Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Certain Women
Certain Women

Certain Women

A separated actress returns to her dying father’s boat, forcing her marriage toward a reckoning.
by Madeleine L'Engle 1992 368 pages
3.74
1k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

The Portia's Last Summer

Emma tends her dying father and unfinished marriage

At eighty-seven, actor David Wheaton2 is spending his final summer aboard the Portia, a working boat in the Pacific Northwest. His daughter1 Emma1 has left her theater season to help her stepmother4 Alice4 and Alice’s brother7 Ben7 care for him. Emma1 is separated from her playwright husband,3 Nik,3 and has removed her wedding rings, but cannot yet explain the break.

When she finds Nik’s abandoned play about the biblical King David among the boat’s charts, her father2 asks to see Nik3 before he dies. The old actor2 believes he has unfinished work with his family, while Emma1 fears that bringing Nik3 back will reopen their hurt. Around them, the sea offers space for farewells, not escape from them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The boat makes care tangible: Emma cooks, Alice manages pain, and Ben keeps the vessel moving while David’s body weakens. The family’s practical labor counters the theatrical glamour that has shaped their lives. Yet the unfinished play turns the Portia into more than a hospice setting. It holds an earlier version of Emma and Nik’s shared ambition, preserved beside navigational charts as if an abandoned future could still be found. David’s request begins the story’s present action, but it also forces Emma to face a marriage she has tried to treat as already over.

A Child Between Houses

Emma seeks a mother and finds rejection instead

Emma’s1 childhood is divided among adults whose needs repeatedly outrank hers. Her mother,19 Elizabeth,19 leaves her in the care of Emma’s grandmother,9 Bahama,9 while father2 David2 pursues his acting life. When David2 marries Edith, the new stepmother displaces Bahama9 and treats Emma1 as an inconvenience.

After Edith slaps Emma1 during a household crisis, Emma1 slaps her back, then uses the choice Adair11 offers to ask to live with Elizabeth.19 The reunion brings little comfort: Elizabeth19 houses her in a detached guest cottage and remains largely absent.

A drunken guest frightens Emma1 there, and the household servant helps her call home. Emma’s maternal grandfather,10 Wesley Bowman,10 welcomes her to Georgia, where his steady affection gives her a place to recover.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Emma learns early that a child can be wanted in theory and neglected in practice. Elizabeth’s failure is not presented as a single cruel act, but as an inability to make room for ordinary care; that distinction helps Emma later resist reducing people to villains. Edith’s slap makes the power imbalance visible, while Emma’s return blow is a first, imperfect assertion of agency. Wesley’s welcome matters because it does not require Emma to perform prettiness, gratitude, or talent. His home gives her a model of attachment that survives disappointment without pretending disappointment never happened.

Bahama's Wider Family

Sophie and school give Emma room to grow

After Edith leaves David,2 Emma1 returns to New York and finds a gentler home with Sophie,6 David’s next wife.6 Sophie6 welcomes Bahama,9 befriends Marical17 and her children, and makes room for Emma’s younger half-brother18 Louis.18 Emma1 grows up among siblings who encourage her acting, music, and studies, even as David’s2 changing marriages keep the family complicated.

Bahama9 later sends Emma1 to boarding school while she seeks rest in Seattle; Emma1 resists, then flourishes in classes and school productions. At college she studies widely and becomes more certain of the classical stage. Bahama’s9 death in Emma’s1 sophomore year brings the far-flung family together for a funeral, leaving Emma1 to carry forward the many forms of love that raised her.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Sophie does not erase Emma’s earlier abandonment; she makes a different household possible. Her generosity is practical, expressed through meals, celebrations, and the daily inclusion of children who might otherwise have been separated by their parents’ histories. Bahama’s decision to send Emma away is painful precisely because it is loving: she recognizes that Emma needs a life beyond the family’s orbit. School gives Emma a protected arena to develop skill before public judgment resumes. The resulting identity is not simply inherited from David. Emma’s craft grows from discipline, study, and the steady attention of people who saw her as more than an actress.

Nik Finds His Abigail

A slow audition becomes love and collaboration

Back in New York, Emma1 struggles to secure mature roles after years away from professional theater. Playwright Niklaas Green3 first overlooks her at an audition, then replaces an actress who cannot develop the part and gives Emma1 the time she needs. Her performance deepens his comedy, and their dinners soon become a courtship.

Nik3 begins a serious play about King David for Emma’s father,2 asking Emma1 to help him understand the biblical wives and family. David’s2 theatrical career and many marriages make the subject feel intimate, while Emma’s1 knowledge of scripture gives Nik3 material he lacks. As they work, Emma1 falls in love with Nik3 and comes to believe that he values her judgment and presence, not merely her famous father’s2 access.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The romance grows through shared attention rather than instant recognition. Nik’s first mistake at the audition mirrors a recurring tension in the novel: people are often more than they reveal at first glance, and understanding requires sustained looking. Emma’s acting method, which depends on time and inward identification, becomes the basis of her partnership with a writer who wants to make old stories emotionally legible. Their play also creates a risky intimacy. David’s marriages are not just a subject for research; they offer both lovers a framework for interpreting their own families, a framework that can illuminate them but also tempt them to confuse analogy with fate.

