Start free trial
Trending New Genres Authors
EnglishEnglish
EspañolSpanish
简体中文Chinese
繁體中文Chinese (Traditional)
FrançaisFrench
DeutschGerman
日本語Japanese
PortuguêsPortuguese
ItalianoItalian
한국어Korean
РусскийRussian
NederlandsDutch
العربيةArabic
PolskiPolish
हिन्दीHindi
Tiếng ViệtVietnamese
SvenskaSwedish
ΕλληνικάGreek
TürkçeTurkish
ไทยThai
ČeštinaCzech
RomânăRomanian
MagyarHungarian
УкраїнськаUkrainian
IndonesiaIndonesian
DanskDanish
SuomiFinnish
БългарскиBulgarian
עבריתHebrew
NorskNorwegian
HrvatskiCroatian
CatalàCatalan
SlovenčinaSlovak
LietuviųLithuanian
SlovenščinaSlovenian
СрпскиSerbian
EestiEstonian
LatviešuLatvian
فارسیPersian
മലയാളംMalayalam
தமிழ்Tamil
اردوUrdu
Searching...
SoBrief
Dungeons and Drama
Dungeons and Drama

Dungeons and Drama

A theater girl fakes dating her game store coworker, but can staged feelings stay pretend?
by Kristy Boyce 2024 304 pages
4.09
46k+ ratings
Listen
Immersive
V2.3
Amazon Kindle Audible
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Unlock listening & more!
Continue

Plot Summary

The Punishment Shift

A theater road trip sends Riley into her father's store

After Riley Morris1 and her best friend, Hoshiko,5 drive her mother’s4 car without permission to see Waitress in Columbus, Riley’s parents4 ground her and assign her eight weeks at her father3 Joel’s game store.

Riley1 already resents the store for the part it played in her parents’ divorce, and she believes Joel3 chose gaming over his family. On her first shift, she mistakes high schooler Nathan Wheeler2 for a thief when he takes cards from behind the counter. Nathan2 reveals he works there and mocks her snap judgment.

Joel3 introduces them as coworkers, then leaves them to sort out their hostility. Riley’s1 punishment has put her inside her father’s3 world, but her first connection there is with someone who shares his love of games and seems to know him better than she does.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Riley treats the store as evidence in a private case against her father: his business stands for the family life she believes he abandoned. The punishment therefore does more than limit her freedom. It forces her to encounter the people and community that give the store meaning, before she is ready to revise her judgment. Her mistaken accusation of Nathan establishes a parallel problem: she fills gaps in what she knows with confident assumptions. That habit will propel the comedy, but it also explains why intimacy becomes difficult. Riley can perform certainty more easily than she can risk asking what someone actually feels.

A Stage Goes Dark

Riley builds a case before the school can abandon it

At school, Riley1 learns that the spring musical has been cut because administrators see dwindling participation, donations, and ticket sales. The loss threatens both her dream of becoming student director and the annual chance she and Hoshiko5 have to perform together.

Riley’s ex-boyfriend,7 Paul,7 advises that money and evidence will matter more than students’ complaints, and she begins researching affordable shows and production costs. At home, her mother4 Shannon4 warns her not to take on theater while grounded, but Riley1 decides the show is worth pursuing anyway.

Choir teacher Miss Sahni9 does not promise a production; she agrees to seek a meeting with Principal Holloway15 and tells Riley1 to bring a serious proposal. Riley1 now has a deadline and a task: prove that students and the community still want a musical.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The cancellation turns Riley’s private ambition into a practical problem. Her first instinct is to insist that theater matters, but Paul’s advice and Miss Sahni’s conditions force her to translate passion into budgets, participation, and labor. This is an early test of whether Riley wants the identity of a director or the less glamorous work that makes directing possible. Her choice to proceed secretly also exposes a tension between initiative and responsibility. She is capable of acting decisively, yet she still treats adult permission as an obstacle to work around rather than a relationship to negotiate.

Nathan Becomes the Boyfriend

Her lie pulls them into the same campaign

When Paul7 visits the store with his new girlfriend, Lainey,14 his pitying concern irritates Riley1 into claiming she already has a boyfriend. Cornered for a name, she blurts out Nathan’s.2 She follows the claim with an awkward kiss on his arm, then asks him to help her make Paul7 believe the relationship.

