Key Takeaways
Treat taste as a moving verdict, not a permanent fact about yourself
Preferences have a history. The book begins with a child changing her favorite color and a father who likes blue, but not on cars. Preferences depend on the object, the setting, and what a person has learned to associate with it. A favorite color can be a record of past experiences, not an inborn truth.
The ecological valence theory proposes that people tend to like colors associated with things they like. In one study, associations predicted color preferences about 80 percent of the time. Adults favored blue, which can suggest clear skies and clean water, while infants showed no preference for blue and seemed drawn to dark yellow shades. Experience helps explain why those responses differ.
This account usefully challenges the idea that preferences are private facts waiting to be uncovered. It resembles predictive processing: the mind interprets new sensations through expectations built from past experience. That does not make a preference fake. Learned associations are part of how a person encounters the world. The caution is that a plausible explanation is not always a proven cause. The color study supports a relationship between associations and liking, but does not establish that every individual preference arose in the same way.
Give unfamiliar pleasures repeated chances before ruling them out
Familiarity can soften resistance. The mere exposure effect is the tendency for repeated contact with something to increase liking, even when the person cannot recall each exposure. It helps explain why coffee, beer, and bitter vegetables can become pleasurable despite an initially unpleasant first impression. Repetition makes an unfamiliar experience easier to process and gives positive associations time to develop.
In one study, young children sampled unfamiliar fruits and cheeses repeatedly for 26 days. When later offered choices, they favored foods they had encountered more often, including some they had initially spat out. Exposure is not a guaranteed conversion, however. Repeated contact can strengthen negative feelings when the first response is strongly unfavorable.
The practical insight is to distinguish an early reaction from a settled preference. In learning theory, repeated encounters can reduce uncertainty, while in skill acquisition, familiarity makes details easier to notice. Together, those processes can turn initial strangeness into interest. Still, persistence should not become coercion. Repetition can also entrench aversion, and the book's examples do not establish one ideal number of tries for every person or experience.
Separate what a thing is from the expectation attached to it
The label changes the experience. A food is judged not only by its sensory qualities, but by what people expect it to be. In a study, people liked salmon-flavored ice cream more when it was presented as a savory frozen mousse. The flavor had not changed; the category had. Likewise, Crystal Pepsi performed better in blind tasting than when people saw its clear appearance and expected something different from a Pepsi.
Choices can also alter later liking. After selecting one option, people may grow more favorable toward it and less favorable toward the alternative. The choice can help create the preference it appears to reveal. Menus, packaging, names, and comparisons all influence what an experience seems to mean.
This is a vivid case of framing: the same stimulus can produce different judgments when its meaning changes. Behavioral economics uses similar demonstrations to show that choices depend on how options are presented, not only on their properties. The point is not that sensory qualities do not matter. Rather, perception and expectation interact, so a blind test and a real-world purchase answer different questions. Neither alone captures the whole experience.
Watch what you do, not only what you say you like
Self-reports can be aspirational. Netflix found that ratings were less useful than watching behavior as its service shifted toward instant streaming. A person might give a serious documentary high marks, yet spend the evening watching a comedy. Search activity, stopping midway, replaying, and choosing what to watch next provide different clues from a star rating.
Behavior is not a perfect window into preference either. People may choose what is convenient, what suits their mood, or what is available. A viewer who leaves a film early may dislike it, be interrupted, or simply prefer another option at that moment. The book's point is not that actions reveal an unfiltered self, but that stated liking and actual choice can diverge.
The distinction resembles the gap between stated and revealed preferences in economics. Observed choices can improve prediction, but prediction is not the same as understanding. A platform may accurately anticipate a click without knowing whether the viewer chose from genuine enthusiasm, habit, or fatigue. This matters because data systems often treat measurable behavior as the ground truth. It is evidence about preference, not a complete account of motive.
Read ratings as social evidence, not a census of taste
Reviews reflect their own conditions. Online ratings are shaped by who chooses to post, when they post, and what previous reviewers have said. Reviews often cluster at the positive and negative ends rather than representing every customer's view. Some platforms also show a general positivity bias, so a high average should not be mistaken for universal approval.