The Door Billy Opened

A brother's assault shatters Emma's sense of safety

When Emma’s half-brother12 Billy12 claims to be ill, she goes to his apartment with medicine, only to discover that no prescription exists. Billy12 has arranged the visit because he wants Emma1 alone; he assaults her and then humiliates her as she tries to leave. Chantal13 and Adair11 reach Emma1 afterward, and Sophie6 takes her to hospital, where the examination compounds her sense of being treated as a body rather than a person.

Emma1 resists involving the police, while David2 and the family argue over how to deal with Billy.12 Soon afterward, Billy12 falls beneath a subway train during a rush-hour encounter with Adair.11 His death does not undo the assault, and Emma1 leaves for Georgia to confront her anger with Wesley’s10 help.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The assault ruptures trust at its most intimate point: Billy is not a stranger but a brother embedded in Emma’s already fractured family. The novel refuses the comforting fiction that kinship makes a person safe, or that Billy’s death settles what he did. Emma’s refusal to report him reflects terror and a need to regain control, not consent or weakness. The family’s inability to find a response that repairs the harm exposes the difference between protecting reputation and protecting a survivor. Wesley’s insistence that Emma name her anger helps distinguish justified anger from self-blame, a distinction she will need in later relationships.

The Wedding After Tamar

Emma tells Nik the truth before marrying him

As Nik’s biblical play reaches the story of Tamar, Emma1 recognizes its resemblance to her own assault and fears what Nik3 will make of the parallel. On the night Nik3 proposes, she tells him what Billy12 did.

Nik3 listens, understands that the resemblance does not dictate their future, and remains committed to her. Emma1 accepts his proposal, and they marry in a small chapel at the Cathedral, with Wesley10 officiating and their scattered family gathered around them.

Their wedding night is tender, but Emma’s1 recovery is gradual: Nik’s3 patience helps her reclaim intimacy without pretending the past has vanished. In the years that follow, they build a life around theater and writing, while the David play continues to bring their families’ wounds into their work.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Emma’s disclosure is a decisive act of authorship. Rather than letting a biblical plot silently define her, she tells Nik where the comparison breaks down and gives him the chance to respond to the actual woman before him. His choice to stay does not cure her trauma; their marriage becomes a context in which trust can be practiced again. The chapel wedding joins several inheritances without making them identical: Wesley’s Baptist faith, Bahama’s Episcopalian habits, and Nik’s divided religious background all remain present. The scene turns commitment into an informed risk, not a guarantee that either spouse will be free of fear or failure.

War Empties the Table

Deaths deepen David's grief and stall Nik's play

The war takes Emma’s brothers15 Etienne15 and Adair,11 whose deaths arrive in separate telegrams within an hour. David2 retreats into grief, and Emma1 returns from tour to sit with him until he can respond.

Earlier family loss has already unsettled them: Billy12 is dead, and Edith and Inez22 are later killed in a train explosion. Nik,3 meanwhile, cannot finish the King David play once it reaches the violence between Tamar, Amnon, and Absalom. Emma1 and Nik3 grieve differently, and the unfinished script becomes a shared absence rather than a project that draws them together.

Nik3 turns to a comic antiwar play based on Everard’s16 hospital experience, but audiences are not ready for it, and its failure adds to Nik’s3 fear that his serious work will never succeed.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Loss accumulates unevenly. The war’s telegrams are abrupt, while David’s grief is prolonged and private, creating a household where no one can assume another person is suffering in the same way. Nik’s abandoned play echoes that difficulty: he can imagine tragic material, but cannot yet shape it without injuring Emma or himself. His turn to comedy is both an artistic refuge and a moral choice, since he wants to expose war without exploiting the people living through it. The family’s table, repeatedly assembled by Sophie, becomes an image of care under conditions that cannot be repaired by gathering alone.

A Small Life Lost

Miscarriage and distance wound the marriage

After five years of marriage, Emma1 becomes pregnant, and she and Nik3 begin imagining a family. A winter fall outside the theater triggers premature labor, and their baby, whom they planned to name Wesley, is stillborn. Nik3 cannot bear his grief directly; he turns it into anger and visits Emma1 briefly in hospital, leaving her to mourn without the comfort she needs.

Sophie6 asks Emma1 to forgive him, but Emma1 feels abandoned. During a later visit to the Portia, Emma1 and Ben,7 Alice’s brother,7 sleep together while Emma1 is grieving and believes Nik3 is involved with another actress. She later recognizes the encounter as a betrayal that also hurt Ben.7 The couple remain married, but their losses have made honesty and closeness harder to sustain.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The miscarriage brings the novel’s central problem into the body: grief cannot be argued away, and love does not ensure that two people can grieve in sync. Nik’s anger shields him from helplessness, but its cost falls on Emma at precisely the moment she needs companionship. Emma’s encounter with Ben is neither romantic rescue nor simple moral failure; it is an attempt to feel wanted when her marriage has gone emotionally cold. Her later self-reproach shows how readily she inherits David’s habit of treating desire as both answer and injury. The scene complicates blame without making consequences disappear.