In exchange, she will help Nathan2 attract Sophia,8 a red-haired player in his Dungeons & Dragons group who seems jealous when Riley1 gets his attention. Nathan2 resists, then agrees to try the plan. Riley1 also accepts Lucas’s6 invitation to join the campaign, partly because playing might get her away from the register. The scheme gives Riley1 a reason to spend time with Nathan,2 while the game gives her an unexpected place among his friends.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The fake relationship begins as a defense against humiliation, not as a search for romance. Riley would rather invent a boyfriend than let Paul define her as abandoned and pitiable. Nathan’s agreement has a different emotional cost: he accepts a plan designed to help him win someone else, even though it puts him close to Riley. Their bargain works because both can disguise vulnerability as strategy. D&D adds another layer of performance, offering Riley a socially acceptable way to enter Nathan’s circle while also giving her a new language for imagination, risk, and collaboration.

The Bard Takes Center Stage

A show tune wins Riley a place at the table

At her first D&D session, Riley1 chooses to play Elphaba, a human bard whose music and storytelling suit her theater instincts. Nathan2 and the others explain the rules, but he doubts that her energetic approach will fit the serious quest. Riley1 answers by singing to persuade his character, Sol, to let her join the party.

The performance draws applause from the players and store regulars, including Joel,3 who has come to listen. In later sessions, Riley1 learns how her bard’s abilities can help the group, while her songs become part of their shared fun. Nathan2 begins playing along with the fake flirtation when Sophia8 is present, but Riley’s1 growing enjoyment of the game is no longer merely a tactic to escape work.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Riley does not become a gamer by suppressing her theatrical instincts; she succeeds by bringing them into a space where she expected to feel like an outsider. Her bard makes performance useful to the group, turning what Nathan initially regards as excess into a contribution. The applause matters because it comes from people in Joel’s world, including Joel himself. Riley is not only finding a hobby. She is discovering that her father’s community can recognize parts of her that she assumed he had ignored. The game’s collaborative rules also contrast with her earlier habit of trying to control outcomes alone.

The Cafeteria Performance

Nathan makes Riley's invented romance convincing

When Paul7 challenges Riley1 at school about her supposed boyfriend, Nathan2 appears at lunch and puts an arm around her, then walks with her hand in hand. Paul’s7 skepticism falters, and Riley1 feels the satisfaction of seeing him forced to reconsider his assumptions.

Before they part, Nathan2 checks what kinds of public affection are comfortable for her, and they agree on a simple signal to stop if either feels uneasy. The careful conversation unsettles Riley1 more than the hand-holding does.

Their arrangement is supposed to be a performance, yet Nathan2 treats her boundaries as real. As the group begins sharing lunches and game nights, Riley1 and Nathan2 become less like hostile coworkers and more like friends, even when their staged intimacy continues around Paul7 and Sophia.8

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The scene succeeds as deception because it is built on genuine attentiveness. Nathan’s respect for Riley’s limits is not part of what she asked him to fake, and that difference makes the performance emotionally hazardous. Their signal creates a small structure of consent inside a relationship they insist is unreal. Riley’s satisfaction at outmaneuvering Paul also reveals how much she has let his judgment govern her self-worth. For now, the invented romance gives her a measure of control, but the growing friendship begins to make the original motive feel too narrow.

Dice, Colors, and Trust

A thoughtful gift makes their act harder to control

During a trip to buy Pop-Tarts and supplies for the store, Riley1 learns that Nathan2 often spends his evenings there because his parents’ work shifts leave him alone at home. His car and independence conceal a lonely routine, and the store functions as a second home. At the next D&D session, Riley1 discovers that Sophia8 has often relied on Nathan2 to buy things for her.

She quietly stops him from purchasing dice for Sophia,8 then accepts a colorful set he chooses for her instead and kisses his cheek. The gift reflects Riley’s1 bright clothes and makes her feel understood. Nathan2 had known about her theater performances for years because Joel3 proudly shared them with store regulars, although he rarely spoke to Riley1 about them himself.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Several assumptions shift at once. Riley sees that Nathan’s constant presence at the store is not simply enthusiasm; it answers an absence at home. She also learns that Joel’s silence to her does not mean indifference, because he has been telling others about her work. That knowledge is comforting and painful in equal measure. The dice sharpen the difference between a generic romantic gesture and being specifically known: Nathan chooses something that reflects Riley’s tastes. Her response is no longer entirely strategic, and the fake relationship starts to carry emotional evidence neither of them has agreed to interpret.

A Showcase Takes Shape

Riley recruits classmates and learns to direct peers

Riley’s1 research shows Miss Sahni9 that a musical could be planned, but the teacher warns that one enthusiastic student cannot prove school-wide interest. With Hoshiko’s5 help, Riley1 collects names from students willing to audition, then Lucas6 suggests staging a preview to make their case visible.

Riley1 chooses songs from Shrek and recruits classmates, including Paul7 as Shrek, for a short showcase. Rehearsals expose the work behind her ambition: she must assign roles, manage disagreements, improve projection, and help Hoshiko5 simplify choreography for inexperienced dancers.

