Key Takeaways
Stop treating glia as packing material: they help run the brain
Einstein’s brain offered a clue. When neuroanatomist Marian Diamond examined four samples from Albert Einstein’s cortex, she found no extra neurons compared with ordinary brains. She did find unusually many nonneuronal cells, called glia. The comparison involved only eleven control brains, and Einstein’s unique case could not be replicated, so the result raised a question rather than proving that glia explain genius.
A century of blind spots. Ramón y Cajal established that neurons are separate cells communicating across synapses. Glia were visible in his microscope, but their unfamiliar forms and lack of electrical impulses made them seem like support tissue. Fields’s central argument is that this focus left most brain cells out of the main account of brain function.
What is striking is how a scientific category can shape what counts as evidence: researchers built instruments to detect neuronal electricity, then treated the cells those instruments could not register as functionally silent. Einstein’s tissue is a memorable prompt, but not strong evidence about intelligence on its own. The more persuasive case comes from many independent roles for glia across brain development, signaling, and disease. The lesson is not that neurons matter less, but that a useful model can become a blindfold when its boundaries go unquestioned.
Track brain signals beyond synapses to see who regulates the message
A second signaling system. Neurons send rapid electrical impulses and release neurotransmitters across synapses. Glia do not fire those impulses, but calcium imaging, which makes chemical changes inside living cells visible, revealed that glia respond when neurons are active. In one early experiment, Schwann cells along stimulated nerve axons lit up after a delay. Astrocytes also detected neurotransmitters and passed calcium signals through networks of their own.
Listening can change the signal. At the junction between a nerve and a muscle, researchers injected messenger chemicals into surrounding Schwann cells and changed the muscle’s response. Astrocytes can absorb or release neurotransmitters, alter synaptic strength, and affect distant connections. The book calls attention to communication operating outside the neuron’s point-to-point wiring, often over slower, broader timescales.
This account expands the familiar circuit diagram from a chain of relays into a system with local regulators and broader feedback. The distinction matters: a cell can influence information without carrying the main signal itself, much as a thermostat affects a room without being its heat source. That does not automatically make every glial response a message with cognitive meaning. Demonstrating influence is easier than establishing what information is represented, how precisely it is encoded, or what behavior depends on it.
Treat glia as both repair crew and source of collateral damage
Four kinds, different jobs. The book describes astrocytes, microglia, oligodendrocytes, and Schwann cells. Astrocytes regulate the chemical environment around neurons and help manage blood flow. Microglia defend the central nervous system against infection and injury. Oligodendrocytes make myelin in the brain and spinal cord, while Schwann cells make it in peripheral nerves. Their functions overlap in supporting and protecting neural circuits, but they are not interchangeable.
Healing has a price. After spinal cord injury, astrocytes and microglia contain damage and clear debris, yet inflammatory chemicals can also injure nearby cells. Astrocytes form a scar that helps isolate the wound but blocks growing axons. In multiple sclerosis, immune attacks damage myelin, and axons can die too. In ALS, faulty astrocytes can contribute to motor neuron death. Glia may protect, harm, or do both in the same disease.
The useful model here is not “good glia” versus “bad glia,” but a response whose value depends on timing, location, and intensity. Inflammation can contain an immediate threat while worsening tissue damage if it persists. This resembles emergency responses in other biological systems: the same mechanism that prevents catastrophe can become a source of chronic injury. It also cautions against treatments that simply suppress glia wholesale. A successful intervention would need to preserve debris clearance and repair while limiting destructive spillover.
Chronic pain can persist because spinal glia keep sounding the alarm
Pain can outlast injury. Acute pain warns of damage, but neuropathic pain may continue after an injury has healed. Fields describes research showing that microglia and astrocytes in the spinal cord can release inflammatory signals that make pain neurons unusually excitable. In animal studies, blocking microglial activation reduced pain-like responses after nerve injury. A touch that is normally harmless can then become painful because the spinal circuitry has changed.
