Key Takeaways
Read 1979 as a chain reaction, not an eternal Sunni-Shia feud
Three shocks converged. In 1979, Iran’s revolution toppled the shah, Saudi zealots seized Mecca’s Holy Mosque, and the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan. These events had different origins, but together they changed the region’s political climate. Iran’s new rulers claimed a revolutionary mandate to lead Muslims; Saudi rulers, shaken by the attack on Islam’s holiest site, leaned harder on religious authorities and began projecting Saudi religious influence abroad. The rivalry that grew between them was not simply an ancient Sunni-Shia quarrel. It was a modern contest for legitimacy and power, fought through religious institutions, cultural influence, and allies beyond each country’s borders.
History became a force. Ghattas traces how this competition reshaped Iran, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, Pakistan, Egypt, Iraq, and Syria, changing not only governments but also public culture and collective memory. The title’s Black Wave names that spread of intolerance and coercive religious politics.
The book’s most useful move is to replace inevitability with a chain of choices. That shift matters because ancient hatreds are easy explanations: they make present-day violence seem natural and therefore difficult to change. A chain-reaction account instead directs attention to institutions, money, leaders, and missed alternatives. It also asks for caution. Three events occurring in one year do not, by themselves, prove a single cause; local histories and state decisions mattered greatly. Ghattas’s strength is showing how separate crises became mutually reinforcing, not claiming that every later conflict had one origin.
Revolutions are vulnerable to the organizers who claim to speak for them
A coalition misread its ally. Khomeini’s return to Iran in 1979 was enabled by an unlikely opposition: secular leftists, nationalists, and religious modernists who thought his popularity could help remove the shah. Many treated his plan for clerical rule as unrealistic, or assumed they could limit it. The exiled ayatollah used the freedoms of Paris to attract international attention, while aides softened his public image for Western audiences. Once back in Iran, he relied on better-organized clerics and loyal revolutionary groups to seize authority from the very coalition that had helped bring him home.
A theory became a state. Khomeini’s wilayat al-faqih, or Guardianship of the Jurist, gave a senior Islamic jurist political authority in the absence of the Hidden Imam. His supporters embedded the idea in Iran’s constitution, making the Supreme Leader more powerful than elected institutions. The revolution’s promise of justice and independence became a theocratic system that purged former allies, critics, and rivals.
Revolutionary coalitions often unite around what they oppose while postponing agreement about what should replace it. That gap is not merely a philosophical problem. It rewards groups with discipline, organization, and a clear claim to authority. The Iranian case also shows why public statements deserve scrutiny: translations and reassuring language helped preserve a broad alliance, even as the revolution’s factions held sharply different goals. This does not mean every alliance with religious actors is doomed, or that Khomeini’s ascent was automatic. It means movements need enforceable rules for power-sharing before victory, not just confidence that allies will remain moderate.
When rulers fear revolt, they trade social freedom for religious legitimacy
Mecca exposed royal weakness. In November 1979, Juhayman al-Otaibi and his followers seized the Holy Mosque, proclaimed one of their own the Mahdi, and demanded an end to Western influence, royal extravagance, and unequal distribution of oil wealth. The siege challenged the House of Saud’s claim to protect Islam’s holiest sites. The state eventually retook the mosque, executing 63 captured rebels in January 1980. But survival came at a cost: the monarchy granted religious authorities greater influence over public life, helping them enforce stricter rules and constrain cultural freedoms.
Different regimes, similar bargains. In Iran, the new Islamic Republic rapidly restricted music, women’s choices, and independent institutions. In Saudi Arabia, women disappeared from television, cinemas closed, and religious police gained power. The systems were not identical, and the scale and form of repression differed. Yet both governments used religious authority to fortify rule and discipline society after political upheaval.
The episode makes legitimacy look less like a slogan than a bargain between ruling elites and institutions capable of mobilizing people. In Saudi Arabia, the clerical establishment helped protect the monarchy after a humiliating crisis, and the monarchy rewarded its influence. In Iran, clerics took the state itself. The comparison is illuminating so long as it does not erase differences: the Iranian revolution reorganized government, while Saudi policy tightened an existing monarchy’s social controls. Nor were clerics merely tools; they had their own beliefs and agendas. The exchange worked precisely because political interests and religious conviction could reinforce each other.
