Key Takeaways
Follow the desires that keep returning, but test them in lived experience.
Desire can point. Martin describes vocation as a calling, a way of life toward which a person feels drawn. In the tenth-anniversary introduction, he says that people may discover this calling through deep desires, whether toward parenting, teaching, business, or religious life. Desire is a clue, not a job title delivered from the sky. His own clue arrived amid workplace strain, when a television program about Trappist monk Thomas Merton stirred a persistent longing for a different life.
Test the attraction. Martin read Merton’s autobiography and other spiritual books, spoke with priests, and gradually explored what Jesuit life involved. The attraction survived his uncertainty and his embarrassment about discussing religion. His story makes vocation less like a lightning bolt and more like a direction revealed over time.
What's compelling is the treatment of desire as information rather than an order. Motivation research often distinguishes goals that feel internally meaningful from those pursued mainly for approval or reward. That distinction helps explain why Martin's prestigious career could feel increasingly misaligned. Still, desire alone is not a reliable compass: novelty, burnout, or the wish to escape can also feel powerful. The useful test is whether an attraction remains meaningful when examined honestly, discussed with others, and tried in real conditions.
A prestigious career can succeed while its work feels morally and personally empty.
Success missed the point. After Wharton, Martin joined General Electric for its respected finance training program and strong salary. In two years, his pay rose by about half, yet greater financial security did not make the work feel more worthwhile. He saw financial reports adjusted to meet targets, longtime staff dismissed during downsizing, and managers treat loyalty as a one-way bargain. In one division, management announced plans to reduce a staff of 400 to 50.
One experience, not a universal verdict. Martin later emphasizes that his account describes his own six years at GE, not every business or business career. His discomfort grew as he questioned whom his work served and whether its costs matched its rewards. He enjoyed coworkers and some responsibilities, but could not make advancement itself feel like a reason to stay.
The memoir distinguishes a job's external rewards from its moral texture. Organizational psychology often examines how autonomy, relationships, and perceived purpose shape whether work feels sustainable. Martin's story shows how a high-status role can score well on pay and opportunity while failing on integrity and meaning. The important qualification is that his GE experience is a case, not proof that corporate work is inherently hollow. The sharper question is whether an organization lets its stated values guide everyday decisions, especially when money or status is at stake.
Act before certainty arrives when a considered choice keeps calling you.
No perfect sign appeared. Martin spent years circling the possibility of religious life, then sought therapy as work stress and family strain affected his health. When his therapist asked what he would do if he could do anything, he answered that he would become a priest. The answer clarified a desire he had been trying to set aside. Yet clarity did not remove practical uncertainty: the Jesuits had not accepted him, and leaving GE first meant risking a period without a plan.
Make the next honest move. After prayer and a powerful inner sense of reassurance, Martin gave notice before receiving an admission decision. His choice followed years of reading, conversations, and an eight-day retreat, not a sudden whim. He still had mixed motives, including the possibility of wanting to escape. Discernment, as his experience suggests, means moving with humility while continuing to examine what is driving the choice.
This is a useful account of acting under uncertainty, not a prescription to treat every intense feeling as divine guidance. Decision science recognizes that some choices cannot be settled by gathering information indefinitely; action itself reveals whether a path fits. Martin had already explored the religious life and understood that acceptance was uncertain, which distinguishes his decision from impulsive flight. A sound application pairs commitment with safeguards: examine motives, consult trusted people, and remain willing to learn from consequences.
In caregiving, presence matters when fixing the problem is impossible.
Help can mean staying. During Jesuit training, Martin worked in a hospital for people facing severe illness and in a Kingston hospice for sick and dying men. He initially wanted to accomplish something visible, but patients often needed little more than company, attention, or help with ordinary care. In Kingston, he bathed men, washed and clipped their nails, and sometimes sang to make the work bearable. When a dying resident was baptized, the sisters asked Martin to do it because the man knew him.