The Marriage Splits

Failure and old wounds drive Emma from Nik

Nik’s3 plays fail one after another, and each setback revives his fear that he has disappointed his parents and will never become the writer he hopes to be. Emma1 supports his work, but their arguments sharpen when he accuses her of depending too much on David2 and of misunderstanding fidelity.

Emma1 also fails to notice how much her father2 has weakened during his final production of King Lear, until her brother18 Louis18 and the actress Regan point it out. When Emma1 and Nik’s3 conflict finally makes living together unbearable, she leaves.

The separation is recent when David’s2 cancer worsens, and Emma1 comes west without her rings, unsure whether she wants reconciliation. David’s2 illness now forces her to see both Nik3 and her father2 without the distance she had used to contain them.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The marriage does not break from a single betrayal. Professional disappointment, unresolved trauma, grief, and mutual defensiveness accumulate until both partners begin using old family patterns as weapons. Nik’s accusations about Emma’s father strike at the person who has shaped her vocation and sense of belonging; Emma’s response is withdrawal rather than repair. Her failure to notice David’s decline extends the same self-protection beyond the marriage. The present crisis therefore does not simply reunite old lovers. It exposes the cost of narrowing attention to one’s own pain, while refusing the easy judgment that either spouse alone caused the separation.

The Family Comes Aboard

Nik and David face unfinished pain together

Emma1 calls Nik3 from Port Clements, and he flies west with Jarvis,14 David’s eldest surviving son14 and a producer who instinctively tries to manage events. Jarvis14 resents being called after Nik3 and clashes with Alice4 over David’s2 care, but Alice4 insists that David2 remain on the boat he loves. Nik3 meets David,2 apologizes for the cruelty he showed Emma,1 and announces a new version of the King David play, told through the women rather than the king.

Sophie6 and Louis18 arrive later, and their presence makes the boat crowded with farewells. Emma1 sees how Jarvis14 stages grief to avoid collapsing, while Sophie6 and Nik3 acknowledge their own habits of choosing withdrawal. The family visits David2 in turns, following Alice’s4 judgment about his strength.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The gathering makes private grief social, with all the friction that entails. Jarvis’s urge to organize the deathbed is not merely vanity; production is the language he knows for keeping chaos at a manageable distance. Alice counters him with clinical judgment and respect for David’s wishes, refusing to let familial status outrank the patient’s needs. Nik’s revised play is an artistic act of listening: he removes the king from the center and gives the women their own perspective. That change also signals a possible change in the marriage, though Emma does not mistake a promising gesture for a completed reconciliation.

Emma Chooses the Wedding

A suspected pregnancy gives their return new stakes

After Jarvis,14 Sophie,6 Louis,18 and Abby5 have said their farewells, Emma1 and Nik3 take a small boat away from the Portia to decide whether they can begin again. Emma1 recognizes that returning cannot mean asking Nik3 to become a version of her father2 or expecting him to heal every wound.

She agrees to return to her husband,3 while asking him not to abandon her when his own despair rises. Alice4 then suspects Emma1 is pregnant, a possibility Emma1 accepts with astonished hope after believing she would not conceive again.

Emma1 tells Nik3 before they leave. David2 receives the news with joy, though he knows he will not meet the child. Emma1 and Nik3 depart, leaving David2 with Alice4 and Ben.7 As they head away, Norma’s8 boat approaches the Portia, answering her earlier promise to see David2 again.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The ending offers commitment, not cure. Emma’s choice is meaningful because it is made before she knows she may be pregnant; the child cannot serve as a reason to resume a marriage she has not chosen for itself. Her promise to return also differs from passive endurance: she asks for reciprocal effort and accepts that both partners will remain imperfect. David’s joy links a possible future generation to the family he has spent the summer reviewing, while his absence from the child’s life remains an irreparable limit. Norma’s arrival leaves her promise open to spiritual interpretation without turning death into a plot trick.

Analysis

Certain Women follows Emma Wheaton1 through a family whose many marriages and many forms of loss resist a tidy moral accounting. The biblical David story supplies a pattern, but the novel repeatedly questions the comfort of patterns: resemblance does not mean repetition, and an ancient plot cannot decide what Emma1 must do. Nik's play changes from an attempted portrait of a king into a way of attending to the women around him. That artistic shift matters because the novel’s central struggle is about who gets to interpret pain. David2 often converts private failures into roles; Nik3 converts them into scripts; Emma’s1 development depends on making her own account rather than inhabiting someone else’s analogy.