In an experiment on a social news site, an artificially added positive vote increased later positive voting and raised the final opinion score by 25 percent. Early opinions can steer later ones, even when those later reviewers are sincere. Ratings can still help consumers find worthwhile products, but a crowd's judgment is partly an outcome of how that crowd encountered earlier judgments.
Online ratings are a useful example of a feedback system, not a neutral measuring instrument. The first visible response can change the conditions under which everyone else responds. This parallels cascades in financial markets, where people may follow earlier signals despite having incomplete information of their own. A practical reader should look for concrete reasons, reviewer fit, and recurring patterns, rather than treating an average score as an objective verdict.
Use taste to connect, but notice when it becomes a border
Preferences signal belonging. Sociologist Pierre Bourdieu studied the tastes of 1,217 people in France and argued that preferences mark social distinctions. Education often predicted cultural choices better than wealth. Music, food, and even the way someone talks about a film can signal where that person belongs, or where they hope to belong.
The later pattern called omnivorousness describes people who display appreciation across many kinds of culture, including popular forms once dismissed by elites. That apparent openness can itself become a status signal. Dislikes draw boundaries too: rejecting a genre may distinguish one group from another. Preferences help people find community, but they are not simply individual choices detached from social life.
Taste works like a social language: a preference can invite recognition from people who share it, while a rejection can mark distance. This connects to social identity research, where group membership shapes both judgment and behavior. The useful caution is that diversity of taste is not automatically freedom from hierarchy. A wide-ranging cultural profile can function as its own badge of distinction, even when it appears more inclusive than older forms of snobbery.
Give challenging art another look before your first reaction hardens
A glance is not an encounter. In one observation at a busy street in Antwerp, fewer than 4 percent of nearly 3,000 passersby stopped at a painting by the prominent artist Luc Tuymans. That does not prove they disliked it. They may not have noticed it, recognized it as art, or had time to respond. In a museum study, the median time spent looking at a painting was 17 seconds.
People often form an affective response before they can explain what they see. A title, a story, or another person's response can direct attention toward details that were previously invisible. Learning about the woman in a Delacroix portrait, for example, changed how one museum researcher saw the painting. Context did not alter the canvas, but it gave the viewer more to notice.
The section distinguishes seeing an image from learning how to attend to it. That is relevant beyond museums: expertise often begins by directing attention toward features novices do not yet know to look for. Yet longer looking is not automatically better, and every artwork need not reward extended analysis. The stronger claim is modest: an immediate reaction can be informative, but it is not always a final judgment.
Build a vocabulary that helps you notice what experts notice
Expertise sharpens perception through learning. Sensory analysts at McCormick describe foods with shared vocabularies, comparing qualities such as crispness, earthiness, or aroma. Their work is not simply a matter of having unusually sensitive tongues. Panelists receive about 150 hours of training, building a memory of familiar flavors and learning words that help them identify them.
Categories matter as much as vocabulary. A wine expert may first identify a wine's type, summon a remembered example, and then look for matching characteristics. That knowledge can reveal differences a novice misses, but it can also bias perception. When white wine was colored red in one study, experts were more likely than novices to describe it as sweeter. Expertise improves discrimination, but it does not eliminate expectation.
Vocabulary can function as an attentional tool. Naming a quality makes it easier to compare, remember, and detect again, much as a naturalist's species knowledge changes what counts as visible in a landscape. The same structure creates a risk: once a category or descriptor is expected, ambiguous sensations may be interpreted to fit it. Good expertise therefore needs both trained perception and the discipline to question the labels guiding it.
Judge today's standards as temporary, not timeless measures of quality
Standards move with their audience. In 1882, Edwin Long's painting The Babylonian Marriage Market set a record price for a work by a living artist. Impressionist paintings, sold cheaply around the same period, were widely rejected. Over time, audiences and critics came to value the Impressionists' color and brushwork, while Long faded from public attention. The canvases stayed the same; the terms of judgment changed.
The same drift appears in cat breeding. The written standard for Persians changed little while show cats developed flatter faces and shorter noses. Judges and breeders gradually treated the altered appearance as normal. Product designers face a similar tension. Raymond Loewy's MAYA principle, meaning most advanced yet acceptable, describes the narrow zone where an innovation feels new without seeming incomprehensible.
