Key Takeaways
Treat each hire as a costly prediction, not a pleasant conversation.
Mistakes carry a bill. Mornell estimates that replacing a bad hire within six months costs about two and a half times the employee’s annual salary. In a small, nonscientific survey of executives, the median reported cost of a hiring mistake was $300,000, and the median time to resolve it was one year. Those figures are not universal, but they make the point: a hiring error consumes money, attention, and sleep.
Selection beats cleanup. The book’s central argument is that careful hiring takes effort upfront but can save far more effort than managing a poor fit. The task is not to find a flawless person. It is to collect enough evidence to make a sound prediction about how a particular candidate will perform in a particular role.
The strongest framing here is hiring as a decision under uncertainty, not a social audition. That shift changes the question from “Did the conversation go well?” to “What evidence would make this prediction more trustworthy?” The cost figures help make an abstract risk tangible, though they come from the author’s rule of thumb and an informal survey, not a universal accounting model. A bad hire’s effects can also spread through team workload and morale, costs that a salary multiplier may miss.
Predict future performance from repeated past behavior, not interview polish.
Sample the real game. Mornell’s Maxim is his principle that past behavior is the strongest guide to future behavior. He illustrates it with San Francisco 49ers scout Tony Razzano. After recommending punter Jim Miller based on impressive kicks in an empty stadium, Razzano learned that isolated drills had not shown how Miller handled pressure in actual games. He began seeking evidence across at least 200 plays.
Gather more than one snapshot. Most employers cannot watch hundreds of performances, but they can observe a candidate in varied situations and ask people who have worked with them for specific examples. Mornell suggests building a substantial record from interviews, assignments, references, and informal interactions, rather than letting one dazzling meeting dominate the decision.
The football example captures a basic measurement problem: performance in a simplified setting may not transfer to a demanding one. Repeated observations across contexts reduce the risk of mistaking a polished presentation for durable capability. The useful unit is not merely the number of observations, however, but their relevance. Twenty examples of a candidate succeeding at the wrong task offer less guidance than a few well-chosen samples of the actual work. The book’s maxim is a strong starting hypothesis, not a guarantee that people never change.
Screen early and redesign the job before booking long interviews.
Clarify the target first. Before recruiting, define the work and the qualities it truly requires. Mornell argues that employers sometimes inherit a job description when they should redesign the role. Pentagram, a design firm, separated creative work from administration by adding an office manager, instead of expecting designers to excel at logistics as well as design.
Build a short funnel. Use a broad candidate search, then request a tailored letter and résumé, make a brief phone call, and consider a small pre-interview assignment. One nonprofit used several of these steps to move from about 80 applicants to 15 promising résumés, 10 short interviews, three reference checks, and two finalists. Mornell argues that screening can eliminate many poor matches before they consume hours of interview time.
This approach treats recruitment as both job design and information design. A clearer role improves the odds of attracting relevant applicants, while an early screen makes the process less dependent on lengthy, expensive conversations. The nonprofit example shows how modest filters can create a manageable funnel. Filters also encode choices: rejecting applicants for a weak cover letter, for instance, may screen writing ability, but it can also exclude people whose skills are strong and whose access or circumstances differ. Each hurdle should test a real job requirement.
Ask your questions, then stop talking long enough to hear evidence.
Make room for answers. Mornell’s practical interviewing advice is to prepare a set of questions, ask them near the beginning, and let the candidate do most of the talking. He found that interviewers often sell the job, lead candidates toward desired answers, or talk to fill silence. A CEO who tried the method gave a finalist ten questions at once; the candidate spoke for an hour, and the interviewer finally had space to listen.
Probe for examples. Ask about past responsibilities, difficult decisions, performance problems, and what former colleagues might say. Follow up when an answer is general. The interviewer should also take notes, including questions or impressions to check later, and ask mainly about areas where they can recognize depth and evasiveness.