The book also separates forgiveness from forgetting and explanation from exoneration. Emma1 can recognize that Billy12 was insecure without minimizing his violence. She can love David2 while naming the harm caused by his choices. She can acknowledge her own betrayal of Nik3 without treating it as proof that she deserves neglect. Such distinctions make the novel’s ethics more demanding than simple reconciliation. Forgiveness is not a reset button. It is a way to remember without allowing injury to dictate every future relation.

Theater offers both insight and danger. Performance lets David2 and Emma1 reach truths that ordinary conversation cannot, yet the family’s habit of turning life into roles can obscure actual needs. Alice’s4 medical care, Ben’s7 labor, Sophie’s6 meals, and Emma’s1 cooking provide a quieter counterpoint: love appears not only as passion or declaration, but as competent attention. The ending does not claim that marriage, faith, or a possible child will heal the family. Emma1 chooses to return to Nik3 before knowing she may be pregnant, and she leaves David2 alive in Alice’s4 care. Hope is therefore a practiced decision, not a promise of a painless outcome.

Summary in 60 Seconds
Emma Wheaton leaves her acting career to care for her dying father aboard his boat while separated from playwright Nik. Her unstable childhood, shaped by divided parents and shifting homes, has taught her to endure rather than speak. After her half-brother Billy assaults her, she confides in Nik, and they marry, but grief over wartime deaths, a stillborn child, and Nik’s emotional withdrawal drive them apart. Emma also betrays Nik with Ben, deepening their estrangement. When her father’s cancer worsens, Nik joins the family, apologizes, and reworks his biblical play to center the women it previously overlooked. Emma and Nik decide to reunite, accepting that forgiveness cannot erase harm. Emma may be pregnant again, and her father welcomes the news before remaining aboard with Alice.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

3.74 out of 5
Average of 1k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Certain Women by Madeleine L'Engle received mixed reviews. Many readers appreciated the complex narrative structure, parallels to King David's story, and L'Engle's exploration of family dynamics and spirituality. Some found the characters well-developed and relatable, while others felt they lacked depth. The book's pacing and heavy-handed religious themes were criticized by some. Fans of L'Engle's young adult works had varying reactions to this adult novel. Overall, reviewers found it thought-provoking but not without flaws.

Your rating:
4.68
122 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Emma Wheaton

Actress seeking wholeness

Emma is David Wheaton’s2 daughter, an actor whose careful, patient approach to roles reflects her desire to understand people before judging them. Raised across a shifting network of parents, stepparents, siblings, and grandparents, she knows both the security of devoted care and the pain of being unwanted. Her vocation gives her a disciplined way to enter other lives, but it can also become a refuge from her own. Emma wants love without surrendering her independence, and she is wary of turning suffering into a fixed identity. Her deepest strength is not invulnerability; it is her ability to reconsider what she believes about herself and others, even when doing so requires admitting her own failures.

David Wheaton

Brilliant, flawed patriarch

David is an acclaimed actor, Emma’s father1, and a man whose charm and appetite for life have shaped a large, complicated family. He approaches roles with artistic rigor but has often treated real relationships as though desire could substitute for responsibility. His children love him, yet they have also had to live with the consequences of his serial marriages and emotional retreats. David is capable of unusual tenderness and self-criticism, though insight does not always arrive before the damage. His identification with the biblical King David lets him examine ambition, faith, love, and regret through a story he admires. Acting remains his clearest means of transforming pain into something others can recognize.

Niklaas Green

Playwright torn between ambition and love

Nik is Emma’s husband1, a playwright whose comic instinct is matched by a serious hunger to make work that will be remembered. An only child raised by intensely involved parents, he carries a complicated need to become independent of their expectations. He studies people closely for his writing, yet can be less attentive to the person beside him when professional failure awakens his insecurity. Emma’s1 family gives him a community he has long lacked, while their histories also make him feel like an outsider. His artistic imagination is most generous when he listens, but he must learn that empathy for fictional characters does not automatically translate into care for the living.

Alice Wheaton

Doctor and steady companion

Alice is David’s wife2, a physician trained far from the isolated Pacific Northwest where she grew up with her brother Ben7. Her practical competence makes her the family’s medical anchor, but her authority is rooted in more than expertise: she respects people’s choices and can remain calm without becoming detached. Alice knows what it is to be treated as an object rather than a person, and she has built a strong sense of self through work, solitude, and love. She is generous toward Emma1 without trying to replace her mother19, and she treats David2 as both patient and husband. Her bond with the sea and island community gives the novel a model of belonging not dependent on fame.

Abby Wheaton

Artist and forgiving friend

Abby is David’s second wife2 and Emma’s godmother1. Once a teacher, she later becomes a painter, developing an independent life that does not erase her deep affection for David2. Her history with him includes great love and painful separation, but she does not reduce either of them to their worst moments. Abby’s dignity is quiet rather than remote; she can welcome Alice4 while acknowledging the unusual emotional history they share. She offers Emma1 perspective without giving easy answers, especially about grief, forgiveness, and the limits of what love can mend. Her travels between France and North America make her a bridge between the family’s past and the lives its members have built apart.

