Key Takeaways
Build a stronger back through active recovery, not a search for a perfect fix.
A patient becomes a reporter. In 2008, after years of pain and failed treatments, Cathryn Jakobson Ramin set out to find a spine surgeon. Instead, she spent six years investigating an industry that often treated ordinary back pain as a broken part to repair. Scans, injections, operations, and painkillers could produce costs and complications without restoring a person’s life.
Function is the destination. The book’s central argument is not that pain is imaginary or that surgery never helps. It is that many people with chronic, nonspecific back pain are better served by active, sustained rehabilitation than by a succession of passive treatments and procedures. Ramin’s own route included an ill-advised operation, then years of rebuilding strength and movement. Her return to hiking in the Andes gives the investigation its human measure: not a perfect scan, but a life no longer organized around pain.
What's striking is how the book shifts the question from which intervention can erase pain to which path can restore agency. That is a useful distinction in any complex health problem, where symptom relief, functional improvement, and structural change are not interchangeable outcomes. The investigation also reminds readers that patients often choose fast, insured interventions over slower, less accessible rehabilitation. That is not simply a failure of willpower. It reflects how systems make some choices easy to obtain and others difficult to find.
Treat MRI findings as clues, not verdicts about the source of pain.
Common does not mean causal. Ramin was frightened by reports of herniated discs and degenerative disc disease, diagnoses her doctors did not adequately contextualize. Yet a study of 67 people without back pain found disc changes in more than 90 percent. Later research cited in the book found degeneration in 96 percent of pain-free people in their eighties. Such findings may be part of aging, not the explanation for a person’s symptoms.
Match the image to the person. An MRI is most useful alongside a physical examination and relevant symptoms, not as a stand-alone diagnosis. Ramin describes patients whose alarming reports led toward more tests and procedures, while a simple explanatory note on one radiology report reduced follow-up scans and prescriptions. Imaging can still be important when serious signs appear, such as progressive weakness, loss of bowel or bladder control, or suspected fracture or infection.
An image feels authoritative because it turns an invisible sensation into something that can be pointed at. But visualization is not the same as explanation. In decision-making, a vivid finding can dominate more informative but less dramatic evidence, such as whether a symptom pattern fits the structure shown. The book’s warning is strongest when it argues for interpretation rather than blanket rejection of imaging. The challenge is to communicate uncertainty without dismissing suffering, a skill that matters as much as the scanner itself.
Ask what surgery can improve, and what it could leave worse.
Fusion is not a reset button. Lumbar spinal fusion joins vertebrae with bone grafts and hardware. The book reports that studies found meaningful success in barely 40 percent of patients, with many continuing to have pain or use painkillers. About one in five patients returned for revision surgery. Fusing one area can also increase stress on nearby spinal levels, which may deteriorate and become painful.
Demand a specific case for operating. Surgeons often cannot identify the exact source of ordinary back pain, and different surgeons may recommend different procedures for the same scan. The book contrasts this uncertainty with clearer situations, such as certain recent disc herniations causing leg symptoms, where nerve decompression may be considered. Before elective surgery, patients need a plain account of likely benefits, complications, recovery demands, and nonsurgical options. A procedure being available does not make it the only remaining choice.
The key issue is not whether surgery is good or bad in the abstract. It is whether the expected gain is large enough to justify an irreversible intervention under uncertainty. That question resembles risk assessment in engineering: the more difficult a system is to restore after a failed repair, the stronger the case needed before altering it. The book is persuasive in demanding honest probabilities. Its broad skepticism should not erase the distinction between elective fusion for vague pain and surgery for urgent or well-localized problems.
Demand evidence and a clear risk discussion before accepting injections or gadgets.
A familiar procedure may still disappoint. The book reports that more than ten million epidural steroid injections were performed annually in the United States. For spinal stenosis and typical chronic back pain, evidence did not show reliable benefit; for recent sciatica, any benefit was generally small and short-lived. The procedure also carries rare but serious risks, including neurological injury. A contaminated batch of injectable medication caused fungal meningitis in 751 patients and killed 64.
