside, where she makes breakfast for Chloe and they manage a gentler exchange than usual. When Lia asks about Cassie’s autopsy, Chloe explains that years of purging had badly damaged Cassie’s body. After a fight with her parents, Cassie fled to the motel, drank heavily, and continued bingeing and purging.
Her esophagus tore while she was vomiting, and she died in shock. Lia has to eat eggs and a muffin before Chloe will explain, turning food into the price of knowledge. The details destroy Lia’s imagined explanations and confirm that Cassie’s death came from the disorder they once treated as a shared challenge.
The autopsy changes Lia’s guilt from a vague haunting into a concrete understanding of what the disorder did. Chloe’s medical explanation is precise, but precision cannot make the death emotionally manageable. The bargain over breakfast exposes how care in this family often arrives as negotiation: Chloe tries to protect Lia by withholding information until she eats, while Lia accepts food only because she needs the truth. Neither is simply wrong, yet each reduces a desperate relationship to leverage. The account also breaks the glamour of their old contest. What once looked to the girls like strength and mastery was a process of bodily injury that ended in terror and isolation.
The Message Behind the Bet
Back with her father’s family, Lia returns to restriction, exercise, and secret weighing even as David and Jennifer debate whether she needs more treatment. After reaching Elijah by phone, she presses him to explain how he knew Cassie had called her.
He admits that Cassie approached him while drunk, distressed that Lia would not answer, and made him promise to pass along a message. Cassie had framed their old contest as a victory for Lia. The revelation lands beside Lia’s own falling weight: she reaches a number she once pursued, but now sees that winning means inheriting the very danger that consumed Cassie.
She continues hiding her behavior, and her parents’ concern becomes more urgent. The contest’s supposed prize offers no control or triumph, only a shrinking path toward the same harm.
The message exposes the emotional logic that has sustained Lia’s disorder: she has confused being thinner with being more successful, more loved, or less vulnerable. Cassie’s declaration gives that private equation a voice, but it does not make the competition fair or meaningful. Lia has not won anything; she has repeated a pattern that was never capable of producing security. Her parents’ arguments show the limits of surveillance when Lia experiences every intervention as a threat to autonomy. Yet the number on the scale no longer offers pure satisfaction. The gap between the promised victory and its actual consequence begins to destabilize the belief that restriction is a form of strength.
The Holiday Bake Sale
As Christmas approaches, Lia’s weight falls and her family grows alarmed. Emma breaks her arm, and Lia helps care for her before taking Emma’s prescription to the drugstore. There, Cassie appears amid artificial snow and tells Lia she is close to dying, blaming her for not answering the calls.
At Emma’s school concert, Lia bakes gingerbread and date-nut bread, then volunteers at the sale. After resisting the food for hours, she eats cupcakes, brownies, fudge, and cookies in a rush she cannot stop.
She tries to purge and takes laxatives, which leave her with severe cramps, dehydration, and a racing heart. Lia hides the danger from Jennifer, then collapses into exhaustion. Her rituals have stopped feeling like control; they now drive her body into immediate physical crisis.
The holiday setting makes food both socially ordinary and psychologically charged. Lia can prepare sweets for Emma and serve them to strangers, but cannot safely experience them as food for herself. The binge is not a sudden reversal of her illness; it is the consequence of prolonged deprivation, followed by the familiar attempt to erase what she ate. Cassie’s pharmacy appearance intensifies Lia’s belief that she is being pursued, while the body’s reaction makes the danger harder to dismiss as metaphor. The scene also reveals Emma’s vulnerability: Lia’s instability is no longer contained within her private life. Even her efforts to be a loving sister coexist with behaviors that frighten and endanger the household.
Emma Finds the Blood
After an argument with David about her declining health and a planned evaluation, Lia turns against herself. She cuts deeply across her torso, and Emma discovers her beside the knife and blood. At the hospital, doctors find severe malnutrition, dehydration, and dangerous heart abnormalities; they close her wounds with thirty-three stitches.
Lia remains there for two days, then goes to Chloe’s house while the family arranges further treatment. During a session with Dr. Parker, Lia finally describes the ghosts, Cassie’s visits, and the lengths she has gone to make them stop.
Dr. Parker takes the disclosure seriously as a sign that Lia’s mind needs more intensive care, but recommends psychiatric treatment. Lia hears the recommendation as another threat of confinement, even though she has finally stopped concealing the scale of her distress.