Listening is not passive. It requires an interviewer to resist steering the candidate toward a preferred story, then distinguish concrete examples from polished generalities. This is one of the book’s most durable recommendations because it improves both evidence quality and the candidate’s opportunity to explain. Still, asking every question at once can feel artificial and may reward quick verbal organization rather than job performance. A prepared structure works best as a guide for consistent inquiry, not a test of who handles an unusual format most smoothly.
Give finalists work that resembles the job they would actually do.
Test the work itself. A résumé and interview describe capability; a job-related task lets a candidate demonstrate it. Mornell describes American Golf asking candidates to visit a course and assess its service, facilities, and condition. One candidate’s practical observations were adopted by the company. Other examples include asking a machinist to interpret a blueprint, a copy editor to revise a chapter, or a finalist to analyze a real business proposal.
Use a fair audition. A brief task during an interview can reveal judgment, communication, and problem-solving. A take-home project or temporary trial can show follow-through and work quality under more realistic conditions. These exercises should resemble actual duties and have clear expectations. The goal is to see relevant work, not to set a trap or obtain unpaid labor.
Work samples narrow the gap between what candidates say they can do and what the role requires them to do. They also give candidates a chance to demonstrate ability that a conventional interview may miss. The design matters: an exercise should measure the skill in question, be comparable across applicants, and take a reasonable amount of time. Otherwise, it can measure free time, familiarity with interview conventions, or willingness to complete unpaid work. A realistic audition is useful precisely because it is relevant, not because it is difficult or surprising.
Translate a candidate’s standout strength into its likely failure mode.
Strengths have edges. Mornell urges interviewers to ask what a candidate’s most impressive quality might look like when pushed too far. A highly sociable, persuasive applicant may build relationships, but could also prioritize popularity, oversell, or avoid difficult conversations. The point is not to treat a strength as a hidden flaw. It is to identify risks worth checking against the job’s demands.
Use tests cautiously. The book describes personality inventories as one possible source of clues, especially when their results match interview examples, past performance, and references. It also presents handwriting analysis, but cautions against relying on it alone. A test result should prompt questions and verification, not serve as a verdict. The candidate should have a fair chance to discuss a concern before it influences the decision.
This is a useful antidote to the halo effect, in which one appealing quality makes a person seem broadly capable. Asking how a strength behaves under pressure turns praise into a more precise hypothesis: sociability may help with clients, while excessive agreeableness may complicate performance feedback. The book is right to treat assessments as supporting evidence, not substitutes for observed work. Its enthusiasm for handwriting analysis is much less secure; a tool’s ability to generate a vivid description does not establish that it predicts job performance.
Treat chemistry and odd behavior as clues, not verdicts.
Notice the first reaction. Mornell considers chemistry useful, but warns that interviewers bring biases about appearance, accent, age, and other traits. One executive learned to pause when lateness irritated her, rather than letting that reaction end the evaluation. A brief walk around the workplace can reveal how a candidate engages with people and surroundings, while also making the meeting less formal.
Investigate behavior in context. A candidate who talks excessively or acts unusually may be revealing something important, but one episode cannot explain its cause. Mornell recounts an academic candidate whose pressured, nonstop self-presentation raised concern; the candidate later connected it to family strain, while the author also suspected a possible alcohol problem. The lesson is to ask what happened, seek a pattern, and avoid treating an impression as a diagnosis.
Intuition can be valuable because people notice signals before they can fully articulate them. It can also be a vehicle for prejudice, so the useful practice is to convert a gut reaction into a testable question. What behavior prompted the reaction? Is it relevant to the work? Does it recur in other settings? This preserves the insight of informal observation without turning personal comfort into a hiring standard. The story about unusual behavior also shows why inference must stay modest: stress, unfamiliarity, and many other factors can produce similar outward signs.
Verify claims through references who can speak beyond the official script.
Check more than dates. Mornell argues that reference checks often confirm basic facts but fail to reveal how a candidate actually worked. Verify education and employment history, ask the candidate what references are likely to say, and request specific examples about performance, relationships, and reasons for leaving. If a reference offers little, seek other informed perspectives, including people higher in the former organization’s chain of command.