New technology is not proof. Ramin describes laser procedures, spinal decompression tables, and vertebral cement procedures promoted with confident promises, despite weak, mixed, or unfavorable evidence. In a sham-controlled vertebroplasty trial, patients improved whether or not cement was injected. This does not mean every injection or device is useless. It means patients should ask what outcome has been measured, how long benefits last, and what risks and alternatives apply to their own case.
The vivid danger here is not only the rare catastrophe. It is the routine conversion of uncertainty into certainty through marketing, habit, or a clinic’s business model. A sound consent conversation should separate the chance of temporary symptom relief from the chance of durable functional recovery. The book’s examples also show why a treatment can look successful immediately after a procedure: sedation, expectation, and short-term numbing can all shape experience. That makes follow-up outcomes more informative than a dramatic first-day impression.
Replace passive, cookie-cutter therapy with tailored, progressive rehabilitation.
Not all physical therapy is active care. Ramin describes high-volume clinics where patients moved among heat packs, ultrasound, electrical stimulation, and assistants, with little individualized exercise. A patient who completes this routine without improvement has not necessarily tried a serious rehabilitation program. The book favors skilled clinicians who assess movement, strength, and daily demands, then prescribe a custom program that builds capacity.
Chronic pain may need a team. A chronic pain rehabilitation program combines exercise with psychological support, education, and often occupational therapy. At the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, patients trained for hours each weekday over four weeks, practicing exercise, relaxation, and ordinary tasks such as carrying groceries. The goal was not merely to lower pain ratings, but to recover work and daily function. Such programs can be demanding and are not suitable for every condition, so careful screening and qualified supervision matter.
This distinction helps explain why patients can honestly say they tried therapy while still having received little of the treatment the book supports. A service label does not tell the patient what happens inside the appointment. The broader lesson is to evaluate care by its active ingredients: individualized assessment, progressive practice, feedback, and a clear plan for independence. The intensive programs described are compelling, but their cost, access, and demanding schedules limit their reach. Better evidence alone does not solve the problem if patients cannot obtain the care.
Take persistent pain seriously without assuming it proves ongoing damage.
The nervous system can amplify pain. Central sensitization is a heightened reactivity of the brain and spinal cord that can make ordinary sensations feel painful, even when no new injury explains them. The book describes how injury, stress, poor sleep, guarding, and fear can reinforce this sensitivity. Pain remains real, but its intensity may no longer map neatly onto tissue damage.
Fear can shrink a life. Ramin learned that she was guarding her back by bending awkwardly and avoiding everyday tasks. That avoidance weakened muscles and strengthened the belief that movement was dangerous. In rehabilitation, patients practice feared activities in a controlled, gradual way. This approach does not mean ignoring sharp or alarming symptoms. It means distinguishing discomfort during rebuilding from evidence of harm, with a clinician’s help when the cause is uncertain.
This account offers a bridge between biology and behavior without reducing pain to either one. The nervous system is not a passive wire carrying a damage report; attention, expectation, emotion, and past experience can influence what it signals. That framing can reduce shame because amplified pain is still bodily pain. It also requires careful language: telling someone that pain is not proof of damage must not become a reason to dismiss symptoms or skip evaluation. Trust makes the difference between reassurance and invalidation.
Treat long-term opioids as a risky trade, not routine chronic-pain care.
Relief can come with a hidden cost. Ramin traces how Purdue promoted OxyContin for chronic, non-cancer pain using claims that addiction was rare, drawing on evidence too weak to support that confidence. Patients in the book describe escalating doses, impaired work and family life, withdrawal, and sometimes worse pain. Opioid-induced hyperalgesia is increased pain sensitivity associated with opioid use, one reason the drugs may stop helping while the dose rises.
The risk is not limited to misuse. Long-term opioids can cause dependence, sedation, constipation, hormonal problems, and overdose, especially when combined with sedatives. Stopping suddenly can also be dangerous and intensely distressing. The book argues for evidence-based alternatives such as exercise and cognitive behavioral therapy, while recognizing that access is uneven and tapering requires support. Patients should discuss risks and a safe plan with a qualified clinician, rather than changing a prescription on their own.
The opioid story is a case study in how professional authority can be shaped by commercial messaging. Once pain relief is framed as a moral obligation and medication as a low-risk answer, caution can appear uncaring. The more useful standard is informed choice: benefits, harms, alternatives, and uncertainty stated together. The book rightly resists treating dependence as a character flaw. It also shows that replacing medication requires real services, not merely telling patients to stop taking it.