Foreign funding can turn local grievance into exportable political infrastructure
A war built networks. After the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia and the United States supported the anti-Soviet effort through Pakistan. Saudi money backed Afghan fighters, charities, and religious schools, while Pakistan’s military ruler Zia ul-Haq pursued his own program of Islamization. Arab volunteers also traveled to Peshawar; an estimated 35,000 joined the Afghan war over its course, though Afghans did most of the fighting. What began as a response to invasion became a meeting place for militants, religious organizers, donors, and aspiring fighters from different countries.
Ideas gained institutions. In Pakistan, Zia’s Islamization changed laws and public life. Saudi-backed schools and organizations helped spread stricter religious teachings, while Iran supported Shia networks and students. These efforts did not simply export a finished doctrine: local grievances, such as discrimination against Pakistan’s Shias, shaped how ideas were received. The result was durable infrastructure, from schools and charities to political groups, that could outlast the original war and serve new causes.
The key mechanism here is institutional persistence. A war ends, but schools, donor networks, personal connections, and political organizations remain available for other purposes. This resembles a broader pattern in which emergency infrastructure becomes ordinary infrastructure once it has staff, funding, and a constituency. The account also resists a common simplification: money alone does not manufacture belief. Pakistani leaders had domestic objectives, communities had real grievances, and Iranian and Saudi influence met different local conditions. External patrons can accelerate a movement, but the political environment determines which parts take root and who gains from them.
Once sect identity becomes state policy, ordinary neighbors become strategic enemies
A tax drew a boundary. In 1980, Zia’s plan to deduct zakat, an obligatory charitable contribution in Sunni practice, from bank accounts alarmed Pakistan’s Shias, for whom the state could not impose it in the same way. Shias mobilized in Islamabad and won an exemption. Their success showed their political strength, but it also intensified Sunni resentment among groups demanding a single Sunni framework for the country.
Rhetoric became machinery. Anti-Shia books, sermons, and religious rulings gained wider circulation, with Saudi-linked clerics and organizations helping promote them. In 1985, the anti-Shia militia Sepah-e Sahaba Pakistan was formed. By 1987, Sunni militants attacked Shia villages in Kurram, killing 52 Shias and 120 Sunnis and destroying homes. The sectarian violence was not a timeless feud suddenly awakening. Political choices made religious identity a tool for mobilization, exclusion, and violence.
The zakat dispute shows how a technical rule can become a test of belonging when a state imposes one community’s interpretation on everyone. The argument is not that religious differences are invented. It is that institutions can turn differences into unequal citizenship, then use the resulting conflict to recruit supporters. Once a group is labeled disloyal or outside the faith, violence can be framed as defense rather than aggression. That transformation is not inevitable: the same dispute produced successful Shia protest and a state exemption. Its danger lay in treating pluralism as a threat to national unity.
Defend culture as infrastructure, because memory shapes what people think is possible
Control reaches daily life. Across the book, political change appears in ordinary details: music vanishes from public spaces, women’s clothing becomes regulated, school lessons narrow, and family photographs are removed from walls. In Mecca, modernization and religious restrictions erased historic neighborhoods and sites. In Egypt, Saudi-influenced religious publishing and changing social norms pushed aside older cultural traditions. In Iran, the state shut universities during a Cultural Revolution and purged scholars and students.
Intellectuals resisted the narrowing. Egyptian scholar Nasr Abu Zeid argued that scripture should be interpreted in historical and linguistic context. His critics branded him an apostate; a court later ruled that his marriage to Ebtehal Younes should end, forcing the couple into exile. Secular intellectual Farag Foda was murdered in 1992 after publicly arguing for a civil state. These stories show that control over culture is not a decorative side issue. It determines which histories, ideas, and ways of living remain visible.
Culture functions here as civic infrastructure: it carries habits of coexistence, provides shared reference points, and preserves examples of lives different from those prescribed by authorities. Destroying a shrine, closing a cinema, or rewriting a textbook can therefore have political consequences beyond the immediate act. At the same time, cultural change is not always imposed from above; people adopt new practices for sincere reasons, status, safety, or community. A careful account must distinguish coercion from choice. The book’s strongest examples show how coercive institutions can make one choice safer and more visible while making alternatives harder to sustain.
After a state collapses, armed networks can outrun democratic institutions
Iraq’s opening became a vacuum. The 2003 US invasion removed Saddam Hussein but did not create trusted institutions able to govern the country. Saddam had already hollowed out civic life, and the post-invasion collapse of state authority left room for armed groups, rival Shia leaders, and foreign-backed networks. Shia cleric Abdulmajid al-Khoei returned hoping to encourage cooperation across communities, but he was murdered by fellow Shias days after Baghdad fell. His death showed that the end of dictatorship did not automatically produce political trust.