Keep the inquiry fair. The book recommends asking references to call back only if the candidate was outstanding, then pursuing deeper conversations with those who respond. It also describes using public records and online research for relevant background. But a candidate deserves an opportunity to explain disputed information. A young employee who had reported financial misconduct in Japan was initially described as a troublemaker, yet independent references confirmed his account and said his action had helped the company.
Reference checking works best as triangulation: compare the candidate’s account with observations from people who saw the work, then investigate discrepancies rather than merely collecting endorsements. The Japanese whistle-blower story is a reminder that negative labels can conceal principled behavior, while a polished reference list can omit important context. The book’s proposed callback test may quickly distinguish enthusiastic advocates from silence, but silence is ambiguous. Busy schedules, company policy, or fear of legal exposure can all limit a response, so it should not be treated as proof of poor performance.
Put predictable friction on the table before making an offer.
Make the match workable. A hire can fail even when the candidate has strong skills, if the realities of the role conflict with important needs. Mornell describes a plant manager finalist who worried that weekend work would prevent him from coaching his child’s sports team. A direct conversation clarified that the schedule was more flexible than he had understood. Another candidate’s concern about health coverage for a seriously ill child was resolved before she accepted the job.
Address the job, not private status. Discuss responsibilities, schedule, travel, relocation, benefits, and likely pressures with candidates in a consistent, job-related way. Mornell recommends meeting a spouse or partner for some executive hires, but that practice can be intrusive and legally risky. The more transferable lesson is to invite candidates to raise practical concerns themselves and resolve feasible problems before they become surprises.
The book’s emphasis on mutual fit corrects a common imbalance: employers scrutinize candidates while leaving the actual demands of the job vague. Early candor helps both sides assess whether the arrangement can work. The boundary is important, however. A spouse’s views, family plans, or medical details should not become informal selection criteria. Employers can explain the role and its conditions to every finalist, then discuss accommodations or logistics through appropriate, lawful channels. Practical fit deserves attention without turning private life into an interview subject.
Build a repeatable hiring system that can reject every finalist.
Make the method yours. Mornell offers 45 possible tactics, not a universal script. He urges employers to choose the steps that suit their work, combine them into a clear process, and remove outdated habits when adding new ones. American Golf took six months to develop a one-page selection flowchart using résumé review, phone screening, assignments, interviews, and references.
Protect the decision from wishful thinking. A trusted colleague should be able to challenge a leader’s favorite candidate. Mornell recounts a college president whose staff had serious concerns about a vice president he had hired; the staff had stayed quiet until the problem became a crisis. When no finalist meets the standard, waiting is better than hiring someone merely to end the search. The point is to invest in people through disciplined selection, not hopeful improvisation.
A hiring process is most valuable when it is repeatable enough to compare candidates and flexible enough to fit the role. A flowchart can clarify who gathers evidence and when, while a dissenting colleague can counter the tendency to defend a favored choice. The process should also be evaluated against outcomes, not just whether each step was completed. Some tactics in the book are anecdotal and may add little predictive value. A durable system keeps the underlying discipline, then drops tools that fail to improve job-relevant decisions.
Analysis
Hiring Smart is a practical business book organized as 45 tactics, supported by stories from companies, executives, and the author’s consulting work. Its unifying idea is that selection should be an evidence-gathering process, not a contest in interview performance. The memorable football example gives that idea a clear shape: a player’s isolated drills did not predict how he handled live pressure, so the scout began looking across many plays. The same logic supports early screening, work samples, careful listening, and persistent reference checks.
The book’s strongest contribution is its insistence on varied, job-relevant evidence. A candidate’s behavior before and after the formal interview can add useful context, and an assignment can reveal skills that verbal self-presentation conceals. The advice to redesign a role before recruiting is also unusually practical: sometimes the hiring problem is a poorly assembled job, not a shortage of ideal applicants. The recommendation to build a process around an organization’s needs makes the tactics more adaptable than a fixed interview script.