Miss Sahni9 notices Riley’s1 steady leadership and offers her volunteer work assisting junior show choir rehearsals. Riley1 is encouraged, but she has been hiding these rehearsals from her parents4 while still grounded, and the growing workload leaves her with more to confess.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Riley’s leadership becomes credible when she has to serve the ensemble rather than her own artistic preferences. She wants an impressive production, but her classmates question her song choices and need practical direction; she must persuade them to build something collectively. The showcase is both advocacy and apprenticeship. It gives Riley evidence for administrators while revealing the less glamorous dimensions of directing, from scheduling to morale. Her secret rehearsals complicate this growth: she is becoming more responsible in practice even as she evades accountability at home. The contradiction is not resolved by good intentions alone.

The Holiday House Detour

Nathan reveals the lonely hours behind his store routine

After Riley’s mother4 allows Nathan2 to drive her home from the store, he takes a detour along a road he knows well and shows her an extravagantly decorated Halloween yard. The joke turns briefly frightening when a person dressed as Michael Myers approaches their car carrying a knife, prompting Nathan2 to speed away.

In the quiet afterward, he explains that his mother works nights and his father is often on hospital shifts, so he spends much of his time managing on his own. Riley1 recognizes why the store feels like home to him and why Joel’s3 open-door community matters. Their late-night drive makes room for unguarded conversation, and both begin imagining a future in which they will still choose to spend time together.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The detour changes the texture of Riley and Nathan’s closeness. Their earlier contact occurred under the cover of customers, friends, or a shared game; here, the dark road creates privacy without an audience to convince. Nathan’s account of his parents is not a plea for sympathy, but it gives Riley a new way to understand his independence and attachment to the store. The sudden scare punctures their reflective mood with comic danger, keeping intimacy from turning solemn. More importantly, Riley begins to imagine continuity beyond the arrangement’s short-term purpose, a thought she has not yet admitted aloud.

No More Offstage

Nathan extends their fake romance through school and homecoming

As rehearsals intensify and Riley’s parents4 grow more comfortable with her progress, Nathan2 asks whether they should stop switching their fake relationship on and off around Paul7 and Sophia.8 He argues that acting like a couple consistently will keep either of them from detecting the scheme.

Riley1 agrees, though she is increasingly unable to separate the role from her feelings. When Paul7 questions their compatibility after rehearsal, Nathan2 takes Riley’s1 hand and announces that they will attend homecoming together.

He has previously dismissed school events, so Riley1 is startled by the commitment. Nathan2 tells her Paul7 remains jealous, but Riley1 resists reading too much into that. Their daily affection now reaches beyond the game store, leaving Riley1 to wonder whether Nathan2 is still acting or simply afraid to say what he wants.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Nathan’s proposal is framed as a technical improvement to their deception, but its practical effect is to extend intimacy into ordinary life. That ambiguity gives both characters plausible deniability: they can behave like partners without risking a direct confession. Riley recognizes the danger yet accepts because the arrangement offers closeness she wants. Her resistance to Nathan’s reading of Paul also shows how selectively she trusts interpretation. She can analyze other people’s behavior as if directing a scene, but she hesitates when the evidence points toward her own desirability or Nathan’s affection.

The Party Splits

Riley releases Nathan to Sophia before the dance

At a crucial D&D battle, Nathan2 expects Riley1 to use her bard’s inspiring ability to strengthen him, but she saves it for the party’s later danger. He takes the choice personally, and Riley1 realizes that even their game has become tangled with what they cannot say outside it.

When Sophia8 learns Nathan2 and Riley1 will attend homecoming together, Riley1 insists they are only friends and that she has no date of her own. She then tells Nathan2 their pretend relationship can end because its purpose was to help him attract Sophia.8

Sophia8 asks Nathan2 to attend her school’s homecoming the following weekend, and he accepts. Riley1 congratulates him and lets him go, though the decision hurts. He still agrees to accompany her to her dance the next night, now as a friend rather than a boyfriend.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The saved ability gives Riley a way to withdraw care while pretending she is making only a tactical choice. Nathan’s hurt exposes how much emotional meaning has accumulated inside the game’s rules. Riley then ends the ruse at the moment it might achieve its original purpose, protecting Nathan’s chance with Sophia while abandoning the role that has become precious to her. Her gesture is generous, but it also lets her avoid asking whether Nathan wants her instead. By accepting Sophia’s invitation, Nathan appears to confirm Riley’s fear, although neither has yet spoken plainly enough to know what the other means.