Sophie Wheaton

The family's generous maker

Sophie is one of David’s wives2 and a warm stepmother to Emma1. She creates family through food, humor, celebrations, and a gift for welcoming children who might otherwise be divided by old grievances. Her ease with affection contrasts with David’s2 more turbulent emotional life, though she is not immune to its costs. Sophie loves openly and believes that ordinary acts of care can hold a household together. She is also protective, particularly of Louis18, and sometimes leaves painful subjects unspoken to spare those she loves. Her generosity is genuine, but her story shows that even a person who gives freely has limits.

Ben Hightree

Boatman rooted in home

Ben is Alice’s younger brother4, a capable fisherman and the practical keeper of the Portia. A damaged leg has not diminished his competence on the water, and his life remains deeply connected to the islands where he and Alice4 grew up. He is unassuming, observant, and generous with Emma1, offering friendship without demanding that she make him the center of her life. Ben’s solitude is a chosen fit with his landscape, not a sign that he lacks affection. His presence helps make David’s2 final summer possible, and his quiet care often speaks more clearly than the family’s elaborate explanations.

Norma Hightree

Wise friend from the islands

Norma is a respected Indigenous woman from a coastal village and a longtime friend of David2 and Emma1. Tall, composed, and direct, she is treated as a person of authority in her community rather than as a symbol of local color. She understands suffering without sentimentalizing it, and she offers care through decisive, embodied gestures. Norma’s relationship with Emma1 is based on trust earned across years, not on a single crisis. Her presence connects the family’s theatrical, urban world to a community shaped by the land and sea, while her spiritual confidence remains distinct from David’s2 and Wesley’s10 forms of faith.

Bahama

Emma's first true mother

Bahama is Emma’s paternal grandmother1 and the person who gives her consistent affection from infancy onward. Large-hearted and practical, she shields Emma1 without encouraging her to mistake protection for a life of her own. She supports Emma’s1 acting while valuing study, friendship, and ordinary responsibilities. Bahama’s Episcopalian faith differs from Wesley Bowman’s10 preaching, but she shares his capacity for loyalty and forgiveness. Her influence is present long after Emma1 loses her, especially in Emma’s1 instinct to honor promises and keep people connected.

Wesley Bowman

Preacher and moral provocateur

Wesley is Emma’s maternal grandfather1, a self-educated Georgia preacher with a theatrical voice and a restless mind. He teaches through scripture, argument, humor, and questions that unsettle his own certainty. Wesley gives Emma1 a secure home when she feels rejected, and his sermons help her see biblical figures as flawed human beings rather than distant moral emblems. His faith is passionate but not tidy; he can be stubborn, proud, and tender in the same conversation. Emma1 inherits from him an interest in the moral complexity beneath religious stories.

Adair

Emma's beloved protector

Adair is one of Emma’s older half-brothers1, admired for his beauty, musicality, intelligence, and easy confidence. He gives Emma1 advice without treating her as fragile and is among the people who encourage her to understand her own choices. His affection is protective but not possessive, and his presence gives Emma1 a sense of safety within a family whose branches do not always join easily. Adair’s own loyalty to the family can make him forceful, yet he also knows the limits of what he can control.

Billy

Insecure older half-brother

Billy is David’s son2 with Myrlo20 and Emma’s older half-brother1. He is handsome and ambitious, but less perceptive than many of his siblings and painfully aware of their gifts and connections. His desire for recognition leaves him vulnerable to status and outside approval, particularly from the wealthy world around his mother20. The family’s mixed feelings about him are sharpened by his distance from his siblings. He is not easily understood, and the novel asks readers to distinguish explanation from excuse.

Chantal

Clear-eyed older sister

Chantal is Emma’s half-sister1, a talented violinist whose striking beauty can obscure her independent judgment. She is emotionally perceptive and willing to say what Emma1 is avoiding, especially when silence begins to harden into fear. Chantal’s life is not organized around the Wheaton family; her work, marriage, and home give her a separate center. She remains close to Emma1 without demanding constant proximity, and her advice often combines tenderness with a sharp understanding of self-protection.

Jarvis

Ambitious producer and brother

Jarvis is David’s son2 with Harriet21, Emma’s half-brother1, and a successful theatrical producer. He is shrewd about careers and skilled at arranging the practical details that others leave undone. That talent can become a need to manage people as well as productions. Jarvis wants recognition and values proximity to influence, but he also loves his family more deeply than he readily admits. His briskness often conceals anxiety, and his instinct to stage events is one way he keeps difficult feelings at a distance.

Etienne

Theater-minded older brother

Etienne is Emma’s older half-brother1, a skilled stage manager who knows the mechanics and mishaps of theater life. He is affectionate without fuss and can bring humor to tense family gatherings. His practical intelligence complements the more flamboyant personalities around him, and he often understands how an artistic ambition depends on teamwork behind the scenes. Emma1 sees in him a trusted sibling and a companion in the family’s shared theatrical world.