Its evidence base is less systematic than its confidence sometimes suggests. The stories are vivid, but they cannot establish that a particular cue reliably predicts later performance. A messy car, missed callback, accent, handwriting sample, or first impression may feel revealing while reflecting circumstances unrelated to competence. The book itself acknowledges bias and legal risk, yet some proposed methods, especially handwriting analysis and meeting a candidate’s spouse, require substantial caution. Contemporary hiring practice should prioritize standardized, job-related assessments, consistent questions, accessibility, and current legal advice over informal profiling.
The best way to use this book is as a design prompt. Ask what each step measures, whether it measures a real requirement, and whether every candidate receives a fair chance to demonstrate it. Keep the habits that improve evidence and reduce wishful thinking. Treat memorable anecdotes as hypotheses to test, not rules to copy. That distinction preserves the book’s central practical insight while avoiding the temptation to mistake a compelling story for a validated selection method.
Review Summary
45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart! receives mixed reviews, with an overall rating of 3.98/5. Many readers find it helpful, praising its practical tips and interview techniques. Some appreciate the focus on finding passionate candidates and checking references. However, critics point out cultural biases, outdated information, and overly specific advice. The book's readability is noted, but some question the ethics of certain hiring practices suggested. Overall, it's seen as a useful resource for hiring managers, despite its limitations.
People Also Read
Glossary
Mornell’s Maxim
Past behavior predicts future behaviorThe author’s principle that a person’s previous behavior is the best starting point for predicting how that person may behave in a new role. It is a guide to gathering evidence, not a claim that people never change. The book emphasizes checking a pattern across settings and considering context, mistakes, and changed circumstances.
Pre-Interview Interview
Brief initial candidate meetingA short, early in-person meeting used to screen candidates before investing in a full interview. It follows preliminary steps such as reviewing a résumé, speaking by phone, or requesting a brief assignment. The aim is to identify obvious mismatches quickly and reserve longer conversations for candidates who merit deeper consideration.
200 plays
Repeated real-world observationsThe author’s shorthand for observing a candidate’s performance across many actions or situations rather than relying on one impressive demonstration. The idea comes from football scouting: workouts in an empty stadium failed to show how a punter performed amid real game pressures. Employers can approximate this broader evidence through work samples, references, and varied interactions.
FAQ
What's "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!" about?
- Purpose of the book: "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!" by Pierre Mornell is a guide to improving the hiring process by predicting the future behavior of candidates through various strategies.
- Focus on behavior: The book emphasizes observing candidates' behavior before, during, and after interviews to make more informed hiring decisions.
- Practical strategies: It provides 45 actionable strategies to help employers identify the best candidates and avoid costly hiring mistakes.
- Target audience: The book is aimed at business owners, managers, and HR professionals who are responsible for hiring key personnel.
Why should I read "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!"?
- Reduce hiring mistakes: The book offers insights into reducing the high costs associated with hiring the wrong person.
- Improve hiring skills: It provides practical tools and strategies to enhance your ability to evaluate and select the right candidates.
- Learn from experts: The author shares experiences and advice from successful business leaders and hiring experts.
- Comprehensive approach: The book covers all stages of the hiring process, from pre-interview strategies to post-interview evaluations.
What are the key takeaways of "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!"?
- Behavior as a predictor: The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior, and observing candidates' actions is crucial.
- Chemistry matters: Trust your instincts about the chemistry between you and the candidate, as it can be a significant factor in hiring decisions.
- Use multiple strategies: Combining different strategies can provide a more comprehensive evaluation of candidates.
- Importance of references: Thorough reference checks are essential to verify candidates' backgrounds and uncover potential issues.
What are the best quotes from "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!" and what do they mean?
- "The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior." This quote emphasizes the importance of understanding a candidate's history to predict their future performance.
- "Never do business with anybody you don’t like." This advice highlights the significance of personal chemistry and trust in professional relationships.