One Real Kiss

Paul returns as Riley doubts what Nathan felt

Riley1 arrives at homecoming in a flamboyant feathered dress, and Nathan,2 dressed in a suit, surprises her by showing how much effort he made for the evening. They dance, laugh over a Weird Al parody, and eventually slow-dance together.

When Nathan2 asks if the night has any rules, Riley1 gives him permission to stop pretending. They kiss, and Riley1 feels certain the moment is real until she spots Paul7 watching. She pulls away, convinced Nathan2 kissed her for Paul’s7 benefit.

Paul7 follows her and reveals that Lainey14 has ended their relationship; he says he misses Riley1 and tries to kiss her. Riley1 turns her face away and rejects him. The encounter confirms Nathan’s2 earlier suspicion that Paul7 was jealous, but Riley’s1 mistaken interpretation of Nathan2 leaves her unable to enjoy the victory.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The kiss is emotionally real, but Riley’s attention is trained on the possibility of an audience. Because the relationship began as a performance, she cannot easily trust an intimate gesture when Paul is nearby. Her reaction illustrates the cost of prolonged ambiguity: even sincerity can look staged once performance has become the couple’s shared language. Paul’s return briefly tempts Riley with the simpler story that she can recover what she lost, but she refuses him. She has moved beyond wanting his approval, even as she remains unsure whether Nathan’s desire exists outside the role.

Leaving Sword and Board

Riley admits the deception and confronts her father

After the dance, Riley1 tells Nathan2 that their arrangement is over and reveals that her parents are lifting her grounding, so she plans to leave the store and may stop playing D&D. Nathan2 is hurt that she knew for a week without telling him.

Riley1 later tells her mother4 Shannon4 that the after-school rehearsals were for the musical showcase, not choir, and admits she has been lying. Shannon4 is angry about the dishonesty but impressed by Riley’s1 work and allows her to accept Miss Sahni’s9 assistant role. She insists Riley1 tell Joel3 herself.

At his apartment, Riley1 explains the project and says she is quitting the store. Joel3 is wounded; Riley1 accuses him of relying on the store instead of building a relationship with her. He says she and Shannon4 have kept him outside their closeness, and the conversation ends painfully.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

Riley’s choice to leave is partly practical, but it is also an attempt to escape the emotional confusion surrounding Nathan and the store. Her silence about the decision repeats the very communication failure she resents in Joel. The confrontation reveals that their estrangement has never had only one author: Joel failed to express interest, while Riley and Shannon formed a tight alliance that made his attempts feel unwelcome. Naming this does not erase his responsibility or Riley’s hurt. It makes their conflict more complex than the story Riley has carried, and leaves both with something to repair.

The Hospital Waiting Room

A health scare gives Riley and Joel a chance to repair

On the morning of Riley’s1 presentation, Joel3 suffers chest pains and trouble breathing at the store and is taken to the hospital. Riley1 abandons the school meeting to wait with Shannon,4 terrified that their last argument may be their final conversation.

Doctors determine that it was not a heart attack, though Joel3 needs medication and changes to his health. When Riley1 sees him, he apologizes for failing to show her how proud he is of her and admits that working together has brought him happiness.

Riley1 offers to give up her other commitments, but Joel3 tells her not to choose from guilt and suggests they can spend time together without the store. He then urges her to attend the musical meeting, insisting she has worked too hard to miss it. Their reconciliation makes room for both affection and independence.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The medical emergency strips away Riley’s ability to treat the relationship with Joel as a problem she can postpone until after the next performance. Fear makes their last argument newly consequential, but the hospital conversation avoids a convenient cure: Joel’s health requires change, and their communication still needs work. His apology identifies the precise injury, not simply a vague failure to be present. Riley’s impulse to abandon her ambitions is an effort to convert guilt into repayment. Joel interrupts that bargain by affirming that love should not require her to surrender the life she is building.

The Show Must Proceed

Friends and store regulars carry her proposal across the finish

Riley1 returns to school late, expecting the showcase to have collapsed without her. Instead, Lucas6 narrates in a Scottish accent after the scheduled narrator becomes ill, while John10 and his boyfriend Jordan13 assemble borrowed costumes with help from their LARPing friends.

Hoshiko5 leads the performance, and the cast completes both Shrek numbers before Riley1 reaches the stage. The school board representative and Music Boosters president hear Riley1 present her budget and cost-saving plans. Nathan2 arrives with Joel’s3 store regulars: one offers lumber, another offers graphic design, and others volunteer their help.