Everard

Conscientious brother and medic

Everard is one of Emma’s half-brothers1, a thoughtful man whose service in an army hospital reflects his conscientious convictions. He is gentle and intellectually curious, willing to revise his explanations when someone points out what they leave out. In conversations about violence, his impulse to make events comprehensible can collide with the need to name responsibility. He offers Emma1 care without claiming to fully understand her experience.

Marical

Elegant mother of many siblings

Marical is Emma’s stepmother1 and the mother of several of David’s children2. A former model, she has poise and beauty, but her deeper strength lies in her capacity to maintain loving relationships across a complicated family. She is not endlessly forgiving, and her boundaries shape the family’s history as much as David’s2 choices do. Marical helps Emma1 understand that a person can love someone and still refuse the terms on which that person wants to live.

Louis

Youngest sibling and actor

Louis is Emma’s much younger half-brother1, raised by Sophie6 and David2. A singer who grows into acting, he is affectionate and open about admiring his family. Sophie’s6 efforts to protect him from adult grief shape his early image of David2, while Emma1 helps him understand that a parent can be loving and vulnerable at once. Louis’s warmth makes him a source of hope without turning him into a cure for the family’s pain.

Elizabeth

Emma's distant mother

Elizabeth is Emma’s mother1, a successful film actress who has little confidence in her capacity to parent. She is not portrayed as a monster so much as a woman whose ambitions and emotional limitations leave her daughter1 without ordinary maternal warmth. Emma1 learns to respect Elizabeth’s acting without expecting her to become someone she cannot be.

Myrlo

David's difficult third wife

Myrlo is David’s third wife2 and Billy’s mother12. She is socially ambitious and focused on security, possessions, and appearance, but she also comes from a background that has left her hungry to make something of herself. Emma1 finds her hard to forgive, while David2 sees in her a reflection of his own capacity for selfishness. Myrlo’s presence reveals how sharply family members can disagree about the same person.

Harriet

Ballerina and Jarvis's mother

Harriet is a celebrated ballerina and Jarvis’s mother14. Her marriage to David2 is brief, but she remains gracious toward his other children and maintains her own life in dance. She represents a world of discipline and physical artistry that differs from David’s2 theater, without being reduced to her former relationship with him.

Inez

Young half-sister seeking family

Inez is Emma’s younger half-sister1, the daughter of David2 and Edith. Although her mother keeps her apart from the wider family, Inez is determined to know her siblings. Her persistence makes her a small but telling presence in a family shaped by separation and divided loyalties.

Plot Devices

Nik's King David play

Mirror for family wounds

Nik’s unfinished play gives the characters a shared language for discussing love, ambition, faith, marriage, and betrayal. Its biblical household resembles David Wheaton’s2 sprawling family closely enough to invite comparison, but not closely enough to make anyone’s future predetermined. Emma1 contributes her knowledge of scripture and acting; David2 sees his own life in the ancient king; Nik3 uses the women’s perspectives to rethink the play. The manuscript, stored among the Portia's charts, returns in the present and helps draw Nik3 back into Emma’s1 life. As the script changes, so does the way its characters interpret their own histories.

The Portia

A moving house of care

The Portia is the boat where the present-day action unfolds and where David2 spends his final summer. Its narrow bunks and working galley require Emma1, Alice4, Ben7, Abby5, and visiting family members to negotiate closeness in practical ways. The boat’s movement through isolated inlets gives the family privacy, while docks and radio calls bring the outside world back in. It is neither a hospital nor a stage, though both forms of care and performance hover around it. The Portia makes the story’s questions physical: who tends the sick, who is allowed aboard, and how a family shares limited space when time is short.

Theatrical roles

Practice for seeing others

Acting is Emma’s1 vocation and the family’s common inheritance. Rehearsals teach her to enter characters slowly, while David’s2 performances transform experiences he cannot always face directly in private. Nik’s3 scripts turn family history into material, and Jarvis’s14 producing offers a more managerial relationship to the stage. The theater can deepen understanding, as when Emma1 and David2 work together, but it can also shelter artists from ordinary obligations. The characters repeatedly ask whether a role reveals the self or hides it. Their lives answer that both can be true, depending on whether the artist listens to people beyond the audience.

The crossroads

Choice after catastrophe

The image of a crossroads comes from Norma’s8 account of a life-changing decision and returns as Emma1 and the family face grief, separation, and the prospect of David’s2 death. It does not promise that choosing life will erase pain. Instead, it names the point at which survival must become an active choice: to risk attachment again, to let others remain imperfect, or to retreat into bitterness. The recurring image links Emma’s1 recovery from trauma with her later decision about Nik3, while allowing different characters to understand the choice in their own ways.

FAQ

Synopsis & Basic Details

What is Certain Women about?

  • A Dying Actor's Reflection: The novel centers on David Wheaton, an aging actor, as he spends his final summer on his boat, the Portia, reflecting on his life, career, and complex relationships with his many wives and children.
  • Family Dynamics and Legacies: The story explores the intricate dynamics within David's family, particularly his relationship with his daughter Emma, and how his past choices have shaped their lives.
  • Unfinished Creative Work: A key element is the unfinished play about King David by Emma's estranged husband, Nik, which mirrors David's own life and becomes a catalyst for reflection and reconciliation.