Emma’s discovery makes the costs of Lia’s secrecy impossible to keep abstract. The injury is both a medical emergency and a rupture in the family’s ability to pretend that the crisis remains manageable at home. The number of stitches echoes the calls, but it is no mystical solution: the body has been repaired temporarily, while the conditions that endangered it remain. Lia’s account to Dr. Parker is a genuine movement toward help, though it does not produce the response Lia hoped for. The clinician’s interpretation and Lia’s supernatural experience occupy incompatible frames. The scene’s tension lies in the fact that speaking honestly is necessary, but honesty alone cannot guarantee that Lia feels understood.
The See-Glass Choice
On Christmas Eve, overwhelmed by the prospect of psychiatric hospitalization and Chloe’s close monitoring, Lia escapes to Elijah’s motel room during a blizzard. Elijah is preparing to leave town. He agrees to let her stay only if she eats enough to remain safe and tells her family where she is.
After Lia sleeps, he drives away, leaving a key, money, and a note urging her not to run from people who love her. Alone and weakened by starvation, dehydration, exhaustion, and sleeping pills, Lia drifts toward death.
In room 113, she experiences Cassie as waiting for her to cross over. Lia takes back the green see-glass and sees possible lives ahead. She asks Cassie what she misses about being alive; Cassie remembers her parents, books, swimming, and waffles, then fades. Lia reaches a pay phone and calls Chloe for help.
The climax turns the childhood see-glass from a token of imagined destiny into an instrument for reopening possibility. Lia’s vision does not promise that every future will be easy; it makes the crucial claim that more than one future remains available. Cassie’s memories of ordinary pleasures also give her a self beyond the competition and the manner of her death. Elijah’s departure is painful, but his note refuses to become another rescue fantasy: Lia must contact her family herself. Whether the scene is supernatural, psychological, or both, its decisive act is Lia choosing connection while still terrified. She does not defeat the illness by willpower; she asks to be found.
A Slow Thaw
Paramedics revive Lia, and she spends ten days in the hospital before beginning a third, longer stay at New Seasons. This time she does not secretly discard meals or exercise through the night. Eating remains frightening, and she still counts, but she practices taking bites without letting the numbers decide every choice.
Her parents and Jennifer join difficult family sessions, where anger and blame finally have room to be spoken without ending the conversation. Cassie’s parents visit, and Lia grieves with them.
Emma brings a card from her class and hugs Lia after her cast comes off; Lia has written to her every day. The treatment continues into spring, with no instant cure. Lia begins to measure progress in meals, conversations, and moments of ease rather than pounds.
The resolution refuses the fantasy of a single revelation curing a chronic illness. Lia’s recovery is shown as repeated behavior under pressure: eating despite fear, staying in treatment, and allowing family members to remain present during conflict. The return of anger is especially important. Earlier, Lia could express distress only through restriction, cutting, or withdrawal; now anger can become language shared with others. Her relationships do not become simple, but they become more available to repair. The final thaw is therefore not a clean escape from winter. It is the gradual recovery of choice, bodily sensation, and time, all of which the disorder had compressed into a single question of weight.
Analysis
Wintergirls traces how an illness can disguise itself as a source of competence. Lia’s counting, restriction, and exercise give her procedures to follow when family life, grief, and her own changing body feel unmanageable. Their apparent precision is deceptive: the routines narrow her choices while making deterioration look like discipline. The story’s emotional center is not simply that Lia misses Cassie, but that the friendship helped both girls translate suffering into a private language of competition. Their bond provided recognition and reinforced danger at the same time. Lia must grieve Cassie without turning that grief into proof that she deserves the same fate.
The novel also examines the limits of care when adults confuse intervention with understanding. Chloe’s medical expertise, David’s affection, Jennifer’s routines, and Dr. Parker’s therapy each offer forms of help, yet Lia often experiences them as attempts to control her. That perception is shaped by real fractures in the family, but it also grows more distorted as malnutrition and fear damage her ability to assess danger. The adults are not interchangeable villains or perfect rescuers. Their mistakes matter, and so does their persistence. Recovery begins when Lia speaks about what she has hidden and when the people around her make room for anger without abandoning responsibility.
The supernatural ambiguity gives psychological pain a visible shape without reducing it to a tidy metaphor. Cassie’s appearances can be read as haunting, hallucination, or an unstable border between memory and perception. The narrative does not need to settle the question to make the consequences real: Lia is frightened, increasingly isolated, and physically endangered. The green glass finally opens not a guaranteed future but the possibility of one. Lia’s survival is not a victory over illness once and for all. It is a series of choices to eat, speak, remain in treatment, and let other people stay close. The thaw is measured in renewed capacity, not cure.