Sectarian violence hardened. Sunni insurgents and Shia militias competed for power. Abu Musab al-Zarqawi deliberately attacked Shias to provoke retaliation and widen the conflict. In 2006, the bombing of the Al-Askari shrine in Samarra triggered attacks on Sunni mosques and clerics. Journalist Atwar Bahjat, whose family crossed Sunni and Shia communities, was killed while reporting from her hometown. Her fate captures the cost of a conflict that made coexistence look like betrayal.
The transition from dictatorship is not just a change of leaders. It requires legitimate rules for security, representation, and dispute resolution. When those are missing, organizations that can protect, punish, or provide services gain a practical advantage over institutions still being built. That helps explain why electoral openings can coexist with militia power. Iraq’s story also cautions against treating sectarian violence as a direct expression of popular belief: political entrepreneurs actively tried to provoke communal retaliation. Yet foreign intervention and local agency both mattered, and neither single factor alone explains the collapse.
A reforming ruler is not pluralist if critics still disappear
Change came from above. Under Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Saudi Arabia introduced visible social changes, including permission for women to drive and a return of concerts and cinemas. Many Saudis welcomed freedoms long denied. But women who had campaigned for the right to drive were detained shortly before the ban was lifted, and critics of the crown prince faced pressure or imprisonment. Jamal Khashoggi, a Saudi journalist who had called for more openness, was murdered inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul in 2018.
Modernization is not accountability. The contrast is between expanding consumer and social options and allowing people to organize, criticize, and claim credit for change. The book also traces Iran’s efforts to build influence through allied armed groups and institutions in Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon, and Saudi Arabia’s efforts to counter that reach. Both governments present their policies as protection of the nation or the faith, while dissenters pay the price.
A ruler can liberalize selected parts of daily life while keeping political authority concentrated. That distinction matters because visible modernization is easy to photograph, whereas the ability to criticize power is harder to measure and more threatening to incumbents. Saudi social reforms met real needs and should not be dismissed as meaningless. But their durability depends partly on whether citizens can advocate for further changes without being punished. The same analytical standard applies across the rivalry: public services or religious solidarity do not substitute for accountability when the state’s decisions harm people beyond its borders.
Protect dissenters who keep alternatives visible before they are isolated
Resistance survived in people. Ghattas follows journalists, poets, clerics, lawyers, and women who challenged the closing of public life. Pakistan’s Mehtab Rashdi refused a government demand to cover her hair on television and left her job rather than comply. Iranian journalist Masih Alinejad helped women share images of themselves without the mandatory veil. In Syria, intellectual Yassin al-Haj Saleh continued documenting abuses even as his country was pulled between Assad, ISIS, and Iran-backed forces.
The alternatives were plural. These figures did not share one ideology or one program. Some were devout, some secular; some argued for reform, others for democratic change. Their common ground was refusal to let rulers or militant movements monopolize religion, identity, or national memory. The book ends not with an easy solution, but with continued protest, writing, music, and organizing across the region.
Dissenters matter not because they are flawless representatives of a population, but because they keep other futures imaginable. Their work can preserve language, evidence, and relationships that authoritarian politics tries to sever. Yet celebrating individual courage should not shift responsibility onto people taking enormous personal risks. Protection also requires institutions, independent media, legal safeguards, and public solidarity. The stories make hope concrete, but not automatic: the people resisting repression need more than admiration from afar. Their alternatives become politically consequential only when others can join them without facing the same isolation.
Analysis
Black Wave is a reported history organized around a striking proposition: the modern Middle East’s intensifying religious and sectarian politics cannot be explained as the inevitable return of ancient divisions. Ghattas locates a major acceleration in 1979, when the Iranian Revolution, the seizure of Mecca’s Holy Mosque, and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan created distinct crises that became connected through political competition. The book’s narrative method makes that connection legible by moving between countries and following lives across decades. A tape recorder in Lebanon, a television presenter in Pakistan, a scholar forced from Egypt, and a journalist murdered in Istanbul become evidence of how geopolitical contests enter domestic routines and personal choices.
Its strongest insight is the feedback loop between state power and religious movements. Governments empower clerics or militant networks for legitimacy, strategic advantage, or control, then discover that these actors have constituencies and ambitions of their own. Funding and doctrine matter, but so do local inequality, weak institutions, repression, and the search for belonging. This layered account avoids treating Saudi Arabia or Iran as omnipotent puppet masters, even while emphasizing their influence.