Shannon4 offers design materials. Faced with visible student and community commitment, Principal Holloway15 approves the spring musical. Nathan’s2 absence from the stage had concealed his work organizing the support that helped make Riley’s proposal persuasive.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The climax turns Riley’s individual campaign into a community undertaking. Her preparation matters, but it cannot produce the final proof alone; students cover missing roles, friends supply costumes, and store regulars offer concrete resources. This fulfillment answers Miss Sahni’s warning that one person cannot demonstrate broad interest. Riley’s project succeeds because she has built relationships across groups she once kept separate. Nathan’s contribution is especially significant because it does not arrive as a romantic declaration. He supports the work Riley loves on its own terms, giving her evidence of care through practical help rather than another performance of affection.

The Truth in the Car

Nathan explains the act concealed his own feelings

After the approval, Riley1 and Nathan2 leave the auditorium together and drive toward the hospital. Riley1 admits she is in love with him before he can mistake her silence for rejection again. Nathan2 says he had loved her since she kissed his cheek at the store, but assumed her behavior was only acting.

He explains that he agreed to the fake relationship because being close to her felt better than losing her, and that he ended things with Sophia8 after the dance. Riley1 apologizes for interpreting their kiss as another performance, and Nathan2 tells her he had not noticed Paul7 watching.

They choose to keep seeing each other, keep Riley1 in the D&D campaign, and make room for her theater work. Nathan2 offers to help with rehearsals, turning their future into a shared plan rather than a ruse.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The confession resolves the central misunderstanding by replacing interpretation with direct speech. Both Riley and Nathan had treated performance as protection: she feared that admitting love would expose her to rejection, while he assumed her fluency in acting meant her affection could not be trusted. Their feelings were real, but neither could safely read them through the behavior they had staged. The relationship becomes possible when each risks stating what the other cannot infer. Their agreement to preserve theater, D&D, and time together also resists the idea that love requires one person to give up a defining part of life.

Epilogue

Six months later, Riley1 is helping Miss Sahni9 stage Legally Blonde, with Hoshiko5 playing Elle Woods and their friends building and painting the set. Riley1 and Nathan2 are together, still teasing each other, and still playing D&D with the group.

Riley1 has earned her driver’s license and sometimes drives Nathan,2 while he continues to help with theater rehearsals. As prom approaches, he tries to guess what she will wear; she reveals only that her dress is red.

May contain spoilers
Analysis

The later scene measures change through ordinary arrangements rather than a grand declaration. Riley now directs a full production, drives herself, and makes room for gaming without surrendering theater. Nathan enters her world by helping with sets and rehearsals, just as Riley once entered his through the game store. Their teasing has survived the end of the fake relationship, which shows that performance no longer has to conceal their feelings. The red dress also echoes Riley’s vivid self-presentation: she has not become less herself to be loved. The ending imagines intimacy as shared participation, not self-erasure.

Analysis

Dungeons and Drama builds its romantic comedy around a protagonist who knows how to perform but struggles to trust what happens offstage. Riley’s1 fake-dating scheme is funny because its practical logic is immediately unstable: the more convincing she and Nathan2 become, the harder it is to tell whether they are acting. Their difficulty is not simply fear of rejection. Each has learned to interpret affection through a role, so direct evidence can be mistaken for another scene. Their eventual honesty matters because it replaces inference with vulnerability.

The book’s two central projects, the romance and the musical revival, develop through the same movement from individual control toward shared work. Riley1 begins by treating the canceled musical as something she can rescue through force of will. Miss Sahni9 makes clear that a budget and a committed audience are necessary; Lucas,6 Hoshiko,5 the cast, and the game-store community then turn her plan into a collective effort. The show is not saved by talent alone, but by people offering time, skills, costumes, materials, and money. That practical collaboration gives Riley1 a more mature model of leadership.

The family plot complicates the easy division Riley1 has drawn between her parents. Joel3 has failed to communicate his pride, while Riley’s1 loyalty to Shannon4 has helped keep him at a distance. Neither fact cancels the other. The hospital scare forces Riley1 to confront how much she has left unsaid, and Joel’s3 apology makes reconciliation possible without asking her to abandon theater. His most meaningful gesture is to encourage her to pursue the work she loves even when it takes her away from his store.

Gaming, theater, and romance all depend on imagination, but the novel distinguishes creative performance from emotional evasion. Riley’s1 bard, the Shrek showcase, and the friends’ costuming give people ways to contribute and be recognized. The fake relationship, by contrast, becomes limiting once it replaces plain speech. The ending brings these worlds together without requiring Riley1 to choose one identity: she can direct, play, drive, love, and remain unmistakably herself.