Review Summary
Wintergirls receives mixed reviews, with many praising Anderson's powerful writing style and raw portrayal of eating disorders. Readers appreciate the authentic depiction of anorexia and the emotional impact of the story. Some find the book triggering or disturbing, while others consider it an important eye-opener. Critics note the poetic language and fragmented narrative, which some find effective and others distracting. The book's exploration of mental illness, self-harm, and friendship resonates with many readers, though some desire more character development and backstory.
People Also Read
Characters
Lia Marrigan Overbrook
A girl caught between selvesLia is an intelligent, observant eighteen-year-old whose anorexia and self-harm have become ways to manage fear, anger, and a body she cannot see accurately. She is fiercely loyal, but loyalty can turn into self-erasure when she believes someone needs her more than she needs help. Her parents’ divorce and their competing expectations have taught her to hide pain behind competence, sarcasm, and carefully counted routines. Lia notices small details others overlook, yet distrusts her own perceptions, especially when food, weight, or grief are involved. Her central struggle is not simply to accept care, but to remain herself while receiving it. She wants autonomy and connection at once, and the tension between those needs shapes her choices.
Cassie Parrish
Lia’s brilliant, troubled twinCassie is Lia’s childhood best friend, a charismatic and unpredictable girl whose humor and intensity draw people close. She is sensitive to rejection and harsh judgment, especially as classmates and adults scrutinize her body and behavior. Her bond with Lia offers deep recognition, but the girls also turn shared insecurity into a contest that reinforces their illnesses. Cassie can be daring, affectionate, and imaginative, while also resisting help when shame makes change feel like surrender. She is not merely the object of Lia’s grief; she represents the complicated intimacy of two young people who understand one another’s pain without knowing how to stop amplifying it.
Chloe Marrigan
The mother who operatesChloe is Lia’s mother and a gifted cardiologist accustomed to making decisive interventions in emergencies. At work, that confidence saves lives; with Lia, it can become pressure, since Chloe often approaches emotional distress as a problem she should be able to diagnose and fix. She is ambitious, exhausted, and deeply protective, but her daughter experiences her expertise as scrutiny and control. Chloe’s history with Lia is marked by arguments, separation, and fear that she has failed to keep her child safe. Beneath her clinical reserve is a mother who remembers Lia’s presence in intimate, sensory ways. She struggles to offer care without taking over, and to admit how frightened she is.
David Overbrook
The distracted, loving fatherDavid is Lia’s father, a celebrated history professor whose professional confidence contrasts with his uncertainty at home. He loves his daughter but often assumes that goodwill, routine, and practical arrangements will be enough to protect her. His work repeatedly competes with family commitments, and his remarriage has left him relying heavily on Jennifer to manage daily care. David dislikes conflict and may mistake a temporary quiet for improvement. When Lia challenges him, he becomes defensive, especially because her illness exposes the promises he has failed to keep. His affection is real, but he must learn that love without attention can feel like abandonment to a child already unsure whether anyone sees her.
Jennifer
The careful stepmotherJennifer is David’s second wife and Emma’s mother. Organized and conscientious, she tries to create dependable routines for the blended household, including monitoring Lia’s health and tending to Emma’s activities. Her attempts to help often come wrapped in caution, making Lia feel watched rather than understood. Jennifer is not indifferent to Lia; she is trying to care for a frightened, often resistant teenager while protecting her own young daughter. Her practical nature gives her a role that neither the adults nor Lia always acknowledge, and she must balance patience with firm boundaries. Jennifer’s affection is sometimes awkward, but her willingness to name the damage Lia’s illness causes shows that she takes both girls seriously.
Emma
Lia’s bright little stepsisterEmma is Jennifer’s nine-year-old daughter and Lia’s stepsister. Curious, talkative, and affectionate, she approaches life through school projects, sports, music, and the small pleasures adults overlook. She wants Lia’s attention without fully understanding the illness that makes Lia withdraw. Emma’s openness gives Lia a chance to practice tenderness, but it also makes Lia’s instability visible to someone young enough to feel responsible for it. She is not simply a symbol of innocence; she has her own frustrations, including activities she does not enjoy and a wish to be included. Her bond with Lia is a potent reason for Lia to keep reaching toward family.