Why should I read Certain Women?

  • Complex Character Studies: The novel offers deep dives into the psyches of its characters, exploring their motivations, regrets, and desires with nuance and empathy.
  • Exploration of Relationships: It provides a rich tapestry of human connections, examining the complexities of love, marriage, family, and friendship with honesty and insight.
  • Thought-Provoking Themes: The book tackles profound themes of mortality, legacy, forgiveness, and the search for meaning, prompting readers to contemplate their own lives and relationships.

What is the background of Certain Women?

  • Biblical Allusions: The story is heavily influenced by the biblical narrative of King David, drawing parallels between his life and David Wheaton's, particularly in their relationships with women and their struggles with power and faith.
  • Theatrical World: The novel is set against the backdrop of the theater world, with many characters involved in acting, writing, and production, which shapes their perspectives and experiences.
  • Pacific Northwest Setting: The story unfolds in the Pacific Northwest, with the natural beauty of the region serving as a backdrop for the characters' emotional journeys and providing a sense of solace and reflection.

What are the most memorable quotes in Certain Women?

  • "You have more than a slingshot, David. You have your entire life.": This quote, spoken by Norma, encapsulates the theme of finding strength and meaning in one's life experiences, even in the face of death.
  • "We cut through what we do to who we are.": This line, spoken by David, highlights the novel's focus on the essential human qualities that transcend roles and professions, emphasizing the importance of genuine connection.
  • "Passion alone isn't enough. There has to be the gift.": This quote, spoken by Emma, reflects the novel's exploration of the nature of talent and the dedication required to pursue one's calling, a theme central to both Emma's and her father's lives.

What writing style, narrative choices, and literary techniques does Madeleine L'Engle use?

  • Introspective and Reflective: L'Engle employs a narrative style that delves deeply into the characters' thoughts and feelings, often using internal monologues and flashbacks to reveal their inner lives.
  • Interweaving of Themes: She skillfully interweaves multiple themes, such as love, loss, faith, and art, creating a rich and layered narrative that resonates on multiple levels.
  • Use of Symbolism and Metaphor: L'Engle uses recurring symbols, such as the Portia and the King David play, to represent larger ideas and themes, adding depth and complexity to the story.

Hidden Details & Subtle Connections

What are some minor details that add significant meaning?

  • The Painted Eyes on Fishing Boats: The detail of black eyes painted on the prows of fishing boats foreshadows the theme of seeing and being seen, and the characters' struggles with self-perception and how they are perceived by others.
  • The Red Raspberry Sherberts: The recurring mention of the red raspberry sherberts in the English drawing-room comedy highlights the theme of memory and the way seemingly insignificant details can hold deep emotional resonance.
  • The Names of David's Wives: The careful listing and discussion of King David's wives, and their individual stories, foreshadows the complex relationships and emotional entanglements that define David Wheaton's life.

What are some subtle foreshadowing and callbacks?

  • David's Longing for King David Role: David's repeated lament about never playing King David foreshadows his own life's parallels with the biblical figure, and the themes of legacy and unfulfilled potential.
  • Emma's Missing Rings: Emma's removal of her wedding rings early in the story foreshadows the breakdown of her marriage with Nik and her emotional journey toward independence.
  • The Mention of the "M'aidez!" Calls: The repeated radio calls of "M'aidez!" foreshadow the characters' own cries for help, both literal and metaphorical, as they grapple with their personal struggles.

What are some unexpected character connections?

  • Abby and Bahama's Friendship: The deep bond between Abby, David's second wife, and Bahama, David's mother, reveals a hidden layer of connection and support within the family, transcending the usual stepmother-stepdaughter dynamic.
  • Nik and Grandpa Bowman's Shared Interest in God: The unexpected connection between Nik, a half-Dutch Catholic and half-Russian Jew, and Grandpa Bowman, a Georgia preacher, highlights the novel's exploration of faith and spirituality beyond traditional boundaries.
  • Sophie and Marical's Friendship: The friendship between Sophie, David's current wife, and Marical, one of his ex-wives, challenges conventional notions of rivalry and demonstrates the possibility of genuine connection between women in complex family situations.

Who are the most significant supporting characters?

  • Norma Hightree: Norma, a Haida Indian woman, serves as a spiritual guide and a source of wisdom for David and Emma, offering a perspective that transcends the confines of their theatrical world.
  • Ben: Ben, Alice's brother, is a steady presence on the Portia, providing practical support and a sense of groundedness, and his quiet strength and loyalty are essential to the story.
  • Sophie: Sophie, David's current wife, is a source of warmth and love, creating a sense of family and stability amidst the chaos of David's past, and her generosity and compassion are a counterpoint to the more troubled characters.

Psychological, Emotional, & Relational Analysis

What are some unspoken motivations of the characters?