Summary in 60 Seconds
After driving her mother’s car without permission, Riley is grounded and assigned to work at her estranged father Joel’s game store. When her ex appears with a new girlfriend, Riley claims Nathan, a coworker and tabletop gamer, is her boyfriend. Nathan agrees, hoping Riley will help him attract Sophia, but their public performance gradually becomes genuine. Riley also fights to restore her school’s canceled musical, organizing a student showcase and community support. She and Nathan kiss at homecoming, yet Riley misreads his motives and ends their arrangement. She then clashes with Joel before his chest pain leads to a hospital visit and a heartfelt reconciliation. Riley’s friends and game store community help win approval for the musical. Riley and Nathan confess their love, reunite, and remain together six months later.
Contains spoilers

Last updated:

Report Issue

Review Summary

4.09 out of 5
Average of 46k+ ratings from Goodreads and Amazon.

Dungeons and Drama has an overall rating of 4.09/5, with most readers praising its adorable fake-dating trope, charming characters, and fun blend of musical theater and D&D elements. Reviewers highlight the sweet romance between Riley and Nathan, the relatable family dynamics, and the accessible portrayal of both worlds. Many recommend the audiobook narrated by Eva Kaminsky. Critical reviews cite underdeveloped characters, simple writing, or feeling too mature for YA romance. The vibrant cover frequently drew readers in, and many compare it favorably to Better Than the Movies.

Your rating:
4.54
57 ratings
Want to read the full book?

Characters

Riley Morris

The determined theater kid

Riley is a high school junior whose bright clothes and quick wit announce the confidence she wants others to see. Theater is not a casual hobby for her; directing is the future she is trying to earn, and the school musical gives shape to her friendships and ambitions. She is resourceful, impulsive, and good at turning setbacks into plans, but she often mistakes forceful action for honest communication. Her parents’ divorce has left her carrying a narrow story about her father3, while Paul’s7 condescension makes her hungry to prove she is wanted. Riley’s challenge is not to become less passionate, but to pair that passion with listening, patience, and the courage to state what she needs.

Nathan Wheeler

The guarded game master

Nathan is Riley’s1 high school classmate and a longtime presence at Joel’s game store. He is observant, dryly funny, and deeply invested in D&D and the friends who gather there. His glasses, gaming shirts, and apparent indifference to school activities make him easy for Riley1 to misread as merely prickly, but his loyalty and consideration emerge in how he treats the group and respects boundaries. Because his parents’ work schedules often leave him on his own, the store offers both community and routine. Nathan is more comfortable playing a character than risking direct emotional honesty, especially when rejection seems possible. His attraction to Riley1 complicates the role he first agrees to play.

Joel Morris

Riley's game-store father

Joel owns Sword and Board Games, a crowded local store that doubles as a gathering place for players, retirees, and young people who need somewhere to belong. He is warm, enthusiastic, and generous with his customers, but less fluent in expressing himself to Riley1, especially about theater, which she shares more readily with her mother4. The store represents a cherished dream to him and a painful family rupture to Riley1, so even his attempts to connect can feel loaded with old grievances. Joel wants more time with his daughter1 but has not always known how to ask for it. His affection is real, though his difficulty communicating has helped create the distance he hopes to close.

Shannon Morris

Riley's theater-minded mother

Shannon is Riley’s1 stylish, supportive mother and an interior designer who shares her daughter’s1 love of musicals, clothes, and creative projects. Their closeness is easy and affectionate, shaped by movie nights and years of working side by side. That intimacy can also make it difficult for Riley1 to feel free of divided loyalties after the divorce. Shannon is protective, particularly when Riley’s1 enthusiasm leads to reckless decisions, and she expects her daughter1 to accept consequences. Beneath her occasional jealousy about Joel’s3 time with Riley1, she wants their daughter1 to have a relationship with both parents3. Shannon’s strength is her ability to reconsider a judgment when Riley1 demonstrates responsibility.

Hoshiko

Riley's steadfast best friend

Hoshiko has been Riley’s1 closest friend since childhood and shares her love of performance, though she is a more accomplished singer and dancer. In everyday settings she can be shy and understated; onstage, she becomes confident and commanding. That contrast gives her a perspective Riley1 sometimes lacks: she understands both the thrill of performing and the vulnerability of being seen. Hoshiko supports Riley’s1 campaign to restore the musical, helps organize rehearsals, and remains a source of blunt affection when Riley’s1 romantic plans grow tangled. Their friendship is generous but not passive. Hoshiko can challenge Riley1 directly while still giving her room to make her own decisions.

Lucas

The generous Dungeon Master

Lucas leads the D&D campaign at Joel’s store and is the first to invite Riley1 into the group. Cheerful and welcoming, he wants enough reliable players to keep the story moving and is quick to make new people feel included. He also notices the romantic tensions around him before the people involved do. Lucas’s suggestion that Riley1 stage a musical preview helps turn her private research into a public case for the arts. His interest in Hoshiko5 grows through their shared time and dance, while his friendship with Nathan2 lets him challenge the plan without abandoning either of them.