The same cells affect opioids. Glia also respond to morphine and can release substances that oppose its pain-relieving effects. This may contribute to tolerance, the need for increasing doses to achieve similar relief. The book presents glia-targeted approaches, including drugs that inhibit specific inflammatory signaling, as promising research directions, not established cures for people.
This reframes chronic pain as a condition of altered regulation, not simply a damaged wire continuing to transmit a signal. It also clarifies why a drug can relieve pain initially yet become less effective with repeated use: the nervous system adapts, and nonneuronal cells may join that adaptation. The therapeutic appeal is considerable, especially if glial targets reduce reliance on escalating opioid doses. But animal findings do not establish human efficacy, and dampening immune-like signaling could interfere with necessary repair.
Build brain circuits with glia before asking neurons to perform
Glia help construct the brain. During fetal development, radial glia form scaffolds that guide newborn neurons into position. Some radial glia also generate neurons. Other glia help direct axons toward their targets and provide a temporary bridge between the brain’s hemispheres as the corpus callosum forms. The developing brain is not simply a neuronal blueprint unfolding on its own; cells around neurons help organize its structure.
Development is vulnerable. The book connects glial injury to problems such as periventricular leukomalacia, in which oxygen deprivation damages cells that mature into myelin-forming oligodendrocytes. It also describes evidence that prenatal alcohol exposure harms glia as well as neurons, disrupting growth and brain wiring. In animal studies, immature astrocytes could reopen a period of visual-circuit flexibility, suggesting that glia help regulate when experience can reshape particular circuits.
The developmental perspective makes brain function less like installing software on finished hardware and more like construction in which the builders continue shaping the structure they inhabit. That view helps explain why timing matters: injury to a developing support system can have effects beyond the cells directly lost. It also makes prevention especially important when fetal development is involved. Still, findings from animal models identify possible mechanisms, not a complete account of human developmental outcomes or a simple route to reversing them.
Practice can change white matter, not just strengthen synapses
Learning may alter insulation. Myelin wraps axons and speeds electrical impulses by allowing signals to travel between exposed gaps called nodes of Ranvier. Fields argues that myelin is more than passive insulation: glia can sense activity in axons, and activity can affect the development and amount of myelin. In one study discussed in the book, professional pianists had differences in white matter along pathways involved in finger movement, and those differences tracked with practice time.
Timing shapes coordination. Diffusion tensor imaging, a brain-scanning method that estimates how water moves through white matter, also found associations between white matter organization and children’s IQ scores. These results do not show that myelin alone creates intelligence or musical skill. They support a broader possibility: experience can tune the timing of signals between brain regions, complementing changes at synapses. Myelination also continues into early adulthood, with frontal regions maturing relatively late.
The proposal is compelling because complex performance depends not only on whether two brain regions connect, but also on whether their signals arrive in useful coordination. It places learning across multiple scales: synaptic strength, circuit timing, and the physical properties of pathways. That is a richer account than a single “memory molecule” explanation. Yet the pianist and IQ findings are correlational. Practice could alter white matter, preexisting differences could shape who practices, or both could be true. The book’s strongest contribution is framing a testable question, not settling causation.
Look to glia for the brain’s slow, unconscious coordination
The brain regulates more than thought. Astrocytes help manage potassium around active neurons, support the blood-brain barrier, and adjust local blood flow to meet neural demand. They also change their position around synapses. In the hypothalamus, astrocytes alter contact with neurons involved in thirst and hormone release. During pregnancy and lactation, changes in astrocytes around oxytocin-producing neurons help reshape the signals associated with birth and milk release.
Sleep offers another window. The book describes experiments in which waves of calcium activity in astrocytes accompanied coordinated neuronal activity during sleep. It also discusses fruit-fly research linking a glial gene to sleep-wake regulation. These examples point to glia as participants in broad, relatively slow changes in brain state, alongside the fast neuronal signals that drive reflexes and immediate sensation.