Limits are part of care. These experiences challenged the idea that useful work must produce a measurable result. Martin could not cure the patients or undo their circumstances. He could still treat them with tenderness and remain present to their needs. Service became less about feeling heroic and more about responding faithfully to the person in front of him.
The chapter's strongest insight aligns with care ethics, which treats attentive presence and responsiveness as real forms of labor, not consolation prizes for failed problem-solving. In serious illness, outcomes are often outside a caregiver's control, while dignity and comfort remain open to influence. That said, presence should not become an excuse to neglect practical intervention or structural reform. The account is most persuasive when it holds both truths together: people deserve immediate, personal care, and their suffering may also call for changes beyond the bedside.
Meet the person, not the category assigned by their hardship.
Labels blur differences. At a Boston hospital, Martin first encountered patients as examples of illness and disability. Over time, he came to know particular people: Gene, who communicated using a letter board and had a dry sense of humor; and Gladys, who sometimes mistook him for a former sweetheart. In Kingston, he tutored boys with serious learning difficulties. One boy, Duane, proudly painted his fingernails because he thought the color was beautiful.
Respect includes ordinary preferences. At a homeless shelter, Martin offered a man an ugly jacket and initially thought the man should simply be grateful to receive clothing. Then he recognized that homelessness did not erase taste, pride, or individuality. Understanding the broader conditions shaping someone's life matters, but it cannot replace meeting that person as more than a social category.
This is a sharp challenge to the way institutions can turn people into cases: patient, homeless person, troubled child. Individual stories restore detail and make stereotyped assumptions harder to sustain. Social science uses a related distinction between aggregate patterns and individual variation: population-level explanations can reveal injustice, but they do not tell anyone exactly who a particular person is. The account wisely needs both levels. Personal attention guards against dehumanization, while structural analysis prevents hardship from being mistaken for an individual failing.
Let prayer begin with honest attention, not perfect religious language.
Prayer started small. Martin entered religious life with a child's understanding of Catholicism and little experience praying beyond asking God to solve problems. During an eight-day retreat, a director asked him to consider who Jesus was. Martin's list of formal religious descriptions eventually gave way to the simple thought that Jesus could be a friend and companion. The director treated this as the beginning of prayer, not an inadequate answer.
Use imagination honestly. In the Jesuit Spiritual Exercises, retreatants meditate on Gospel scenes by imagining their setting and placing themselves within it. Martin found that this approach let him notice feelings and questions that abstract argument had not reached. During the thirty-day Long Retreat, he used these meditations to consider Jesus's life and his own responses. Prayer became less a test of theological knowledge and more a relationship attended to over time.
The movement from abstract description to imagined encounter resembles experiential learning: people often understand a situation differently when they inhabit it, even imaginatively, rather than merely analyze it. Martin's approach also lowers the barrier to beginning prayer. It does not require eloquence or certainty. Still, imagination can reflect a person's assumptions as much as it reveals insight. A grounded practice benefits from returning to the text, speaking with a trusted guide, and noticing whether an imagined encounter deepens compassion rather than simply confirming what one already believes.
Review ordinary days to notice where gratitude, fear, and grace converge.
A daily review. The Jesuit examen is a short prayer for reviewing the day in the presence of God. Martin describes beginning with gratitude, asking for help to see clearly, replaying the day's events, noticing where he responded well or poorly, and asking forgiveness and help for the next day. The practice could take about fifteen minutes. Its material is ordinary: a good conversation, a moment of sunlight, a decision made under pressure, or a familiar mistake.
Attention becomes a habit. Rather than treating spiritual life as separate from work and relationships, the examen asks a person to look for meaning within them. In the novitiate, Martin learned to regard daily experience as material for reflection, rather than waiting for dramatic religious feelings. The practice offered a repeatable way to see patterns in his reactions and to recognize what he was grateful for.