This account complicates the comforting belief that reputation simply tracks enduring merit. Institutions, markets, and repeated exposure shape what people can see as valuable. At the same time, historical reversal does not prove that quality is arbitrary. Some works sustain attention across changing contexts, while others do not. The key is to treat a current consensus as evidence about the present, not as proof that future audiences will agree.
Expect popularity to magnify luck as much as merit
Trends can grow through copying. The neutral model of cultural change proposes that some shifts in popularity arise from random copying, not because one option is inherently superior. Researchers found that dog breed popularity changed substantially over time without a clear relationship to health or behavior. Movies sometimes boosted a breed, but such effects were exceptions rather than the usual explanation.
Online music markets show a related pattern: social influence can make already visible songs more popular and obscure songs less visible. In experiments where listeners saw others' choices, popularity became more unequal and less predictable from stated song quality. This helps explain why a trend's success is not reliable proof of excellence, or why a neglected option lacks value.
The neutral model is powerful because it makes room for contingency in cultural history. A small early advantage can become self-reinforcing, so success may reflect timing and visibility as well as quality. Still, randomness is not the only force at work. Marketing, institutions, and functional differences can shape which options spread. The most useful stance is neither cynicism nor blind faith in the crowd: popularity is a signal worth investigating, not a verdict.
Analysis
The book's central achievement is to replace the idea of taste as a stable inner compass with a more realistic account of preference as an interaction among sensation, memory, expectation, learning, social identity, and available choices. Its examples make that argument concrete: a color preference follows associations, a label changes the apparent flavor of food, and a rating can influence the next rating. These cases span everyday consumption and high culture without pretending that they are identical experiences.
The most important conceptual distinction is between liking, choosing, and judging quality. A person can report liking one thing, repeatedly choose another, and still believe a third is objectively better. Treating these as interchangeable creates bad research and bad self-knowledge. The book's attention to actual behavior improves on surveys, but behavior itself remains ambiguous: convenience, mood, price, social company, and platform design all affect what people do. Data can predict action while leaving its meaning unsettled.
The account also reveals a productive tension. If preferences are shaped by experience and social setting, then people can cultivate new pleasures, but they cannot simply choose any taste at will. Exposure may widen appreciation, yet it can reinforce aversion; expertise may sharpen perception, yet its categories can bias it; crowds may pool knowledge, yet visible opinions can suppress independent judgment. The book is strongest when it treats these as mechanisms with competing effects rather than as universal rules.
Its final implication is practical and epistemic. A person need not distrust every preference, but should be curious about its conditions. What did the label promise? What did repetition teach? Which comparison set defined good? Whose approval mattered? Such questions do not dissolve pleasure into analysis. They help distinguish a first reaction from a lasting preference, and popularity from merit, while preserving the possibility that an unfamiliar experience can become genuinely one's own.
Review Summary
You May Also Like explores why we like what we like, examining taste across various domains including food, music, and art. Vanderbilt draws on research from psychology, neuroscience, and marketing to analyze how preferences form and change. While some readers found the book insightful and thought-provoking, others felt it lacked cohesion or definitive conclusions. The book's strength lies in its interesting anecdotes and ability to make readers reflect on their own tastes, though some found certain sections dry or overly detailed.
People Also Read
Glossary
Ecological valence theory
Color liking through associationA theory that people tend to prefer colors associated with things they like and avoid colors linked to things they dislike. In studies discussed in the book, the things people liked predicted their color preferences. The theory allows both biological predispositions and learned associations to contribute, rather than treating color preferences as fixed from birth.
Mere exposure effect
Familiarity can increase likingThe tendency for repeated exposure to a stimulus to improve a person's attitude toward it, sometimes even when the person is not conscious of having encountered it before. It helps explain how people can acquire liking for unfamiliar foods, music, or other experiences. Repetition is not guaranteed to help, since it may deepen an existing dislike.
Flavor-nutrient conditioning
Liking learned from bodily rewardA learning process in which a flavor becomes more appealing because it is followed by a beneficial nutritional effect in the body. The association can form without the person consciously tasting or recognizing the nutrient. Experiments described in the book found that people and animals could develop a preference for a flavor paired with calories delivered after ingestion.