- "Invest in people, not ideas." It underscores the value of hiring the right individuals, as they are the key to a company's success.
- "You can never pay the right person enough, and you always pay the wrong person too much." This quote reflects the long-term cost implications of hiring decisions.
How does Pierre Mornell suggest using intuition in hiring?
- Trust your gut: Mornell advises trusting your instincts when you have a strong feeling about a candidate, whether positive or negative.
- Chemistry is crucial: He emphasizes that chemistry between the interviewer and candidate is often determined in the first few minutes.
- Be aware of biases: While intuition is important, it's also crucial to be aware of personal biases that might affect your judgment.
- Balance with evidence: Use intuition as one part of a broader strategy that includes behavioral observations and reference checks.
What are some pre-interview strategies from "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!"?
- Phone contact: Make initial phone contact with candidates to gauge their communication skills and responsiveness.
- Assignment before interview: Give candidates a task related to the job to assess their problem-solving abilities and initiative.
- Resume reading in teams: Review resumes in teams to gain diverse perspectives and insights into candidates' qualifications.
- Cast a wide net: Use various channels to attract a diverse pool of candidates, increasing the chances of finding the right fit.
How does "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!" suggest conducting interviews?
- Ask all questions at once: Present all your questions at the beginning to focus on listening and observing the candidate's responses.
- Have fun: Use unconventional questions to see how candidates think on their feet and reveal their personalities.
- Assign a mini-project: During the interview, give candidates a task to perform to observe their practical skills and creativity.
- Seek closure: Announce a five-minute warning before the end of the interview to prompt candidates to share any final thoughts.
What post-interview strategies does Pierre Mornell recommend?
- Request a return call: Ask candidates to call you back at a specific time to test their reliability and interest in the position.
- Assign a take-home project: Give finalists a project to complete after the interview to further assess their skills and attention to detail.
- Travel with finalists: For executive positions, travel with candidates to observe their behavior in different settings and situations.
- Meet the spouse: If possible, meet the candidate's spouse or significant other to understand their support system and potential impact on job performance.
How important are reference checks according to "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!"?
- Essential for verification: Reference checks are crucial for verifying the accuracy of candidates' resumes and claims.
- Network up the chain: Speak with higher-level references to gain more insightful and honest feedback about the candidate.
- Ask for a call back: Leave messages asking references to call you back if the candidate was outstanding, as a lack of response can be telling.
- Meet references in person: Whenever possible, meet key references face-to-face to encourage more candid discussions.
What role do psychological tests play in "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!"?
- Supplementary tool: Psychological tests are used as an additional tool to gain insights into a candidate's personality and potential fit.
- Interpretation is key: The value of these tests depends on the skill of the interpreter and how well the results align with other observations.
- Legal considerations: Be aware of legal implications and ensure tests are used appropriately and fairly.
- Discuss results: Use test results as a starting point for discussions with candidates to explore their self-awareness and openness to feedback.
How does "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!" address the issue of hiring mistakes?
- High cost of mistakes: The book emphasizes the financial and emotional costs of hiring the wrong person and the importance of rectifying mistakes quickly.
- Learning from errors: It encourages learning from past hiring mistakes to improve future decision-making processes.
- No compromise: The book advises against compromising on hiring standards, even if the search takes longer than expected.
- Continuous improvement: Regularly update and refine your hiring strategies based on experiences and outcomes.
What is the significance of the "200 plays" rule in "45 Effective Ways for Hiring Smart!"?
- Observation over time: The "200 plays" rule suggests observing a candidate's behavior in multiple situations to get a comprehensive understanding.
- Beyond interviews: It emphasizes the importance of seeing candidates in action beyond the interview setting to predict future performance.
- Multiple data points: Gathering numerous observations helps reduce the influence of a single impressive or poor performance.
- Adaptable approach: While 200 plays may not always be feasible, the principle encourages using as many observations as possible to make informed decisions.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.