The examen has a clear cousin in reflective practice used in education and clinical work: review an event, identify responses, and decide what to carry forward. Its distinctive strength is that gratitude and moral accountability sit together, so self-scrutiny need not become either self-congratulation or self-punishment. The risk is rumination, especially for people prone to anxiety. A useful review stays specific and time-limited, distinguishes responsibility from what was outside one's control, and ends with a next step rather than an endless replay.
Treat vows as chosen constraints, not proof of superior virtue.
Three different promises. Jesuit vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience reshaped Martin's life in distinct ways. Poverty meant surrendering personal control over money and living on a modest allowance, which reduced financial worries but limited choices. Chastity meant forgoing an exclusive romantic partnership, a real sacrifice that did not eliminate affection or falling in love. Obedience meant accepting assignments through conversation and discernment, not simply obeying every instruction without thought.
Freedom has a cost. Martin found these commitments meaningful, but not effortless. He missed intimacy, questioned whether Jesuit communities lived simply enough, and struggled when ordinary responsibilities felt frustrating. He also recognized that celibacy was not a better life than marriage, and that he could not claim to thrive in extreme material poverty. The vows made sense to him as a particular way to serve, not a universal measure of holiness.
The memoir presents commitment as a trade: a chosen limit can reduce certain burdens while creating others. This resembles the broader idea of voluntary constraint, where people accept boundaries to protect a valued purpose. The distinction matters because sacrifice can be romanticized, especially when it is someone else's sacrifice. Martin's candid account of longing and discomfort keeps the vows from becoming a tidy ideal. Their meaning depends on informed consent, supportive community, and a real connection between the constraint and the work it is meant to serve.
Build a life where service, reflection, and companionship reinforce one another.
A calling takes a community. Jesuit life joined prayer and work, study and service, across settings as different as a hospital, a Kingston hospice, and a school for boys on New York's Lower East Side. Martin found a place among Jesuits with sharply different backgrounds and personalities. The community could be imperfect, frustrating, and occasionally comical, yet its members shared work, prayer, and the demands of daily life.
The story's turn. After two years of novitiate, Martin took first vows, not priestly ordination or the end of training. He had traded a corporate salary and career path for a long formation process and a modest life. The final scene is not a claim that religious life is flawless. It is the recognition that, through service, prayer, and friendship, a life that once seemed unlikely had become his own.
The book's narrative resists the lone-hero model of transformation. Martin's change depends on relationships: friends who listen, therapists who ask useful questions, spiritual guides who make prayer accessible, and patients and students who alter his understanding of service. That pattern connects vocation to social identity: people often sustain a demanding path through communities that give it language and practice. Yet community is not automatically supportive. Its value depends on room for difference, honest dissent, and the freedom to reconsider whether a shared life still fits.
Analysis
This memoir's central argument is enacted rather than announced: a life can look successful from the outside and still be organized around desires that do not feel like one's own. Martin's path from Wharton and GE to Jesuit life is compelling because he does not begin as a ready-made spiritual seeker. His early faith is shallow, his understanding of religion is limited, and his first encounter with a retreat includes confusion about whether he is praying at all. That makes the transformation legible as a sequence of experiences, not a conversion fable in which certainty arrives fully formed.
The corporate chapters are essential to this structure. They show how status, salary, and promotion can narrow attention, while also demonstrating that the workplace itself contains friendships and humane relationships. Martin's later qualification that his GE story is not representative of every business career matters. The contrast is between two ways of organizing his particular life, not between inherently bad commerce and inherently holy religious service. The book is strongest when it lets moral discomfort emerge through specific events, such as manipulated reporting and the indifference shown to laid-off employees, rather than treating a whole sector as a villain.
Its account of vocation is simultaneously spiritual and practical. Desire prompts inquiry, prayer and conversation help interpret it, and service tests it against concrete life. The hospice, classroom, and homeless shelter complicate any fantasy that meaningful work always feels uplifting. Sometimes the work is smelly, repetitive, unstructured, or emotionally painful. Presence and small acts matter, but they do not erase poverty, illness, or institutional failures. That tension gives the book unusual credibility: service is valuable without being a magical solution.