Sensory-specific satiety
A food loses appeal as eatenA decline in the pleasantness of a particular food as it is consumed, beyond the general feeling of being full. Other foods can remain appealing, which helps explain why people seek variety during meals. The effect can respond to sensory properties such as taste, texture, and appearance, and can influence what someone wants next.
Taste space
A map of preference patternsA model that represents people and their preferences as positions in a network of correlated answers and behaviors. The book describes Hunch's attempt to use many responses to locate people relative to one another, including when they had not answered a particular question themselves. The model identifies patterns, but does not by itself explain why those patterns exist.
Omnivorousness
Appreciation across cultural genresA pattern in which people, especially those with cultural status, express interest in a wide range of cultural forms rather than restricting themselves to traditionally elite ones. This can look more inclusive than older forms of distinction, but breadth itself can become a status signal. Omnivorousness does not mean liking everything equally or abandoning social boundaries.
Conformist distinction
Belonging while seeming distinctThe tension between wanting to share tastes with a valued group and wanting to remain different from outsiders or even from other members of that group. It helps explain why people adopt a style to belong, then abandon it when it becomes too common. The pursuit of individuality can therefore produce new forms of conformity.
Neutral model
Popularity shifting through random copyingA model of cultural change in which some traits rise or fall through repeated copying and chance, rather than because they are inherently better or more useful. The book applies this idea to such patterns as dog breed popularity and changing cultural forms. It is not a claim that all cultural change is random, since external influences and selection can also matter.
MAYA
Novelty within an acceptable rangeRaymond Loewy's design principle, named from the phrase most advanced yet acceptable. It describes the balance in which a product or design feels new enough to attract attention but familiar enough to be understood and accepted. The idea helps explain why radical innovation may meet resistance until audiences gain reference points for it.
FAQ
What is [You May Also Like: Taste in an Age of Endless Choice] by Tom Vanderbilt about?
- Exploration of taste formation: The book investigates how human taste is formed, influenced, and constantly evolving, especially in a world of overwhelming choices.
- Interdisciplinary approach: Vanderbilt draws from psychology, neuroscience, sociology, and economics to unpack the science and philosophy behind why we like what we like.
- Role of social and cultural factors: It examines the interplay between biology, culture, social context, and individual psychology in shaping preferences.
- Modern context of abundance: The book highlights how endless options in food, music, art, and consumer goods challenge our ability to choose and shape our tastes.
Why should I read [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt?
- Understand your own preferences: The book helps readers make sense of their own tastes, showing that preferences are adaptive, context-dependent, and not as fixed as we think.
- Navigate choice overload: It offers practical insights for making better decisions and appreciating what you like amid today’s overwhelming abundance of options.
- Connects science to daily life: Vanderbilt combines rigorous research with relatable anecdotes, making complex ideas about taste accessible and relevant.
- Reveals hidden influences: Readers gain awareness of how social influence, marketing, and even randomness shape their choices, leading to more informed decision-making.
What are the key takeaways from [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt?
- Taste is dynamic and social: Preferences are shaped by culture, social influence, memory, and a constant tension between novelty and familiarity.
- Judgments are quick and unconscious: We often know what we like before we know why, with affective judgments happening rapidly and beneath conscious awareness.
- Language reinforces taste: Talking about taste helps unlock and reinforce liking, aiding memory and appreciation.
- Dislikes are revealing: Negative reactions often say more about identity and social boundaries than likes, and are more influential in shaping group dynamics.
- Be open and reflective: Recognize the malleability of taste, question easy likes, and appreciate the complex interplay of biology, culture, and experience.
How does [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt explain the science behind why we like certain foods?
- Innate and learned preferences: Humans are born with basic taste preferences (e.g., sweet is good, bitter is bad), but most food likes and dislikes are learned through exposure and cultural context.
- Multi-sensory experience: Enjoying food involves taste, smell, texture, and even sound, with presentation and anticipation playing significant roles.