The emphasis on unconscious regulation corrects a common bias: vivid, reportable thought is not the whole of brain function. Temperature, fluid balance, arousal, and coordinated movement depend on systems operating without deliberate awareness. Glia’s slower signaling may suit some forms of modulation better than rapid reflexes. The restraint is important, though. Evidence that glia influence a physiological state does not establish that they generate subjective experience. The book’s proposal is strongest when it separates modulation of neural activity from claims about consciousness itself.
Follow infectious disease into glia, where brain defenses can become hosts
Kuru’s route was cultural. In Papua New Guinea, the Fore people suffered a fatal disorder called kuru. The pattern initially looked puzzling until investigators found that funeral practices included consuming the bodies of relatives, and women and children were more exposed to infected brain tissue than men. Experiments transmitting the disease to chimpanzees established infectivity. Researchers eventually identified prions, misshapen proteins that can induce normal versions of the protein to refold abnormally, as the cause of this class of disease.
Glia can shelter infection. The book also describes HIV entering the brain through infected immune cells and infecting microglia, which can spread the virus and contribute to neural damage. In prion disease, astrocytes and microglia may help propagate infection, damage neurons, or help clear harmful material. Their role is not one-dimensional: the brain’s defenders can become part of the disease process while still attempting to contain it.
The kuru story shows why disease mechanisms cannot be found in tissue alone. The epidemic’s distribution made sense only when biology was connected to social practice. That is a powerful reminder for medicine: patterns of exposure, behavior, and environment can reveal what laboratory analysis initially misses. The glial account adds another layer by showing how an immune defense can also provide a route for infection or injury. Such dual roles complicate treatment, because suppressing a cell’s harmful activity may also weaken its protective function.
Challenge scientific blind spots with better tools and wider hypotheses
Methods shape discovery. Electrodes reveal neuronal impulses but miss many glial signals. Calcium imaging made activity in living glia visible; brain imaging later exposed changes in white matter that had been easy to overlook. The book’s history, from Cajal’s drawings to modern microscopes, shows how new tools can turn a familiar cell into a new scientific problem.
Keep claims proportional. The findings reach from glial brain tumors to possible roles in Alzheimer’s disease, psychiatric disorders, memory, and aging. Some are established functions, such as myelin formation; others are emerging interpretations, especially claims about glia shaping thought. The practical implication is to include glia in research and treatment design without assuming every proposed role is proven. Better categories, measurements, and experiments are needed to distinguish cause from response.
The book’s most durable argument is methodological: explanations improve when researchers study the parts their instruments and assumptions have excluded. That principle applies far beyond neuroscience, especially in fields where measurable variables can crowd out less convenient ones. The same argument also demands disciplined skepticism. A neglected cell type can be genuinely important, but correcting neglect does not mean assigning it every unexplained function. Scientific progress requires both imaginative hypothesis-making and careful separation of observation, mechanism, and speculation.
Analysis
The book’s central achievement is a change in scale. It asks readers to move from the neuron as a self-sufficient computational unit to the nervous system as a partnership among cells that signal, nourish, insulate, defend, and remodel one another. Glia are not simply an additional cast of brain cells. Their functions connect neural activity to immunity, blood flow, metabolism, development, and tissue repair. This makes the account valuable not only as a correction to neuron-centered neuroscience, but as a model of biological systems in which regulation is distributed across specialized partners.
Its narrative method reinforces that shift. The opening puzzle of Einstein’s unusually glia-rich tissue gives the reader a vivid question, while the history of microscopy explains why the answer remained elusive. Scientific instruments do not merely collect facts; they privilege certain kinds of facts. Electrodes made electrical impulses legible and helped establish a powerful neuronal model. Calcium imaging and advanced microscopy made slower chemical activity visible. The book therefore tells two stories at once: the discovery of glial function and the discovery that scientific attention itself has a physiology.
The main interpretive challenge is the broad reach of the thesis. Evidence that glia affect synapses, injury responses, or myelination does not automatically prove that they encode thoughts or account for intelligence. The book often marks these distinctions, but its ambitious framing can make emerging hypotheses feel more settled than they are. Einstein’s tissue is suggestive, not explanatory; white matter correlations do not isolate causal mechanisms; and animal experiments do not guarantee clinical treatments.