The approach also has limits that readers should keep in view. A sweeping, seven-country narrative naturally foregrounds the Saudi-Iran rivalry, and a vivid sequence of events can make causation feel more settled than the evidence warrants. The rivalry is a powerful organizing lens, not a complete explanation for every conflict or social change. Local leaders, Western interventions, class divisions, and older intellectual traditions retain independent importance. Ghattas’s central argument is most persuasive when read as a history of amplification: regional competition magnified existing grievances and narrowed cultural space, rather than creating every grievance from nothing. The book’s moral center is not nostalgia for a flawless past, but the record of people who kept pluralist possibilities alive even as political systems tried to erase them.
Review Summary
Black Wave offers a compelling analysis of the Middle East's transformation since 1979, focusing on the Saudi-Iran rivalry. Ghattas skillfully weaves personal stories with geopolitical events, examining how religious extremism and sectarian violence reshaped the region. Readers praise her clear writing, extensive research, and ability to explain complex issues. The book provides valuable insights into countries like Pakistan and Egypt, often overlooked in mainstream commentary. While some critics note biases in later chapters, most reviewers consider it an essential read for understanding the Middle East's recent history and current challenges.
People Also Read
Glossary
Black Wave
spread of cultural intoleranceGhattas’s metaphor for the widening influence of coercive, exclusionary religious politics across the Middle East after 1979. It describes more than militant violence: it includes changes in education, public culture, religious practice, and collective memory that made once-visible alternatives harder to sustain.
wilayat al-faqih
rule by a juristKhomeini’s doctrine that a qualified Islamic jurist should govern during the absence of the Hidden Imam. Traditionally, the concept had a limited role in Shia jurisprudence. Khomeini recast it as a political principle and used it to justify the Supreme Leader’s authority in the Islamic Republic of Iran.
sahwa
Islamic awakeningLiterally an awakening, the term refers in the book to the Saudi religious revival encouraged after the 1979 crisis. It combined religious conservatism with political activism, drawing on Saudi religious teaching and ideas associated with Muslim Brotherhood thinkers. The movement challenged the monarchy even though the state had initially encouraged religious revival.
hakimiyya
God’s sovereign ruleA political idea developed in modern Islamist thought, especially in the work of Abu A’la al-Mawdudi and later Sayyid Qutb. It holds that ultimate sovereignty belongs to God and that society and government should be ordered under divine law. In the book, the concept helps explain arguments for transforming both public institutions and private life.
fard ayn
individual religious dutyAn obligation that rests on each Muslim individually, rather than being fulfilled by the community on someone’s behalf. Abdallah Azzam applied this category to the Afghan jihad, arguing that Muslims had a personal duty to defend Muslim territory there. The claim helped encourage foreign volunteers to join the war against Soviet forces.
FAQ
What's Black Wave about?
- Exploration of Rivalry: Black Wave by Kim Ghattas examines the intense rivalry between Saudi Arabia and Iran over the past forty years, focusing on its impact on culture, religion, and collective memory in the Middle East.
- Cultural and Religious Impact: The book highlights how pivotal events like the Iranian Revolution and the siege of the Holy Mosque in Mecca in 1979 have led to significant cultural and religious shifts in the region.
- Personal Narratives: Ghattas weaves personal stories and interviews throughout the narrative, providing a human perspective on the political upheaval and allowing readers to connect emotionally with the historical events discussed.
Why should I read Black Wave?
- In-depth Historical Context: The book provides a comprehensive overview of pivotal events in Middle Eastern history, particularly focusing on the year 1979, which is crucial for understanding contemporary geopolitics.
- Unique Perspective: Ghattas offers insights often overlooked in mainstream narratives, particularly the voices of those who resist extremism, essential for grasping the complexities of the region.
- Cultural Relevance: The themes of cultural identity, sectarianism, and the struggle for power resonate beyond the Middle East, making it relevant to global discussions about religion and politics today.
What are the key takeaways of Black Wave?
- 1979 as a Turning Point: The book emphasizes that 1979 was a watershed moment that fundamentally altered the political landscape of the Middle East, marking the beginning of a new era of sectarian conflict and rivalry.
- Role of Religion in Politics: Ghattas illustrates how both Saudi Arabia and Iran have manipulated religious narratives to justify their political ambitions, leading to increased sectarian violence and cultural intolerance.