Elijah
The motel’s wandering witnessElijah is a young handyman living at the Gateway Motel, a resourceful drifter who collects books, ideas, and strange visions. He is funny, irreverent, and comfortable admitting that he lives by improvisation, though his humor can conceal grief and a history of instability. His connection to Cassie brings him into Lia’s orbit, but he does not behave like a conventional rescuer. He offers practical help, asks for honesty, and sets limits when Lia’s safety is at risk. Elijah’s own losses have made him wary of family ties, so his insistence that Lia contact hers carries particular weight. He sees her pain without pretending he can solve it.
Dr. Nancy Parker
The patient questionerDr. Parker is Lia’s therapist, a steady and persistent presence who invites her to examine feelings she would rather avoid. Lia distrusts therapy because questions can feel like traps and because treatment has previously meant surveillance, forced meals, and hospitalization. Dr. Parker does not respond to Lia’s anger with retaliation, which frustrates Lia but gradually creates room for disclosure. She takes the severity of Lia’s condition seriously, though her clinical interpretation of Lia’s visions differs from Lia’s own experience. Her role is not to supply a magical answer, but to keep asking what Lia is trying to communicate and what kind of care might keep her safe.
Mrs. Parrish
Cassie’s grieving motherMrs. Parrish is Cassie’s mother, a devoted presence in her daughter’s childhood who organizes school activities and family rituals. She once welcomed Lia into the Parrish home and became part of the girls’ shared world. Her care does not mean she always understood the private suffering unfolding there. In grief, she seeks answers from the people who knew Cassie most closely, including Lia. Her vulnerability forces Lia to confront that Cassie’s absence is not only her personal wound; it has emptied a family home and left a mother searching for meaning.
Mr. Parrish
Cassie’s demanding fatherMr. Parrish is Cassie’s father and the school principal who also occupies a position of authority in his daughter’s life. He values discipline and achievement, and his expectations can make Cassie feel judged rather than understood. He is part of the family history Lia knows intimately, including moments when Cassie’s grief or distress was dismissed. His presence at the funeral reflects a parent trying to bear a loss that cannot be managed through rules.
Plot Devices
The Thirty-Three Calls
Guilt made countableCassie’s repeated calls turn Lia’s phone into a physical record of a decision she cannot reverse. The messages reveal that Cassie was frightened, regretful, and trying to reconnect, while Lia had avoided answering because she feared being hurt again. The number recurs as a private measure of guilt, then echoes in the stitches closing Lia’s wounds. It does not prove that Lia caused Cassie’s death, but it gives Lia a concrete object around which to organize grief and self-blame. Destroying the phone can erase the recording, not the responsibility Lia feels or the unanswered question of what she might have done.
The Green See-Glass
A window into choiceCassie and Lia invent a story about a piece of green sea-glass that can reveal the future. Lia steals it as a child, returns it to Cassie at the wake, and later encounters it again in her near-death vision. The object links childhood imagination, the girls’ blood oath, and Lia’s final confrontation with the belief that their old contest has already determined her fate. Its meaning changes from an impossible promise of prediction into an image of multiple possible lives. The glass cannot remove pain or guarantee recovery; it helps Lia recognize that a future remains available if she chooses to seek help.
Cassie’s Apparitions
Grief made visibleLia experiences Cassie as a presence in rooms, mirrors, stores, and the motel, often announced by a scent associated with her friend. The apparitions accuse Lia, comfort her, and sometimes seem to manipulate the surrounding world. Their status remains deliberately uncertain: they may be ghosts, hallucinations shaped by grief and malnutrition, or both within Lia’s experience. In each appearance, the story gives form to a conflict Lia cannot yet express directly, especially her guilt, fear of death, and anger at being trapped by illness. The visions become more dangerous as Lia’s health worsens, then change as she finally speaks honestly about them.
The Calorie Ledger
Control that consumes itselfLia counts calories, weighs herself, and sets target numbers as if precision could protect her from a body and life she experiences as unpredictable. The arithmetic gives her rituals, rules, and momentary relief, while also obscuring the physical decline those rules produce. Food becomes a sequence of calculations rather than nourishment, and every meal risks feeling like failure. The ledger also binds Lia to Cassie’s old competition, making thinness appear to be a shared achievement. As the story progresses, the numbers lose their promised power: Lia understands that no target will satisfy the disorder, and recovery requires learning to act without knowing the measurement first.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.