Paul

Riley's self-assured ex

Paul is Riley’s1 ex-boyfriend and a talented actor who has often been treated as natural leading-man material. He ended their relationship after winning a role in a community production, telling himself the decision was practical because of his schedule. His polished confidence can slide into condescension, especially when he assumes he understands Riley’s1 feelings better than she does. Paul’s presence keeps Riley1 focused on proving she is not heartbroken or unwanted. He is also a capable performer, which makes Riley’s1 choice to work with him on the showcase professionally useful even when their personal history complicates it.

Sophia

The elusive D&D player

Sophia is a striking red-haired player from North Scottsville who joins Lucas’s6 D&D group inconsistently. She is quick to pursue what interests her and can be dismissive of the group’s needs, which creates friction around her character’s absences. Nathan’s2 attraction to her makes Riley1 see her as a rival before she understands how little they know one another. Sophia is not part of Riley’s1 theater world, and her presence forces Riley1 to test whether she can help Nathan2 without controlling what he chooses.

Miss Sahni

The new choir director

Miss Sahni is the young choir teacher who inherits the school’s musical program after its longtime director retires. A performer herself, she understands why theater matters, but she is realistic about budget limits and the time required to earn administrative support. She neither dismisses Riley’s1 ambition nor promises a result she cannot guarantee. Instead, she gives Riley1 concrete hurdles and a chance to show what she can do. Her recognition of Riley’s1 ability to lead helps the student see directing as a discipline, not merely a dream.

John

The exacting rules expert

John is a precise, serious D&D player who cares about rules, strategy, and getting the campaign right. His bluntness can make him seem unwelcoming, but he is dependable and committed to his friends. Outside the game, John enjoys live-action role-playing and makes his own elaborate costumes with his boyfriend, Jordan13. Those skills connect the gaming group to the school musical in unexpected ways. John’s attention to detail and practical competence give him a place beyond the table, even when he is impatient with distractions.

Anthony

The irrepressible flirt

Anthony is a relaxed, sociable member of the D&D group who enjoys teasing his friends and flirting with new people. His jokes can be tactless, but he is also perceptive about the emotional imbalance in Nathan’s2 pursuit of Sophia8. Anthony tends to say what the others are circling around, whether or not the timing is ideal. He has a homecoming date and a life beyond the game, yet he remains invested in the group’s friendships and is willing to help when Riley’s1 musical project needs support.

Fred and Arthur

The store's loyal regulars

Fred and Arthur are retired regulars who spend much of their time at Sword and Board Games playing miniature war games. They tease Joel3, welcome Riley1, and quickly treat her as part of the store’s extended family. Fred shares produce from his garden, while Arthur encourages Riley’s1 singing. Their easy affection shows how Joel’s business has become a community space rather than simply a shop. They are also among the adults who recognize that Riley’s1 presence brings a new energy to the store.

Jordan

John's supportive boyfriend

Jordan is John’s10 boyfriend and shares his interest in live-action role-playing. He is comfortable helping with homemade costumes and joins the wider friend group without needing to be the center of attention. His partnership with John10 shows a quieter, more established form of affection than Riley1 and Nathan’s2 uncertain performance. When the school musical needs practical help, Jordan contributes alongside John10 and their gaming friends.

Lainey

Paul's talented leading lady

Lainey is an actor from a neighboring town who performs opposite Paul7 in a community production. Riley1 sees her as a polished rival before they have any real relationship, partly because Lainey seems to embody the leading-lady role Riley1 wanted. Her visit to the store exposes Riley’s1 insecurity and prompts the false-boyfriend claim that drives the romance plot.

Principal Holloway

The school's cautious principal

Principal Holloway is responsible for weighing the school musical against limited funds and doubts about student participation. He represents the institutional decision Riley1 must persuade, not a personal enemy. His caution makes the showcase and community support consequential: enthusiasm alone will not answer the school’s practical concerns.

Kenzie

Anthony's homecoming date

Kenzie is Anthony’s11 homecoming date and joins the group’s celebrations. She is friendly, socially confident, and willing to suggest that other students can contribute service hours to the musical. Her practical support helps make the revival look like a school-wide effort rather than Riley’s project alone.

Plot Devices

The fake relationship

A cover for vulnerability

Riley1 invents Nathan2 as her boyfriend to protect herself from Paul’s7 pity, then proposes that she help Nathan2 attract Sophia8 in return. The arrangement gives them a reason to flirt in public, spend time together, and explain away increasingly intimate behavior. Its usefulness depends on both pretending they can control what the performance means. As their friendship deepens, the cover story creates the very uncertainty it was meant to avoid: each has trouble recognizing sincere affection when it arrives in the language of acting.