- The Silenced Majority: The author highlights the stories of progressive thinkers and activists who continue to fight against extremism, offering hope for a more pluralistic future in the Middle East.
How does Black Wave address the concept of sectarianism?
- Sectarian Identities Explored: The book discusses how the rivalry between Saudi Arabia and Iran has exacerbated sectarian identities, particularly between Sunni and Shia Muslims, leading to violence and conflict.
- Cultural Manipulation: Ghattas explains how both nations have used sectarian narratives to consolidate power and justify their actions, resulting in a culture of intolerance and fear.
- Historical Context: The author provides historical background on the Sunni-Shia split, tracing its roots back to early Islamic history, essential for understanding current dynamics and conflicts.
What role did the events of 1979 play in shaping modern Middle Eastern politics?
- Catalyst for Change: The events of 1979, including the Iranian Revolution and the siege of the Holy Mosque, acted as catalysts for significant political and social change in the region.
- Shift in Power Dynamics: The power dynamics in the Middle East shifted dramatically, with Iran emerging as a revolutionary state and Saudi Arabia reinforcing its conservative stance.
- Long-term Consequences: Ghattas argues that the legacy of 1979 continues to shape contemporary issues, including terrorism, sectarian violence, and the struggle for political legitimacy.
How does Black Wave depict the role of women in the context of these political changes?
- Women as Agents of Change: The book highlights the stories of women who have resisted oppressive regimes and fought for their rights amidst the turmoil.
- Impact of Extremism: Ghattas illustrates how the rise of extremism has disproportionately affected women, often stripping them of their rights and freedoms.
- Cultural Narratives: The author discusses how cultural narratives surrounding women have been manipulated by both Saudi and Iranian regimes to serve their political agendas.
What insights does Black Wave provide about the future of the Middle East?
- Hope Amidst Despair: Despite the grim realities presented, Ghattas emphasizes the resilience of progressive voices and movements in the region.
- Need for Understanding: The book argues that a deeper understanding of historical and cultural contexts is essential for addressing the challenges facing the Middle East today.
- Potential for Change: Ghattas suggests that ongoing struggles against extremism and authoritarianism may eventually lead to meaningful change.
How does Black Wave connect the events in the Middle East to global politics?
- Interconnectedness of Events: The book illustrates how local events in the Middle East have far-reaching implications for global politics, particularly in relation to terrorism and international relations.
- Role of External Powers: Ghattas discusses the involvement of external powers, including the United States and Russia, in shaping the dynamics of the region.
- Cultural Exchange: The author highlights how cultural exchanges and ideas flow between the Middle East and the West, influencing perceptions and policies.
What are the implications of the Saudi-Iran rivalry as discussed in Black Wave?
- Destabilizing Effects: The rivalry has had destabilizing effects on the entire region, leading to proxy wars and sectarian violence.
- Cultural and Religious Manipulation: Both nations have manipulated cultural and religious narratives to justify their actions and consolidate power.
- Future of Regional Alliances: The rivalry continues to shape regional alliances and conflicts, with countries often forced to choose sides.
How does Black Wave address the concept of cultural identity in the Middle East?
- Cultural Heritage Under Siege: The book discusses how cultural identities have been threatened by the rise of extremism and authoritarianism.
- Resistance and Resilience: Ghattas highlights the stories of individuals and groups who resist cultural impositions, advocating for a more inclusive understanding of identity.
- Historical Context: The author provides historical context for the cultural dynamics at play, tracing the roots of contemporary identities back to earlier periods in Islamic history.
What are the best quotes from Black Wave and what do they mean?
- “What happened to us?”: This recurring question reflects the collective despair and confusion felt across the Arab and Muslim world regarding their current state.
- “Where they make a wasteland, they call it peace.”: This quote by Tacitus critiques the notion that peace can be achieved through oppression.
- “Every day is Ashura, every land is Karbala.”: This phrase signifies the ongoing struggle against tyranny and injustice, drawing from the martyrdom of Imam Hussein.
How does Black Wave explore the cultural aspects of the rivalry?
- Literary Reflections: The book discusses how poets and writers have responded to the political climate, using their art to express resistance, despair, and hope.
- Artistic Movements: Ghattas highlights the role of cultural movements in shaping public opinion and identity, particularly in Lebanon and Iran.
- Media Influence: The narrative examines how media has been used as a tool for propaganda and shaping narratives around the rivalry.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.