- Sensory-specific satiety: We tire of specific foods during a meal, which explains why variety increases consumption and enjoyment, and why we often have “room for dessert.”
- Expectation and memory: What we expect and remember about food shapes our experience and future preferences.
What is the "hipster effect" and how does [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt use it to explain taste trends?
- Definition of hipster effect: Coined by mathematician Jonathan Touboul, it describes how people trying to be different from the majority end up looking alike, creating cycles of conformity through nonconformity.
- Social synchronization: Because individuals react to others with delayed or noisy information, nonconformists inadvertently synchronize, leading to trends that rise and fall unpredictably.
- Implications for taste: The quest for uniqueness can paradoxically generate conformity, influencing fashion, music, and other taste domains as people chase distinctiveness but end up in similar groups.
What is "conformist distinction" and how does [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt use it to explain human taste?
- Balancing belonging and individuality: Conformist distinction is the human drive to feel part of a group while maintaining a sense of uniqueness, leading to tastes that are shared but also subtly differentiated.
- Strategies for distinction: People select subgroups or emphasize superior conformity within a group (e.g., “I’m more punk than you”) to express individuality while still conforming.
- Taste cycles: This dynamic causes cycles where individuals adopt new tastes to differentiate from others, but in doing so, form new groups with shared tastes, perpetuating the tension between conformity and distinction.
How does social learning and imitation shape taste, according to [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt?
- Imitation as survival strategy: Humans are exceptional social learners, imitating others to efficiently acquire knowledge without costly trial and error, which has been crucial for cultural evolution.
- Spread of arbitrary behaviors: Studies of chimpanzees and humans show even nonfunctional behaviors can spread through imitation, highlighting the power and sometimes irrationality of social learning.
- Social cues and conformity: People tend to prefer what others are consuming, especially under uncertainty, as demonstrated in experiments with children and food choices.
How does randomness and error contribute to taste change in [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt?
- Neutral model of cultural change: Adapted from genetics, this model suggests most cultural changes, including taste shifts, occur through random copying and drift rather than selective advantage.
- Examples from nature and language: Birdsong and language evolution show that imperfect imitation and frequency of use, not inherent superiority, drive change.
- Implications for human culture: Many taste changes, such as baby names or dog breed popularity, can be explained by random fluctuations and social copying rather than functional or quality differences.
How does [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt address the impact of the Internet and social media on taste and popularity?
- Increased choice and exposure: The Internet offers unprecedented access to diverse cultural products, theoretically enabling more democratic and varied taste.
- Paradox of concentration: Despite more options, popular hits have become more dominant, with top songs and products capturing larger market shares due to social influence and feedback loops.
- Social influence effects: Visibility of others’ choices amplifies popularity disparities and unpredictability, making markets less about individual preference and more about social contagion.
How does [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt explain the measurement and communication of taste?
- Challenges in measurement: Tools like the nine-point hedonic scale are used to quantify liking, but ratings are influenced by interpretation, regression to the mean, and social desirability.
- Implicit vs. explicit feedback: Modern platforms like Netflix rely more on actual behavior than stated preferences, reflecting the complexity of capturing true tastes.
- Limited sensory vocabulary: Humans have few basic taste terms, making it hard to precisely describe complex flavors; experts develop specialized lexicons to communicate subtle sensory attributes.
How do expert judges evaluate taste in domains like food, beer, and art, according to [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt?
- Analytic and holistic styles: Judges use both detailed criteria and overall impressions (“halo effect”) to assess quality.
- Cognitive biases: Order effects, similarity biases, and social influences affect judgments, showing that even experts are subject to cognitive biases.
- Expertise as pattern recognition: Experts excel at extracting relevant information and recognizing patterns, but their judgments remain influenced by subjective and contextual factors.
How and why do tastes change over time, according to [You May Also Like] by Tom Vanderbilt?
- Projection bias: We tend to assume our future tastes will resemble current ones, but tastes often change dramatically as we age and experience new things.
- Novelty and familiarity tension: People crave novelty but also prefer familiarity; tastes evolve as we balance these competing drives.
- Social dynamics of distinction: Taste changes are influenced by desires to be both like others and distinct, creating cycles of conformity and differentiation in cultural preferences.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.