The D&D campaign

A shared stage for growth

The campaign gives Riley1 an entry point into Nathan’s2 group and lets her use musical theater instincts in an unfamiliar setting. Her bard’s songs can help the party, so performance becomes a genuine contribution rather than an interruption. The players’ fictional quest also provides a low-risk space for teasing, teamwork, and emotional displacement. Riley’s1 decisions in the game begin to reflect what she cannot yet say about her relationship with Nathan2, while the group’s shared commitment makes the store feel like a community rather than a workplace.

The musical proposal

Ambition made measurable

Riley’s1 proposal turns the school’s canceled musical into a concrete challenge. She researches costs, licensing, cast size, and ways to reduce expenses, then gathers students and stages a Shrek preview to demonstrate interest. The project tests her directing skills before she holds the title, requiring her to coordinate performers and solve practical problems. It also gathers people from her theater life and her father’s3 game-store community, allowing the story’s separate groups to contribute to one visible cause.

Sword and Board Games

A community crossroads

Joel’s3 store first appears to Riley1 as the cause of her parents’ distance and the place she is forced to work. Its game tables, regulars, and open-door culture gradually reveal a wider purpose. Nathan2 finds company there when his parents are working, Riley1 gains friends and a new hobby, and Joel’s3 customers become part of the effort to restore the musical. The store links family repair, romance, gaming, and community support without making those relationships identical.

About the Author

Kristy Boyce is a Columbus, Ohio-based author who works as a senior lecturer of psychology at The Ohio State University. Outside of writing and teaching, she enjoys spending time with her husband and son, reading, creating fairy gardens, and watching feel-good reality television, including The Great British Bake-Off and So You Think You Can Dance. She is also actively involved in the literary community, serving as the social media coordinator for Central and Southern Ohio SCBWI, demonstrating her commitment to supporting and connecting fellow writers in her region.

Download PDF

To save this Dungeons and Drama summary for later, download the free PDF. You can print it out, or read offline at your convenience.
Download PDF
File size: 0.39 MB     Pages: 27

Download EPUB

To read this Dungeons and Drama summary on your e-reader device or app, download the free EPUB. The .epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
Download EPUB
File size: 1.45 MB     Pages: 35
Want to read the full book?
Follow
Listen1 mins
Home
Swipe
Library
Get App
Try Full Access for 3 Days
Listen, bookmark, and more
Compare Features Free Pro
📖 Read Summaries
Read unlimited summaries. Free users get 3 per month
🎧 Listen to Summaries
Listen to unlimited summaries in 40 languages
—
❤️ Unlimited Bookmarks
Free users are limited to 4
—
📜 Unlimited History
Free users are limited to 4
—
📥 Unlimited Downloads
Free users are limited to 1
—
Risk-Free Timeline
Today: Get Instant Access
Listen to full summaries of 26,000+ books. That's 12,000+ hours of audio!
Day 2: Trial Reminder
We'll send you a notification that your trial is ending soon.
Day 3: Your subscription begins
You'll be charged on Nov 25,
cancel anytime before.
Consume 2.8× More Books
2.8× more books Listening Reading
Our users love us
1M+ readers
Trustpilot Rating
TrustPilot
4.6 Excellent
This site is a total game-changer. I've been flying through book summaries like never before. Highly, highly recommend.
— Dave G
Worth my money and time, and really well made. I've never seen this quality of summaries on other websites. Very helpful!
— Em
Highly recommended!! Fantastic service. Perfect for those that want a little more than a teaser but not all the intricate details of a full audio book.
— Greg M
Save 62%
Yearly
$119.88 $44.99/year/yr
$3.75/mo
Monthly
$9.99/mo
Start a 3-Day Free Trial
3 days free, then $44.99/year. Cancel anytime.
Unlock a world of fiction & nonfiction books
26,000+ books for the price of 2 books
Read any book in 10 minutes
Discover new books like Tinder
Request any book if it's not summarized
Read more books than anyone you know
#1 app for book lovers
Lifelike & immersive summaries
30-day money-back guarantee
Download summaries in EPUBs or PDFs
Cancel anytime in a few clicks

Why one summary?

Scanner
Find a barcode to scan

⭐
⭐
⭐
We have a special gift for you
Open
38% off
DISCOUNT FOR YOU
⭐
⭐
⭐
$79.99
$49.99/year
Only $4.16 per month
Continue
2 taps to start, super easy to cancel
Settings
General
Widget
Loading...