  • David's Need for Validation: David's constant references to his acting career and his desire to play King David reveal an underlying need for validation and recognition, stemming from his insecurities about his personal life.
  • Emma's Fear of Vulnerability: Emma's initial reluctance to discuss her marriage with Nik and her removal of her wedding rings suggest a deep-seated fear of vulnerability and a desire to protect herself from further emotional pain.
  • Nik's Struggle with Self-Worth: Nik's intense focus on his writing and his desire for recognition reveal an underlying struggle with self-worth and a need to prove himself, stemming from his complex relationship with his parents.

What psychological complexities do the characters exhibit?

  • David's Cycle of Self-Destruction: David's pattern of marrying and divorcing, and his tendency to seek validation through external sources, reveal a deep-seated cycle of self-destruction and a struggle with his own identity.
  • Emma's Internal Conflict: Emma's internal conflict between her desire for independence and her need for connection, and her struggle to reconcile her love for her father with his flaws, highlight her psychological complexity.
  • Nik's Creative Obsession: Nik's obsessive focus on his writing, his tendency to become consumed by his work, and his difficulty in balancing his creative life with his personal relationships reveal a complex and often self-destructive personality.

What are the major emotional turning points?

  • David's Confession of His Wives: David's decision to openly discuss his past marriages with Emma marks a turning point in his emotional journey, as he begins to confront his past mistakes and seek forgiveness.
  • Emma's Decision to Call Nik: Emma's decision to call Nik after her father asks to see him represents a significant emotional shift, as she begins to confront her feelings for her estranged husband and consider the possibility of reconciliation.
  • The Arrival of Abby: Abby's arrival on the Portia serves as a major emotional turning point, bringing a sense of peace and closure to David and offering Emma a much-needed source of support and guidance.

How do relationship dynamics evolve?

  • Emma and David's Evolving Bond: The relationship between Emma and David evolves from a complex mix of love and resentment to a deeper understanding and acceptance, as they share memories and confront their shared history.
  • Emma and Nik's Reconciliation: The relationship between Emma and Nik evolves from estrangement and unresolved conflict to a tentative reconciliation, as they begin to confront their past mistakes and consider the possibility of a future together.
  • Alice and David's Quiet Strength: The relationship between Alice and David is characterized by a quiet strength and mutual respect, as they navigate the challenges of his illness and prepare for his death, and their bond serves as a model of mature love and acceptance.

Interpretation & Debate

Which parts of the story remain ambiguous or open-ended?

  • The Nature of David's "Darkness": The exact nature of David's "darkness" and the reasons behind his self-destructive behavior remain somewhat ambiguous, leaving readers to interpret his motivations and struggles.
  • The Future of Emma and Nik's Relationship: The ending of the novel leaves the future of Emma and Nik's relationship open-ended, suggesting the possibility of reconciliation but not guaranteeing a happily-ever-after.
  • The Meaning of Norma's Prophecy: The meaning of Norma's statement that she will see David again remains ambiguous, leaving readers to ponder the nature of life, death, and the possibility of spiritual connection.

What are some debatable, controversial scenes or moments in Certain Women?

  • David's Treatment of His Wives: David's treatment of his wives, particularly his tendency to move from one relationship to another, raises questions about his morality and his capacity for genuine love and commitment.
  • The Portrayal of Myrlo: The portrayal of Myrlo, David's third wife, as a shallow and materialistic woman, raises questions about the novel's treatment of female characters and its potential for perpetuating stereotypes.
  • The Justification of David's Actions: The novel's exploration of David's actions, particularly his role in Uriah's death, raises questions about the nature of sin, forgiveness, and the extent to which one can be redeemed.

Certain Women Ending Explained: How It Ends & What It Means

  • Open-Ended Resolution: The ending of "Certain Women" is not a neat resolution, but rather an open-ended exploration of life's complexities, with the characters facing an uncertain future.
  • Acceptance of Imperfection: The ending emphasizes the importance of accepting human imperfection, both in oneself and in others, and the need to find meaning and connection despite life's challenges.
  • Hope for New Beginnings: While the novel acknowledges the pain of loss and the difficulties of relationships, it also offers a glimmer of hope for new beginnings, suggesting that even in the face of death, life continues, and love endures.

About the Author

Madeleine L'Engle was an American author best known for her young adult fiction, particularly the Newbery Medal-winning "A Wrinkle in Time" and its sequels. She also wrote adult fiction, non-fiction, and poetry. L'Engle's works often blended science, faith, and fantasy, reflecting her Christian beliefs and interest in modern science. Her writing explored themes of family, spirituality, and the nature of good and evil. L'Engle was associated with New York's Cathedral of St. John the Divine and incorporated her experiences there into some of her works. Her unique style and ability to tackle complex themes in accessible ways earned her a devoted readership across multiple generations.

Download PDF

To save this Certain Women summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.41 MB     Pages: 29

Download EPUB

To read this Certain Women summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.37 MB     Pages: 42
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...