Check who profits when tests and procedures become the default.
Incentives shape the menu. Ramin describes financial relationships among surgeons, device manufacturers, hospitals, imaging clinics, and pain practices. She recounts how device-company payments to influential surgeons could affect research and promotion, and how some physician-owned distributorships profited when surgeons used more hardware. In one hospital, fusion rates rose after the facility began buying from a surgeon-owned distributor.
More care is not always better care. The book links rising MRI use with more referrals for invasive treatment, and reports a sixfold difference in spine surgery rates between some U.S. regions. These patterns suggest that local practice and payment systems can influence treatment as much as medical need. Patients can ask whether a clinician has a financial relationship with a product or facility, whether a second opinion is appropriate, and what would happen if they waited or chose rehabilitation first.
The book treats overuse as a system problem, not simply a collection of bad actors. That matters because incentives can distort judgment even when clinicians sincerely want to help. Transparency is necessary, but disclosure alone may not neutralize a conflict; patients still have to interpret complicated information while in pain. A practical safeguard is to seek a recommendation that survives outside the financial ecosystem of the proposed intervention, especially when the diagnosis is uncertain and the decision is irreversible.
Train the movements daily life demands, with expert coaching and measurable progress.
Strength must transfer to life. Ramin’s therapists found weaknesses and movement habits that gym machines had not corrected. Instead of exercising isolated muscles for appearance, functional training practices the coordinated actions used for lifting, walking, standing, and carrying. The book’s specialists disagree about specific exercises, but emphasize accurate technique, progression, and work that fits the patient’s actual limitations.
The Big Three are one example. Biomechanist Stuart McGill’s named group of spine-stabilizing exercises includes a modified curl-up, a side bridge, and a bird dog. Their purpose is to build trunk endurance while limiting stress on the lower back. McGill stresses precise form, not simply completing repetitions. Other clinicians favor different methods, including carefully supervised resistance training. The practical lesson is to find a qualified practitioner who can assess movement, explain the purpose of each exercise, and adjust the dose safely.
Specificity is the difference between exercise as a slogan and exercise as rehabilitation. A movement must be both safe enough for the person and relevant enough to transfer into the life they want back. The specialists’ disagreements are useful here: they suggest that no single exercise recipe fits every back. A reader should value sound assessment and coaching over loyalty to a branded method. A technique that works for one person can be poorly matched to another person’s symptoms or movement pattern.
Keep practicing after improvement; a resilient back needs ongoing maintenance.
There is no permanent procedural shortcut. Ramin found that stopping exercise during a stressful move brought her pain back within weeks. She later rebuilt strength with a trainer who corrected her movement and helped her return to ordinary tasks. Her recovery depended less on finding a final treatment than on maintaining a regular practice.
Make movement part of the day. The book challenges the search for a perfect chair or a single ideal posture. Long periods of sitting are part of the problem; varying position, getting up, and developing strength are more useful than holding a rigid pose. Ramin explores Feldenkrais, Alexander Technique, selected yoga, Tai Chi, and Qigong as ways to improve body awareness and movement. Their evidence and suitability differ, so the best choice is one that is safe, appropriately taught, and sustainable.
The ending is deliberately practical: recovery is less like replacing a part and more like maintaining a capacity. That idea connects rehabilitation to motor learning, where repeated practice helps make new movement patterns available without constant conscious effort. It also makes relapse less mysterious. A flare does not automatically mean the body has failed; it may signal that sleep, stress, activity, or training needs attention. The caution is that lifelong practice should not be framed as blame. Support, time, and access shape what people can sustain.
Analysis
Crooked is investigative journalism with a patient’s plot. Its structure moves from the author’s search for a surgeon through a tour of treatments and financial systems, then toward rehabilitation and a return to meaningful activity. That arc gives a sprawling subject coherence: the question begins as What is wrong with my spine? and becomes What kind of care restores function without creating new harm?
The book’s most durable contribution is its distinction between a visible abnormality and a useful diagnosis. It shows how normal age-related findings can become a narrative of fragility, and how that narrative can feed imaging, procedures, fear, and inactivity. Its account of chronic pain similarly refuses a crude mind-versus-body split. Pain may persist through changes in nervous-system sensitivity, behavior, sleep, mood, and physical conditioning, without being imaginary.