The memoir is not evidence that religious life is right for everyone, nor that an inner conviction settles a decision beyond question. Its broader contribution is a method of attention: notice recurring desires, examine their motives, learn from actual encounters, and make commitments with awareness of their costs. Its spiritual interpretation is particular to Catholic faith, while the questions it raises about meaningful work, moral responsibility, and chosen belonging travel well beyond it.
Review Summary
In Good Company is highly rated for its entertaining and honest portrayal of James Martin's journey from corporate life to becoming a Jesuit priest. Readers appreciate Martin's humor, relatability, and insights into spirituality. The book resonates with many for its exploration of finding purpose beyond material success. Some reviewers note that while engaging, the memoir could have delved deeper into Martin's emotional and spiritual growth. Overall, it's praised as an inspiring read that offers valuable life lessons, even for non-religious readers.
People Also Read
Glossary
vocation
a life's callingA vocation is a way of life a person feels called toward. Martin uses the word broadly, not only for priesthood or religious orders, but also for work, parenting, and other forms of life. He describes people as discovering vocation through deep desires that develop over time, while treating those desires as something to examine rather than automatically obey.
examen
daily prayerful reviewThe examen is a brief prayer associated with St. Ignatius Loyola. A person gives thanks, asks for help seeing clearly, reviews the day's events and responses, acknowledges failures, and asks for forgiveness and help. Martin presents it as a practical way to notice where God seemed present in ordinary experiences and where a person may need to change.
Spiritual Exercises
guided prayer practicesThe Spiritual Exercises are a collection of meditations and prayer instructions developed by Ignatius of Loyola to help people draw closer to God and discern how to live. They include reflecting on Scripture, imagining oneself within Gospel scenes, and reviewing one's desires and choices. A retreat director can guide someone through the exercises over an extended retreat.
magis
seeking more for GodMagis is a Jesuit term associated with seeking what is greater or more in the service of God. In Martin's account, it describes the redirection of ambition: the energy once spent pursuing worldly achievement can be devoted to serving God and others. It does not simply mean doing more tasks or competing to appear more virtuous.
agere contra
act against a hindranceAgere contra is an Ignatian practice of acting against a strong reluctance when that reluctance may limit freedom or availability for service. It is not a rule to oppose every preference or ignore legitimate needs. Martin encounters it as an invitation to question whether fear or resistance is preventing him from undertaking a useful experience, such as working in a hospital.
contemplatives in action
prayer within active serviceContemplatives in action describes the Jesuit ideal of combining prayer and reflection with active work in the world. Rather than withdrawing from ordinary life, Jesuits seek to remain attentive to God while teaching, serving, studying, or undertaking other ministries. Martin finds this model appealing because it joins spiritual life with practical engagement.
Long Retreat
thirty-day guided retreatThe Long Retreat, also called the Thirty-Day Retreat, is an extended retreat based on Ignatius's Spiritual Exercises. It involves periods of prayer, silence, and guided meditation, especially on Scripture and the life of Jesus. Martin makes the retreat after his first year of Jesuit novitiate and describes using imagination to enter Gospel scenes and reflect on his own life.
first fervor
early vocational enthusiasmFirst fervor is the intense early enthusiasm a person may feel after entering religious life or recognizing a vocation. Martin uses the term for the feeling that Jesuit life seems nearly ideal. It can provide energy and joy, but it is also a stage marked by limited experience, before the ordinary frustrations and imperfections of communal life become fully apparent.
composition of place
imagining a Scripture sceneComposition of place is an Ignatian method of prayer that uses imagination to picture the setting of a biblical passage. The person imagines the people, surroundings, sounds, and other details, and may place themselves within the scene. Martin finds this method helpful in meditating on Gospel stories because it draws attention to personal feelings and responses as well as ideas.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.