The strongest synthesis is consequently neither “neurons are obsolete” nor “glia are a second, independent brain.” It is that neural computation depends on an interacting environment whose components operate at different speeds and scales. Neurons provide rapid, specific transmission. Glia influence the conditions, timing, and durability of that transmission. This relational view opens research questions across cognition and medicine while preserving the need for precise causal tests. The book’s lasting lesson is to expand the model without replacing one oversimplification with another.
Review Summary
The Other Brain receives mostly positive reviews for its fascinating exploration of glial cells and their crucial role in brain function. Readers appreciate Fields' ability to make complex neuroscience accessible, though some find the writing style repetitive or overly technical. Many reviewers highlight the book's potential to revolutionize understanding of brain disorders and treatments. Some criticize the occasional use of sensationalism or meandering narratives. Overall, readers find the book informative and thought-provoking, praising its contribution to neuroscience while acknowledging its challenges for non-expert readers.
People Also Read
Glossary
neuron doctrine
neurons as separate signaling cellsThe theory associated with Santiago Ramón y Cajal that neurons are distinct cells rather than a continuous fused network. They receive and send information in an organized direction, communicating across specialized gaps called synapses. The book treats this doctrine as foundational, while arguing that it left glial cells and their forms of communication largely outside the standard account.
calcium imaging
visualizing calcium signals in cellsA method for observing changes in calcium concentration inside living cells. Researchers use calcium-sensitive fluorescent dyes or indicators, then record changes in brightness with microscopes. Because calcium acts as an internal signal in many cells, the method can reveal cellular activity that electrodes designed to detect neuronal impulses may miss, including signaling in glia.
gliotransmitter
signal released by gliaA signaling molecule released by a glial cell and detected by other cells, including neurons, other glia, vascular cells, or immune cells. The book uses the term for substances such as ATP and glutamate when glia release them to affect cellular communication. The term describes a proposed signaling role, not a claim that every glial release has the same function.
long-term potentiation
lasting increase in synaptic strengthA sustained strengthening of a synaptic connection after repeated or intense stimulation. In hippocampal slices, researchers observed that a brief burst of electrical stimulation could make subsequent synaptic responses larger for hours. The phenomenon is widely studied as a cellular model for learning and memory, though it is not by itself a complete explanation of memory.
node of Ranvier
gap between myelin segmentsAn exposed section of an axon between neighboring regions of myelin. In myelinated axons, electrical impulses are regenerated at these nodes and travel rapidly between them, rather than being continuously regenerated along the entire axon. The book emphasizes that their spacing and the surrounding myelin, formed by glia, help determine the speed of signal transmission.
NG2 cell
dividing glial precursor cellA type of cell identified by the NG2 marker and found throughout the adult brain. Unlike mature neurons, NG2 cells can divide, and research described in the book suggests that they can develop into several types of brain cells. Their ability to proliferate makes them interesting for repair research, while also raising concerns about uncontrolled growth.
glial scar
glial barrier around injuryA boundary formed largely by reactive astrocytes around damaged regions of the brain or spinal cord. The scar helps contain injury and restore separation between damaged and healthier tissue. However, molecules associated with it can impede the growth of axons through the injury site, creating a conflict between protecting tissue and enabling neural regeneration.
FAQ
What's The Other Brain about?
- Exploration of Glial Cells: The book focuses on glial cells, which constitute about 85% of the brain's cellular makeup, challenging the neuron-centric view of brain function.
- Mental Health Impact: It explores how glial cells are involved in mental health issues like schizophrenia and depression, suggesting new treatment possibilities.
- Revolutionizing Neuroscience: R. Douglas Fields presents discoveries that reshape our understanding of the brain, emphasizing glial cells as active participants in brain processes.
Why should I read The Other Brain?
- Cutting-Edge Research: The book offers insights into the latest neuroscience research, particularly on often-overlooked glial cells.
- Practical Implications: Understanding glial function has significant implications for treating neurological diseases and mental health disorders.