Its sharpest criticism is institutional. Fee-for-service medicine can reward scans, injections, devices, and operations more readily than time-intensive rehabilitation. Conflicts of interest and weak oversight amplify the risk. The proposed alternative is not one miracle method, but carefully screened, individualized, progressive rehabilitation that measures function and teaches patients to manage their bodies.
The argument deserves two qualifications. First, the book is not a clinical guideline, and its 2017 evidence landscape should not be mistaken for current medical advice. Second, vivid malpractice cases and compelling rehabilitation stories illustrate possibilities, not universal outcomes. Some interventions are appropriate for specific diagnoses, while exercise itself needs screening and adaptation. The book is strongest when it teaches readers to ask better questions about evidence, risk, incentives, and function, rather than when its broadest indictments might sound like a verdict on every clinician or procedure. Its lasting value is disciplined skepticism paired with a constructive alternative: do not confuse doing more with getting better, and do not confuse a scan with an explanation.
People Also Read
Glossary
central sensitization
heightened nervous-system reactivityA state in which the brain and spinal cord become unusually responsive to signals, so that sensations may be amplified or interpreted as painful. In the book, it helps explain why persistent pain can continue even when current tissue damage does not account for its intensity. Stress, poor sleep, guarding, and fear may reinforce the process.
fear-avoidant behavior
avoiding feared movementA pattern in which a person limits ordinary movement because they expect it to cause injury or worsen pain. Avoidance can reduce strength and confidence, making daily actions harder and reinforcing the belief that the body is fragile. Rehabilitation aims to rebuild confidence through appropriate, progressive activity.
pain catastrophizing
fixating on worst outcomesA tendency to interpret pain through an expected worst-case scenario, such as assuming that movement will cause permanent damage or that recovery is impossible. The book describes how frightening scan reports and warnings to avoid activity can intensify this thinking, increasing distress and encouraging further restriction.
chronic pain rehabilitation program (CPRP)
interdisciplinary functional rehabilitationAn intensive program that combines physical reconditioning with psychological support, education, and often occupational therapy. Patients practice exercise and daily activities while learning strategies for sleep, stress, and pain. The aim is to restore function and independence, rather than relying mainly on passive treatments or procedures.
functional restoration
rebuilding practical physical capacityA rehabilitation approach that progressively increases a person’s ability to perform meaningful tasks, such as lifting, walking, or returning to work. The book describes programs that measure strength and function, encourage safe activity despite some discomfort, and help participants regain productive roles rather than centering care on pain scores alone.
McKenzie Method of Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT)
movement-based assessment and treatmentA physical therapy method developed by New Zealand physiotherapist Robin McKenzie. It assesses how particular spinal movements affect a patient’s symptoms, then uses the most helpful movements and positions as treatment. The book presents it as a potentially useful approach for some recent disc-related episodes, while noting that many acute episodes improve without professional treatment.
Big Three
three trunk-stability exercisesStuart McGill’s group of exercises for building trunk endurance while limiting demands on the lumbar spine: a modified curl-up, a side bridge, and a bird dog. The book emphasizes careful technique and appropriate repetitions. These exercises are an example of one specialist’s approach, not a universal prescription for every back-pain condition.
MedX
measured lumbar-strength equipmentA computerized exercise machine designed to isolate and strengthen the muscles that extend the lower back while limiting the user’s ability to compensate with other muscle groups. The system records strength and progress. The book presents it as one tool used in structured rehabilitation, while noting that access and insurance reimbursement have been obstacles.
opioid-induced hyperalgesia
opioid-related pain sensitivityA possible effect of prolonged opioid use in which a person becomes more sensitive to pain. The book discusses it alongside dependence, tolerance, and other risks of long-term opioid therapy. It is one reason that increasing a dose may not lead to sustained relief, and why medication changes require clinician guidance.
iatrogenic
harm caused by medical careAn injury or harmful outcome caused by medical treatment, whether intentional or accidental. Ramin uses the term to describe the possibility that a chain of well-intended tests and interventions can worsen a patient’s condition. The concept encourages patients and clinicians to weigh treatment risks alongside potential benefits.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.