- Engaging Narrative: Fields combines scientific rigor with storytelling, making complex concepts accessible and engaging.
What are the key takeaways of The Other Brain?
- Glia's Crucial Role: Glial cells are essential for brain function, influencing memory, mental health, and cognitive processes.
- Neurons vs. Glia: The book challenges the neuron-centric view, showing that glia are integral to brain activity.
- Future of Neuroscience: Fields suggests future research will focus more on glia, potentially leading to breakthroughs in understanding brain disorders.
What are the best quotes from The Other Brain and what do they mean?
- “Glia do not fire electrical impulses...”: This highlights the historical oversight in neuroscience, where glial cells were dismissed due to their lack of electrical activity.
- “The discovery of glia—the other brain...”: This emphasizes the transformative potential of recognizing glial cells as active participants in brain function.
- “The other brain, operating entirely outside our conscious mind...”: This encapsulates the book's thesis, highlighting glial cells' crucial yet overlooked role.
What are glial cells and why are they important?
- Types of Glial Cells: Glial cells include astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, Schwann cells, and microglia, each with distinct functions.
- Support and Protection: They provide structural support, maintain homeostasis, and protect neurons, playing a vital role in brain health.
- Involvement in Disease: Glial cells are implicated in neurological disorders, indicating they are active participants in brain pathology.
How do glial cells contribute to mental health according to The Other Brain?
- Silent Partners in Mental Illness: Glial cells are involved in conditions like depression and schizophrenia, playing a role in underlying mechanisms.
- Neuroinflammation: Glial cells can become reactive, leading to neuroinflammation linked to mental health issues.
- Potential for New Treatments: Understanding glial function could lead to novel therapeutic approaches targeting these cells.
How do glial cells interact with neurons according to The Other Brain?
- Communication Pathways: Glial cells communicate with neurons through signaling molecules, influencing neuronal activity.
- Support Functions: They provide metabolic support, maintain the extracellular environment, and clear excess neurotransmitters.
- Regulatory Role: Glial cells modulate synaptic transmission and plasticity, affecting learning and memory processes.
What role do glial cells play in neurological diseases as discussed in The Other Brain?
- Neuroinflammation: Activated glial cells contribute to neuroinflammation, implicated in disorders like Alzheimer’s and multiple sclerosis.
- Neuroprotection vs. Neurotoxicity: Glial cells can protect neurons or contribute to damage, depending on the context.
- Potential Therapeutic Targets: Targeting glial cells could be a novel approach for treating neurological diseases.
How do glial cells contribute to memory and learning in The Other Brain?
- Role in Synaptic Plasticity: Glial cells influence synaptic strength and plasticity, essential for memory formation.
- Calcium Signaling: Calcium waves in astrocytes modulate neuronal activity, affecting learning processes.
- Myelination and Learning: Myelination, facilitated by oligodendrocytes, is linked to learning efficiency and cognitive performance.
What is the significance of astrocytes in The Other Brain?
- Dynamic Cellular Behavior: Astrocytes actively participate in brain function, changing shape and function in response to activity.
- Regulation of Neurotransmitters: They release gliotransmitters that modulate synaptic transmission, challenging their traditional view as support cells.
- Implications for Mental Health: Dysfunction in astrocytic activity can contribute to mental health disorders.
How does The Other Brain challenge traditional neuroscience views?
- Glia as Active Participants: The book argues that glial cells are active participants in brain function, challenging the neuron-centric view.
- Interconnectedness of Neurons and Glia: Fields emphasizes the importance of understanding neuron-glia interactions for a complete understanding of brain function.
- Revising Research Priorities: The author calls for a shift in research priorities to include glial biology, potentially reshaping neuroscience.
What future directions does The Other Brain suggest for neuroscience research?
- Investigating Glial Diversity: More research is needed into the various types of glial cells and their specific functions.
- Exploring Glial Plasticity: Studying how glial cells adapt and change in response to experience could have implications for learning and memory.
- Understanding Glial Involvement in Diseases: Investigating glial dysfunction in neurological diseases could lead to new therapeutic strategies.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.